Please put this much detail and length for each season and the movies as well please. I loved your voice over and your thoroughness you put into it! You have gained a new sub! Keep up the amazing work!!! 😁
Great stuff, idk why but I find your rambling very entertaining instead of annoying or boring. Its a nice antithesis to all the glorified plot summaries being framed as analysis.
Princess Celestia is like a district manager who has a vanity store in a small town. Needs the manager to email her once a day to confirm that the store is actually open and running, tries to schedule visits once a month but only shows up on occasion (almost always unannounced), knowledgeable enough about the business to give ideas but since she works so infrequently, all of her help is useless and only sets the store (or mane6) BACK, lots of meetings that should have been an email or letter, and who comes from so much money she doesn't actually understand what it's like for a sales associate making minimum wage (or a pony from a small town with a small business who has never had to take on this much responsibility before). MLP is a show very empathetic to retail employees and the older I get, the more I realize that Celestia is written to be pretty intentionally fake and offputting- like when a member of corporate shows up at your job and pretends they know what they're doing.
1:31:08 no silly, rarity said that it was rare to rainbow being a friend of Gilda not because griffons are rare, is because ponys are racist and never get alone with other species
5:28:37 This setup really doesn’t make sense because mouse is a primary part of a great horned owl’s diet. Are we supposed to believe that all non-monster animals are herbivorous in this world because they are too scared too eat other animals because most animals in this show seem to be hyperintelligent? Speaking of which, the mice seen in the beginning of “The Stare Master” do not look anything like this! This whole small plot device is hysterical😂
Finished the entire video (in 2 sittings), and man, that was an amazing retrospective of season 1. Seriously, great job! I can't imagine how long it took to research and edit this video. Good luck with the rest of the series, I can't wait to see how long those videos will be.
YEAA THIS IS WHAT WE'VE BEEN WAITIN' FOR, 6 HOUR VIDEOOOOOO, this one is boutta be a banger fr, next episodes will probebaly be the longest videos around this side of the mlp fandom lmao
As someone who became very knowledgeable about sewing, (BFA in theatre with mainly costume construction classes, design, etc) and has fluttershy as my favorite character, what she says in suited for success made me so upset upon rewatching. 1. “The arms eye is tight” That dress has no arms eyes!!! It’s closer to a cloak. She even lifts a front hoof for that line and there’s zero restriction in movement because there’s nothing there! 2. I would not call that collar a “midi collar” But ok close enough 3. I would not call it a shawl lapel either, she’s not wearing a tux?! 4. “The hem is clearly machine stitched” Ok that’s just MEAN 😭 Fluttershy basically said “I can tell you didn’t spend hours hoof stitching my hem, it looks like a machine did it” which makes sense to save time when you can’t stitch it by hand. If she was PAYING MONEY for this dress sure I’d say Fluttershy can ask for the hem to be redone but FOR FREE?! Bro shut up. 5. “The pleats are uneven” those don’t look like pleats at the bottom, but I’ll let it slide since animation stuff. Also that’s just straight up roasting Rarity’s hard work 💀 6. “You used a back stitch, when it clearly called for a top stitch, or maybe even a traditional blanket stitch” I’m not sure what she’s referring to since a back stitch would like a normal stitch just with no gaps if done by hand. Saying it called for a top stitch would imply Rarity likely hid and pressed fabric just over a stitch for a cleaner look. And Fluttershy is saying a top stitch should be added to avoid that pressed fabric from moving even a hair/a style choice. A blanket stitch? NO never on a dress like that, unless that’s an intentional homemade look? It’s a very visible stitch unless it’s just used for binding thick fabric pieces together by hand, instead of a machine, and then it’s hidden by being underneath/the fabric you see it the not stitched side. The seam is seen as a line. It would make no sense on a dress like this in my opinion. It’s basically a stitching border that can look cutesy and homemade. Either way, NOT the stitch you would use for a dress to the Gala. 7. I didn’t study enough French fashion to know much besides some basics but yeah I’m not sure why Fluttershy cares so much about what style the dress is based off of. I can only guess that she suggested a style and simply is saying Rairty failed to replicate the style. Anyways I know the scene was just to imply Fluttershy knows about sewing and fashion, but as someone who actually learned it and then rewatched that episode it made me angry to hear someone say things so blatantly incorrectly and act entitled about it 💀😂 3:25:18
5:33:32 honestly I never thought anything weird of her inviting them to an after party the next day. As in my culture it’s very common to come back the day after to reheat all the leftovers and have basically another party.
Hey Eff excellent video, you're one of the few brony channels i stick to actually watch. Since you're planning on continuing these retrospectives i think you should foucs on stuff that happens on the Interent at that time, like how the fandom was banned in 4chan and how it spread all 2011, etc.
5:31:24 since i’m Polish, i decided to check the wiki out of curiosity and yeah; the owl (i’m not gonna bother with the name.) is stated to be female. The trivia states that the reason for it is speculated due be problems with translation, from what i got at least.
this video ate. devoured even. edit: i had a dream this specific video got over 100k views in like 7 hours. I fell asleep while watching it though so maybe thats why it was in my dream.
I honestly agree, like as a kid for me I enjoyed it but I think if it didn't have the problematic connotations in it then I think it would of been one of the better early episodes
The best thing about this show was the animation itself. This looks like a mix of Dr. Seuss, UPA, Chuck Jones and John Sutherland cartoons rolled into one. The visuals looks like it was done in the 1950’s and 1960’s, but this looks like it came out of the 1960’s.
on look before u sleep segment rn. two things. one, while you make good points about the book's odd placement, the inclusion of twilight saying it's her "own personal copy" is to further emphasize the fact that twilight was really excited about the idea of a slumber party with her friends to make rarity and applejack's behavior in the episode look all the more inconsiderate. two, you are a menace for revealing what marshmallows are made of. this is why they say ignorance is bliss. i'll still give ur vid a like tho edit: when lauren talks ab fluttershy's awkward phase, she actually means that her being distinctly taller than the majority of fillies her age is actually considered awkward, which can often lead people (especially younger ones) to believe they're different and cause them to recluse like fluttershy.
2:28:46 I will love if in this episode (and all the episodes where they know Celestia was arrived) all the ponys from poniville wear clothes That can justify rarity doing clothes here
2:08:12 I feel like this episode fits better with somebody like Fluttershy They could make twilight like in the first episode and little by little change with the POWER OF FRIENDSHIP, and use Fluttershy as the shy friend, the one who always want a slumber party but was to shy to having one, I mean, she also live in a tree Soo the last pun was there too 😂
2:53:29 aren't we gonna talk about how Lucky Clover is literally walking backwards for some reason? no? okay let's focus on Lyra talking to a kid, probably her younger relative or just some kid who wanted to ask her about something
Hiya i found an inacurate mlp toy,about 4 of them. They all have the same template of rainbow dash,they were a keychain,they didnt have wings,horns,a cutie mark! There was a red rainbow dash,a twilight,applejack and fluttershy. They weirdly look male
This was quite a ride.. only 8 more to go!
Our CVLT: discord.gg/TKBeBdSZSx
Support me on Patreon: www.patreon.com/EffMinus
Find me: linktr.ee/EffMinus
Can't wait for the 8 more 🗣️🗣️🗣️
Keep it up bro, I love these videos
sorry babe can’t hang out, eff minus just dropped a 6 hour long mlp retrospective
I had to pause my honeymoon because Eff dropped this.
Oh, mum died? I’ll come to the funeral… Wait nvm Eff Minus posted another AWESOME video
Lol "babe"? We wish
@Froggybeanskinda funny but abit to far but oh well
this is the most brief retrospective of all time
Man, six hours gotta be the shortest retrospective you’ve ever posted!!
yeah, my bad, i'll try to make the next one an acceptable length
@@EffMinusthat acceptable length must be 10 hours, since I felt like this retrospective was too brief.
not me thinking this was all 9 seasons, a whole SIX hour video about season 1… respect
Everypony wake up, EffMinus posted
Hell yeah. This video is the size of half a day
Wouldn't "half a day" be 12 hours? A whole day is 24 hours if you include the night part of the day.
@traviseller8160 imnnot including the night
Please put this much detail and length for each season and the movies as well please. I loved your voice over and your thoroughness you put into it!
You have gained a new sub! Keep up the amazing work!!!
😁
thank you eff minus for posting this rn, ive had such a bad morning and this has genuinely made my day a little better
as a creator, that's what i love to hear xd
Oh yeah! Eff Minus! My mental state goes from depressed to slightly less depressed!
Uhhh you ok😊
Yk it's gonna be a fire 6 hours when Effminus posts :]
GOSH DANG IT 6 1/2 HOURS ON 1 SEASON BRO.
Gotta listen to it all while I clean 🤣🤣🤣🤣
0:04 Quick and brief he says 😂
Your voice is so nice, this video has become one of my faves to fall asleep to
Thanks for uploading this, I miss Gen 4, I feel nostalgic for watching this, I miss this version of MLP 😢
Since there’s extra content I’m gonna watch the whole video when I get home
Six hours.. impressive effminus
Great stuff, idk why but I find your rambling very entertaining instead of annoying or boring. Its a nice antithesis to all the glorified plot summaries being framed as analysis.
Princess Celestia is like a district manager who has a vanity store in a small town. Needs the manager to email her once a day to confirm that the store is actually open and running, tries to schedule visits once a month but only shows up on occasion (almost always unannounced), knowledgeable enough about the business to give ideas but since she works so infrequently, all of her help is useless and only sets the store (or mane6) BACK, lots of meetings that should have been an email or letter, and who comes from so much money she doesn't actually understand what it's like for a sales associate making minimum wage (or a pony from a small town with a small business who has never had to take on this much responsibility before). MLP is a show very empathetic to retail employees and the older I get, the more I realize that Celestia is written to be pretty intentionally fake and offputting- like when a member of corporate shows up at your job and pretends they know what they're doing.
6 hour long retrospective is magic!
1:31:08 no silly, rarity said that it was rare to rainbow being a friend of Gilda not because griffons are rare, is because ponys are racist and never get alone with other species
5:28:37 This setup really doesn’t make sense because mouse is a primary part of a great horned owl’s diet. Are we supposed to believe that all non-monster animals are herbivorous in this world because they are too scared too eat other animals because most animals in this show seem to be hyperintelligent? Speaking of which, the mice seen in the beginning of “The Stare Master” do not look anything like this! This whole small plot device is hysterical😂
>Brief retrospective
>6+ hours long
>bookmarked
>brief retrospective
>6 1/2 hour video
definitely gonna have to watch this in parts lmao
Finished the entire video (in 2 sittings), and man, that was an amazing retrospective of season 1. Seriously, great job! I can't imagine how long it took to research and edit this video. Good luck with the rest of the series, I can't wait to see how long those videos will be.
All of my favorite RUclipsrs been dropping long vids lately, it's amazing.
"Quick retrospective"
*6 hours pony video*
I can’t believe he managed to pack in all this in 6 hours! So brief!
Oh my master has posted 🙏
YOOO EFF MINUS JUST POSTED A SIX HOUR VIDEO ABOUT COLORFUL PONIES!!!!!!
Only 6 hours long stop half-assing these videos!!!!!
To be clear this is a joke you work really hard on your videos
Time to cancel all my plans n watch this twice
Miyuki!!
@EffMinus IVE BEEN SPOTTED
YEAH MORE EFF MINUS
5:14:32 Lauren’s explanation got jossed a few seasons later cause “Sparkle’s Seven” showed a Baby Spike living with Twilight and her family
YEAA THIS IS WHAT WE'VE BEEN WAITIN' FOR, 6 HOUR VIDEOOOOOO, this one is boutta be a banger fr, next episodes will probebaly be the longest videos around this side of the mlp fandom lmao
Holy pony. Guess I know what to do all day now. Thanks EffMinus.
This is gonna be a great day at work.
this has been GREAT to have on in the background whilst I draw Sugar Belle!
As someone who became very knowledgeable about sewing, (BFA in theatre with mainly costume construction classes, design, etc) and has fluttershy as my favorite character, what she says in suited for success made me so upset upon rewatching.
1. “The arms eye is tight” That dress has no arms eyes!!! It’s closer to a cloak. She even lifts a front hoof for that line and there’s zero restriction in movement because there’s nothing there!
2. I would not call that collar a “midi collar” But ok close enough
3. I would not call it a shawl lapel either, she’s not wearing a tux?!
4. “The hem is clearly machine stitched” Ok that’s just MEAN 😭 Fluttershy basically said “I can tell you didn’t spend hours hoof stitching my hem, it looks like a machine did it” which makes sense to save time when you can’t stitch it by hand. If she was PAYING MONEY for this dress sure I’d say Fluttershy can ask for the hem to be redone but FOR FREE?! Bro shut up.
5. “The pleats are uneven” those don’t look like pleats at the bottom, but I’ll let it slide since animation stuff. Also that’s just straight up roasting Rarity’s hard work 💀
6. “You used a back stitch, when it clearly called for a top stitch, or maybe even a traditional blanket stitch” I’m not sure what she’s referring to since a back stitch would like a normal stitch just with no gaps if done by hand. Saying it called for a top stitch would imply Rarity likely hid and pressed fabric just over a stitch for a cleaner look. And Fluttershy is saying a top stitch should be added to avoid that pressed fabric from moving even a hair/a style choice. A blanket stitch? NO never on a dress like that, unless that’s an intentional homemade look? It’s a very visible stitch unless it’s just used for binding thick fabric pieces together by hand, instead of a machine, and then it’s hidden by being underneath/the fabric you see it the not stitched side. The seam is seen as a line. It would make no sense on a dress like this in my opinion. It’s basically a stitching border that can look cutesy and homemade. Either way, NOT the stitch you would use for a dress to the Gala.
7. I didn’t study enough French fashion to know much besides some basics but yeah I’m not sure why Fluttershy cares so much about what style the dress is based off of. I can only guess that she suggested a style and simply is saying Rairty failed to replicate the style.
Anyways I know the scene was just to imply Fluttershy knows about sewing and fashion, but as someone who actually learned it and then rewatched that episode it made me angry to hear someone say things so blatantly incorrectly and act entitled about it 💀😂 3:25:18
5:33:32 honestly I never thought anything weird of her inviting them to an after party the next day. As in my culture it’s very common to come back the day after to reheat all the leftovers and have basically another party.
Love when eff uploads super long videos🎉
Hey Eff excellent video, you're one of the few brony channels i stick to actually watch. Since you're planning on continuing these retrospectives i think you should foucs on stuff that happens on the Interent at that time, like how the fandom was banned in 4chan and how it spread all 2011, etc.
5:31:24 since i’m Polish, i decided to check the wiki out of curiosity and yeah; the owl (i’m not gonna bother with the name.) is stated to be female. The trivia states that the reason for it is speculated due be problems with translation, from what i got at least.
☝️🤓 average polish person (me)
“Hello fairy friends, and welcome back to the WinxForeverPodcast. I am your host, Lola Valentine.”
i've been realllllyyyy into long form mlp content lately so your channel is a mf blessing.
If I were to drink every time when I hear "we'll return to it later" and the video never returned to it, I'd put my local liqueur store out of stock
He is prob referring to later seasons as this looks like it might be a whole series.
this video ate. devoured even.
edit: i had a dream this specific video got over 100k views in like 7 hours. I fell asleep while watching it though so maybe thats why it was in my dream.
Ok 6h, let me pick my breakfast and I will see you during the day 😊👌
I know I'm in the minority here, but I loved Over a barrel as a kid. If not for the problematic stuff, It'd be such a great episode
I honestly agree, like as a kid for me I enjoyed it but I think if it didn't have the problematic connotations in it then I think it would of been one of the better early episodes
Wow over 6 hours?! Dang
i shall NOT condone fluttershy slander 😡☝️
Just had dinner. Im eating munchies. And now there's THIS!! Yay
Thank you for this 🙏
6 hours oh my god this is a good day
The best thing about this show was the animation itself. This looks like a mix of Dr. Seuss, UPA, Chuck Jones and John Sutherland cartoons rolled into one. The visuals looks like it was done in the 1950’s and 1960’s, but this looks like it came out of the 1960’s.
I am starting to question my mental state. I still love your videos though.
drinking game idea: take a shot after every vine boom sound effect
Oh 6 hours
" Mum i am ill can't go to school "
cant wait for 2 season video
Eff Minus you are a mad man but I guess I am too bc I am watching all this
HELL YEAH 20 mins
37:58
Twilight Sparkle surprised with her nose scrunched.
Yeah, I got time to watch
Amazing video, just make it a little longer next time! ❤
sorry dude, I can’t hang out. EFF MINUS POSTED A SIX HOUR LONG VIDEO
on look before u sleep segment rn. two things.
one, while you make good points about the book's odd placement, the inclusion of twilight saying it's her "own personal copy" is to further emphasize the fact that twilight was really excited about the idea of a slumber party with her friends to make rarity and applejack's behavior in the episode look all the more inconsiderate.
two, you are a menace for revealing what marshmallows are made of. this is why they say ignorance is bliss. i'll still give ur vid a like tho
edit: when lauren talks ab fluttershy's awkward phase, she actually means that her being distinctly taller than the majority of fillies her age is actually considered awkward, which can often lead people (especially younger ones) to believe they're different and cause them to recluse like fluttershy.
2:28:46 I will love if in this episode (and all the episodes where they know Celestia was arrived) all the ponys from poniville wear clothes
That can justify rarity doing clothes here
4:26:39 50 years is wild
I need a pony ranking from you
Amending Fences confirms Twilight never went back to her old tower in Canterlot after the first episode
2:08:12 I feel like this episode fits better with somebody like Fluttershy
They could make twilight like in the first episode and little by little change with the POWER OF FRIENDSHIP, and use Fluttershy as the shy friend, the one who always want a slumber party but was to shy to having one, I mean, she also live in a tree Soo the last pun was there too 😂
WHO ELSE WATCHED SONIC 3?????
Watched it Friday!!
It was so good omg 😭😂
it was absolute fire
ABSOLUTE CINEMA
I DID
Sonic 2 was 2 times as good as Sonic 1, Sonic 3 was 3 times as good as Sonic 2
That sunset was diabolical 5:37:36
Thanks!
OMG thank you!!!
This is longer than Everywhere at the End of Time
Can you do a review on My Little Pony Equestria girls friendship games?
Hey cool video
Poor zebras can't get it right lol. If you have seen Fantasia, you know.
never in my life ive watched such a long viudeo
Very brief indeed
NOT THE SCISSOR TWILIGHT LMAO
“A Brief Retrospective Season 1”
Runtime: 6 fucking hours
I watch this instead of watching the actual show!
2:53:29 aren't we gonna talk about how Lucky Clover is literally walking backwards for some reason? no? okay let's focus on Lyra talking to a kid, probably her younger relative or just some kid who wanted to ask her about something
I reversed the footage lol
@ ah lmao somehow i didn't think it could be the case
1:42:23 carrot went to the solon earlier that day, she takes extra offence because she had just dyed it :3
37:11 It may be since both are Sea Serpents, but some of the earlier designs remind me of Jean Claude from Jumpstart.
Yes.. very brief
I believe Pinkie pie is Chaos magic adjacent.
5:04:48 Numberjacks mentioned
I think this guy doesn't like Fluttershy I'm not sure tho.
Did I already watch this? It seems really familiar 🤔
It’s a compilation of the three parts he already posted of the season 1 retrospective
thanks for your job/////)))
0:05 very quick aha not like its 6hours or SOMETHING
This is a KIDS show. The problem with Bronies is that THEY LOOK INTO IT TOO MUCH.
1:28:17 shes llyinngg about gilda just getting there !
Timestamp for myself
2:50:14
41:14 in a nutshell she is Deadpool's friend
Finishing watching this feels like a divorce
Hiya i found an inacurate mlp toy,about 4 of them. They all have the same template of rainbow dash,they were a keychain,they didnt have wings,horns,a cutie mark! There was a red rainbow dash,a twilight,applejack and fluttershy. They weirdly look male
Sounds like that’s likely a knockoff MLP
hell yeah
holy shit