Is CollX an App worth getting?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 дек 2024

Комментарии • 133

  • @katg6325
    @katg6325 Год назад +18

    The directions tell you to put the card on a dark background to scan it. If you wait for the scan to finish instead of going to the downloading page, you'll receive a price.

  • @gracethegrace390
    @gracethegrace390 Год назад +32

    I'm calling user error, you have to be a little bit smarter than what you're trying to do, you need to lay the card on a dark flat surface, make sure your cameras focused and you're good, look at the thousands and thousands of cards that are uploaded to this app, it works

    • @Celtics10
      @Celtics10 5 месяцев назад +4

      This comment helped me more than the video

    • @kens7432
      @kens7432 4 месяца назад +1

      Still garbage! NEVER ACCURATE

  • @Jonny-x8j
    @Jonny-x8j Год назад +6

    I like the app I’ve been using it for months I am a collector but when I buy sometimes it’s hundreds of cards at a time just to get a couple that I actually want the rest I sell or trade this is perfect for that

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад +1

      I made this video back in the Spring, but I may do a follow-up video and make another attempt at it.

  • @themicdfiles1865
    @themicdfiles1865 Год назад +3

    I lay the cards on black felt background, use my studio lights, hold the phone directly over the top of the card and have had zero issues. If I have had an unrecognized card it's usually my fault from moving my hand. I re-snap it and it picks it up just fine. I think that by holding the cards in the air you're picking up background stuff that is throwing off the reader. In the app description I believe it says to photograph your cards against a black background. I've been using this for a couple months while I'm going through my tubs of cards from back in the day. It's slow going. I forgot how many sports cards I have. This will take me a year if I put in 8 hour days and I'm not that patient. My concern is their valuation on certain cards, so sometimes I have to do some crosss-referencing. give it another go with the black background, good lighting, and as close to a straight shot as you can get. I'll bet you'll be surprised.

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад +1

      Yea, I made that video almost 6 months ago. I had no idea what I was doing. Live and learn.

  • @scuba130
    @scuba130 Год назад +7

    This was all user error, you had the settings wrong also holding the card was wrong

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад

      Yep, I've heard that quite a bit from all the comments. I'm a moron 90% of the time. Haha
      I'll have to give it another try. Thanks for checking out the vlog. 👍

  • @gatekeepermarine
    @gatekeepermarine Год назад +4

    The app works better if you lay the card on a flat surface to scan the card. There is also an option at the bottom to scan front only or front and back. It's normally good at recognizing the card but not always the set, for example topps vs topps tiffany. Some cards I had to scan front and back to recognize. There is an option you can set for graded cards. However, I haven't tried to scan any with the app. Hope this helps.

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад

      Thank you so much. I may give that a try. Did you see the other comment that was left? They mention that Android phones may not work as well as an iPhone. Are you using an iPhone?

    • @gatekeepermarine
      @gatekeepermarine Год назад +1

      @@HomerunBaker21 I'm using android.

    • @nunya8866
      @nunya8866 Год назад +1

      I scanned 366 cards the other day before I deleted my account (I already had over 10,000 in there) and it didn't recognize not one single card. Worthless app -5 stars I give it.

    • @aznation4592
      @aznation4592 10 месяцев назад

      I laid the card down and still didn’t recognize

    • @nunya8866
      @nunya8866 10 месяцев назад

      @@aznation4592 Back away from it some and try. Still to many glitches coming up for me to join.

  • @chuckanois1301
    @chuckanois1301 Год назад +3

    I mean, it’s not an app designed for grading.
    Just downloaded the other day and I’m like the app for running numerous cards through and see which ones pop up with a bit of value, let’s say… Over $0.50?
    Some people like the numbers as well as the thrill of collecting. For
    Me however, I buy at random and don’t fully know what I have. Years down the road, I have no idea what I actually have, so I run thru the cards fast with the app and see which ones pop with a value.
    It doesn’t differ well between base rookies and let’s say prizm rookies though and that can be a huge issue.

  • @jo1olo694
    @jo1olo694 Год назад +9

    i scanned a bunch of cards the value of them pretty high according to this app but then i look them up on ebay and theyre worthless...

    • @ScrapforJesus
      @ScrapforJesus Год назад +4

      All the time. That’s why I quit using the app

    • @GetSum01
      @GetSum01 6 месяцев назад

      😂😂😂

    • @GetSum01
      @GetSum01 6 месяцев назад

      It's a Collector App

    • @kens7432
      @kens7432 4 месяца назад +1

      Garbage app never scans correct even when on a dark surface and focused, it is color blind never gets the shit right

  • @billgarcia8460
    @billgarcia8460 Год назад +4

    You were taking front and back of card but your setting was on front only. Change the setting to front and back, then give it another try

  • @dman38
    @dman38 9 месяцев назад +2

    A year later, this still happens. Not a fan of that app at all. And the pricing it gives you when it DOES find your card is usually WAAY off.

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  9 месяцев назад

      I agree completely, but everyone hates on my simple review.

    • @dman38
      @dman38 9 месяцев назад

      @@HomerunBaker21 nature of the internet. Keep doing what you do.

    • @kennethmanning1821
      @kennethmanning1821 3 месяца назад

      I don't like it cards I was aware of the price range. This app is way off

  • @steve219big
    @steve219big 8 месяцев назад +2

    I could not find a price for using the app. Is it a free app ?

  • @bonniecrawford9573
    @bonniecrawford9573 Год назад +1

    before you flip to next screen where it says cannot recognize card leave it on first screen till it does then go to next screen!

    • @bonniecrawford9573
      @bonniecrawford9573 Год назад

      it really is a good app just got to give it time to finish scanning!

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад

      I get it, but most are missing my point. I've been collecting since the 70's. I probably have over 50 million cards. I don't have that kind of time. Haha

  • @JulioCarrillo-wc7to
    @JulioCarrillo-wc7to Год назад

    You may want to read the directions prior to utilizing the app.
    Works great. I usually scan the front.
    Lay flat what you want to scan, unless your a secret agent and you don’t have time.
    Read the directions and try it one more time.
    Or go get your 8 year old nephew and have him show you. Good luck!

  • @kevinbraswell8980
    @kevinbraswell8980 Год назад

    Just started using the app today and it works fine for me it's lay the car down on a flat surface and just take your time and scan it the app is awesome and it recognized every single one of them now I'll go and match the prices to eBay and see how correct it is but the scanning is 100 for me

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад

      I made this video back in the Spring and haven't really tried out the app since. I guess I'm old school and don't collect to see the price of how much a card is worth, but more for the cool accomplishments the player may have contributed to baseball.

  • @ernieb820
    @ernieb820 Год назад +1

    The app doesnt like to scan chrome cards and doesnt recognize autographs unless its issued that way

  • @Schwarzgeist89
    @Schwarzgeist89 5 месяцев назад +1

    This work for Pokemon cards?

  • @britt3272
    @britt3272 Год назад

    Plus you were taking the pics wrong if it said you're uploading two cards. One for the front and a different card for the back. Your settings are on front only. I use this app and I absolutely love it. The only thing I don't love about it is that I can't do my massive Garbage Pail Kids card collection on the app. That's it.

  • @kevinwalker5596
    @kevinwalker5596 Год назад +15

    USER ERROR, lay it down

  • @Wopi-qw7dv
    @Wopi-qw7dv 8 месяцев назад

    User error if he does front and back he needs to click the front and back button

  • @user-Vida-Locust
    @user-Vida-Locust 6 месяцев назад

    If I have 100 sports cards how much should sale all of them. 1 cent each?

  • @_JohnJohn_
    @_JohnJohn_ Год назад

    App works well, but may have to vary your search a bit.

  • @barryr8275
    @barryr8275 Год назад +1

    Hi again - Just a quick question: Do you have Android or an I phone? I also tried to do some scans on my Android phone. It seems that this App hasn't gotten Android phones to work that well with their system. They say that the App works find on I phones, but not YET on Android Phones. Have a really good day. Barry

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад +1

      Hi Barry. Yea, it's an Android. That's super useful information that would have been nice if they mentioned that in Google Play. Hopefully they can set it up with Android. When they do, I'm happy to give it another try. It is a cool idea and I would love for it to work properly. My only concern is the "actual" value of a card. A scan isn't as accurate as human eyes, or PSA would use it to grade their card inventory.

  • @MrJewishfox
    @MrJewishfox Год назад

    Question I have If I'm looking to sell at a convention or a card show And i'd like this might help me set my prices

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад +1

      Well, to be honest, I'm not an expert on how this App works. I tried it out and wasn't too impressed. It's probably great for cataloging your cards, but as far as prices, that's up in the air.

    • @MrJewishfox
      @MrJewishfox Год назад

      @@HomerunBaker21 Figured as much it seems like pricing as the hardest thing Collectors I mean do you just throw it on eBay and let people go bit crazy over Do you know how to set up a base price you should let people I have very little experience I'm always willing to learn From others

    • @ACertifiedhoodclassic
      @ACertifiedhoodclassic Год назад

      ​@mib921 from what I've seen, it tells you if it is based on last sale or not. It shows you the last known sales in ebay and other databases, and calculates and adverage if it's a commonly sold card or a last sale if the sales before that exceed a certain time period. It isn't up in the air, it's based off recent online sales, and if it's up in the air, that's because one happened to sell for that high of a price to cause collx to think its worth more. I mean, if It sold for that, then it sold for that! What I'd do is when a card scans and tells me I have a good hit, I'd go into those records on the app to proof check the prices. Most of the time, it's because it was the first one listed in a long time that they sell for so much. I think it's a pretty good app, as long as you're carefull in checking the legitimately of those prices.

  • @TomWagemaker
    @TomWagemaker 4 месяца назад

    You have to be in a very well lit room and no glare. I use Collectibles, and the same thing happens.

  • @brittanykipple5588
    @brittanykipple5588 11 месяцев назад

    If your scanning front and back need to click the button. Wait for price

  • @thomasphantom7270
    @thomasphantom7270 Год назад +3

    Should of figured out the app first. Not show your mistakes. And down grade it. Works great. Comparable to eBay prices

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад

      But isn't that what life is about anyway? Learning from mistakes? I'm not afraid to show my mistakes at all.

  • @kfrazman1
    @kfrazman1 Год назад

    it actually works great! Operator headspace and timing issue.

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад

      Yea, I made that video almost 6 months ago. I had no idea what I was doing. Live and learn.

  • @kerriemoore3052
    @kerriemoore3052 Год назад

    it most likely didnt scan bc its covered. I have scsnned 3,500 cards. if they are in a sleeve or glare etc. thats the reason

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад

      Yea, I made that video almost 6 months ago. I had no idea what I was doing. Live and learn.

  • @williamcoburn3574
    @williamcoburn3574 Год назад

    Are the pics not going through because of your fingers in the pic?

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад

      Not too sure. I made that vlog back in the Spring as a joke and haven't watched it since. It's definitely gotten a lot of people mad though. Haha

  • @mattmorgan2534
    @mattmorgan2534 3 месяца назад

    No brother. Most sports card collectors collected when they were kids for the fun and love of it. But when we become older, we are very concerned with what the price of those cards have become.

  • @packerpf
    @packerpf 2 месяца назад

    Lol this app works amazing this was 100% user error.

  • @jamieprystupa9642
    @jamieprystupa9642 Год назад

    Lay it on a flat blank surface not holding it in your hand !

  • @eliascruz9757
    @eliascruz9757 Год назад +1

    You have to put the card on a flat platform.. with no flash glare you can not use you hand to hold the card . It works only one photo no need to photo the back

  • @FeliciaJordan-h9u
    @FeliciaJordan-h9u 11 месяцев назад

    I'm with the shouldn't call bull shit until u have actually taken a pic of the card In the SQUARE provided like scanning a credit card or check .. come on really... I have scanned lots of mine and it worked fine. Of course there were some they couldn't find but that's standard with anything

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  11 месяцев назад

      I don't care, to be honest. I filmed this a year ago. I just wanted to stir the pot at the time. The whole idea is not about scanning it to find a price, it's about the joy of collecting and NO app is going to replace that, regardless of how cool and easy it is. Thanks for watching though. 😉

  • @DarinsCards
    @DarinsCards Год назад +5

    You should delete this video, you are doing a disservice to the man who is trying to build this app and sell it.

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад

      Why? This was only my opinion. We're all entitled to our own opinions. In fact, most all the comments are making suggestions on what I was doing wrong.

  • @AppalachianAdventures8556
    @AppalachianAdventures8556 7 месяцев назад

    Although I don’t agree with how you tried to show your audience how to scan a card, lol. You tried. Lay the card on a flat surface before you scan it. ALT, Whatnot, are better apps….

  • @edwardzimmerman2338
    @edwardzimmerman2338 7 месяцев назад

    Well first of all u were taking pictures of front n back on the mode of just front. You should have switched the option to front n back n then it would have found ur cards 😂. I'm on the app been using it pretty hard every day but it does over price the cards by fare from ebay . I have Reggie white from the eagles n price is almost 900 vs. Ebay at $2-3 bucks raw😂. Opppsssss

  • @brandon_AAinc
    @brandon_AAinc 9 месяцев назад

    Yeah, could u re-do your video please?
    I would follow a new review of the app from you because you seem to be a smart guy with some knowledge of trading cards.
    Next time just follow the guideline’s. For every 10 cards I scan 8 are found. I’ve found that some refractors have a harder time being found in the system
    Anyways.. happy hunting guys.!

  • @davidclem1722
    @davidclem1722 7 месяцев назад

    I can tell you how it works common sense would be to lay the card on a flat surface ive scanned thousands of cards doing it the way your supposed to do itm

  • @aubreyleake7052
    @aubreyleake7052 Год назад

    On front only mode the whole video

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад

      Yea, I made that video almost 6 months ago. I had no idea what I was doing. Live and learn.

  • @metalshredder4life817
    @metalshredder4life817 Год назад +2

    The App is junk. All the prices are highly inaccurate and it doesnt like to recognize any cards with chrome or foil or refractor/prizm cards at all. Those are just the 3 biggest issues with it. Another issue it has is that it misleads ignorant new collectors or people that find a collection at a yard sale thinking they can turn a profit and they all post boxes of junk wax and ask for $3500 after wasting hours or days of thier time soiling themselves everytime CollX gives them an inaccurate price. And when you explain that Collx is junk and how to use ebay search they get offended and think you're the stupid one or that you are trying to swindle them when you say thier box of junk is sadly only worth $50-$100 if you can even find a buyer.
    The app should be deleted until they choose to turn it into a reall selling app that can base values off sales from the actual app instead of trying to steal the wrong info off of ebay. But cards dont sell on Collx either so it will probably never be useful in that sense either.
    But if you want a picture catalog of your collection and just ignore the value part it's a great app. But what's the point in that when you own the cards and can look at them when you want to.

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад

      My thoughts exactly. I've been collecting for 50 years. Never needed an app before to determine what the value is, or what my cards look like. For 20 years, I used to use an Excel Spreadsheet to catalog my boxes and some specific player's cards, but then it got to be too much. Bottom line, if you're a perfectionist or have OCD, you don't need an app. Haha

    • @jusblazzinshabazz6794
      @jusblazzinshabazz6794 Год назад

      ​I know absolutely 💯 nothing about baseball cards but I work in NYC as a doorman and a porter for over 25yrs.
      On a move out about 11yrs ago I acquired about 300 different baseball cards .
      How do I tell if they are of any value???

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад

      @@jusblazzinshabazz6794 that's the million dollar question. Prices go up and down as much as the stock market. If they are preserved well, in a box and not rubber band or loose and flying around, they could be worth at least something if the corners aren't all bent up. If they're in card sleeves, in a binder, you're doing good. Look at the back of the card and find the year and the maker of the card, near the bottom of the card. Then go to eBay and type in the year, player, and card maker. Look up the card starting at the lowest price. That should give you an idea on how much it COULD be worth. If you have over 300+ cards, it could be awhile. Being in NY, you'll do better with Derek Jeter cards than you would with Paul O'Neill cards, no offense to Paul.
      Hope that helps.

  • @dagobertohernandezsalas1734
    @dagobertohernandezsalas1734 Год назад

    sometimes the card don't have

  • @user-oy8be1lx8w
    @user-oy8be1lx8w 6 месяцев назад

    This dude made me lol. No clue how to use it. I don’t even have a graded card and I could figure out the rectangle with the line at the top was for graded cards. This guy is making money off people clowning him. 🤣

  • @jrod9560
    @jrod9560 7 месяцев назад

    The app doesnt recognize anything thats not base lmao..

  • @bobgrayanythingoutdoors4819
    @bobgrayanythingoutdoors4819 Год назад

    You are trying to compare collx prices with a card listing on ebay that hasnt sold. Someone had it listed for 12 that doesnt mean its what its worth. Your logic is all wrong. Your going to mislead people becauase u dont know what your talking about. U need to find a few cards that have already sold and get an average.

  • @pena.CP7
    @pena.CP7 10 месяцев назад

    Center stage

  • @bosshawk36
    @bosshawk36 Год назад

    Want to know-no clue scan & learn!! It’s great

  • @pena.CP7
    @pena.CP7 10 месяцев назад

    Rookie,, I swear… smh 🤦🏻‍♂️

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  10 месяцев назад

      Made this video a year ago and haven't bothered to make an update. Mainly because I LOVE all these comments blasting me. Thanks for the click and view though. 😉

  • @minimorgz3876
    @minimorgz3876 4 месяца назад

    You can't be holding the cards. It needs to be framed in without other objects in photo. User needs to do more research into how to use an app before making judgement.

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  4 месяца назад

      @@minimorgz3876 there was no research needed. I just gave my opinion a week after the app was released....well over a year ago. But it isn't based on the app, as it's more of an observation of how the hobby has gone away from collecting for fun and moved into the dollar value of it. I appreciate the input.

  • @dagobertohernandezsalas1734
    @dagobertohernandezsalas1734 Год назад

    I know how to work

  • @edgarb2364
    @edgarb2364 7 месяцев назад

    I think you to old to use the app it look like you trying to find too many issue on the app’ if you don’t like it don’t used that simple

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  7 месяцев назад

      Thank you for your deep dive into my app usage. I appreciate it. 😉

  • @TheGreenGorman
    @TheGreenGorman 4 месяца назад

    This app doesn't work in Australia therefore it doesn't exist🎉 in my eyes anyway

  • @ChadForquer
    @ChadForquer Месяц назад

    Going into a review with your mind made up before you even download an app is a very bad look.

  • @matthewsteeno5861
    @matthewsteeno5861 11 месяцев назад +1

    This guy is horrible

  • @hunterdublin1929
    @hunterdublin1929 4 месяца назад

    skill issue lol

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  4 месяца назад

      @@hunterdublin1929 I never said I was the smartest guy, but I am the nicest. Thanks for watching. 😉

  • @David-fv7zg
    @David-fv7zg 11 месяцев назад

    You should have actually used this service before making a video. Seriously.

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  11 месяцев назад

      I made it on a whim a year ago. I also went in with a preconceived notion that people collecting for monetary reasons was ridiculous. Collect for the fun of collecting, not to see how much something. Who cares how much it is? I have cards I love from the 50's that are barely worth $25. (I used to categorize all my cards in an Excel spreadsheet. Talk about time consuming, but just as enjoyable)

    • @David-fv7zg
      @David-fv7zg 11 месяцев назад

      @@HomerunBaker21 I guess thats why your channel is exploding with subscribers...I guess you have a right to your opinion, not matter how wrong it is.

  • @jamesleatherwood2293
    @jamesleatherwood2293 Год назад +2

    Junk App Good for Nothing!

    • @AandarksHobbies
      @AandarksHobbies Год назад

      App worked just fine for me… lay the card in a dark surface. The guy who made this video didn’t bother to read the instructions that were given by the app itself.

  • @AprilJohnson-cook
    @AprilJohnson-cook Год назад

    Your a truck dude. Learn how to upload a photo before you try to degrade the app.

  • @stephenconnell3645
    @stephenconnell3645 Год назад +3

    Try reading the directions brain surgeon do you work for PSA I think it's great PSA be out of business soon thank God

    • @HomerunBaker21
      @HomerunBaker21  Год назад

      Thanks! You made me laugh. Brain surgeons technically deal with neurosurgery, which uses a different part of the brain than that of someone winging it on a baseball card app. (Read some of the other comments. You'll get a jist of the error that was made) 😁