What Happened to the Old Scottish Flag?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 19 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 521

  • @historywithhilbert
    @historywithhilbert  4 года назад +78

    Thanks for watching everyone, hope yous enjoyed the video! Be sure to check out my other videos on history and flags if you found it interesting and give me a thumbs up or considering subscribbling if you're new!
    Two points of order to make. At one point I describe engus Mac Fergusa as a Scots king but he is better described as a Pictish king because this is before the creation of the Kingdom of Scots. Secondly when referring to the Jacobite Risings and the Battle of Culloden, the risings started in 1745 but the battle was in 1746.

    • @pauladambarral5039
      @pauladambarral5039 4 года назад +1

      I want what happened to the old Portuguese flag

    • @Alulim-Eridu
      @Alulim-Eridu 4 года назад

      Jjiijiinjiniffniionf nf Jjiijiinjiniffniion nf nf k f nf nf nfk kk r k rk nitty the o.oooooo

    • @Alulim-Eridu
      @Alulim-Eridu 4 года назад

      o.iloilo to get out of it comes (I'mkmf down to

    • @mexicanshawarma5971
      @mexicanshawarma5971 4 года назад

      is too much to ask if you do a video about Bahrain?

    • @cennethadameveson3715
      @cennethadameveson3715 4 года назад +1

      Definitely do the Draig Goch! Roman cavalry standard, red/white earthquake dragons and of course Harri (VII) Tudor.
      Saltire of Scotland is a gift to Scottish school kids; white cross, blue background. So much easier than drawing and colouring in a dragon like we do here in Wales🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿😆
      The cross of St David flag has become more common in Wales. I would love to see in incorporated into the union flag just to kill the racist "ain't no black on the union jack" slogan.
      Great video, as usual.

  • @grant6849
    @grant6849 3 года назад +42

    I am a Scotsman and I was always taught that the Lion Rampant was the Scottish Royal Banner (pre Union of Crowns 1607) and the Saltire (St Andrew’s Cross) was the flag of the people

    • @NontonSejarah-drg.naufal
      @NontonSejarah-drg.naufal Год назад +1

      King Idi Amin?

    • @rosbif4960
      @rosbif4960 5 месяцев назад +2

      This video confuses the designs on flags with heraldic devices. The most important difference between the two is that an undifferenced heraldic device can only be used by the person to which it refers, whereas non-heraldic designs can be used by any number of people.

  • @ecurewitz
    @ecurewitz 4 года назад +195

    Last time I was this early, it was still called Pictland

    • @historywithhilbert
      @historywithhilbert  4 года назад +44

      F in the chat for the Pictish language.

    • @jacintovski
      @jacintovski 4 года назад +5

      @@historywithhilbert F

    • @RickBrode
      @RickBrode 4 года назад +2

      F

    • @ecurewitz
      @ecurewitz 4 года назад +2

      History With Hilbert true, true, I have no idea how to say Pictland in Pictish. But I would assume that the Anglo-Saxons would have called it something very similar to that. So, someone would have called it that

    • @RestlessRebel
      @RestlessRebel 4 года назад +5

      Aye I remember those days

  • @RickBrode
    @RickBrode 4 года назад +143

    I enjoyed it. The connection with France was a thing I was expecting lol.

  • @TripWagstaff5213
    @TripWagstaff5213 4 года назад +86

    The Nova Scotian flag is a combination of each 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

    • @mowvu
      @mowvu 4 года назад +1

      i fucking love flags, i live next door to scotland and i never realised that in all my days. very interesting!

    • @bl9194
      @bl9194 3 года назад +3

      Based.

    • @PolarAppleCaps
      @PolarAppleCaps 3 года назад

      Hello fellow bluenoser

    • @YusuphYT
      @YusuphYT 3 года назад +2

      @@mowvu how could you not realise that 😭 it’s called Nova Scotia, New Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

    • @mowvu
      @mowvu 3 года назад +1

      @@YusuphYT hold on i was on about the flag not the name haha. the flag i never noticed was so scottish.

  • @criffermaclennan
    @criffermaclennan 4 года назад +69

    Culloden was actually fought in 1746

    • @graemehighlander9237
      @graemehighlander9237 3 года назад +1

      16th April and on a field it was never meant but forced ….many many myths surround that battle and some are indeed either 19th cent inventions and or propaganda …
      Oh and Culloden is in the north Cùil Lodair or for the battle Blàr Chùil Lodair

  • @campbella2796
    @campbella2796 4 года назад +36

    You missed out the legend of the white saltire appearing in sky after King Angus prayed before his battle with the Northumbrians.

    • @johnbinnie5697
      @johnbinnie5697 4 года назад

      www.historic-uk.com/HistoryUK/HistoryofScotland/The-two-flags-of-Scotland/
      I like the flying dragon at the battle of the standard in this video but I can't find any reference to it or depiction of it. Can you find anything to back this up?

    • @alicemilne1444
      @alicemilne1444 3 года назад +2

      @MTF Commander Scotland was Christian long before that. The oldest known site of a Christian church is in Whithorn in Scotland. It was founded by St Ninian in the late 4th century. The Picts were already building churches in the 6th century and the Gaels of Dal Riada were pretty active in the West. It was them who Christianised the Northumbrian Angles.

    • @alicemilne1444
      @alicemilne1444 3 года назад

      @MTF Commander Well, that may be what you heard but it's quite illogical.

  • @Usammityduzntafraidofanythin
    @Usammityduzntafraidofanythin 4 года назад +139

    England: Dude, you can't use the lion banner, I'm using the lion banner.
    Scotland: There's no law against me using it too.
    England: Okay, then I get to have three lions. I win!
    Scotland: Sorry, what were we talking about again?
    England: Six lions! I've got six lions, plus that french symbol. And it's a quadrant!
    Scotland: Aight...

    • @gwaptiva
      @gwaptiva 4 года назад +5

      Except that the English has three leopards on their banner :P

    • @Mongo42089
      @Mongo42089 4 года назад

      69th like.... niiiiice.

    • @HarcusCGTV
      @HarcusCGTV 4 года назад +7

      They are leopards... funny how English people dont even know their own flags, eh?... lol

    • @eldricgrubbidge6465
      @eldricgrubbidge6465 4 года назад +11

      @@gwaptiva leopards are lions in heraldry though. It's a leo pard. A lion with a beard. Not sure when the word got transferred to what we think of as leopards now.

    • @gwaptiva
      @gwaptiva 4 года назад

      @@eldricgrubbidge6465 Touche, sir

  • @neilbuckley1613
    @neilbuckley1613 4 года назад +50

    I thought Eleanor of Provence was married to King Henry III of England. King Alexander III OF Scotland married their daughter , Margaret.

  • @lewisfraser5381
    @lewisfraser5381 3 года назад +12

    The Rampant Lion comes from King William “The Lion” , William I of Scotland. Who was crowned King of Scots in 1165, 24 years before Richard “The Lionheart” was crowned King of England.

  • @janetmackinnon3411
    @janetmackinnon3411 4 года назад +14

    William, King of Scots (1165--1214) was known as "William the Lion".

    • @Libbyyyyyyyyyy
      @Libbyyyyyyyyyy 3 года назад +2

      This is the most obvious connection in my opinion

  • @AverytheCubanAmerican
    @AverytheCubanAmerican 4 года назад +153

    Malcolm III? You could say he's the true Malcolm in the Middle...Ages

    • @malcolm5514
      @malcolm5514 4 года назад +2

      I've always been a fan of any "King Malcolm"s. I just find it has a certain ring to it, you know? :D

    • @alowais32
      @alowais32 4 года назад

      Aaaaaaaaaaaaaasa

    • @UKchronics
      @UKchronics 4 года назад +1

      You watch a lot of History and Geography videos my friend i see you all over the place

  • @willhovell9019
    @willhovell9019 5 месяцев назад +2

    We used to have paper coloured flags for sandcastles in the 1950s and 1960s with the Scottish lion rampant and the English 3 yellow lions on a red background. The Irish flag of yellow harp on a blue background, the Welsh red dragon on a green and white background, the Union flag or Union Jack, and bizarrely the Star state flag of Arizona in the USA. The flag of Wales is also the yellow cross on a black background, Cornwall white cross on a black background, Devon white cross with black outline on a green background, Northumberland yellow on a red trellis. The flags of Shetland and Orkney are very Scandinavian as expected. Well done Hilbert

  • @kylemackenzie3381
    @kylemackenzie3381 4 года назад +6

    William the Lion ruled Scotland from 1165 to 1214, his standard was the red lion on the yellow background, and he reigned before Richard 1 took the throne of England, surely the Lion rampant comes from him

  • @swiftflight7927
    @swiftflight7927 4 года назад +49

    Long Dutch Legs, as if it were a documented and legislated issue.

    • @historywithhilbert
      @historywithhilbert  4 года назад +20

      Watch me get a lawsuit for not enough leg room on public transport.

    • @kevinconrad6156
      @kevinconrad6156 4 года назад +3

      @Basil II The Netherlands is the tallest average country, so ya I don't doubt he has long legs.

    • @dougieranger
      @dougieranger 4 года назад +4

      Tallest nation on Earth the Netherlands.

    • @francescoazzoni3445
      @francescoazzoni3445 4 года назад +5

      @Basil II they have to evolve strong legs, usually 3/4 m to stay over the water before the invention of the dam.

    • @GrahameGould
      @GrahameGould 4 года назад +1

      @Basil II That's a tribe (or whatever), not a nation.

  • @robertmcqueen289
    @robertmcqueen289 4 года назад +6

    Interesting video. The 'Rampant Lion' is still in use today. You will find it on the 'Scottish Sovereign Standard'. To clear up any confusion.
    The UK has 2 Sovereign Standards. One, is flown when the monarch travels in England, Wales & Northern Ireland. The second, is only flown in Scotland. The main difference are the lions. These standards date back to 1606. When the only monarch to have 2 coronations King James the Sixth of Scotland, became, King James the first of England. Part of the deal was that he kept his own standard in Scotland. As he knew that the Scottish people would never accept the English one. He was after all a 'wily scot'. This king James had the conference to create 'The King James Holy Bible', and introduced 'The book of common prayer'. Although the latter was a tad more difficult to introduce to Scottish worshippers. Especially in the tradition Kirks at the time. He was also the king that Guy Fawkes tried to kill.
    One hopes that, that has cleared up any queries.

  • @PlayerOblivion
    @PlayerOblivion 4 года назад +17

    0:10 this picture is beautiful

  • @dannyhussain5489
    @dannyhussain5489 4 года назад +28

    I see you've noticed the Bardcore trend taking off. Finally a fad worth pursuing.

    • @adroitdroid5989
      @adroitdroid5989 4 года назад +7

      "Run, ye run bullyrooks, faster than mine arrow"

  • @rustyshackelford3590
    @rustyshackelford3590 4 года назад +20

    Love that medieval fortunate son

  • @Champions67HH
    @Champions67HH 3 года назад +3

    I love this channel so much and have learnt alot from this especially medieval and biking history and you do a great job!

  • @wethreebros5895
    @wethreebros5895 4 года назад +7

    No better timing I just so happened to be wondering why all day

  • @cmac6861
    @cmac6861 4 года назад +135

    Could people please stop calling the Saltire "Scotland's new flag". It is the oldest flag still currently in use in the whole world having first popped up in 832AD.

    • @DJMCIL
      @DJMCIL 4 года назад +14

      lion rampant is way better than the saltire

    • @tomlucas4890
      @tomlucas4890 3 года назад

      Interesting, it is also the flag of Russia.

    • @connorc4044
      @connorc4044 3 года назад +20

      Hasn’t Denmark’s been around since 700s when it fell out the sky or something like that? btw not biased as I am a scot.

    • @OldChannelRezto
      @OldChannelRezto 2 года назад +19

      Denmark’s flag is the oldest continually used flag in the world. Not Scotland.

    • @garthreid7114
      @garthreid7114 2 года назад +3

      I don't believe in religion, therefore reject ANYTHING that's associated with saints, that's what YOU cow tow to, not me, and not pagan Scots. The Lion Rampant stands proud above any other flag thank you.

  • @karenhanania9014
    @karenhanania9014 4 года назад +3

    Very interesting! I agree with your theory as to why the fleur-de-lis were added to the Rampant Lion flag. Flags in general are interesting to me.

  • @scottmcgilvray2848
    @scottmcgilvray2848 4 года назад +1

    Thank You so much for the video. I, of course subscribed to this channel. I’m about 90% Scottish and very proud of it. My research was limited to the books that were available to me in my youth. I’ve learned so much more here on RUclips.
    Thanks again

  • @andrewrobinson2565
    @andrewrobinson2565 4 года назад +4

    Always educational. Bloody marvellous. I'm waiting for my tartan passport... (any tartan on the cover for 20 Scottish Pounds extra.).

  • @joekelly7108
    @joekelly7108 4 года назад +2

    I really appreciate how professional your videos are man! Props to you! I just wanted to say that I'd love to see a little more on ireland, and the celtic side of things. But I'll watch literally anything you put out.

    • @bettyrobb8219
      @bettyrobb8219 2 года назад

      Me too!! 🙋‍♀️🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇨🇦

  • @donfelipe7510
    @donfelipe7510 4 года назад +2

    Hilbert as a fellow proud Northumbrian could you possible make some content on flags and banners that we know of used by the old kingdom of Northumbria and maybe the other Anglo-Saxon-Danish Kingdoms? Or perhaps the banners carried by Northumbrian families such as the Percys, Fenwicks or Hazleriggs into battle?

  • @comradeedwin1006
    @comradeedwin1006 4 года назад +3

    Love your videos keep the great work up!

  • @shanemize3775
    @shanemize3775 3 года назад +1

    Very cool video! I really enjoyed it.

  • @richiec9077
    @richiec9077 4 года назад +1

    I liked the bit about the dragon banner , I'd love to hear or see more on that

  • @damianow.6114
    @damianow.6114 4 года назад +5

    Echt een leuke video ! Schotland heeft me altijd al geïnteresseerd!!!

  • @reddyshreddy5050
    @reddyshreddy5050 4 года назад +22

    [Great discussion in the comments]

  • @TheHacknor
    @TheHacknor 4 года назад +22

    Not gonna lie even as an Englishman the saltire over the cross version of the Union flag looks better

    • @Raums
      @Raums 4 года назад

      I thought it looked fantastic, Shame it was dropped.

    • @callumw1597
      @callumw1597 4 года назад +13

      And as an Englishman, I disagree. The Cross of St.George looks better upfront.

    • @ianleishman6774
      @ianleishman6774 4 года назад +6

      @@callumw1597 As a Scotsman, I concur. Now, I must go and give myself 40 lashes.

    • @DavBlc7
      @DavBlc7 4 года назад +4

      I'd guess the Saltire will be dropped from the union flag if Scotland gain Independence again within a few years time.

    • @campbella2796
      @campbella2796 4 года назад +7

      @@DavBlc7 I've a suspicion they would keep it in there just to piss off Scots.

  • @liamimbriolo6066
    @liamimbriolo6066 4 года назад +3

    In the end the Scots not only conquered Britain but the Scottish Peoples would be overrepresented in the imperial endeavours of the British Empire all over the world. Kind of blows that whole "Scottish oppression at the hands of the Anglos" out of the water and is rather an indicator of lack of historical knowledge.

    • @michael3088
      @michael3088 4 года назад +2

      yeah sadly there's alot of that mindset in some people (usually Americans who haven't done their research on their proud Scottish heritage) England often cops alot of the historical blame especially in pop culure and is a bit demonized sadly when the reality was since the act of union the king of Scotland also ascended to the throne of England so it was never take over by conquest and Scotland had been pulling many political strings

  • @patrickmacdougall4861
    @patrickmacdougall4861 4 года назад +12

    Kind a looks like a combination of those flags made the Nova Scotia flag

    • @richardhaines6525
      @richardhaines6525 4 года назад +3

      Yes, it would have been a good footnote at the end of the video to show the history of Nova Scotia’s flag

    • @onion_wind
      @onion_wind 4 года назад

      I'm waiting for him to mention that, I guess he won't then lol

    • @FD-vj6hd
      @FD-vj6hd 4 года назад +3

      That is the case, the lion rampant flag is just a banner version of the arms of scotland, and the arms of scotland were adopted as the arms of nova scotia, so that why that’s there, and the saltire section of ns flag is just the saltire of scotland with reverses colours to make it distinct

    • @richardhaines6525
      @richardhaines6525 4 года назад +2

      F D Thank you for this info, many people in NS are proud of their provincial flag, and I always wondered what the lion rampant one was that I sometimes saw as well, and figured that they must be of an historical “royal “ flag

    • @robtoe10
      @robtoe10 4 года назад +3

      @on-board the crazy train aye, spot on. Nova Scotia is Latin for New Scotland

  • @marijntaal1531
    @marijntaal1531 4 года назад +1

    Cool video, but as others have already mentioned in the comment section the lion in the royal banner of Scotland likely originated from the personal banner of king William 'the Lion' of Scotland (r. 1165 - 1214), which displayed a red lion rampant with a forked tail on a yellow background. His nickname 'the Lion' was given to him after his death, though.
    Interestingly, the design of a red lion rampant with a forked tail and a blue tongue and blue claws on a yellow field was also the banner of the counts of Holland, an area that nowadays roughly makes up the provinces of North and South Holland in the Netherlands (This is the area in the Netherlands where the city of Amsterdam lies). The reason for the similarities between the Scottish and the Hollandish lionbanners is the fact that in 1162 count Floris III of Holland married Ada of Huntingdon, sister of king William 'the Lion' of Scotland. From him, Floris adopted the lion rampant and the name William. Floris and Ada named their son William in honor of the Scottish king. He would later become count William I of Holland and the name stuck as there would be six counts William in total. The reason the current king of the Netherlands, William-Alexander, is called William may have more to do with the name of his ancestor William the Silent, prince of Orange.
    After the county of Holland passed to the house of Avesnes and later to the house of Wittelsbach, the Hollandish/Scottish lion slowly disapeared to the background of the count's banner before the county was incorporated in the mass of lands of the Burgundian dukes and later fell into the hands of the Habsburgs. However, the design is still used today as the official flag of the Dutch province of South Holland in the Netherlands.

  • @marcuskennedy709
    @marcuskennedy709 4 года назад +3

    Really enjoyed the video, could you do one for Ireland? I understand there isn't so much of a simple chronology, but there were many different flags used to represent Ireland nonetheless. I'd be really interested to hear the history behind some of them, thanks.

  • @mishapurser4439
    @mishapurser4439 2 года назад +1

    The yellow saltire on a blue field is understood to be the flag of Mercia and the Midlands. It's interesting that the Scots once used the same flag.

  • @calvinemerson
    @calvinemerson 4 года назад

    to stretch the long dutch legs! same! my half frisian legs needed regular stretching driving a circuit around ireland. 2 meters doesn’t fit all too well in a little buggy. brilliant video as always!

  • @gaelicpatriot3604
    @gaelicpatriot3604 4 года назад +8

    Do the banners of different Irish high kings as well

    • @TravisC02
      @TravisC02 4 года назад +4

      That sounds like a great video idea, I’d love to see that.

  • @Newidhan
    @Newidhan 4 года назад +4

    You can make a new show just about flags, maybe call it something catchy like... hmm... Fun with Flags!

  • @SupremeLeaderKimJong-un
    @SupremeLeaderKimJong-un 4 года назад +9

    Scotland will be free again. Led by a unicorn

  • @rabsputin
    @rabsputin 4 года назад +4

    It's the Lion Rampant, not the Rampant Lion. It's the royal standard for the Scottish monarchy. The saltire has been Scotland's flag since as early as the tenth century.

  • @jenna2431
    @jenna2431 2 года назад

    In the Delaware Valley of PA where the Scots-Irish first amassed in America, there's a town just over the Susquehanna called Red Lion. Apparently someone hearkened back a bit. And the next town over is Brogue.

  • @jillfarley520
    @jillfarley520 4 года назад +1

    I really love watching your interesting videos!

  • @jeffgraham9208
    @jeffgraham9208 4 года назад +5

    Well done!

  • @4TheWinQuinn
    @4TheWinQuinn 4 года назад +7

    Hey Hilbert please may you turn the music down just slightly. Would sound abit better :)

  • @arnljot9030
    @arnljot9030 4 года назад +3

    Imagine if they used the unicorn.

  • @TheRealPuppycat
    @TheRealPuppycat 4 года назад +3

    I really enjoyed this video and it got me think would it be possible to do a video about burgundy ? They were French People who ruled over the Netherlands and used a Red St. Andrew's cross

    • @johnbinnie5697
      @johnbinnie5697 4 года назад +1

      The saltire is supposedly adopted to honour Burgundy's Scottish troops. One of Burgundy's clerks documented it but years later so it's questioned. Good link!

    • @TheRealPuppycat
      @TheRealPuppycat 4 года назад +1

      @@johnbinnie5697 Thanks I really been intrigued with History of the Neatherlands you could say I'm a bit a weeb for them

  • @stefanocapparelli4997
    @stefanocapparelli4997 4 года назад

    GOSH!!! I've been waiting for this video since forever!!!

  • @gitafff
    @gitafff 2 года назад +1

    scotland didnt use tartan until somewhere around 1500s or 1400s

  • @gavinlaird85
    @gavinlaird85 4 года назад +1

    Great video m8 really enjoyed it.

  • @johndickson76
    @johndickson76 3 года назад +1

    I have memories as a young child, around 1980, of the lion rampant being more common, especially during the annual Scotland vs England football match. Perhaps something to do with nationalism being less popular in those days?

  • @ianleishman6774
    @ianleishman6774 4 года назад

    Pass nearby the battle site at Otterburn on the way down to visit the in law's in Darlington. It's not Consett you live by any chance? It's the first decent size town we pass thereafter.

  • @celtichistorydecoded
    @celtichistorydecoded 2 года назад

    Love this - great video. Thank you

  • @NapoleonCalland
    @NapoleonCalland 2 года назад

    The English conquest of Scotland was indeed a long and complicated affair, as you said. Mostly because it failed, leading to a Scottish King, James VI, uniting three crowns on one head.

  • @Nastyswimmer
    @Nastyswimmer 3 года назад +2

    Nothing happened to it. It isn't the "Old" Scottish Flag, it the Scottish Royal Standard - the monarch's personal flag, still in use today.

  • @diranbodossian6061
    @diranbodossian6061 4 года назад +1

    Well this actually answered a question I had in my mind! But even if it didn't it was worth it just for Medieval Fortunate Son!

    • @amandaweaver9150
      @amandaweaver9150 3 года назад

      did you know that there is a scottish flag that has a UNICORN!!! on it!!!!!!!

  • @briangarrow448
    @briangarrow448 4 года назад +10

    He mentions his long Dutch legs when talking about driving to Scotland and stopping in Otterburn.
    A very subtle hint that the Dutch are, on average, the tallest people in the world.

    • @HappyBeezerStudios
      @HappyBeezerStudios 3 года назад +2

      Thats one way to keep your head over water

    • @lolmacdonald9401
      @lolmacdonald9401 2 года назад

      Lol I lived in Holland and one time someone went 'oh you are so small" it has stuck with me, it effected me! Ha ! I'm 5'8 !! X

  • @lukebentze6949
    @lukebentze6949 4 года назад +1

    Can you please do a video on the Basque Flag?

  • @aymarafan7669
    @aymarafan7669 4 года назад +1

    The long legs of the Fries and Dutch together, just imagine that length and the pride of Northumbria!

  • @keithwright8626
    @keithwright8626 4 года назад

    The Lion Rampant without the double tressure was the standard of King William I the Lion. He was the longest reigning king of Scotland alone (1165 - 1249). This is the most probable origin of the Lion Rampant used by Scottish Kings. William used it as the Lion Rampant had been used as a badge by many kings of his royal house (and as you said is associated with Malcom III Canmore, he even used it as a badge for Irish nobles allied with him).

  • @fallofmanbrand
    @fallofmanbrand 4 года назад +2

    amazing video

  • @andrewcomerford9411
    @andrewcomerford9411 4 года назад

    The Lion Rampant was instituted by William the Lion (Alexander I's nephew) replacing the boar standard which had until then been the Royal insignia. The Saltire was introduced as a national flag in the 9th Century, making it one of the oldest flags in the world.

  • @matthewc4223
    @matthewc4223 4 года назад

    In outlaw king, the lion rampant the lions itself is removed from flags and cloaks when Edward I longshanks is at Stirling . when Robert's rebellion kicks in you see the lion a lot. Thought that was a cool detail in the film

  • @TheLostCorner
    @TheLostCorner 4 года назад +2

    Out of interest, what makes the letter suggesting to James VI/I that he put the saltire in front of the St George cross "hilarious"? Is there something else in the letter, or are you simply meaning that they thought he should put Scotland "first"? (I'd view the latter as interesting, and also quite possibly futile, but I'm not sure I'd describe it as 'hilarious' particularly in the context of the time.)

  • @MilkyKilky
    @MilkyKilky 4 года назад

    Nice touch with the medieval Fortunate Son cover.

  • @jamellfoster6029
    @jamellfoster6029 4 года назад

    Alexander III was married to the daughter of Eleanor of Provence's (& Henry III of England's) daughter Margaret, sister of Edward I (Longshanks), grandniece of Richard the Lionheart...

  • @ZoahLord
    @ZoahLord 4 года назад +1

    The 'Scottish Dragon' may be a remnant of the old conquered 'Welsh' kingdoms of the Old North, such as Strathclyde

    • @BillyBobDingo1971
      @BillyBobDingo1971 4 года назад

      Possibly. The River Clyde was named by ancient Welsh.

  • @jonathanthomsen6440
    @jonathanthomsen6440 4 года назад +7

    My family on my father’s side of the family come from Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿, The under Scottish name Thomsen, and some of them was know as The Lord of Kylnekylle, Ayrshire c. 1370-80, and all some of mother family’s under The Family name Duran is also from Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿, and PS because my full name is Jonathan Duran Høg Thomsen, I am a part of the Scottish family Thomsen and I am also a part of the Scottish and Irish Thompson/ Tomsem and and under many more, / and more too as well and I’m also a part of The Danish family Thomsen too as well and I am also a part of Scottish Family Duran and The Spanish Family Duran and of French Family Duran and Italian Family Duran and of The English Duran Family too as well, 🙂😎✌️

  • @docfurious2408
    @docfurious2408 3 года назад

    The lion Rampant is the Monarchs personal flag, the St. Andrews' flag is the banner or flag of the people of Scotland.

  • @marcocapelle
    @marcocapelle 4 года назад +1

    Never realized that the British flag is a merger of the English and Scottish flag, nice to hear. Also, I like the alternative flag with the Scottish flag over the English flag :-)

    • @WyteXLighting
      @WyteXLighting Год назад

      Also its the flag of the south dixie without the 12 stars and red white and blue Confederate States of America way better than ole glory and it seem every body loves the st andrew cross including me which also means rebel thats the flag of dixie horrah [>

  • @asnowman8094
    @asnowman8094 4 года назад +1

    At Hampden the Lion Rampants were the protestants when the stadiums flags switched to all/mostly Saltires was when the protestants stopped going and the 'tartan army' took over.

  • @sheiruto1058
    @sheiruto1058 4 года назад

    hilbert flags are interesting but please also make videos about conflicts and conquests i really love those topics.
    and yeah video like were viking really mean that is one of my favourites.

  • @jacquelinevanderkooij4301
    @jacquelinevanderkooij4301 11 месяцев назад

    About the gold/red lion shield(wapen).
    (I know you talk about the flag)
    The 'graven van Holland' used the same picture of the red lion on gold.
    Graaf Dirk VII started to use this (also on his coins) and he lived from 11..-1203.
    Why is this important?
    Dirk VII was the son of Ada of Scotland, daughter of Henry Earl of Huntingdon, granddaughter of King David I of Scotland.
    So .... if the shield was already in use by earlier family in Holland (before 1203 by Dirk VII), the scottish flag must have been much older than 1222.
    I read in the past Floris III (1140-1190), husband of Ada of Scotland, started to use red 'lion on gold', but I can't find it back 😅 . They married 1162.

  • @12345678900987659101
    @12345678900987659101 4 года назад +1

    Heraldic flags always look nice. Maryland has a nice one as far as State Flags go.

  • @jackstraughan24
    @jackstraughan24 Год назад

    I thought I recognised your accent. Fellow Northumbrian here

  • @snorkythepig5954
    @snorkythepig5954 4 года назад +1

    Thanks for a great film, Hilbert. King Angus is said to have seen a saltire of cloud against a blue sky before the battle in 832 against Athelstan’s army. The battle was at Athelstaneford in East Lothian and there is a memorial there, explaining the legend. Is it unusual to have named a place after the defeated king? Check out scottishflagtrust.com for more about the memorial and the history of the saltire.

  • @greggilmour7671
    @greggilmour7671 7 месяцев назад

    The Saltire is St Andrew’s Cross on a Sky Blue background. It is the national flag of Scotland, still.
    The Lion Rampant is the personal flag of the King of Scotland and as such belongs to the King of the United Kingdom since 1603 when James VI of Scotland became James I &VI of England and Scotland, so the Lion Rampant Standard exists as an entity and has done since first adopted. It is adapted into the personal standard of the UK, along with the 3 reposed lions standard of the King of England and the harp standard of the King of Ireland.
    It is seldom displayed as a stand alone standard but my guess is that it would rightly be displayed when and if the Monarch is acting in matters pertaining only to Scotland?

  • @andrewobrien8325
    @andrewobrien8325 4 года назад +2

    Huh. I always assumed the Lion Rampant was inspired by King William the Lion and to be honest I prefer the lion rampant over the saltire...it just strikes me as a less religious themed flag but honestly both are good to me

    • @elwolf8536
      @elwolf8536 4 года назад

      The lion is best .
      Regards from England

    • @asmithy317
      @asmithy317 4 года назад +2

      Not inspired by, it was William I (AKA William the Lion) who first used it as his standard, he reigned as King of Scotland 1142-1214. Unlike what it says in the video there is absolutely no connection between the Scottish flag and the Frenchman Richard the Lion Heart.

  • @emilyo.3431
    @emilyo.3431 4 года назад

    Could you do a video on the flags of Hungary? So much interesting history yet it's not often talked about!

  • @cammysmith7562
    @cammysmith7562 4 года назад +2

    I have always preferred the old rampant lion to the saltire

  • @irreview
    @irreview 4 года назад

    In Crusader Kings PC game, when you play as Scotland you start out as the old flag and I always wonder why they didn't have the cross of St George.

  • @patrickcasey8447
    @patrickcasey8447 4 года назад +2

    Might be wrong, but i thought William 'the lion' was called 'the lion' because he introduced the rampant lion flag

  • @Linz0440
    @Linz0440 3 года назад

    At the time of Richard the Lionhart in England, and before and after, there was a king William the Lion (1142 - 4 December 1214),

  • @ukwatotskuhide270
    @ukwatotskuhide270 4 года назад +4

    Loved it.

  • @kyledrevlo1962
    @kyledrevlo1962 3 года назад

    Very cool how the union jack was a blend of the two. I had no idea! (sorrry, American here)

  • @rajaa3294
    @rajaa3294 2 года назад

    I loved this report and explanation ,,

  • @elwolf8536
    @elwolf8536 4 года назад +1

    8:34 as a Yorkshire man I like the flag on the right 👌

  • @jean-pierredeclemy7032
    @jean-pierredeclemy7032 4 года назад

    On a sailing visit to Scotland we visited the chandlery in the first port on the east coast and could only purchase a lion rampant courtesy flag.

    • @craigevans6156
      @craigevans6156 3 года назад +1

      There is an issue with the Saltire used as a courtesy flag as it is almost identical to code flag M. “I have a doctor on board”

  • @johnshoemakerjr5840
    @johnshoemakerjr5840 3 года назад

    The rampant lion flag was used by clan MacDowell, The Lords of Galloway, since Prince Fergus. It probably was used by their Norse cousins clan MacDougal of Argyll, the Lords of Lorn. Both clans ruled other parts of Dal Riada at various times. Thanks, J.R.S.,Jr.,Esq.

  • @alanjackson5438
    @alanjackson5438 4 года назад +1

    Regional flags, Northumbria or Gwynedd for example would be good.

  • @robertfindley9000
    @robertfindley9000 4 года назад

    The original Royal Standard was a blue boar on a white background the standard of Kenneth MacAlpin and his descendants until 1222 when William the Lion changed it

  • @saitama4128
    @saitama4128 4 года назад

    Love these vids

  • @bigal7561
    @bigal7561 3 года назад

    Excellent video

  • @thomasboyd7943
    @thomasboyd7943 4 года назад +2

    Thank you. God bless Holland and England.

  • @hairybattler
    @hairybattler 3 года назад

    King William, known as William the Lion reigned 1165 - 1214, may be where the rampant lion came from. Just an idea.

  • @PNETriffid
    @PNETriffid 5 месяцев назад

    I'm surprised you haven't mentioned that Alexander II's father was known as William (I of Scotland) the Lion.

  • @johndtha
    @johndtha 4 года назад +2

    Hey, usually a big fan of your videos but there are a few mistakes in here.
    I don't think that Alexander III was married to Eleanor of Provence. Wasn't she married to and English king?
    Also, the seal that you show with the Lion Rampant is that of Alexander II, not Alexander I. The chronology gets a bit confusing confusing because of this as you mention Malcolm III (1058-1093) then Alexander (1214-1249) then the battle of the Standard in 1138.

    • @naveenk6603
      @naveenk6603 4 года назад +1

      That's Eleanor of Aquitaine

    • @johndtha
      @johndtha 4 года назад +1

      @@naveenk6603 Looked it up - different person but still nothing to do with Alexander III
      "Eleanor of Provence (c. 1223 - 24/25 June 1291[1]) was a French noblewoman who became Queen consort of England as the wife of King Henry III from 1236 until his death in 1272. She served as regent of England during the absence of her spouse in 1253.[2]"

  • @Ace-fd7fz
    @Ace-fd7fz 3 года назад

    Idk why but the irn bru at 0:20 made me burst our laughing xD