The Twins | CalArts 2022 Film | Michelle Tang
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 апр 2022
- Hello! My third year student film, The Twins, is finally released!
-
Short Synopsis: Twins Lake and Lucas hate each others’ guts. One day after school, their sibling rivalry gets out of hand.
-
Watch the process video here: • The Twins | Short Film...
-
Director: Michelle Tang @txmichh
Music: Roy Berardo
Sound Design: Jack Weiss
Foley Engineer: Shane Vincent
Foley Assistant: Keiolani Mahinan
Recording Engineer: Chengqing Zhu
Re-Recording Mixer: Daniel Eaton
Animation Help: Sumin Cho, Jasper Wang
Cast: Rebecca Chiara Marano - Lake & Lucas
Chacha Tahng - Mrs. J
Torianna Jacque - Blaire
Tiffany Pang - Kayden
Michelle Tang - Olive
Cat Song - Cat
Spanish Translation: Lisset I. Rivera
Chinese Translation: May Yan
-
Watch other films made by my classmates:
• 2022 CalArts Character...
-
/ txmichh
michelletangart.weebly.com/
/ txmichh
/ michelle-tang-6511571a2
vimeo.com/michelletang
If you liked this film, check out my latest film, The Borrower's Hypnotist, here: ruclips.net/video/yKveFi_CHZY/видео.html
MICHELLE! YOU NEED TO MAKE A SEQUEL TO THE TWINS! PLEASE!🥺🥺
@@brandonfox9610 i dont think there will be
who is older Lake? or Lucas?
also identical or fraternal twins
Nooooooooooooooo
Lake taking on Lucas' life has so much more power to it if you think about it because it's unlikely that anyone would believe him with what happened. Lucas ruined his reputation so thoroughly that everyone would assume it was in some way Lake's fault. In the end, it would be much easier to be Lucas and have the good reputation Lake was always meant to have. It's like a clean slate, a way to finally emerge from the stigma that Lucas fabricated for him.
It is still very sad. They are both kids. They don't know what they are doing. I blame the parents and teacher for not stepping in. As adults they should have seen this getting out of hand.
@@JuMiKu Can't step in if they don't know about it...
@@I_Eat_Lemons The teacher clearly should have noticed that his own brother tattled on him all the time. The parents definitely should have noticed the strained relationship.
It is a parent's job to notice these things.
My goodness when he was walking towards Lucas with the pipe I was scared he was gonna hit him I was like "maybe you're not in a very good position to be saying this stuff"
Well I was wrong, but he died either way 😶
@@JuMiKu Well, the sad things is that children won't always listen to their parents, and that siblings won't suddenly stop their innapropriate behaviour just because their parents said to do so. Sometimes, it can even take more than just the parents. As for the teacher, she more than likely noticed it but was ignorant about it (Some teachers are like that, I've met some)
The fact that Lake had to disguise himself as Lucas really says what the world thought of him, and what he thought of himself. He thought Lake wouldn't be as missed as Lucas, despite saying earlier that if people knew the real Lucas, they would like Lake more.
The world can be horrible because of favouritism embedded into our society. The favouritism in our society is the reason why people can have low self-esteem, envy, greed etc. This short film is a great example of favouritism within our society, just with a darker twist.
@@ravenwithcall8527 Yes. And the way society is right now, I bet something similar has happened like this.
in the reflection of the glasses you can see him draging away Lucas's body
I also feel like if they were to find out what happened to Lucas the people will twist the narrative since one he is a "bad child" and not well liked either way so he would deal with alot of repercussions
Luca's whole life was dependent on a lie at Lake's expense....And it's not like anyone besides Lake knew about the real Lucas anyway. "Very bad" Lake is gone. "Good 'ol" Lucas simply needs a new pair of glasses, and one less bad apple to be late for class. The evil(er?) twin is gone, regardless of who everybody thinks that was....And figuring the Lake and Lucas their family and community know never even really existed, let's hope this Lucas turns out better than the first one was going to...
Lucas: YOU WISH YOU WERE ME!
Lake: Good idea.
Funny
Fr
@@Sinasa1414Free Turkestan
@@Knowledgeable418 yesss
@@Sinasa1414 UYGHUR MUSLIMS ARE BEING PUT IN CONCENTRATION CAMPS
the sad part is no one cared enough to put a missing poster about him, if you saw the hand, you can see that he put his own poster up
Damn
💀
Mano tava ruim agr tu piorou
why would he put his own poster up?
@@Nopeasaurus
Cause nobody cares about him
So the obvious answer is lake put it up
im pretty sure lucas put it up after all you could see a white sleeve not a red one
love the symbolism that at the beginning, lucas faked being hurt to get lake in trouble. what led to his demise was lake not believing him when he actually was.
Brilliant analysis
Boy who cried wolf
Wow
like the boy who cried wolf
As the old fable “the boy who cried wolf” has taught us, if you continuously lie about something, no one will believe you when you’re really telling the truth
I interpret it as Lake only taking Lucas's place because he had no other choice. Think about it, if Lucas the 'good' kid died, everyone would blame Lake for doing something since everyone knew Lake already hated his twin brother, not knowing Lucas was much, much worse.
It feels somewhat poetic that the brother Lucas bullied to become more liked is the one who took his coveted position.
I actually believe this if you look closely in the glasses the one dragging the body has messier hair
Plus this fits into the ‘twins’ aspect of the film. Of course it would be easy to switch if you looked the same!
Somehow I feel like the ending was Lucas's final, unintentional joke.
He said "You wish you were me." Lake never want to, but now he have to...
For god knows how long it will be, until he either break the news or someone finds out. If this were to be real, yes I know it's dumb to feel sympathy to a fictional characters, but still--I hope they understand, more so as they have no right to judge him even more to live as his other half, who HATED him.
Lake’s car was hidden. Maybe it’s to hide something. Because Lake had the car last. But I like that theory
If a part 2 comes out showing this guy in adulthood, we may see him getting caught.
Love how the owl symbols death, when they entered the junkyard area with blue eyes, but when Lucas died the owl’s eyes are shown red.
it's because they made the streets red and the owl happened to be in the red filter
@@LuckClover1Right, red filter as in murder
@@LuckClover1Yeah that was an intentional choice
Actually was Luke who died, Lucas pretended to be him
Please, China is oppressing East Turkestan, can you spread this?
Driver really said “🗣️I WOKE UP IN A NEW BUGATTI🗣️ 🚗💨💨💨💨
🚗 🚬 🚬 🚬
HE DIED BROTHA BUT DA BANGER AINT MAKING ME DO HIS GRAVE 🔥
@@Romaniafutbol FR
120 in a school zone less goooo
120 mph on School Zone moment
When Lake said "I'm tellimg Mrs. J" and Lucas replied "Really? Think she'll believe you?" in 2:14 is probably the reason Lake pretended to be his brother because he knew no one will believe him.
snitches get stitches
@@Ratsoup445 No even worse sniches get dishes
@@Ratsoup445 snitches get ditches
@Jovan Ristovski there Lucas dies, and Luke pretended to be Lucas
@@samuraiboi2735 snitches get car crashes
I thought this was going to be more of an inspirational, moralized film. Sitting here chilled to the bone, insanely good work.
Life is pretty screwed when the sugar is removed
It's a sad end with a the obvious mutual hate
Same
I kind of knew it wasn’t. I mean just how the thumbnail was make it clear.
Although not my favorite, I found the story... oddly satisfying and new. Most stories of siblings follow a plot where sibling A and B start out rocky, but make up once they put aside their differences. "Twins" has a raw realism that explores how damaged and/or toxic a sibling relationship can become. It's even brave enough to explore a scenario where the relationship (for lack of better words) "dies", as though telling its audience such a thing can happen.
Lucas: HELP ME UP! IM SORRY OK LAKE! PLEASE!
Lake: 🗿
Lake: help yourself
Lake:*turns into talking Ben* no
Lmfao but dark
Im I know how ankle hurts but why didn’t he crawl?
"there's something inside you."
When he says "Lake help me up. Please im sorry please.. " is the most saddest thing ive ever heard and the tone he was saying it in was like he was about to cry
No not sad but rather happy, he deserve it
Well, he didn't have time to cry.
@@ArmyTiny-nz8odbro he doesn’t deserve it they are just kids whats wrong with you
All the car imagery forseshadowing the crash was great. That last bit though..... Both of these kids are crazy
Lake didn't have a choice, dude. If he told the truth that Lucas was they one who came into the junk yard, no one would believe him. Its easier if everyone thought Lake was the one who disappeared
@@PichuElric I’m sorry but he did have a choice. It’s sick impersonating ur dead brother who u had a part in his dead. What if they didn’t believe him? He could have changed the story to make it seem like he was the one who led Lucas to the junkyard. He could have done a million things before taking his brother’s “place”.
@@MT-xq4km You should understand that the whole problem was that he DIDN'T want people to think he led Lucas to the junkyard and then to Lucas's death. He was angry at Lucas, didn't know a car would come at that exact moment, thus didn't help him. He had no part in his brother's death, but everyone would have thought he did
@@PichuElric he did have a part. He literally hid the body and witnessed his death. Also I do understand why Lake did that but sometimes you have to sacrifice yourself to not be a horrible human being. Also he is a child so if he would have been proclaimed guilty than is punishment would be not so bad.
@@MT-xq4km so would u just leave the body lying on the road
The real kicker is knowing that no one will recognize that they're interacting with the wrong twin. He did such devious things to his brother in order to be "liked". Yet, in the end, no one knew him well enough to see the difference. No one will realize that an imposter took his place, because that's how surface level his "popularity" was. They weren't his friends.
Oh the irony
…
I'm sorry to ruin the mood but...
"imposter" 📮
@@waddledeeznutz6477 💀
they probably would realize after the events of the film took place (maybe he would be late or not do the mannerisms of his twin quite right) after all, we only saw the first few seconds of the first day impersonating him.
This is genuinely one of the saddest animations I've ever seen, especially considering the relationship with twins in general having a certain mental bond and unmatched love for one another, such as Gravity Falls or the book series Unwanteds by Lisa Mcmann being great examples of this. And there are still plenty of examples in fiction where the main protagonist saves his enemy like Geronimo saving his cousin from a train in the 13th book of Geronimo Stilton or Anne trying to save Sasha in Amphibia. I personally think this is still very sad but I still think you did a good job on it.
Huh neat, a reference to the Unwanteds. Don’t see that too much. I love that series
@@SuperDestroyerFox Nice to see you do, I find it a slightly sad series but I do like it
@@kirbypro8112 “slightly sad” feels the same as Alex Hirsh saying “this will just be another silly episode filled with goofy jokes for kids”
@@SuperDestroyerFox Oh, thanks for telling me, in that case it's very sad because of all the deaths that happened over the course of the series.
In fiction, yeah, twins have 'a mental bond and unmatched love for one another', but irl? Not really.
The sad fact about this is the only reason Lucas said he was sorry was because he knew he was in danger / hurt. If he wasn't he would never have said that or even considered his brother's feelings considering his unknown literal hatred for him.
Edit : I feel bad for the animator who has to see the sheer embarrassment in the reply section. Arguing over an animated film cmon now 🤡
children in a nutshell
So we aren’t gonna talk about lake’s unhealthy obsession with toys and obvious anger management issues? Not to mention the physical harm he put other children in as retaliation instead of trying to understand why his brother didn’t like him? We’re also ignoring Lucas literally covering up his brother’s death and committing fucking identity theft because his brother was a snitch? Jesus christ you have some really messed up priorities. Oh no my brother was a snitch, lets leave him in the road suffering and take his identity when he dies.
Edit: it’s so disturbing how many of you are defending Lake for what he did. While Lucas may have held some control over what happened, he isn’t the sole orchestrator over what occurred before and during the road scene. Lucas and Lake both played a role in what came to be, and all I’m doing is pointing out some of the things Lake did that was left out in Toon’s comment.
@@basicallytrqsh ur taking this way too seriously bro, calm down lmao
@@basicallytrqsh So you couldn't make this a comment itself instead of making a novel on someone else's comment??
@@basicallytrqsh But the commenter isn't even wrong?
Does that excuse the fact the kid just impersonated his own brother and hid the body absolutely not. But the simple fact is all that could've been avoided if Lucas actually acknowledged the fact what he was doing was not right.
You don't just tell someone you're sorry when you're in danger because chances are you'll just do the same shit again.
I like how when Lucas breaks the rules, Lake says “I’m gonna tell mrs J.” Not their parents- not the authorities- *Their school teacher-*
Saddest part is that "Mrs J" is probably the entire world to them. They're children, Lake probably doesn't even fully grasp WHO the authorities are.
Which rules? You mean laws or school rules? Obviously, if it was school rules they’d tell their teacher but laws, authorities, yes.
I think they live on school grounds by the look of it. Which is something some countries do in fact do.
First lake second Lucas
@@kilsnacks ohh that makes sense actually
That was smart of Lake because everyone knew how he hated his brother, so if he didn't pretend to be his brother, everyone would think Lake had something to do with Lucas disappearance
well after he’s gone in that school he could be it’s self again, right?
0:27 Lucas: OWW!!!
(Lake kicks his cracking your feet.)
The saddest part about this ending is that he couldn't tell them the truth even if he wanted to. Because everyone thinks he's a troublemaker, they probably will think he killed his brother out of jealousy. Even his parents probably wouldn't believe him. He's now burdened to live someone else's life forever.
Edit: I got inspired by @Puchielric to write this comment further explaining the ending.
Wait so the brown hair boy did die
@@TheFlamerWolf no. The blue shirt that was a goodie too shoes died
@@milo4861 I see, thx for sub for you ^^
@@TheFlamerWolf yw
No the one with the red shirt died because that was him at the missing poster
Look at Lake's missing child picture. It's cropped, Lucas is looking perfect (from how much i can see) and Lake is angry/ doesn't even wanna be there. That's the only picture his parents found/have of him. It shows how much he was ignored considering no one even had a decent pic of him
Mmmm truly sad
well Lake attached his own poster (i read it in the comments), anyway this is a very interesting detail to show that on image Lucas i the perfect child while Lake is the “rebellious” soul
Скорее всего, у них нет родителей. Это может быть детский дом.
@@user-kapcanych мне тоже казалось, что это школа-интернат, потому что среди взрослых только их учительница
That's dark bro
3:43
That glasses move showed he regrets his decisions
all seriousness aside,my guy looks like he says "UhM tEaChEr WhAt AbOuT tHe HoMeWoRk☝️🤓"
Asian ahh nerd, basically
That ending tho
And how flawless that could be. It’s easy to say him and “lake” got into a fight and the other ran away. It’s easy to say that he’s a bit different and has lower grades/stars after his brother’s disappearance because of the stress and change. They lived together and probably even had the same room, so he would know enough about his mannerisms to copy them enough to hide. The only problem might be going to the eye doctor for new glasses if he didn’t need them but his brother did.
Another thing since they are young they have parents how would he hide the truth from them?
@@Glitchhusky9304 the parents probably are very busy ppl, and Lucas probs did the things he did to get their attention
Since they are busy, they prob dont know their children that much
@@cacapee6201 but what if they weren't? Wouldn't they noticed that their kid didn't come home from school what would lake(sorry I get the name confused) say if someone asked where lake was
@@Glitchhusky9304 he'd lie about it, of course. Plus, this question was answered at the post-credits scene via the missing poster, meaning that Lake *did* manage to fool his parents, since Lake's the one "missing" in the poster, and *not* Lucas.
@@hershyijustshatmyself9253 oh wow
I have chills that is a much darker ending than I thought .
Ikr :(
Agree
Me too. And at the end, that was Lake disguised as Lucas (which no one KNOWS). I feel bad for them both. Though Lucas was a jerk, I feel bad that he died. And I feel bad that Lake was never appreciated.
@@RCSXDV I thought lake is the one who died, this is cursed now.
Same here, I thought it was gonna be more sweet.
Lake summoned the spirit of his toy car, guy is goated.
I hate it, but you get a like
Damn. That hit deep. The plot twist shocked me to my core. The video finished and I was shocked speechless.
The way he said “you wish you were me” right before was AMAZING foreshadowing. The car imagery before the crash was just as good too. I had to keep replaying that scene
Lucas probably wished he was the 'me' he was referring to in that statement, which would add to Lake's point. Both twins were pretending to be that non-existent "Lucas."
I didn't even notice that 😭
when he sayed "you wish you were me" it's real because lake suited as Lucas when Lucas died
Man this made me have nightmares
same
I love how Lake isn’t designed to look like a really mean psychotic kid. He looks like a normal kid especially compared to his brother’s design.
Domt judge a book by its cover
I don't even think Lake was psychotic, he was pushed around so many times by his brother, and was treated terribly being in a toxic relationship.
Lake didn't even intend for Lucas' death, he just wanted his car back that Lucas wouldn't give back.
Although, it is pretty dark that he took over his brother's life, and faking his death.
And even then, no one would believe him even if he came out with the truth and said he got hit by a car, everyone would just think he murdered Lucas intentionally.
So in Lake's mind, the best possible option that he saw for himself was to just take over his brother's life.
Those glasses were a good touch though
Ikr ! Was thinking the same
Lucas made his life a living hell, that’s as much mercy Lake could give
We need a part 2 honestly..
Fr!
I Mean Not Really, What Else Is There To Do With This Story?
@@highhat3561 Something like themes of guilt and regret
Yeah, there should be a part 2 where everyone finds out that Lake is pretending to be Lucas and ask him where he is, then Lake would tell the truth and tell them how much he was treated badly by everyone after Lucas always lied about Lake and confess that he left him for dead because of how he ruined his life and threatened to destroy his favorite toy and that he pushed him into the road and broke his ankle and didn't save him even after he apologized and left him to get run over by a car and went to help him, but Lucas gave him, his final words was that he's sorry for everything and wished that he never did that before passing away, he felt terrible for letting him die and decided to become him after hiding his body so that they think he's still alive and show how much he regrets what he did and than cry with guilt and wished that he saved him, so his parents, friends, and teachers feel sorry for him after falling for such lies and try to get him through therapy and get the help he needs to heal before finding Lucas' body and give him a proper burial.
@@booyaahhtime5190 I think it should also take place in the future where Lake is in college
the scene in the car dump was great, really made it feel imposing, and that shot in the reflection of the glasses? perfection. Lucas is dead, sure, but that ending made it so much darker.
I bet this will blow up, and if it doesn't it should.
Edit: I'm guessing since this comment has over 1000 likes i was right
I think Lake is dead instead of Lucas. Because at the end we see Lucas toy car in the Lake's packback
@@chiarademichele2000 It could be, but you could also see it as Lake really took Lucas place. Finally getting to be the one who's liked and getting good grades.
@@Linnzy think thats more likely the case
when the car runs the kid over it sped right past someone with a red shirt.Lucas had blue clothes on.And the shadow makes it look like someone with more spiky haircis dragging someone with sleek hair. so its safe to say Lucas is dead and Lake took his place
@@chiarademichele2000 No, I think it indicates that Lake still has and likes his car, but wants to hide it, because he's pretending to be Lucas.
Maybe I'm confusing: Lucas is the red boy with the toy car and Lake is with the glasses? Or is it the opposite?
Edit: I saw the video again, I confused the twins name, sorry everyone
The fact that the car, that rolled over Lucas, looks the same as Lake‘s toy…Amazing animation with a lot of hidden symbols, that say more than what is shown! Love it
The car hit Lake...
@@skygard49 no lake is pretending to be Lucas at the end 😬 even creepier
@@jaceullom4085 yes
@@skygard49 the car hit Lucas,you can see on his glass after he got hit you can clearly see Lake taking Lucas
@@skygard49 also the hair at the end
It's honestly so morbid that instead of saying his brother went missing, he just decided the world was better off thinking HE went missing. The fact they couldn't even find a good picture, let alone one of him smiling is also sad.
The worst part is if he told the truth they'd probably think he did it ON PURPOSE.
It's also sad to me that this is a result of him snapping because he had enough of his brother bullying him.
Side note:His car was a comfort item
I really want a sequel now
I like how in the end, while Lake looks like Lucas, his hair is slightly messier, alluding to his original hair. His demeanor is also more calm, indicating how he is still adjusting to being Lucas.
That explains why he has the car I didn't notice that thanks
That explains I was so confused I thought lake got hit by the car and Lucas had the toy car because he kept it as a memory or evidence from the cops
Wow, the amount of subtle clues and hints in this film is just-
I completely misread the ending as the bully surviving and the victim giving his life to save his bully brother. Ok
@@jakevendrotti1496 same😅
Honestly, this chilled me and gave me “there’s a man in the woods” vibes. The fact that Lucas purposely tried to make it out for him to be the hero and only said sorry in his time of need is just insane. Also, I find it odd no one has found Lucas’s body yet, like, did the car come back? Did lake bury him? What happened?
Lake may have hidden his brother in the car lot, in the most damaged one to avoid anyone managing to find it
@@CamdenakaNeptunesdaughter1213 imagine if he went back there everyday to Mourn his grave
@@OzenEater until one day the body is gone
yeah the teacher kinda looked like the mom from "there's a man in the woods"
I think the human in the car is drunk and he buried him i guess
luca knew the car was coming that’s why he was begging while lake had no idea
I have a doubt about who really died if he died because the truth is that the ending is quite unexpected, Literally a work of art made into animation, a pretty cool and at the same time mysterious story
Lake (bullied twin) and Lucas (the twin that bullied Lake) at the end Lake pushes Lucas on the street, he havent noticed the car coming and when was about to help him get up, Lucas died... Getting ran over a car.. Lake burried his body and pretended to be Him
that's actually quite interesting.
i saw around 3 comments about this... and well, really either of the two twins could have been hit.
the car's direction wasn't too clear, either.
it could be Lucas who got hit and Lake took on his identity...
or Lake died because the car might have tried to avoid one kid and hit the other. Lucas might have been hurt in the process yet survived and pretended like nothing really happened.
it could be either but both are tragic.
It could be Lake who actually died and Lucas was so traumatized by the incident he just walked up and pretended nothing about it. I got this theory of Lakes shadow not showing up on 2:47 foreshadowing his disappearance or the fact that he's a nobody
But why would Lucas have Lake's hair?@@meisucksatlife8837
The ending is so crushing. Besides the fact no one would believe him but there is the underlying feeling that he knows everyone would prefer that outcome. Imagine having to live your life hearing everything everyone thought about you as you pretend to be the person who made them preserve you that way.
This is pretty much part of the plot of Black Butler lol
@@JG-sg9knyou mean as in that ciel realises everyone would of preferred him dying in the fire?
lol crushing? thats what happened to lucas 😭
i'll stop now
@@JG-sg9kn Wait what?
pun intended?
I think the saddest part is that Lake knew that if Lucas went missing, he’d probably be suspected first and tormented for the rest of his life. If Lake went missing, no one would care.
Lake loses both ways and that’s just depressing.
considering that in the credits thers a missing poster of Lake theres clearly people that care about him, what makes you think no one would care? /gen
@@franny6221 if you look at the arm, you can see that lake himself puts up the missing poster.
@@spidergirl6730 True
Yeah i saw it as he took his brothers identity because he would be blamed maliciously for the death instead of it being an accident, so if he covers up the death as a missing and taking his brothers identity they would believe actually believe in him and what he says.
what a stupid story
this scares me a lot when the twin dies. Before he sounds like he’s actually sorry and he loves his brother, but his brother think he hates him.
Bro I never thought it was gonna end like this…
What I really like about this film is the foreshadowing. When Lake appears late to class, he kicks Lucas in the ankle. And the next scene shows Lake running a rock over with his toy car while looking at Lucas, foreshadowing the car running the boy over while Lake isn't paying attention. It was in front of our faces all this time and I was nOT expecting that ending, it was so dark and unique and I love it!
And also when Lake was drawing on his desk it showed Lucas dead
He also adjusts his glasses alot, they even shined a couple of times. Then the last scene, they're broken.
also the owl appears right after lucas gets run over and in some culture owls represent death
That was Lucas's lesson (get hit by a car) because he bully his brother, So Lake hid Lucas's body and pretended to be here
The car that hit Lucas was red, just like the car that Lake always carries around
The scariest part is how realistic this is. Nothing happens in this movie that couldn't happen in real life.
Yup.
There is a true story like this quite... I think she took inspiration from her.
@@WMASHA-fx7kg Ok. 😐
@@WMASHA-fx7kg sure 😒
@@blazeking8424 MASHA's right, back in 1876 a man by the name of David Pumpernickel was found to actually be a much younger man of unknown origin. The real David Pumpkernickel's body was found decomposing in a river bank, apparently the man replaced him for six days before the grieving family got the news. He was subsequently arrested, but wasn't jailed, as his behavior did not constitute a crime at the time. It's unclear as to how similar the two men looked, but the fact nobody figured it out until the body was found is pretty trippy, right?
The Loud Shut Up Got Me
Bro t his is amazing. My heart literally dropped at the end, I thought they would make uppppp 😭
I feel bad for both brothers in this film because Lucas lost his life and Lake is left with the guilt of not saving his brother for the rest of his life ( I'm pretty sure if he knew the car was coming he would have helped him up). Besides the ending, I still really enjoyed this animation I loved the style and in my opinion the voice acting was really good!
Same here!
@@user-id3fc8qs7y he was really young and made mistakes, sure he deserved a smack for it but dying..? It's a bit far
@@user-id3fc8qs7y Bro, someone being a bully doesn’t justify being killed
Glad to know that I’m not the only one that thinks about this
@@dragonmaster9299 that and he’s just a kid. Kids respond to how the adults in their life respond to their antics.
I'm glad that the bird with the dead mouse was added in that scene before the brother died. It kind of prepares the audience for the death that's about to happen, and kinds of symbolize how the protagonist would carry the identity of a dead child.
I agree also because in certain native American beliefs, looking into an owls eyes can bring bad luck (especially death). I mean I don't know if that was also the symbolic meaning of the owl but that was my personal perception
@@definitelynotgianna1036 absolutely, owls are seen a bad omen in lots of countries
great example of foreshadowing!
@@kawauso2199 yes! I think it's an important tool for storytelling
I’m the 1000th like :D))
00:43 anyone notice that lake never actually entered the do not enter section?
I know but he’s near the fence so it doesn’t matter
A chilling story. In honesty, I do wonder if his parents will even care that 'Lake' is missing so long as they stil have what they *think* is their Golden Child. In time, they will forget him as a bad and diappointing memory.
HOLY I WAS NOT EXPECTING A DARK ANIMATED FILM. Animation films I have seen are symbolic, have a good ending, or has an overarching message. This is so unique!
I know it has a dark ending
This animation is gonna blow up
It's films like these, that are why we should start calling it a "medium" instead of a "genre"
Ive seen lots of animated horror films
You should check out the horror animation out there, there's quite a lot.
While the boys are exploring the old car field, an owl makes recurring appearances. Owls are viewed as omens of death, so that's a nice foreshadowing :)
Edit: yes, there are many different animals that are seen as omens of death, owls are just one of them and just so happen to be used in this animation lol
I thought that was crows?
@@tynishabiggs2799 or ravens?
@@tynishabiggs2799 Yeah, a flock of crows are literally called a "murder", lol.
I had a feeling someone would die
@@tynishabiggs2799 those too lol
This is by far My favorite short film I have ever seen
I like how at the end he put up a missing sign😢😢😢
Watched this a year later, I never noticed in the end Lake puts his own missing poster up.
No one cared that he was missing enough to put a poster up.
Yeah that's massed up
That wasn’t Lake that was Lucas
@@ImJustMeg.Mlucas is dead so lake wore his clothes and his glasses to look like him
@@MrCruncthe facial shape is lucas, lake has more angled-like face.
Lake didn't intend for him to die! You can tell by how surprised he was when the car came. I think he was so scared that he might get in trouble because everyone would've thought he killed him by their relationship, so he pretended to be his brother in the end sense he's the special treated one!
When Lake (at the end when he was impersonating Lucas) said that Lake (of course he was acting that Lake was gone) was late, you could even hear him speaking in a sorrow voice and that he wasn’t joking about it like how Lucas would usually do.
@@lyonidus3073 Exactly! People in the comments were saying they were confused about the story, I'm like.. what's confusing about it? LOL
@@Seanime lake killed his brother, the red car symbolizes that
@@B.bell2k I didn't say he didn't I said he didn't intend for him to die, also he didn't kill his brother the car did. Watch it again! All lake did was push him down to stop him from breaking his car, he was surprised when a car actually did come and run over his brother. Also correct the car does symbolize what happened being as though it was the same exact car that killed Lucas!
I feel like lake intended for him to die or have thoughts of killing lucas. You can see when he’s writing on his desk with his scissors it shows a sketch of lucas getting slashed
Both Lucas and Lake needed child therapy. Lake had so much aggression (for obvious reasons) and didn't have a nondestructive outlet. I don't think Lucas would've given him peace about it either. It's obvious whose the favorite child is and it kind of gives us an idea of what Lake was thinking when he took his twins place. He doesn't want to get into trouble again and with Lucas gone, he won't have to worry about getting into trouble ever again. He knows people prefer Lucas over him so if he disappears, no one will miss him as much as they would miss Lucas. Even if Lake told the truth, no one would believe him due to how everyone labeled Lucas as the good twin and Lake as the bad twin. In his mind, it'll be easier to lie about it. Everything will be easier for him. No twin to torture him, to snitch on him, no one will compare him to anybody again, and he will finally get what he has always wanted.
Lucas on the other hand, despite having people surrounding him and giving him all the positive attention, he's still being compared to his twin. He, in a way, is not his own person. Everywhere he goes, there's Lake not too far behind. He looks down on his twin in shame all while having everyone around him feeding his ego. When someone or a group of people put you on a high pedestal, you forget where you came from and sometimes those who put you there in the first place. Lucas was getting so much praise, he became overconfident in himself and only thought highly of himself. He noticed, on some level, that at the cost of his brother's happiness, he can gained more praise. He would do anything that would benefit himself. Makes you wonder what their home life is like for their lives to be like this at the start of the video.
Even though Lake took over Lucas life, he didn't seem all that confident about it. I doubt anyone would after burying someone who shares the same face as you or a relative. Also, why was the teacher not asking him what happened to him or why he looked so roughed up??? But going back to the incident, it really looked like even though Lake didn't want to, he was about to help his brother up. He was contemplating before turning around. One thing someone brought up in the comments was that Lucas only apologized when he knew he was hurt/in danger. If he was ok, would he still apologize? If the twins positions were switched at the moment, do you think he would've helped Lake? In my opinion, no. He wouldn't apologized but he would most likely help his brother out.
In other words, lake was in desperate need of someone to show him love, and took a chance to get it.
Wym need child theraphy? Lucas is a goner 🥳
@@CamdenakaNeptunesdaughter1213 lake was probably loved more at home since daddy didn’t like the fruity Lucas LOL
It’s just a animation jeez
@@MkayThatsGay and I'm just analyzing it. Don't like what I have to say? Shut up. Mind your business and move on. It's not that hard.
I just know years later, they discover Lucas was the missing twin all along
Of course they will. It's only a matter of time before Lake gets fingerprinted and they'll know he's not Lucas. If he needs a job with security clearance (fingerprints), access to money or assets (fingerprints)... or if he gets injured or sick enough (possibly, you guessed it: fingerprints), it's only a matter of time. It's why they fingerprint you at birth. The only real way he can escape this is possibly by changing his fingerprints (by, say, "accidently" burning his hands), getting a blood transfusion, or going off the grid well enough.
If you don't understand, Luke (red shirt) let Lucas (glasses) die and Luke pretends to be Lucas
2:53 when he says “ shut up! You wish you were me!”, you can sense something in his tone of voice. You can see the real Lucas. He’s telling himself that because he thinks if people become friends with lake they’ll stop liking him. He’s a kid, he needs validation and craves attention. He’s scared of isolation. In that moment we can see Lucas briefly break out of the perfect persona he’s created for himself and see how vulnerable and fragile he really is. He’s not a snob, he’s scared of what people will think if he’s not perfect.
yes, THIS
Yes, and it may be because Lucas was in an more open range but when he said “Shut up” it did not echo unlike when Lake did indicating that Lake is easily known as the “bad kid”
And kills him
Man lucas is an emo
It's so sad he never got to realize he didn't need to do any of that to be liked.
I'm getting chills, that missing poster and how he sneakily closes his backpack with his car toy inside. This is beautifully animated, and the story is truly chilling.
Yes same but still I want the story to continue
Fr I thought the non glasses twin lived and would become good but it’s probably gonna be total opposite
I realized my mistake the glasses twin did die but at the end the non glasses turns into the glasses twin since they’re twins because of the toy car thats why the short film is called “twins”.
This is oddly confusing. To sum it up, the twin with the glasses got hit by the car and the twin without the glasses dressed up pretending to be the twin with the glasses. Since people thought the twin with glasses was still alive, the missing poster shows the twin without glasses who’s gone “missing” because he’s actually pretending to be the twin with glasses who has actually died.
What I saw, was lake carrying luke (if that’s his name I forgot) and then, I thought Lake died because of the car in Luke’s backpack, I’ll look at the backpacks and see.
Edit: I JUST REALIZED THE HAIR AND IVE WATCHED THIS FILM 5 TIMES-
1:24 I would've quietly left Lucas and tell Ms jay
She would have said, "Why didn't you go after him? Why aren't you with him now?"
If you pay closer attention, you can see that lake (as Lucas) was putting up a missing sign of himself showing that nobody really did care about him because if they did care, they would’ve put up the sign when they realized he was gone 3:51
I know to sad
For those confused, Lake basically hid Luca's body and pretended to be him
Yeah.....i kind of saw that coming...i mean, twin swich place is pretty commen trope but i think this ia a pretty good animation
Thats not gonna work for long lmfao
I thought he died
@@guestdamess1103 he did
My question is why didn't lake appear in the reflection of the car? Was he dead the entire time?
Didn’t see many people point it out, but I like how color is used in specific parts of the short, specifically in the junkyard scene and onwards. To understand you need to know that Lucas wears a blue shirt and lake wears a red one. While Lucas lures lake into the junkyard with his toy car, he’s in “control” so the area/surroundings are blue-ish. Contrarily, at 2:54 once lake takes control, the scenery turns red.
I realized this right before I saw the comment 👌🏿
Yeah it really makes it feel like Lake is out of place in the junkyard, until he take control of the situation, where the scene turns red, which depicts a sense of urgency, but also that Lake has the upper hand.
fsr I thought they used that so they wouldn't have to show blood or something lmao but your point is way smarter
Yes!!! And the fade from blue to red between whose hands it's in!!
Fucking love that
The animation was well made! I don't completley blame Lake for his brothers death. Lake did not know his brother was abt to get hit, you can even see a hint of surprise at the car scene 3:10
I know i'm so late but ohmygosh... I love this so much! The animation is so satisfying to watch and the artstyle is beautiful. Love everything in this, keep up a good work!
whether or not Lucas deserved it, his death was caused by himself, Lake merely foreshadowed it. Lucas was the one to steal the toy car to make Lake follow, he was the one to run into the junkyard and taunt lake into coming with, he was the one to threaten to break lake's car in a fit of anger from just hearing the truth, and he was the one to make his brother hate him, meaning lake didn't have the reason to care about how his brother was hurt. It's entirely fair to blame Lucas, he's the one who built the trap
Karma
That's cruel. Sure, he's a sociopath but he's still a kid. He was begging his brother for help and the boy did nothing. I acknowledge that Lucas would not have done anything either and that the car came speeding out of nowhere and Lake was just as suprised by what happened. It was a tragic accident. For me, the last scene was poignant because I can imagine Lake being haunted by his brother last words- begging him for help.
I think it doesn't matter who survived because, in a way, no one made it out unscathed. And it seems to me like both twins died on that road.
@@horacehalt4216 it is cruel, this is a cruel animation. But im not speaking of feelings, i am speaking of facts. Factually, lucas caused this all to happen. Had he not done any of these steps (destroying his brother's reputation, stealing his car, running to the junkyard, trying to break the car) he would have not been killed. It was Lucas's choices that led to his death.
@@horacehalt4216 I might disagree with your view, but I love that final sentence: “Both twins died on that road that day.”
He fell into the trap he built
I love their character designs. Usually, the bad guys in stories would be dressed similar as Lake, and the "nerds" (glasses stereotype) would be more preppy, clean, and in a lot of cases, always the victim of some bully of sorts. It's really nice and refreshing change.
True but as of now there's starting to be more and more of this reversed archetype. As people with glasses that dresses overly nice is also often to be shown to have a smug dark side, or is supposed to be the annoying villain, like berdly.
Already lots of this in anime world
And this video popularized the pac man nerd meme
Isn’t lake the bad guy tho by the end
@@boopboop9356 we can't really say either of them is the bad guy, I only labelled the one with glasses (sorry I forgot his name) as bad bcs bfr the plot, he was the bully and the other twin was his victim
Mostly when I see sibling animations, they usually end it with the siblings settling their differences and being like best friends.
But this one, Nope! Did not expect the ending of this one 😨
Honestly, when the boys entered the broken car field, I thought at some point, LAKE would be the one to get hurt and make Lucas feel bad about everything he's done to him. But OH MY GOD, I was NOT expecting Lucas to die and be replaced by his brother. This took a dark twist and I loved it.
While Lake was holding the pipe I thought for a moment he was going to intentionally kill Lucas, or at least hit him maybe not trying to kill him but end up doing it. I was like, "man, Lucas, really not reading the room when the kid with no reputation and nothing to lose is holding a weapon and you're all alone."
It always feels good knowing some people love and enjoy the death of innocents.
@@mahdiabderraouf5795 yes especially when they’re animated characters that’s my favorite type of death
Holy Jesus I thought the car skidded out of the way and only broke Lucas's glasses, and Lake felt guilty and ran from home.
I kinda expected it... wish it was longer
Has anyone noticed that Lake doesn't appear in the reflection of the car window (2:46)? In my opinion, that also symbolizes that Lake doesn't even exist, he's invisible to others, while Lucas is always the twin who has all the attention turned to him. If Lake was the one who died, probably no one would have cared about his disappearance.
Thank you, i was wondering if anyone else noticed that
But lake has a reflection at 1:40
Ooooohhhh....
they literally put up missing posters of lake at the end when he takes on Lucas' identity to hide what happened, at the very least the parents would've cared
I think it's just the way the shot is angled more from Lake's perspective, so we can't see his reflection from the camera is. Cause in every other instance, everyone acknowledges Lake's existence
The teachers gasp when Lake hit Lucas leg 😂
I think the ending poster shows that the parents were neglecting him and that Lucas was the favorite child. They put a cropped picture of him and Lucas instead of just him, showing that they only took pictures of Lucas, ignoring Lake.
OH MY GOD this is so good !!!!?!?!????!! Huge congrats Michelle !!!!!!!!!!
Ikr!
It’s so good XD
SAKU?!?!
It is but it's sad and it has a very good moral that just life
Wait I’m confused lake is gone?
The symbolism of the bag at the end. Lake zipped up the bag with the toy car in it. I interpreted it as symbolism of him keeping the whole accident a secret, zipping his lips, and keeping it to himself.
The missing poster at the ends means he swapped places with his twin
Corrrect, buddy that’s mean keep a secret from a horrible accident
No it’s because lake always has the car but since lakes pretending to be Lucas he can’t be caught with his brothers toy or that would be suspicious.
@@Wishtelle it’s literally because his brother always have the car.
@@Zumberr even lake could died and maybe his brother hidden that toy car cause he regret his decision.
the ending left me in total shock they were both ten years old TEN!
Reminds me of what happened with Bulletproof from the Invincible comics. Similar situation with his brother.
This is *beautiful*. For the people saying Lake is a psychopath- no, he is not. That is a disorder and he shows none of the symptoms. In fact, he did not mean for his brother to get hurt. He didn't know the car was there. And after all, if that had been Lake with a hurt ankle, would Lucas have helped him up? If anything, Lucas could be the one diagnosed as a psychopath. He manipulates and has no remorse for what he is doing for his brother.
This short is just amazing. It deserves to be seen. People do not understand how toxic sibling relationships, no matter if there's am age difference or they're twins, can be.
*an, and true
true also I don't think lakes brother got hurt...
@@0Crowns yes he did he got ran over from a car and lake dragged his dead body out of the way
I agree though that idea neglects to mention the fact that Lake might have straight up killed Lucas. The car that runs him over looks identical to Lake’s toy car. It could be a metaphor. In that case I’m pretty sure it’s safe to say that both of them were psychopaths
At first I thought you were talking about Lucas(the little shit with glasses) in the first part and I thought "no way he isn't, and even if its too exaggerative, he is definitely a narcissist" and then I realized you were talking about Lake, the other kid and now I'm like "oh that makes sense"
It’s cool how detailed this is like how in the part where you could see their reflections one of them didn’t have a reflection
im not sure if youre implying that this was symbolism but im pretty sure it was a smart use of perspective rather than that if so.
timestamp please?
@@captainsquiggles5958 2:47
thanks! :D
Why didn't lake have a reflection?
That’s so cool that he pretended to be his bully brother, I actually love this! Well done!🎉
How is that cool?
Lake can't win if Lucas was found to be dead, they would suspect him, if he died, apparently no one would care enough to find him.
If he can't win as Lake, why not win as Lucas?
I think it sucks that Lake looked like he was about to actually help him before the car drove past. Very well written.
The fact that he drags his brothers body with little to no reaction is crazy especially at age 10! Great work
What's more scary is that he's wearing the same clothes Lucas died in, He literally took off the clothes of his brothers mangled broken lifeless body and started wearing it
@@user-zw2wq8jo2r exactly that was what I was thinking 🤔
Well, he was a dick. I definitely did a kid or two in myself, it’s very easy to accustom to.
Jokes aside, screw him.
@@user-zw2wq8jo2r🤨
I just noticed that reflection in the glasses, how come I didn’t notice that before? 😭
I love the framing foreshadowing when Lake and Lucas are fighting on the train tracks, where Lake is “in” the “toy” car for a moment before he pushes Lucas onto the tracks. I also love the intricate camera movements and the amazing lighting as well as palette that really brongs the mood together, the sound design is great too. They both sound so “innocent” in a way that diverts expectation, especially since they are clearly very young looking. I love the palette work and the backgrounds, the animation is really smooth and I cant imagine how long this took. The writing is great, very creative and I love the amount of work put into this. Lake is pretty mischievous (carving into the table and kicking Lucas) but Lucas is very selfish, and both are pretty normal for a kid.
I think it was a street.
Yeah it was a street. I thought it was train tracks too.
Ma’am its ‘brings’
Ps- i like the way you interpreted the entire thing, its actually amazing animation and cinematography!
amazing please part 2 even if theres no part 2😅
Ohhh. Literal chills.
In the Credits, You can actually see that Lake put up the missing poster of himself. You can see that because the arm that’s shown putting up the poster has a mark on it, the mark is the exact one on Lake’s clothes and the mark is also in the exact location shown. This might mean that nobody actually cares about lake enough to put up the missing poster of him, so he does it himself.
Omg, you're right! I never realised.
That's even darker
It's even sadder, because he is the only one to care enough about himself to at least print these posters. Not his teacher, not his parents, nobody but Lake himself...
He is the only one who is missing ,,the real Lake" and that's so depressing...
Oh wow!
@@tiamatpolarstar damn...thats so sad
Here’s something that’s really bugging me, if Lake is able to take Lucas’s so effortlessly and there’s a missing posture of him, that means even their parents can’t tell them apart!
What makes you think Lucas wasn’t the favorite child.
@@infinityheart_tm9270 what do you mean, Lucas is likely the favorite!
@@infinityheart_tm9270 considering how Lucas always gets stars while Lake gets detention everytime I think it's VERY clear who's the favourite twin
Exactly it's bugging me too :/
@@ToastallyManonMcMarrington something tells me that the dad may have loved the more masculine lake than Lucas which is why he took it out on Lake at school when he had the chance
This should be in movie theaters
I need part 2 PLEASE😢
The worst part is that since the video has no sequel and is left with an open ending to us readers, we could know that if Lake chooses the option to get away from his crime of accidentally murdering his brother, he'll have to live a life where he assumes the identity of a now-dead brother of his for the rest of his life to avoid getting into trouble. At the same time, he makes everyone think that he is dead.
Why do I say it's worst? Imagine every day is a struggle for you to fake yourself as someone else, knowing that you can never return to your old or should we say "original" life because of accidental murder. You'll forever faking yourself as someone else till your dead of old-age.
Not necessarily, at some point he can start to act like himself again since kids change a lot as they grow, but he could also forget how to act like himself as well
I don't think he'll have to act any differently, because Lake and Lucas are implied to be pretty similar, except everyone just thinks Lake is a worse troublemaker because Lucas always gets him in trouble or tattles on him.
With Lucas gone and no longer making Lake out to be a bad kid, Lake probably won't get into his characteristic problems
@@deronawuah2136 - Plus, any deviations in behavior/grades could just be pinned on him grieving the loss of his twin.
Not really worst
You say he murdered his brother but did he really? The driver of the car did. Lake more likely took his brothers place because he knew no one would miss him but they’d miss Lucas considering he’s the favourite.
At the end, I literally got a chill down my spine. Seriously. I wasn't scared until that end. Especially the "missing" child poster. Geez. That was great! Seriously done a better job than most professional companies can do! Great storytelling in only 3 minutes! Better than a full length film could do, that's for sure
Its also lake putting up the "missing" child poster
666th like 😈
@@theplushkingoftsumtsum785 996 likes now
Only 4 away till 1000
I really don’t get it 😭
Maybe since there twins lake is trying to be his twin brother and his other brother dies
They need to make a part 2
el final me encanto .:D
In some cultures, owls represent death. How fitting that this one was following the boys, as though anticipating which brother would meet his fate... 🦉
when the car runs over lucas you can see the owl with blood red eyes
@@A3N.A2B that's Lake, Lucas is the one with glasses
@@Straight_To_The_Asylum no Lucas dies, Lake is impersonating lucas
@@Emmanuel44444 hes saying before he dieds 🤦♂️🤦♂️
@@imjaceyt he's referring to the car running over lucas
0:32 , watch Lake's action with the car.
0:37 , the sketch with the scissors
3:13 , it shows the car entering the screen as soon as he turned around. Meaning he never intentionally meaned to kill Lucas.
3:23 , him dragging the body through the reflection of the glasses.
Lake's car was supposed to be a symbol of the car running over Lucas.
I never noticed the glasses. This animation is so sad.
At 3:13 you can also see his horrified face at the car coming, another sign of how he didn’t know the car was there:(
Don't forget when Lake kicked Lucas' ankle, then in the end, Lucas actually injured his ankle and got ran over.
Wrong again the red is actually Lucas and the other with glasses is lake and they switch places cause lake manipulated Lucas cause he hear him say they won’t believe you and he said they would not be your friends if they knew who you really were
@@Ghxstcore then the rest of the dialogue wouldn’t make sense
Part two please!!!!
3:08 favorite part
Well executed, chilling and an over-all excellent analysis of both twin and sibling mentality. It is hard to stand up to the perceived "golden child", especially when they are your sibling. Lucas is a product of excessive praise and, as a result became a bully. Lake was forced to sit in his brother's shadow due to being framed as the "problem child". You can tell from the teacher's dismissal over Lake being late and the smug face Lucas makes at saying his brother is running late that this is a common occurrence. Lucas possibly sabotages his brother when they wake up and it likely rouses no suspicion because they live close enough to walk to school.
Little behaviors like this, if left unchecked, can gradually grow until you get a situation like we see in the first half; where Lake is tormented constantly because Lucas abuses the fact that everyone sees him as the better child. This is particularly bad in cases with twins because not only are people more likely to compare you both, but you effectively have a living mirror you are expected to be a perfect replica of.
Like John from the most recent 911 episode: he saved his bus driver from a heart attack and later started killing others for the attention.
I have an identical twin brother and can honestly say that we have never been held to the standard of the other twin. In both our home and public lives we have always been judged on our own merits.
Not saying this is normal for all twins, mind you. Just sharing my own experience.
i have a twin this is true
👍
Make sense