Both Aretha and jhud failed miserably! It’s like asking an opera singer to sing “Respect”-- it only works if they take the time to learn to have the right attitude, enunciation and breathing. Jhud doesn’t need to sing it as an opera singer but she NEEDS TO HET HER ENUNCIATION, BREATHING, AND EMOTION CORRECT! sorry but this is a Hot Mess for those who are familiar with this genre and song! Screaming and singing loud without proper sustaining of notes doesn’t work here - it exposes her lack of training! In her genre it works perfectly; but not her! Like getting a line dancer to do ballet without proper training first - it just doesn’t really work- Nice that she’s trying different things but Gurl- u gotta do your homework and come correctly-- u can’t just memorize the words and pick up a mic and think that will work in this arena-- it just doesn’t work and I think Jhud realizes it herself!
They both burned the house down with that torch- and not in a good way! They were both horrible. Bad enunciation; improper breathing; wrong emotion for what the song is about-- just horrible! She has a great voice - no doubt- but she needs to do her homework and study this genre before butchering it like Aretha! We love jhud but if u r going to go outside your lane; then study it and come correctly! I would say the exact same thing if a opera singer attempted “Respect” without the proper sassiness and attitude! Go study this genre and THEN Come correct
@@clickonmikey01 Well if you want to look at it that way. That is probably why most people do not appreciate opera. Most of those singers just study and sing it properly without being naturally gifted with a divine voice. All the studying in the world and hitting the right notes does NOT make for a great performance. The voice must sound pleasing to the ear also. To each his own. You like what you like and I like what I like.
Among the 178 Fox American Idol finalists, I’d rank her at #4. I’d rank Kelly Clarkson at #6. I’d rank Adam Lambert at #5. Whom I’d rank at #3: ruclips.net/video/mqrBQ53ad4c/видео.html Whom I’d rank at #2: ruclips.net/video/5_zGvBYJmXw/видео.html Whom I’d rank at #1: ruclips.net/video/aen83END3gM/видео.html
Wow what a perfect person to sing this beautiful song! She inspired me to always challenge myself. She looked absolutely stunning and i love the dress! Thank you Jennifer Hudson, i always thought that you had a beautiful voice!
Jennifer is so unbelievably good, could listen to her all day long :) I honor, worship and love her from the bottom of my heart. Whenever you will give a concert/performance in Germany, I will pay any price ;) Want to see and listen to you live once in my lifetime if possible in any way :) Cheers, our princess of soul
Aretha's rendition can never be reached. She only had 15 mins to learn this song and perform it. It still is a spiritual experience. She made it her own and felt it.
The orchestra's music was beautiful but it really drowned her out, it was too loud. There's a version on here where she is at the apollo singing this and she was even more amazing!
A really unremarkable tone and timbre. She can do the vocal gymnastics but there’s nothing special or memorable or iconic with her voice. She has volume, but nothing that draws you in - like Aretha’s smokiness or Mariah’s honey or Whitney’s bell-like clarity, Patti’s impish creativity. Hudson just leaves me cold. People literally crying in the audience, I’m like… reallllyy? She was screaming and it was thin and shrill.
I enjoyed most of her rendition. But those last few notes didn't work. Aretha sounded better, and wisely moved further away from an opera style and sung it Aretha style. There is nothing wrong with non opera singers doing an aria, if they can make it their own and make sure every note comes correct. It can serve to capture the interest of those who weren't opera fans.
O.K....first of all, I am a HUGE Jennifer Hudson fan. I have all of her CDs and I will continue to support her music and endeavors. However, this is not her genre. Coming from someone who sings opera, this was tough to watch. Her intonation, diction and pitch were off, and she looked nervous. She started singing this song in a soprano-ish range but as it went on, she went to a more contralto-ish range, which is the belting portion of her voice and it's great but not for this song. To sing this song and other opera arias, you must incorporate great technique because Nessun Dorma is not entirely about just belting, but she wasn't even doing that, she was hollering, and it turned into a hit or miss song and it missed. This is not about "hating" on her. Jennifer has to find her true voice and this genre isn't it. Here lately, it sounds as if she's relying more on the hollering portion of her voice and it's losing its vibrancy. Still love you Jennifer!
@@rosieramos9464 And you know what? There's nothing wrong with that. Hell, opera singers don't usually excel at say Johnny Mathis or Frank Sinatra. Those are entirely different genres and disciplines altogether. I LOVED LOVED LOVED Jennifer's JHud CD! I thought that she didn't get a fair shake from her record label on that. However, this is a no for me.
No one is born an opera singer. That song was an opera aria but she was not singing in Opera. She can learn intonation, diction & pitch as well as other techniques like you did.
@@cedricedwards4760 True. Yes, she can learn the necessary requirements to incorporate change. In this instance, it would've been better if she had taken more time to learn her craft for this song. Opera arias will expose weaknesses and it did in her case. She likes to belt but in Opera arias, it requires significantly more discipline than just belting. She went from singing in her head voice and into her chest voice and the transition wasn't good. It's like I said: I love Jennifer and will buy her music but this is not good.
@@Songbird_Singz88 Vicky was speaking straight facts. You can hear that she can barely hold those top notes because she’s yelling. It sounds painful. Truly a slap in the face to actual opera singers
@@dannysanchez1478 Sorry, but we cannot take you seriously…nobody said that she is an opera singer. People like her, Aretha and Whitney in the past got invited to participate as „NON-opera“ singers to make it THEIR way…you should inform and read what this idea is all about before complaining again. You should also watch some opera singers‘ and opera vocal coaches’ reactions here on YT about JHud‘s performances and capabilities, they are full of admiration and they are blown off by her. AGAIN, of course there are opera singers out there who can sing opera in a better technical way… they were coached for many years to come there…this was a GUEST performance, and 99% of listeners were fascinated (except you annd half a dozen other people who are „insulted“ by her voice…my goodness…)
Don't argue with Opera purist it's pointless they are so stuck up and stuck on themselves so much it's just ridiculous Whitney Houston for example can sing Opera ,jazz,blues, showtunes ect but by Opera folks who don't nearly have the versitilty to sing her songs are often super haters I take anything they say with a grain of salt
I love Hudson and it's obvious she has a powerful voice but for this piece she lacks the proper technique. She pushes too much air and was bringing her shoulders up a lot at the very last part. Opera is somehow soft but it projects a lot, compare here there is not mm.. enough air to hug each word. She was struggling, good job though 👏👏👏
This was very bad classical technique. You can hear how it hurts. She is yelling. Her diction is terrible, her Italian is terrible, her placement is incorrect. There’s many things wrong here. Yes she may have sounded better than many individuals but this was almost an insult to the classical community in my opinion.
Whitney & Aretha Must Be So PROUD❤❤️🩹
I love how she is stretching herself. I also love her outfit in this!
OMG!!!! OMG!!!! Jennifer Hudson absolutely nailed it! Moving beyond words!!!
How could one not love this magnificent rendition/performance of this classic piece of drama, Jennifer made it absolutely sensational
She is truly a vocal savage! That was BEAUTIFUL 💞
She is the best singer I have heard in a long time and it's effortless
she literally gave me chills.
Just beautiful., Jennifer your voice has been kissed by God., you’re amazing👌🏾❤️❤️❤️
Only the best non-opera vocalists get invited to sing opera on a global scale, ie Aretha and Jennifer!
But she is not singing opera 😂😂
David Phelps is one too
David Phelps is one too
@@CallasAfrica She is bringing an aria to a new audience
Both Aretha and jhud failed miserably! It’s like asking an opera singer to sing “Respect”-- it only works if they take the time to learn to have the right attitude, enunciation and breathing. Jhud doesn’t need to sing it as an opera singer but she NEEDS TO HET HER ENUNCIATION, BREATHING, AND EMOTION CORRECT! sorry but this is a Hot Mess for those who are familiar with this genre and song! Screaming and singing loud without proper sustaining of notes doesn’t work here - it exposes her lack of training! In her genre it works perfectly; but not her! Like getting a line dancer to do ballet without proper training first - it just doesn’t really work- Nice that she’s trying different things but Gurl- u gotta do your homework and come correctly-- u can’t just memorize the words and pick up a mic and think that will work in this arena-- it just doesn’t work and I think Jhud realizes it herself!
Absolutely amazing!! Blessed!!! Chills went through my body! And I seen tears in the croud!🔥❤️🎶
Jennifer is a vocal beast
PURE CLASS AND TALENT
Mega powerhouse diva the one and only Ms. JENNIFER HUDSON .i bow down🏰 pure royalty.
First time I've seen this. She got better as it went along. Outstanding!
I love Nessum Dorma and she did that!!! 🔥
Jennifer Jennifer Jennifer!!! My most favourite artist
Aretha had no rehearsal with orchestra. She sang this song in Pavarotti's key notes, and that is why she is called The Queen of Soul!
You did that Jenn! Aretha passed the torch to you.
They both burned the house down with that torch- and not in a good way! They were both horrible. Bad enunciation; improper breathing; wrong emotion for what the song is about-- just horrible! She has a great voice - no doubt- but she needs to do her homework and study this genre before butchering it like Aretha! We love jhud but if u r going to go outside your lane; then study it and come correctly! I would say the exact same thing if a opera singer attempted “Respect” without the proper sassiness and attitude! Go study this genre and THEN Come correct
@@clickonmikey01 Well if you want to look at it that way. That is probably why most people do not appreciate opera. Most of those singers just study and sing it properly without being naturally gifted with a divine voice. All the studying in the world and hitting the right notes does NOT make for a great performance. The voice must sound pleasing to the ear also. To each his own. You like what you like and I like what I like.
MultitalentedJennifer Hudsonis an angelical E.G.O.T. in my humbleopinion!
BEST SINGER/ VOCALIST OF OUR TIME!!!! A TALENT❤
Among the 178 Fox American Idol finalists, I’d rank her at #4. I’d rank Kelly Clarkson at #6. I’d rank Adam Lambert at #5.
Whom I’d rank at #3: ruclips.net/video/mqrBQ53ad4c/видео.html
Whom I’d rank at #2: ruclips.net/video/5_zGvBYJmXw/видео.html
Whom I’d rank at #1: ruclips.net/video/aen83END3gM/видео.html
So beautiful!!
💯💯
This was incredible.😊😁
“Music is the universal language of mankind.” - Henry Wadsworth Longfellow
Wow what a perfect person to sing this beautiful song! She inspired me to always challenge myself. She looked absolutely stunning and i love the dress! Thank you Jennifer Hudson, i always thought that you had a beautiful voice!
Beautiful
Aretha was my favourite singer my whole life but Jennifer Hudson is just amazing. Like she’s the translator for my soul.
Let the church say amen ⛪🙏😇💪🎶🎼🎵🎙️🎤🎧👐💯 Absolutely beautiful dahling GivethanXo #legendary #jenniferhudson
Iconic singer, Queen of all time ❤️👏 Powerful Performance 🔥
Angels are among us. Just gave me chills and tears of joy @jenniferhudson
Magnificently sung🤗😁💖🌷
She gets beter everytime ♥
Wow this is beautiful 👏🏾
Absolutely breath taking
Just FLAWLESS! JHUD QUEEN ALL THE TIME!!!
This is sublime.
Fantástica hermosa maravillosa
amazing!!
Wow! Que voz... 😍
Da italiano dico che è stata fantastica. Bravissima.
I’m stunned.
Beautiful just beautiful 🔥❤️🔥
Wow amazing
took her two months to learn this. THE DEDICATION!!!!
The Best👌🏻💯👏🏼🎼🎙️
Girl you better sing because you know how to. sing baby sing just loving every minute of it
Outstanding! Jennifer is Miss Aretha Franklin all over again. Hearing her sing opera reminded me of Josephine Baker.
❤️❤️❤️
Goosebumps!!!!!!!!😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Fab,fab,and fab.
Beautifully done!
Spellbinding!
Raw talent... I cried
Yessss, girl!!!
Way to go Jennifer!!! Beautiful
Chills
She did that beautifully
Beautiful❤️❤️❤️❤️
Jennifer absolutely stunning Beautiful and she absolutely smashed it 😍❤️😍
Jennifer is so unbelievably good, could listen to her all day long :) I honor, worship and love her from the bottom of my heart. Whenever you will give a concert/performance in Germany, I will pay any price ;) Want to see and listen to you live once in my lifetime if possible in any way :) Cheers, our princess of soul
And the church says Amen
Go head Jen!!
YES!!!!!
CRYIIIIIIIIING!!!!
stunning... the new standard
They are trying to make Jennifer Hudson like Aretha Franklin😊
Wwooowwww!
Aretha's rendition can never be reached. She only had 15 mins to learn this song and perform it. It still is a spiritual experience. She made it her own and felt it.
Well she already knew the song as she sang it at a Music Cares event for Pavarotti.
🙏❤️❤️❤️
Omg
Coming from a pretty crappy Year from an Italian woman that has lost hope....You brought Light and Beaty
Jesus loves you 🙏🏼❤️
I was scared the mic would break. Wow
Meu Deus 😱🥰🥰🥰
Chingonzisimo!!!!!
The orchestra's music was beautiful but it really drowned her out, it was too loud. There's a version on here where she is at the apollo singing this and she was even more amazing!
Right. I feel like she was way too close to the orchestra and it drowned her out in those non belty moments
Brava e bello ascoltarti in italiano...😄😄😄😉😘💝👑
Unfortunately audio (recording audio) wasn’t really that good.
Jhud I need you❤️🩹
She is so beautiful
Absolutely beatiful
Soprano dramática por excelencia
She is a natural dramatic soprano if she learns how to sing that way omg she would be unstoppable
Omgaaawd!!! I’m going outside to slap somebody!!! 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
A really unremarkable tone and timbre. She can do the vocal gymnastics but there’s nothing special or memorable or iconic with her voice. She has volume, but nothing that draws you in - like Aretha’s smokiness or Mariah’s honey or Whitney’s bell-like clarity, Patti’s impish creativity. Hudson just leaves me cold. People literally crying in the audience, I’m like… reallllyy? She was screaming and it was thin and shrill.
I didn't hear the vin of the vincerò in the last two vinceròs 😕
Much as I love her - she is not a trained opera singer - go to Callas and Pavarotti X
6/10
She did the song good, but I liked Aretha’s better it touch my heart:
2:44 sounds outta tune
I love Jennifer Hudson and all that is her.. But, NO!!!
She has one of the best voices alive, but I didn’t like this.
A big no
I enjoyed most of her rendition. But those last few notes didn't work. Aretha sounded better, and wisely moved further away from an opera style and sung it Aretha style.
There is nothing wrong with non opera singers doing an aria, if they can make it their own and make sure every note comes correct. It can serve to capture the interest of those who weren't opera fans.
I love JHUD, but I didn’t love this performance. She did look beautiful though.
O.K....first of all, I am a HUGE Jennifer Hudson fan. I have all of her CDs and I will continue to support her music and endeavors. However, this is not her genre. Coming from someone who sings opera, this was tough to watch. Her intonation, diction and pitch were off, and she looked nervous. She started singing this song in a soprano-ish range but as it went on, she went to a more contralto-ish range, which is the belting portion of her voice and it's great but not for this song. To sing this song and other opera arias, you must incorporate great technique because Nessun Dorma is not entirely about just belting, but she wasn't even doing that, she was hollering, and it turned into a hit or miss song and it missed. This is not about "hating" on her. Jennifer has to find her true voice and this genre isn't it. Here lately, it sounds as if she's relying more on the hollering portion of her voice and it's losing its vibrancy. Still love you Jennifer!
Agreed. Not her genre but made a great effort.
@@rosieramos9464 And you know what? There's nothing wrong with that. Hell, opera singers don't usually excel at say Johnny Mathis or Frank Sinatra. Those are entirely different genres and disciplines altogether. I LOVED LOVED LOVED Jennifer's JHud CD! I thought that she didn't get a fair shake from her record label on that. However, this is a no for me.
No one is born an opera singer. That song was an opera aria but she was not singing in Opera. She can learn intonation, diction & pitch as well as other techniques like you did.
@@cedricedwards4760 True. Yes, she can learn the necessary requirements to incorporate change. In this instance, it would've been better if she had taken more time to learn her craft for this song. Opera arias will expose weaknesses and it did in her case. She likes to belt but in Opera arias, it requires significantly more discipline than just belting. She went from singing in her head voice and into her chest voice and the transition wasn't good. It's like I said: I love Jennifer and will buy her music but this is not good.
That’s why you will stay stuck. Was Jennifer Hudson Audra McDonald obviously not but Jennifer’s range far exceeds most modern day singers.
opera is dead :(
So is RnB..😢
a slap in the face to the opera genre.... maybe it was better live
There's always gonna be some hater lurking ....on a page of a person they don't even like .. pathetic
@@Songbird_Singz88 Vicky was speaking straight facts. You can hear that she can barely hold those top notes because she’s yelling. It sounds painful. Truly a slap in the face to actual opera singers
@@dannysanchez1478 Sorry, but we cannot take you seriously…nobody said that she is an opera singer. People like her, Aretha and Whitney in the past got invited to participate as „NON-opera“ singers to make it THEIR way…you should inform and read what this idea is all about before complaining again. You should also watch some opera singers‘ and opera vocal coaches’ reactions here on YT about JHud‘s performances and capabilities, they are full of admiration and they are blown off by her. AGAIN, of course there are opera singers out there who can sing opera in a better technical way… they were coached for many years to come there…this was a GUEST performance, and 99% of listeners were fascinated (except you annd half a dozen other people who are „insulted“ by her voice…my goodness…)
Don't argue with Opera purist it's pointless they are so stuck up and stuck on themselves so much it's just ridiculous Whitney Houston for example can sing Opera ,jazz,blues, showtunes ect but by Opera folks who don't nearly have the versitilty to sing her songs are often super haters I take anything they say with a grain of salt
@@Songbird_Singz88 HOw is she a "hater?"
Disaster
It's nice, but not true operatic
Aretha sang it better with beautiful runs, more soul and feeling ... Jennifers voice was kind of boring.....
I love Hudson and it's obvious she has a powerful voice but for this piece she lacks the proper technique. She pushes too much air and was bringing her shoulders up a lot at the very last part. Opera is somehow soft but it projects a lot, compare here there is not mm.. enough air to hug each word. She was struggling, good job though 👏👏👏
Since you are putting your opinion out here, I want too hear you do it better than the incomparable JHUD., if not stay in your lane🙄🤐🤷🏽♀️🤦🏾♀️
This was very bad classical technique. You can hear how it hurts. She is yelling. Her diction is terrible, her Italian is terrible, her placement is incorrect. There’s many things wrong here. Yes she may have sounded better than many individuals but this was almost an insult to the classical community in my opinion.
G5 belted babyyyyy! Tell me who’s done it in this song…..not even Pavarotti…
@Alejandro Tamez don't embarrass yourself. This was really bad. Not hating on jennifer but she liked like she was in pain