Response to Shaykh Uthman Ibn Farooq on ‘Waḥdatul Wujūd’
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
- Brought to you by the Hanafi fiqh channel and presented by Shaykh Muhammad Yasir Al-Hanafi.
Shaykh Yasir Al-Hanafi's facebook page: / shaykhmohammadyasir
Shaykh Yasir Al-Hanafi's instagram page: / mohammad_yasir_alhanafi
NOTE: If you are having issues with the audio, please refresh the page or restart the RUclips app. It could have been that the video was initially still processing. A couple of viewers have confirmed the audio is now working after testing on multiple devices.
May Allah reward you for defending Haq.
17:56 Assalamu alaikum Sheikh Yasir, Sheikh Uthman bin Farooq is not fond of Bishr al Hafi (ra). I saw once in a video on his channel regarding tasawwuf he criticised Bishr al Hafi (ra). It would be good to see a future discussion regarding tasawwuf and aqeedah and the rijal of tasawwuf and aqeedah between you and Sheikh Uthman. He has all of the tell-tale signs of Salafism but insha Allah it seems he might be open to discussion I hope.
- Shehroze, student of knowledge from Al Burhan Islamabad, under Sh Adnan Kakahel sahb.
Why are you so nice to them? Be kind, well-mannered but firm. All they do is takfir of Muslims and all you do is praise them! You're too nice!!!!
@@abdullahk8691well you have a choice, either throw water on the fire or gasoline lol
@@Anonymous-411 so telling the truth is gasoline is it?
I’ve watched an odd off few videos of this Ustadh and I have to say.. his mannerism and respect towards others is the best amongst the refutation culture on social media.. sincerity on a different level. Allah azawajal bless you Ustadh and hope we we find a common boundary amongst the Muslims.
I've found that Following 1 of 4 fiqh is common boundary
Its obvious someone told him to tone it down because his mannerisms year ago were unbearable
Bro this is his English version
Come to subcontinent and see for yourself how vile these hanafis are
Eating was more important to Mawiyah bin sufiyan Rather than obey Allah Messenger pbuh
Sahih Muslim 6628
Ibn Abbas reported: I was playing with children that Allah's Messenger ( صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم ) happened to pass by (us). I hid myself behind the door. He (the Prophet) came and patted my shoulders and said: Go and call Mu'awiya. I returned and said: He is busy in taking food. He again asked me to go and call Mu'awiya to him. I went (and came back) and said that he was busy in taking food, whereupon he said: May Allah not fill his belly! Ibn Muthanna, said: I asked Umm Umayya what he meant by the word Hatani. He said: It means he patted my shoulders.
Exactly what i was thinking
Allah bless shaykh Yasir. Please continue this path
Maashaa Allah . BaarakAllahu feekum Sheikh. You have really given us a fair, respectful and clear answer on this matter. I love Sheikh Uthman but I feel that honestly their is a disdain and rubbishing of any scholar from Deoband and only Saudi scholars are knowledgeable on Deen.
Also I found that Brothe Daniel was ambushed as if to find out if he's Muslim but Alhamdulillah he stood his ground.
I find it problematic that all Deobandis and Barelvis are lumped together when it is as clear as daylight these two maddrassas have been at loggerheads for decades and their Aaqidah differs dramatically.
Any Deoband Aalim will never worship or ask of the dead at graves as was alluded to so that is a misrepresentation and false.
Salafi scholars have their good points and sometimes Deoband scholars do make things in Tasawwuf which are not part of the Sunnah important but ultimately both groups have good in them and Tauheed as a focal point Alhamdulillah. I hope Inshaa Allah thus discussion can take take place to clear up misconceptions Inshaa Allah.
Barelwis and Deobandis follow the exact same fiqh and the exact same aqeedah. Where are the differences you mention? Have you ever seen people from either group that worship graves? It is a grave sin to make accusations that you have no evidence for except hearsay.
His refutation was like honey
May Allah give success to the righteous.
Alhamdulilah the Taliban have had the direct help of Allah, and they are 'deobandi'.
Alhamdulilah.
May Allah be harsh to those that slander and insult Sheikh al-Akhbar aka Muḥyī ad-Dīn aka the greatest teacher. He was a high ranking wali and Sheikh of walis. Who was that? Imam Ibn Arabi (RA). He was mastered all the sciences each consisting an ocean of knowledge. There was not a single scholar in his era that possessed more knowledge than him in any Islamic science yet we have deviants calling him kuffar and not understanding the sophisticated terminologies used by Sufis. Wahdatul Wujud is the language of Awliyahs.
I'll quote the Mujahid and Mujaddid of the 9th century called Imam Hafid Al Suyuti (RA) said: "For my part, the last word concerning ibn ‘Arabi, and this is accepted neither by his contemporary admirers nor by his detractors, is that he be considered a Wali but reading his books is forbidden. He himself is related as saying, ‘We are a people whose books are forbidden to read.’ This is because the Sufiyyah, by convention, use a technical terminology known only to them and by which they refer to meanings in a way different from common usage."
The teacher of Imam Hafid Ibn Hajar Al-Asqalani (RA) called Al-Imam Siraj ad-Din al-Bulqini said: "We seek refuge in Allah from saying that ibn ‘Arabi affirms Hulul (indwelling) and Ittihad (unity)! He is far above that. Rather, he is one of the greatest A’immah and among those who have probed the oceans of the sciences of Qur’an and Hadith."
Imam Ibn Hajar Al-Haytami (RA) says regarding him:
"There is unanimity that Ibn Arabi was the most knowledgeable Scholar of his era, as he mastered every science of Islāmic knowledge….And there is unanimity that he was the most pious in his era, most staunch on the Sunna and the greatest in self-sacrifice”.
As a Shafi'i brother I stand behind you against ahlul bidah who lie on the creed of the Salaf and slander the great classical scholars.
Well problem is most western da'is are under wahhabi influence, very few are on right path like shaykh Murad or shaykh Hamza Yusuf.
Think many would disagree with you on the second half of that sentence.
@@N65. why? Shakyh Hamza Yusuf is such a powerful 'alim. Shaykh Hakim Murad too, Abudllah Farooq too. They are all elite. Like it or not. Thats a fact.
@@amersekic8535 lmao elite 😂
@@kingman-bo5dt yeah laugh man cuz you have nothing else. Wahhabism is falsehood and wrong aqeedah of zahiri/mujassim mix. Terrible poison for ummah.
Seekersguidance are doing good work
Shaykh is a gem. I don't know Shaykh personally but in 2021, I lost my eyesight, and one of my friends in Bradford told Shaykh and Shaykh phoned me to give me such good nasheeha, it helped me so much to carry on. He didn't have to phone me but it was such a surprise and I will always remember that call and appreciate it. Since Shaykh came into the scene, I've been learning from him and appreciate everything he does. JazakAllahu khair ya Shaykh.
I am absolutely shocked! I follow salafi scholars generally (although I don’t necessarily call myself salafi but ascribe to salafiyya methodology). I have seen lots of refutations and clarifications from salafis. I might have never seen your videos ever. But this video came in my recommendations so I had some time and decided let’s see what this man has to say. Ya Sheikh I’m so moved by this. This is how a refutation should be. Wallahi your Adab and Character is so so so … I don’t have words to say. Salafis sometimes are bit harsh (not all of them obviously) in refutations etc.
I just hope even if salafis don’t learn anything else from this video they can learn from you how to make a refutation video. I mean if we claim to be followers of Mohammed SallAllahu Alaihi wasallam, our dealings with others whom we disagree in somethings should still be flawless. Obviously you can never reach the character of him SallAllahu Alaihi wasallam but I think I can say you try to be true follower of him. Saying we follow Quran and Sunnah is easy, anyone can talk the talk but to walk the walk is the true test.
May Allah grant you the highest rank in Jannah for your Adab for nothing can be more heavier in the scales than good character. May Allah grant you ikhlas. May Allah turn all your evil deeds into mountains of good deeds. May Allah unite the Muslims. Ameen
Ameen
Very true
Agi you should look to what he is saying not how he is saying things
@@mocryptottm7223 it's called manners
@@jamalkhalil77 it's called having knowledge of the Understanding of the Selef
In the toxic refutation culture, this feels like fresh air Subhan Allah!
Such a beautiful akhlaq this is may Allah reward shaykh yasir
ameen
May Allah reward? Why do Muslims still speak in medieval bollocks?
Sheikh usman and his salafi group misunderstood the deobandis. They are great islamic scholars like other muslims. Stop denying this reality. Go and see their tremendous work in fields of tafseer, hadith, fiqh. They are marvelous 👍💪💪🌹❤️
Deobandi aqeeda is batil and kufr go open their books... am former deobandi...
Here Imdaadullah Muhajir Makki is saying that man is in reality a manifestation of Allaah in human form which is the belief of wahdatul wajood.
In another place Imdaadullah Muhajir Makki he said concerning the verse, “Verily! I am your Lord! So take off your shoes.” (Ta-Ha 20:12), “The sound that came from (mount) Toor came from the innerself of Moosaa (Alayhis-Salaam) and this is present in all humans.” (Shamaa’im Imdaadiyyah pg.59)
@@Spark12429 Twister of words and compulsive liar!
@@geniunerf4868 who's liar...
@@Spark12429 Don’t waste your time with these people akhi
Just seek knowledge from ahlul hadeeth and leave these guys
I see Salafis in the chat going crazy! 👀.. each one having their own interpretation of the quran and Sunnah.. claiming taqleed is wrong but they do taqleed when their scholars give them their opinion " correct opinion" 🤣.. they follow the khalaf and call themselves salaf.
Then the issues of aqeedah they blow out of proportion and claim every group other than athari is correct when they haven't even studied under the shuyookh to hear a unbiased opinion.
Facts they don't even agree on aqeeda in their own circles, but are quick to issue takfir against every other Muslim.
This man has amazing manners! May Allah bless him and increase him in good!
Without banging Deobandi drums too much BUT Alhamdulillah Very very Big percentage of Schoolers from Deoband have very good manners unlike Majority of Bralvis so called Schoolers.
I respect the hanafis as this is the way I came into Islam, I still prefer to lean towards the hanafi school in my Islam, however I find that the salafis have much more of a only e presence, in the age of the internet I feel the hanafis and deobandi need to get online more, besides the hanafi fiqh channel there’s not much hanafi deobandi channels out there, this is why I feel a lot of the younger generation gravitate towards the salafi way because they have a huge online presence.
That's the problem really. Salafis are using the internet to cause mischief. They're bringing up topics that should be discussed in masjids onto the internet and causing fitna and doubts in young Muslims.
Many monetize the online influence and hence the huge presence of such actors who will upload videos at high frequency .True Ulema are doing the work in a real traditional school, and upload videos only when very necessary.
I thank Allah for guiding me out of the Salafī movement and giving me awareness of who the real Ahlus Sunnah (true Athari, Ash'ari and Maturidi) are.
Bro Allah is not the one guiding you out of Selefia because if you know the minhadj Selef....how could you leave the Path and understanding of the 1e 3 generations? So i think it was Sheithan who guided you out
@@mocryptottm7223 He was not a Salafist in the first place, he is a liar. Salafism is not a movement but a methodology.
He claims that 3 different creeds are correct 🫠, go make dua to br guidedto the correct creed of islam.
Don’t water down the creed.
Search for the creed of our first 3 generations.
@@mocryptottm7223 salafi is a group like other groups which has good bad and is not fully correct there good sufis bad sufis good dalafi bad salafi etc
Miaw saud were a corrupt bandit alliance whom many salafi take from blindly
@@mocryptottm7223 salafi is a sect which contains good and bad deviants like madkhali
As a school, Deoband The largest of number of huffadh & ulama.
The largest da’wah group - jama’at Tabligh - have their roots in Deoband.
The most successful contemporary jihad movement - Taliban - have their roots in Deoband.
Ilm, da’wah & jihad!
And ignorants target them. SubhanAllah
and yet taliban have banned girls from education now i dont care what taliban is
Sunni hanafi deobandi movement
This man is a gem for the ummah and has benefited me tremendously. May Allah reward him without measure. Ameen
Agreed SH Uthman is Allahumma Barak
@@carlosillich787 I was referring to Sheikh Yasir just to be clear but I also believe Sheikh Uthman has done good for the ummah as well. I just wanted to make it clear who I was specifically referring to.
@ahmad hanbal be willing to take that to qiyamah my brother
@ahmad hanbal بسم الله
The criteria for spouse selection in Islam is "religion(deen) and character(akhlaaq)" as per a hadith.
Why did the Hadith(saying of the Prophet) say deen,but not imaan?
If a person has deen,he is going to have character,right? Are they two things?
If a person has deen,it means "he pays attention to his basic religious obligations seriously,observes the limits in morals(by imitation or because of parents) and can be externally identified as a person of religion". Not just in legal sense.
What's in his heart and the level of sincerity or the level of his devotion in his worship are not to be judged. These things come under the definition of "high imaan". Or it means brightness of the heart.
Character
A person can be said to have deen(religion) because he claims so. But people are'nt interested to deal with him socially because his manners(akhlaaq) are ugly. Like the one who uploads videos to prove that "Mr.X the liar from Birmingham" is wrong and he is right. And 2000 angry hot heads from uk Asian community are given opportunity to write debased comments.
Can anyone marry his daughter? Maybe these 2000 hot heads must be asked to contemplate.
Definition of character is what David Brooks wrote. A person of character means a person who has emotional control. He can check his disposition and knows how to reform it. He judges issues very critically and does not make useless statements.
Another incident can clarify the issue. The companions of the prophet went to meet the most special wife of the prophet and asked her "What was the khulq(character) of the prophet at home". They weren't asking whether he(Our prophet) practised religion at home or if he had another moral standard inside the home. Question was about his expression style.
Verification of facts
A person appears in a video. He is sitting in car and hurriedly says 'Assallam alaikumu brothers,this is quick video about Mr.X the liar from Birmingham who gave this opinion.."
Then he talks about a topic which is not relevant to be mentioned here because he has the failed in many Islamic standards
The video starts with a picture of the person he disagrees with
1. Whats the need to mention "Birmingham"? Perhaps he has another enemy in Birmingham and his hatred was exposed. Or he hates entire Birmingham.
(Indication : A person of no emotional control and therefore cant be listened to)
2. There is a catchy headline to get attention.
(Indication : A lot of emphasis to express grudge. His family affairs are likely to be ruined)
3. The video has no proof that the speaker has checked and authorized it to be uploaded
Indication : He cant manage his life's affairs efficiently and therefore cant be trusted for opinions.
The video has a comment section where anyone can write anything and there's no moderation
Indication : His house,property and dignity wont be safe. Can be easily scammed.
If a person listens a person of no standard with engaging interest,he can acquire the same dirty manners and say about others "Oh this short Hindi speaking guy from London"
The science of "keeping the mind at rest about advanced religious issues and strictly adhere to basic Islam"
Currently,there are 3 hour long videos of a famous Muslim speaker trying to refute atheism by debating with an atheist.
Rather than wasting 3 hours on internet, there is an easy way to not to get a psychiatric disorder called "religious mania" and make life easy.
If someone wants to question the existence of Allah,a simple answer is enough.
"Allah exists for sure. He is uncreated. His essence cant be described. But humans can witness Allah's signs in the creation. But Allah is not part of the created things. We have this understanding because of prophets and their message. Now,its up to people to decide whether they want to know Allah(to have awe) or they keep talking about him in a vague theoretical way. If someone feels,he does not need Allah,then its his problem. He may have a disposition dysfunction,health issue or he maybe blinded by a grudge just like a person who hates entire Birmingham because of someone residing there. People with such issues need to rest their minds and associate with decent people with sound social aptitude. This will give heart certain inclinations(called asraar in Arabic). That will lead him to where he needs to go. Reading a lot of books or debates cant lead to anything. Trying to know Allah without social emotions is not how the Prophet delivered the message of Islam"
Finished.No need for 3 hours of brain damage.
May Allah Accept your works, and make it a means of acceptance and Guidance for the Ummah!
How can someone be more humble than saying "give us some benefit of doubt"? May Allaah reward you Sheikh.
ما شاء الله
This is the true nature of an authentic scholar! May Allah bless Shaykh Yasir and revive more like him! ❤
This is the first time I have heard the definition of Wahdatul Wujud, and what's amazing to me is I contemplated this once a few months ago that if you really thought about it, then Allah is the only One True Existence! Subhanallah this came naturally to me which makes me think this is the fitrah.....jazkallahu khayr for informing me of this
If Allah is the only true existence that means you’re denying the attributes of Allah and names. Allah is a creator, sustainer all seeing all hearing etc… the fact that everything depends on Him alone doesn’t mean only he exist. You’re confused and can easily fall into shirk and kufur. May Allah forgive you and all those who liked your stupid comment.
@@Aurora-lm5ns so you’re saying attributes of Allah are separate entities and not part of Him?
@@immigreat54 his creation is no doubt.
@@Aurora-lm5ns Your comment is stupid. Period.
@@Aurora-lm5ns You are demonstrating heightened stupidity, you succeeded 🙁
When sh.yasir is calm and polite them you know youve messed up🤣🤣
Mashallah Sheikh what a beautiful explanation, we need more Sheikhs like you, what a beautiful character Mashallah, amazing words and advice, Alhamdulillah you humbled me subhanallah, may Allah SWT bless guide and unite the Muslim ummah
Allah bless you hazrat, but please dont call uthman ibn farooq "shaykh"
I love how the Shaykh responds these days. Such great akhlaq; May Allah preserve him. I am a follower of Shaykh Uthman but Shaykh Yasir melts my heart. Love from Bangladesh.
Sheikh Uthman isn’t inspiring at all.
@@dariusneidhart1068 everyone tries their best to spread the beauty of Islam.
@@dariusneidhart1068 Calm down little kid, look at Shaykh Uthmaan's background.
I found Salafis very dishonest when it comes to Deoband, sufis, tassawuf. You will always find them quoting Imam Ibn Taimiyyah , Ibnl Qayyum rahimahullah but when it comes to sufis they completely ignore all the works these two great men have done for Tasawwuf and they have praised sufis and also wanted to have their final resting place with sufis. The salafies always claim they only follow salaf ( the first three generations) but they completely ingnore the ijtihad, fatwas of sahabi like Ibn Masud (ra,) and his students then Imam Abu Hanifa who was also a salaf! It's sad but the truth is salafies only take whatever they seem fit for their agenda from the first three generations and completely ignore all the opinions that goes against them as I mentioned about sufism , Imam ibn Qayyim and Imam Taimiyyah.
As salaamu alykum Sheikh Yasser. I've watched some of your earlier videos and this is the 2nd of the recent ones and this really reminds me of the adaab of Ikhtilaf between the salaf. This is how it needs to be done, alhamdulillah. Please continue to do so. Together with this form of reaction I think it will really be a good thing to arrange a direct discussion with the likes of Sheikh Uthmaan so that all their misconceptions are cleared up. We have enough external enemies and there has never been such a dire need for unity as there is today where we, the Muslim Ummah, are facing a barrage of attacks on so many fronts and platforms. In unity there is and will always be strength.
never gonna happen. what? some people lower themselves in front of their online audience?
Subhanallah, what a beautiful voice of reason! Clear language, beautiful mannerisms, full of knowledge, mashallah. This is the mainstream sunni way which includes tasawwuf.
Shariat
Tariqat
Ma'arifat
Haqeeqat
All 4 are necessary to Reach Allah Swt, without Shariat no one Reaches the Destiny 😊
May Allah SWT reward you and the HFC team immensely for your contribution to our Ummah. Aameen ya rabb
Subscribing to this channel because of this sound explanation. May Allah continue to sow unity in our hearts, amin.
Unity can be achieved by following and spreading Quran and Sunnah, not by defending Sufism. Our only source of knowledge should be Quran and Sunnah, other sources lead us astray.
@@MegaRizm brother, ANY and EVERY muslim believes in the Qur'an and Sunnah. Madhaib are a mercy to us. It goes without saying that the people of Ahlus Sunnah wal Jama'ah do not accept pantheism or the worshipping of graves. Much of everything else discussed among the ummah are matters of ihtilaf.
Why didn't they reach out to Doebandi scholars to allow Q&A to have the Senior scholars speak to the congregation like this.... Missed opportunity for certain, we all AGREE about Islam but we all have forgot each others "Modern" history of being disconnected since Centruries of Coloinialism...
They lack too much knowledge about Deobandis, they don’t want to get roasted.
Only the ignorant ones do not reach out
Search about Mufti Taqi Usmani and shaykh Abul Hasan Ali nadwi, They are highly respected among top Saudi scholars
May Allah reward the Shaykh. The video is very comprehensive and free from egotistical mannerisms. Mashallah
Shaykh Yasir Al-Hanafi is a great Scholar and a great teacher. May Allah Almighty reward him for his great service in religious matters.
Brother if you truly know and knew real scolars you wouldnt say such a statement...but i guess that a one eyed man is King in the land of the blind.
@mocrypto TTM my brother stop this sort of replies you are getting into a trap of shetaniayt you are causing troubles stop dividing you are behaving like the English as Muhammad p.u.b.h. said if you have something to say then good words otherwise stay silent
@@nazirbismillah7796 if you want to do blind following and not seek knowledge.....salaamoelijkoem
@@nazirbismillah7796 problem is with most of none arab speaking moslims is that you are dependent on translations and if some of you speaks arabic you raise him to a level wich he definetly not deserves. If you are a student of knowledge and and posess fluent arabic then you see though that all. Anyway go emotional en fellow desires and you only get the fruits of what you seed.
@@mocryptottm7223 I'm not surprised the brother has not replied to u. Yes brother Yasir said in this video that he is not a scholar and should not be called one, although he has lots of knowledge. It's not only Arabs that speak Arabic. In fact there are lots of those who have learnt Arabic and have perhaps much more a deeper understanding than some Arabs. Ur first comment was uncalled for and is not good character so try refrain from such comments. Barakallah feek
May Allah bless you and also Daniel Haqiqatjou for holding ground in the discussion.
Masha Allah. Deen is Adab and I am happy to see our Ahnaf brothers with their good manners.
MashAllah. Such a beautiful way of justifying the concept. Hearing Shaykh Uthman's claim truly got me confused and was waiting for someone to record this clarification. May Allah reward you with his blessings and adding Mufti Taqi Usmani's explanation really cleared all the doubts about Wahdatul Wujud.
Deoband is real islam their adab is outstanding and their knowledge of Tawheed is amazing
True but people with superficial knowledge of deoband claims it to be misguided kufr shirk etc
@@Abdullah_2442 those are part of mujasamah pseudo salafis
Deoband is a creedal school of thought which believes in different things compared to athari,ashari and maturidi creedal schools.
That's how a Muslim should be. Usman bin farook have hurt and made all the deobandis very angry bkoz of his stupid comments on deobandis but still this man is so kind and so respectful. Don't get me wrong i love shayk Usman alot i watch all his debates and all. But i don't like the way he talks, SOMETIMES ON SOME ISSUES.
uthman is an westerner regardless of what he is. his behavioral (us) attitude suits him 100%
Masha Allah Sheikh! Jazakallah khair for the excellent clarification. May Allah taala protect the aqeedah of Ahle sunnah waljamaah. May He guide the misguided so called salafis who have appeared relatively recently. They falsely believe that only they are the enlightened Muslims. They ridiculously refute the scholarship of great Islamic scholars like Imam Hanafi, Shafiee, Maliki and Hambali who were actually the GENUINE SALAFIS.
No Salafi “refutes” the scholarship of any of the four Imams. We follow them and the evidence. If you are going to be critical of the Salafi manhaj at least be truthful in your criticism. What you stated is categorically false. And be careful of following deviants who put their own theories into the mouths of the scholars of the past.
@@eesaabdurrahman1569 like you pseudo Salafi's do. When you misquote and bend the truth to fit into your polemical minds. Like how this episode highlights.
@@Mohsinn769 the Salafis follow the beliefs of the companions and those directly after them based upon proof. What else is necessary for us to examine? The proofs that, for example, Imam Malik, followed the Athari creed as understood by the Salafi manhaj are obvious. For example, his anger at the innovation of asking “how” in regards to Allah’s rising above.
And why is it necessary for you to include emojis in your question? Is the intention to disrespectfully mock? What is the wisdom in that? My response was in relation to the false claim that we “refute the scholarship” of the four Imams. This is a baseless lie for which there is no evidence.
@@eesaabdurrahman1569plain lie. Salafis constantly say Imam Abu Hanifa had incorrect Aqeeda. RUclips is littered with their videos.
@@Anonymous-411 give one example of a Salafi saying that Abu Hanifa had incorrect Aqeedah. This is a completely false claim. Rather the Salafi affirm the Aqeedah of the early generations and refute that which opposes it.
As a salafi shafi’i Muslim, I love this response, I clicked on expecting to hear complete arrogance , but you responded in respect and akhlaq. So jazakallahu Khayran, we need more people to criticise and correct our brothers in your way.
Edit: I’m no longer Salafi alhamdulillah. After studying this great deen and learning the true way of the Salaf, I’ve embraced the Quran only path.
You can't be salafi and shafiye.
How can a person be a shafai and a salafi; lol
@@thecerebralexplorerAs salamu alaikum. Ofc you can, infact there are even many hanafis that are also salafis . Salafiyyah is striving to following the Quran and sunnah with the interpretation of the salaf as salih. This is what the Imams of the 4 mathhahib all strived to do, the difference is that I do not stick to the Shafi’i opinion like it’s revelation and claim that all others have inferior opinion, rather if a matter comes from the Sunnah of the prophet that has been verified and it’s isnaad has been declared sahih and it conflicts with the Shafi’i position, I follow the Prophet (صلی الله عليه وسلم) not Imam Shafi’i رضي الله عنه.
Truth of the matter is the 4 imams, even with their venerated amounts of knowledge were human like me and you and not anbiya’. So ofc their knowledge was limited which made some exposed to some aspects of the Sunnah while others another, but Salafiyyah takes a holistic approach.
Follow your own respected mathaahib in ambiguous matters not addressed or not addressed clearly in the Quran and sunnah and by the salaf as salih, and fills the Quran and Sunnah on clear matters, even if it conflicts with the opinions of your respected school of thoughts, this is the essence of being ‘Salafi’ and arguably the essence of being a true Muslim who strives in the way of Allah.
@@jamalnasir7395 oh boy I have news for you, Most salafis actually follow a mathhab, the La mathhabis (Those who don’t have a specific madhhab) are a minority of salafi Muslims.
@@Pyaweti
Then you are a salafi and not a Muqallid. Hence, not a shafi.
Apart from them, I won't argue with you with regards to the fact that you should follow one imam since you seem to know nothing about how things work when it comes to Fiqh and Hadees.
Wasalam.
I’m salafi alhamdulillah however I have to say this shaikhs manners go back to his parents, may Allaah bless them. Ameen.
Since you mention you are salafi, just out of curiosity, when Allah said when He comes down to the nearest heaven at 1/3rd of the night, what does it mean to you in its meaning?
@@cmdaltctr salaam
I hope he says the mercy of Allah descends rather than Allah coming down
@@cmdaltctr my respected brother in Islam, I’m not going to take the bait on a well known deobandi platform, my answer is in line with the athaar, I would urge you to go to bro hajjis channel and he has explained exactly what you have asked, and that in sha Allaah is my position.
@@truthseeker2095 brohajji is out of his depths against Ashari's who are well versed and that have clearer understanding of deeper matters and topics such as these. although I do admire brohajis works his works are more epistemological based not of an understanding one through knowledge and wisdom. for the sake of Allah i hope i have not offended anyone with this comment but please take it with a grain of salt.
@@anzrahman373 so the mercy of Allah only lands on the 3.rd part of night??
His Arabic is somewhat weak and he doesn't seem to know basic grammar and he wants to talk about such concepts. You're responding to someone who's trying to apply a kulli ruling on something which requires study of the subject takseemat as well as looking at the authors works. However, to do that one still needs grounding in several other subjects. I feel he parrots what he reads on Salafi forums or something. I
Unless one is as Zamakshari's level in grammar and a master in the poetic meter as well as philosophical (used in place of tafakkur) insight needed for deeper thinking he shouldn't be talking about such things and labelling them shirkh or küfr.
You're being too nice to him.
Shaykh has to maintain good character even while exposing something.
The problem is with most salafi brothers, they are obsessed with negativity towards tassawuf.
Well said
@@nav021298 the core goal of pseudo- salafism is fighting tasawuf.
@@nav021298 I think it appears so because there are many pseudo shayks around.
I Love you my beloved Shaykh Yasir Al Hanafi ❤️. May Allah preserve you my beloved Shaykh.
Wahabi or Salafi really restrict knowledge of muslim
Ma Sha Allah. What beautiful way he presented his side. Wallah this is a humble guy.
I honestly rate this brother. Whilst I suspect we would disagree on some matters (myself studying initially at a ‘brelvi’ institute and thereafter, Al-azar), I envisage that any disagreement would not prevent us from embracing each other as brothers in Islam.
If you want to understand the core of barelvi then check out hussam ul harmain
Then check maulana ilyas ghummans response to hussaam ul haramain
The thruth be told they ie The so called sheik uthman and the like of them have no real knowledge of Islam to debate the above point ...nowdays almost everyone who puts on a nice headress and a beard with a elementary knowledge having a good gift of gab thinks they have the right to adress any problem on islam ,be it from hadith to philosophy...no offense intended ..some have even no adab about whome they speck .
I love the mannerisms of this brother mashaAllah. Although I am Salafi inshaAllah, it is good to see that knowledge is refuted with knowledge with good mannerisms even from those we disagree with.
Mannerism is one of most important teaching in deobandi madrasa .
(ألا إن كل شيء خلا الله باطل ) صحيح البخاري
This response was needed and appropriate. Shaikh Uthman was talking far beyond what is true.
Give specific examples and your rebuttal.
@@KnowledgeBoutique rebuttal to what? I just commented on the video which was the rebuttal. Do you want a rebuttal to the rebuttal?
@@KnowledgeBoutique but if you want an example, Uthman ibn Farooq said that deobandis believe that the Prophet (saw) is alive and walking around, meeting people, sitting down, having dinner. This is absolute rubbish. He needs to either provide the proof for this claim or retract it.
@@KnowledgeBoutique Do you have any comment? I just gave you a specific example.
At young age I have been genuinely fortunate to follow these "deviated group" in their Tabligh Dawah tour in my country (The Gambia 🇬🇲). A decade ago the issue of Salafiasm surfaced in our national theological discussions, the outcome of which eventually made our senior Ulamas worried about the movement.
I am forever grateful for the spiritual foundation these people have opportune me with, but Salafis qualify them as Bida'h Jama'at.
regardless of differences, learn from this Shaykh, this is what muslim Akhlq should be like....my salafi brothers are too harsh........and yes i on the Athari Aqida
May Allah reward you shaykh.
Subhanallah What a beautiful sincere calm response from your part! Ever since u explained it the first time i never forgot this explanation of yours. I sincerely love u and i really wished i could learn anything islamic with you even something small like how to drink the sunnah way just so i could meet u and hug you🤗 may allah ta'ala reward you and increase your knowledge and make the ummah to unite ameen
You Sir are not just a teacher of knowledge, but that of akhlaq as well, something which I haven't really encountered across other shaykhs. May Allah SWT magnify the blessings upon you ya shaykh.
Please don't call him "shaykh". He has no right to be platformed with esteemed scholars. He's a half baked student and has been known because of his dawah table stalls. He should stick to that and know his. The saying "A little knowledge is dangerous" is right.
Brother do you know book almuhannad ala al mufannad ... This book is aqida book of deobandis. If you read this book it mentioned that prophet (saw) is physically alive in grave ... And the dust which touching the boby( jism mubarak) of prophet (saw) is greater (afzal) then the Kaaba , arsh and kursi ... And also mentioned that they (deobandis) believe in getting faiz from graves... If any deobandi don't believe in this aqaid so he is not a deobandi .. the Shaikh in this video is also a deobandi hanafi I definitely say that this Shaikh believes in this book if he don't then he can't be a deobandi... So the aqaid of deobandis are against the Qur'an and Hadith... Shaikh Usman bin Farooq is a true scholar . His aqaid are according to Quran and Hadith because he is not a deobandi. Thank you
@@alfurqan1981 qarn al shaytan is from Najd.
MashaAllah very well explained brother! May Allah increase you in knowledge even more.
MA SHA ALLAH I'm also a follower of Salafi and we may have disagreements. The way you address following adab you are following the true Sunnah May ALLAH preserve you amen
MashaAllah every word is gold ! Speaking with knowledge and adab.
MaShaAllah. All of us Muslims are reciters of La ilaha illallah, only if all of you brothers of knowledge can come together and have dialogs and move forward as on body, only then there can be real progress. This crab in a barrel mentality is not getting any of us anywhere.
A series of him reading highlights from this book would be awsome! BarakAllāhu feek
While the Mongol hordes were approaching the gates of Baghdad to wipe out its population and great centres of learning, our renowned scholars at the time were busy debating 'the length of miswaak' on the bank of River Euphrates.
As the famous saying goes; "One thing we learn from history is that we never learn from history."
What you recommend? What should they do? Come with solution not just criticism.
Why don't you regularly upload videos, I'm always eagerly waiting for your videos. We have learned so much from your channel. Please please keep uploading these beautiful videos regularly.
That's what happen, when salafi people blindly listen to others.
This gives me study Islam more and more as a Talibul ilm.
It is saddening to see SHEIKH UTHMAN ascribing false aqaid with DEOBAND, it goes on to show how less he knows about DEOBAND & its great shayokhs. Shielh uthman should know that aqaid of deoband are the one from quran & sunnah & the understanding of salaf.
Kudos to DANIEL HAQIQATJOU.... How he holds his position & grounds his argument & defends deoband.
Jazaakallaahu Khairan Shaykh Yasir.
I love you for the sake of Allah and every video of yours increases me in knowledge and spirituality.
Please keep these videos coming as the extreme Salafis are trying to police everyone else like Deoband is something bad etc.
May Allah (SWT) bless you Shaykh and the Hanafi Fiqh channel, Aameen
The Adab/Manner of you brothers correcting other Muslim brother is amazing. ❤️ May Allah bless you.
Subhaanallah; we shouldn't praise directly but I have to say that this is an exemplary response. Alhamdulillah and jazakumullah for sharing this.
Shiekh I want to become like you how and where to get islamic knowledge like u
Reach out to your nearby branch of darul ulom deoband in your country
Alhamdulillah Sheikh I have been following this channel for many years. And also Sheikh uthmaan. But it's clear explanation of misinformation given by Sh. Uthmaan which we don't believe in, I definitely hope our Sheikh will agree with you InshaAllah!!
Sh. Uthmaan plz accept it as correction in positive manner but not as argument...
3:12 - Thank you for this clarification. I follow the Hanbali Madhab, my dad is Deobando Hanafi. Many people criticise deobandos and say they aren't Sunnis etc. However, when I ask my Dad about Islam his views are always in line with Imam Abu Hanifa and the classical texts? So this made me confused. Thanks for making it clear deobando just represents the geographical state and isn't a sect as that is what it seems like
You got it right
You must ask your dad hard questions like where is Allah and attributes of Allah
If answers are in line with classic scholars like Ibn Teimje or Ahmed Ibn Hanbal etc and he is good
@@halimkuci5 yeh that's what I was thinking. However, if I told him that Allah is above the throne etc, he would easily listen. I told my mum and she changed her opinion quite quickly
First you have to understand Al-Azhar, Al-Medina, Dar-ul-Uloom Deoband are amongst the respected top Islamic seminaries in the world. They are not sects.
If the noisy neighbors claim otherwise ask them in the Indo-Pak region which of there sects produced scholars who’s matched them in linguistics and Islamic sciences.
The Pseudo-Salafi are too busy with politics; what is the Arsh? Where is the Arsh? What’s the google coordinates? Even there seniors tried to explain these things who have varied opinions.
They do not realise they are creating unnecessary fitnah in itself we should remain silent concerning these details and meanings which is the safest position.
@@bouncer786 The evidence is clear that Allah is above the throne. However, we shouldn't delve into these cknvos so much. If you are giving genuine naseehah, go ahead, or else if you are just debating then no point
Subhanallah brother. I really like and appreciate your way of critique. We need this badly. Dua for your channel 's growth.
Was wahadatul wajood word given by prophet pbuh himself ? Ofc not. Then why early sufi choose the word which also found in pantheism ? Why so manu ambiguous statements and words in sufism and which leading people to innovations ??? Ofc these ambiguity clearly corrupt aqeedah… shaykh please consider this
Sub7aanAllaah, perfect admonition/reaction following the perfectly respectful ettiquettes. However, given how Shaykh Uthman, Karim and the other Shaykh that ambushed and tried to bully Daniel, I would be somewhat reluctant to assume the "sincerity" and "genuinity" of Shaykh Uthman. Nevertheless, I would love to see a discussion between you and Shaykh Uthman. He is fantastic on the comparative religions platform but he is a major source of misguidance for the Muslims when he starts talking on Fiqh and 3aqeedah.
I have the same feeling as you regarding the sincerity of Shaykh Uthman
What they did to brother Daniel was wrong. He’s a gem for the ummah right now , especially given his battle against feminism and liberalism
Lost count how many times a deobandi brother presented nothing but wholesome akhlaq Lool. Can’t hate these guys
Why use the term "Wahdat-ul-Wujood (oneness of existence) to begin with in relation to Allah?! Saying that you mean it is being used in the context of tasawwuf doesn't negative the ugliness of this term. Essentially, monism. Tell me, what did you mean by wahdatul wujood in tasawwuf?! Such sophistry is merely beating around the bush.
Clear and educated response from our Shaykh. Im not sure that Uthman Farooq is able to produce a response simply due to the fact that hes punching way above his weight.
This comment is uncalled for. He is also highly knowledgeable
@@Ummmaryameesa He aren't Knowledgeable. Can't even read or say simple things straight.
@@Ummmaryameesa He is a great Daee and should stay in his lane, his Dawah is excellent, however he is not a scholar and has not studied to be one, he doesn't even have basic command of Arabic.
Jennifer Aniston shhh!!!
@@hubros8225 really? You call your sister in Islam Jennifer Aniston? I’m kind of offended.
First of all if you want to correct a brother's fault you don't do it publicly but meet with the individual and tell him. I think Uthman did mention Allah is not in everything and I could be wrong. Not because Uthman was in a public forum you have to correct him publicly. Just a note...If any Muslim claim he belongs to any sect he will be in the Hellfire. And that includes the Salifis.
Ok Shaikh, But what about book *FADIAL-E-AAMAL* written by Maulana Zakaria there are lots of things in the book about *Wahdatul Wujid*. And this book is widely reading by Ahlul-Devband and Jamat-tablig eveyday.
mashallah jazakallah you've left me speechless. I'd never really understood wahdul wujood before but you've explained it so well that i am completely on board with it now. how can anyone deny the concept?
Masha Allah very insightful
Jazakallahu khair,
from a non hanafi.
Ur response was ...in very good way mashallah..
Probably my favorite channel on RUclips
I suggest Sheikh Yasir can make vlogs on daily basis and keep this channel active all the time. It will benefit all of us in sha Allah. This channel has a lot of subscribers but seems like not active all the time. For example this video came after almost 4 months.
سربکف سر بلند دیوبند ❤
Masha Allah. Great video. Lots of misconceptions are clarified. I'm a Madeena graduate and I am coming from a Salafi background. I dunno about other professors, but those who taught us Aqeeda never mentioned anything about Deobandis being an unorthodox aqeeda sect. In fact Deobandis were not even mentioned at all. I believe the problem is people are projecting certain individual behaviors on the whole group which is wrong. We have to go the basic texts of that group to claim such. And Sheikh Uthman seems not have done that and I feel he has to apologize for that if he wants to come clean.
Deobandis are not an aqeedah sect, nor are they a madhab. They are an institution of education, so one cannot refer to them as an Aqeedah as it's incoherent. One should study the history of Deobandis so one can gain better understanding Inshallah.
Maturidi,Ashari and Salafi are brothers (not including Hashawi,Mujassima,Muattılah,Murjiah...etc)
May Allah preserve you Sheik
First time to get that
Very good video with new information for me
The way you explained is the best
People should use good intention with their brothers
May Allah give you more information and spread it out by you.
Masha'Allah
I really appreciate the way you talk, it's the best way to do ikhtilaaf. May Allah bless you Āmīn.
Love from kashmir
Where are you from in Kashmir?
@@Mohsinn769 Sopore
Jazakallahu Khaira Moulana. Please tag all their channels.
Amazing manners, may Allah reward you. One thing though, Uthman Farooq is not a shaykh, he does not unfortunately have basic command of the Arabic language, it was amazing to see your level of adab but we also shouldn't give a title to someone who doesn't deserve it at all
بارك الله فيكم يا مولانا
Imagine believing that wahdatul wujud is some simplistic pantheistic baloney. How can you undermine your own tradition so badly?
MashaAllah Allah swt bless u my brother..shining example of good mannerisms this is how we should all talk and advice one another.