Sitting Bull: No Reservations - Native American History - Part 2 - Extra History
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 фев 2024
- 📜 Liked our Sitting Bull Episode? Then why not check out our sponsor Cell to Singularity? Download it for free on Steam, iOS and Android: 2ly.link/1vyXZ
🔥 Sitting Bull, a pivotal figure in Lakota history, navigates the turbulent landscape of 19th-century America. In the aftermath of the assassination of Bear’s Rib, Sitting Bull emerges as a beacon of defiance against encroaching settlers and oppressive government policies. Through acts of strategic warfare and unwavering resilience, Sitting Bull challenges the status quo, inspiring his people to resist oppression and reclaim their sovereignty. Join us on a journey through history as we unravel the legends and legacies of Sitting Bull, showcasing his indomitable spirit and enduring impact on Native American history.
* Watch Extra History ad-free & get 1-week early access on NEBULA go.nebula.tv/extrahistory
* Suggest & Vote on our next episodes, get exclusive content & 24-hour early access on PATREON bit.ly/EHPatreon
* Show off your fandom with MERCH from our store! extracredits.store/
* Interested in sponsoring an episode?* Email us: extracredits@standard.tv
TWITTER: bit.ly/ECTweet I FACEBOOK: bit.ly/ECFBPage
INSTAGRAM: bit.ly/ECisonInstagram I TIKTOK: bit.ly/ECtiktokz
BLUESKY: bit.ly/ECBlueSky I TWITCH: bit.ly/ECtwitch
GAMING: / @extracredits
Miss an episode in our Sitting Bull Series?
Part 1 - • Sitting Bull: Origin o...
Part 2 - • Sitting Bull: No Reser...
Part 3 - • Sitting Bull: Battle o...
Part 4 - • The Murder of Sitting ...
Series Wrap-up & Recommended Reading / Lies Episode - • Sitting Bull - LIES - ...
Thanks for the high-quality conversations & for following our community guidelines here: bit.ly/ECFansRNice
Artist: Nick DeWitt I Writer: Robert Rath I Researcher: A. Siso I Showrunner & Narrator: Matthew Krol I Video Editor: Devon House Creative I Audio Editor: Clean Waves I Studio Director: Geoffry Zatkin I Social Media: Kat Rider I ♪ Music by Demetori: bit.ly/1EQA5N7 I ♪ "The Real Dracula" by Tiffany Roman
#ExtraHistory #NativeAmerican #History
![Roddy Ricch - Survivors Remorse [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/J5IeFzr2GgE/mqdefault.jpg)
No bull! We got FREE games right here with Cell to Singularity on Steam, iOS and Android: 2ly.link/1vyXZ
Thanks for Watching!
Love your content guys! You're amazing!😊😊😊❤❤
I've been playing that game for years, and now it's so exciting to see them support my favorite channel!! Not to mention, the art in this episode is lovely! ❤️
رسمت ملابس سكان اصلين بشكل خاطئة
hi
You guys were successful with me! I just downloaded the game and I'm gonna play it now.
"Reservations?
Nah. I am sitting Bull, not sitting Duck!"
*Thathanka Iyotake
Gen. George Crook: Are you sure about that?
@@somerandofilipino6957”well then you must be a goose because your getting cooked
With that bit with the tobaco pipe his name ought to be "Buffalo Who Sits Down becauses his balls are too damn massive to carry."
Give them ears... That's a creepy way to call killing people 😳
Gotta get the message through to them somehow.
We are in a history channel, better to get used to it 😅
@@briannamcdaniel266Didn't work
@@spartanx9293 Unfortunately
yikes.
8:01 that right there is THE power move. Under fire, walks right into it, sits down and has a smoke like its nothing. Sitting Bull had balls of steel
*Thathanka Iyotake
Tha-thank-a i-yo-take?
Sitting Bull said “your aim’s trash, better go hunt buffalo instead” 😂
@@nuh_uh210"Skill issue, not even aimbot could help you"
-Buffallo Bull who sits down because his balls are just too damn massive to carry
Sitting Bull is better than most action heroes because instead of dodging bullets, using the force to push them aside, or slowing time to knock them to the ground, this man doesn't stare death in the face because he's afraid; he he expects death to look him in the face and dares any man to try and shoot him.
*Thathanka Iyotake
8:00 was such a bad-ass move! He really lived up to his name - calm, indifferent, unmoveable. It reminds me of a saying from The Art of War: “To fight and conquer in all your battles is not supreme excellence; supreme excellence consists in breaking the enemy’s resistance without fighting.”
Or as Quintus Flabius Maximus once said "If you can win a battle without having to fire a shot in anger, then you are the true victor".
What's amazing is the horrible aim of the soldiers. Or is it bullet deviation?
The difference between an act of badass bravery and an act of stupidity is mostly luck.
@@I_Hate_RUclips.
The army of the time wasn't renowned for their excellent marksmanship. There were a few factors going into that:
1. Recruitment from immigrant populations who'd been barred from firearm usage in their home countries. And people who were born in the US weren't automatically crack shots, most had only used shotguns on the farm, or were unfamiliar with firearms in the cities.
2. A strained supply chain that reduced the amount of supplies units stationed in far flung outposts could bring in. This had a cascading effect, since the higher ranking officers recognized that they could only send so many rounds per soldier, otherwise they'd be cutting into the other necessities. So they decided to make sure that the weapons issued would be slow to fire, to discourage the soldiers from wasting ammunition. And the limited ammo supply also cut down on the number of rounds the soldiers could fire to gain and maintain proficiency with their weapons.
So all of these led to the US military on the whole not having the best track record for accuracy at the time.
@_RUclips. It's just a legend. This situation is nonsence. Also what would be follow-up of this situation? Everyone just went back in peace?
Only way it could be possible is these were bunch of scared civilians that didn't wanted spotted natives to come any closer and shot just to make loud sound with and off-chance of maybe hitting. So maybe that could be some explaination.
After part one i read his quote 'when the last tree is chopped, the last river poisioned will man realise he cant eat money'
So true
Fun fact: After the stunt with the pipe, he actually had trouble walking back home due to the sheer mass and weight of the enormous brass balls he was dragging behind him.
Sitting Bull had serious anime protagonist plot armor
*Thathanka Iyotake
@@LangThoughtswhat are you saying?
Giving people 'ears' is the most badass, passive way of declaring your intentions of deadly force ive ever heard and I f*king love it
It is the natural conclusion to someone who wont listen:
"Huh, I don't think you can hear me, LET ME GIVE YOU MOTHERFUCKING EARS!"
@@Nverdiskey word *passive* lol
we should give israel some ears
@@skellurip there are only sides because we make them.
Yeah well it's not a concept that was reserved for just your enemies, as a child, someone threatening to improve your hearing indicated that they were going to draw blood.
Can we talk about well the writers and narrator do their jobs? Last episode's and today's openings honestly gave me chills
The opening of how Matt’s words were on the letter was well done too!
Thank you for teaching Native western history
As a South Dakotan thank you for doing this story
Even though its episode 2... Sitting bull was truly a Chad 🗿
*Thathanka Iyotake
A Gigachad!!!!
@@LangThoughts oh, it’s his name in native tongue
It'd be nice if you addressed their "relationship" with the Crow in the subsequent lies episode. You've briefly touched on it twice on it without really going into, probably because it doesn't fit with the story being told, but it's still important.
Something for the lies episode maybe
I'd like to thank EH for doing this series. I as an American think despite not being directly responsible for what our predecessors did, we still owe it to the people whose land we stole to understand this grim part of our history, and just do better.
i'd love to see a similar series on the seminole wars, an equally important story and often forgotten story in American history
Well I think because its the native americans stuff not for whole USA I think ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I LOVE THIS VIDEO!!!!!! This is what we are learning in Minnesota history Native Americans!
Bet the reason Sitting Bull was able to pull of that feat is he understood the weapons of the Army, their effective range, and knew, so long as he walks at an even pace, those bullets will land anywhere but where he is.
*Thathanka Iyotake
Given that there were soldiers among them it's unlikely they were shooting to kill.
There were more soldiers than natives at that railway, if they wanted him dead they had ample time to do it so I doubt it was their intention.
Still cold as hell to risk it though.
@@larsdewit6521 also us troops at the time did not have super good aim but true
@@LangThoughtskeep doing your good work friend
Peace is not an option against an enemy who wants nothing more than your non-existence.
This series is alredy amazing! You guys rock! 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥💪💪💪💪
I did not expect the Cell to Singularity sponsor considering I play that game. Neat.
Puffing the pipe in a battlefield? This man is an ABSOLUTE LEGEND
I love these stories about legendary Indian war chiefs! Maybe one about the controversial Comanche tribes? Quanah Parker was was a seriously interesting chieftain.
Sitting Bull: The man so brave and bad ass that he warped reality to give his opponents storm trooper aim.
He is to cool for special abilities like that, US soldiers at the time were not exactly the best at shooting stuff is all.
WOW IN ALL THAT CHAOS HE JUST SMOKES LIKE A CHAD Sitting Bull YOU NATIVE LEGEND 7:50
4:22 Gorilla war? Gotta love those subtitles ❤️ 😂
Loving the art in this series so far!
Also, that letter at the beginning sounded so threatening. 😅
Thanks to the powerful medicine of his shield.
Well played respecting the cultures history, extra.
What a joke.
@@PavelTayTaywhat is?
@@PavelTayTayhey man what’s the joke?
YOU guys are the Best! Always look forward to your videos 😊😊😊❤❤❤
As someone who has played cell to singularity daily for about 1 year now. It was so weird to see the game I play a lot show up here
Thank you guys for all the great work , another great video
I'm happy that you pointed out that "Sioux" isn't the proper name. Also, do you think you would ever do an episode on the Sand Creek Massacre?
It's so dark...so dark.😢
It's crazy watching this and the Ken Burns documentary from 3 months ago on Sitting Bull
I see what you did there with the "no reservations" line, because he didn't want to go to a reservation, and he had no reservations about fighting against it!
Yeah 😂
Having recently rewatched your John Snow series, letting them succumb to Cholera in squalor is a very clear picture of inhumanity.
Please do the Greek war of independence of 1821 against the ottoman empire next
I've been asking for this since the first episodes of the sengoku Jidai!
Whenever there's a new video, I hop over to nebula to watch the newest one, then let this one play on mute in another window so that you get the extra youtube view credit. it's not much, but i love your channel more then anything on this platform
Yes! Thank you for the extra views!
@@extrahistorymoney! It makes the world go round! Love ya guys!
Matt's REALLY good at narrating, and the writers are amazing at their job.
damn, not only did the army aim like gd Storm Troopers, but dude's balls much have been literal cannon shots dragging the entire way to and from
its convenient this series started getting made the same time i got back into red dead redemption, love hearing more native american history!
When this series is over you guys should make a video about the history of Mount Rushmore. It's seriously messed up when you really break it down. 😅
Hello, great episode as always, quick question though. During the story at the end where sitting bull sat amidst a volley of bullets, how come he was never shot once?
Is it due to the weapons of the time being extremely innacurate? Is it due to extra contracts the US millitary had to follow regarding their relations with the natives? Is it because the terrain was especially well suited for this (whether sitting bull was far, hidden, something else)? Is it because it is a legend and the truth is less romanticized? Was he wounded but not enough for it to actually handicap him?
Thanks again for the episode!
Damn lol those blue coats had the straight up stormtrooper aim
Day 2 of asking for the history of Louis Riel and the red river rébellion
SB really walked through a storm bullets so he can smoke
Hey uh if I may ask, could you guys talk about the Halifax explosion after all of the sitting bull episodes are done? Thanks.
PANR has tuned in.
Love this video, love history
Definitely the title of the Sitting Bull biopic directed by Micheal Bay. "Sitting Bull:NO RESERVATIONS"
"They didn't listen, so he gave them ears" would be the tag line.
Similar situation to that of the Palestinians.
Love this channel. I absolutely love history and the animation makes it easier to get my kids involved.
That is a very good resistance, cant wait for the continuation.
Can’t wait for the next few episodes
Heads up, Extra History: The captions are a little wrong. Ya might wanna check on them.
For Bitting Bull's sake.
Thank you for the video.
Love these videos
I am never going to have the pure brass balls of Sitting Bull.
If I were one of those soldiers, I would’ve just given up and resigned. Ain’t no way I’m fighting a man like that
Huh….didn’t expect that
CTS!!! LETS GO!
Okay, I'm just curious and please call me out if this is out of bounds for questioning but were those soldiers over 100 yards when firing or were they just really bad shots when Sitting Bull stood in their fire unarmed? It's amazing but the distance of the riflemen is kinda important in my opinion.
They were not bad shots per se, but most troops at the time were not like sharpshooters.
This Lakato deserves his own movie
3:35 Name that was an exonym given to the Lakota by the Ojibwe who were, let's say, not in good terms with them due to past actions, meaning "ennemies". Today it reffers to the three closely socioculturally linked nations of the Lakota, Dakota and Nakota. Kinda like "Vainkakh" to reffer to the nations of the Chechens and Ingush. You really should do btw an episode on Russian's own Manifest Destiny, against the nations of the caucasus (especially the Circassians), the Crimeans (or crimean tatar), of the arctic, Central Asia and the Siberian lands.
I love that four horns had four feathers on his head like actual horns where on his haed
Head not haed
Gold. Enough said.
🎉part 2 wahoo🎉
Love you
WHOAAH CALM DOWN BUDDY!!!!!!!!!
Love you too stranger
Cool vid
that feather fasion they have is so cool
The amount of wounds this legend took is amazing
Canada also followed a similar history to the us and its treatment of indigenous Americans. The only difference is that our percentage of our population is higher than compared to the US.
Unfortunately humans like killing each other for the most bearbones reasons.
I used to live in Red Cloud, Nebraska!
Nice
Something I always grapple with is putting myself into the mind of historical figures like sitting bull. What did he feel in that moment of calm? Did he trust wholly to his War magic, that his faith was protection? or did he grapple with fear and was motiviated by the very real political concern that he was considered craven?
Well people believe in Jesus and god, how is the magic any different then our gods?
7:53 seems he knew the enemy had clone trooper aim
You mean storm trooper right?
Minié balls were not actually balls, but bullets like the ones we have today. They were extremely nasty.
You should talk about D.B. Cooper next. One of the most Wanted Robbers in Washington State history.
Sitting Bull is the definition of plot armor
7 minutes ago, epic🥳
It’s unbelievable how this reminds me of how the Palestinians are being treated by the occupying Israelis
I know right?
I push x to doubt the chill smoking during a gunfight story
Question, what are Sitting Bull and the other natives' non-English names?
I thought the thumbnail was someone shooting at Sitting Bull. But then I looked harder and he’s just lighting one up 👌
Sitting Bull has some iron brass balls to just walk casually towards them WHILE THEY'RE FIRING AT HIM.
Wow.
That display of bravado must have been pretty demoralizing to the people shooting at them. Imagine shooting dozens of rounds at someone who's literally just sitting there like they're having a picnic and not hitting them once. I know guns were far less accurate back then but man, that'd be a serious blow to your ego there
I forget which episode of into the West the mini series had an episode that covered everything in this chapter. Lol
Yay I'm in the first five hundred to watch this🎉
Woahhh O.O This one, *mannnn.*
wow
Wait, was that a reference to space ship you at 9:04?
Bit of a small complaint. US troops should not have lever action repeaters, as they were still extremely rare and expensive. It would be much more accurate to give them Sprigfield '63s and Sharps carbines, which were more common during the American Civil War era.
They will probably cover that in lies
Why isn't Rob being credited at the end of the videos like he used to be?
Rob got cancelled.
It's in the description now
3:17 Can you please do a video about the corrupt Indian agent, why he ate grass and the execution in Mankato, Mn and how President Lincoln fit in to all of this.
So it wasn’t enough for the United States to be fighting a war against the confederacy? They fought a war against American Indians at the same time? Jesus those were horrible times.
Multiple wars technically, there were actually nations that chose the confederate side thinking they could negotiate a better deal out of it (how exactly I have ZERO clue), and nations who saw the war and instead decided to open fire on everyone.
Knowing Better has a solid video essay on the whole history of the reservation system
2:41 eyup, and the constant warfare against natives didn't end until the Wounded Knee Massacre, which got multiple soldiers medal of honors because of their 'valor' unaliving the unarmed, sick, women, and kids
@@reillycurran8508 because the Oklahoma Tribes had economic ties to the Confederates. Namely the rich upper class which owned slaves and plantations. Most Tribesmen didn't care for either side, though
Yeah the US sucked.
@@THECHEESELORD69 always has been
Do Bonifacio next!
Land back!
Ah i think thats part of why only a Single Railroad Mainline was built Across South Dakota (that being the Milwaukee Road in 1910) all the Others went either north or South with the Union Pacific having gone through Nebraska, the ATSF through Kansas, the Southern Pacific through Texas, and the Great Northern and Northern Pacific through North Dakota
Weren't the executions of the St. Patrick's Batallion (La Batallón de San Patricio) during the Mexican-American War larger? Reports I've seen put the number of San Patricios executed at around 50.
What's the origin of the turn of phrase giving someone ears to mean killing them?
holes in your head
Screw the people who poisoned the food 😡