He has not addressed anything! He doesn't know what he is talking about the church. He Maybe right about everything else. This video about the church and the Pope is misleading.
Then, would you please enlighten him as well as the people in general the 'facts' that you cliam you know? Its important that we are not misled. Thanks. Is there anything more to understand that's not been reported by the news media? Should we talk about the history of catholicism in Kerala? Better still, shall we discuss the teachings of Christ on where, how and who to worship? Your views matter please.
Whether the priest faces the altar or the congregation, the Holy Spirit is present and active! Let's focus on the unity and love that binds us together in Christ. 'For where two or three are gathered in my name, there am I among them' (Matthew 18:20). Praying for a spirit of unity and reverence in our worship. Praise the Lord!
Though " malayali analysis" is correct, the ernakulam schism history is not analysed at all. Ernakulam bishop parekattil was the culprit behind all this when he decided to turn to the public during the mass in 1968 It was a move diametrically opposite to the east syrian tradition and the directives of the dicastry for eastern churches vatican. He was removed by vatican for disobedience and for misleading them by making different versions of the same document in malayalam and english. Though removed he had ample time to sow the seeds of schism that is burning in the church
Namaskaram Shri Scariaji Stalin once famously asked, "How many Divisions does the Pope command". Notwithstanding that cruel quip, Vatican has been a moral force for good, World over. Great video. Your snarky comment at the end about the pilot was fabulous. Regards, Sumal S
Bro.The karelaties mainly catholic are 3groups.Latin (RC), Syro Malabar and Malankara catholic.In figting and merely verge of split are facing shame to all xains.Other factors Non catholic xains are also in the state of fighting,and legal issue.In the meatime there are lot of non catholic parish are closed and non operational.All these infighting,political influence created mockery by them i, the eys of other faith.Harldly no fight regarding Temples and Mosque in kerala.,🙏
There is more to the controversy surrounding syro Malabar Church It is not disobedience as is propogated. There are monetory as well as a well planned out Power tussle hidden behind the oft quoted disobedience. Do more research sir. Just go through the reason why a whole diocese except a handful are standing strong and firm behind the priests in Ernakulam Angamally arch diocese. It is an urban population who are well educated. There are layers of undercurrents in this issue. Moreover it is a pity that Pope Francis was misguided by our spiritual leaders and dragged into the matters of our church. Dealing with an iron fist is not what Christ has taught us. Neither is pope Francis an autocrat. Pope stands for synodality, which is an all embracing phenomenon. The syro Malabar church is an independent church.Pope being it's nominal head Offering Holy mass with the security of hundreds of policemen in our church was painful. Moreover the sacrilege and atrocities committed in our Holy Altar cannot be forgotten or forgiven. Who committed those atrocities? Not the parishioners. Our church is not allowed to celebrate Holy mass even now. It is not disobedience. It is definitely more than that. I strongly believe that "God's prayer" which is beautifully written in the holy Bible should not be made ornamental according to the whims and fancies of the so called spiritual leaders. They are definitely not above Jesus Christ.
Whole diocese? A handful (say thousands) of amt supporters and Rebel priests! I'm also part of so called diocese. Ordinary layout people are not at all interested in these.
For the Synod it has become an ego problem , For the Archdiocese it is the matter of faith. People wish to see and experience mass with active participation. In new Synodal mass important parts of the Mass is hidden form the Laity
Sir, Pope Francis never told the same sex marriages could be blessed. His understanding is that we can pray for them. What is wrong with praying for others.
Thanks Jo. No one could have addressed the "Syro-Malabar church's issue" any better than you did.
Thank you, George
He has not addressed anything! He doesn't know what he is talking about the church. He Maybe right about everything else. This video about the church and the Pope is misleading.
Then, would you please enlighten him as well as the people in
general the 'facts' that you cliam you know? Its important that we are not misled. Thanks. Is there anything more to understand that's not been reported by the news media? Should we talk about the history of catholicism in Kerala? Better still, shall we discuss the teachings of Christ on where, how and who to worship? Your views matter please.
Watch the Explanation on the topic by Fr Jose Maniparampil . If you really want to know the facts you find it there.
Whether the priest faces the altar or the congregation, the Holy Spirit is present and active! Let's focus on the unity and love that binds us together in Christ. 'For where two or three are gathered in my name, there am I among them' (Matthew 18:20). Praying for a spirit of unity and reverence in our worship. Praise the Lord!
Spirit of unity 👍
Opposite directions do not bear fruits ?
Though " malayali analysis" is correct, the ernakulam schism history is not analysed at all.
Ernakulam bishop parekattil was the culprit behind all this when he decided to turn to the public during the mass in 1968
It was a move diametrically opposite to the east syrian tradition and the directives of the dicastry for eastern churches vatican. He was removed by vatican for disobedience and for misleading them by making different versions of the same document in malayalam and english. Though removed he had ample time to sow the seeds of schism that is burning in the church
Thank you for commenting
Namaskaram Shri Scariaji
Stalin once famously asked, "How many Divisions does the Pope command".
Notwithstanding that cruel quip, Vatican has been a moral force for good, World over.
Great video. Your snarky comment at the end about the pilot was fabulous.
Regards,
Sumal S
Namaskaram, Sumal
True, Jesus would be shocked and pained seeing so many warring factions, all declaring allegiance to him
Video-ending comment 😊🙏
Very interesting & informative. thanks Joe.
Thanks much
Ha, need to be a Malayali to figure out a Malayali.....Excellent analysis...!
Thank you 😊
It also takes a Syro Malabar to figure out a Syro Malabar issue, He may be right about everything else,but not about the church and the Pope.
The doctor was neither cockpit facing nor passenger facing but patient facing!! Thought provoking indeed!!
Congratulations, another great episode💐❤️🌹
Thank you, Levi ❤️
Joe, a beautiful presentation. Hooe you remember me. Wondering if I can get hold of your tel no.
Thank you, Francis
You can reach me at joe.journo@gmail.com
What a great observation….
Keep up the good work.
Thank you so much
Excellent .... beautifully explained 🙏🏼
Thank you 😊
Joe you are really exceptional - just like Keralite?!
😊 Thank you
Well described 🎉..
A new phrase is evolved..
A doctor face nighter Cockpit nor piolet but the patient 😅
Thank you, Mammen George 😊
Joe,
Well said, as always..❤
Keep it up
Thank you, Jacob
❤❤❤
😊🙏
Excellent 👌👍
Thank you 😊
Why can't these people leave the church than asking the church to go their way....there are other roman Catholic churches there where they can go
Excellent
Thank you
Canada is not Kerala
Bro.The karelaties mainly catholic are 3groups.Latin (RC), Syro Malabar and Malankara catholic.In figting and merely verge of split are facing shame to all xains.Other factors Non catholic xains are also in the state of fighting,and legal issue.In the meatime there are lot of non catholic parish are closed and non operational.All these infighting,political influence created mockery by them i, the eys of other faith.Harldly no fight regarding Temples and Mosque in kerala.,🙏
Thank you for commenting
What a load of crap and half truths coated with a thick layer of Sugar
There is more to the controversy surrounding syro Malabar Church
It is not disobedience as is propogated.
There are monetory as well as a well planned out Power tussle hidden behind the oft quoted disobedience.
Do more research sir.
Just go through the reason why a whole diocese except a handful are standing strong and firm behind the priests in Ernakulam Angamally arch diocese.
It is an urban population who are well educated.
There are layers of undercurrents in this issue.
Moreover it is a pity that Pope Francis was misguided by our spiritual leaders and dragged into the matters of our church.
Dealing with an iron fist is not what Christ has taught us. Neither is pope Francis an autocrat.
Pope stands for synodality, which is an all embracing phenomenon.
The syro Malabar church is an independent church.Pope being it's nominal head
Offering Holy mass with the security of hundreds of policemen in our church was painful.
Moreover the sacrilege and atrocities committed in our Holy Altar cannot be forgotten or forgiven.
Who committed those atrocities?
Not the parishioners.
Our church is not allowed to celebrate Holy mass even now.
It is not disobedience. It is definitely more than that.
I strongly believe that "God's prayer" which is beautifully written in the holy Bible should not be made ornamental according to the whims and fancies of the so called spiritual leaders.
They are definitely not above Jesus Christ.
Thank you for commenting
Whole diocese?
A handful (say thousands) of amt supporters and Rebel priests!
I'm also part of so called diocese.
Ordinary layout people are not at all interested in these.
Ego problem for the rebels, ..
For the Synod it has become an ego problem , For the Archdiocese it is the matter of faith. People wish to see and experience mass with active participation. In new Synodal mass important parts of the Mass is hidden form the Laity
What's hidden is the agenda of the rebels.
Bla, bla, bla lost 6 minutes
So True!
Sir, Pope Francis never told the same sex marriages could be blessed. His understanding is that we can pray for them. What is wrong with praying for others.
There's nothing wrong in praying for them. Pope's call to pray for them and Kerala's initiative for a transgender policy are mentioned as positives
Then malayalis should be questioning religion
Many are, though they are not in the majority like elsewhere
Pope of the damned
ഒന്ന് പോടെ ഇംഗ്ലീഷ് മാമാ... പോപ്പിനെ question ചെയുന്നത് വിമതന്മാർ ആണ് ...
💯😂😂😂