@@catherinewhitman8333 I've been listening to Carville and Maher since the 90s. What looses my attention is 6 people all yelling at the same time and nobody listening to anyone else or obvious liers.
Elitest BS. Quaint obsession with Trump, and they don’t think MAGA “interviews” aren’t cherry picked? It’s the deep state system enslaving us ALL. Two parties are just a distraction for us to think we are free.
Bill said in the Owens interview that Dennis Prager looks like a pervert. So Bill does Jamie boy look like a pervert. Bill has a vary low IQ he is not smart not even a little bit.
I had same experience with him in Vegas. I was at a bar and saw him walking by, I yelled out “Carville”, as he passed by, gave me high five and kept walking. Very cool guy and I’m not a democrat and lean right. I’ve always felt this guy was a straight shooter and not far left loon. A reasonable guy you could converse with and would listen.
he is one of the most dishonest scumbags around, he said teh conservatives want to get rid of the 14th amendment, this is a lie, the conventions of states wants a balenced budget amenment, rank choice voting, and term limits for congress and senate. giving congress a blank check is like putting a raging crack addict in charge of your money and investments.
If people are intelligent, and nuanced to some extent yet authentic and rational, no matter what your politics, it's hard to dislike them. He's a good example.
Just pure gold here and the reason free form podcasts need to exist. Carville is unfiltered and no spin. Refreshing to hear the details and machinations of in the trenches politics. When you remove the embellishments of spin, propaganda, posturing you can see a path to compromise and consensus. It really makes you wonder how many Congress people would vote for an agenda if they did not fear Party - not constituent - retribution.
All are good, but this old timer wants to hear guests that want to make a difference. James is a unique treasure and has a super podcast, email questions are fun. Never underestimate a southern gulf coaster.
I met this guy years ago at a gas station. I didn't realize it was him.I was on my way to work .I was pumping gas and this clean early 70s pickup pulled in.The driver started a conversation with me and we talked for quite a while.I drove away and suddenly realized that was James Carville.I'm not liberal or political at all but he he was a very cool person. .
He's very unusual in that he's somewhat open-minded. His wife is Mary Matalin, who is very, very conservative. How they stayed married is beyond me. But she's much, much smarter than him. She was one of the very, very few in 2016 who realized that Trump was going to win. Here she is two months before the election saying that Trump had a "100 percent change" to win, no doubt in her mind at all. Her take is exactly on the money, maybe the best analysis of the 2016 election of them all. But she seems to have retired from commentary. ruclips.net/video/D-0Pd6twLG8/видео.html
That's fine.Being skeptical these days is smart.It's 100% true.And it's utterly unimportant.Seems like a worthless lie.But please explain your theory sir.@@chickenfishhybrid44
I wish Bill would always talk politics like this instead of the scripted stuff on Real Time. I would pay money for this type of information and insight - and opinions from people as knowledgeable as Bill and James.
Thank you for an engaged intelligent conversation. I love it when people are listening to each other and responding to what was said. No scoring points.
You know this show it's about knowing people in a relaxed environment, no format, natural conversations, and certainly it's not an interview format. Some people don't talk much and feel comfortable that way.
No kidding. I've seen em all. There is a running narrative here, one that I agree with, that Bill tends to talk through the guests, make it about his usual talking points, and show disregard for any real input from the guest. Not here. He did a good job.@@gezaporkolab
Loved this show with James Carville..miss his humor and insight. Just retired from a small Florida college ...everything that both of you discussed is right on. At 75...I have come to finally accept the fact that academia has turned into a big business rather than a place of true learning and critical thinking! Sad.
But on the bright side universities push the same conformity based on complete bullshit. University shut down any conservatives views to the detriment of seeking the truth. The truth more often lies in the middle.
Bring James Carville back again! Your BEST podcast to date. Good Job! Love the idea about government child care it goes hand in hand with women’s equality. ❤
@@Illumirage me? Am I terrible human? I like the idea of Government child care, we pay enough in property taxes & income taxes to cover the expenses of child care for 6mo to 5 yrs old then they are in kindergarten. We also need all Gov schools to have after school programs until 6pm so parents can work.
Nope! You didn't hear the racist comment he made about the black man in muddy work boots that can't wipe his ass. All because the black man from the south voted for Trump 😢 sad.
I truly believe the democratic party is a party filled with racist. It's the party where an old white man can say "if you don't vote for me you ain't black" Biden.
Seriously?? He said Whitmer is good, said, not implied, said all or at least most republicans don’t want presidents who break the law to be barred from being presidents (I see where his little knowledge on the subject can lead him to think this way) but also says they don’t want black people’s individual rights and doesn’t want their vote to count. I’m only 11 minutes into this, and having watched his Real Time it’s clear he gets his information from liberal media that also doesn’t know shit about the Republican Party or conservatives
The MAGA Trump cult, though, will vote for him against their own economic interests, just to 'own the libs' -- and because the ultra-fundamentalist evangelical Christians out there in TV land believe the bullshit they're preached: that God chose Trump to be an 'anointed' king of America . . . that the election really WAS stolen by 'DemonRats' against God's Will, etc. Those crazy bastards never viewed Romney or McCain that way -- though there were certain zany vibes regarding 'W', as in the documentary "JESUS CAMP" in the immediate aftermath of 9/11, when for them it became a Holy War of Christian America against Islamist Terrorism, with their belief that God must have 'chosen' George W, Bush to 'win' the 2000 election, just so he'd be the one leading our righteous forces in the fight, rather than Gore. It wasn't the Economy that led to Trump's win in 2016. Under Obama/Biden, the economy recovered from the nosedive that Bush/Cheney left us with and steadily improved over the course of 8 years . . . but Republicans (and their Fox News propaganda wing) complained that the recovery under Obama wasn't good enough -- this after their last elected POTUS (W) had TANKED the economy! It wasn't the Economy that Trump's most rabid fanbase was concerned about; it was all the dog-whistling he did catering to their hatred of everything even slightly to the left of the Alt-Right. I only WISH the state of the Economy would guarantee victory, since America's doing just fine, especially compared to the rest of the world in the wake of the Covid crisis. Our only hope is that the majority of Americans who despise Trump will vote BLUE down the line, ensuring a Democrat is in the White House and, hopefully, that the Dems keep the Senate AND flip the House -- preferably with sizable majorities in both so that obstructionist shenanigans by DINOs like Manchin and Synema won't hamstring a sensible agenda. Maybe Boebert will be defeated in Colorado, too, after her 'sleeve-job' incident pisses off too many of the fed-up Republican base who just can't abide such hypocrisy. There's hope yet!
I used to buy that argument until the 2022 midterms. Biden and Democrats had to defend 8% inflation and $4 a gallon gas and the Republican tsunami never happened.
I had stopped watching bc I got tired of seeing Bill stupid stoned & slurring words. Watched this one to see James Carville. This was by far the best episode in a very long time. Enjoyed the conversation immensely.
I was getting concerned by the amount of alcohol Bill was drinking. It made him a sloppy ignorant drunk. His smoking was not his problem. He seemed to be working thru something. He is good now. These two understand the back room politics. They are great!!!
Good interview. Talking with Mr Carville is truly talking to history as a political insider. I appreciate that you’re an Independent and look honestly at each candidate. I learned that “woke” folks only make up a few Democrats as I had the [mis]conception that all Democrats are woke. To paraphrase Mr. Carville, all Democrats aren’t woke but all woke are Democrats. My fault with the Democratic elected officials is that they don’t publicly tell the woke that they are stupid (as you have done repeatedly); or, at best, they simply ignore it. Thank you for mentioning our education problems but I wish you had talked about the immigration crisis, the homeless/drug crisis, the crime crisis (at least in large cities).
I am a republican but I love James Carville, my favorite quote is "drag a fitty dolla bill through a trailer park and you don't know what you gonna get"
i was working in Pentagon city in 2005 and I believe he lived near by and i saw him a few times in my stores. One day I had the courage to finally walk up and thank him for his work. He graciously said thank you and was very kind.
I'm a "liberal" in Utah and have had many obviously "conservative" friendships here most of my life that I value immensely. We discuss contentious things, but no one holds grudges, and we just try to understand each other. I also work with people all over the world, and we (almost) always get along about anything. It takes two to tango.
That's the way it is supposed to be. We should learn from each other & maybe compromise yet never JUDGE some1 for their beliefs as long as they r civil & dont hurt anyone. NO 1 IS ABOVE THE LAW. Thx u give me hope.
Yea, Mike Lee is way smart, but the same way Ted Cruz is way smart , but with no friendships across lines and stay on your sides, good side.@@mojomojo5779
Just spent most of the summer in Utah and I agree that I saw some of what your saying, but Utah will likely never produce national political leaders. Can't keep the state folks happy and then expand to the national stage. It's too far a leap to travel.
This is the best interview/ conversation that Bill has had in the long time. I made some good insights from listening to this conversation. Much needed ❤ thank you.
Thank you for having this conversation. I needed it after work. I went to a Mexican restaurant, sat in the bar, ate a taco and enjoyed the discussion you had.
So true! I get Bill wants a relaxed chill/fun convo in this new incarnation but man he def gets a little too random & misses some great talking points . Kinda frustrating
this episode was marginally better than the bill cranston episode - at least james carville can get out of his own way... bill cranston is lost and turned out to be a total putz ... ❤
Bill, I am a fan from way back. It concerns me that the last few shows of club random you are talking over the guest. We’re all getting older and slower, let them talk! I tune in to hear what they have to say! Thank you for all you do❤
High quality daycare back in the day in 60 and 70's was done by grandma and grandpa who were retired, aunts who didn't, work, teenagers who looked out for younger kids of farm families in their rural neighborhoods. That was daycare back in the day.
@@dustinweber1945you have a point. A friend of mine retired for 7 months then returned coz EVERYONE was asking her to babysit. Why not? Youre retired. How presumptuous.
That was because grandmas and grandpa could retire. Young ladies could pay their way through college by babysitting, Now you have to own a hedge fund to be able to afford college or daycare
The best argument for daycare is Henry Kieser in WWII. The only way he could get his shipyards to produce a Liberty ship a day was to hire Women ie “Rossie the Riveter” - the only way he could get these women to take these jobs was to offer Daycare.
Ohhhh you don't see what's happening at these schools now. Parents don't stand a chance. Students who push back when they're told 2+2=5 get exiled. Open your eyes. The Ds will pay at the polls for it.
James has a seasoned Southern voice, theirs no way it could eva be copied or abused so the culprits would come up looking stupid for even trying... wonderful conversation fellas,,,
Jordan Peterson says it best. (paraphrased) On the right, you can tell when they've gone too far. When you see people breaking out the jackboots and badges, things have gone too far. On the left, there is no limit to how far things can go.
@@pdcdesign9632 Yeah isn't that great! Bill the atheist has religious guests on, and he treats then kindly. Are you able to talk to atheists, or are you too scared of them?
Sen. Chris Murphy is WONDERFUL! I'm from MN and if he ever ran for president, I'd feel GREAT voting for Murphy. Quality human being of real HEART & INTEGRITY
J.C.'s education: "Louisiana State University LSU Paul M. Hebert Law Center Ascension Catholic High Following the conclusion of his military enlistment, Carville finished his studies at LSU at night, where he earned his Bachelor of Science degree in General Studies in 1970, and his Juris Doctor degree in 1973. Carville is a member of the Sigma Nu fraternity."
I agree our schools are failing miserably. I am 64 and I was lucky to get a good high school education. The blame must be shared with the parents. Both of my parents were educators. My father made me learn Greek and Latin roots and tested me on them. At the time I hated this. When I became an paramedic it became obvious how lucky I had parents who were partners in the education process
Hi Kenneth. That's a very cool comment and I applaud you (and your parents). Greek and Latin. I didn't realise that I had an interest in English until I had to study Shakespeare. I did not get any formal Greek or Latin and I wish I had. Paramedic is an interesting career choice and I hope it served you well. On a side note, I am also 64 years old.
Some awfully presumptuous things being said about Springsteen by Maher , and I’m not even a fan. Maybe Springsteen simply doesn’t like Christie, or want him around. 2023 Bill is opinion before facts, personal agenda before facts.
Hearing James Carville drop the f bomb gives me an unreasonable amount of joy. Another great interview!
Missed that, what was the timestamp?
Why do people think swear words make them grown up. 3 year olds can cuss with as much enthusiasm as any grown up.
@@miyojewoltsnasonth2159are you so used to hearing it that you don't even notice? At least 10 times.
@@Kathleen-pl9pumaybe it's the only way they can get your attention!
@@catherinewhitman8333 I've been listening to Carville and Maher since the 90s. What looses my attention is 6 people all yelling at the same time and nobody listening to anyone else or obvious liers.
LOVE James Carville! Please have him on Real Time more frequently.
Elitest BS. Quaint obsession with Trump, and they don’t think MAGA “interviews” aren’t cherry picked? It’s the deep state system enslaving us ALL. Two parties are just a distraction for us to think we are free.
Carville and his wife Mary Matlin are the best. Would love to see them both on Real Time
@@NairaRenault I agree he's great!
Bill said in the Owens interview that Dennis Prager looks like a pervert. So Bill does Jamie boy look like a pervert. Bill has a vary low IQ he is not smart not even a little bit.
@@NairaRenault you could’ve made a point with this
I had same experience with him in Vegas. I was at a bar and saw him walking by, I yelled out “Carville”, as he passed by, gave me high five and kept walking. Very cool guy and I’m not a democrat and lean right. I’ve always felt this guy was a straight shooter and not far left loon. A reasonable guy you could converse with and would listen.
Nothing less cool and more lame than bothering a celebrity. James Carville couldn't care less aboit you.
T right
I remember James saying that people use social media the way a drunk uses a lamppost.
They seek support, not… illumination.
What percentage of social media can teach you something? 10%?
That was an awesome comment
Funny
Great quote. I've never heard that.
I gotta admit, I do that.
Bill don’t be afraid to have political talk on Club Random. James was awesome. I love the long form interviews.
he is one of the most dishonest scumbags around, he said teh conservatives want to get rid of the 14th amendment, this is a lie, the conventions of states wants a balenced budget amenment, rank choice voting, and term limits for congress and senate. giving congress a blank check is like putting a raging crack addict in charge of your money and investments.
If people are intelligent, and nuanced to some extent yet authentic and rational, no matter what your politics, it's hard to dislike them. He's a good example.
I'm trying very hard to even take these two seriously. So much craziness.
BOOM. Really well said. These guys are bright and funny and this exchange was just so genuine and super chill and relaxed. Great comment.
James Carville??? Just came from Real Time, he certainly doesn’t seem like that kinda person
good interview, James Carville is always interesting
Just pure gold here and the reason free form podcasts need to exist. Carville is unfiltered and no spin. Refreshing to hear the details and machinations of in the trenches politics. When you remove the embellishments of spin, propaganda, posturing you can see a path to compromise and consensus. It really makes you wonder how many Congress people would vote for an agenda if they did not fear Party - not constituent - retribution.
And the Oscar for best podcast interview goes to this one. Quality, informative and real. Thank you
Now THAT was a conversation that I could (and did) listen to.
Best interview in quite awhile, this conversation is everything I wish Real Time could be!! Great Job. Thanks
All are good, but this old timer wants to hear guests that want to make a difference. James is a unique treasure and has a super podcast, email questions are fun. Never underestimate a southern gulf coaster.
Bill has let his fear of me too turn him into conservative wing nut.
It's nice to hear a interview without all that hooping and hollering and clapping like on his other show.
9:00 As a Michigander Whitmer is rlly not that good, I can’t take too much of what he says seriously unless I know he’s right, and w this he’s mot
😃 Great show, please have him on again before next election. I could listen to both of them for a long time.
When James Carville was 45 he looked 65, but now that he's 78 he looks 65.
That’s because the stem cell research we’ve come along way! 😅
Clinton’s top shelf Adrenachrome
Let's find out what he's drinking. 🥤🥤🥤
lol right on the money 😅
Theres something to be said for aging early
Hey Bill, this is an AMAZING episode!!!! Keep up the GREAT WORK, and James Carville ROCKS!!!! 🤘
Lol. Sure buddy 😂
Love James Carville.Very interesting
💙💙💙
I'm not a big fan but knew this would be an outrageously interesting conversation. Thanks, William!
I met this guy years ago at a gas station. I didn't realize it was him.I was on my way to work .I was pumping gas and this clean early 70s pickup pulled in.The driver started a conversation with me and we talked for quite a while.I drove away and suddenly realized that was James Carville.I'm not liberal or political at all but he he was a very cool person.
.
Great story, *@uncred.*
He's very unusual in that he's somewhat open-minded. His wife is Mary Matalin, who is very, very conservative. How they stayed married is beyond me. But she's much, much smarter than him. She was one of the very, very few in 2016 who realized that Trump was going to win. Here she is two months before the election saying that Trump had a "100 percent change" to win, no doubt in her mind at all. Her take is exactly on the money, maybe the best analysis of the 2016 election of them all. But she seems to have retired from commentary.
ruclips.net/video/D-0Pd6twLG8/видео.html
He's a treasure, has a good podcast too.
Lucky You! He has always been a hero to me.
That's fine.Being skeptical these days is smart.It's 100% true.And it's utterly unimportant.Seems like a worthless lie.But please explain your theory sir.@@chickenfishhybrid44
This is honestly one of my favorite interviews ever
I wish Bill would always talk politics like this instead of the scripted stuff on Real Time. I would pay money for this type of information and insight - and opinions from people as knowledgeable as Bill and James.
This was excellent. One of Bill's best!
I Just love this interview, it's normal I wish more conversation could be like this between 2/party's!
Awesome! Thanks for all you're doing Bill!! And to Bill's team as well.
I loved being a part of this great political conversation. Thank you!!
Thank you for an engaged intelligent conversation. I love it when people are listening to each other and responding to what was said. No scoring points.
Bill's best interview in terms of flow, listening, not interrupting etc....
And he NEVER said COCK as he did, many TIMES, the Female Skier...
CLASSLESS...😮
You know this show it's about knowing people in a relaxed environment, no format, natural conversations, and certainly it's not an interview format. Some people don't talk much and feel comfortable that way.
I agree
No kidding. I've seen em all. There is a running narrative here, one that I agree with, that Bill tends to talk through the guests, make it about his usual talking points, and show disregard for any real input from the guest. Not here. He did a good job.@@gezaporkolab
That’s for sure. Bill kissed ass in this one.
He talked right over Riley Gaines and kept yelling “Cock!” in that one.
I can barely understand James most of the time, but when I do he always hits it right for me. Good interview with lots of insight.
Excellent discussion, thank you Gentlemen. RBL
Loved this show with James Carville..miss his humor and insight. Just retired from a small Florida college ...everything that both of you discussed is right on. At 75...I have come to finally accept the fact that academia has turned into a big business rather than a place of true learning and critical thinking! Sad.
And so it goes. World War II, We dont need a sequel!
But on the bright side universities push the same conformity based on complete bullshit. University shut down any conservatives views to the detriment of seeking the truth. The truth more often lies in the middle.
"...academia has turned into a big business rather than a place of true learning and critical thinking!" Very true. I'm in that world.
True that!
why do all liberals stan for a guy who epitomizes southern white racists
Bring James Carville back again! Your BEST podcast to date. Good Job! Love the idea about government child care it goes hand in hand with women’s equality. ❤
Terrible human being
absolutely a great guest but, at times, I was wanting subtitles. ha
@@Illumirage me? Am I terrible human? I like the idea of Government child care, we pay enough in property taxes & income taxes to cover the expenses of child care for 6mo to 5 yrs old then they are in kindergarten. We also need all Gov schools to have after school programs until 6pm so parents can work.
@@joanneweed1683 no, James
I wish this could have been four hours long, best episode yet!
Bill M reading commercials is hilarious.
Fantastic!!! Thank you gentlemen.
Love James Carville !!
This is my kind of political convo!! Speaking right to my heart. Damn is carville amazing…
Nope! You didn't hear the racist comment he made about the black man in muddy work boots that can't wipe his ass. All because the black man from the south voted for Trump 😢 sad.
I truly believe the democratic party is a party filled with racist. It's the party where an old white man can say "if you don't vote for me you ain't black" Biden.
Seriously?? He said Whitmer is good, said, not implied, said all or at least most republicans don’t want presidents who break the law to be barred from being presidents (I see where his little knowledge on the subject can lead him to think this way) but also says they don’t want black people’s individual rights and doesn’t want their vote to count. I’m only 11 minutes into this, and having watched his Real Time it’s clear he gets his information from liberal media that also doesn’t know shit about the Republican Party or conservatives
Always a joy to see James ❤
"Its the economy, stupid" - James Carville. all these years later its still the economy, stupid. its what will decide the next election.
The MAGA Trump cult, though, will vote for him against their own economic interests, just to 'own the libs' -- and because the ultra-fundamentalist evangelical Christians out there in TV land believe the bullshit they're preached: that God chose Trump to be an 'anointed' king of America . . . that the election really WAS stolen by 'DemonRats' against God's Will, etc. Those crazy bastards never viewed Romney or McCain that way -- though there were certain zany vibes regarding 'W', as in the documentary "JESUS CAMP" in the immediate aftermath of 9/11, when for them it became a Holy War of Christian America against Islamist Terrorism, with their belief that God must have 'chosen' George W, Bush to 'win' the 2000 election, just so he'd be the one leading our righteous forces in the fight, rather than Gore.
It wasn't the Economy that led to Trump's win in 2016. Under Obama/Biden, the economy recovered from the nosedive that Bush/Cheney left us with and steadily improved over the course of 8 years . . . but Republicans (and their Fox News propaganda wing) complained that the recovery under Obama wasn't good enough -- this after their last elected POTUS (W) had TANKED the economy! It wasn't the Economy that Trump's most rabid fanbase was concerned about; it was all the dog-whistling he did catering to their hatred of everything even slightly to the left of the Alt-Right.
I only WISH the state of the Economy would guarantee victory, since America's doing just fine, especially compared to the rest of the world in the wake of the Covid crisis. Our only hope is that the majority of Americans who despise Trump will vote BLUE down the line, ensuring a Democrat is in the White House and, hopefully, that the Dems keep the Senate AND flip the House -- preferably with sizable majorities in both so that obstructionist shenanigans by DINOs like Manchin and Synema won't hamstring a sensible agenda.
Maybe Boebert will be defeated in Colorado, too, after her 'sleeve-job' incident pisses off too many of the fed-up Republican base who just can't abide such hypocrisy. There's hope yet!
That theory failed Trump 2020. His economy was record setting
I used to buy that argument until the 2022 midterms. Biden and Democrats had to defend 8% inflation and $4 a gallon gas and the Republican tsunami never happened.
No the nut cases will win because the right is louder and meaner
The economy is doing well right now and should be doing great by November 2024.
How can you not love this guy! Classic! And thanks to Ari Melber I have been able to study him! Fascinated
Love Ari, too!!!
I had stopped watching bc I got tired of seeing Bill stupid stoned & slurring words. Watched this one to see James Carville. This was by far the best episode in a very long time. Enjoyed the conversation immensely.
I was getting concerned by the
amount of alcohol Bill was drinking. It made him a sloppy ignorant drunk. His smoking was not his
problem. He seemed
to be working thru something. He is good now. These two understand the
back room politics. They are great!!!
Love Carville... These 2 men are plain speaking , tell it like it is
Good interview. Talking with Mr Carville is truly talking to history as a political insider. I appreciate that you’re an Independent and look honestly at each candidate. I learned that “woke” folks only make up a few Democrats as I had the [mis]conception that all Democrats are woke. To paraphrase Mr. Carville, all Democrats aren’t woke but all woke are Democrats. My fault with the Democratic elected officials is that they don’t publicly tell the woke that they are stupid (as you have done repeatedly); or, at best, they simply ignore it.
Thank you for mentioning our education problems but I wish you had talked about the immigration crisis, the homeless/drug crisis, the crime crisis (at least in large cities).
Finally a good episode with a normal, smart guest. More of this please
This was the most entertaining interview you’ve done yet on club random. Love the political talk.
I have always liked James Carville!! Very interesting
I am a republican but I love James Carville, my favorite quote is "drag a fitty dolla bill through a trailer park and you don't know what you gonna get"
Like him...always have but if I knew him personally, I would say "Jim, those pants aren't for you" 😘
I wish Bill let James talk more. He’s such a fascinating man.
Bill, please have Mr. Carville back on when you can. The conversation and chemistry were both great!
LOVE James Carville! Best one of these yet for me.
i was working in Pentagon city in 2005 and I believe he lived near by and i saw him a few times in my stores. One day I had the courage to finally walk up and thank him for his work. He graciously said thank you and was very kind.
I always enjoy listening to JC. He’s very knowledgeable about the inner workings of politics. He’s a person I’d love to talk with one on one.
Myself being a Florida Democrat of deep southern roots I would very happy to have a conversation with James.
Please speak about black people who raisist... there are many.
I'm a "liberal" in Utah and have had many obviously "conservative" friendships here most of my life that I value immensely. We discuss contentious things, but no one holds grudges, and we just try to understand each other. I also work with people all over the world, and we (almost) always get along about anything. It takes two to tango.
That's the way it is supposed to be. We should learn from each other & maybe compromise yet never JUDGE some1 for their beliefs as long as they r civil & dont hurt anyone. NO 1 IS ABOVE THE LAW. Thx u give me hope.
You must not be talking to MAGAts
Yea, Mike Lee is way smart, but the same way Ted Cruz is way smart , but with no friendships across lines and stay on your sides, good side.@@mojomojo5779
Just spent most of the summer in Utah and I agree that I saw some of what your saying, but Utah will likely never produce national political leaders. Can't keep the state folks happy and then expand to the national stage. It's too far a leap to travel.
@@mojomojo5779you think you’re a good person, don’t you?
Love James could listen to him talk aĺl day. Thanks Bill amazing interview
I thought James was gonna do a full Dreyfuss a couple of times there.....but he recovered!
I may be ignorant of what a “Dreyfuss” is. Is that referring to Richard Dreyfuss?
@@DennisNedryisStillAliveYes, he spent his whole interview slowly sliding down his chair.
Great talk.. Bill Maher and James Carville.
I wish they would give some examples of the bicoastal leftists they were talking about. ..they spoke negatively about them. I don’t know who they are.
I am 70 year old endangered moderate Democrat. Carville nailed it with his observation about the Bush v. Gore recount.
Lol 0. Vv0lV chef vg
At the beginning I was thinking, I hope Bill doesn’t get high so he can have a good conversation.
No you're not. There is NO SUCH thing as a moderate democrat. Stop virtue signalling. You are a flaming left wing Liberal. Liar Liar Pants On Fire.
Agreed about Mahr being high & drunk doesn't make for good conversation. I wish he was sober, so he could ask good questions.
What was that white stick he was handing?
This is the best interview/ conversation that Bill has had in the long time. I made some good insights from listening to this conversation. Much needed ❤ thank you.
That trump is honest and says what he thinks was negated by that abortion issue. The duplicity of trump cannot be denied on some issues.
Thank you for having this conversation. I needed it after work. I went to a Mexican restaurant, sat in the bar, ate a taco and enjoyed the discussion you had.
I remember Carville from Old School. We always Respect him.
JC never disappoints! 😂
I could listen to another hour or two of JC ! The Best Club Random yet...
JC is awesome. For those who love him, you might find the Bill Hader SNL impressions of him very funny 😅
Unique and wonderful ❤
One of the best club randoms, probably because Maher wasn’t stoned.
wha? he's smoking a huge doobie.
So true! I get Bill wants a relaxed chill/fun convo in this new incarnation but man he def gets a little too random & misses some great talking points . Kinda frustrating
For real? He's totally stoned and has a doobie in hand.
this episode was marginally better than the bill cranston episode - at least james carville can get out of his own way... bill cranston is lost and turned out to be a total putz ... ❤
Yeah noticed it was not as smoky...
Can’t believe I just saw this! Great show- these two together… so good!
Bill dressed up for James, James dressed down for Bill
Now that’s equality versus equity 😂🎉
I live in New Orleans. This is how he's dressed every time I see him. 😂
Years of retirement will do that for you. 🫡
And that dynamic shows in the talk, because Bill never pulls back on so many things after he said them to a guest.
James dressed up to represent the LSU Fightin’ Tigers, baby!
James as sharp as ever❤, what an interesting conversation!
Insightful discussions with terrific guests. I love listening to James Carvilles opinion. Thanks Bill
Bill, I am a fan from way back. It concerns me that the last few shows of club random you are talking over the guest. We’re all getting older and slower, let them talk! I tune in to hear what they have to say! Thank you for all you do❤
Why do you write "Bill" as if he's reading the comments
@@DTR89 because this person thinks she's special.
@@DTR89 to be fair, you would think someone will read the nice comments to him ... Probably
He shows serious signs of senility
Why shouldn't she? Who knows what he might or mightn't read...
James is spot on about Bush vs Gore. This Club Random is one of the best !!!!!!!
It was the beginning of the end.
Yes, we dodged a bullet.
James Carville ,and Bill Maher ❤ intelligent conversation!
you must be kidding as of today
High quality daycare back in the day in 60 and 70's was done by grandma and grandpa who were retired, aunts who didn't, work, teenagers who looked out for younger kids of farm families in their rural neighborhoods. That was daycare back in the day.
That happened the same in the burbs and urban areas. You're talking about society back then, there was nothing geographical about it.
well people have to work until they're dead now so the 1 parent at home / early retirement just isn't a thing for most
@@dustinweber1945you have a point. A friend of mine retired for 7 months then returned coz EVERYONE was asking her to babysit. Why not? Youre retired. How presumptuous.
That was because grandmas and grandpa could retire. Young ladies could pay their way through college by babysitting, Now you have to own a hedge fund to be able to afford college or daycare
The best argument for daycare is Henry Kieser in WWII. The only way he could get his shipyards to produce a Liberty ship a day was to hire Women ie “Rossie the Riveter” - the only way he could get these women to take these jobs was to offer Daycare.
James Carville is a brilliant political Democrat strategist. I enjoyed this conversation with Bill and highly recommend his own podcast.
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Love politics war room.
And David Axelrod...😅
ewww
@@mr.joshuah1412 Thanks for WATCHING,
James Carville
Loved every minute of your conversation guys ! Thank you both .👍🇺🇸
I love Carville. Funny, smart, and insightful.
Me too! He is one of a kind!! ❤
Great episode!!! Great conversation!
Except Bill never shut up.
Great discussion with a political expert who knows what he is talking about.
Great show Bill! James is doing his Richard Dreyfuss impersonation in the chair!
Mr Bill, this is by far my favourite of all time. Such a mind he’s got. Billy Bob Thornton has to play James Carville in the movie.
he pretty much did ....Primary Colors...
That would be perfect!
@mikephillips3339 is that the one with Sandra Bullock? If so that was an intense movie, but awesom
THAT'S RIGHT, PRIMARY COLORS IN 1998...TRAVOLTA WAS CLINTON CHARACTER...GREAT MOVIE
Ed Harris, maybe.
15 minutes in and I just noticed the print of 'The Last Supper' on the wall. Hilarious!
"Education" hasn't failed the kids, but their parents have failed them by ignoring what they've needed -- which was and needs to be: PARENTING.
In most cases it’s both
@@rayc5577 No, it's not. Kids need to get to school ready to learn; parents are the sole responsibility for that.
Ohhhh you don't see what's happening at these schools now. Parents don't stand a chance. Students who push back when they're told 2+2=5 get exiled. Open your eyes. The Ds will pay at the polls for it.
Great episode. 👍
James has a seasoned Southern voice, theirs no way it could eva be copied or abused so the culprits would come up looking stupid for even trying... wonderful conversation fellas,,,
Born and bred in New Orleans
Had the pleasure to serve him & his wife in my restaurant the other day. What a character. He’s got a great wife behind him as well.
BILL ? 😮
No she’s a Republican who has worked to kill healthcare bills, which has kept people from getting healthcare and therefore, DYING.
Lol, Carville's wife is a lot more like his handler/manager now
@@mikewhite4560
@@mikewhite4560hardly
His wife's a Republican neo-con witch.
I love this show!! People are themselves here.I personally like the longer episodes.
Finally Bill Maher was engaged in conversation without dominating it! Maher didnt derail conversation to his topics of choice.
"everything has become a purity test"...Carville nailed it
Many people have been saying that for years, all conservatives.
On both sides of the coin
Jordan Peterson says it best. (paraphrased) On the right, you can tell when they've gone too far. When you see people breaking out the jackboots and badges, things have gone too far. On the left, there is no limit to how far things can go.
No, everything has not become a purity test. People are just upset that's in some circles it's not acceptable to bully people.
@@bobearly3653 The people banning books are ones you have to watch out for,
I am Bill Maher’s demographic 10/10 these guests he has… god Bless you sir!!! James Carville is one of my heroes!!
You apparently don'toften
watch Bill very often. He's an atheist.
@@pdcdesign9632 Yeah isn't that great! Bill the atheist has religious guests on, and he treats then kindly.
Are you able to talk to atheists, or are you too scared of them?
@@keep-ukraine-free thanks for responding Karen but I happen to be an atheist also. The OP mentioned god if you read it.
What an AMAZING interview!!!! By far your best!!!! Two great minds...
James Carville is a fantastic person...... I agree with 99% of what he says....... a great American Patriot
The Bible says you'll go to hell for lying.
Eternal torment.
Love James Carville! He's been there and done it. Its cool to see these 2 together since Bill has watched him forever.
Grumpy old men
Tractor pulls are awesome
James makes politics fun ....in a strange way
As a resident of CT, I can assure you the nation needs to know Chris Murphy.
Sen. Chris Murphy is WONDERFUL! I'm from MN and if he ever ran for president, I'd feel GREAT voting for Murphy. Quality human being of real HEART & INTEGRITY
I met Bill Clinton at a rally at UPenn during the1996 campaign, I spoke to him, he was extremely charismatic.....
Most politicians are.
James Carville is the GOAT!
Billy Corgan looks different with glasses.
😅
Yeah, the life on the road, the partying ,really has aged the Smashing Pumpkin's front man , big time
😂😂😂
😂
jopo, u got me u effer,
i'd just put on mi glasses was holding tiny phone close to get a look at this fossil when i saw ur pinned comment 🥇🏆
👋👋👋👋👋
One of the BEST episodes!!! Great guest!!! Maher is at his best with smart guests!
I can remember James from infancy. Love the man!
Me too!❤
James is never seen without some type of LSU swag!
Isn't he a professor there?
J.C.'s education:
"Louisiana State University
LSU Paul M. Hebert Law Center Ascension Catholic High
Following the conclusion of
his military enlistment,
Carville finished his studies at LSU at night,
where he earned his Bachelor of Science degree in General Studies in 1970,
and his Juris Doctor degree in 1973.
Carville is a member of the Sigma Nu fraternity."
I agree our schools are failing miserably. I am 64 and I was lucky to get a good high school education. The blame must be shared with the parents. Both of my parents were educators. My father made me learn Greek and Latin roots and tested me on them. At the time I hated this. When I became an paramedic it became obvious how lucky I had parents who were partners in the education process
Hi Kenneth. That's a very cool comment and I applaud you (and your parents). Greek and Latin. I didn't realise that I had an interest in English until I had to study Shakespeare. I did not get any formal Greek or Latin and I wish I had. Paramedic is an interesting career choice and I hope it served you well. On a side note, I am also 64 years old.
@@roderickcampbell2105 thanks
In my high school, Shakespeare wasn’t even taught.
It does not have to deal with age...it is knowing history and what has happened that people have witnessed.
Loved this show, what a great guest as always. SO smart
And Bill didn't CROSS A PICKET LINE....LOL 😊
Some awfully presumptuous things being said about Springsteen by Maher , and I’m not even a fan. Maybe Springsteen simply doesn’t like Christie, or want him around.
2023 Bill is opinion before facts, personal agenda before facts.
Grumpy old men
Bill ---- PLEASE HAVE JAMES BACK TO CONTINUE THIS CHAT THRU THIS PRIMARY SEASON! We need to hear from James as much as possible.
James captured my interest for more than fifteen minutes. That's a feat as far as Club Random goes.
Carville is the BEST!!!
Watch him on EVERY podcast can find - Smart, sharp and funny.
Congrats Bill, Love this long format :)