I read the entire section of Adhan and Iqamah in Man La Yahduruhul Faqih, and there is no mention of _Aliyyun_ _Waliyyullah_ or Shahadah Ath-Thalithah. Even Hadrat Bilal, the Prophet's (S) mu'adhdhin did not recite it in his Adhan. He did recite _hayya_ _ala_ _khayril_ _amal_ though.
The sad reality is that ghuluw has become mainstream and original tashayyu has become marginalized. I believe many are receptive and ready for classical tashayyu but are confused by the insistence of popular speakers that this is simply a deviant movement. Alhamdulillah Syed Ali Hur is countering them one by one but I believe more scholars need to come out and openly speak their mind because speaking to them privately I know that they are on the same page.
He has brought his arguments from the Quran and authentic narrations. If he is wrong then please counter his arguments using the same authentic sources.
@@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam If you are truthful counter him. Character assassination is all what you people can do. You can't answer him on point. Write down in the comments what you disagree. He has opened my mind and made me Qur'an centric. That's what the Ahlulbayt had come to do. The traditional Shias have completely misguided the lay people by making the Ahlulbayt the focus when in reality it was Allah and the Qur'an that was the focus of these people. So if you are really truthful reply to the points he has made under the videos. It requires guts to speak the truth and there are very few like Syed Ali Hur! It's easy to call someone Muqasir. Bring forth your proof if you are truthful! If not just shut your mouth and don't become the kind of people like Banu Umayya who used to curse Maula Ali when they knew that they couldn't counter him in any way.
@@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam You are the one accusing him of lies! So the burden of proof is on you to prove him wrong! Tell us what do you disagree with him? Tell us a single point!
JZK. What you have described dear Sayyid (may Allah swt bless you and increase you) is essentially the current day Shia system of organized religion following "the way of the forefathers" - something severely condemned by the Quran in the harshest of manners. God bless you immensely for your work, effort, and striving for rectification (Islaah). BaarakAllah Feek! Wa Mazeed.
May Allah Bless your team for sharing all this knowledge. But, as I am watching all these videos I have reached a point of utter confusion: 1. Please list all the practices n beliefs of the early shias which are missing from the practices and beliefs of mainstream 12r shias today? 2. Please list all the practices n beliefs of mainstream 12r shias today which are corrupted and need reform? 3. Did the 12 imams as write books of sunnah/hadith? 4. Which practices and beliefs of mainstream sunnis today go against the teachings of Ahlulbait as and Prophet Momammad Pbuh? Kindly answer my questions as I am totally confused!!
@@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam the sad reality is the books mentioned by you are attributed to the imams just like John, Mark, Mathew n Luke are. I wanted to know if there is any authentic book written by any imams!
Salaam. Jazakumullahu Khayran for your kind wishes. Answering the questions you have listed above is one of the primary goals of this channel. We have hours worth of content answering these precise questions, with authentic evidences from our earliest and most authoritative sources. We would recommend you go through the videos on our channel right from the beginning at your own leisurely pace. With each lecture and episode you watch, you will get more clarity and insight into what you are looking for, and your confusion will be replaced with certainty and confidence inshallah.
Ahlussunnah has less kufr than shites...You will never find shia debating with Christians hindus or jews or doing dawah to non muslims...But the sunni scholars always debate non muslim and revert them to islam...
So how does one follow the fiqh of ahlul bayt i mean 12'er fiqh when there is ao much fabrications ..or is following the fiqh of imam zaid a better choice and closest to the truth
Can you clarify if Aga Sistanis ruling on Magrib time is based on Gulluw? He has said Magrib time is at Sunset and as a precaution we should wait until redness has disappeared..and if it is then are you telling me that he is unaware of these Hadithes and probably more to make this masael? Also, we're not sure why he keeps going on about the sky turning dark because we're not aware of any Khoja Shia who prays Magrib when it's totally dark. I asked this in the previous videa and you casually didn't respond to this question and answered all others.
@@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam no need to be derogatory. Ppl like you are the reason why others run away from Islam. If you even slightly read the Quran you'd understand the entire approach of the Prophet was to perfect Akhlaq, which you are clearly lacking.
Perhaps the following lecture would give you more clarity: ruclips.net/video/xkVEyckGxR4/видео.html It explains how the Imams (as) rejected this so called precaution in narrations that are deemed authentic by the Maraaje themselves. But then why don't some Maraaje act on them and abolish the popular precautionary ruling. Well, some have actually abolished it. Others, their circumstances don't permit. If you read the writings of the inner circle of the Maraaje, they talk about how Maraaje themselves are often very fearful of defying popular trends for fear of public backlash. We have shared the testimony of Grand Ayatullah Sayyid Hossein al Burujerdi in this regard before, whereby he said in his Bahthul Kharij lectures as recorded by his student Ayatullah Shaykh Nematullah Salehi Najafabadi, “You are surprised at how Imam Sadiq (s) would do Taqiyyah in front of his opponents and the government, and give a verdict against what was true? There is no room for surprise here. We have also reached a point where we fear our followers and do not dare write a verdict or opinion (that is against what is famous amongst the jurists) in our Risalah (Fiqh Manual)!” Reference: Showkarān e Andīsheh, Khātirāt Ayatullah Najaf Ābādī, p. 55: I So my dear, this was the supreme Marja and Head of the Hawza of Qum in his time, and he was also the teacher of Sayyid Seestani. So you need to wake up to the fact that you don't live in an ideal world, where scholars have all the intellectual freedom they need to promote all the truths. Rather, they have to tread very cautiously and live under constant fear of upsetting the public, and also fear of other opportunistic rival Maraaje and Ulama creating Fitnah and problems for them if they speak out or write against popular rulings. Thus, you can't afford to blindly follow them assuming they would have seen all the Ahadith about a given topic. Even where they know that a popular verdict is contradicted by authentic Ahadith of Imams (as), they have to pick and choose their battles, so sometimes they will gather the courage to speak out against something or write the correct verdict, and in other instances they will go by whatever is expedient given their tough circumstances and the weight of public pressure on them. But this is why you should be grateful that platforms like Al Islaah exist which give God fearing scholars full freedom to preach their conscience and state the truth, and present the actual teachings of the Quran and Ahlul Bayt (as), regardless of how unpopular and bitter they might be, without fear of being banned or deplatformed for speaking out the truth. Lastly we would admonish you to be respectful in your speech, and not use derogatory language or else, otherwise we will enforce our policy of not enagaging with those who are disrespectful and insulting to our scholars in their comments. May Allah Bless you.
You should watch his upcoming lectures. He will be revealing his views on this. He sees good things in all these sectarian paradigms and bad things as well. He says we should make the Quran and established Sunnah the criterion, and accept the good from all schools, and reject the evil of all sects. But our only Divinely Approved Religious identity and badge is MUSLIM.
![Megan Thee Stallion - Bigger In Texas [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QxTkZTLWdo4/mqdefault.jpg)
I read the entire section of Adhan and Iqamah in Man La Yahduruhul Faqih, and there is no mention of _Aliyyun_ _Waliyyullah_ or Shahadah Ath-Thalithah. Even Hadrat Bilal, the Prophet's (S) mu'adhdhin did not recite it in his Adhan. He did recite _hayya_ _ala_ _khayril_ _amal_ though.
The sad reality is that ghuluw has become mainstream and original tashayyu has become marginalized.
I believe many are receptive and ready for classical tashayyu but are confused by the insistence of popular speakers that this is simply a deviant movement.
Alhamdulillah Syed Ali Hur is countering them one by one but I believe more scholars need to come out and openly speak their mind because speaking to them privately I know that they are on the same page.
He has brought his arguments from the Quran and authentic narrations. If he is wrong then please counter his arguments using the same authentic sources.
@@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam If you are truthful counter him. Character assassination is all what you people can do. You can't answer him on point. Write down in the comments what you disagree. He has opened my mind and made me Qur'an centric. That's what the Ahlulbayt had come to do. The traditional Shias have completely misguided the lay people by making the Ahlulbayt the focus when in reality it was Allah and the Qur'an that was the focus of these people. So if you are really truthful reply to the points he has made under the videos. It requires guts to speak the truth and there are very few like Syed Ali Hur! It's easy to call someone Muqasir. Bring forth your proof if you are truthful! If not just shut your mouth and don't become the kind of people like Banu Umayya who used to curse Maula Ali when they knew that they couldn't counter him in any way.
@@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam You are the one accusing him of lies! So the burden of proof is on you to prove him wrong! Tell us what do you disagree with him? Tell us a single point!
@@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam Stop worrying about my comment. Stay on point and give us a single thing that he said was wrong with proof!
If Nahjul Balagha and the Kutub al Arba'a are books of nawasib then I must ask you which books you refer to then?
I want to become your student ma sha Allah
Even I want to.
JZK. What you have described dear Sayyid (may Allah swt bless you and increase you) is essentially the current day Shia system of organized religion following "the way of the forefathers" - something severely condemned by the Quran in the harshest of manners. God bless you immensely for your work, effort, and striving for rectification (Islaah). BaarakAllah Feek! Wa Mazeed.
May Allah Bless your team for sharing all this knowledge. But, as I am watching all these videos I have reached a point of utter confusion:
1. Please list all the practices n beliefs of the early shias which are missing from the practices and beliefs of mainstream 12r shias today?
2. Please list all the practices n beliefs of mainstream 12r shias today which are corrupted and need reform?
3. Did the 12 imams as write books of sunnah/hadith?
4. Which practices and beliefs of mainstream sunnis today go against the teachings of Ahlulbait as and Prophet Momammad Pbuh?
Kindly answer my questions as I am totally confused!!
@@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam Unfortunately your reply reeks of sectarianism. May Allah guide you.
@@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam the sad reality is the books mentioned by you are attributed to the imams just like John, Mark, Mathew n Luke are. I wanted to know if there is any authentic book written by any imams!
@@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam what about the Book of Intellect in al-Kafi? You really need to ponder over it.
Salaam. Jazakumullahu Khayran for your kind wishes. Answering the questions you have listed above is one of the primary goals of this channel. We have hours worth of content answering these precise questions, with authentic evidences from our earliest and most authoritative sources. We would recommend you go through the videos on our channel right from the beginning at your own leisurely pace. With each lecture and episode you watch, you will get more clarity and insight into what you are looking for, and your confusion will be replaced with certainty and confidence inshallah.
Ahlussunnah has less kufr than shites...You will never find shia debating with Christians hindus or jews or doing dawah to non muslims...But the sunni scholars always debate non muslim and revert them to islam...
I agree with Syed Ali Hur.
Can you make a lecture on wiping or washing the feet
Read the Qur'an. It says, "wipe a part of your heads and your feet up to the ankles" وَامْسَحُوا بِرُءُوسِكُمْ وَأَرْجُلَكُمْ إِلَى الْكَعْبَيْنِ ۚ
So how does one follow the fiqh of ahlul bayt i mean 12'er fiqh when there is ao much fabrications ..or is following the fiqh of imam zaid a better choice and closest to the truth
Can you clarify if Aga Sistanis ruling on Magrib time is based on Gulluw? He has said Magrib time is at Sunset and as a precaution we should wait until redness has disappeared..and if it is then are you telling me that he is unaware of these Hadithes and probably more to make this masael?
Also, we're not sure why he keeps going on about the sky turning dark because we're not aware of any Khoja Shia who prays Magrib when it's totally dark. I asked this in the previous videa and you casually didn't respond to this question and answered all others.
@@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam no need to be derogatory. Ppl like you are the reason why others run away from Islam. If you even slightly read the Quran you'd understand the entire approach of the Prophet was to perfect Akhlaq, which you are clearly lacking.
Sistani ghali ! He allows shirk ( ya Ali madad ) ! He will take others to hellfire with himself
Perhaps the following lecture would give you more clarity:
ruclips.net/video/xkVEyckGxR4/видео.html
It explains how the Imams (as) rejected this so called precaution in narrations that are deemed authentic by the Maraaje themselves.
But then why don't some Maraaje act on them and abolish the popular precautionary ruling.
Well, some have actually abolished it.
Others, their circumstances don't permit.
If you read the writings of the inner circle of the Maraaje, they talk about how Maraaje themselves are often very fearful of defying popular trends for fear of public backlash.
We have shared the testimony of Grand Ayatullah Sayyid Hossein al Burujerdi in this regard before, whereby he said in his Bahthul Kharij lectures as recorded by his student Ayatullah Shaykh Nematullah Salehi Najafabadi,
“You are surprised at how Imam Sadiq (s) would do Taqiyyah in front of his opponents and the government, and give a verdict against what was true? There is no room for surprise here. We have also reached a point where we fear our followers and do not dare write a verdict or opinion (that is against what is famous amongst the jurists) in our Risalah (Fiqh Manual)!”
Reference: Showkarān e Andīsheh, Khātirāt Ayatullah Najaf Ābādī, p. 55: I
So my dear, this was the supreme Marja and Head of the Hawza of Qum in his time, and he was also the teacher of Sayyid Seestani. So you need to wake up to the fact that you don't live in an ideal world, where scholars have all the intellectual freedom they need to promote all the truths. Rather, they have to tread very cautiously and live under constant fear of upsetting the public, and also fear of other opportunistic rival Maraaje and Ulama creating Fitnah and problems for them if they speak out or write against popular rulings. Thus, you can't afford to blindly follow them assuming they would have seen all the Ahadith about a given topic. Even where they know that a popular verdict is contradicted by authentic Ahadith of Imams (as), they have to pick and choose their battles, so sometimes they will gather the courage to speak out against something or write the correct verdict, and in other instances they will go by whatever is expedient given their tough circumstances and the weight of public pressure on them.
But this is why you should be grateful that platforms like Al Islaah exist which give God fearing scholars full freedom to preach their conscience and state the truth, and present the actual teachings of the Quran and Ahlul Bayt (as), regardless of how unpopular and bitter they might be, without fear of being banned or deplatformed for speaking out the truth.
Lastly we would admonish you to be respectful in your speech, and not use derogatory language or else, otherwise we will enforce our policy of not enagaging with those who are disrespectful and insulting to our scholars in their comments.
May Allah Bless you.
What are the rulings on qunoot? The sunnis do not do it in fard prayers only witr, but we do it in fard prayers. Is this correct?
Actually the Shafies also sometimes do it in their wajib prayers as well.
Actually the Shafies also sometimes do it in their wajib prayers as well.
So did they fabricate in tashahhud also? What is the correct tashahhud according to the shia and zaydis
I have heard a few scholars say that only two shahadats are present in the tashahhud as found in the four primary books.
Just to clarify..is Syed Ali hurr a zaydi Shia now ? Or ithna Ashari ..or Sunni ,😊???
Can we just call him a Muslim?
He seems like a Muslim, may Allah bless him.
You should watch his upcoming lectures. He will be revealing his views on this. He sees good things in all these sectarian paradigms and bad things as well. He says we should make the Quran and established Sunnah the criterion, and accept the good from all schools, and reject the evil of all sects. But our only Divinely Approved Religious identity and badge is MUSLIM.
@@Al-Islaah thank you sir . Would you like to go on mufti Abu Layth mindtrap podcast?
@@fahadalam8322 it would be great if it happens. The two are great assets of reform in Islam
Are al islaah jafari or imaeli shia?