DM542 vs TB6600 and NEMA 23 stepper Motor torque test Hanpose vs Pu Fei De on Arduino Uno
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 фев 2022
- Testing the 2 most popular Stepper Motor and Driver available online for my 6040 CNC built.
1. Bottle weight 500g
2. Metal add another 50g
3. Distance is 180cm
Torque is ard 1N.M
Link to test set up
• Nema 23 stepper motor ...
Link to the Made in China equivalent DM542 and stepper motors and drivers consistency
• Testing Made in China ...
Link to Arduino Grbl CNC6040 set up with DM542 and Nema23 stepper motors
• Arduino Grbl CNC6040 s...
Can the ENA and DIR inputs be supplied by more than 5V? Will it work with 12V?
You are testing holding power. Dip switch 4 controls the amount of current flowing to the stepper when it is in the hold position. You have dip switch 4 set to low, you need to set it to high (on) which will double the holding amps. I would not increase the amperage to the motor past manufacturers specifications. It will increase the temperature of the motor, especially in the hold position. Steppers can take a lot of heat, but I never let them run any faster than warm to the touch max. Running them hotter may cause missed steps when rotating.
The motor is not making an exact full rotation? is that the issue?
Shall I get the arduino code for torque control ??
great video can u tell which one is better DM542 vs ykd2305m
I didn't use ykd2305m, so I won't know
❤❤❤ helpful
What's the torque values??
You measure torque without sharing torque values??
The SW4 is off on the DM542, which means the holding current is only half the settings (2.84/2 A). I think that's the reason why the holding torque is not as good as TB6600.
Get a DM542T (4.0) great drivers.
Have you considered that your wiring may be wrong ? The DM542 Dir+ and Pul+ should be getting 5v. There is a pin on the Uno for this.
5v volt pin at the UNO can not be controlled like the digital pin.
The stepper motor potentially draws 6,0A as this is 3,0A _per phase_ and not the entire motor.
Hai admin...are you sell the driver..?
Do you think that the 3.3 amp setting would still work for a 3 amp motor?
It should. Just that the motor will run hotter anf shotter life span. Just like putting a turbo to a naturally espirated engine
@@milo178 but some M542 driver say RMS 3 amp and peak 4.2 amps. So whats the current written on the motor? rms or peak?
@@dopetechlab9619 I think they are normally rms.
@@milo178 ok, i think i'll just run it for a while at 3.31 amps and measure the temp. Thanks for your help!
WHen using the DM542 each time on the last rotation the motor made a grave noise while on the first 3 rotations it was very quiet. Why is that so ?
I was trying to find it's limit by increasing it's rpm each turn. The last rotation has the highest rpm
@@milo178 Thankyou fir your reply M178. For my University Project I am working on a hardness testing machine which involves a stepper motor and these days I am searching for stepper motors that's how I came across your video. Can you kindly share your email or any other contact detail where I can take guidance from you to select a particular stepper ?
What's the name of the part that sits on the motor shaft?
Thanks for the video!
Linear rail / rod bracket
@@milo178 Thank you!
What USB device did you use to drive the motor?
Used power bank
@@milo178 Do you have a link to a Power bank that you plugged in?
What device did you used to rotate the motor?
@@milo178 You are using a code from what program to your AUdrino Board?
@@harryking5636 you can see my part 1 video. It's just an arduino code
So when can we expect an album?
Album not so soon. Got stuck for a while as the Spindle wasn't working and was trying to figure out the cause. It's now working again and the next video will be on this fault finding
@@milo178 nice! That beat was fire 🎶
is the metal rail really 1.8 meters? it doesn't look like it
Yah, u r right. its 180mm. But the torque is still correct though.
good how can run this with forward and reverse with switch
There should switches available to switch the direction available at the stepper driver
@@milo178 boss need code and circuit please help me
Conveyor belt L= 120× W=40 Cm
Pulley D= 6Cm
Object weight on conveyor belt is 3 kg
Conveyor belt can run with this stepper motor plz ans me 🙏🙏🙏
I dont know the answer to this question. Sorry man
I don't think your test was definitive. In what way is the DM542 better than the TB6600? The two things that I take away from your video is that (1) the DM542 is quieter and (2) the TB6600 delivers more torque.
It's quiter and smoother
@@milo178 thanks for clarifying. I, too, would prefer a smoother, quieter solution (though those might sometimes be secondary requirements). What is your application?
@@shaunonverwacht9626 ruclips.net/video/xr9kQavV8gI/видео.html
@BuildGUY torque difference only slightly due to amp settings availability. I don't need so much torque, so smoother is better for me
Lol, torque test but all he says is, here’s a bottle of water? How much does the bottle of water weigh?
My apologies, its a torque test for 2 separate stepper drivers and motors to see which is better.
@@milo178 what was the weight of the water bottle?
@@justtestingonce 500grams
@@milo178 thanks, can u put that in the description for others. Also, that seems very low for Nema 23 at 280oz inch, the holding torque should be 2 N.m
@@justtestingonce the length about 180cm. The metal another 50g. So it's about 1N.M at the setting.
This si bad test
This is a stupid and useless test