Once again I just want to say thank you all for not only watching this video, but also getting my channel to 1,000 subs! I cannot thank y'all enough for the support you have given this channel for the many years you have, even if my upload schedule has been sporadic. This was in production for five years and I lost motivation to continue making the video, but since we hit the milestone, I felt like it was only right to finally finish this video instead of leaving y'all empty handed. Shoutout to Mega Shadow, Larry the Lone Wolf and UltraMac Productions for helping me out with this video! Only time will tell when my next Top 10 video will come out. This is MrDIRECTOREIGHT signing off! Also I'm gonna just put this at the end in case someone takes this as a legitimate list: Most of the opinions and comments in this video are purely satire and are not meant to be taken seriously otherwise.
Well, well, welcome back, man! :D Gosh, I can't wait to see your Top 10. I been watching your previous ones and I enjoyed them. Seeing you return is truly amazing thing ever.
As a fan of all your previous logo countdowns since they were brand-new, I must say it's such a delightful surprise seeing you return to more amusing content like this (complete with your hilarious "ad breaks")! Please keep it up! The more RUclipsrs reviewing logos, the better!
Damn, this is a blast in the past for me I would rewatch your logo videos my freshman year of high school in 2018, and i must say, you’re still doing a great job! Good to have you back!
15:39 | even it look like the OC APLHA logo (idk if they steal it or they DIDNT KNOW the logo exist but IS REALLY LOOK LIKE IT) But yeah I REALLY like this video ( I think this your BEST top 10 logo video )
This feels like revisting an old friend. All of my previous favorite logo youtubers all here. Keep up the good work man. We need more people like you since so many of the other logo videos are just idiots that don't know what they're talking about. I'll never grow out of these videos.
the funniest things about the font for kwsu is that the w is a upside down m, and the fonts name is STOP, like the font was warning to them to stop them from making it
At the end of the day, I don't actually hate the logo. I find some charm in how cheesy it is, the music's good and I kinda like the color combination. The animation's a bit basic, but it's fine. The end result is like the only thing I don't really like that much.
the fact this has an actual reaction makes it different from others like a mix of Nostalgia Critic/AVGN(Because of The Skits),RioGio0447 (because of Robert's and Your Voice similarity),and No. Prods(Because of the fake commercials and the Numbers before each logos).Good Job
Well, it’s about time, and, can’t wait for this to be premiered and can’t wait for more warnings and commercials, so yep, nothing else to say any further.
The UNC logo at #2 looks like a pbs production company couldn’t figure out how to make something original for themselves so they had to force some wannabe hippie that dropped out of high school to make any random design for their logo. Same goes to the KWSU logo. I’m glad you’re back and congrats on 1,000 subscribers. Have you seen the A.K.A. Cartoon Logo? Maybe for the next logo list that you make, it could be in the top 10?
You know, some of your editing in this video reminds me of the older Caddicarus videos, spefically those from pre-2020. And I mean that as a compliment.
The commentary style, I was mainly inspired by Scott the Woz, he's one of my favorite creators on RUclips. But there are a couple instances where I was inspired by Caddicarus, specifically the part where I yell "WHAT?!?" while talking about #1 lol. But yeah I can see the comparisons, I appreciate that.
How I missed your Top 10 videos! I loved these commercials, I miss NationFarm, the cheesiness of these logos made me narf a hundred times (OMG ANIMANIACS REFERENCE CONFIRMED!!!!!!! 😲🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓😂😂😂😂😂), and they did the moog synthesizers so dirty. I honestly reccomend this video of yours! 🤗❤ ♪♪trees! 🌳🌲🌴♪♪
Thank you for avoiding the KUCB Unalaska bandwagon. It’s just text from a character generator in a tiny community in the middle of nowhere. In fact, I was inspired by KUCB for my birthday one year. I was petting my doggo while I blew out the candles.
Why sid you have to use the worst quality version of the number 7 logo? Alden found a version from 1987 that sounds WAY less quiet than the one you used for your logo.
I never heard who Larry the Lone WOlf is, but I already have reservations against him. He somehow thinks the designers from a logo from 50 years ago would stumble upon this video, and try to make another ident with the only constructive feedback being “do better.” Very helpful, man. How about you “do better” with your criticism of an ident being discussed by tons of other people like Ian already.
For the South Carolina ETV ident, I would’ve put the logo with the turd/diarrhea color scheme from the early 70s . Aside from the colors, The Scanimate, font type, and music were all awful.
i found a another logo thats way worse than WHYY-TV 12 and even the logo is tv dx and has the worst tv dx quality its called televiziunea română this bunch of cheese logo is made in roman in the 1970s and is worse than WHYY-TV 12 pick the logo in your next top 10 cheesy logos video
My opinions: 10. This logo started in 1981. Not 1978. It's fine imo. Not much to say about it. 9. Ugh imagine this is ur alarm. This ain't an alarm in Ohio, it's an alarm in Idaho this time! The view is beautiful imo. But OMG the music is awful UGH. 8. Gold and purple is a dull color scheme, but the gold is shiny so it's fine. The N is weird bc it should connect perfectly to the circle. Copyright is necessary bc it shows the meaning of AETN, and the year it was aired. 7. OMG the music gets louder and louder. The view is good, the logo is so 80s, but the music is the worst part. It gets louder 'til the end. Ugh. Also, this logo started in 1985. 6. Yep, this one is cheesy for sure. For '76, it's OK, but for now, it's ugly AF. The color of the BG is gross. THANK GOD ANOTHER FUNNY COMMERCIAL BREAK!!! The Cardboard Mirror 😂😂😂 don't you know it's opaque? Meaning it can't reflect so it's not a mirror? The lid for a metal pot: The noise is goofy ahh 😂 Galactic K25+: It's just a Samsung Galaxy. But more advanced. THE SLOGAN IS FRICKING FUNNY 😂😂😂 Now back to the main program: 5. OK, first off, ur recreation of the V of Steel is nice. But this logo sucks tho. The animation is bad af. The music is fine tho. Disco-y imo. 4. UGH I HATE THE SYNTH. Who thinks this fits?! I know scanimate is common in the 70s but MY GOD this is cheap like it costs just a $20 bill. The synth is so ATROCIOUS AS F***. 3. Classic. I found out this is from Heart's concert in '76. But Kai the Logo Guy absolutely HATES THIS. Because of these reasons: • The longevity of the logo ('76-'94, but now we found out it's only seen once in 1976) • The animation • The music • THE FONT 2. The font is fricking unreadable. The E looks like a C, the T looks like a J since it's flipped. Sure this is from 1971 but my gosh this is bad for today. UGH? More like AUGHHHH Honorable Mentions: 1. This logo is worse than the next one in number 5. 2. The music kinda sounds the same as the Idaho one in number 9. But the font is BOLD THAT I CAN'T READ IT PROPERLY! Just kidding. 3. First PBS logo when it's called PBS (before this, it's called NET). Boring, just an announcer saying that this is PBS, and just saying the meaning of it. 4. The beep of the countdown is irritating. Like the skyline of California tho. 5. Ah yes this one. I saw this at Kai's top 10 scariest PBS logos. It's #7 in that list. But it's just looks like a ripoff of WGBH. Recap? FUGETABOUTIT. Let's just go to number 1 instead. 1. OH MY GOD THE FRICKING TRAIL EFFECT. Funny how the station's name is WHYY. F*CK YOU DELAWARE FOR THIS. YOU TOO PHILLY. Ugh. This is absolutely the worst logo ever. Your city is PHILLY? Dang I thought you like the 76ers for some reason. But seriously. This logo is bad. And that's it. Edit: I read your reply to my reply saying that some of the logos are outdated. But there's just one more error I saw. #5 started not in 1979, but 1981. But #1 is from 1982?? That looks like it's from '74-'77. Not '82. But UGH this logo is so much cheese. Edit 2: Alright nvm, recap reaction time! 10. With a mariachi band? Maybe it's all trumpets. 9. "The next worst thing since the iPhone radar alarm" 💀💀💀 8. Nothing? 7. My ears 💀 6. cheese 5. Haha the outline glows 4. I T ' S S O L O N G T H A T I T L O O K S S O F O R M A L 3. Meh idk that font 2. So what logo overtakes it? HM: 1. Umm... ok 2. IT'S SO BOLD 3. generic 4. A test card?! 5. ye we forgot abt maine Another reaction for #1: Ok, WHAT?! YEAH I'VE SEEN WORSE. Combine the last two logos and that's what u get. But the year. 🤦♂️ Seriously, that's from the 80s? 1982? NINETEEN EIGHTY TWO?! why?! That looks like it's from the 70s, but I understand it's the 70s-80s transition, that's why. I T ' S S O C H E E S Y I T L O O K S C H E E S I E R T H A N G R I L L E D C H E E S E A N D A C H E E S E B U R G E R. Another edit. I mean yeah No. 4 was from 1975, but come on, compare this to today, and you quickly say that we have better logos today bc the synth 😡😡😡
I got the information for the logos off AVID (formerly the CLG Wiki), and they tend to be pretty accurate with the dates. I will say a couple of the logos' dates are outdated, but I couldn't update them before getting the video out cuz the wiki was down. But for KTCA and KUED, they say the dates that I put for them in the video, so I'm just going off of that. Interesting to hear your thoughts on these logos tho.
Once again I just want to say thank you all for not only watching this video, but also getting my channel to 1,000 subs! I cannot thank y'all enough for the support you have given this channel for the many years you have, even if my upload schedule has been sporadic. This was in production for five years and I lost motivation to continue making the video, but since we hit the milestone, I felt like it was only right to finally finish this video instead of leaving y'all empty handed. Shoutout to Mega Shadow, Larry the Lone Wolf and UltraMac Productions for helping me out with this video! Only time will tell when my next Top 10 video will come out. This is MrDIRECTOREIGHT signing off!
Also I'm gonna just put this at the end in case someone takes this as a legitimate list: Most of the opinions and comments in this video are purely satire and are not meant to be taken seriously otherwise.
Well, well, welcome back, man! :D Gosh, I can't wait to see your Top 10. I been watching your previous ones and I enjoyed them. Seeing you return is truly amazing thing ever.
5:01 Yes!! The introduction of the new entry transitions
The commercial breaks deserve a subscribe
As a fan of all your previous logo countdowns since they were brand-new, I must say it's such a delightful surprise seeing you return to more amusing content like this (complete with your hilarious "ad breaks")! Please keep it up! The more RUclipsrs reviewing logos, the better!
Awwwww the baby shadow icon so cute 😊
Damn, this is a blast in the past for me
I would rewatch your logo videos my freshman year of high school in 2018, and i must say, you’re still doing a great job!
Good to have you back!
15:39 | even it look like the OC APLHA logo (idk if they steal it or they DIDNT KNOW the logo exist but IS REALLY LOOK LIKE IT)
But yeah I REALLY like this video ( I think this your BEST top 10 logo video )
It's about time that we see another Top 10 logos video.
This feels like revisting an old friend. All of my previous favorite logo youtubers all here. Keep up the good work man. We need more people like you since so many of the other logo videos are just idiots that don't know what they're talking about. I'll never grow out of these videos.
the funniest things about the font for kwsu is that the w is a upside down m, and the fonts name is STOP, like the font was warning to them to stop them from making it
also #4 isn’t a pbs station, it’s just a production unit
This man came back when we needed him the most
i love the amount of skits in this, its amazing
That's WHY MrDIRECTOREIGHT IS THE MVP! HE'S THE GOAT! THE GOAT!!!!!!🐐
I love the S.C.E.T logo. The music, the colors, and the logo are good in my opinion.
At the end of the day, I don't actually hate the logo. I find some charm in how cheesy it is, the music's good and I kinda like the color combination. The animation's a bit basic, but it's fine. The end result is like the only thing I don't really like that much.
the fact this has an actual reaction makes it different from others like a mix of Nostalgia Critic/AVGN(Because of The Skits),RioGio0447 (because of Robert's and Your Voice similarity),and No. Prods(Because of the fake commercials and the Numbers before each logos).Good Job
Well, it’s about time, and, can’t wait for this to be premiered and can’t wait for more warnings and commercials, so yep, nothing else to say any further.
Out of all the list youve done this honestly was the funniest one
Aye thanks man. I'm glad you enjoyed it!
@@MrDIRECTOREIGHT been watching yo shit since 2016 bro you improved Hella keep grindin boss
amazing video as always!! Great to see the top 10s back!
Will admit. This was actually a great list, plus a funny video for the price of one.
The UNC logo at #2 looks like a pbs production company couldn’t figure out how to make something original for themselves so they had to force some wannabe hippie that dropped out of high school to make any random design for their logo. Same goes to the KWSU logo. I’m glad you’re back and congrats on 1,000 subscribers. Have you seen the A.K.A. Cartoon Logo? Maybe for the next logo list that you make, it could be in the top 10?
You know, some of your editing in this video reminds me of the older Caddicarus videos, spefically those from pre-2020. And I mean that as a compliment.
The commentary style, I was mainly inspired by Scott the Woz, he's one of my favorite creators on RUclips. But there are a couple instances where I was inspired by Caddicarus, specifically the part where I yell "WHAT?!?" while talking about #1 lol. But yeah I can see the comparisons, I appreciate that.
I swear #9 was an attempt to recreate the WGBH synth bit with a budget of a shoestring. GBH resident here, it still sucks you barely hear it anymore.
I Like This
Number 4 sounded like a pinball machine
As a fellow South Carolina resident, putting the ETV logo on this list is a dishonor to our community.
Just kidding, great video!
20:47 The classic "prcscnjs".
You should make a tutorial on how to make logo videos and how you record footage of these logos.
Been a very long time, MrDirectoreight. I hope the years has treated you kindly. :)
And congratulations for 1000 subscribers
Youre in my hometown
return of the king
I look forward for more top 10 logo videos from you if you could sometime in the future
2:21 Where do I recognize that voice from? 🤔
welcome back to form.
I still remember when I did that YTP of the prequel
I’m your biggest fan
How I missed your Top 10 videos! I loved these commercials, I miss NationFarm, the cheesiness of these logos made me narf a hundred times (OMG ANIMANIACS REFERENCE CONFIRMED!!!!!!! 😲🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓🤓😂😂😂😂😂), and they did the moog synthesizers so dirty. I honestly reccomend this video of yours! 🤗❤
♪♪trees! 🌳🌲🌴♪♪
Thanks man! I'm glad you enjoyed this video!
You’re back!
If only No. and ENunn come back too!
This is my first of your's.
Hep, it sounds like trees
11:37
(Rare footage) user dox himself due to a bad pbs station id.
Lmao i knew someone was gonna say that
Thank you for avoiding the KUCB Unalaska bandwagon. It’s just text from a character generator in a tiny community in the middle of nowhere.
In fact, I was inspired by KUCB for my birthday one year. I was petting my doggo while I blew out the candles.
Holy crap dude i missed ur vids
The intros (and some commentary) were taken from No. Entertainment from 5+ years ago.
19:50 the font for KWSU is called Stop, it isn’t unable to read. They just didn’t use the font properly, the W is clearly an upside-down M!
I mean just off the name of the font, they should've just stopped right there lmao
The font was also used by mpt from 1984 to 1999,and yet their logos arent ugly
@@aaronclemente5086i think it’s also because kwsu is an outline, while mpt is not
we are so back
Ah yes finally 👍👍👍
What alarm is this? 0:03
12:48 was that a hotel Mario reference because it sounds like it
No it wasn't, but that's funny now that I think of it lol
Yea lol just how you said it sounded exactly like it
nice!
12:45 WHAT THE F*CK
0:01 bro is a spiderman fan💀
A very graining amount of cheese, and not the good cheese.
Why sid you have to use the worst quality version of the number 7 logo? Alden found a version from 1987 that sounds WAY less quiet than the one you used for your logo.
The funny
I ordered the Galactic K25+ Ultra from Samsang. Where is it? :)
Edit: This is Amir btw. Sup
5:14
I never heard who Larry the Lone WOlf is, but I already have reservations against him. He somehow thinks the designers from a logo from 50 years ago would stumble upon this video, and try to make another ident with the only constructive feedback being “do better.”
Very helpful, man. How about you “do better” with your criticism of an ident being discussed by tons of other people like Ian already.
For the South Carolina ETV ident, I would’ve put the logo with the turd/diarrhea color scheme from the early 70s . Aside from the colors, The Scanimate, font type, and music were all awful.
Where tf have you been the past 11 months?
Working on music and videos while also tryna find a job, it's been a lot going on, please be patient
damn the carolinas sucked at making logos in the 70s/early 80s
i found a another logo thats way worse than WHYY-TV 12 and even the logo is tv dx and has the worst tv dx quality
its called televiziunea română this bunch of cheese logo is made in roman in the 1970s and is worse than WHYY-TV 12 pick the logo in your next top 10 cheesy logos video
My opinions:
10. This logo started in 1981. Not 1978. It's fine imo. Not much to say about it.
9. Ugh imagine this is ur alarm. This ain't an alarm in Ohio, it's an alarm in Idaho this time! The view is beautiful imo. But OMG the music is awful UGH.
8. Gold and purple is a dull color scheme, but the gold is shiny so it's fine. The N is weird bc it should connect perfectly to the circle. Copyright is necessary bc it shows the meaning of AETN, and the year it was aired.
7. OMG the music gets louder and louder. The view is good, the logo is so 80s, but the music is the worst part. It gets louder 'til the end. Ugh. Also, this logo started in 1985.
6. Yep, this one is cheesy for sure. For '76, it's OK, but for now, it's ugly AF. The color of the BG is gross.
THANK GOD ANOTHER FUNNY COMMERCIAL BREAK!!!
The Cardboard Mirror 😂😂😂 don't you know it's opaque? Meaning it can't reflect so it's not a mirror?
The lid for a metal pot: The noise is goofy ahh 😂
Galactic K25+: It's just a Samsung Galaxy. But more advanced. THE SLOGAN IS FRICKING FUNNY 😂😂😂
Now back to the main program:
5. OK, first off, ur recreation of the V of Steel is nice. But this logo sucks tho. The animation is bad af. The music is fine tho. Disco-y imo.
4. UGH I HATE THE SYNTH. Who thinks this fits?! I know scanimate is common in the 70s but MY GOD this is cheap like it costs just a $20 bill. The synth is so ATROCIOUS AS F***.
3. Classic. I found out this is from Heart's concert in '76. But Kai the Logo Guy absolutely HATES THIS. Because of these reasons:
• The longevity of the logo ('76-'94, but now we found out it's only seen once in 1976)
• The animation
• The music
• THE FONT
2. The font is fricking unreadable. The E looks like a C, the T looks like a J since it's flipped. Sure this is from 1971 but my gosh this is bad for today. UGH? More like AUGHHHH
Honorable Mentions:
1. This logo is worse than the next one in number 5.
2. The music kinda sounds the same as the Idaho one in number 9. But the font is BOLD THAT I CAN'T READ IT PROPERLY! Just kidding.
3. First PBS logo when it's called PBS (before this, it's called NET). Boring, just an announcer saying that this is PBS, and just saying the meaning of it.
4. The beep of the countdown is irritating. Like the skyline of California tho.
5. Ah yes this one. I saw this at Kai's top 10 scariest PBS logos. It's #7 in that list. But it's just looks like a ripoff of WGBH.
Recap? FUGETABOUTIT. Let's just go to number 1 instead.
1. OH MY GOD THE FRICKING TRAIL EFFECT. Funny how the station's name is WHYY. F*CK YOU DELAWARE FOR THIS. YOU TOO PHILLY. Ugh. This is absolutely the worst logo ever. Your city is PHILLY? Dang I thought you like the 76ers for some reason. But seriously. This logo is bad.
And that's it.
Edit: I read your reply to my reply saying that some of the logos are outdated. But there's just one more error I saw. #5 started not in 1979, but 1981.
But #1 is from 1982?? That looks like it's from '74-'77. Not '82. But UGH this logo is so much cheese.
Edit 2: Alright nvm, recap reaction time!
10. With a mariachi band? Maybe it's all trumpets.
9. "The next worst thing since the iPhone radar alarm" 💀💀💀
8. Nothing?
7. My ears 💀
6. cheese
5. Haha the outline glows
4. I T ' S S O L O N G T H A T I T L O O K S S O F O R M A L
3. Meh idk that font
2. So what logo overtakes it?
HM:
1. Umm... ok
2. IT'S SO BOLD
3. generic
4. A test card?!
5. ye we forgot abt maine
Another reaction for #1:
Ok, WHAT?!
YEAH I'VE SEEN WORSE. Combine the last two logos and that's what u get. But the year. 🤦♂️ Seriously, that's from the 80s? 1982? NINETEEN EIGHTY TWO?! why?! That looks like it's from the 70s, but I understand it's the 70s-80s transition, that's why. I T ' S S O C H E E S Y I T L O O K S C H E E S I E R T H A N G R I L L E D C H E E S E A N D A C H E E S E B U R G E R.
Another edit.
I mean yeah No. 4 was from 1975, but come on, compare this to today, and you quickly say that we have better logos today bc the synth 😡😡😡
I got the information for the logos off AVID (formerly the CLG Wiki), and they tend to be pretty accurate with the dates. I will say a couple of the logos' dates are outdated, but I couldn't update them before getting the video out cuz the wiki was down. But for KTCA and KUED, they say the dates that I put for them in the video, so I'm just going off of that. Interesting to hear your thoughts on these logos tho.
Also, I gotta say 1975-1985 are the years that has the cheesiest PBS stations logos.
@@MrDIRECTOREIGHTwhy dont you use logopedia
Return of the king