I've heard it for years.... you really have to listen. it's incredibly fast, and almost imperceptible. she's dotting figures... some of that's half a count; maybe half a second, depending on tempo.
@@adamd6648Whitney's vibrato wasn't only insanely powerful but also lightning speed fast Idk what y'all talking about 😂 Mariah's vibrato was weak and inconsistent
@@Swahili14your crazy Sway don't diminish MiMi's talent her vibrato has neva been weak I don't know what you're talking about don't play her like that I'm not saying she doesn't lip sync sometimes but she doesn't most of the time she's a pro when she sings live you need to stop being a hater or whateva and these woman you mentioned respected each otha's talent bc they knew what a real singer was this is why the Vocal Trinity is MiMi Nippy and Celine their voices are golden so don't so that
Bonnie Tyler had nodules removed and, her entire vocal tone and timbre changed. It took her months to recover from the surgery. I think late 1990-91... I'd have to look it up; but, she really worked to reshape her sound after that. Mariah's ENT is trying to save her tone and vocal physical structure at the same time. Bravo for this MD, whoever he is.
Definitely, it can go very wrong. Best example from memory is Julie Andrews. She could never really sing again or at least was very restricted in terms of notes.
Bonnie Tyler's nodules were removed right after "Lost in France" her first single, when she recorded "It's A Heartache" and she sounded very raspy because she wasn't silent during the weeks after surgery. That's the reason she sounds hoarse.
In case people who are Mariah Carey fans and didn’t know what Vocal Nodule are. Vocal nodules (also known as vocal fold nodules or vocal cord nodules) can develop if you use your voice too much over a long period of time. They make your voice hoarse and change the sound of your voice. These small, benign (non-cancerous) nodules usually go away again if you rest your voice or do voice therapy.
@@kevinwashington2733 LMAO not chop off. 😭 Well, yeah. It is kind of scary because it'll cause changes in your voice, mainly the tone or color of it. I have nodules myself and it's really hard because it reduces your range and vocal stamina, hence faster fatigue happens on your voice when you perform songs consecutively (I'm already tired by the second or third one. Depends on the condition you have in a given day).
@@daydream10.18 well it happens too much time when ur being coloratura in ur own free studio time for many years trying to hit da highest-ranking note so fucking loud w/o giving it a rest. btw, da "chopped off" part means u have to let doctors cut da nodules out when ur in surgery.
Shaq retired before 40, but nobody doubts his past basketball talents. But somehow when a female singer in her 50s can’t perform at the same level as in her 20s, it undoes all her past greatness.
My sister was once had nodules. However, these nodules were many and can threatened her health. She underwent surgery to remove those. She also once had beautiful voice and won many beauty contest. After surgery, her voice was not as good as before. She even had offkeys when singing now. But she said that it was okay at least she's okay now.
i always thought she kept a helium balloon tucked up under her big dresses she wears all the time and when she reaches up towards her ear like that she got the nozzle tucked up behind her ear sneakin in balloon puffs before the grand finale.
I love Mariah from the beginning she broke into the music scene in 1990. You recognise a superstar going into superstardom overnight. Her voice is just so special ❤❤❤
Didn’t Julie Andrews undergo similar surgery in like the 90's or something with a similar result? Or did she have something else going on that needed correcting and that's what killed her singing voice? I’m sorry your cousin lost her ability to sing after her operation.
Im guessing the nodules are why she can be so breathy easily. Whenever Ive heard singers with nodules their voices are usually raspy and have a whispery quality.
That's actually true based on my experience and my own observations on others with noduels too. I also have nodules and can easily access my whisper register and falsetto although the range is very inconsistent, sometimes nothing comes out so apparently it can really be a hit or miss for most of the time.
Just realizing how open she can be🖤 but I never understood the high note hype for a long time simply because its like a scream little girls do and I did well to turn melodic when learning "After the Pain" but I think ppl(females) grow out of that ability typically ? So to not to and more so to have perfect control of the note is whats so impressive...
@@christinec.8107she wasn’t, she got them from using whistles while she was a child. Exploring and developing that register but also suffered damage from it
Vocal nodules can be scary, I talked a lot working and preaching I began to loose my voice, found out I have nodules, I had to go to speech therapy and everything.
She has nodules because she just can't stop singing. She sings all day long. If you would have her voice, you'll also didn't want to shup up, you would be inloved with your own voice.
Unfortunately, this is often an insurance coverage issue. If there is no pain or distress to the patient, removing the nodules would be viewed solely as a cosmetic procedure, not a medically necessary one. Not saying this is either right or fair, just pointing out the why of this not getting approved. Have doctors determined the size of the nodules if at all possible? I think sometimes the size of growths is taken into account also.
Years of vocal abuse sounds good enough to earn millions, until one day she could have challenges with just being able to talk. This is why singers must study voice and not just how to sing. It has been so sad to see what happened to these amazing voices. Most of the best hitmaking singing is done with vocal abuse, until the voice is gone.
Notice how she stopped herself from saying "squeezing". It's because she doesn't do that. That's Christina's signature when she's using her head voice to mimic whistles.
Yes but the difference here is Mariah had them since she was very young. She learned to use them as an instrument. And her cords adapted. For an adult singer it just strains the voice.
@@strangerthings88 the risk is far more dangerous than the benefit. Mariah has been singing with nodules for so long that removing could possibly offset and destroy her entire voice beyond beyond rehabilitation. Removing could possibly result in the complete destruction of her voice (including speaking voice) if it goes wrong. Just look at Julie Andrews. She lost everything. Mariah needs to get training and do treatments to stop the swelling, not having them removed. Idk why she doesn’t
The fast vibrato in those runs- its so fast that most people wouldnt notice/hear theres one,its just sounds like its just a part of the run crazy
I've heard it for years.... you really have to listen. it's incredibly fast, and almost imperceptible. she's dotting figures... some of that's half a count; maybe half a second, depending on tempo.
Yea you really gotta listen out for it. She was unstoppable in her hay day.
@@adamd6648Whitney's vibrato wasn't only insanely powerful but also lightning speed fast
Idk what y'all talking about 😂
Mariah's vibrato was weak and inconsistent
@@Swahili14during 90’s even Whitney didn’t stand a chance she was miraculous in that era
@@Swahili14your crazy Sway don't diminish MiMi's talent her vibrato has neva been weak I don't know what you're talking about don't play her like that I'm not saying she doesn't lip sync sometimes but she doesn't most of the time she's a pro when she sings live you need to stop being a hater or whateva and these woman you mentioned respected each otha's talent bc they knew what a real singer was this is why the Vocal Trinity is MiMi Nippy and Celine their voices are golden so don't so that
I like how an imperfection is what makes her as special as she is vocally.
Bonnie Tyler had nodules removed and, her entire vocal tone and timbre changed. It took her months to recover from the surgery. I think late 1990-91... I'd have to look it up; but, she really worked to reshape her sound after that. Mariah's ENT is trying to save her tone and vocal physical structure at the same time. Bravo for this MD, whoever he is.
Wow
Mariah tone is one of a kind that’s why
Voice therapy is the gold standard for vocal nodules
Definitely, it can go very wrong. Best example from memory is Julie Andrews. She could never really sing again or at least was very restricted in terms of notes.
Bonnie Tyler's nodules were removed right after "Lost in France" her first single, when she recorded "It's A Heartache" and she sounded very raspy because she wasn't silent during the weeks after surgery. That's the reason she sounds hoarse.
One of the best singers ever
The fact that she finished all 'her voice is gone' accusations with perfect and concise, factual reasoning ❤
Her voice is amazing
Was where u been she haven't song like that in 20yrs
@@HondaFn1Not true, during covid and when she gets proper vocal rest she does.
@@misterbee66 keep it a buck shes a studio singer she cant sing live if u a true fan u would know this
@@HondaFn1 I am a true fan, she can sing live. She is not a studio singer. She is not the greatest performer, she can certainly sing however.
@misterbee66 🧢 she sing over her recorded music that's not singing
I love the way she honest abouy her vocal technique
I love Mariah Carey, regardless of her high notes gone.... it's okay. She's a legend....if doctors can't help then she will still retire as a lgend.
Thank you for the honesty Mimi 💚 it's so sweet and it's helpful for people to understand
In case people who are Mariah Carey fans and didn’t know what Vocal Nodule are.
Vocal nodules (also known as vocal fold nodules or vocal cord nodules) can develop if you use your voice too much over a long period of time. They make your voice hoarse and change the sound of your voice. These small, benign (non-cancerous) nodules usually go away again if you rest your voice or do voice therapy.
i watched freak da freak out of victorious as a kid to know da 1st time wut vocal nodules mean an wut happens to it.
It won't go away once it grows bigger. Usually, that will already require surgery.
@@daydream10.18 well damn. i like to sing but i hate to get my throat chopped off.
@@kevinwashington2733 LMAO not chop off. 😭 Well, yeah. It is kind of scary because it'll cause changes in your voice, mainly the tone or color of it. I have nodules myself and it's really hard because it reduces your range and vocal stamina, hence faster fatigue happens on your voice when you perform songs consecutively (I'm already tired by the second or third one. Depends on the condition you have in a given day).
@@daydream10.18 well it happens too much time when ur being coloratura in ur own free studio time for many years trying to hit da highest-ranking note so fucking loud w/o giving it a rest. btw, da "chopped off" part means u have to let doctors cut da nodules out when ur in surgery.
That is really so much vocal game she just gave. So many singers getting surgeries. She didnt have to share that.
Why she didn t have to share? Whatcu sayin?
Shaq retired before 40, but nobody doubts his past basketball talents. But somehow when a female singer in her 50s can’t perform at the same level as in her 20s, it undoes all her past greatness.
No it doesn’t lol
Damn! Mariah Is the vocal beast
My sister was once had nodules. However, these nodules were many and can threatened her health. She underwent surgery to remove those. She also once had beautiful voice and won many beauty contest. After surgery, her voice was not as good as before. She even had offkeys when singing now. But she said that it was okay at least she's okay now.
She is genius. ❤❤❤
Leave the nodules, Mariah!!!❤
She’s pretty
What makes you unique makes you more beautiful ❤
Your voice is awesome
i always thought she kept a helium balloon tucked up under her big dresses she wears all the time and when she reaches up towards her ear like that she got the nozzle tucked up behind her ear sneakin in balloon puffs before the grand finale.
😆
😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
How to say you hate a person without saying it.
I love her hair back then when she use to rock it curly
Mariah is beautifully blessed with a gift 📦 of a amazing voice 🎶 ❤
I love Mariah from the beginning she broke into the music scene in 1990. You recognise a superstar going into superstardom overnight. Her voice is just so special ❤❤❤
“I HAVE NODES” - pitch perfect
Mariah is up there with whitney❤ best singers
You're GIFTED momma
My cousin was training to be an opera singer. They removed her nodules and destroyed her voice.
Didn’t Julie Andrews undergo similar surgery in like the 90's or something with a similar result? Or did she have something else going on that needed correcting and that's what killed her singing voice? I’m sorry your cousin lost her ability to sing after her operation.
Yes. She did.
Fabulous voice, I absolutely love her!!!❤
Ha fatto bene a non toglierli in questo caso...❤
That girl can sing.
They were naturally and specifically made for her vocal craftness❤
Mariah Carey is the queen of vocal embellishment. It can get exhausting to listen too, but it's still amazing.
God bless you Mimi...your voice is amazing...
Sad she can’t sing like this anymore. What a talent she was.
I miss her ❤
The voice is good but the musical arrangements always progressive. Emotions is fab 😊😊 I will listen to that album til I die. Congratulations !!
Wow!!!
An amazingly
wonderful
Voice!!!💐💐💐💐💐💫
Dang so if she had, had them removed she wouldn't be the legend she is 😮 God bless the person who told her not to remove them.
Mskes sense. It changes the shape of the space sound travels through, which is how we make instruments
Im guessing the nodules are why she can be so breathy easily. Whenever Ive heard singers with nodules their voices are usually raspy and have a whispery quality.
That's actually true based on my experience and my own observations on others with noduels too. I also have nodules and can easily access my whisper register and falsetto although the range is very inconsistent, sometimes nothing comes out so apparently it can really be a hit or miss for most of the time.
Mariah's a mutant!! What a power 😂
she is her own worst critic. I absolutely think that she does not believe she is the top vocalist ever .
Just realizing how open she can be🖤 but I never understood the high note hype for a long time simply because its like a scream little girls do and I did well to turn melodic when learning "After the Pain" but I think ppl(females) grow out of that ability typically ? So to not to and more so to have perfect control of the note is whats so impressive...
Yes! Plz got back on lore lodge!!🖤
This is definitely true
Still gorgeous
Love that girl.
I would NOT leave a nodule on my vocal cords. I would be very afraid of them becoming malignant.
If I recall she was born with them
@christinec.8107 People are often born with all types of growths that are benign for years and then become malignant. It's common.
@@trevizolganot true
@@christinec.8107she wasn’t, she got them from using whistles while she was a child. Exploring and developing that register but also suffered damage from it
make the best out of the worse i guess it’s like how people who’ve lost a leg are lighter than those who didn’t bad things aren’t always bad
How considerate of the doctor to investigate what what going on and see what would happen after surgery.
LUV MARIAH!
Lovvvvvve ms carey ..
❤❤❤❤❤
❤❤❤❤❤❤
Like dancers and callouses
Vocal nodules can be scary, I talked a lot working and preaching I began to loose my voice, found out I have nodules, I had to go to speech therapy and everything.
She has nodules because she just can't stop singing. She sings all day long. If you would have her voice, you'll also didn't want to shup up, you would be inloved with your own voice.
Hello beautiful mariah carey 🙏📖😊🥰😘❤🌹👑🎤💿💽📀🦋love you
Linda demais... só fã...❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
God given
My idol
God gave you that gift.
❤❤❤Mc❤❤❤
I too have them from an accident thank uuuuuu
I have nodules which brought my singing career to an end unfortunately. Good on you Mariah.😊 Maybe I should just have mine removed.
Please don't EVER remove the nodules!!!!
I have nodules and how I wish they can do something like that 😂😂😂. But they just sit there and keep saying "NO". 😭😭😭😭
Unfortunately, this is often an insurance coverage issue. If there is no pain or distress to the patient, removing the nodules would be viewed solely as a cosmetic procedure, not a medically necessary one. Not saying this is either right or fair, just pointing out the why of this not getting approved. Have doctors determined the size of the nodules if at all possible? I think sometimes the size of growths is taken into account also.
😂😂😂
Now i think she need do this
Grow TF up
Years of vocal abuse sounds good enough to earn millions, until one day she could have challenges with just being able to talk. This is why singers must study voice and not just how to sing. It has been so sad to see what happened to these amazing voices. Most of the best hitmaking singing is done with vocal abuse, until the voice is gone.
Right 👍
It’s possible she has them from pushing her natural vocal range too far too fast
I wonder if she removed them will she sing like before . She already had proven she can do the whistle
Ay the beginning she sounds like Nicki Minaj
Didn’t Whitney Houston have a hanger accident to her throat, as a child? Resulting in her vocal ability?
Yep
❤❤❤❤❤😊🎉
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Interesting
❤❤❤❤
I do too
Yaaaaawwwn!!!
❤
She won't scream no more
👏👏👏👏👏👏
She’s explaining something recent and you put a video of 30 years ago
And??
One run too much! 😂
She has nodules. I knew it and knowm
Does it hurt?
I still have my tonsils
...? 😅
@TheEarthRealm fr. Ppl say the weirdest shit online. Lol
how about reducing the size of nodules? wouldnt it help? back to its size in the 90s? is that even possible?
It’s not
Woh oh oh oh oh oh oh oh
😂😂😂
Girl, get them done. It’s time.
Notice how she stopped herself from saying "squeezing". It's because she doesn't do that. That's Christina's signature when she's using her head voice to mimic whistles.
Man if I was her husband
They can be removed should do it I know a singer who had them and removed them and after a while her voice improved a lot
Let her age.
Creates narrowed passage..
❤️💗💜🥰🇧🇿
Ça provoque des notes aiguës ou c’est à force de faire des notes aiguës j’ai pas compris
Didnt Adele get her Nodules removed?
Yes but the difference here is Mariah had them since she was very young. She learned to use them as an instrument. And her cords adapted. For an adult singer it just strains the voice.
@@EddierockificationMariah’s voice is more strained and restricted than ever they need to go.
@@strangerthings88they can’t go
@@debutriah2854 why’s that?
@@strangerthings88 the risk is far more dangerous than the benefit. Mariah has been singing with nodules for so long that removing could possibly offset and destroy her entire voice beyond beyond rehabilitation. Removing could possibly result in the complete destruction of her voice (including speaking voice) if it goes wrong. Just look at Julie Andrews. She lost everything. Mariah needs to get training and do treatments to stop the swelling, not having them removed. Idk why she doesn’t
Monica the singer had her removed f up here entire voice
That's not how nodules work