Sitz bath tubs are bad for your hemorrhoids! Please do not buy these!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 окт 2024

Комментарии • 386

  • @Alineko82
    @Alineko82 Год назад +34

    I had a huge hem for a year, right in the middle, finally got serious about sitz baths three times a day. To my suprise a week later it was gone... i mean... gone gone. It fell off. 😅 One of the happiest days of my life.

    • @magicminutes340
      @magicminutes340 7 месяцев назад +2

      Wowww happy for you

      Currently dealing with this😢

    • @bellonazir4419
      @bellonazir4419 4 месяца назад

      Wow mine is about 8 months now still yet I still have them

    • @magicminutes340
      @magicminutes340 4 месяца назад

      @@bellonazir4419 may I ask internal or external

  • @addictedtogear
    @addictedtogear 11 месяцев назад +17

    It’s great that the doctor is telling you what not to do but perhaps he can also include what you should do as part of the video. It would be more helpful

    • @CityStarrzz
      @CityStarrzz Месяц назад

      The rest of his channel is telling you exactly that… you haven’t really looked have you

  • @r8chlletters
    @r8chlletters 8 месяцев назад +20

    He’s not saying not to soak. He’s saying the mechanical position of using an on-toilet sitz can make the condition worse.

  • @Anthony-fu6cl
    @Anthony-fu6cl Год назад +106

    With all due respect, I have to disagree that these toilet sitz baths have no benefits. I had extremely bad external hemorrhoids last week and bought one of these from Amazon out of desperation because I can't fill my tub. Out of everything I tried, from Prep H, Lidocaine, and oral analgesics like Tylenol and Advil, sitting in one of these for 15 minutes reduced my pain the most and for the longest. My pain went from a 9/10 to a 4/10 for several hours afterwards, the sitz bath was worth it. Anatomically I understand what you're saying, and that's why I wouldn't recommend a prolonged session, but the amount of pain reduction just from using a toilet sitz bath should not be taken for granted.

    • @sisterspooky
      @sisterspooky Год назад +10

      @Anthony_fu6cI - With all due respect, your personal experience aside, what the doctor is describing is the physical effects of those apparatuses and how they’re a net negative for the _majority_ of hemorrhoid situations.
      It’s nice you had a good experience, but in situations, as he described above, they’re doing more harm than good. The idea is to reduce the hemorrhoids, thus the pain will be alleviated. That device isn’t going to reduce anything physical. It’s the same with a massage… one can massage a sore area and make it feel good, but massaging the same area too long and it’ll make the muscle hurt worse.
      It’s wonderful it worked for you, but perhaps your situation wasn’t quite as severe as others. _(And that’s awesome!)_ However, as a physician, his understanding of how these things impact the overall situation will be more informed, and it’s best to leave it to the experts. Anecdotal evidence is helpful in some situations, but it’s still anecdotal evidence. 😉
      Have a wonderful week. 😀

    • @Anthony-fu6cl
      @Anthony-fu6cl Год назад +18

      @@sisterspooky you may not have meant it that way, but your message comes off as very passive aggressive and patronizing. I already said I understood the physical/anatomical reasons why he doesn't recommend the bath. I watched the video and understood it very clearly. I was simply sharing my anecdotal evidence which relieved pain for me so others can also weigh in if it worked. No one has to take a random strangers evidence as fact, but if you read reviews for anything at all, then you probably do AT LEAST consider them. You'd also be surprised at how often doctor's can be wrong, that is why it always recommended to ask several doctors. Of course anything of a good thing isn't a good thing, I never recommended sitting on it for hours on end. Pain management and relief should not be underestimated. That is why hospitals have many sorts of distraction therapy and other non-pharmacological methods for pain management. There is evidence based (aka studies based off of many patient's ANECDOTAL stories gathered through surveys) that reports relief from different therapies. The reason sitz baths were even recommended in the first place was because of this evidence based proof that it works for pain relief.

    • @MrElPoderozo1
      @MrElPoderozo1 Год назад +6

      I agree with you. I was in a lot of pain. The kind of pain that could make a full grown man cry, yes! I almost cried of pain and the pain woke me up in the middle of the night.
      I have a feasure and I don't wish this on nobody. I am still dealing with it and it is a very slow healing process VERY SLOW. I purchased a Sitz bath and the very first try it seemed to have helped. Just don't go over 5 minutes because what the doctor here is saying will happen and is true.
      But I am willing to bet ANY money that when a person has a feasure and has tried preparation H, and any other cream but still has not helped, that person WILL be buying a Sitz bath real fast😂

    • @mrmyagi2123
      @mrmyagi2123 Год назад +6

      Sitz baths have been my most productive anti hemorrhoid solution. Minimizes swelling and erases pain.

    • @Jupiter29
      @Jupiter29 Год назад +2

      Did it reduce the size of the hemorrhoid ?? Or just the pain?

  • @the_average_backpacker
    @the_average_backpacker 2 года назад +31

    I'm so glad I came across this. It validated what I've been experiencing during my hemorrhoidectomy recovery. I'm in week 2 and am still sitting in the bathtub because I couldn't tolerate sitting in the toilet-mounted sitz bath for any amount of time.

    • @pitdawg6418
      @pitdawg6418 Год назад

      For how long to you lay in your bathtub to soak and how many times a week? Thank you, speedy healing I'm on my 1st week of a hemorrhoidectomy

    • @the_average_backpacker
      @the_average_backpacker Год назад +3

      @@pitdawg6418 sending my best to you! I was soaking 15-30 mins after each BM and also anytime the pain was just not manageable with meds. Walking hurt so much but definitely do it even if you're in pain. Of course listen to your body - sometimes I started feeling better after 5-10 mins of walking, sometimes I felt worse and would stop.

    • @Brandon-ih9fu
      @Brandon-ih9fu 2 месяца назад

      Day 7 (hemroiddectomy) recovery and I feel you! Using the shower technique and it's been helping. Here's to your recovery, mine and others!

  • @2-2Wrlrd
    @2-2Wrlrd Год назад +12

    Doc! I’m a pharmacist and thank you for your insight! You are spot on and this is great information! I’m glad you described all of this material clearly and slowly because many elderly people will find this very helpful. I admit I talk way to fast and I have to remind myself to slow down. As you know, if they don’t comprehend the concept they will be lost and forget everything thereby wasting our time! Don’t listen to the jack wagons saying to speed up. It’s perfect for understanding this material.

    • @bh9262
      @bh9262 11 месяцев назад

      I hope if you are distributing ciprofloxacin to people that you are properly warning them of the potential side effects! And that alternative antibiotics should be considered if available! Its horrible!

  • @userpkcu
    @userpkcu 2 года назад +22

    you're so friendly! I'm not even near you but so grateful for your friendliness all your patients are so lucky to have you. many blessings to you and your family

  • @keosh777
    @keosh777 11 месяцев назад +7

    For my post hemorrhoid surgery I was recommended by my proctologist to do sitz bath with Epsom salts using warm water. The product I use is the first one you mentioned. For me, it really calmed out mild itching. My proctologist said a key factor to less post operative pain is cleanliness. I was uhmm pretty anal about my sitz bath routine after surgery. I can report zero post operative pain. None. I know this is absolutely not the norm. Feeling fortunate. I'll attribute my excellent recovery in part to the sitz bath routine. I'll look at your other videos regarding options for sitz bath.

  • @tazmo2239
    @tazmo2239 2 года назад +19

    Totally agree with this and ties in with my findings. Trying to get rid of an external hemorrhoid, using a recently purchased Sitz bath for 10 mins and my hemorrhoid had blown up. Not using this again. I wish I’d seen this sooner. Thank you for the video.

    • @deonpetersenportfolio8701
      @deonpetersenportfolio8701 2 года назад +2

      What worked for you to get it away?

    • @cibiecibie
      @cibiecibie Год назад +1

      I'm regretting for purchasing a sitz bath basin now. I'm on my 3rd day and it's not too much pain except for when i poo but i bought is as per my doctor advised me.

    • @tazmo2239
      @tazmo2239 Год назад

      @@cibiecibie I found it’s much better if you run a proper bath about 6-8”, mix in some Epsom salts, and then sit/relax in that for 20 mins or so. There’s not so much pressure as you get with the sitz bath (toilet mounted ones) and on the whole (pun intended 😁) it was much better.

    • @vanderer_prashant
      @vanderer_prashant 8 месяцев назад

      But I wonder whether sitz bath helps in treating anal fissures for those who don't have a hemorrhoid

  • @cindy2418
    @cindy2418 2 года назад +14

    I am using a sitz bath after a hemmroid removal and it’s helping me with the pain a lot.

    • @91rahuldesai
      @91rahuldesai 2 года назад +2

      Sitz bath tubs really help

    • @kleparaskevas2628
      @kleparaskevas2628 2 года назад

      Id you have rubber bands to hemorrhoids?

    • @1CasHale
      @1CasHale Год назад

      Why did the doctor like this comment ìf he's saying sitzs baths are bad???

    • @stephaniehowe0973
      @stephaniehowe0973 8 месяцев назад

      ​@@kleparaskevas2628
      Your doctor is often required by insurance. Even when he knows it won't ever work.
      It's a miserable feeling very painful & the band will come off.
      With out the roid.

  • @caseythelion46
    @caseythelion46 Год назад +15

    If I’m honest, my mini sitz bath was a LIFESAVER when I had my anal fistula seton placement. I would frequently have the problem of my handheld bidet not getting everything off that area when I went to the bathroom, but the sitz would leave me completely clean. It’s really nice for when you’re too sore to bend down to get into a bathtub, which was my main problem after my seton placement. If it’s not good for hemorrhoids then it’s at least good for fistulas!

    • @mikelam339
      @mikelam339 Год назад +1

      I just got my seton placement today and haven't use the sitz bath yet. Still have the guaze packing around the wound. Is it better to soak everything then take off the bandage?

  • @suereed3474
    @suereed3474 Год назад +8

    I had a plastic bowl that fit into my toilet seat. Sitz baths worked for me, giving me great relief. I had an allergic reaction to the hemorrhoid cream the doctor prescribed. An antihistamine stopped that.

  • @dwilliams3730
    @dwilliams3730 2 года назад +5

    Really appreciate your videos doctor. You keep this difficult subject light, informative and professional. I wish you were located in my city.

  • @jamilaabdullahi7784
    @jamilaabdullahi7784 3 года назад +8

    I'm so glad and grateful for this wonderful channel🙏

  • @nt4409
    @nt4409 2 года назад +3

    Thank you for uploading this video, this really supports what i thought initially.

  • @Inmate533
    @Inmate533 2 года назад +7

    I love friendly proctologists. Thank you for the info doctor!

  • @fourbanks
    @fourbanks Год назад +7

    Swimming in the warm sea regularly is the only cure I know of and always has worked for me over the past 50 years

  • @waynehunt9165
    @waynehunt9165 Год назад +3

    I so agree! I’ve questioned the difference between sitting on a toilet and sitting in a sitz bath. Makes no sense to sit in a sitz bath for 10-15 minutes!

  • @soniasultana4734
    @soniasultana4734 Год назад

    that,s greaty you're so friendly! Really appreciate you.Thank you for uploading, this really supports what i thought accuratly.

  • @uvrays7939
    @uvrays7939 3 года назад +6

    My home remedy is to relax in a hot bath with 2 handfuls of rough pure salt and 2 capfulls of antiseptic.

  • @JRock-vf4fw
    @JRock-vf4fw Год назад

    Thank you so much! You saved me time, money, and energy. Keep those learning videos coming.

  • @dianawilliams-coe7747
    @dianawilliams-coe7747 Год назад +1

    I was just about to purchase this tub. Glad I came across this video.

  • @Brandon-ih9fu
    @Brandon-ih9fu 2 месяца назад

    Just started using mine (previously using shower technique for hemroids) Thought hey give it a try! Had a hemroiddectomy last Thursday. Found out real fast (day 2) how uncomfortable they are and second prob most important, possibilities of uti's. So now I do the shower technique and will never use a sitz bath again! Does the same thing and more comfortable to do, could use the tub but would have to clean it out everytime and I can't be bending down scrubbing it. It does help some with the pain management but telling you can get same results from warm shower running down your backside. If it works for you hell yeah if not I hope you find one that does help! Hope everyone here wins their battles with these issues we have. It can weigh heavily in many ways and alter our day to days... We got this! Health and happiness to everyone!

  • @boyka1827
    @boyka1827 2 года назад +13

    For those who disagree with the video. Here are my 50 cents. I had an internal hemorrhoid surgery 2 weeks ago. I agree with you about the benefits of warm water, but everybody uses warm water in different ways to minimize the pain. Some people put water in Sitz bath and some use bathtub. For the first week after surgery, I tried to avoid what Dr said in the video by kneeling on my knee to poop while warm water was pouring on my lower back from the bathtub faucet to reduce the pain and it worked. I bought the Sitz bath to put on top of the toilet and put warm water in it but it didn't work (to reduce the pain, the water have to be hot. I put the ratio as 90% hot and 10% cold). Also, pooping while on my knee reduce the time of sitting which was more helpful for hemorrhoids.
    P/S: I didn't watch this video before. As of right now, I'm 20 days after surgery. I'm pretty much back to work but lifting heavy stuff (worst surgery I ever had in my life. The pain was horrible)

    • @MisterPotter
      @MisterPotter 2 года назад +1

      So I should trust a person that makes more money by treating than having healthy patients hmmmmmmm

    • @ajrockinshockin2893
      @ajrockinshockin2893 2 года назад +2

      I use a Squatty Potty and it helps. You can find them online. Also there are RUclips videos that show and tell you how and why it works. Good luck 👍

    • @mtorres1422
      @mtorres1422 2 года назад +1

      100% agree about surgery. Wrost pain I’ve ever experienced. (I should add I’ve broken my skull before)

    • @Mindovermatter767
      @Mindovermatter767 2 года назад

      Boyka hope you are doing well! What issue made you have surgery were you in pain Ihave been in pain for 2 weeks no blood or outbreak 80 percent healthy.

    • @boyka1827
      @boyka1827 2 года назад

      @@Mindovermatter767 there was a bit of blood coming from my rectal when I go to poop so I decided to have a surgery to remove the internal hemorrhoirds to put an end to the problem. As of right now, it has been 4 months from the surgery and I'm enjoying my life. I know you've been 2 weeks but my experience was the pain will come on and off even the 3rd week. It sucks but you won't feel normal until a month after the surgery so think about the positive activities and walk a bit if you can.

  • @naubaucat
    @naubaucat 7 месяцев назад

    That makes a lot of sense, and I find sitting in a tub of warm water is a lot better with less pressure.

  • @topdrive4086
    @topdrive4086 11 месяцев назад

    Chung is spot on here. These contraptions are counterproductive. Someone who goes into intricate details can understand. These tubs exacerbate the hemorrhoids by letting them hang into without support. I’ve experienced the same & was always left thinking about their efficacy. I think a bigger solo tub in which one can sit, lay down would be a better bet.

  • @Cap10osama
    @Cap10osama Год назад +6

    Hello Doctor, thank you for your videos and informations… Does this information apply to the fissures as well or is it only for hemorrhoids cases?

  • @hk0195
    @hk0195 2 года назад +1

    You are 100% right my flare gets even worse after sitz bath in that toilet bowl

  • @AllanAmericoBerti
    @AllanAmericoBerti Год назад +1

    While sitz bath tubs may be a relaxing option for some people, it's important to keep in mind that they can be harmful for hemorrhoids and consider other treatment options. You upload very good content to your youtube channel, congratulations, keep it up

  • @aokiQ
    @aokiQ Год назад +1

    Thanks for clearing this, I bought one thinking how is this gonna make me better? It was recommended to use for 15-20 min. I couldn’t stay on for that long. 5-6 min is max for me 😂 now I know why! Thank you ❤

  • @sinfashion0
    @sinfashion0 8 месяцев назад

    Thank you much dr. What would you recommend for fissures due to chronic diarrhea

  • @moeezyspanishletras
    @moeezyspanishletras Год назад +2

    Sitz bath was my miracle. Just don’t use them right after you have a bowel movement. That’s when they make the pain worst. The sitz bath is the best thing if you have a problem with swelling.

  • @maryknight7969
    @maryknight7969 Год назад

    My mom is 100 yrs old, doesn't have hemorrhoids. Tub isn't an option. There's a bidet attachment. A sitz is covered by Medicare. Peri cleanliness is paramount. Her parts are worn out, and approaching stool on the left is visible on her lower pelvic area. Depends are irritating and hold dampness. She has a weak bladder and uses the toilet 2x/hr; it's a huge issue. Even a washcloth is irritating after awhile. After seeing your explanations, I'll compromise and allow a bubbling Sitz bath from 1/2 - 3 minutes max (timed) and not every day. Maybe there is an inflatable she can use while horizontal in the bed, and I must research, as the aging process will require new strategies. I appreciate your soothing and clear explanations and plan to look at your other topics.

  • @isabellechouinard1024
    @isabellechouinard1024 7 месяцев назад

    Thank you for your comments on sitz bath, but it would be nice that you propose an alternative way to soothe itchiness at the bottom end area.😉

  • @lucyziegler
    @lucyziegler Год назад

    My hospital sent me home with one after giving birth because my stitches were swollen and I had hemroids from pushing, I highly disagree that it has no use. It very much did help

  • @swimbait1
    @swimbait1 8 месяцев назад

    I have a rice filled heating pad called the bed buddy and I put it in the microwave for two minutes to warm it up. I then lay down and place it under me and across the painful area. It works amazing and stays warm easily for an hour. You could probably make something similar with a cloth bag (a sock maybe?) filled with rice.

  • @emarshall2171
    @emarshall2171 2 года назад +3

    I listened to your logic here and I can't say I agree. While I don't suffer from an issue, my relative does and I am helping to find solutions. My logic is that while some of what you suggest here may be true, there appears to be more benefit from the application the warm water AND mineral than harm gravity might cause. For instance, having to spend more time on the toilet because your condition may also involve constipation does more harm to the hemorrhoids according to your logic. If the device has been proven to relax the area and calm the hemorrhoids, then you stand a better chance of having to spend less time sitting on the toilet when its pooping time, despite the con you've outlined. To me its a matter of weighing the pros and cons.

  • @vforvaishu8030
    @vforvaishu8030 2 года назад

    Very informative very helpful .......I hv canceled my order of sitz bath tub, which was about to deliver Tomorrow 👍🏻

  • @philipadam7870
    @philipadam7870 7 месяцев назад

    I’m about to have a procedure in the UK called Exroid, it is none surgical and comes highly recommended. Does anyone know of this, including you kind and most generous doctor! Thank you for responding…

  • @nikvh437
    @nikvh437 Год назад +2

    I've been using a sitz bath for about 2 weeks for a perianal abscess surgery I had and I can tell it's causing hemmhroids that I've otherwise never noticed so this makes sense. Solve one issue and cause another!

    • @daithunnarzari1259
      @daithunnarzari1259 11 месяцев назад +1

      Same issue.. I had perianal abscess surgery. Now facing problem of hemorrhoids 😢

    • @nikvh437
      @nikvh437 11 месяцев назад

      @@daithunnarzari1259 it took a while but they’ve mellowed put thankfully

  • @judilynn9569
    @judilynn9569 2 года назад +3

    Is this regarding use with hemorrhoids or after removal? Post op people say it's their best friend.

  • @rpersen
    @rpersen 3 года назад +6

    I occasionally use organic extra virgin coconut oil as an ointment, it gives quite the good pain relief. Is this something you recommend or not? Thanks.

    • @yourfriendlyproctologist
      @yourfriendlyproctologist  3 года назад +5

      I don't recommend it, but it wouldn't be dangerous to do so. If it helps you, I don't have an issue with it.

    • @xris423
      @xris423 Год назад

      @@yourfriendlyproctologist can my 6 yo son use the creams that has ingredients of lidocaine / phenyl? It always says for ages 12 and up.

  • @ezraomenyi1259
    @ezraomenyi1259 2 года назад +10

    Am a medical student who just got fissures and hemorrhoids. What I can say is that when you are experiencing the pain nothing really matters other than getting the relief. The pain is so much that you just cry for that relief and would do anything to have it go away. If eating uncooked rats will give me relief I’ll do it in a second.
    My observation is that use the sitz bath during the acute moments when you have the pain. For me it’s after having a bowel movement. And when not in pain don’t use it. Also minimize the time you spend on the sitz bath to the minimum time needed to give you relief.
    There is a reality that patients going through something have and only those who have gone through it can understand.
    Also as a medical student, I believe that you need to have a peer reviewed study to state sitz bath are bad.

    • @yourfriendlyproctologist
      @yourfriendlyproctologist  2 года назад +13

      Thanks for commenting Ezra and thanks for watching the videos.
      Allow me to clarify a detail to you that you may have missed. I do not discourage sitz baths. I discourage the use of sitz baths TUBS as shown in this video.
      It's ok to disagree with me. It's ok to express your opinion. However, I will say the fact you are a "medical student" is completely irrelevant to your point. And the fact you mention your title so often seems to imply your fissure is different from everyone else or that your opinion carries more "evidence."
      May I offer some unsolicited advice? I would suggest you self-reflect and adjust your tone. There is a difference between expressing your opinion in a manner that will open people's ears to HEAR and expressing as you've done above where people want to walk away. Your patients and colleagues will know the difference. As a medical student, you have a long road ahead. I wish you luck as you gain knowledge and wisdom.

    • @owlcarnival
      @owlcarnival 2 года назад +3

      @@yourfriendlyproctologist Another person suffering from the same condition. I second Ezra. I think Ezra is making good points. There should be more peer reviewed information on the subject. Plenty of other proctologist would have other opinions on the subject.
      I do think you make an interesting point about gravity/blood flow. But do the negatives out way the benefits? Also, different conditions may call for different actions. Perhaps more blood flow can be a good thing. There are so many things that could cause anal irritation. Even the severity of the conditions could also effect treatment.
      Saying something like “you should burn all sitz baths” sounds too definitive. There is so much gray area.

  • @capresti3537
    @capresti3537 2 года назад +50

    I disagree, warm water sitz baths can speed healing by shrinking the hemorrhoids it increases blood flow reduces inflammation and relaxes the anal sphincter. Adding sea salt also speeds healing even faster. Many people claim benefit with these tubs.

    • @ingenuity168
      @ingenuity168 2 года назад +6

      It helped me.

    • @1eldare1
      @1eldare1 2 года назад +3

      do you know if its good for fissure also?

    • @capresti3537
      @capresti3537 2 года назад +1

      @@1eldare1 yes

    • @socalifone3044
      @socalifone3044 2 года назад

      Do you happen to have any type of a medical degree such as a MD DO or PA? I'm not criticizing you I'm just curious. Thanks

    • @capresti3537
      @capresti3537 2 года назад +1

      @@socalifone3044 No but i am a natural medicine researcher.

  • @giftengeorge7182
    @giftengeorge7182 Год назад +1

    I think the best way to counter this is by pooping laying face down butt up.
    Doctor, even though I suffer from hemorrhoids, I never had an idea what this is all about. Thank you so much for the enlightenment

  • @eldarlatif2356
    @eldarlatif2356 2 года назад

    Thanks a lot for the video! How do feel about adding epsom salt to the warm water? Does it really help with hemorrhoids?

    • @shadaimccarter523
      @shadaimccarter523 2 года назад

      Don’t do it!! It burns like hell esp if your surgery is brand new.

  • @dontrecommendchannel
    @dontrecommendchannel Год назад

    hello, I don't have Epsom Salt is it safe to use Baking Soda as an Alternative if it is how much Baking Soda should I add?

  • @scf7334
    @scf7334 Год назад +1

    Is it possible to totally get rid of hemorrhoids without surgery? Or is treating them as good as it gets? I’m pretty sure I have them, but don’t have medical insurance and I’m concerned about what to do… I’ve never had them before.

  • @salma_Nella22
    @salma_Nella22 Год назад

    I appreciate this so much! I just gave birth and I was just about to purchase one but something just felt so off about it. It doesn’t seem practical or sanitary.

  • @IAMZERG
    @IAMZERG 8 месяцев назад

    I think this is part of the reason so many people have issues trusting doctors. They recommend things like sitz baths with good intentions... but that simply make things worse.

  • @altruisticenergy
    @altruisticenergy Год назад

    Your videos have been informative in educating myself on postpartum recovery. Thank you!! 🙏💗

  • @marymastromauro8164
    @marymastromauro8164 8 месяцев назад

    I was told years ago never to use the rings to sit on either, they contricted the muscles in your hips and did not relieve the hemorrhoids

  • @girishnigale4369
    @girishnigale4369 3 года назад +1

    Hello Dr, Video was very informative and thanks for sharing.

  • @arbitrarylib
    @arbitrarylib Год назад +1

    These things are so embarrassing to me. I always had constipation issues, I want to solve that this year.

  • @cutwater1965
    @cutwater1965 2 года назад +1

    Hi Doctor. I WAS researching to buy one of these because recommendations. I have been sitting on a doughnut pillow for many months. According to your priciple, this would be counter-produtive! Am I right?

    • @yourfriendlyproctologist
      @yourfriendlyproctologist  2 года назад +1

      I'm not a fan of donut pillows. This is actually the topic of my next video tomorrow!

  • @scubartistqnolsy
    @scubartistqnolsy Год назад

    wheres the link for a better sitz bath routine please.. thanks..

  • @quocnguyen9152
    @quocnguyen9152 3 года назад +11

    Surgeon recommended sitz bath with epsom salt to treat hemorrhoids prior to surgery. To make sure I understand, you recommend against the over the toilet sitz bath tubs, but you do recommend whole bathtub sitz baths (e.g. without involving a toilet)? While waiting for your next video, do you have any other recommendations?

    • @yourfriendlyproctologist
      @yourfriendlyproctologist  3 года назад +16

      Yes, bathtub sitz baths are better than the toilet versions.

    • @91rahuldesai
      @91rahuldesai 2 года назад +5

      @@yourfriendlyproctologist everyone is not rich to own bathtubs and soak themselves in hot water. I don't own a bathtub - all i have is a toilet and this sitz bath tub. I sit there for five mins and it gives me relaxation post a bowel movement. I have to squat to expel out stool post the first bowel movement - i have like two streams cos i suffer from anismus.
      But sitz bath have always helped

    • @technolive1980
      @technolive1980 2 года назад

      @@yourfriendlyproctologist they are the same thing

    • @baybay7898
      @baybay7898 2 года назад

      @@91rahuldesai they are the same thing. You just need to make sure you change the water (second wash ) if the first wash "polluted" the water.

    • @ennd91
      @ennd91 2 года назад +1

      @@91rahuldesai i too don’t have a tub, only shower, so i bought a washtub just enough for me to fit in and i sit in it in the shower

  • @sharonkahn9803
    @sharonkahn9803 Год назад

    What do you recommend, I do go regularly every day, and honestly I don't push. And then all sudden I've got some, very uncomfortable I'm taking Epsom salt bath
    Anything else you recommend

  • @bh9262
    @bh9262 11 месяцев назад

    Are they good for pelvic floor disfunction? Rectal tightness?

  • @vince1229
    @vince1229 Год назад

    Hot water expands everything. Ice water shrinks everything. I've got a concussion. I'm going to put my head in boiling water so all the blood vessels explode.

  • @justus09
    @justus09 2 года назад +2

    Hi doctor, my wife is pregnant for 8 weeks but is seeing fresh blood from her stool when pooping at times its because she is constipated, what would you recommend to stop the bleeding? Thank you so much

    • @salma_Nella22
      @salma_Nella22 Год назад

      Whenever I see a man here doing research for his wife it warms my heart and makes me smile❤ I’m sorry that you never got an answer from this doctor. I know your post is 6 months old but did you ever get your answer? How is she doing today and what helped her?

  • @timle9069
    @timle9069 2 года назад

    For hemorrhoids sitting on the toilet for a long time is no good. Would’n it be the same thing if having a sitz bath using it the tub on toilet. Is that right doctor? Or any different between them. Thanks for the video

  • @KristinA-xv4yk
    @KristinA-xv4yk 2 года назад +7

    My issue w the toilet insert sitz tubs is that they INSERT INTO THE TOILET 😂 I can’t. I’ll clean my bathtub once a day before I get myself into a cycle of cleaning my toilet after every use in order to not get toilet rim germs on a plastic tub.

    • @Anthony-fu6cl
      @Anthony-fu6cl Год назад

      I was like this too, I'm a huge germaphobe and I live with slobs who don't clean up after themselves. But the payoff in pain reduction after using it was worth it, so I just clean everything twice. No regrets!

  • @kylelipong7403
    @kylelipong7403 2 года назад +1

    Doc after the surgery is it okay to take sleeping pills to help you skip the pain ? Is it effective? Thanks.!

  • @SmurfandTurf97
    @SmurfandTurf97 Год назад +1

    What about after surgery? Is it good to use a sitz?

  • @thomaswhudson
    @thomaswhudson 11 месяцев назад

    I really feel like this feels great after I use it. I have never had a flare up like this, but I def. feel like it helps.

    • @leanpadla
      @leanpadla 8 месяцев назад

      Hemorrhoids flare up / crisis?
      What you need:
      -daflon 1g tabs
      -macrogol 3350 laxative powder
      -water base lube
      ‐clean gloves
      Take daflon tab as directed by the doctor for hemorrhoid crisis dose. Take macrogol 3350 laxative as well 1-2x a day or more until you maintain a soft stool with no straining needed. Maintain the same macrogol frequency.
      Pooping: everytime you are about to poop, where a gloves and apply the lube on your anal area and you gloves prior pooping. Hold you hemorrhoids with your gloved hands from getting fully out of your anus to prevent worsening of the hemorrhoids and/or fissure.
      Do it everytime for 2 months without anal sex. Do regular mild jogging to promote healing.

  • @5353iceman
    @5353iceman 2 года назад +2

    I used my sitz bath a couple of times and found it uncomfortable. I either sit in the bath tube or lay down with an ice pack. Thank you for the video.

  • @suzanmiller558
    @suzanmiller558 4 месяца назад

    I bought one of those sitz baths from Amazon and tried it once. The whole experience was a disaster. Been doing a bath every day.

  • @vinny1010
    @vinny1010 2 года назад +10

    Similar to a Sitz bath, I'm hearing from many who had their Hs vanish in a matter of 2-3 days by sitting on a heavy bucket filled with boiling water and minced garlic cloves. In fact, they found relief minutes after one usage when other doctor-recommended creams or ointments didn't really do much. I'm not saying you're wrong (I'm not a medical professional), but it does make me question the medical theory. Ie. Before gravity makes its negative impact, as you stated, could garlic + steam affect the H faster (by shrinking it) whereby counteracting those negative effects?

  • @suziepeck5717
    @suziepeck5717 Год назад

    I hope it's okay to make the comment that I am about to make. I can definitely understand how the warm water from a sitz bath could be comforting to hemorrhoids sufferers. However as a female, I don't like the idea of my vaginal area soaking in poopy water to be honest. It probably doesn't matter as much to a male. I fail to see how it is sanitary for a woman though. Anyone else agree?

  • @suzanmiller558
    @suzanmiller558 4 месяца назад

    I wish that sitz bath salts that you recommended came in a bigger size since the sitz bath bowl are not good for us and we should use a bathtub you have to use more so that little bag lasts about four baths.

  • @shmackydoodRon
    @shmackydoodRon Год назад

    I was given one by my surgeon. I thought it was a cowboy hat.

  • @saliksayyar9793
    @saliksayyar9793 9 месяцев назад

    May have to do with the size of the individual. May be fine for smaller and thinner folks

  • @mattmatt245
    @mattmatt245 Год назад

    In my opinion warm sitz baths provide some relief for thrombosed external hemorrhoids.

  • @bh9262
    @bh9262 11 месяцев назад

    I haven't gotten better from pelvic floor disfunction after 3 months.i feel a prisoner to the physical therapist

  • @naturegirl4074
    @naturegirl4074 Год назад

    Exactly what o always say. These toilet tubs are totally contradictory.

  • @virginiacooper1929
    @virginiacooper1929 2 года назад

    I've also heard don't sit in a recliner because the same pressure is put on your bottom. Is that true?

  • @steadyeddie7
    @steadyeddie7 3 года назад +2

    Hi Dr, I was looking for one, I have a 4cm bladder stone and BPH, I keep getting bladder infections and uti's, could you please advise me would one of these be of any benefit to me as my main concern is hygiene. Thank you so much.

    • @yourfriendlyproctologist
      @yourfriendlyproctologist  3 года назад +3

      Thank you for sharing your story. I believe the shower or laying flat on your bed will probably be the safest option for you.

    • @steadyeddie7
      @steadyeddie7 3 года назад

      @@yourfriendlyproctologist Thank you for your time and advice, much appreciated, i will follow orders, take care doc.

  • @JaguerRhye
    @JaguerRhye 3 года назад +1

    Thank you for the video. Do you know if regular cold baths each day can help reduce the swelling of internal hemorrhoids?

    • @yourfriendlyproctologist
      @yourfriendlyproctologist  3 года назад +2

      Sitz baths can definitely help. But if you don't find these remedies to help enough, it may be time to see a specialist.

    • @JaguerRhye
      @JaguerRhye 3 года назад +2

      @@yourfriendlyproctologist OK, thanks for responding. I was just referring to regular baths so that one could be laying down where there would not be as much pressure on the rectal area compared to might occur with a sitz bath.

    • @yourfriendlyproctologist
      @yourfriendlyproctologist  3 года назад +4

      @@JaguerRhye Yes, a regular bath is infinitely better than using these sitz bath tubs.

    • @hmm2903
      @hmm2903 2 года назад +1

      @@yourfriendlyproctologist i do not have a bathtub. Only a shower. I use a tub which I sit in. Am i then doing the same thing by using what you are not recommending? If so what should I do?

    • @normalishistory8951
      @normalishistory8951 8 месяцев назад

      ​@@hmm2903 My question exactly.

  • @iciajay6891
    @iciajay6891 2 года назад +2

    If you don't have a bathtub what do you recommend? I only have accses to a shower.

    • @yourfriendlyproctologist
      @yourfriendlyproctologist  2 года назад +1

      showering and letting the water run down your backside can work great!

    • @ezrahong7343
      @ezrahong7343 2 года назад +1

      i literally using this rectangle plastic storage bin and soak myself in it. U can just get some kind of plastic tub that you can stay soak in or climb i. easily

  • @narutokun19
    @narutokun19 7 месяцев назад

    Very interesting. I switched to one of these from the bath as it seemed a) more convenient and b) largely recommended. At a certain point I just realized I MUST be doing it wrong because it seemed to be making things worse (especially since I felt better one night not doing anything and then worse in the morning after using it). The whole mechanics did seem odd because the hemmoroids are just sitting out there the same cause of the problem but I figured the water must be making things better somehow I just have it too hot or shouldn't use epsom salts or am not relaxing the right way? I think this verifies my experience and I will switch back to baths or just skip and use the shower when I don't have enough time. BUT why is this recommended in pretty much every how to fix hemmoroids article out there???

  • @katherincastillo1732
    @katherincastillo1732 2 года назад +1

    I have a quick question, so a family member of mine has a small abscess in their private area, what would you recommend?

  • @marioalejandro7549
    @marioalejandro7549 2 года назад +1

    Solutions please.

  • @anandmayekar1513
    @anandmayekar1513 2 года назад

    Great Dr.Chung 🙏🙏🙏❤️🙏🙏🙏

  • @patz6689
    @patz6689 8 месяцев назад

    I am currently suffering from a very severe flare up of an external hemorrhoid. I have the packable/foldable sitz bath from amazon, but when I tried to use it, my body hurt so much from it-I couldn’t continue using it. I ended up in Urgent Care and the PA told me to use a bathtub for all the benefits of relaxing the muscles around the anus. The problem is, when my husband and I travel to various countries, many accommodations do not have tubs and only offer showers, so the foldable option seems better than nothing.

  • @strongsyedaa7378
    @strongsyedaa7378 Год назад +1

    What to use instead of Sitz Bath?

  • @NitinAvasarmol
    @NitinAvasarmol 5 месяцев назад

    so is sitz bath bad for fissure spasm relaxation as well?

  • @stephaniehowe0973
    @stephaniehowe0973 8 месяцев назад

    I went home with this after my 2nd hemmoroid surgery.
    I didn't like it. Sadly I had to take a hot bath after every single time I went the bathroom

  • @devinjm007
    @devinjm007 2 года назад +7

    Hi I’ve been dealing with an anal fissure for the past few days and the pain after bowel movements is excruciating, so much so that I’ve been afraid to eat. Ive been taking laxative and hydrocortisone cream. What would you recommend for anal fissures? Would a sitz bath help with this?

    • @yourfriendlyproctologist
      @yourfriendlyproctologist  2 года назад +3

      I have several videos on fissures...check them out! I would advise seeing a specialist near you for diagnosis and care.

    • @ajrockinshockin2893
      @ajrockinshockin2893 2 года назад +2

      I'm reading this and I'm hoping your anal fissure has healed itself. I've had two anal fissure surgical procedures and it's pure hell on earth. I bought a Squatty Potty and I highly recommend you do the same. You can watch the RUclips videos on Squatty Potty. Hope this helps you as much as it has helped me.

    • @dallaskubano214
      @dallaskubano214 2 года назад +1

      How’s the fissure going ? I just started caring for mine close to 2 weeks now. So much pain I had to go see a specialist. The pain is still tremendous the meds or creams just tone it down but impossible to sleep without taking super strong pills

    • @ety3144
      @ety3144 2 года назад

      Aloe Vera has helped me with swelling if you have any of that while the fissure is healing… pain killers help for sure to get through it. Some people do fasting or juice fast for 3days each… I’m always too hungry to try that

    • @manjitmatharu328
      @manjitmatharu328 Год назад +1

      Currently going through a bad patch with mine but creams and ointment will help to protect the skin when passing a bowl movement. Lots of fibrous foods will help everything pass easier. Try soaking 1tbsp chia seeds and add to hot water with lime and honey for digestion aid.

  • @shadown5757
    @shadown5757 2 года назад

    Thank you for the information 🙏

  • @Mary-pn8cl
    @Mary-pn8cl 3 года назад +20

    Makes sense. I thought about that too. I’ve been debating for months whether to buy one but now I come across this video so I’m taking it as a sign not to.
    Question: do you feel the same way about “donut pillows”? (Cushions basically in the shape of a toilet seat)

    • @playamelodythateverybodyknows
      @playamelodythateverybodyknows 3 года назад +4

      Sitting alone makes it stretch esp on hard surface...so i sit on one side with the support of my elbow to make sure my weight doesnt fall on the center where the anus is or just sit on a very soft pillow

    • @yourfriendlyproctologist
      @yourfriendlyproctologist  3 года назад +20

      I do feel the same about donut cushions and I do not recommend them. I would recommend a soft cushion if you need to sit and change your position frequently.

    • @eversgirls574
      @eversgirls574 3 года назад +6

      Oh no, I was about to buy a donut pillow for work 🤦🏻‍♀️ I have to sit all day and it's so uncomfortable

    • @rpersen
      @rpersen 3 года назад +7

      Donut pillows helped for a while, but it just made my condition worse. I still have the pillow, but probably won’t use it again. Now I use a normal, soft pillow.

  • @ChavonJWright
    @ChavonJWright 2 года назад +2

    Wont it be incredibly painful to enter and exit a typical tub?! I keep grimacing thinking about lifting one leg or squatting down to the water without intense pain post-op hemorrhoidectomy surgery! It seems these baths would be such an easier option that minimizes tension after an already painful BM.

  • @Re.x0
    @Re.x0 8 месяцев назад

    Hmmm well then what about those hemorrhoid pillows to sit on? Don't they do the smiliar thing by the space inbetween the pillow when you sit?

  • @ingenuity168
    @ingenuity168 2 года назад +1

    Just use an ordinary plastic basin and don't sit on it for more than 3 minutes.

  • @melochan
    @melochan 2 года назад

    Would using an Asian-style in-ground toilet be better? Or even using a “squatty potty”?

  • @kiaraechegaray3164
    @kiaraechegaray3164 7 месяцев назад

    What about for a fissure? Are they bad for fissures too? These tubs seem to have the same size opening of my toilet

  • @chhitizdailyvlog9598
    @chhitizdailyvlog9598 2 года назад

    Hi doctor,I had my surgery on friday and i couldn't pee as of today . I think urine retention is one of the effects of surgery but for so many days . My doctor hasn't had this experience with his patients before. What do you say about this? I am on cathedral at the moment until tuesday. i did several TOV while i was in hospital. The pain is excessive but i am controlling. Please suggest

    • @adelabuidris6292
      @adelabuidris6292 Год назад

      Hey.
      How's it going now
      What type of surgery did you've

  • @christopherpi2010
    @christopherpi2010 Год назад

    Please review the Hemaway VIP hemrroid toilet commode adapter.

  • @maelstrom4859
    @maelstrom4859 2 года назад

    What about for prostatitis? I'm tired of taking full body baths.

  • @olgatlangelani3887
    @olgatlangelani3887 2 года назад +2

    Tha you s much about ur videos, 2 weeks back I was having a painful hemorrhoids but after following ur tips of taking a shower after a bowel movement by bending down while in the shower and allowing water to pass trough my anus, today I'm happy, it has worked for me. Thank u so much Dr Chung, God bless u.