"Hey, Theo, guess what? I used to have a husband, he looked like a silver clam in armor, lol. Anyway, ya know who is really hawt? Sauron. I've been chasing after that bad boy for centuries."
@@AnnaBellaChannel Going by Tolkien yes. His elves are compulsive monogamous. Mating and marriage is synomous to them and once it's taken place the bond is insoluble and eternal. Every other elf can instantly recognize a mated one from the voice and eyes. Cheating or sex outside marriage is an alien concept to them.
Not only just that but Theo literally knows nothing about Galadriel’s personality. So why would he say that as if he was watching the series with us. Hack writers.
@@liamglynch no, her exact birthdate isn’t official, but it’s likely she was born around the year 300 of the second age because Galadriel didn’t have her before she crossed into eriador from Beleriand.
@@thomasrobinson4890Sorry! I misread it as Celeborn. Yes, Celebrian was born in the second age, but the original commenter is not necessarily wrong in their criticism. The show is canonically all over the place, and timelines are not particularly accurate, so who the hell knows if or when Celebrian will turn up if at all. The scene is a little absurd tbh. Then again, the show is a strange project in artistic license..
Elves don't really fie either. They go to the halls of Mandos and await judgement. After a certain amount of time, they then return to the world of the living.
THEY BETTER CAST A REALLY GOOD CELEBORN NOW TO COMPETE WITH DARK LORD SAURON! No way is anyone gonna be able to compete with that chemistry. Unless Charlie Vickers plays Celeborn too with some moustache and long hair disguise 😂
OMG I had literally thought the same haha!!🤣🤣 If Celeborn can't stay dead they can still have Charlie playing him too (with make-up and blond wig🧝♂️😅), and in the meantime let's put Sauron in armor and mask too, so basically anyone else can play him, and Vickers can just add his voiceover...perfect evil plan loading LOL❣️👻😈
@@RavenIdril2966I think he’s dead? I haven’t watched most of s2 yet but Galadriel here says “was”. Edit: Nevermind! Apparently Celeborn is in the LOTR movies, I never knew his name. I looked into it a bit and apparently there was a period when Galadriel and her husband were on an extremely long break.
god i wish they don't make another corny love triangle story between two canonical tolkien characters and a made up character like legolas/kili/tauriel again
Sauron/Galadriel/Celeborn love triangle incoming? Bad Boy Romance Novel Cover Sauron being her baby daddy? Nice Guy Cuckeborn showing up one day with amnesia? Why not, it's already one big soap opera, throw in all the cliches. The writers need to go all the way with this, it could be a gold mine of comedic potential.
Hi! Short explanation for why the writers decided to go this route (probably): by Tolkien-lore they were actually separated for a while due to tragic circumstances before setelling down in Lothlorien. True, that event happened at a different time later, but because Tolkien was never too specific about these events, it makes as good sense to have them separated at this dark times as if it happened later. Mind you, elves live for thousand and thousand of years, he could have been missing for 400years and they'll still be young when meeting again. They will eventually have a daughter, and also help Frodo in LOTR. From a purely writing standpoint, you need to take away something dear to the character in order for them to go on a journey hoping to acquire/or avenge it.
I actually asked for Unfinished Tales as a birthday present, partly to check out the Galadriel and Celeborn backstory, and it’s an inconsistent mess. I understand that even Tolkien didn’t know that Galadriel was going to be that important when he started, and he kept changing his mind on Celeborn, so I’m just grateful that he did not ultimately go with the name “Teleporno” and leave it there.
Celeborn and Galadriel were separated for 50 years ( SA1350 -SA1400) and she came to Lothlórien in that time while Celeborn remain in Eregion. The rings of power were forge in SA1500 and in SA1600 the One Ring. And in the SA 1697 attacked Eregion. I assume that the action in the series take place around the year SA1500 So by this time in the lore they would have already reunite. The story so far its very mixt and it doesnt respect the time line of the books nor the events.
Probably trying repress her trauma or something. Only time she expressed emotion is on the last episode when Elrond found her drowning. She was crying there
Just watch her face while she remembers Celeborn. It softens, and there's a little smile that forms at the corners of her mouth. It's subtle, but very powerful.
FINALLY! After 7 episodes we finally hear about her husband! Im questioning the showrunners here like why only now? Also, dont think he is “dead”. But if they are trying to do some kind of mystery box next season pls stoppp.
Yeah it has to be a mystery box thing, cause he's in lotr, unless they're rewriting everything ( which I wouldn't be surprised if they did) he's gotta be alive. Unless they're doing a multiverse thing 😅
Something tells me this was a last minute addition after the online backlash, when people started noticing there was no Celeborn. Why the hell wouldn't she mention her murdered husband before now, especially when she was crying about her dead brother to Sauron?
@@rodneymoore5824 well, they've already rewritten the lore. Finrod doesn't die defending Beren in Sauron's dungeon according to this show, and thus Beren must have died.
@@thelaw6267 So tell me how, after this was shot ages ago and went through post-production, they suddenly decided, “oh noooez, a handful of geeks are upset! Quick! We must fly back to New Zealand and re-shoot!” For whatever reason it’s in there, it would not be online backlash.
Time Guyladriel spends searching every corner of the world for Sexy Sauron: *1000 Years* Time Guyladriel spends searching every corner of the world for her missing 'Silver Clam' husband: *0 Years* Nuff said.
Well, Celeborn can't be dead. Like we know Isildur can't be dead either. Unless the writers of this show are going for a really radical rewriting of Tolkien.
Hahaha she is like “I am hunting for Sauron for 1000 years!! Husband?! Who dat? I think he’s dead.” Still love Gal though after the finale. Hope she kicks Sauron’s ass
She thinks hunting down Sauron is her duty, and that looking for her husband will be futile. If he is dead, he will eventually rejoin her (elves do not remarry).
In the lore I know there was a bit where they were apart from each other for like a century but they were supposed to have had their daughter at that point too.
I wonder if we will see Valinor in future seasons. Celeborn could have returned to Valinor after Morgoth was defeated without each other knowing they survived. Episode 1 did have all those elves end up in Valinor and if Celeborn is there, those elves could have told that Galadriel was with them but jumped off the ship they were on.
I truly hope that we shall see more of Valinor. Especially when Numenorians attack there. Perhaps we shall see Finrod with Amarie and Finarfin and Earwen plus other elven royalty from Vanyar and Teleri, like Galadriel's Grandfather Olwe. We have already seen Tirion, but it would be super amazing to see Alqualonde and Valimar. One can always hope!
Lol future seasons? Amazon is bleeding money right now, I fully expect them to cancel halfway through production of season 2 of this hot mess of a fan fiction.
...and yet they DARE to say that this show isn't a complete and utter mockery of Tolkien's work. This is a 70 second clip, and yet one could write pages upon pages about all the things wrong with it. She's obsessed with her brother but hasn't ever even mentioned her husband before? And the moment she does she mocks him for not having fitting armor?
Celeborn left and never came back. There's no body. How is that "complete and utter mockery" of Tolkien? At least the show is preparing to turn that useless character into something meaningful during the upcoming season.
Right?! I mean everytime we hear about her so called revenge it is only relating to Finrod. I truly dont know why only now we hear her husband? I tried to defend this show last week but today, nope. Dont know what they’re doing now. But there is still one last episode and Im just waiting if Sauron will be revealed 😂
@@akikolehmainen88 you know that isn’t what they were talking about. They are talking about the stupid love triangle that is coming up and you knew that. You can’t even debate in reality because the winning is so bad you have to make shit up. You lose
She spends so much time searching for her bro and whining about how much she loved him and how much she wants vengeance, and only just now mentions she was married to a dude who went MIA. I can make so many conspiracy theories about this! Maybe Celeborn found out some not-so-nice things about Gally and Finrod, if you catch my meaning, and then faked his own death cause he got tired of her being psycho and calling him names. Maybe he was so horrified that he married a psychotic murder machine that he jumped of a cliff!!!! Well he’s probably just captured and she’ll have to girlboss her way into saving him, but one can daydream about the alternatives. 😅
I hope that celeborn being missing is an excuse to make Hallbrand Galadriels love interest or sum other bullshit like that. If amazons did that I wonder whether they will be sued by Tolkien estate
Perhaps he just went missing like Thorin’s Father, Thrain. Thorin lost him during the Battle of Moria, and went missing after that. Sometimes in war soldiers get lost during battle. They Either return alive or they’re found dead. The Chances are Celeborn is Still Alive.
The phrase your looking for is Missing in Action or MIA, a clear distinction from being AWOL or Deserting. A soldier missing in action is still considered "alive" until his death is reported and active / loyal until proven otherwise.
Oh my God...This is such a travesty on just about every level....Bad writing, bad acting, no context, no subtext, just a complete destruction of Tolkien's work...I lament the work these people do in there bubbles so completely removed from any form of reality, and most certainly looking down on others, dividing as much as possible at very turn!
Her jaw barely moves when she talks and she did that weird twitchy thing with her nose that one time she talked to Elrond. She was terribly miscast in this role.
@@knzafir of course he isnt, the scriptwriters arent allowed to do this, sameway its pointless to show Isildur in mortal danger, because he died as a grown man after Saurons defeat according to the lore but it doesnt change the fact that the writers creat cheap drama and suspension where there is actually none. All the main protagonist which have a certain fate within Tolkiens lore have bullet proved plot armour.
"Hey, Theo, guess what? I used to have a husband, he looked like a silver clam in armor, lol. Anyway, ya know who is really hawt? Sauron. I've been chasing after that bad boy for centuries.
Feels to me that McKay & Payne didn’t know about Celeborn until the audience asked were he was during the promotional campaign, witch is why he’s only mentioned in the last episodes of season1 almost like an afterthought
Yeah very alive but ROP forgot to mention it until episode 7 🤭 But it seems that in season 2 we will see him already as they already cast the actor who will play her husband
Elves are immortal so yes. Their bodies can be destroyed but the spirits will go to Mandos halls were he will create their bodies anew free to resume as before.
They are elves, they are supposed to more virtuous than mortals, and when they fall in love, they fall hard, they can literally die from heartbreak. So one partner for 10,000 years isn't going to make them restless.
We’re to believe that elves didn’t prepare armour that fit them? Elves who seem to have great capability of reforging a sword couldn’t fit armour for a literal prince?
This, plus calling hiim a silver clam , come on show writers that is just utter and complete bs when it is he that is actually the warrior out of the pair. Sure galadriel is a capable fighter but it is him that goes to defend Eregion, it is him that holds off sauron long enough to have Elrond join his forces. It is him that leads the elves of Lothlorien to Dol Guldur and captures the castle before Galadriel throws down its walls and lay bare it's pits. the only way I can see his armor didn't properly fit is because his armor is too damaged to be repaired in time due to the kinslaying .
Hahaha! But just to explain, it was Elrond who did that move for a ruse. Galadriel doesnt know that Elrond will do that so she isnt after her son in law. It is still a VERY STUPID SCENE. Urge I hate that scene so much. The writers just inserted that for controversy.
Is it just me or does this seem like a throw away that was put in by the showrunners after fans called them out on the lore? So much time spend talking about Finrod and how much she loved him and is going to avenge him no matter what! ... oh and the guy she was married to but that would just be gravy.
Nah he isnt dead. Just missing in action. With this decision I have no idea why the showrunners* decided to do that. We were all thinking he will show up this season 2 (and also Galadriel’s daughter) but seems like they arent included this season.
@michaelriggs325 Oh, yes, they do... stick a sword through them, and you will see them die... they are immortal only by age. Their bodies are just as frail as ours!
If they said that she didn't meet him yet, it would be rewriting things too. At this point Galadriel and Celeborn should be married for several thousand years and already have their daughter Celebrian (Arwen's mother)
But if they aren't allowed to The Silmarillion as material, why is everyone expecting Tolkien's vision? This series it's a "based-on" series not an adaptation.
@@lilamoonlight2007 The appendixes should be enough for them to do a masterpiece. It gave them extra spaces needed. Also, reasons why people hated this show is 1. Wokeness. I'm all for colours and feminism, but making Galadriel like some arrogant jerk is kinda stupid, she's basically been to Valinor 2. Some bad CGI. Numenor only sent 3 ships???? 3. Forgettable characters. They could have fixed it had 1. Elves look more like elves, majestic. (Black people can also look majestic btw) 2. Make Galadriel more wiser and somewhat more commanding 3. Celeborn should always stick with Galadriel, where both support one another(Tolkien basically make love a central theme) 4. Start the whole story with everyone still recovering from the deluge of Beleriand, like, they tried to build back the glories of the old kingdoms of Gondolin and Nargothrond. And Annatar appearing, giving everyone a hope that everything can be return to what its once was. This is my opinion, I ain't a storyteller, but I'm sure there are others that are more well versed in the lore of Middle Earth.
@@Keram-io8hv Kin Strife would be a nice story, a 10 year exile of Eldacar and the burning of Ostgilliath. Legit you have a Rhaegar style story, since Valacar married a woman who is considered to be unacceptable according to Numenoreans standards.
Celeborn is nowhere to be seen so Guyladriel can have her Bossgirl agenda. Same goes for Míriel and that other activist Actor. God i hate this abomination of a Show.
Oh here we go again..the new mystery box..but for $$$ and new subscription you will find out what happened to Celeborn. This show is beyond stupid and bad writing. Oh and did i mention member berries? -.-
Galadrail: My husband is dead! Tolkien: No I specifically put him in the lor as living ♟️📝📖🤔😏 Me: the screenwriters need to be 🔥ed oh wait .... never mind 😂 thx Amazon you finally got one thing right 👍
Well technically she didnt say her husband is dead though. The question was “did you lose someone”. Those are two different things… And we all know he isnt even dead anyway so . But yes go off to Amazon. My suggestion is you write them an email. I think their address is ihate@amazon.com
![Galadriel and Celeborn LOTR 1.21 [HD 1080p]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/tanpDhkretk/mqdefault.jpg)
![Galadriel and Celeborn LOTR 1.21 [HD 1080p]](/img/tr.png)
YO WHAT’S UP PEEPS? This video has an uptick in views due to season 2 so hello there! 👋 Celeborn is still not around though…
"Hey, Theo, guess what? I used to have a husband, he looked like a silver clam in armor, lol. Anyway, ya know who is really hawt? Sauron. I've been chasing after that bad boy for centuries."
Celeborn: you cheated on me
Galadriel: we were on a break
Are we sure that Celeborn is the biological father to her daughter?
@@AnnaBellaChannel poor celeborn 😆
@AnnaBellaChannel which would mean that Arwen is descended from Sauron.
@@NickThorbjørnsen2207 Oddly enough yes.
@@AnnaBellaChannel Going by Tolkien yes. His elves are compulsive monogamous. Mating and marriage is synomous to them and once it's taken place the bond is insoluble and eternal. Every other elf can instantly recognize a mated one from the voice and eyes. Cheating or sex outside marriage is an alien concept to them.
" YOU were dancing?? "
Same question in my head boi. Same.
Not only just that but Theo literally knows nothing about Galadriel’s personality. So why would he say that as if he was watching the series with us. Hack writers.
@@kingkoua1 since he sees Galadriel as a fighter, he couldn’t imagine that she was a girly woman that danced.
Yup. Dancing. In chain mail thong underwear. Because before she was regal, Galadriel was a fighter, and before she was a fighter, she was loooooose. 🤣
Celeborn is obviously going to pop up sometime she said she never saw him again…
Celeborn and galadriel already had a daughter canonically wise in first age so this departure from truth is ridiculously unexplained .
No Celebrian was born in the second age
@@thomasrobinson4890 nope. First Age…
@@liamglynch no, her exact birthdate isn’t official, but it’s likely she was born around the year 300 of the second age because Galadriel didn’t have her before she crossed into eriador from Beleriand.
That awkward moment when your daughter marries your best friend. 😅
@@thomasrobinson4890Sorry! I misread it as Celeborn. Yes, Celebrian was born in the second age, but the original commenter is not necessarily wrong in their criticism. The show is canonically all over the place, and timelines are not particularly accurate, so who the hell knows if or when Celebrian will turn up if at all. The scene is a little absurd tbh. Then again, the show is a strange project in artistic license..
He ain't dead, she just said she didn't see him again. It's likely he'll pop up again soon.
It would be breaking something(among other things) if he was actually dead.
Definitely not dead!
Celeborn just went on a Sindarin scale drinking binge and bar hopping in Dorwinion
@Losrandir those things can last centuries.
Elves don't really fie either. They go to the halls of Mandos and await judgement. After a certain amount of time, they then return to the world of the living.
THEY BETTER CAST A REALLY GOOD CELEBORN NOW TO COMPETE WITH DARK LORD SAURON! No way is anyone gonna be able to compete with that chemistry. Unless Charlie Vickers plays Celeborn too with some moustache and long hair disguise 😂
Your so right 🤣🤣🤣
Couldn't agree more ! Charlie and Morfydd have an amazing chemistry
OMG I had literally thought the same haha!!🤣🤣 If Celeborn can't stay dead they can still have Charlie playing him too (with make-up and blond wig🧝♂️😅), and in the meantime let's put Sauron in armor and mask too, so basically anyone else can play him, and Vickers can just add his voiceover...perfect evil plan loading LOL❣️👻😈
I hope to learn more about her husband in the second season
They should get either Benedict Cumberbatch or Tom Hiddleston as Celeborn
Knowing she fell in love at First sight with him, why only mention him there ??? And make her look like an unmarried woman for 7 wholes episodes
Hope they explain in season 2 where the hell as celeborn been.
@@RavenIdril2966I think he’s dead? I haven’t watched most of s2 yet but Galadriel here says “was”.
Edit: Nevermind! Apparently Celeborn is in the LOTR movies, I never knew his name. I looked into it a bit and apparently there was a period when Galadriel and her husband were on an extremely long break.
@@RavenIdril2966 well she just kissed elrond in the latest episode -.-
I want them to go full drama and cast Henry Cavill or something. Full harem for galadriel like an romance anime 😂
@@LolsAtLancei have little knowledge on Elrond’s family tree but correct me if im wrong isnt elrond her son in law????
god i wish they don't make another corny love triangle story between two canonical tolkien characters and a made up character like legolas/kili/tauriel again
Sauron/Galadriel/Celeborn love triangle incoming? Bad Boy Romance Novel Cover Sauron being her baby daddy? Nice Guy Cuckeborn showing up one day with amnesia? Why not, it's already one big soap opera, throw in all the cliches. The writers need to go all the way with this, it could be a gold mine of comedic potential.
Dude, if a love triangle emerges Im totally out 😂 Imagine being MIA for a millennia. I guess Celeborn doesnt want to be found.
celeborn is not a nice guy
Arwen the granddaughter of Palp-I mean Sauron?!
@@kristinazubic9669
SPOILERS:
Palpatine and Sauron are secretly the SAME PERSON!!!!!!
@@therearenoshortcuts9868 gooooood
He run away, he forget to do dishes and was affraid of tempest inside his wife
Hi! Short explanation for why the writers decided to go this route (probably): by Tolkien-lore they were actually separated for a while due to tragic circumstances before setelling down in Lothlorien. True, that event happened at a different time later, but because Tolkien was never too specific about these events, it makes as good sense to have them separated at this dark times as if it happened later. Mind you, elves live for thousand and thousand of years, he could have been missing for 400years and they'll still be young when meeting again. They will eventually have a daughter, and also help Frodo in LOTR.
From a purely writing standpoint, you need to take away something dear to the character in order for them to go on a journey hoping to acquire/or avenge it.
Thank you! I was so confused for a minute.
I actually asked for Unfinished Tales as a birthday present, partly to check out the Galadriel and Celeborn backstory, and it’s an inconsistent mess. I understand that even Tolkien didn’t know that Galadriel was going to be that important when he started, and he kept changing his mind on Celeborn, so I’m just grateful that he did not ultimately go with the name “Teleporno” and leave it there.
@@professorbutters ik, right?
Celeborn and Galadriel were separated for 50 years ( SA1350 -SA1400) and she came to Lothlórien in that time while Celeborn remain in Eregion.
The rings of power were forge in SA1500 and in SA1600 the One Ring. And in the SA 1697 attacked Eregion. I assume that the action in the series take place around the year SA1500
So by this time in the lore they would have already reunite.
The story so far its very mixt and it doesnt respect the time line of the books nor the events.
@@andreidma9215 Also their daughter would be born around SA 300, making her 1200 years old by the time of the forging of the rings.
Galadriel doesn’t change expression throughout this entire scene and it’s so unnerving
Probably trying repress her trauma or something. Only time she expressed emotion is on the last episode when Elrond found her drowning. She was crying there
Just watch her face while she remembers Celeborn. It softens, and there's a little smile that forms at the corners of her mouth. It's subtle, but very powerful.
remember about kate blanchett' galadriel expression?
FINALLY! After 7 episodes we finally hear about her husband! Im questioning the showrunners here like why only now? Also, dont think he is “dead”. But if they are trying to do some kind of mystery box next season pls stoppp.
Yeah it has to be a mystery box thing, cause he's in lotr, unless they're rewriting everything ( which I wouldn't be surprised if they did) he's gotta be alive. Unless they're doing a multiverse thing 😅
Something tells me this was a last minute addition after the online backlash, when people started noticing there was no Celeborn. Why the hell wouldn't she mention her murdered husband before now, especially when she was crying about her dead brother to Sauron?
Don't forget about Isildur's "mystery box death". It's just tiring at this point.
@@rodneymoore5824 well, they've already rewritten the lore. Finrod doesn't die defending Beren in Sauron's dungeon according to this show, and thus Beren must have died.
@@thelaw6267 So tell me how, after this was shot ages ago and went through post-production, they suddenly decided, “oh noooez, a handful of geeks are upset! Quick! We must fly back to New Zealand and re-shoot!” For whatever reason it’s in there, it would not be online backlash.
WHERE IS ELROND, FOR I MUCH DESIRE TO SPEAK TO HIM?
Time Guyladriel spends searching every corner of the world for Sexy Sauron: *1000 Years*
Time Guyladriel spends searching every corner of the world for her missing 'Silver Clam' husband: *0 Years*
Nuff said.
Galadriel talks about her brother more than she talks about her husband.
LMAO this is so true though. Also, she has other brothers but I guess Finrod just has it lol!
Well, Celeborn can't be dead. Like we know Isildur can't be dead either. Unless the writers of this show are going for a really radical rewriting of Tolkien.
Celeborn is going to rock up the moment Guyladriel has sex with Soyron or something like that
@@see8852Soyron? what's wrong with you?
@@Stinkmeaner420 i thought it was pretty funny
I think they already went for a radical rewriting of Tolkien.
They legally can't. They have ground rules where they can't kill characters that will show up in the third age
Ahahahhahaha you cant make this shit up!!!!!
Well he's definitely secretly not dead because Celebrian doesn't exist yet. And also he was in the LOTR trilogy.
So she lost her husband and was seeking only for sauron... So much for a loving wife
Hahaha she is like “I am hunting for Sauron for 1000 years!! Husband?! Who dat? I think he’s dead.” Still love Gal though after the finale. Hope she kicks Sauron’s ass
@@NinaC Im sure shi will, but he still didnt do anything to deserve that. The irony he could be good if gal wouldn't dig
She thinks hunting down Sauron is her duty, and that looking for her husband will be futile. If he is dead, he will eventually rejoin her (elves do not remarry).
In the lore I know there was a bit where they were apart from each other for like a century but they were supposed to have had their daughter at that point too.
@@professorbutters What a good wife.
Can’t help but go here. What’s with Elrond kissing Galadriel?
Same here
Such a stupid scene 🤮
@@NinaC diba? ang unnecessary
They ran out of ideas on how Elrond will hand over the pick for her lock😂😂😂
I think this was for show so he could give her that brooch
I wonder if we will see Valinor in future seasons. Celeborn could have returned to Valinor after Morgoth was defeated without each other knowing they survived. Episode 1 did have all those elves end up in Valinor and if Celeborn is there, those elves could have told that Galadriel was with them but jumped off the ship they were on.
I truly hope that we shall see more of Valinor. Especially when Numenorians attack there. Perhaps we shall see Finrod with Amarie and Finarfin and Earwen plus other elven royalty from Vanyar and Teleri, like Galadriel's Grandfather Olwe. We have already seen Tirion, but it would be super amazing to see Alqualonde and Valimar. One can always hope!
Lol future seasons? Amazon is bleeding money right now, I fully expect them to cancel halfway through production of season 2 of this hot mess of a fan fiction.
Good ole’ Teleporno-uh, I mean Celeborn!
With a name like Teleporno Ill go into hiding too 👀
Atleast she is tragically likeable character now . Fun fact he is alive.
...and yet they DARE to say that this show isn't a complete and utter mockery of Tolkien's work.
This is a 70 second clip, and yet one could write pages upon pages about all the things wrong with it.
She's obsessed with her brother but hasn't ever even mentioned her husband before? And the moment she does she mocks him for not having fitting armor?
Celeborn left and never came back. There's no body. How is that "complete and utter mockery" of Tolkien? At least the show is preparing to turn that useless character into something meaningful during the upcoming season.
@@akikolehmainen88 mate, its a soap opera cliche from the 80s and 90s.
Right?! I mean everytime we hear about her so called revenge it is only relating to Finrod. I truly dont know why only now we hear her husband? I tried to defend this show last week but today, nope. Dont know what they’re doing now. But there is still one last episode and Im just waiting if Sauron will be revealed 😂
@@midwaybrumenbridge If people leaving for war and not coming back is a soap opera cliche, maybe you should watch that kind of TV less.
@@akikolehmainen88 you know that isn’t what they were talking about. They are talking about the stupid love triangle that is coming up and you knew that. You can’t even debate in reality because the winning is so bad you have to make shit up. You lose
Man, they butcher the lore worse by the episode.
She spends so much time searching for her bro and whining about how much she loved him and how much she wants vengeance, and only just now mentions she was married to a dude who went MIA.
I can make so many conspiracy theories about this!
Maybe Celeborn found out some not-so-nice things about Gally and Finrod, if you catch my meaning, and then faked his own death cause he got tired of her being psycho and calling him names.
Maybe he was so horrified that he married a psychotic murder machine that he jumped of a cliff!!!!
Well he’s probably just captured and she’ll have to girlboss her way into saving him, but one can daydream about the alternatives. 😅
Poor dude. The thing he wifed up.
Can't wait for Celeborn to kick hallbrand's ass
I hope that celeborn being missing is an excuse to make Hallbrand Galadriels love interest or sum other bullshit like that. If amazons did that I wonder whether they will be sued by Tolkien estate
The Tolkien Estate doesn't care anymore, only Christopher did.
@@thelaw6267 The sad truth no one wants to admit.
Perhaps he just went missing like Thorin’s Father, Thrain. Thorin lost him during the Battle of Moria, and went missing after that. Sometimes in war soldiers get lost during battle. They Either return alive or they’re found dead. The Chances are Celeborn is Still Alive.
Celeborn has to be alive. He's in The Lord of the Rings.
The phrase your looking for is Missing in Action or MIA, a clear distinction from being AWOL or Deserting. A soldier missing in action is still considered "alive" until his death is reported and active / loyal until proven otherwise.
Oh my God...This is such a travesty on just about every level....Bad writing, bad acting, no context, no subtext, just a complete destruction of Tolkien's work...I lament the work these people do in there bubbles so completely removed from any form of reality, and most certainly looking down on others, dividing as much as possible at very turn!
Lol how is it a destruction of Tolkien's work. The source material is still there, this is just a terrible fanfiction adaptation
Actually a good scene and actor's playing! Definitely like this one
She is so unlikeable
She is a good actress
They pushed her to be this way
Actually is the opposite
She is very likeable now
She isn't that good at acting tho (same expressions in many scenes)
@@alexheisenberg8709 Elves don’t show much emotion dear. 😂 Watch Lord of the Rings again.
@@remindyouofwho7201 🤔🤔🤔🤔 now you that you say it... but even elrond's actor showed more emotion in this series. Just saying
Her jaw barely moves when she talks and she did that weird twitchy thing with her nose that one time she talked to Elrond. She was terribly miscast in this role.
@@alexheisenberg8709Watch other movies and you'll see she's a good actress (her name is Morfydd Clark)
poor celeborn 🥲
They really throw all the respect into the freaking fires of mount doom
They need to fix the dead husband notion or get the wrath of Tolkien fans. Also they need to acknowledge celebrian mother of elrond's children .
I think they already got the actor for Celeborn - Calam Lynch who played Theo in Bridgerton
"They need to fix the dead husband notion or get the wrath of Tolkien fans." They've already gotten the wrath of Tolkien fans, so why stop now?
@@NinaC Jup and he is pretty jacked and quite good looking, it all comes down to camera work. lightning and his acting though.
Tell me where is Gandalf, for I much desire to... escape with him
Cute, she mocks her dead husband
I don't think he's dead. She said she'd never seen him after
@@knzafir of course he isnt, the scriptwriters arent allowed to do this, sameway its pointless to show Isildur in mortal danger, because he died as a grown man after Saurons defeat according to the lore but it doesnt change the fact that the writers creat cheap drama and suspension where there is actually none. All the main protagonist which have a certain fate within Tolkiens lore have bullet proved plot armour.
@@knzafir Well, he can't be dead. He appears in The Lord of the Rings, which happens after this.
"Hey, Theo, guess what? I used to have a husband, he looked like a silver clam in armor, lol. Anyway, ya know who is really hawt? Sauron. I've been chasing after that bad boy for centuries.
Celeborn is Sauron
They really should just cast Charlie Vickers pretending to be Celeborn and messing with her mind again 😂
That's what will likely happen in season 2 .
Thank god this series ain't camon.
Tolkien has been rolling in his grave so rappidly he tyrned into a barrow wight
Tolkien is burning in hell after what he did to his niece
Feels to me that McKay & Payne didn’t know about Celeborn until the audience asked were he was during the promotional campaign, witch is why he’s only mentioned in the last episodes of season1 almost like an afterthought
How can her seemingly dead ex compare to the hunk that is Halbrand? No wonder she forgot all about him until ep 7
Hahahaha!!!
Yet she's gonna get it on with Zauuuron.
Boombayah with the Dark Lord.
I mean it is Sauron 👀
Isn't her husband alive in LoTR?
Yeah very alive but ROP forgot to mention it until episode 7 🤭 But it seems that in season 2 we will see him already as they already cast the actor who will play her husband
Elves are immortal so yes. Their bodies can be destroyed but the spirits will go to Mandos halls were he will create their bodies anew free to resume as before.
People: this makes no sense. Celeborn can't be dead
Me: perhaps... Galadriel married twice. I mean, one partner for 10.000 years?...
Yes
Nah she said his name, Celeborn. Same one
She said his name out loud
“One partner for 10.000 years?”
Literally yes! Tolkien lore.
They are elves, they are supposed to more virtuous than mortals, and when they fall in love, they fall hard, they can literally die from heartbreak. So one partner for 10,000 years isn't going to make them restless.
We’re to believe that elves didn’t prepare armour that fit them? Elves who seem to have great capability of reforging a sword couldn’t fit armour for a literal prince?
This, plus calling hiim a silver clam , come on show writers that is just utter and complete bs when it is he that is actually the warrior out of the pair. Sure galadriel is a capable fighter but it is him that goes to defend Eregion, it is him that holds off sauron long enough to have Elrond join his forces. It is him that leads the elves of Lothlorien to Dol Guldur and captures the castle before Galadriel throws down its walls and lay bare it's pits.
the only way I can see his armor didn't properly fit is because his armor is too damaged to be repaired in time due to the kinslaying .
Celeborn will be introduced in season 3
I really hope it is a great actor
I really don't understand why her eyes and her face look the same in almost every scene. Often only her mouth moves.
I didn't watch the episodes, but I watched a lot of RUclips scenes of her.
LOTR movies Galadriel : her whole face same in almost every scene. Often only her mind moves 😂
Well she's just being a bad actor throughout the show. It wasn't the right casting
The Dark Lord apparently wasn’t enough for her. Now she’s after her son in law too!
Hahaha! But just to explain, it was Elrond who did that move for a ruse. Galadriel doesnt know that Elrond will do that so she isnt after her son in law. It is still a VERY STUPID SCENE. Urge I hate that scene so much. The writers just inserted that for controversy.
@@NinaC Oh I know, just making fun of some stupid shit.
"Tell me, where is Celeborn, for I much desire to speak with him..."
Why galadriel?
Is it just me or does this seem like a throw away that was put in by the showrunners after fans called them out on the lore? So much time spend talking about Finrod and how much she loved him and is going to avenge him no matter what! ... oh and the guy she was married to but that would just be gravy.
This scene was filmed a YEAR before the show premiered
So, if Celeborn died, who was that with her on Fellowship of the Ring and at the end of Return of the King?!
Nah he isnt dead. Just missing in action. With this decision I have no idea why the showrunners* decided to do that. We were all thinking he will show up this season 2 (and also Galadriel’s daughter) but seems like they arent included this season.
Elves dont die
@michaelriggs325 Oh, yes, they do... stick a sword through them, and you will see them die... they are immortal only by age. Their bodies are just as frail as ours!
I have a ring of immense power
celeborn don't come back. Your wife is not like you know.
Perpetually dirty - can’t believe this is an elf
Well they were just hit by a volcano eruption. I guess Galadriel should do a Fern in Frieren and just ask for laundry magic 👍👍👍
@@NinaC Awesome elf.
Nooooooo :,( I thought maybe she didn't meet him yet, so now they are rewriting things??
If they said that she didn't meet him yet, it would be rewriting things too. At this point Galadriel and Celeborn should be married for several thousand years and already have their daughter Celebrian (Arwen's mother)
But if they aren't allowed to The Silmarillion as material, why is everyone expecting Tolkien's vision? This series it's a "based-on" series not an adaptation.
@Easttowest why not? They wanted to do it and they could, it's on a streaming service so it's not like people are hold at gunpoint to watch it anyway.
@@lilamoonlight2007 The appendixes should be enough for them to do a masterpiece. It gave them extra spaces needed.
Also, reasons why people hated this show is
1. Wokeness. I'm all for colours and feminism, but making Galadriel like some arrogant jerk is kinda stupid, she's basically been to Valinor
2. Some bad CGI. Numenor only sent 3 ships????
3. Forgettable characters.
They could have fixed it had
1. Elves look more like elves, majestic. (Black people can also look majestic btw)
2. Make Galadriel more wiser and somewhat more commanding
3. Celeborn should always stick with Galadriel, where both support one another(Tolkien basically make love a central theme)
4. Start the whole story with everyone still recovering from the deluge of Beleriand, like, they tried to build back the glories of the old kingdoms of Gondolin and Nargothrond. And Annatar appearing, giving everyone a hope that everything can be return to what its once was.
This is my opinion, I ain't a storyteller, but I'm sure there are others that are more well versed in the lore of Middle Earth.
They could try to make their own and new story, not copy something what already exists
@@Keram-io8hv Kin Strife would be a nice story, a 10 year exile of Eldacar and the burning of Ostgilliath.
Legit you have a Rhaegar style story, since Valacar married a woman who is considered to be unacceptable according to Numenoreans standards.
Just don't make a series if it's gonna be this Innacurate. It's disrespectful honestly.
Erm... Amazon, Celeborn isn't dead
........(sigh)
This is wrong in so many levels
she literlly has zero aggression in her body language she looks like a child in armour
Celeborn is nowhere to be seen so Guyladriel can have her Bossgirl agenda. Same goes for Míriel and that other activist Actor. God i hate this abomination of a Show.
The fact the you use “Guyladriel” just tells me everything about you my dear.
They didn’t just kill off celeborn so Galadriel could have a girlmance with the queen of numenor. Canon celeborn is not gonna like this.
TOUCH SOME GRASS CHALLENGE!!!! **LEVEL IMPOSSIBLE!😱😱**
This trash is not worth to watch...Amazon has absolutely no respect from Tolkiens great work.
This show sucks ass so bad....
Well if there is any consolation season 2 is better than season 1 so far. But that is due to the Sauron and Elrond show
Oh here we go again..the new mystery box..but for $$$ and new subscription you will find out what happened to Celeborn. This show is beyond stupid and bad writing. Oh and did i mention member berries? -.-
Galadrail: My husband is dead!
Tolkien: No I specifically put him in the lor as living ♟️📝📖🤔😏
Me: the screenwriters need to be 🔥ed oh wait .... never mind 😂 thx Amazon you finally got one thing right 👍
Well technically she didnt say her husband is dead though. The question was “did you lose someone”. Those are two different things… And we all know he isnt even dead anyway so .
But yes go off to Amazon. My suggestion is you write them an email. I think their address is ihate@amazon.com