The most wonderful, best Pathétique I’ve ever heard. More than any other historical recordings with historical conductors and orchestras- this girl conductor is brilliant
33:06 I've heard many recordings and seen it live 4 times, however this is the most energetic so far without derailing, it's almost painful to come into contact with this interpretation. That shows in such a colorful and sincere way all the joy that a tormented soul carried, along with it, like baggage, alongside sadness, throughout its life.
She is the best conductor with all that passion , before as a prodigy chello girl, and now as a conductor, but I miss her with her Chello she was absolutely amazing. She is a genious of music. Bravo Han Na Chang you have the touch of God and of a real artist !!!! .
She is the greatest woman conductor not only in our time but in the whole music history and as an intellectual shaman, the second woman is Ben-Dor and no more.
Bravo this was amazing. Han-Na Chang is just amazing conductor have seen her twice in Oslo and she is just outstanding. Trondheim Symhony Orchestra is just amazing. Bravo Bravo.
Am I listening a Lorin Maazel? He conducted Vienna Philharmonic in 1964. That is still my favorite No.6 since 1976 when I was in high school. Hanna Chang's interpretation is very similar to his. So lovely, so painfully and sadly, and so beautifully. Bravo! Hanna Chang. 장하나씨. 첼로만 잘하는줄 알았더니 지휘로도 거장이 되었어요. 축하합니다. 그리고 정말로 놀라워요. 타고 난 천재적 재능에 노력이 더해지니 그 성취가 놀랍습니다. 앞으로 메이저 오케스트라를 지휘하는 모습 보고싶어요.
Great interpretation, one of the best I've ever heard, specially when Maestro Chang conducts from memory. I would love to be a member of this orchestra under her baton.
When commenters say such-and-such a piece or such-and-such a performer/performance is the greatest of all time, I cringe. Art is not quantitative like won-loss records or championships in sports. Though there's good and bad, there's is still some element of beauty is in the eye of the beholder. The person who says this is the best performance ever of this work should bear in mind that this symphony has been recorded by almost every major conductor and major orchestra since the invention of the record player.
i love the conductor. She is very dramatic and knows every note of Marvelous composition. She is truly a leading conductor as a master artist Should direct to motivate and inspire the musicians. Superb!!! A very talent and skillful orchestra A love between master and artist. Artist and Conductor have tremendous Energy and stamina! The last drop of juice! Bravo!
She is known as a genius who has won at the age of eleven the first prize at Rostropovitch's Competition. Dedication to music is astonishing. A true musician.
What a fantastic conductor and orchestra! But also the video editor has got to be recognized. For the first time as a viewer of classical performance videos, I am allowed to see the ENTIRE orchestra for not just momentary glimpses, but long enough to allow the magnificence of all these highly talented people working together to sink in. Congratulations on not cutting every 5 seconds just for the sake of creating action realizing that the orchestra is the action.
Very good! Some details were superb! I found the brass and percussion outstanding. Bit unfortunate applause. I am always a bit scared hoping the audience doesn't applaud at the end of the molto vivace. One loses the stark emotional impact of the the adagio lamentoso. It is like applauding after an orgasm lol.
As I mentioned at another video of the 6th, there is an old tradition from 19th century to applaude after the 3rd mvt. INSTEAD of the 4th in this symphony, considering the last one as a 'Requiem', and it's not opportune to applaude after sacred music. It comes from the slightly exaggerating time of heroes adoration of genius...
I personaly prefer her 5th symphony as it is too much emotional and too much subjective.But at least better than Karajan, Bernstein, Solti and etc. But now one year later I find it wonderful as my constructing loudspeaker improved..
Origins of music unevidenced. Except it is gift to humanity from God the Creator. Music continues in heaven. Discontinues in hell. Jesus Christ died and resurrected for remissions of everybody's pre-existing sins to save from eternal hell. Penalty of sin already paid by Jesus Christ on The Cross. Accept HIM. Be saved from eternal hell. Enter heaven. Enjoy heavenly music. For free.
She is every bit as talented and engaging a conductor as she is a cellist. I love this performance.
I agree completely.
A performance for the ages, so moving.
The child prodigy cellist Hang Na? So much talent.
The most wonderful, best Pathétique I’ve ever heard. More than any other historical recordings with historical conductors and orchestras- this girl conductor is brilliant
33:06
I've heard many recordings and seen it live 4 times, however this is the most energetic so far without derailing, it's almost painful to come into contact with this interpretation. That shows in such a colorful and sincere way all the joy that a tormented soul carried, along with it, like baggage, alongside sadness, throughout its life.
She is the best conductor with all that passion , before as a prodigy chello girl, and now as a conductor, but I miss her with her Chello she was absolutely amazing. She is a genious of music. Bravo Han Na Chang you have the touch of God and of a real artist !!!!
.
I don't use this expression very often, but..."They nailed it". What a spectacular performance.
She is the greatest woman conductor not only in our time but in the whole music history and as an intellectual shaman, the second woman is Ben-Dor and no more.
Bravo this was amazing. Han-Na Chang is just amazing conductor have seen her twice in Oslo and she is just outstanding. Trondheim Symhony Orchestra is just amazing. Bravo Bravo.
One of the best performances I have ever seen of Pathetique. 3rd and 4th movements are outstanding, brilliant! Congratulations!!
Am I listening a Lorin Maazel? He conducted Vienna Philharmonic in 1964. That is still my favorite No.6 since 1976 when I was in high school.
Hanna Chang's interpretation is very similar to his. So lovely, so painfully and sadly, and so beautifully. Bravo! Hanna Chang.
장하나씨. 첼로만 잘하는줄 알았더니 지휘로도 거장이 되었어요. 축하합니다. 그리고 정말로 놀라워요. 타고 난 천재적 재능에 노력이 더해지니
그 성취가 놀랍습니다. 앞으로 메이저 오케스트라를 지휘하는 모습 보고싶어요.
장한나 씨가 로린 마젤한테 지휘를 배웠죠. 알고 계시죠?
The way the basses died out at the end.... absolutely breathtaking
Thank you! ❤️
Everything has already been said and nothing can be said about this accessible and profound masterpiece.
지휘자로 훌륭하게 성장한 장한나 너무 멋지고 자랑스럽다.
부드럽고 감성적인 차이코프스키도 좋고.
First class performance with all the clarity, vigour and pathos one would expect of the Pathétique.
Great interpretation, one of the best I've ever heard, specially when Maestro Chang conducts from memory. I would love to be a member of this orchestra under her baton.
0:27 Adagio - Allegro non troppo
19:09 Allegro con grazia
27:33 Allegro molto vivace
36:06 Finale: Adagio lamentoso
정세균과는 어떤 관계신지
너무 훌륭한 지휘~장한나 최곱니다.
한순간도 집중력을 놓치지않는 저 표정,동작
들이 황홀한 무아지경을 만들어 내는군요.
한국의 이런 지휘자가 있어서 너무
자랑스럽습니다.
When commenters say such-and-such a piece or such-and-such a performer/performance is the greatest of all time, I cringe. Art is not quantitative like won-loss records or championships in sports. Though there's good and bad, there's is still some element of beauty is in the eye of the beholder. The person who says this is the best performance ever of this work should bear in mind that this symphony has been recorded by almost every major conductor and major orchestra since the invention of the record player.
that adagio lamentoso is heart- rending and just an astonishing piece of music
Bravo! Hanna chang. The orchestra is full of energy.
43:00 most nervous moment of trombone 😨
The best representation of the third movement I think I've ever seen. Too bad some applause breaks the magic with the final movement.
i love the conductor. She is very dramatic and knows every note of
Marvelous composition. She is truly a leading conductor as a master artist
Should direct to motivate and inspire the musicians. Superb!!!
A very talent and skillful orchestra
A love between master and artist.
Artist and Conductor have tremendous
Energy and stamina! The last drop of juice! Bravo!
@@andrewgary8915 Completely agree with you. She can be the model of all emerging conductors.
pfft, i would've applauded too. that was amazing. fuk the decorum. lol
Brilliant performance. Deeply touching to my heart.
She is known as a genius who has won at the age of eleven the first prize at Rostropovitch's Competition. Dedication to music is astonishing. A true musician.
her debut album is conducted by rostropovich. that tells us how much rostropovich valued her talent
What a fantastic conductor and orchestra! But also the video editor has got to be recognized. For the first time as a viewer of classical performance videos, I am allowed to see the ENTIRE orchestra for not just momentary glimpses, but long enough to allow the magnificence of all these highly talented people working together to sink in. Congratulations on not cutting every 5 seconds just for the sake of creating action realizing that the orchestra is the action.
Brilliant orchestra and conductor.
Good on you Hanna, brilliant performance on a brilliant symphony. Made my day.
She is amazing
It's like Bernstein and Solti together. Love her gestual language.
Musica meravigliosa senza tempo.
Самая лучшая симфония....the most great symphony
By far one of the best Tchaikovsky I have ever heard :)
She killed the last movement
From IkSan they made my ear I love classic because of her performance
You can hear the devestation in the last movment
저 순간을 한공간에서 함께했다는것이 너무 자랑스러워요~~~!!!
저두요 ㅎㅎ
태초에 빛이 있었다.소리는 열.전기.자기.에너지와 더불어 빛이다.태초에 음악이 있었다.
케플러가 그랬죠. 지구는 FAMINE 이라고....
음악판 성경의 첫 구절인가요...?
Unbelievable!
참 좋습니다(very good)!
Great Performance. Thank You All~!!!!
Very good! Some details were superb! I found the brass and percussion outstanding. Bit unfortunate applause. I am always a bit scared hoping the audience doesn't applaud at the end of the molto vivace. One loses the stark emotional impact of the the adagio lamentoso. It is like applauding after an orgasm lol.
Han-Na Chang does not orchestrate, does not conduct an orchestra - she IS the music !
Isn't the opening bassoon line of this symphony very similar to the famous horn solo in the 5th?
Wow.......
Slava would be so proud!
3악장 후 박수 미안해요. 마에스트라...장한나! 멋져요...
미안할 거 없어요. 박수를 치고 싶게 만들 정도로 박진감 넘치는 작곡, 연주인걸요.
As I mentioned at another video of the 6th, there is an old tradition from 19th century to applaude after the 3rd mvt. INSTEAD of the 4th in this symphony, considering the last one as a 'Requiem', and it's not opportune to applaude after sacred music.
It comes from the slightly exaggerating time of heroes adoration of genius...
36:06 "Big Bird, don't you remember we told you, Mr Hooper died. He's dead."
I personaly prefer her 5th symphony as it is too much emotional and too much subjective.But at least better than Karajan, Bernstein, Solti and etc. But now one year later I find it wonderful as my constructing loudspeaker improved..
…………She is so „sweet“…………
I can compare Maestro Chang with Myung-Whun Chung.
I think she spends too much energy...
Too much energy? Do you mean women shouldn’t be seen directing an orchestra on stage? Too much energy compared to what? Someone reading a book?
@@profpf who talked about women? are you stupid? or you don't understand English?
What a waste of her talent, the orchestra didn't seem to follow........
As a cellist, she was one of the best.
Origins of music unevidenced. Except it is gift to humanity from God the Creator. Music continues in heaven. Discontinues in hell.
Jesus Christ died and resurrected for remissions of everybody's pre-existing sins to save from eternal hell. Penalty of sin already paid by Jesus Christ on The Cross. Accept HIM. Be saved from eternal hell. Enter heaven. Enjoy heavenly music. For free.
지휘자 안보는 것 같은데...
그런 지휘자를 뭐하러 돈줘서 고용하고, 재계약까지 하겠어요?
엄청 잘 봅니다.