MUST SEE: Why I Quit Being a Jewish Anti-Israel Extremist | The Quad
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 июн 2024
- This week the Quad interview a former Jewish anti-Israel activist Ateret Violet Shmuel on why she hated Israel so much, what she believed about herself and other Jews and what made her decide to change directions. This is a MUST-SEE for anyone who wants to understand the current protests happening across the United States.
The Quad (Emily Schrader, Fleur Hassan-Nahoum , Vivian Bercovici , Ashira Solomon) are joined by Executive Director of Yeshiva University in Israel Stephanie Strauss to unpack the anti-Israel college protests that are threatening Jewish life on campus.
Chapters
00:00 Intro
1:31 Rafah Operation
3:35 Campus protests - where is this coming from and what can be done about it?
12:46 Interview: Ateret Violet Shmuel
29:30 Scumbags and Heroes
Subscribe Now to @JNS_TV
Stay informed about Israel and the Jewish World!
Latest news: Get in-depth analysis at bit.ly/jewish_news_service
Subscribe for more: Never miss a story - sign up for our newsletter bit.ly/subscribe_to_JNS
Support our work: Your donation helps JNS fight for accurate headlines: bit.ly/Support_JNS
The Quad (Fleur Hassan Nahoum, Emily Schrader, Vivian Bercovici and Ashira Solomon) premieres on
RUclips: @JNS_TV
Facebook: / jns.org
Twitter: / jns_org
Website: jns.org
You can catch the audio version of the show on
Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/2VxykG6...
Apple: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
or wherever you listen to your podcasts! 
Развлечения
I grew up in a Western Country with muslim family. I never had hatred for Jews, despite being taught to hate them. I would be more than happy to help a Jewish person or family in need while they are under attack. God bless you all.
You are so special. Most people if they are taught to hate, the will hate, but you managed not to be this way.
It seems that you are above brainwashing, that's is very cool!
You're lucky you didn't grew up in a Muslim country. The brainwashing to hate Jews there is extremely strong! Thank you for not falling to hate and bigotry!!!
thank you...inshallah, it wont come to that, but what you could do now is explain to you muslim family, to get them to see the errors of what they have learned. let them be honest about the personality of their prophet, the rape of aisha at age 9, the sex slaves, etc, and compare that to the life of Jesus and the Jewish prophets...
I SERIOUSLY DOUBT THAT GOING BY YOUR NAME
Thank you so much❤
I stand with Israel, always! From an American ally.
Translation: "I'm totally for mass slaughter and genocide of an entire civilization, whooooo!!! I'm Hannibal Lecter! Yaaay serial killers, this is awesome!!" You should just take yourself out of the gene pool now.
Even after Sde Teiman? Even after Hind Rajab, and 10,000 other kids just like her? This is not about Hamas, this is a thinly veiled genocide... just listen to the words of the Israeli leaders themselves.
Why Egypt built second wall?
Why Palestinians tried to take over Jordan?
What Palestinians did in Lebanon?
Why would you believe Hamas - they have no respect to human life .
@@tweaker1bms
😂😂😂
Brainwashed numbnut
No one gives a flip, dude
As a South African, I stand with Israel and the Jewish people. And do not fear the ordinary peoples of the world, the silent majority, stand with Israel. Their voices will be heard...
I wish you better government in the future . Thank you. We pray for SA
@@useyourdelusion6807do you simpathise with Hamas?
@@Forbiddenjadetheonly huh? Weird question.
Why would you stand with a genocidal apartheid state, who actively supported and funded apartheid south africa
@@useyourdelusion6807not realy, I thought the same.
As a Dane i Stand with Israel.
Thank you! That means a lot!!! And thanks Denmark for giving us both jury and public points at the Eurovision yesterday!!! It was a huge display of support and love for Israel! 🥰
What is not being talked about is the fact that the problem Israel is having is the mass migration of Muslims into Western countries.
The problem Israel is having is mass migration of Middle Eastern people into Westin countries
Thank you so much, I LOVE Denmark too! We have been visiting Hvide Sande and Blavand two years ago!
@@GPBKM ... Denmark here, we also stood with the Jews during WW2
I stand with Israel and the Jewish people ❣️
❤️❤️🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
And the many good Arab and Christian Israel citizens
AND MANCHESTER PEOPLE IN ENGLAND 🇬🇧 SOME PEOPLE WHO ARE TRULY AMAZING LOVELY BEAUTIFUL PEOPLE 😍 🤩 👌 WISH YOU THE VERY BEST 👌
WE ARE LOST WITHOUT ISRAEL !!
I didn't think it before but now I believe that Israel is a necessity, these students have convinced me of the necessity of a Jewish homeland-God bless the Jewish people.
God dont bless no mess
The only problem is, all our jewish eggs are in one basket. If they destroy Israel, 50% of the world's Jews will be gone. Though, if I'm going to die, I want to die with my brothers and sisters
@@egyptwasblack2 According to who ?.
@@egyptwasblack2Correct. And since he has blessed the Jewish people we know they are not a mess! ♥️ ✡️
Modern israel is a mess and has nothing do with ancient israel.
From the Netherlands: as a Christian woman I cannot do anything else but stand with Israel. They are our spiritual brothers and sisters. And they are the nicest people in the world. I met so many of them. I even knew some of them in Sderot and other villages around Gaza. ✝️🇳🇱❤️🇮🇱🙏🏻🎗️🎗️
Deuteronomy 29:27-29
Thank you.
I appreciate that you stand with Israel but you should really get out of the Abrahamic religions. They have destroyed the world. If you are a Christian you are a Luciferian and you’re not saved. Know the real Jesus.
You are minority you like it or not.
Ty! May the G-d of israel bless you ❤
I stand with Israel.
There was a horrible situation, Jews against Jews. please Israel unite against the outside and stay strong .. Am Israel Chai xxx
A juwesh people have to unite and fight hate to the core together not apart . SHALOM TO YOU!!
Unfortunately, there are Antisemitic Jews who have been at gut to hate themselves and most of the time, these leftists do this to fit in or because they are mashuganah, crazy like Norman Finklestein who makes money by pandering to holocaust deniers. Luckily they are very small in number, but the problem is these antisemitic Jews are being used by Jew haters to try to say they are the majority. 94% of Israelis are for a war to end all threats from Iran and its proxies
It's humanity vs Israel...
זה שיש בינינו חילוקי דעות מהותיים בגלל ממשל פגום ולקוי, זה לא אומר כלום, זה כמו במשפחה נורמלית עם ויכוחים וצעקות. כאלה אנחנו, ולרגע לא שוכחים את האחדות וצבא לעת מצוקה💪🇮🇱🕊
Never forget the October 7th genocide, never !!!!!
Provided by Bibi Netenyahu support of Hamas. Just a fact
@@bdadolph That was a bad chess move, but please, don't even try to offload all fault away from Islamist agendas. They are all like this.
What about 75 years of illegal occupation?
@@tanzirhossain7159there is no illegal occupation
@@bdadolph To say that BB supported HAMAS it is a lie; Iran was the one who did it. Israel transferred money to the Palestinians, and they chose Hamas as their government, so it went through them, and it is solely their fault and responsibility. But, as usual, they pass the blame onto others...
As a German I stand with Israel 🇮🇱
💙
@@Gee-xb7rt Said Goebberls
I stand with Israel always ❣️
@@victoriakn7480 Yes, you wear the curse of God, and you will meet the same fate as the abominations that break God's laws.
The Ottoman census of 1878 indicated the following demographics for the Jerusalem, Nablus, and Acre districts.
Muslim -403,795 or 85.5%
Christian-43,659 or 9.2%
Jewish-15,001 or 3.2% Jewish (Foreign-born) -10,000 or 2.1%
Who would want to waste a bagel on a pro-Hamas demonstrator?
I hope a bakery sends them loads of bagels as a troll.
Edit: grammar
😂😂😂😂😂😅😂❤
bagel? dog?
@@agengsatya96haha bagel not beagle
They should have delivered a truck load of baloney because that's what their narrative is.
Hello from Switzerland I stand with Israel and I pray for wisdom and freedom God bless you all
May Israel keep strong in its resolve to combat the horrific attacks perpetrated on the Holy Land on October 7, 2023. May God continue to protect and bless Israel and its people.
Nothing holy about a genocide that started since 1948. Hypocrite
Amen ✨️ 🙏🏻 ✨️
Hatred of Israel and the Jews is the epitome of ignorance. I've known more than enough Israelis and indeed Jews outside as well as inside Israel. They are righteous people. Those who hate them probably don't know any in person and need scapegoats to hate and to blame for many of the world's problems. If Israel falls the West will fall. In turning against Israel, the West is losing its morals and its values. Israell be strong. You were savagely attacked on 7th October and your people have suffered immensely sincetime immemorial. If western countries wish to uphold a supposedly liberated world after the defeat and death of Hitler, they, indeed we cannot afford to undo the good which has been done since then. Long live Israel. Long live democracy in the rapidly rotting world of people supporting terrorism.
@@VeyPericas 🥱
@@egyptwasblack2awww, another activist. Read a book
"Egypt was black" says everything we need to know about your education.
I am not a Jew neither am I a Muslim, I come from a Scottish protestant family. I have supported Israel not just since the terrible massacre of innocent people on the 7th October. I've always had great admiration for the Jewish people who are, and people should acknowledge this if they'd care to do some research, that they have been the most oppressed people for thousands of years, well above the black Africans who certainly were victims of slavery, no denial there. Yet, despite their ordeals, they do not consider themselves as victims. They have licked their wounds, pulled up their sleeves, built up their lives, considered education for themselves and future generations paramount, hence their success in many fields, I have no doubt. I listened to Ateret Violet Shmuel with great interest and although I have no doubt your channel is pretty widespread, she should be invited on to other podcasters' videos for her message to be heard by many more to counteract the narratives of those who continue to poison the minds of young people including those who are Jewish themselves, spewing them lies and teaching them self-hate. Be assured that there are many like me who don't swallow the bait, recognise the negative propoganda spread about Israel and the Jews as a whole. May this war which has been raging for months now, be won by Israel who are a beacon of light in the darkness of the Middle East. Thoughts for those hostages who are still in the grips of Hamas, praying they will go home safe and sound.
❤🙏
Thanks!
❤
❤️
Well said. Very well written. I applaud you 👏
I stand with isreal
The Ottoman census of 1878 indicated the following demographics for the Jerusalem, Nablus, and Acre districts.
Muslim -403,795 or 85.5%
Christian-43,659 or 9.2%
Jewish-15,001 or 3.2% Jewish (Foreign-born) -10,000 or 2.1%
@@theredboneking Your statistics are incorrect.
Learn to spell!
Even the Jewish Virtual Library has the Jewish population at 8% in 1882.
@katrinakaesehagen7676 I can find no information to support your claim. What I do know is that people living in that area in the 1930s, can recall a time when Jews and Palestinians babysat each other’s children.
The Trans Atlantic slave trade is well documented and the names of the ships and their owners are available.
I stand with israel.
Wonderful video. Am Israel Chai. Love from Spain!
Finally a Spaniard that isn't a Francoist Israel hater.
As a Christian from New Zealand I stand with Israel 100%
My hero is Eden Golan who represented Israel in the Eurovision contest.
Standing tall and proud,she gave an inspiring performance despite the booing haters whose sole purpose was to harass her.
Bravo Eden for standing your ground and brilliantly singing the song that they didn’t want to hear❤️
You deserve a gold star ⭐️
Every Jewish American should remember that If his grandfather had not immigrated to the United States before 1921, the year the gates of the United States were closed to Jewish immigrants. he would probably be an Israeli today, that is, if his grandfather had survived the Holocaust. The quotas for Jewish immigration to the United States since 1921 are very low and the odds are close to zero.
I thought immigration restrictions were reduced after 1924 but 1921 might be right. I am 3/4 1921 by the way. My great grandmother came in 1929 which, as you indicate, was very rate. In other news, need to build the hotels/bungalows again in Sullivan county again since we probably won't be able to vacation in other places with the Jew Hatred.
The Ottoman census of 1878 indicated the following demographics for the Jerusalem, Nablus, and Acre districts.
Muslim -403,795 or 85.5%
Christian-43,659 or 9.2%
Jewish-15,001 or 3.2% Jewish (Foreign-born) -10,000 or 2.1%
Recall that ship called the St louis that turned away Jews fleeing from Nazis in Canada and united states.
@@theredboneking The emigration of Jews from Europe to Palestine increased greatly after 1921 because of the massacres and pogroms perpetrated there, and the fact that the United States and the rest of the world closed their doors to the Jews. Palestine was the only place they could escape to.
@ThePropress Before the Romans forced them out?
Bullies have always been fashionable. As someone who was bullied in middle school, I can directly attest to this. When my mom went to my sixth grade teacher about this, she was told that the bully was troubled and they were trying to help him. She responded, who’s trying to help my daughter?
Society and schools unconsciously side with bullies because the bully embodies seemingly positive traits, physical strength and the ability to aggressively assert that “strength”, while the bullied person shows the traits they don’t like, the inability to fight back. Seeming strength vs. seeming weakness, that’s why schools do NOTHING about bullies.
This was so enlightening. I am a Gentile but I have always supported Israel and Jews! I pray God will see Israel and the Jews through this crisis! May God’s will be done!
@user-xf7kd4jd2n
G-d bless you and I know that he will.
Ateret Shmuel was eloquent and unreservedly fantastic!! Thank you Quad!
It’s good that she has come around to sanity about her *own* people, but she still seems to buy into Leftism. A pity.
The Jews have survived thousands of years of oppression only because they kept the Torah! A recent poll showed that Jews are the happiest people in the world despite their centuries of persecution! This is due to their connection to God! God is pure joy!
They have a family.
Oh please. 🥱
I know very few Jews who even believe in Torah, much less keep Torah. Many promote homosexuality, transgender garbage, and all kind of anti-Torah ideologies and beliefs. Others replace Torah with Talmud, Mishnah, etc., and honor those more than they honor or keep Torah. Sad to say, this is what I have seen.
The majority of Jews have not kept Torah. Israel’s God has kept Jews. He will come through for Israel and show His power. Moshiach will come and rescue Israel and Israel will recognize the one that was pierced and who gave His life to redeem His people, also offered to the whole world. He will come as King of Israel.
If you are referring to the same annual poll i think you are, it compares *countries*, not religions, so it ranks Israel against other nations, and does not make any reference to, or statement about Jews around the world.
As such, the factors affecting happiness are multi-faceted and societal, and do not just boil down to religiosity. As you surely know, a large number of Israelis are secular. So if happiness were linked to, or due to “their connection to God”, Israel would rank much lower (because so many Israelis are not religious).
*If we are talking about the same poll.
@@egyptwasblack2 : your username indicates difficulties separating reality from fantasy. maybe take a trip to egypt and see if you can find 2 people who agree with you. (just warning in advance, though, they really do not like this agenda there.)
I think Ateret's interview is WAY too important to be just hidden in the middle of a 41 minute long youtube video.
Ateret's voice is incredibly important and needs to be surfaced everywhere.
Agree that girl is right
Indigenous rights are Jewish rights!
I agree 👍 with that 1000 %.
Nope. DNa says palestinians are the closest people to the ancient hebrews... Netanyahu descends drom Khazars and have 0 semitic ancestry. Try again, you failed
@@egyptwasblack2that is actually a lie. Which is something you do all the time jusging by your name.
@@DonXardas thats not a lie. Its known fact. DNA speaks for itself. Ancient hebrews doesnt exist anymore and the closest people to them are the Palestinians who never left the place. DNA tests are illegal in Israel for the simple fact that they want to hide the truth....you better run and tell that
@@egyptwasblack2 If that's true then they should deconvert from their colonialist Arab cult and come back to the land of their people.
One of my parents is Israeli taught me about Israel and took me there a lot. I feel like the American Jews all should go there. You feel alive and can feel people’s souls present when you speak there.
I agree with “feel people’s souls”. The Israeli’s are 100% authentic.
The excuse that it is 'not their fault' can only be used for so long.
These young people's ignorant and bigoted activism is the outcome
of a lack of character that their parents have never taught them.
The Ottoman census of 1878 indicated the following demographics for the Jerusalem, Nablus, and Acre districts.
Muslim -403,795 or 85.5%
Christian-43,659 or 9.2%
Jewish-15,001 or 3.2% Jewish (Foreign-born) -10,000 or 2.1%
@@theredbonekingthe Ottoman Empire went bye-bye at end of WWI, signing the Treaty of Sevres, and conceeding its claim on its territories, like Palestine to the Allies.
And in 1948, the New immigrants threw out most of the indigenous population that had lived there since the 7th century. 750,000 in 1948 and another 300,000 in 1967.
People living there in the 1930’s can recall a time when Jews and Arabs would babysit each other’s children…….until the Zionists arrived.
@@theredboneking Please explain why that happened.
Thank You, Ateret. You truly did the world a favor with telling your testimony, it put some calm in my heart for those who have turned against Israel around me, because your testimony told me that it doesn't mean they're inherently evil, just mislead and brainwashed by the propaganda.
Deuteronomy 29:27-
And the L‑rd uprooted them from upon their land, with fury, anger and great wrath, and He cast them to another land, as it is this day.’ Just as a day passes and it will never return, so too, 👉they will be exiled never to return.”👈
Deuteronomy 29:24 -
All the nations will say, ‘Why has the Lord done thus to this land? Why this great outburst of anger?'
Deuteronomy 29:25 -
Then men will say, ‘Because they forsook the covenant of the Lord , the God of their fathers, which He made with them when He brought them out of the land of Egypt.
Deuteronomy 32:26-27 -
26 I said, I would scatter them into corners, 👉I would make the remembrance of them to cease from among men:👈
27 Were it not that I feared the wrath of the enemy, lest their adversaries should behave themselves strangely, and lest they should say, Our hand is high, and the Lord hath not done all this.
Unfortunately they are doing evil, whether they think so or not.
The Jewish Virtual Library shows 8% Jewish population in 1882. 85% Arab population, which have lived there for generations. Since the 7th century. Israel professor Dr Ilan explains in one of several books, how the two switched.
@@theredboneking no
As a South African 🇿🇦 living in New Zealand 🇳🇿 I stand with Israel 🇮🇱
funny how no ones care about the christians in holy land...
Thank you 🙏🏻🇮🇱💕
@@SS-lk6wf south african stand with mandela not apartheid
I don’t think we should avoid the term Zionism. The reason Zionism is treated as a curse and considered fascism is that antisemites have defined it that way and spread that definition purposely. I don’t think it’s right to adopt the language as changed by people who use it to manipulate.
I also don’t think we should be trying to fit Jews in to these narratives of oppressor/oppressed, colonizer, etc. They are purposeful blood libel, whether used against Jews or anyone else. Some of them may have good intentions and want to do good in the world, but most are using it as a way to bully and gain power, even if they are thinking they are doing good. It needs to end.
I believe the word Zionism should be used more often in the correct way. People should explain what it means, its history etc.
Jew, Juif, Jid, Yahud, Ebreo, Jude, Zid, Yahudi: all treated as the worst insult you could give someone. You don’t change a term which is indigenous to the Jewish people (in the English language) because it’s perceived as something unforgivable. It’s perceived that way because it’s associated with Jews. So I agree with you: “it’s not right to adopt the language as changed by people who use it to manipulate”. And instead see it this way: “A rose by any other name…” If the rose haters have poo on their upper lip and it alters their sense of smell, should a rose rename itself?
I disagree. The left has already turn the words Zionism and Zionist into a pejorative. It's a harsh sounding word that kinda sounds like Nazi doesn't it. Until 5 years ago I rarely heard the word. Jews like me were PRO ISRAEL. I am still pro Israel. In my mind, once the State of Israel was created in 1948, the Zionists had reached their goal. As such, Zionism as a movement no longer needed to exist. The word Zionist was retconned by anti-Jewish forces to use as a sword and as a mask against what they truly are - Jew haters and, therefore, antisemites.
Someone once asked me to define Zionism, and I said decolonization of the Jewish homeland. Too many people seem to forget that the Arabs are colonizers, of other peoples' lands, throughout the Levant and northern Africa. We need to stop referring to the Arabs, who are occupying parts of Israel, as "palestinians", and refer to them as Arab colonizers.
> "whether used against Jews or anyone else"
Exactly. Schmuel needs to continue her deprogramming, and not just try to remove Jews from the targeting of the illiberal left. (Though I can see why that would be a priority for her).
I guess I can't relate to these students today. I went to college thirty years ago and I questioned everything. I never accepted what a professor said without questioning it and deciding for myself whether I believed it. It's difficult for me to understand how people could fall for this 'victim/oppressor' garbage.
It is indeed hard to believe that university students have such a lack of critical thinking skills. Possibly a reflection of society at large.... getting dumber by the day Still... you'd expect the young generation to actually want to think and discover the truth of history. The other factor is that the activists that are now the professors in these universities have an agenda to indoctrinate their students. Its all a bit depressing really
You did not grow being told America & the West was evil, the way the schools & their books have been sneaking this
toxin into books & teaching lessons for a long time. Brainwashing works, that is the reason the left uses it.
Intifada just another word for war with Israel.
Jihad is the same thing.
True !!!!
& other non Muslims are the target as well. They are compelled to destroy all of us by their religion.
Jihad is war with everyone who doesn't agree with you. You can have two sides both waging Muslim Jihad.
Great show ladies. Always informative, intelligent and inspiring in these difficult times. The studio set is very attractive too. Keep up your good work. 👏🏻 PS My hero of the week would have been Eden Golan at the Eurovision Sing Contest. She sang so well and was so brave when being physically and verbally threatened by irrational Jewphobia.
❤👍💯
You’re right! Eden kept smiling through it all. Not an easy thing to do.
Your guest's advice to any young people who are anti-Israel was perfect.
Like all civilized humans, I stand strongly with Israel.
Jewish students are welcome to come study in Israel!
As a Christian from the Netherlands I support Israel and the Israelis, and the Jews all over the world.
Praying for the Peace of Jerusalem.
G d bless you all.
🙏🏻🙏🏻🇮🇱
Proud Christian standing with Israel. May Al Shaddai bless and guide you all.
Thank you, ladies, for your inteligent conversation.
Remember, non jewish intelligent women are with you 100%, we stand firmly with you, we know Israel defends not just Israel but our Western culture and our safety.
G-d bless you and may we win , there is no other way.
I tried to understand this entire anti Israeli non-sense in the West, and I really dont get it but we must win it, simply must !
LOL Speak for yourself.
@@darrenwithers3628And for millions of us. Seems YOU are the one speaking only for yourself here.
I have such a problem with being Jewish "Anti-Israel." I just don't understand it and yes, I have trouble tolerating/forgiving. I am an immigrant (actually had two emigrations), am close to ultimate tragedies of the last century (father lost entire Polish-Jewish traditional family, among other things), and being anti-Israel was something that never entered a mind of any member of my seriously truncated family.
Yes, I don't understand how people having unlimited access to information and luxurious (even the underprivileged) lives, choose barbarity.
well there's a reason why people are getting furious about Israel..
I can tell you as someone who went from a strong supporter, to being somewhat ashamed of Israel is that it is the "conditioning" that these student groups and student advocates do to their Jewish ✡️ classmate! They convince you that you if you support Israel 🇮🇱 than you are no better than the Nazis, the Russians, the Spanish etc. They compare Israel to the worse of human history and make you a supporter of Israel just as bad as the people who killed your ancestors all those years ago! They tell you that Jews are "white" colonizers and that Israel is not Judea! They prey upon those who like myself, who are trying to discover their identity and what it means to be Jewish! They go after the ignorant Jews, who tend be more secular and who don't get exposure to Jewish Life!
@@stefansollberger5658and think black ppl are inferior?
There has to be a reason, right?
Obviously not.
@@stefansollberger5658 Yes, and the reason is well known. It's antisemitism, Herr Sollberger.
dr anna
@@anna-tn8mg that's a bit too simple...i can't hear anymore that word antisemitism....it's just used to put people silent
by the way i heard that most people in Israel are racists. What's worse...being so called antisemitic (ridiculous) or being racist.,
Love you all. You are amazing, brilliant, and brave people! 🙏🇮🇱🇺🇲❤️❤️❤️
I think the schools should kick out these students who are protesting. Also take their scholarships away.
And what about the paid protesters?
It's refreshing to unexpectedly stumble upon something that's actually positive. Great interview.
What? A liar pretendiing they were pro Palestine?
Ateret is great! Thanks for having her on!
IT'S A SPIRITUAL BATTLE; 1ST AND FOREMOST#!
The world, on the whole, WILL NOT & CAN NOT UNDERSTAND the Jewish life and it's CREATION!!!
🥱
@@egyptwasblack2you will yawn your way to kafakela.
@@mtzipora sorry i dont kill people, steal their lands, their identity and lie on them.
🎼Give Israelis Peace. Leave, Leave Israel in Peace.🎶
"you don't have to openly hate Jews to be an anti-Semite" perfect. I do feel really sorry for these students and I thank this woman for speaking out.
Of course Zionists would say that because Palestine supporters don't hate Jews.
Absolutely heartbreaking. It has to stop. I feel like I'm living in an alternate reality since October 7. 😢💔🎗️🇮🇱
Nah, you just can't handle the truth about Israel and deny reality.
@@darrenwithers3628on what fact do you base that?
Maybe just say nothing if you can not understand what this person is talking about….and it is sure that you just don’t understand the comment.
I pray that your hart will be heald and that you will encounter the love of Christ. I stand with Israel from the netherlands 🇦🇷🇱🇺💙❤️
@@darrenwithers3628you are everywhere! Who pays you dude?
EDEN YES YES YES AND ALL OUT STRONG SISTERS 🇮🇱💙💙💙🇮🇱
5th place. Thank you world for your votes!
This is such a wonderful conversation and so affirming. I am a Ph.D. at Brown, and I have been feeling the same way. I share all the values that Ateret has. When October 7th happened, about two days after the tone of the rhetoric on Israeli TV has changed from shock and fear to retaliation and revenge. I was very angry because I knew what is about to happen. I am very critical of Bibi’s government and I am definitely not for the death of innocent people. However, the narratives taught in these universities, especially liberal ones are dangerously false. I study Religious Studies but I am a Sinologist and one thing you learn quickly doing any studies related to East Asia is that western paradigms just don’t fit. The same can be said for Israel. I am also in a Gender Studies program because I focus on women in Chinese religion and the narratives of oppressor and oppressed just dominate in all programs in the humanities. It does feel a lot like brainwashing. And no matter how much professors might emphasize that all views are welcome. This is just not true. The left doesn’t welcome any more dissent. I felt very isolated on campus last semester. Now I am doing research in Taiwan and am just extremely delighted not to be on campus. I feel like American universities have lost the plot.
"It does feel a lot like brainwashing". Do you know why ? Because it is...that simple. You must know the old saying : 'If it looks like a duck, walks like a duck and quacks like a duck, then it`s a duck".
@@paulcarfantan6688I agree. But I was raised in Israel, served in the IDF spokesperson, was an officer and so I was there for three years. I am a product of Israel and I love my country. I am also a naturalized American, and I love this country. I also did my BA and MA in China, and I love that country. Brainwashing exists literally everywhere. I am VERY critical of the Israel education system. Perhaps not a popular opinion in a chanel that seems to think highly of Emily Schrader---Israel lies. Maybe not about everything, not all the time, but it does. Just now, I have a friend who is a peace activist and been one all her life and served with me in the IDF, she shared live footage of how settlers are destroying food supply to Gaza. This is not something Israelis will ever share with the world, will they? What makes us look bad we hide. There's a lot of ugly dishonesty going around. As someone who also had to basically defend and explain what the IDF is doing, I hate to tell you, it's not one bad apple, there are quite a lot.
You don't want to engage with or encourage antisemitism, I get that, but even this chanel, and I appreciate what these women are doing, is not free of bias. I am one of those Jews, and I get a lot of flack for that, who cares about the truth in all its ugliness. I care about integrity.
@@talihershkovitz689 So you`re very critical of Israel`s education system, okay, that`s interesting. But I wonder, are you also very critical of the Palestinian education system ?
I`m curious.
@@paulcarfantan6688 why is it "interesting"? It's interesting that I am a thinking human being and am capable of questioning the paradigms and "facts" that were taught to me? 🤔. And why such a statement merits an immediate comparison to the Palestinians? It's common knowledge that they are brainwashed from a young age to hate Israelis. But Israel also just bombed all schools and universities that existed in Gaza. What was taught it them I couldn't tell you, but I am sure it wasn't just "we hate Israel" on repeat all day long. I don't know why on the one hand Israelis proclaim we are better, more democratic, more enlightened (true for some, maybe most but not all), have better values----all of which I generally agree with----and at the same time, every time there is a critique of Israel, people parrot "but what about the Palestinians?"
@@paulcarfantan6688 1) anyone who claims to be a thinking human being should be critical of the paradigms and half-facts that are taught in most education systems of the so-called free world. 2) What does it matter what I think of the Palestinians? I will answer directly because otherwise you'll say I am equivocating. Everyone knows they are brainwashes to hate us. But Israel just razed all their school and 12 universities. While I am sure those institutions taught anti-israel content, I doubt it was "we hate Israel" all day every day on repeat.
Why everytime people criticize Israel , instead of addressing such critique head on, Jews and Israelis alike parrot back "but what about the Palestinians?" On the one hand, proclaiming we are better than them, more democratic, more enlightened and then fall back to false comparisons. It's a weak and frankly, absurd line of argument. Know your audience, you are talking to a native Hebrew speaker, a product of Israeli society, a former IDF officer, and my entire family lives there. I am tethered to the country, for better or for worse, even if I live overseas. There is no need to parrot "what about the Palestinians" with me because I know a thing or two about the Palestinians.
I’m going out to counter protest with my Jewish brothers this week
Yeah? And you are going to start crying anti semitism when they oppose you.
@@darrenwithers3628 I can’t say that cuz I’m not Jewish and obviously don’t matter as much
Thank goodness I’m not the only one who thinks Norman Stinklefein is a (insert derogatory word of your choice).
He is a terrible person. Good Lord!!
He is the intellectual Equivalent of Stella Goldschlag.
@@OhUiginnthat was too kind. He’s the intellectual equivalent of a retaining wall that can’t retain anything.
He uses his Jewish identity to legitimise his repugnant ideas. The worst kind of Jew you can imagine.
Unbelievable how those students had a need to show hate even for him. Talk about a kapo compmex
Am proud of you ladies for great stuff on you show. Well done!! Keep it up!!
Love you Emily!! Stay strong and keep smiling 😊 ❤. I’ve watched you on several programs and I support everything you are for.
I went to Jewish school and became a carpenter. Most Jews in my area leave for larger cities and intermarry like me. So it’s sad when you do go to the temple and there is only 20 people 80 years old.
I voted for Trump twice and moved to the country and really are at odds with a lot of Jews. We only share an ancient and religious history and I am not in their tax bracket.
The left has hated white Americans for twenty years. But now the right wants to abandon Israel and save what money we have as a country. I am at complete odds with the Democrats and leftist. Nothing I learned in Hebrew school was open borders trans and Gay.
🤍
Make aliyah
I have been very disappointed to see so many on the right go against Israel. Will never again watch or follow them. My support is to Israel and the Jewish right to live in their land in peace. Those who hate Israel spew lies, false history and propaganda. If someone identifies as a so called Palestinian they should be living in what was called TransJordan (& that land too should belong to Israel)
Biden and the left wants to abandon Israel.
I think you should make Aliyah. Israel needs people that can make and build. I wish I could live in Israel,but I don’t qualify as Jewish…
Jews must follow the Torah in order to save themselves and to live a moral and fulfilling and happy life as been demonstrated for thousands of years!
It is their fault. Ignorance is not an excuse. I am not even Jewish and I am on the side of Israel. It is easy to find the truths in this day and age. Information is very attainable.
You are the one who is ignorant and listening to propaganda.
I do not totally disagree with the statements that most start out with good intentions. I believe there are still and always were well intentioned individuals, but I believe that there is a clear and growing number of nefarious and subversive people in a vein of social justice that do not in any way have anything positive or well intentioned that they start with.
100%
Blessings to israel...and may your enemies be utterly discouraged. May they all learn that God certainly loves and protects the Jews.
🥱
@@egyptwasblack2 you are not bored by that statement.....you are worried that it is the truth. You are about to learn that the Jews are indeed Gods chosen people. Israel will always prevail. God has their backs. You can try yawning about that but you are far from sleepy.....
@@butterflywings-lk9fu Girl bye. Ancient hebrews dont exist anymore and these new one are not chosen.
The Jews are successful because God blesses the Jews as it says in the Bible!
God dont bless no mess
@@egyptwasblack2 The world becomes more dumbed down by comments like yours! Immature people who base their comments on lies that are not derived from any facts are simply ignored by normal people! When a child-like mind makes such comments it demonstrates that the one who made the comments disgraces himself and he doesn't realize that anyone reading such juvenile comments thinks that the commenter's mind did not mature past kindergarten! Do not forget to change your diapers the next time you vomit another comment like this!
And the whole world is blessed thru them 💖
@@brendabrinkmanpasichnyk3500 thats a lie
What a stupid statement.
I liked very much your choices for the Heroes ❤. I thank them all and I thank you !
Love Israel. Thank you for sharing this, well done!!!! 💗Love & Light
Great show, as always, ladies! Sending prayers and support to you all.
From the Sea to the River Israel Forever!♥️🇮🇱♥️✡️♥️✌️
🇮🇱Am Yisrael Chai🇮🇱
If our children have been taught empiricism and logical thinking critical thinking and so on, then they wouldn't be so easily victimized
So, what about the parents teaching proper values and critical thinking? If I disagreed with anything that was taught at school, I addressed why I didn't agree. My opinions, which I gave reasons for, are my child's opinions too.
Thank you for your openness and courage to share your experience! Your comments will help many young people who are blinded by antisemitic propaganda and poisoned narrative about Jews and Israel. Hope many people listen your message!
@@joebrewer4529 🤔🤔🤔
Finkelstein is gonna have a hell of a wake up call… sooner rather than later.
He is such an hateful human being a d a lier.
Terrible person.
I really doubt it. He is far too identified with his position, with his self perceived importance. The adoration of any and every person who embraces his position is not going to given up. He is the ultimate bad faith actor in my opinion. Relying on the suffering of Palestinians for his legitimacy. Just disgusting.
@@MeganLeibovici When the war is over and when the fog of war vanish, the mob will move on to the next self righteous cause and will forget Israel and Palestine. There will be no one to listen to him. He will either apologize and tell the truth or he will stand alone for the rest of his days.
Free Palestine
Stand strong fear not
Glad you lady's are back,I've missed you,love from the UK 🇬🇧
Ladies.
Good one - so appreciate you guys
Why don't you have Mosab Hassan Yousef(Green Prince) Douglas Murray on your show
In NZ , our family was invited to Host Israeli Travelers . We ,my husband and I felt led to say Yes ,to this work of Service , to Isrel and HA SHEM. WE knew ,back in 2000 .that these days were coming . We're Believers in Yahshua and study The Revelation book of B,rit HA Dasha, so we know, our service , was going to lead to future sacrifice.,which is in these days We're in today. Hosting Israeli Travellers ,may lead to persecution ,SO be it . Whether we live ,or die , with Israel, we belong to HA SHEM, our MIGHTY MAKER OF US ALL . OUR SOULS BELONG TO HIM , ANYWAY . love in Him, from NZ,HIT❤
What Ateret Violet Shmuel said was very helpful.
Thanks a lot for your very important conversation ❤❤❤
There was the Eurovision just now. Despite how much they have tried to boycot the Israelian participant and despite the various protests against Israel in and out the venue and worldwide, and despite the political decision of the judges, the PEOPLE'S vote was VERY clear.
She arrived 2nd with votes coming from all over the world and this proves what the majority of people Worldwide feels about Israel.
I, together with the large majority worldwide, stand for Israel from East Africa
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Viva Israel 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱❤️
I mean, this is the dumbest comment ever but if you say so lol
@@darrenwithers3628 L you just can't take the reality that the majority of THE PEOPLE voted for her and proved to stand for Sra
Cry baby, cry
I used to believe in conspiracy theories about 15 years ago and “zionism” was this eerie, mysterious word related to world domination, war and conspiracy. I thought when I overcame that nonsensical and truly ig..no..ra..nt world view that the world would soon follow. Now I’m shocked at hearing academics use the term in a similar way. Recently I had someone explain to me that “certainly there’s antisemitism in this conflict but there’s also the reverse, namely zionism, which is racism against Muslim people”…I thought I was hallucinating but that is apparently what people understand zionism to be nowadays. Instead of opening up a dictionary for once people fall for all the antisemitic propaganda without even realizing that it is antisemitic or at least rooted in antisemitic sentiments that are centuries old.
I was a huge conspiracy theorist myself, most of that stuff is complete cancer and will hurt your worldview. I don’t agree 100% with what is goin on but I’m not for Islam taking over and Israel has a right to exist.
Zionism is the belief in an ethno nationalist State. It's racism. Pure and simple.
I do want to make sure we and the media remember the calm voices of the students who are still going to school, not breaking laws, not being radicalized. My daughter one of them.
I've been waiting to hear this story. Hope it's educational
The Jews have nothing to fear because God protects them forever! In the end all Jew haters will be severely punished by God as it says in the Bible!
Are your gods called Rotschild and freemasons ?
@@egyptwasblack2 The world becomes more dumbed down by comments like yours! Immature people who base their comments on lies that are not derived from any facts are simply ignored by normal people! When a child-like mind makes such comments it demonstrates that the one who made the comments disgraces himself and he doesn't realize that anyone reading such juvenile comments thinks that the commenter's mind did not mature past kindergarten! Do not forget to change your diapers the next time you vomit another comment like this!
True, but Jewish heretics will also be punished.
@@egyptwasblack2 ahh there you go again..... fear and denial
@@butterflywings-lk9fu Is your god Rotschild ?
I'm somewhere in S.E.Asia I stand with Israel.
I’m not Jewish, in fact I’m an atheist, but as a people I admire you. I support you and am going to wear the Star of David until this passes.
Indulgence! THATS the word! Thanks. 😊
I support Israel.
You all are my heroes!
THIS Gentile stands with Israel!
Thank you, it means the world 🇮🇱🙏🏻💕
Can we make Emily the Hero of the day for the interview on Pierce Morgan with Cenk, something or other? Emily was an absolute Legend. Calm, articulate and intelligent. Just brilliant.
I miss you too. You are wonderful. Nice to see and hear you again
Ateret - Please start a RUclips channel and dedicate it to this cause. ❤
💯 agree
love how being against ultra-nationalism is considered extreme!
Very interesting, intelligent conversations.
Norm Fink might have learnt in those few seconds (after his speech) , more than during his whole life. I didn’t loose hope for him.
Millions of Americans like me support Trump and Israel!
Great show, ladies. Much love from the UK 🤍💙
2nd comment here. This is the very best addressing of the wound within our youth that I have heard to date. I would extend the kindness to Jewish youth certainly but not exclusively.
I ♥️ Ziostan!
Your Star of David is beautiful Fleur. Emily was fantastic on Piers today.
If there is another debate, please ask Rania to answer this: Most Palestinians in Lebanon have never been afforded entitlement under the law to Lebanese citizenship and therefore remain stateless. This includes many who arrived from what is now Israel as early as 1948 during the Arab-Israeli war, and their descendants.6 Mar 2024
That was a great show!!