Are the snares and hats meant to be at different pitches? Based on the loops at the end I'd say B is a well serviced Roland 909, A is the Behringer and C is a Roland that needs a service/cap job. All things considered, my biggest take away from this is; no one can convince me the Roland is worth an extra 5,745GBP compared to the Behringer. Edit; listening again, the A bass drum is very clearly different to B and C which sound quite uniform. I think A over all, based on the loops, is pitched slightly higher than B and C.
Most drums has two tones, so you can't pitch them perfectly, one will be too high and the other too low. The hihat can't be pitched on a 909, and the Behringer is in Authentic Mode, so it also can't be pitched, so you get what you get.
@@RegebroRepairs Yeah that's fair, tbh when I wrote the comment I couldn't remember if the 909 had tuneable snares 'n' hats or if it was just slight analogue circuit tuning drift/slightly different samples I was hearing, I was pretty sure you can pitch the hats on the RD-9 but couldn't remember if that was an original feature on the Roland aswell or a behringer update. Too much gear too little grey matter haha.
The TR909 Rev 2 loop (C: because I watched your results video) has an interesting "flam" like quality in the loop. It's almost as if there is another note in there.
Great video concept. They all sound nice to me. I am wondering if the sounds are all from the same source and it was an exercise to illustrate how silly the original 909 vs clone debate is.
I took part but do not really care which is which, as I totally y love the RD9. It grooves and sounds gorgeous! But honestly 1 instrument I would like to know if it is the one I guessed: the snare.
Which is the RD-9 is randomized per sound. Hearing the difference on individual drum sounds is difficult, the loop seems to be clearer from the results I have so far.
All three sound completely different. All three are usable. 😊
Don't know. I'm here just to sample stuff!! :)
Are the snares and hats meant to be at different pitches? Based on the loops at the end I'd say B is a well serviced Roland 909, A is the Behringer and C is a Roland that needs a service/cap job. All things considered, my biggest take away from this is; no one can convince me the Roland is worth an extra 5,745GBP compared to the Behringer. Edit; listening again, the A bass drum is very clearly different to B and C which sound quite uniform. I think A over all, based on the loops, is pitched slightly higher than B and C.
Most drums has two tones, so you can't pitch them perfectly, one will be too high and the other too low.
The hihat can't be pitched on a 909, and the Behringer is in Authentic Mode, so it also can't be pitched, so you get what you get.
@@RegebroRepairs Yeah that's fair, tbh when I wrote the comment I couldn't remember if the 909 had tuneable snares 'n' hats or if it was just slight analogue circuit tuning drift/slightly different samples I was hearing, I was pretty sure you can pitch the hats on the RD-9 but couldn't remember if that was an original feature on the Roland aswell or a behringer update. Too much gear too little grey matter haha.
Can you include the stereo output of each as well?
The RD-9 doesn't have a stereo out.
The TR909 Rev 2 loop (C: because I watched your results video) has an interesting "flam" like quality in the loop. It's almost as if there is another note in there.
I don't hear that, but it definitely is a bit darker than the others, for some reason.
Great video concept. They all sound nice to me. I am wondering if the sounds are all from the same source and it was an exercise to illustrate how silly the original 909 vs clone debate is.
I took part but do not really care which is which, as I totally y love the RD9. It grooves and sounds gorgeous! But honestly 1 instrument I would like to know if it is the one I guessed: the snare.
one has more high end in it (10kh or more ) on top
Rd9
The magic with a real 909 is the sequencer and the flaws in the machine, yeah the rd9 sounds the same when the sounds are soloed.
Hi Tom, whoever you are
i’m laughing way too hard at this
Shout outs to Acid Mitch from MPC forums days
I am guessing C is 909
In the loops A and C are 909's, yes.
A sounds slightly different
Which is the RD-9 is randomized per sound. Hearing the difference on individual drum sounds is difficult, the loop seems to be clearer from the results I have so far.
I've had 09 and now have 909
IT'S FAT and multi-outs is awesome obviously
Great Bheringer
B is the RD as it has more top end, That is my geuss
Im on phone speaker and i think B is behringer rd9
I think A is the 909 because of that lower tuning
Wow that C machine is awful
On which sound?
@@RegebroRepairs The kick