@@AnnabelNightwishbro I'm a former homeschooler and yes that stereotype does hold true sometimes but not quite as often as you think. I think it's more when the kids are isolated and not around others that they're like this. I had friends from schools and other homeschool friends, and I'd say I'm not that dorky. And if I'm a bad example, I can think of many others who aren't
@Alixir1228 so... I said "most homeschoolers would agree with me", which judging by your commentary, I could bet you're a part of the minority that don't in fact agree. That's okay. You're within you're right to do so. That's what's great about freedom of speech; we don't have to agree with one another. You're not speaking for a majority, or even a great number of people, you are speaking for yourself, on behalf of of yourself, and I'm happy you feel brave enough to do that, but it's not gonna change anything. I said what I said and stand by it. There's a lot of kids who came out alright as a result of being educated at home, but there is a substantial few who are mimicking only what they've seen on TV because they've had literally no contact with the outside world other than strict supervision from the parents. It's tragic, but it'll become normalized with the wave of newcomer homeschool parents that are coming down the pipeline. The next couple decades will be interesting. And btw, if a comment on the internet is sincerely distressing for you, I'd say it's probably best that you take it as a sign that you're probably done with the internet for the safety and well-being of your feelings. Or, you can say something equally upsetting back to me if it makes you feel better, as a treat.
@@Carebearritual RUclips has deleted my comment explaining myself even if I didn’t share a link. I was NOT talking about the other and older Mary Roach. Mary Roach who “auditioned” was indeed an aspiring actress/comedian in the past. She was interviewed on the blog Idle Idols but the website is no longer online. People can find it on the internet database. Also check the full audition right before she leaves she sings another song and is trying hard not to laugh. There’s your other proof. Also I just found the pictures of Mark McGrath and her on Extra on Getty Images. I just wish I could find a clip of that moment.
fr, i wanna live in the universe where she has a proper mentor😂 I loved her energy, and like you said her voice wasn't even bad, she was just making some odd choices
I remember kids talking about how they found out she was actually part of a comedy group, and this was for a bit or something. Idk if it’s true, but I remember hearing that. I suspect that they stopped airing the auditions for that exact reason - to stop people from coming in as a joke
She was trying to kick start her comedic career by going on the show and she thought she'd be received like William Hung but instead she got mocked and bullied into disappearing. She can also sing. And the show definitely didn't care if people were coming in being fake just like Dr Phil doesn't care lol It's like reality tv and the crazier the better which meant more people tuning in.
@@skinsey85where have you seen that she can actually sing? Def not from her audition and I haven’t seen anything when I try to look her up online. She’s so bad in her audition that I’d love to see her actually sing if this was a comedy thing
My brother and I memorized this as kids. We would watch the VHS recording of it until we could do it perfectly and perform it for our parents. This unlocked quite the core memory for me.
@@KaylaMarieQ people still regularly taped stuff they saw on TV in the 2000s. RUclips wasn’t a thing until 2005 and I remember my family taping things as late as 2007. Even then, it depends on the technology they had in their home.
@@tvtvtfan3767that reply is played out. You sound like a doofus. And no she doesn’t. Why do incels always take every little opportunity to try shame women for looking old? Why don’t you lose some weight, judging from your fat basement throne. Get a life.
She’s honestly not as terrible as she’s made out to be. I truly believe with just a handful of formal vocal lessons she really could reach that 8/10 she thinks she’s at
I used to crash auditions like this and put on personas just to make the auditioners squirm. My favorite was a lyrical dance to “My heart Will Go On” I should start doing that again, it was so fucking funny
For anyone curious, she went on to get her cosmetology license and works as a hairdresser. Unfortunately, she never changed her last name to "Gilbeaux". Yet.
i can’t stop watching this honestly you perfectly captured every single moment of this interview that i replayed over and over but damn and those dimples
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
Shes oblivious while also completely self aware. Fascinating
She's a comedian. How self aware do you have to be before you stop judging other people based on Internet clips? 😉
I give her an ate/10
this comment ate
I see what you did there ❤️ 😅
"He/him"
Are you sure?
I know that’s right!!!
Where is the rnb though lol
Core memory unlocked
oh my gosh i totally forgot about her lmao
Aww me too ❤
Right I had no idea who she was until I heard the singing start and I was like ohhh I remember this one 😂
Same haha. And she got really mean!
fr
Honestly she was just ahead of her time
I agree. If she auditioned today she'd get through. Very unique voice that simply needs some direction. Hope she didn't give up after this ❤
Honey no 😂😂😂 hell no
To be honest she just sounds like Grimes
Reminds me a bit of kimbra @@ewe392
i feel the same way
"I hate gay Halloween. What do you mean you're Mary Roach from season four of American idol?" 😂
LMAOOO
You’re just jealous napoleon.
@@earichard68it’s a meme lol
@ it’s a joke lol
She gave off homeschooler energy like no one else. Bless her for coming out for our enjoyment.
@Alixir1228 as a former homeschooler, you don't know what you're talking about and thank you.
@Alixir1228 hell, a majority would agree with the stereotypes.
@@AnnabelNightwishbro I'm a former homeschooler and yes that stereotype does hold true sometimes but not quite as often as you think. I think it's more when the kids are isolated and not around others that they're like this. I had friends from schools and other homeschool friends, and I'd say I'm not that dorky. And if I'm a bad example, I can think of many others who aren't
You gave off that douchebag energy like no one else in these comments. Bless you and yo mama. 🙏🏼 😃
@Alixir1228 so... I said "most homeschoolers would agree with me", which judging by your commentary, I could bet you're a part of the minority that don't in fact agree. That's okay. You're within you're right to do so. That's what's great about freedom of speech; we don't have to agree with one another. You're not speaking for a majority, or even a great number of people, you are speaking for yourself, on behalf of of yourself, and I'm happy you feel brave enough to do that, but it's not gonna change anything. I said what I said and stand by it. There's a lot of kids who came out alright as a result of being educated at home, but there is a substantial few who are mimicking only what they've seen on TV because they've had literally no contact with the outside world other than strict supervision from the parents. It's tragic, but it'll become normalized with the wave of newcomer homeschool parents that are coming down the pipeline. The next couple decades will be interesting.
And btw, if a comment on the internet is sincerely distressing for you, I'd say it's probably best that you take it as a sign that you're probably done with the internet for the safety and well-being of your feelings. Or, you can say something equally upsetting back to me if it makes you feel better, as a treat.
She looks like she’s trolling for laughs. I like it
she indeed was a comedian, it was wonderful
Wow, how'd you spot that? If not for the comments, I'd have never known.
That may be my autism, too.
You can tell she actually has a good voice… 😂
@@xamyx725 Yeah 😂
I want more of Mary Roach !!!
Guilbeaux*
XD
She passed away.
@@spookyhousesnooo 😢
@@Suziesweetworld This is unconfirmed.
Her book, "BONK" was incredible. Highly recommended.
This is the mandatory comment to remind everyone that Mary was an aspiring comedian/actress and deserved a lot more love haahahaha. Great job JJ!
wait really? is there a guide for who faked their bad audition somewhere?
not the same mary roach….
research literacy is at an all time low idk why i’m surprised
oh my god then this is brilliant
@@Carebearritual RUclips has deleted my comment explaining myself even if I didn’t share a link. I was NOT talking about the other and older Mary Roach. Mary Roach who “auditioned” was indeed an aspiring actress/comedian in the past. She was interviewed on the blog Idle Idols but the website is no longer online. People can find it on the internet database. Also check the full audition right before she leaves she sings another song and is trying hard not to laugh. There’s your other proof.
Also I just found the pictures of Mark McGrath and her on Extra on Getty Images. I just wish I could find a clip of that moment.
Tbh, her voice is actually pretty. She’s just a weird person with a weird pronunciation. And that random nasal thing she would do.
similar to bjork style or something cant pin point
fr, i wanna live in the universe where she has a proper mentor😂 I loved her energy, and like you said her voice wasn't even bad, she was just making some odd choices
Yeah, sounds like an underdeveloped Lana Del Rey and Florence and the Machine. Someone could have coached her and turned her into a modern hit
She sucks
@@fionayarr9243100%
She's the living embodiment of the last strawberry in the "oh look a strawberry" meme
That's hilarious! 😂😂
😂😂😂
This comment should be at the top 🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣💀💀💀
“How do I think I did? ATE 💅😌”
You just brought back so many memories 😭😭😭
I remember kids talking about how they found out she was actually part of a comedy group, and this was for a bit or something. Idk if it’s true, but I remember hearing that. I suspect that they stopped airing the auditions for that exact reason - to stop people from coming in as a joke
She was trying to kick start her comedic career by going on the show and she thought she'd be received like William Hung but instead she got mocked and bullied into disappearing. She can also sing. And the show definitely didn't care if people were coming in being fake just like Dr Phil doesn't care lol It's like reality tv and the crazier the better which meant more people tuning in.
But amature comedians doing bad audition bits is the best part of American idol
@@skinsey85where have you seen that she can actually sing? Def not from her audition and I haven’t seen anything when I try to look her up online. She’s so bad in her audition that I’d love to see her actually sing if this was a comedy thing
@@melodymay4888 you can tell she can actually sing from the way she does. It sounds bad but not in the same way as someone who is tone deaf
You know honestly that makes me feel a lot better because if that's true she did an amazing job.
We should all strive to emulate her 100% confidence.
“I feel the earth move” honestly that part sounded good. No comment on everything else.
I actually love her and think her voice is good
You forgot the “Not too shabby 😏” when Simon asks “How do you think you did?” 😂❤
The way she says the word “quality” scratches my brain in a way no asmr session ever has 😂
YES WHAT IS THAT?? I don’t even like ASMR
My brother and I memorized this as kids. We would watch the VHS recording of it until we could do it perfectly and perform it for our parents. This unlocked quite the core memory for me.
VHS recording in the 2000s is wild 😂 why didnt you just watch it online?
@@KaylaMarieQ is this a serious question? lol
@@lucas-xu3wu yeah do you have a serious answer?
@@KaylaMarieQ people still regularly taped stuff they saw on TV in the 2000s. RUclips wasn’t a thing until 2005 and I remember my family taping things as late as 2007. Even then, it depends on the technology they had in their home.
@ yeah i didnt know anyone who was still doing that. We would just watch clips online or record using a dvr
I love her speaking voice she sounds like an old movie star!! I could listen to her talk all day
I was literally just watching her audition again for like the 100th time the other day!
this will live in my mind rent free forever
SHE ATE. i love her brand of comedy
That audition is such a classic!!! She gives off so many vibes.. fun and innocent, yet psycho in a split second.
she’s an icon, she’s a legend, and she is the moment. now cmon now ✨✨
Please do more of these
Yes! There are so many X factor auditions that live in my head rent free and I’d love to see them be brought to life!
SHE WAS ONLY 18?!
She looks 35
This comment and reply are, word for word, what I said aloud to myself watching this video.
@@tvtvtfan3767that reply is played out. You sound like a doofus. And no she doesn’t. Why do incels always take every little opportunity to try shame women for looking old? Why don’t you lose some weight, judging from your fat basement throne. Get a life.
Finally, someone mentioned it lol 😂, thought she was in her late 20s.
She’s honestly not as terrible as she’s made out to be. I truly believe with just a handful of formal vocal lessons she really could reach that 8/10 she thinks she’s at
Plus I bet people are always nervous too, but I agree that some lessons and experience would help
I love her sm
I want to see more Mary Roach Gilbaux!!!
" I feel the eArTh _MOOooovee_ " 😂😂
I remember watching this audition with my family and laughing until our tummies were aching. This is when American idol was good 😂
the full video of the actual audition is crazy!!!! simon is like: How do you think you did? and she's like: not to shabby
The way I REMEMBER HER & that purse 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
2024, she sounds like a star
Can’t cope when you do these videos. Hysterical
I love her 😭😭😭
You're doing amazing sweetie 🥲🫶
OMG BEST COSTUME OF THE YEAR!!!❤❤❤❤❤❤
This is one of my all time favourite contestants!!! Love this!!
We need her now more than ever
I love her, she seems from the twinpeaks world.
So much yesss. She's so Twin Peaks. Or Eightball (Daniel Clowes) 😂
I used to crash auditions like this and put on personas just to make the auditioners squirm. My favorite was a lyrical dance to “My heart Will Go On”
I should start doing that again, it was so fucking funny
This is my favorite audition. Thank you for bringing it back. Amazing. 😂
This is amazing. Because even though you’re lip syncing, I can still see the lisp.
One of my favorite Idol auditions.
She is the real life superstar(Mary Katherine Gallagher)
She’s a light. God bless her.
I wish I could have some of her confidence😂
I never thought I’d see a remake of this. I’m crying laughing 🤣 ROFL. Made my day lol
For anyone curious, she went on to get her cosmetology license and works as a hairdresser. Unfortunately, she never changed her last name to "Gilbeaux". Yet.
8/10 bc She ate!!! I love her 😂❤
This is a deep deep cut, apparently she was an actress/comedian (probably theatre kid) who was trying to mess with the system ahahaha
Who else had to watch this over and over?? Omg im dying! 😂😂😂
I still think about Mary Guilbeaux from time to time, I wonder how she's doing now in her 40s
She was awesome.... UNIQUE AS HELL.... SHE NEEDS TO DO MOVIE😂
who is this DIVA 💜
Not the shot from the back 😂
They should make an X factor musical.
Omg. Significant parts of middle school were spent watching videos like this. 😂
I hope she doesn't give up!
Omg this is EVERYTHING! LOVED IT! HAHAHAHA Gotta love Mary Gilbeaux lol
"8?" She did indeed!!
If she auditioned today, she’ll make it through. A lot of singers wants to sound like her nowadays lol
I wonder where she’s at now. Truly an icon
She was an actress and was trolling all of us! She's brilliant!
OMG. That’s American Idol Audition Gold 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
i can’t stop watching this honestly you perfectly captured every single moment of this interview that i replayed over and over but damn and those dimples
This video will live on in my mind forever!😭
Please do more iconic American idol auditions
Omg the lashes 😂😂 You look fine as hell
IM SO GLAD YOU DID THIS 😩🤣🤣🤣
She is also an acclaimed non-fiction author! Love her books!
Not the same woman.
This is incredible. Art. Be proud. 👏
Day 7 of asking you to do the Rasputin dance at your next curtain call
He should
MORE OF THESE PLEASE
I thought that was Tom Scott for a split second 💀
She sounds awesome
Her audition is my favorite of the entire series. She gave her all.❤
Fav audition from that show. Thanks for recreating it!!😂
omg JJ you're iconic
This impression is spot on, I'm so happy you did this, she was glorious😂
Well… certainly unique vocal style
she’s insane, i love her
Omg I'm singing this song for my chorus class 😭 😂😂
Omfg you absolutely nailed this!! Loving all the angles 😂
This makes the video even more funny.
She’s hilarious😂 the simon cowel part😭
Yes! I remember this audition! 😂
I NEVER KNEW I NEEDED THIS!!!! thank you ~
She walked so Jojo Siwa could run. Just realized I don’t know how to spell Jojos name 😂
I remember this audition. Wow you mimic her mannerisms so well ! 👏
Very funny, you killed it
This kind of confidence is a gift
For whatever reason you look like Rose McGowan in the face. You should totally do her next!
bro are you blind, he looks nothing like her
All I watched was the auditions lol
Could’ve gone without this
🤮🤮🤮
So glad our girl mary is getting the recognition she deserves
She was 18?!? She looks like 32!
I love and miss her! ❤