Miftah Ismail's Populist Neoliberalism
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 окт 2024
- Lately Miftah Ismail has won a big following by pointing out that Pakistan only works for the 1% of the super rich. This video examines the policies he suggests to fix this problem.
------------------------------------------------------
English RUclips Channel: / taimurrahman1975
Instagram: / taimur_laal
Twitter: / taimur_laal
![[4K] Watch SpaceX Catch A Starship Rocket From Space!!! #IFT5](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pIKI7y3DTXk/mqdefault.jpg)
Amazing work, Dr Taimur! I have been following your work for the last few years. It's truly great that you have been educating us! I'm glad to see how you have statistically crushed the loud pseudo arguments of neoliberals, through stats-driven facts. Thanks!
"Taimur Rahman's populist Neomarxism" - intentionally lying about Miftah's own strategies for taking care of the poor while hiding the weaknesses behind his ideas for privatization.
Dear sir hats up to u. You are a gem. It was such an insightful and descriptive lecture. It added a lot of information to my knowledge. May u live long. Huge respect 😍
Always a delight to listen to your lectures.
It's a wonderful lecture, lots of new learning..Keep it up,Doctor shb
Amazing video dr sahab. Always educate us with these videos.
Worth watching - much appreciated Prof. Dr. Taimur Sb.
Sir, please come to Sindh. There are thousands of ghost schools here and there are countless politically appointed teachers who do nothing but waste time and resources.
Really appreciable Sir
WOW, excellent lecture, great research and insight; well-done, sir!
What a fruitful analysis Sir.... you did postmortem of these neoliberalism
Much appreciated sir
Great work 💯
Great work Sir!!!
Great work Dr sb, thank you for this!!
Taimur rahman should be next finance minister of pakistan
vote lena parta ha pehla
@@crumpfyllc5571 Special assistant to prime minister/ technocrat
We need a Miftah Ismail vs Dr Taimur Rahman debate.
U r doing a grt job keep it up.
Sir love from Lucknow Uttar pardesh India
Sir always love to watch u
Sir riba,islami maashiyyat ,ye sab bht achy videos thy
Sir sir Syed per kch banaeye hm aligarh muslim University Students k lea
What a joker was this man Mr Miftah, gladly he is no more Finance Minister.
Ustad g shukria. Allah khush rkhy. Amen
Excellent... ab aye ga mza🥰🥰🥰🥰
I try to look at all sensible voices across the spectrum. I listen to Pro govt podcasts (The one which make some sense), I listen to pro PTI Media, I listen to Capitalists, I listen to Socialists.. the result.. I am very very confused. Any suggestions how to deal with this as I dont want to get stuck in echo chambers.
As you showed in the graphs globally famine is decreasing irrespective of the population size, this is the same argument that capitalists use to justify that capitalism is working. How would critique this and especially "trickle down effect" that capitalist use to defend it
great analysis
Mr.Taimur Saab. I know you've been critical of Miftah's economic policies. But do you think Dar is any better??
Sir socialism r liberalism ki ek debate hvi ti recently I think ap k ilm ma hoga jisma socialism k representative sibghat wayne k pints kafi kamzor nzar aiye
Plz ap os hawaly sy koi video bnayein
Human societies have been built on cooperation not hyper competition
Unfortunate times we live in today
Can you tell who is best analyst shahbaaz Rana, Dr Ashfaq Hassan, and hafez pasha....
Text book is the only option for Pakistan. Let the dollar flow and focus on exports. Otherwise, we will keep drowning.
It's a good lecture, but what would you suggest if Pakistan does not go to IMF? Is there any other way of getting out of this debt trap
Very well explained.
Salam sir thanks you are educating masses in presenting socialististic approaches. Although many of us differ from many socialististic approaches. But your presentation of alternative ideas are really admirable. Sir with due respect we have some questions here. Which we are also trying to find their answers. And we will be highly thankful to you if you make detailed video on answers to such questions. Sir you said that if we continue IMF's or Miftah ismail's policies policies then inflation could shoot upto 60% but there are also some experts like hafeez pasha who are saying that if we doesn't follow IMF'S path than condition would be worse double than that is going to be because of IMF. Sir you presented some solutions like protectionism and reforms but sir they are long term solutions right now if we ask you about some short term solutions than what would you suggest? As we are falling rapidly because of falling dollar reserves. And sir just like you made this video on Miftah ismail or neo liberal point of view we would be pleasured higly if you make such detailed video on daronomics, PTIs, PPPs, plus Islamic theological point of views as well. So we can correlate and compare all of these things. Finally thanks Allah gives you long life and noore hidayah to present solutions
You are my inspiration !!
Sir very good analysis.
You are gem for pak💞
Sir, apki books kahan sy melsakti hn koi contact number dain .
nice analysis
بہت بہترین تجزیہ
How can people do comments or liked without listening the complete story
dear sir ,how can we improve the education system of pakistan .
It was detailed and informative ... make one video on the solution of those issues which pakistan is facing currently , if the government doesn't enforce imf,s conditions .
I agree with your critique of neoliberal economics that was designed to ease access of western capital to emerging markets but current crisis is because Pakistan is oil dependent economy and we need dollar reserves to import it.
How will you finance the immediate dollar deficiency crisis if not through IMF?
Also, you proposed the alternative as to import oil from Iran, Tajikistan and Russia in other currencies but the problem is that west will cut us from international markets and economy via sanctions. What would we do then.
Great questions, that's the problem exactly, critique is easy but solution is difficult.
Great sir!
Greatwork sir as always...fact based
Kindly give your analysis on Miftahnomics and Darnomics in detail. Which one is better for Pak in the short n long run?
These Economic related Topics should be explained in Urdu so in general people get awareness
Well research vlog. I enjoyed watching it. I also watched Atif Mian's views on Pakistan's economy. If it is feasible for you to share your opinion about his views. Thanks
great SIR G.
Professor I do understand your point of view towards the population argument presented by Miftah Ismail. However, we need to realise that negating population growth as a problem will not be very helpful to the economic growth. It is not even hunger that is the main problem, the rate at which population is growing is not sustainable due to lack of education infrastructure. As a result, people aren’t much productive as they lack the skills necessary for a modern economy. We need to control the population regardless of Neoliberal or Socialist policies. By population control, I don’t think Miftah meant to eradicate poor population. Currently, Pakistan has almost ~ 4 Children per women. Stable rate is 2.1.
I hope you will clarify your stance on this.
Even Communist countries like China controlled population, albeit with other problems 2 generations later.
Please invite miftah ismail on your youtube channel and we would like to see your debate with him on privatisation.
How miftah ismail defend himself on privatisation?
Thanks for the Expose!
Plz show whole scenario of policy decisions. Ishaq daar could lower fuel prices because international prices dropped.
Sir g corruption khatam kr k open decision Lena hogy.. Export barhane hogy simple Sab khud banana hoga or achi market tactics use kr k west market capture krna hogy. Artificial intelligence p agy scop Hai abi se Kam Shoro krna hogy. IT sector Mae logo ko education Dena Hai bohat jobs create hojaygy. Simple formula lagana Hai time by time...
law ko acha banana paryga or bat bat pr gardan katny band krni parygi freedom of expresion dena paryga
First need to work on accountability, otherwise corruption perpetuate Pakistan in more loss.
سر جی ہمارے علاقے میں ایک سکول مارکیٹ کے سکنڈ پلور سے بنایا گیا ہے جو اصل میں دوکانوں سے کمروں کا کام لیا جاتا ہے۔ یعنی گراؤنڈ پلور دوکانیں اور اوپر سکول ہے۔
Do throw some light on Ishaq Dar policies please
Sure. He has no policies aside from trying to keep the dollar low and getting capital $ from abroad.
@@Taimur_Laal 🤣🤣
Changed my thoughts 🚩✌️✌️
Execellent!!!
Its not the IMF though which needs to impose the policy in the first place, Pakistan itself has got herself in a position like that with past blundurs of politicians and decision makers. IMF just needs assurences for their debt which I and you would also want in the same situation. It is true that the Miftah is ignoring the underlying problems and want to change it without addresing the fundamentals .
Sir solution btaen trade deficit kese khtn kren without IMF
Getting rid of these elephants is not easy however, getting rid of them will help government save the money it is spending on running these departments in loss.
What about unemployment as a result of privatisation ?
I m strange why u give him attention...he was opportunity in Pmln, but failed and applied same capitalist steps.. what is his achievements with lots of contradiction... Anyway thanks
What is your solution otherwise? It is not just IMF but it is in our own interest. To maintain dollars we have to spend our reserves. You are an economist you know better.
Sir your video donot come regularly
Please made on videos on muslim cold war.
Video series
Professor sb. your thesis does not shed any light that how a weak poor democratic state like Pakistan build a capacity to have state owned economy and afford state own/run Institutions like PIA, Steel Mills etc ?? and plz give any one example of a poor and weak country or state in the whole world which follows or afford the model that you prescribed. i.e Socialist Model. Thanks
Comrade agr tu Moftaa sb 83 % of the gdp consume krne wala jehadfesabhiLila waloo ke trf nhe jaenge tu gp krenge jstra imran bhai aur mia sb shabas krrhe hai ?
What then is the solution to Pak’s dollar crisis? We need $$s to import in the short term and avoid default (to avert an even greater suffering than what Miftah Ismail is suggesting), can you please explain how we can come out of this crisis without burdening the population? I only see IMF as the short term solution. Over time we can make changes but simply shrugging off his idea as inflationary and not in the interest of public isn’t fair if you cannot provide an alternative that is better.
And to clarify, I don’t disagree with you on some of criticism of his grand vision (regarding education etc.), neither am I a neoliberal supporter …. I quite enjoyed your Junaid Khan Vlog. I just don’t see an immediate solution that doesn’t involve the IMF.
Sir, your science is not match with him. I think both of u should come neck to neck and debate with each other about the current economic problem of Pakistan. By this way we can get to know the exect cause
آپ نے مفتاح اسماعیل کی کارپوریشن کی ویب سائٹ کے ریونیو کا ڈیٹا کہاں سے لیا ہے۔ اس پر تھوڑی رہنمائی کر دیں ۔
It is in the website of Ismail Industries. Just google it. It is in the public domain.
Not sure what are you getting at. Privatisation of bankrupt enterprises makes lot of sense. State has no business to run companies. It has failed consistently. Miftah is right in his economics. Forget about nei liberalism.
Please do talks on the economic policy of Pakistan mazdoor kisan party
After watching your entire video, I would like to say what I think. I think, either you're mixing two things. First, your own ideology and second, on-ground facts. Or, you're sad because a bourgeois is talking about lower classes, and of poor people. Because we all know that all these are problems of Pakistan. The resources are occupied by a few people. There is an elite capture on everything. You have had talked about land reforms, infact you have even led many rallies , and today, if someone else is talking about what you have struggled alot and you are making allegations based on mere old references instead of appraising it.
According to you, it's a populist agenda of neolibrals. Sorry to say sir, but at this stage your frustration is hinting as you are trying to build apopulist agenda. You are opposing him for the sake of opposition.
You are still my teacher. I really respect you alot. Everyone has the right to dissent, so should I. I said what i think is right.
Baki ghustakhi kay liye maazrat
A vlog more then 20 mins is hard to digest. Plese make it short
Corporate farming is not a bad idea. Otherwise, we will keep experiencing reduced growth and keep suffering. Lol If corporate farming starts it will employ farmers. PIA can never go into profit unless you reduce the staff. I am shocked at the lack of indebt analysis.
i was very influence by Ji but now its look like Ji be PPP ka sath mil gaye ge, abb samj be nahi aa rhi kis ka sath chalaain
Aik bar JI ko bhi azama lo
MuFTAY NE 6 MAH KI FINANCE MINISTRY K DOR MN RUPAY K BERRA GHURQ KIA... MUFTAH IMF ( JACK RUSSLE) KA COMMISSION KHOR TUTTOO... AISA GHUDAR I WATEN ...NZR ATA HY JIS NE DOLLER KHREEDAY HUY HYN AUR RUPAY KI VALUE GIRA RA HY K US K DOLLERS KI QEEMAT BURR JAY
Capitalism is the only way forward. Hope Pakistan would be able to break the shackles of socialism
Begali promoting captialism. Something is fishy.
@@vaibhavs13 nothing is fishy. Left bengal/India few years back for the west where meritocracy thrives.
Bro Pakistan is as capitalist as it gets
@@souravmukherjee4987 Pakistan was never socialist, Infact Pakistan is hyper-capitilist as it gets.
@@souravmukherjee4987 where is socialism in Pakistan lol
Miftah ismail etny important hogye k un py precious time barbad kea jye I don't think so
That’s quite deceptive to say it’s going for free . It comes with shit load of debt and that’s the real cost, obviously you knew this but chose not to mention
PIA is a loss making entity rather than losing money on an airline that isn't used by 99% of the pakistanis shouldn't the government spend on things that impact 100% the pakistan like Health care and Education, Yes due Miftah Ismail's policies the Inflation skyrocketed but if you compare the prices of the Petrol and Diesel by the purchasing power with compare to other nations like China, Vietnam and laos it is still heavily subsidized, why should the government subsidize every citizen rather than diverting it to those who need in the form of BIC, why should every people get subsidized electricity by borrowing from international institution rather than fixing the production cost of electricity and giving direct income support to those who need, it is very easy to criticize someone and label him with some tags, rather than presenting the real solution and doing the same thing, I don't support the that PIA should be Privatized rather as it is a non essential service shouldn't it be at least not losing.
Left ki tamam jamatun ko asay logun ke khilaf KAMARBASTA HONA CHAHIAY
You are now talking like IK. But how can these money be brought inside Pakistan?
Make him finance minister. He will show
Dr Sahab now what will you say? at least some one thinks about country, and try to plan out, it is true there would weakness in plans but at least Miftah Sahab have good thaughts about beloved country, instead of so called Khan sahab who just think to be PM and have zero plan, I am not sure why your task is cricise to him instead of appreciate anything, although you are feeling in heart he is saying right but you don't want to appreciate him. Our country need planning even Miftah sahab does not say that IMF but he say right now it is only option and no other option, which is true. See now Dar sahab is doing same, because these are only viable option available, please create another video where give options not criticise others, but that is not easy task.
مفتاع کو مباحثے کے لیے مدعو کریں
Sex is nice but have you listened to Taimur Rehman?
Sir first become a BILLIONIRE then teach/lecture others...
Otherwise no one take you seriously...
Also your stance on population growth is wrong IMO. You cannot just relate hunger with population growth. Exponential rise in population especially in Pak is unsustainable in terms of resource exploitation. + socialists also want more quantity than to more quallity which is absurd. It was disappointing to see that you did not address the need for population control in Pak which somehow makes you another Molvi in the country advocating for more breeding.
Japan and china leaders are now begging to their audience for more childrens.
when muftah was finance minister then he also pathetic and people abuse him.. all are bol bachaan
💯
سر مطلب اب ھم مفتاح کو IMF کا ایجنٹ کہہ سکتے ہیں 🤔
Sir kuda ka khoof karo naqam tajurba mat karo please
I think it is not the question that who's the better financial wizard, Dar or Miftah. Did they get a level playing field & power of financial reforms ?
Today's dire fiscal deficit & negative growth, power crisis & deal with IMF doesn't leave much room for wizardry.
Increasing the taxes, privatisation, increasing fuel prices & forgoing the subsidies is only one aspect of strategy to deal with the financial crisis. Dar may be a little better than Miftah.
So has anyone & you tried to identify the root causes of this financial crisis & its real management ?
What real structural changes are required ? This is not upto a finance minister. It requires a revolutionary socio economic ideology.
Miftah may be a free market economist & don't suit our country, but Dar has no solutions as well.
Weak political mandate , lack of clear ideological base of political parties & political engineering is behind it.
Privatisating sick government enterprises effectively closes financial pits that consume huge amounts of public money & do not produce any revenue. The alleged corruption or tax evasion or risk of failure is not a credible argument against privatisation. The baseline is that public funds cannot be spent on organisations that do not respond with growth & competency.
I do not fully agree with Miftah but your lecture is an anti Miftah & anti IMF tirade without discussing real solutions. You did not also highlight why Pakistan had to go to IMF in the first place ? What plagues Pakistan's economy ??
Atleast Miftah has an ideology , he's a free market economist. What is Dar ? Does he have an ideology ?
bhot middle classiaa intellectuals ko motasar kra hai ? allah kher kre ?
Miftah imf ka gulam hai
مفتاح ! کے مطابق اپنے بیویوں سمیت سب کچھ پرائیوٹائز کرکے ملٹی نیشنل کمپنیوں کو حوالے کرو 😛
Students of low cost private schools outperform Government school students. This has been shown in studies done by Alif Ailaan and Status of Education Report by ITA.
You’re concealing facts to promote your own agenda.
Students in PEF affiliated schools and under Public Private Partnership have better learning outcomes as shown by independent studies by Idara Taleem o Agahi.
Your point of view is just to perpetuate the existing system with superficial reforms.
No matter the training and resources spent on Govt schools, they can’t be reformed because of Govt teachers.
The only countries that have significantly overcome poverty have adopted free market economics. You’re a relic of the past!
Can you name a country that overcame poverty with free market reforms?
@@rehman1833 India and China.
But free market is just one ingredient not holy grail. You first need govt to invest in basic skilling, infrastructure, healthcare, population control and some industrial policy to create a basic skills base then go for free market reforms to expose those industries to global competition.
Every successful country did this.
@@rehman1833 India is a good example. So is China
Totally wrong
Miftah mulak gushan hai
bakwas programe
مفتاح تو بہت ہی عوام دشمن ہے
1st comment
Mubarak ho