When a supremely trained classical maestro like Dr. Ajay admitted Kishore Kumar as his GURU who was not trained classical music (Kishore), we have to believe how talented Kishore Kumar was
Pt. Ajay Chakraborty never admitted that Kishore Kumar was his Guru, what he says is to pay regards to the popular and senior singer, I heard both of them and the 'Loy and nodes' which are used by Pt Ajay Chakraborty touched the soul. This was the reason of my comment.
শ্রদ্ধেয় অজয় বাবু আপনাকে আমার অন্তরের বিনম্র শ্রদ্ধা জানাই। এই ধরনের অনুষ্ঠানে আপনার মতো একজন মহান শিল্পীর হিন্দি ছবির অতি জনপ্রিয় সংগীত পরিবেশনে ও শ্রবনে আমরা অত্যন্ত আনন্দিত ও গর্বিত হলাম।
The stature of Kishore Kumar is that singer like Kishore Kumar comes once in one thousand years. He was the ever best versatile singer in India. Until the music & songs remain in India, the name of Kishore Kumar will remain in India. Let us salute 🙏 Kishore Kumar.
আমাদের জেলার আর সারা বাংলার গর্ব পণ্ডিত অজয় চক্রবর্তী। আজ থেকে প্রায় ৩৮ বছর আগে চুঁচুড়া স্টেশন চত্বরে একটা তানপুরা নিয়ে udhoktader জন্য। কি সিম্প্লিসিটি। আমাকে জিজ্ঞেস করলেন আচ্ছা ভাই চুঁচুড়া রবিদ্র bhawan টা কতো দুর? আজও মনে আছে। গল্পঃ নয় এটা sathi ।
The great maestro Pandit Bhimsen Joshi once jokingly said.. good that Kishore Kumar didn't learn classical music or else the likes of him and other classical singers would have become jobless... A great tribute to Kishore da!!
Kishorda ki range pata chalati hai, itne bade classical singer ko sun ke pata chalta hai ki itana classical based song kishorda ne kitna madhur, khubasurat aur aasan tarike se ga diya... Hats off to my legendary singer Kishoreda
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice. I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Yeh rohit hai na. yeh pandit ji ke pass gana seekhne gaya tha.Isko laath maarke bhaga diya unhone isliye yeh har jagah same comment copy, paste kar raha hai pagal sale.😆😆
Beautifully sung in a Ghazal andaaz.I enjoyed it. What a mesmerising lyrics by Gulzar sahab. A great tribute to Hemant & kishore da. Thanks for sharing!!
Level বলতে quality বোঝাতে চেয়েছি, গানের কথা, সুর এইসব। সবচেয়ে প্রধান যে ব্যাপারটা ছিল সেটা হল.. একজন শিল্পী আর এক জন শিল্পীর specialty ভালোভাবে বুঝতেন, মানতেন এবং তাকে গুরুত্ব দিয়ে সেভাবে কাজেও লাগাতেন সেই speciality... অর্থাৎ ওনাদের মানসিকতা খুব উঁচু দরের ছিল... তাই ওনারা বলতে পারতেন.. এই গান আমাকে দিয়ে নয় অন্য শিল্পীর নাম উল্লেখ করে বলতেন, ওর কন্ঠে ভালো লাগবে.. ওনাকে দিয়ে গাওয়ান। যাইহোক বেশি ব্যাখ্যা করতে হলে অনেক লম্বা হয়ে যাবে... আশা করা যায় বোঝাতে পেরেছি....
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice. I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
@@Rohit-oj5dv the truth is listening to shastriya sangeet requires sadhana.. everybody cannot appreciate classical music without some sadhana.. because people like you whose perception of mind is in the gross level of sounds will never get the immense depth and bliss of the classical style of music.. but whose mind is a little elevated has noticed that how panditji evoked the wonderful spirit of yaman kalyan raga through this cover which kishoreda never could have done will surely appreciate panditiji's exposition...
@@ds86496 Some people like the final product. Cant blame them. Imagine, if one is able to analyze at 0,5 speed the technicalities of a Tendulkar straight drive, then one can assess the nitty-gritties of how the ball was pitched, how Tendulkar responded in terms of foot work, stroke ,and follow through. The public in general is content watching the shot as it is made!
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice. I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Yeh rohit hai na. yeh pandit ji ke pass gana seekhne gaya tha.Isko laath maarke bhaga diya unhone isliye yeh har jagah same comment copy, paste kar raha hai pagal sale.😆😆
@@Rohit-oj5dv he is just showing the use of Kalyan raag in the song... 😅Hatsoff to u...u expect Ajay ji ko sing like kishor da?man these pandits and ustads are different...the keep experimenting they r an institute with vast knowledge...they go deep and use raga techniques in every song, basically they r trainers..
@@biprojitchoudhury6285 accepted bro. But all said n done, I feel he shudn't hv attempted this song, the magic cn never b recreated. He cn sing his own songs n experiment. Pl spare Kushorekumar, the ultimate legend.
When we listen to this rendering we all the more realize the greatness of Kishore da. When the Almighty blesses you, grammar and technicalities appear so trivial !!
When a classical Pandit like Dr. Ajay admits Kishoreda (not a classical learned singer) as his GURU...just think the stature of Kishoreda as a singer....needless to say anything
Kishoreda was not classically trained...doesnt mean that he did not learn it at all...it is just that he was not formally under a well known guru..thats it..else, he understood it and could deliver it through his songs very well..
@@ninadchoudhury3362 no When Kishore Kumar born at that time his voice was not soo good but Later One miraculous incident happened that made his voice completely changed to a heavenly voice .Dadamoni or Ashok Kumar told the story.
I am an amateur in music. But I have avidly followed Late Hemant Mukherjee’s works since my late mother was his avid fan. Could hum also songs of Nagin since 3-years of age...and onto Khamoshi. Hearing the maestro and scholar Panditji saying kind words about his skill in composition, I thought I will add a few humble words. Once my son presented a piece of Hemant Kumar’s song as a final thesis of his learning music as a subject, the musicians were keen to study him. The opinion overall was overwhelming with one saying:” He is a genius. How well in 2-3 notes he changes the mood of the composition”. He was not considered as a full some musician being commercially successful over say legendary Salil Chowdhury. Yet the genius lies forgotten among many of the new generation.
I know nothing of the 'Grammar' of music. All I know is the serenity, tranquility and simplicity in Hemanta Da's songs draws me in - makes me want to immerse myself in them. Be it Woh Shaam Kuchh Ajeeb Thi or Ye Nayan Dare Dare and so many others.
Pandit Ji is indeed a legend! 🙏🏻Kishore da is above & beyond of any grammar of music! Immediately listen to the original version and you will realize that there is no one in the universe who can do justice to this song.
@@dr.alokranjankhatua9908 With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice. I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice. I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Applies to EVERY Kishore Kumar's karaoke track available.....and every song sung by every singer.....listen to the original back to back and doodh-kaa-doodh-paanii-kaa-paanii
I belong to the present generation. My father being a fan of great Kishore Kumar and king of romance Rajesh Khanna, often listens to these mesmerizing songs of this pair. I am least hesitant to say here that I too have become fond of this song.
তাই নাকি! একটু জানতে পারি আপনার সঙ্গীত যোগ্যতা কতদূর? বা আদৌ আছে কিনা! একজন পন্ডিতজিকে জাজ করছেন মশাই। উনি কি করলেন আর কেন সেটা বোঝার ক্ষমতা থাকা চাই অবশ্য।
Creativity ka start grammar se ho sakta hai ... Lekin wo dhire dhire sabhi grammars ke pare chala jaata hai ... Jai Kishore da ... Is gaane me aap jo feel daal ke gae hai ... wo direct dil ko chhuta hai ... is gaane ka srijan kerne wala sabhi kalakaro ko dil ki gehraiyon so dhanyawad deta hun
Koi shaqye ? No two minds. With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice. I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Such an erudite singer should not have carried out this costly experiment. Hemanta Mukherjee was the composer and Kishore Kumar was the singer. It is unfortunate.
Wonderful voice and great singing of legendary Kishore Kumarji with Hemant Kumar's melody Composition will remain in heart forever, no extra unnecessary ornaments are needed here.....
হেমন্ত মুখোপাধ্যায় পন্ডিতের পন্ডিত সরস্বতী মায়ের বরপুত্র কিন্তু পন্ডিত অজয় চক্রবর্তী হল এক অহংকারী ব্যাক্তি যিনি নিজেকে শ্রেষ্ঠত্ব প্রমাণ করতে বিভিন্ন পন্থা অবলম্বন করে থাকেন এমন কি হেমন্ত মুখোপাধ্যায় মান্না দে কে ছোট করতে একটুও ভাবেন না
@@sailenmajumdar6668 With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice. I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
@@sailenmajumdar6668 মশাই আপনি পন্ডিত অজয় চক্রবর্তীর চরিত্র বিশ্লেষণ করছেন।কে বললো আপনাকে উনি অহঙ্কারী।নিয়মিত ওঠাবসা করে থাকেন ওনার সাথে মনে হচ্ছে।উনি হেমন্তবাবুকে ছোট করেননি।প্রশংসাই করেছেন।উনি বলতে চেয়েছেন বিশেষ কিছু না শিখেও যে এতো ভালো সুরকার হওয়া যায় এরকম আগে এদেশে জন্মায়নি।অবশ্য আপনার ছোট মস্তিষ্কে ঢুকবে না এসব। আগে ওনার সমকক্ষ হোন,তারপর নাহয় এসব মানাবে আপনার মুখে তার আগে নয়।তাই উনি আজ স্বনামধন্য পৃথিবী বিখ্যাত পন্ডিত আর আপনি হরিদাস পাল।😅😅
Just shows, despite whatever embellishment you add to such songs in versions that express the nuances of the raaga, the simplicity, feel and depth of the original composition by maestros like Hemanta da and voiced by Kishore da can never be further excelled upon. This is why pure classical has its own place, as does filmi compositions - theirs. :) We are fortunate to have such legends in both fields who have made life better for us and are continuing to do so :) God bless them!
Pandit Ajay Chakroborty is one of the best and well known classical singer and he has added so much to the song. Kishore da used selected few techniques so well that it always felt complete in its own way. It is great to listen this very different rendition.
संगीत के उत्कृष्ट साधक पंडित अजय चक्रवर्ती दादा को सादर प्रणाम...... आपकी कला की समीक्षा शब्दों से करना संभव ही नहीं, अनुभूति को शब्द देना कठिन हो रहा, सभी शब्दकोश कम परे.......
অজয়বাবু আপনি ভুলে যাচ্ছেন যে আপনি জাস্ট গান করেন কিন্তু কিশোরকুমার আমাদের একটা আবেগের নাম। সারা পৃথিবীতে কোটি কোটি মানুষ তার গান শুনে ঘুমোতে যান। আপনি তার ধারেকাছেও নন।
Any day With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice. I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Yeh rohit hai na. yeh pandit ji ke pass gana seekhne gaya tha.Isko laath maarke bhaga diya unhone isliye yeh har jagah same comment copy, paste kar raha hai pagal sale.😆😆
Even though my favourite singer is Rafi Sahab, but this song is in my top favourite list which i can listen on loop. Hats off to the genius Kishore Da.
Salutes Sir ! kya baat hai !! Romance, mellowness, mood, melody, expression, pitch, modulation, classicism ....you have put everything in this six magical minutes of a song!! man kar raha hai keh du...Pandit ji once more. Great artistes can not and should not be compared. A play back singer may rule recording studios but conventional stage is clearly your terrain.
অদ্ভুত লাগলো একটি বহুশ্রুত মিষ্টি গানকে স্রেফ নিজের পান্ডিত্য ফলানোর যায়গা বানিয়ে নিলেন!!! সমগ্র শ্রোতাকূল কি উনার কাছে এধরনের ক্ল্যারিফিকেশন চেয়েছিলো??? এ কারনেই রাগসঙ্গীতের জগৎ থেকেও উনি বেশ কিছুটা সরে গেছেন। আমি নিজে বেশ কয়েকটি অনুষ্ঠানে শ্রোতা হয়ে শুনেছি কতরকম বন্দিশ আছে একই রাগে এবং সেটা কি কি ভাবে গাওয়া হয় সেটা স্টেজে বসে শেখাচ্ছেন৷ দুনিয়াশুদ্ধ মানুষকে যদি উনি ছাত্র ছাত্রী মনে করেন তো কিছু বলার নেই🙏🙏🙏
Its really the rare-most occasion, Pandit Ajoy Chakraborty singing Kishore Dada's such a beautiful song ...just look at their mutual respect... that's why they are Legends....great information from SriTapan Basu. Thanks for the upload.
I could sense what Tapan ji was saying about. But since I don't understand Such a sweet Bengali, I would request you to translate for us. Please. With Great affection and love from one Marathi- Punekar With immense gratitude!
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice. I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Yeh rohit hai na. yeh pandit ji ke pass gana seekhne gaya tha.Isko laath maarke bhaga diya unhone isliye yeh har jagah same comment copy, paste kar raha hai pagal sale.😆😆
Kadiye dilo ganer line gulo,sotti aisob ganer govirota bojhar jonno akta joggota proyojon chilo,kono bikolpo nei asob ganer r seisob silpider...Osadharon sir Ajay chakraborty...
What a blending of mentaining the raag ras & the original song. Explaining every words expression with different phrases of kalyan. One & only he can. (koti pranaams in his feet)
গান মানেই গলার কালোয়াতি নয়, গান মানে ভাবের সুরেলা প্রকাশ। ভাবটাই আসল।ভাবটা হৃদয়ে থাকে, কিশোর কুমারের গলা শুধু নয় ভাব অনুভবের ও তা প্রকাশের ক্ষমতা এত বেশী ছিল বাকি সমস্ত গায়ক আজও তার কাছে শিশু, যত বড়ই ক্লাসিকাল গায়ক হন না কেন।
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice. I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
A very favorite song of mine... And pandit ji has done some wonderful classical touch in this song... Such talented person he is ...n I'm listening now his version for the 50 th time...n the middle sargam of kalyan...uff...🙏 N kishor kumar, hemanta are my all time favorite... Unparalleled talents. 🙏
Gulzar(writer) Hemant mukharjee(composer) Kishore kumar(singer) This trio had made this song for every living generation. Great song, great writing, great compose.
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice. I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Hemant Kumar is one of the best composer in hindi film industry despite being first class singer what is unparralel in Indian film industry.But his talent has not been judged due to mess doing in industry.
After listening Pandil ji singing immediately listen to the original song sung by Khishore Kumar. There is no match. The starting "Woh shaam" leh delivered by Kishoreda is heart touching & superb.
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice. I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
@@Rohit-oj5dv So Mr. Haridas Pal u r judging Pandit Ajay Chakraborty. Tell me r u musically trained? have u ever learned music? i think u r not becoz u didnt get what he had tried to explain.U moron...first get some knowledge & achieve the lvl of pandit ji then judge him.That's why he is world famous pandit ji & u r Haridas Pal. 😆😆🤣🤣
@@Shubho_Chakraborty Mr.S, as ur name suggests, u must b a stupid. Wat do u knw about me ? Who r u ? Did u notice in the beginning of my post I wrote 'With due respect to Panditji' ? Actually it's pointless to interact with a moron like u. Dude, hv a great life, God bless u.
Sir Pandit Chakrabarty Ji, i am listening to you for the first time in my life, may b am not that blessed. Would like to be very fair here.... first of all there is no comparison possible between Kishore/ Hemant Dadas' master piece, but you did not try at all anywhere to copy the original one... otherwise it would have become Cover Version (Have heard one of by Abhijeet - nice one). You have really sang it very well in your own style without even thinking of the original harkats n all, this make this rendition very beautiful. If someone, who has not listened the original one, listens this version first, that person would go with this rendition forever. Thanks Sir, I will try and follow your other songs definitely. Love you :)
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice. I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
You probably don't know who Pandit Chakraborty is.....He was trying to explain how this song could have been sung based on Raag Kalyan. He also credited Hemant Kumar and Kishore Da for their excellent creation.
First of all take my sata koti Pranam to respected Pandit Ajai Chakraborty. Now I came to know that the original Raga is use for this 💓 melody. With love and regards from Northeast
Wo shaam is such a beautiful song, a masterpiece from the combined efforts of composer the great Hemant Kumar, written by Gulzar and probably the best renderation by Kishore Kumar. Here listen to the song by the maestro Pandit Ajoy Chakrabarti..you will go to another worl mesmarized...
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice. I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Yeh rohit hai na. yeh pandit ji ke pass gana seekhne gaya tha.Isko laath maarke bhaga diya unhone isliye yeh har jagah same comment copy, paste kar raha hai pagal sale.😆😆
When a supremely trained classical maestro like Dr. Ajay admitted Kishore Kumar as his GURU who was not trained classical music (Kishore), we have to believe how talented Kishore Kumar was
Pt. Ajay Chakraborty never admitted that Kishore Kumar was his Guru, what he says is to pay regards to the popular and senior singer, I heard both of them and the 'Loy and nodes' which are used by Pt Ajay Chakraborty touched the soul. This was the reason of my comment.
Listen 1:53 to 1:58 what is said by Pd Ajay Chakraborty.
শ্রদ্ধেয় অজয় বাবু আপনাকে আমার অন্তরের বিনম্র শ্রদ্ধা জানাই।
এই ধরনের অনুষ্ঠানে আপনার মতো একজন মহান শিল্পীর হিন্দি ছবির অতি জনপ্রিয় সংগীত পরিবেশনে ও শ্রবনে আমরা অত্যন্ত আনন্দিত ও গর্বিত হলাম।
The stature of Kishore Kumar is that singer like Kishore Kumar comes once in one thousand years. He was the ever best versatile singer in India. Until the music & songs remain in India, the name of Kishore Kumar will remain in India.
Let us salute 🙏 Kishore Kumar.
Kishor da jaisa singar birle hi paida hote hai
BEAUTIFUL. Voice. PRONAM Janai. THANKS FOR THE POST. MAY.GOD BLESS YOU
And we had d chance to see him, hear him and we continue to hear him…we r so lucky!
We r lucky to have such legends!
আমাদের জেলার আর সারা বাংলার গর্ব পণ্ডিত অজয় চক্রবর্তী। আজ থেকে প্রায় ৩৮ বছর আগে চুঁচুড়া স্টেশন চত্বরে একটা তানপুরা নিয়ে udhoktader জন্য। কি সিম্প্লিসিটি।
আমাকে জিজ্ঞেস করলেন আচ্ছা ভাই চুঁচুড়া রবিদ্র bhawan টা কতো দুর?
আজও মনে আছে।
গল্পঃ নয় এটা sathi ।
The great maestro Pandit Bhimsen Joshi once jokingly said.. good that Kishore Kumar didn't learn classical music or else the likes of him and other classical singers would have become jobless... A great tribute to Kishore da!!
A great tribute to Hemantda, Kishoreda, and Gulzar by respected Panditji.
Kishorda ki range pata chalati hai, itne bade classical singer ko sun ke pata chalta hai ki itana classical based song kishorda ne kitna madhur, khubasurat aur aasan tarike se ga diya... Hats off to my legendary singer Kishoreda
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice.
I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Yeh rohit hai na. yeh pandit ji ke pass gana seekhne gaya tha.Isko laath maarke bhaga diya unhone isliye yeh har jagah same comment copy, paste kar raha hai pagal sale.😆😆
@@Shubho_Chakraborty 😂😂
Beautifully sung in a Ghazal andaaz.I enjoyed it. What a mesmerising lyrics by Gulzar sahab. A great tribute to Hemant & kishore da. Thanks for sharing!!
একদম মনের কথা বলেছেন... তখন ওই level এর গান তৈরি হয়েছিল কারণ ওঁনাদের মনটাও অনেক উঁচু লেভেল এর ছিল। গোল্ডেন সময়ের শিল্পী দের জন্য 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Level!!!!!!mon!!!!!! kichui bojha gelo apnar boktobye..
Level বলতে quality বোঝাতে চেয়েছি, গানের কথা, সুর এইসব। সবচেয়ে প্রধান যে ব্যাপারটা ছিল সেটা হল.. একজন শিল্পী আর এক জন শিল্পীর specialty ভালোভাবে বুঝতেন, মানতেন এবং তাকে গুরুত্ব দিয়ে সেভাবে কাজেও লাগাতেন সেই speciality... অর্থাৎ ওনাদের মানসিকতা খুব উঁচু দরের ছিল... তাই ওনারা বলতে পারতেন.. এই গান আমাকে দিয়ে নয় অন্য শিল্পীর নাম উল্লেখ করে বলতেন, ওর কন্ঠে ভালো লাগবে.. ওনাকে দিয়ে গাওয়ান। যাইহোক বেশি ব্যাখ্যা করতে হলে অনেক লম্বা হয়ে যাবে... আশা করা যায় বোঝাতে পেরেছি....
কিশোর কুমারের তুলনা শুধু কিশোর কুমারের সঙ্গে হতে পারে ! কি বলেন অজয় বাবু !!!!
একদম ঠিক কথা ❤
Kishore's songs are still hummed by even teenagers but others' songs have been faded away with time..Kishore is the only timeless singer
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice.
I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
keu fade kreni.. ekhono lata mangeshkar, md rafi, hemanta mukhopadhyay, shyamal mitra enader gaan o soman bhabe chole...
@@Rohit-oj5dv the truth is listening to shastriya sangeet requires sadhana.. everybody cannot appreciate classical music without some sadhana.. because people like you whose perception of mind is in the gross level of sounds will never get the immense depth and bliss of the classical style of music.. but whose mind is a little elevated has noticed that how panditji evoked the wonderful spirit of yaman kalyan raga through this cover which kishoreda never could have done will surely appreciate panditiji's exposition...
@@ds86496 Some people like the final product. Cant blame them. Imagine, if one is able to analyze at 0,5 speed the technicalities of a Tendulkar straight drive, then one can assess the nitty-gritties of how the ball was pitched, how Tendulkar responded in terms of foot work, stroke ,and follow through. The public in general is content watching the shot as it is made!
@@Rohit-oj5dv p
রাগ আর অনুরাগের পার্থক্য পন্ডিত অজয় চক্রবর্তী সুন্দর ভাবে বুজিয়ে দিলেন।
কুর্নিশ জানাই।
Kishore Kumar is Kishore Kumar. He put such emotion packed voice that nobody can make it so deep and effective.
Classical singer.
Hats off Pandit ji.
আমাদের জেলার,দেশের বাইরে সকলের হৃদয় জয় করা একজন মানুষ।
In gaano ko pandit ajay jaise shakhs hi nibha skte hain 🙏👌
Wonderful Singing Pandit Ajay Ji...... But Kishore Kumar Is Kishore Kumar incomparable ................ Thanks...
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice.
I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Yeh rohit hai na. yeh pandit ji ke pass gana seekhne gaya tha.Isko laath maarke bhaga diya unhone isliye yeh har jagah same comment copy, paste kar raha hai pagal sale.😆😆
@@Rohit-oj5dv he is just showing the use of Kalyan raag in the song... 😅Hatsoff to u...u expect Ajay ji ko sing like kishor da?man these pandits and ustads are different...the keep experimenting they r an institute with vast knowledge...they go deep and use raga techniques in every song, basically they r trainers..
@@biprojitchoudhury6285 accepted bro. But all said n done, I feel he shudn't hv attempted this song, the magic cn never b recreated. He cn sing his own songs n experiment. Pl spare Kushorekumar, the ultimate legend.
Not to compare 2 godly creators with each other. Both r great in their respective places.
When we listen to this rendering we all the more realize the greatness of Kishore da. When the Almighty blesses you, grammar and technicalities appear so trivial !!
बिल्कुल निशब्द करदेने वाली गायक़ी who else can do except Pandit ji aur his legendary daughter Ms. Kaushiki.🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
When a classical Pandit like Dr. Ajay admits Kishoreda (not a classical learned singer) as his GURU...just think the stature of Kishoreda as a singer....needless to say anything
Kishoreda was not classically trained...doesnt mean that he did not learn it at all...it is just that he was not formally under a well known guru..thats it..else, he understood it and could deliver it through his songs very well..
@@shrinivaskulkarni9657 No, he was borne with this talent..he could have grasped any tune and converted them into harmonica
Jaikishorda🙏
@@ninadchoudhury3362 no When Kishore Kumar born at that time his voice was not soo good but Later One miraculous incident happened that made his voice completely changed to a heavenly voice .Dadamoni or Ashok Kumar told the story.
@@chandranibanerjee9074 ঘটনাটা ছিল পায়ের আঙুল কেটে গিয়েছিল।এতো যন্ত্রণা হয়েছিল আর এতো কেঁদেছিল যে গলা পরিষ্কার হয়ে গিয়েছিল।
I am an amateur in music. But I have avidly followed Late Hemant Mukherjee’s works since my late mother was his avid fan. Could hum also songs of Nagin since 3-years of age...and onto Khamoshi. Hearing the maestro and scholar Panditji saying kind words about his skill in composition, I thought I will add a few humble words. Once my son presented a piece of Hemant Kumar’s song as a final thesis of his learning music as a subject, the musicians were keen to study him. The opinion overall was overwhelming with one saying:” He is a genius. How well in 2-3 notes he changes the mood of the composition”. He was not considered as a full some musician being commercially successful over say legendary Salil Chowdhury. Yet the genius lies forgotten among many of the new generation.
Thanks for sharing sir/ma'am🙏 awesome thought.
His rare talent in music composition was eclipsed only by his peerless singing voice! A complete musician of a century!
I know nothing of the 'Grammar' of music. All I know is the serenity, tranquility and simplicity in Hemanta Da's songs draws me in - makes me want to immerse myself in them. Be it Woh Shaam Kuchh Ajeeb Thi or Ye Nayan Dare Dare and so many others.
100% true 👍
You expressed my heart's very vocabulary :)
Yes.... many of us are...we have attached ourselves to such creative music... unknowingly...
really true. kishore da said sangeet dil se aate hai.
Bengal is full of gems . Wah sir bahut sunder. Love from Haryana
Kishore Kumar's "Woh" itself has got so much feel that nobody can match it.
They dont want to hear this truth… pt ji doesn’t have any emotion… really bad
Pandit Ji is indeed a legend! 🙏🏻Kishore da is above & beyond of any grammar of music! Immediately listen to the original version and you will realize that there is no one in the universe who can do justice to this song.
copy to copy is not original, though it seems to be original to us, but some times its need to be justified by wise person like panditji
@@dr.alokranjankhatua9908 With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice.
I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice.
I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Very true...this is applicable to ALL Karaoke Singers who think that they have sung the Kishore song well !!!
Applies to EVERY Kishore Kumar's karaoke track available.....and every song sung by every singer.....listen to the original back to back and doodh-kaa-doodh-paanii-kaa-paanii
Kishore da r Hemonto da odbhut osadharon aar sorboshreshtho juti. Onader akta duet Dustoro Parabar Periye osadharon.
My deep regards to Pandit Dr. Ajay jee whom I regard as one of the best classical singer of India. What a wonderful rendition 🙏🙏
I belong to the present generation. My father being a fan of great Kishore Kumar and king of romance Rajesh Khanna, often listens to these mesmerizing songs of this pair. I am least hesitant to say here that I too have become fond of this song.
He is one of the greatest singers of our time.
শেখা উচিত কি ভাবে একটা অসাধারণ গান কে কিভাবে বারোটা বাজানো যায় ।
তাই নাকি! একটু জানতে পারি আপনার সঙ্গীত যোগ্যতা কতদূর? বা আদৌ আছে কিনা! একজন পন্ডিতজিকে জাজ করছেন মশাই। উনি কি করলেন আর কেন সেটা বোঝার ক্ষমতা থাকা চাই অবশ্য।
Apni toh onek baro pandit😂😂
Kishore da was not talented ,He was the power house of talent.
Creativity ka start grammar se ho sakta hai ... Lekin wo dhire dhire sabhi grammars ke pare chala jaata hai ... Jai Kishore da ... Is gaane me aap jo feel daal ke gae hai ... wo direct dil ko chhuta hai ... is gaane ka srijan kerne wala sabhi kalakaro ko dil ki gehraiyon so dhanyawad deta hun
Keno kishor da god gifted sober golate gan ta sonar por bujte pari ei gan sudhu kishor dar jonno
Koi shaqye ? No two minds.
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice.
I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Such an erudite singer should not have carried out this costly experiment. Hemanta Mukherjee was the composer and Kishore Kumar was the singer. It is unfortunate.
পন্ডিত অজয় চক্রবর্তী কে কুর্নিশ জানাই।
Wonderful voice and great singing of legendary Kishore Kumarji with Hemant Kumar's melody Composition will remain in heart forever, no extra unnecessary ornaments are needed here.....
👌👌
Pandit Ji I melt on this
Hemanta was not pandit..... But he is a legend... We must keep it in mind
হেমন্ত মুখোপাধ্যায় পন্ডিতের পন্ডিত
সরস্বতী মায়ের বরপুত্র
কিন্তু পন্ডিত অজয় চক্রবর্তী হল এক অহংকারী ব্যাক্তি যিনি নিজেকে শ্রেষ্ঠত্ব প্রমাণ করতে বিভিন্ন পন্থা অবলম্বন করে থাকেন এমন কি হেমন্ত মুখোপাধ্যায় মান্না দে কে ছোট করতে একটুও ভাবেন না
@@sailenmajumdar6668 With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice.
I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
@@sailenmajumdar6668 মশাই আপনি পন্ডিত অজয় চক্রবর্তীর চরিত্র বিশ্লেষণ করছেন।কে বললো আপনাকে উনি অহঙ্কারী।নিয়মিত ওঠাবসা করে থাকেন ওনার সাথে মনে হচ্ছে।উনি হেমন্তবাবুকে ছোট করেননি।প্রশংসাই করেছেন।উনি বলতে চেয়েছেন বিশেষ কিছু না শিখেও যে এতো ভালো সুরকার হওয়া যায় এরকম আগে এদেশে জন্মায়নি।অবশ্য আপনার ছোট মস্তিষ্কে ঢুকবে না এসব। আগে ওনার সমকক্ষ হোন,তারপর নাহয় এসব মানাবে আপনার মুখে তার আগে নয়।তাই উনি আজ স্বনামধন্য পৃথিবী বিখ্যাত পন্ডিত আর আপনি হরিদাস পাল।😅😅
@@Shubho_Chakraborty দারুণ বলেছেন।
গুরুজী আপনাকে আমার শ্রদ্ধা আর প্রণাম 🙏🙏 ছাড়া কিছু দেওয়ার নেই। সুস্থ থাকুন, ভালো থাকুন।
How carefully he hits every notes,jaise kisi notes ko chaut na lag jaaye, magician 🙏🙏🙏
Just shows, despite whatever embellishment you add to such songs in versions that express the nuances of the raaga, the simplicity, feel and depth of the original composition by maestros like Hemanta da and voiced by Kishore da can never be further excelled upon.
This is why pure classical has its own place, as does filmi compositions - theirs. :)
We are fortunate to have such legends in both fields who have made life better for us and are continuing to do so :)
God bless them!
Bhimsen joshi in an interview said that if Kishore da ever started to pursue classical singing, all others would have been nowhere close to him.
Pandit Ajay Chakroborty is one of the best and well known classical singer and he has added so much to the song. Kishore da used selected few techniques so well that it always felt complete in its own way. It is great to listen this very different rendition.
Boss, beautiful rendition and aise gaane sun kar Woh Shaam Zaroor Ajeeb Ho Jayega.
Khub bhalo....ki misti
What a divine voice. God's gift to us.
Really great best vocal perfection Pandit Sir jii I had ever heard
Pandit Ji remains highly highly respected, but this song will remain owned by Kishore Da alone. 🙏
संगीत के उत्कृष्ट साधक पंडित अजय चक्रवर्ती दादा को सादर प्रणाम...... आपकी कला की समीक्षा शब्दों से करना संभव ही नहीं, अनुभूति को शब्द देना कठिन हो रहा, सभी शब्दकोश कम परे.......
And the same is true for his daughter, Kaushiki.
অজয়বাবু আপনি ভুলে যাচ্ছেন যে আপনি জাস্ট গান করেন কিন্তু কিশোরকুমার আমাদের একটা আবেগের নাম। সারা পৃথিবীতে কোটি কোটি মানুষ তার গান শুনে ঘুমোতে যান। আপনি তার ধারেকাছেও নন।
Guru ji Pronam Janai. Eto apurbo geyechen, chokhe jol chole aslo.
অসাধারণ, রাগের খেলায় গানটা অন্যরকম লাগলো তবে আমার কাছে কিশোর কুমারের গাওয়া version'টাই এগিয়ে থাকবে।
Any day
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice.
I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Yeh rohit hai na. yeh pandit ji ke pass gana seekhne gaya tha.Isko laath maarke bhaga diya unhone isliye yeh har jagah same comment copy, paste kar raha hai pagal sale.😆😆
রাগের খেলাতে গানটির পিন্ডি চটকানো হলো
प्रणाम ईस गीत और पं अजय चक्रवर्ती जी को
Even though my favourite singer is Rafi Sahab, but this song is in my top favourite list which i can listen on loop. Hats off to the genius Kishore Da.
Salutes Sir ! kya baat hai !! Romance, mellowness, mood, melody, expression, pitch, modulation, classicism ....you have put everything in this six magical minutes of a song!! man kar raha hai keh du...Pandit ji once more. Great artistes can not and should not be compared. A play back singer may rule recording studios but conventional stage is clearly your terrain.
গলার কায়দা করন,মুড়কি এসব কিচ্ছু না,যার গান আমাদের সোল কে টাচ করে, সেই আসল গায়ক।। আর কিশোরদা এই কারনেই সেরার সেরা!!!!!
অদ্ভুত লাগলো একটি বহুশ্রুত মিষ্টি গানকে স্রেফ নিজের পান্ডিত্য ফলানোর যায়গা বানিয়ে নিলেন!!! সমগ্র শ্রোতাকূল কি উনার কাছে এধরনের ক্ল্যারিফিকেশন চেয়েছিলো??? এ কারনেই রাগসঙ্গীতের জগৎ থেকেও উনি বেশ কিছুটা সরে গেছেন। আমি নিজে বেশ কয়েকটি অনুষ্ঠানে শ্রোতা হয়ে শুনেছি কতরকম বন্দিশ আছে একই রাগে এবং সেটা কি কি ভাবে গাওয়া হয় সেটা স্টেজে বসে শেখাচ্ছেন৷ দুনিয়াশুদ্ধ মানুষকে যদি উনি ছাত্র ছাত্রী মনে করেন তো কিছু বলার নেই🙏🙏🙏
Akdom thik Katha dada
সেরার সেরা বলা যায় না। কিংবদন্তীদের সবাই সেরা। হেমন্তবাবুর ধারেকাছে কেউ নেই আবার কিশোরবাবুর ধারেকাছে কেউ নেই। মান্না দে মহঃ রফি সবার ক্ষেত্রেই এক কথা।
এগুলো চেস্টা না করাই ভাল। পাতে ফেলার যোগ্য নয়
are dada.apnake youtube e peye gelam.kemon ache.onek din fb te kichu likhchen na.
God's Voice...What a control over voice...my ears got purified..
Hemanta Mukherjee babu and Kishore da great legendary singer,,, mere koti koti pranam dono legend ko 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Excellently sung by panditji but K.Kumar my Guru is the guru of Indian music.
Mumu
Kishor Kumar was God gifted. Even Lata Mangeshkar has said that her most favourite singer was Kishor Kumar. Manna De too acknowledged his brilliance.
By admitting Kishore da as his guru makes him more humble and real legend. This is his greatness. He is so nice and great
Ashadharan. ...Sat sat pranam Guru ji. ...Namaskar Guru ji. ....Jai Hind
Kishore Kumar will always remain Kishore Kumar... No improvisations in his song can replace him .
No one is trying here to replace…Gaana ga rehi hain…Why is comparing?
All praise to goddess Durga for blessing this land with sons like Hemant Da, Kishore Da , Ajoy da.
He gave kaushiki to this world to continue his legacy she is no way less than any legend
Its really the rare-most occasion, Pandit Ajoy Chakraborty singing Kishore Dada's such a beautiful song ...just look at their mutual respect... that's why they are Legends....great information from SriTapan Basu. Thanks for the upload.
I could sense what Tapan ji was saying about. But since I don't understand Such a sweet Bengali, I would request you to translate for us. Please.
With Great affection and love from one Marathi- Punekar
With immense gratitude!
That's why Kishore Da is called genious
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice.
I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Yeh rohit hai na. yeh pandit ji ke pass gana seekhne gaya tha.Isko laath maarke bhaga diya unhone isliye yeh har jagah same comment copy, paste kar raha hai pagal sale.😆😆
Kadiye dilo ganer line gulo,sotti aisob ganer govirota bojhar jonno akta joggota proyojon chilo,kono bikolpo nei asob ganer r seisob silpider...Osadharon sir Ajay chakraborty...
Excellent. Legend passes his legacy to a legend!
koi 50 sal tak classical sikh ke aaye aur kishore da jaisa sirf ek line gaa ke dikhade ....nahi ga paayega .... kishore da is the greatest ...
Wah wah wah Pandit ji, dil ko chu gaya aap ka dhunn..... 🎶👍🎶👍🎶
Bahut sunder dada
What a blending of mentaining the raag ras & the original song.
Explaining every words expression with different phrases of kalyan.
One & only he can.
(koti pranaams in his feet)
Pandit ajoiy Chakraborty sangit samrat app ne ke janai amar antarik pranam.
গান মানেই গলার কালোয়াতি নয়, গান মানে ভাবের সুরেলা প্রকাশ। ভাবটাই আসল।ভাবটা হৃদয়ে থাকে, কিশোর কুমারের গলা শুধু নয় ভাব অনুভবের ও তা প্রকাশের ক্ষমতা এত বেশী ছিল বাকি সমস্ত গায়ক আজও তার কাছে শিশু, যত বড়ই ক্লাসিকাল গায়ক হন না কেন।
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice.
I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
বাজে লাগে এইসব গানকে নতুন ভাবে গাওয়ার অপচেষ্টাকে
Pandit ji admitting dada's talent. A great person realizing talent of another god gifted person.
Pandit Ajoy renders so effortlessly and does NOT try to imitate the original singer. Credit to him for his professionalism. By Kawal Maraj
Only classical singer can portray the essence of such songs. They need no other instruments except tabla.
Kishor Kumar, a legend je gaite gaite gayen! Shatabasar ou ektai jonmai.
Kishore kumar is the 8th wonder of the world
ঠিক
Exactly right.
Hemant Kumar is another wonder of the world. Rarest Gem.
This shows Ajoy Chakrabarty's technical virtuosity and the sheer genius of both Kishore and Hemant. Treat. Thanks for sharing.
Mind blowing lyrics,music and singing.We are grateful to u for representing the same.
A very favorite song of mine... And pandit ji has done some wonderful classical touch in this song... Such talented person he is ...n I'm listening now his version for the 50 th time...n the middle sargam of kalyan...uff...🙏
N kishor kumar, hemanta are my all time favorite... Unparalleled talents. 🙏
Gulzar(writer)
Hemant mukharjee(composer)
Kishore kumar(singer)
This trio had made this song for every living generation. Great song, great writing, great compose.
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice.
I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
@@Rohit-oj5dv right you are
Hemant Kumar is one of the best composer in hindi film industry despite being first class singer what is unparralel in Indian film industry.But his talent has not been judged due to mess doing in industry.
Kishore kumar is the top above
Pandit namer samne laglei ki keo pandit hay. Hemanta, Kishore, manna....... They are legends.🙏
Pandit Chakraborty is just Devine. Salutations Sir.
Kishore Kumar ek hi
No one comes close even to 100bilion km to him,,
After listening Pandil ji singing immediately listen to the original song sung by Khishore Kumar. There is no match. The starting "Woh shaam" leh delivered by Kishoreda is heart touching & superb.
I'm crying being nostalgic!!! Pandit ji is really greatest singer in Bengal 🌷🌸🌷
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice.
I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
In India not in Bengal.🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
And Dua Lipa is best in world ❤️❤️🔥 ....
@@Rohit-oj5dv So Mr. Haridas Pal u r judging Pandit Ajay Chakraborty. Tell me r u musically trained? have u ever learned music? i think u r not becoz u didnt get what he had tried to explain.U moron...first get some knowledge & achieve the lvl of pandit ji then judge him.That's why he is world famous pandit ji & u r Haridas Pal. 😆😆🤣🤣
@@Shubho_Chakraborty Mr.S, as ur name suggests, u must b a stupid. Wat do u knw about me ? Who r u ? Did u notice in the beginning of my post I wrote 'With due respect to Panditji' ?
Actually it's pointless to interact with a moron like u.
Dude, hv a great life, God bless u.
Ajoy da brings NO EXPRESSION to this song . Classical singers fail miserably singing light music
You're too dumb to understand the emotion.
No words to explain but only tears in my eyes after listening to this song by Pt. Ajoy Chakrabarty.
পন্ডিত জি আপনাকে অনেক অনেক ধন্যবাদ, আপনাকে জানাই আমার আন্তরিক শুভেচ্ছা ও অভিনন্দন।
Sir Pandit Chakrabarty Ji, i am listening to you for the first time in my life, may b am not that blessed. Would like to be very fair here.... first of all there is no comparison possible between Kishore/ Hemant Dadas' master piece, but you did not try at all anywhere to copy the original one... otherwise it would have become Cover Version (Have heard one of by Abhijeet - nice one). You have really sang it very well in your own style without even thinking of the original harkats n all, this make this rendition very beautiful. If someone, who has not listened the original one, listens this version first, that person would go with this rendition forever. Thanks Sir, I will try and follow your other songs definitely. Love you :)
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice.
I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Excellent
You probably don't know who Pandit Chakraborty is.....He was trying to explain how this song could have been sung based on Raag Kalyan. He also credited Hemant Kumar and Kishore Da for their excellent creation.
Sure Sir, Thank you.
বন্যেরা বনে সুন্দর, শিশুরা মাতৃক্রোড়ে।
First of all take my sata koti Pranam to respected Pandit Ajai Chakraborty. Now I came to know that the original Raga is use for this 💓 melody. With love and regards from Northeast
Beautiful beautiful but not even 1 pe recent of kishore da, that tells us how great kishore da was
Kishor Da was a comet, which visits earth may be once in million years.
Two genius at work. Both God gifted
"Akjon Shilpi r ak Jon shilpir sotta k onubhab Korten" khub khati Kotha bolechhen sir.
Wo shaam is such a beautiful song, a masterpiece from the combined efforts of composer the great Hemant Kumar, written by Gulzar and probably the best renderation by Kishore Kumar. Here listen to the song by the maestro Pandit Ajoy Chakrabarti..you will go to another worl mesmarized...
With due respect to Pandit Chakrabarty, I wud like to say, Kishorekumar's song distorted in a classical way is never acceptable by Kishorekumar admirers. This presentation fails to create even 1% aura of the magic which Kishorekumar had in his voice.
I jus wana say the classical improvisations were absolutely unnecessary. No wonder the legendary Kishorekumar is immortal, unique and unsubstitutable.
Yeh rohit hai na. yeh pandit ji ke pass gana seekhne gaya tha.Isko laath maarke bhaga diya unhone isliye yeh har jagah same comment copy, paste kar raha hai pagal sale.😆😆
When a musical Pundit is behind the mike it’s more than an icing on the cake. The classical version is even better, simply awesome !!
Kishore was unique.... Otherwise all classical singer's would have been the best playback singer's..
This proves the point..
Definitely 👍
Jay hind saab.. apne dil khush kiya.. me indian Army se sham.. apka fan hu... Hum par bhi apna haath banaye rakhein
Kishore Kumar means a legendary figure and trying to copy a legend like kishore kumar you end up mesmerizing the entire song