Sabaton, a band that deserves FAR more recognition for their faithful coverage of history in their songs and especially for their dedication to the idea that war is hell for all who fight in them.
@@thebritishempire8754 they got dragged in by allies too but land was defiantly a big factor, the first war was just something they got dragged in too then became the biggest factor in and got blamed for.
I love the ending though in which the enemy just got up on his knees, and the men in the trenches does not shoot. Then the enemy nods his head as a way of showing his graciousness and thankfulness for not shooting him while the boy miraculously survived. And then the sky clears indicating the light at the other end of the tunnel. Some sign of humanity in the darkest hours.
"We push. They push. Every once in a while, we push hard enough that the light breaks through the clouds. So the world beyond the war glimmers, just out of reach."
There's a book called "Bloody Red Tabs" that gives the details of all British senior officers killed or wounded in WW1. It's quite the tome. What you also have to remember is that right up until at least the first world war, quite a lot of those Generals (especially the British) had seen hand to hand combat in colonial wars as junior officers - and many WW2 generals had been frontline combat officers in WW1.
A soldier lies in a wasteland of mud. A another soldier crawls through the mud to him and says "Where's the frontline mate? The soldier replied "You're in it mate." From the film Passchendaele.
This reminds me one war joke about III Battle of Ypres (Battle of Passchendaele): There's a soldier travelling around the no man's land. Then, suddenly, he falls neck deep into mud. He finds another soldier in the same situation, and asks him: ,,Where is the trench?" ,,You're standing in it"
Давным-давно, в ранней юности, испытал схожие эмоции от прочтения Ремарка "На западном фронте без перемен". И сейчас, просматривая клип и слушая песню отхватываю неслабых таких флешбэков. Респект Сабатону. Великая песня. Всем мир!
Пока не истребишь (буквально!) всех разжигателей и выгодоприобретателей войн - мира не будет! всегда будут войны и истребление людей - людьми, ради выгоды, власти, холопов и дальнейших войн...
@@Колян-м4у agreed, i wouldnt want to stand shoulder to shoulder with this knew generation of 🌈 warriors, ill stick to the middle aged watching my back thanks, not some feckless, gutless little millenial turds..
My great-great grandfather fought at this battle. He lost his hearing, 3 of his best friends and his brother. He was never the same. He was only 17. Rest in Peace Private Aquila Barber
The kid in the middle of the battle that's completely shocked brings a tear to my eye. He looks like my little brother. To think that kids that age would see the worst face of humankind is truly horrific.
Welcom to WW2 i know this reply is harsh but that is just a fact and i cant imagine to see the bravery of everyone of these kids to just have the courage to kill a person if necessary or if you have eye contact with the enemy i can tell storys of my great grandpa who saw it all.
WW1 was just so savage and apocalyptic. Trenches, mud, tremendous artillery barrages, melee combat since bolt actions were too slow for close combat, chemical weapons... This song is based on the Battle of Passchendaele. You can look up real photos of the battlefield in 1917. It's the closest thing to hell on Earth.
The man who wrote The Hobbit fought at the Somme and he described it as the guns, artillery and screaming all being so loud it all became one loud tinnitus sound. You couldn't hear anything, just see the destruction.
Madness. As a former Australian mechanised infantry officer (2/14 Light Horse) I think that video is a brutally realistic portrayal of what war looked like in that era. The senior officers who thought that was a way to fight a war were criminally insane, in my opinion. Haig was by far the worst of the madmen. All war is madness. The Great War was one of the worst.
Another sad thing is the fact the Germans actually cared for the men in trenches keeping the trenches clean as dirt can be and even having men have food and not in water so they can catch teen foot yet they lost
@@ziz9087 what a load of horse manure. The Germans didn't give a shit, seeing as how they didn't rotate soldiers away from the front for rest like the French did. In the German army you stayed in the trenches until you died or the war was over. The French had monthly rotations every other month.
Can’t Imagine my great grandfather went through this multiple times in his life. Stationed in Verdun in the first and went into Russia with the Windhund Division in the Second World War. No matter on which side you fought, wars are dreadful for everyone, and the ones who survive have to live in horror for the rest of their lives. That’s the ultimate sacrifice and we can’t forget them.
@@mamavswild he was lucky that his division split, because the other half went to Stalingrad. He went on to the Black Sea where his commanding officer surrendered, eventually being in a Soviet and later British POW camp. He died peacefully at age 102. I can’t imagine the misery and horror all the soldiers that fought in these wars had to go through. His company had to survive on rats and their horses. Let’s appreciate this period of peace and let’s hope it lasts.
@@prussianangler Oh my gosh that’s...just amazing. I’m so glad he was able to help build a better life for himself after the war. I’m an Army Officer (US) and we read and research books on theory, warfare, tactics and strategic decision making all the time as part of our professional development...one of the books that is required reading for US Army Officers (according to army.mil and the war college) is ‘The Forgotten Soldier’ by Guy Sajer, a soldier who fought in the Grossdeutschland Division. I wrote a thesis following the read and basically it said that I learned... ....I learned that I would rather SAW OFF MY OWN HEAD than be a Soldat on the Ostfront. Fuuuuuuk that! I have tremendous respect for your grandfather being able to make it through such a difficult time. What most people fail to realize is, the young men who fought and struggled to survive/die in the Wehrmacht were just aged 7-13 when Bad Mustache Man came to power (it was the saintly WWI generation who voted he and his party in! Of course, it was more complicated than that and many lived to regret that decision and besides he never had more than 34% of the vote but hey that’s another discussion)...they were as innocent as anyone else. What they got for their innocence was a militarized boyscout program, indoctrination and more indoctrination. Then a brutal 6 years only half survived, then a lifetime of being told that they were pieces of shit. I’m humble enough to know that had I been born with the same accident of time and geography, my ass would’ve been out on the ostfront too.
@@mamavswild yes it must’ve been really bad. I really like it that you got to read literature about the other side. Every soldier suffered tremendously, no matter what side. Many German soldiers were also drafted, such as my great grandfather in WW2. We should all respect the men and women that put their life and sanity on the line to fight for their country. That’s why I admire the American tradition of honoring your servicemen and women and your veterans as heroes, which they are. Here in Germany people have no respect for our soldiers and even talk bad about them for our involvement in Mali and co, which is still for a good cause. To the point of Hitler getting voted, that is absolutely true. The people that voted him were also super desperate, because the Great Depression and the Versailles treaty were really hard for the German people. I am absolutely disgusted by what we’ve done in WW2, but people have to understand the whole story before judging and blaming returning soldiers.
This song has to be the most depressing Sabaton song to date. The way the story is told, the sounds of everything, just everything about this song buries itself deep in your heart.
Wow. Sabaton has a very special and unique gift with telling history through music and it often gives me chills and brings a tear to my eye. This video and song complement each other very well. Nice job.
Maximum respect to my German great-great grandfather Ernest Zimmermann, of Bavarian Regiment 14, 5th Bavarian Division, who fought in the Battle of the Somme.
"Whoever said war is hell is wrong. Hell is where sinners are punished, war is where innocents are murdered in the most brutal ways imaginable. Those in Hell chose to sin. Those in war are thrown into a fire that destroys anything that comes out of it". -Me.
From the first season of M*A*S*H: "Hawkeye: War isn't Hell. War is war, and Hell is Hell. And of the two, war is a lot worse. Father Mulcahy: How do you figure, Hawkeye? Hawkeye: Easy, Father. Tell me, who goes to Hell? Father Mulcahy: Sinners, I believe. Hawkeye: Exactly. There are no innocent bystanders in Hell. War is chock full of them - little kids, cripples, old ladies. In fact, except for some of the brass, almost everybody involved is an innocent bystander."
@@sjalkzjziskzkzo смотри: миля грубо говоря 1,5 км. Всего 6 миль. Всего (6×1,5)=9 км. Теперь 9÷600000=100500 жизней (все расчёты примерные). То есть примерно цена 1 км это 100500 жизней... Понятно что считать цену км или миль жизнями юношей и мужчин, дедов это глупо и ненормально, но командование тех времён считало это обычным ежедневным делом, сам знаешь...
Thank you for mentioning the rarely mentioned Canadian Corps, who get rare attention yet contributed so much in these times of sheer brutality. RIP the Newfoundland Regiment... May your lives never be forgotten..
Same could be said for the South Africans fighting in both world wars and the Korean war only to have our war hero's now be "Britsh war hero's only born and lived in South Africa and fought in our army, air force"
@@Gidi66 That is so VERY true. It is truly sad that those soldiers are not recognized as SOUTH AFRICANS... South Africa is a strong, independent and self sustaining nation with it's own identity. It is a very unique and beautiful place. Like everywhere, it is not without it's troubles though. Respect to your ancestors who fought for their brothers in arms in an unjust conflict that should never have happened and which they should never have been involved. Brave people all.
@@Gidi66 Damn.... That is brutal.. A lot of the unrest in modern day Africa is due to European meddling in the area in the first place.. Such a beautiful continent yet a few greedy individuals ruin it for the sake of their own greed. And that part about going from concentration camps to 'friendly' lines in one of the most brutal battles of history is just... I simply don't have words for that. May God bless their souls. Canadians fought voluntarily and with enthusiasm. These people had no choice yet still fought like lions. I am going to have to do some proper research on this subject now as it is a very important piece of world history.. I have always had a fascination with the continent of Africa, yet it has so much history that it is impossible to learn all of it. You just fed me an excellent bit to study up on. Thank you for your contribution here.
@@_M_a_r_t_i_n_M some Boers didn't like fighting for the British the people who had conquerd us in war and let 27 thousand women and children starve in the camps and some 30 thousand native allies of the Boers, and they where mostly if German descent so they rebelled, it's was the reason why South African soldiers didn't sent troops abroad in the first month or 2. An old general went to the military academy where a lot of new recruits where gathered for their final ceremony and gave a speech and the young men joined him to actively try and join the Germans hell they even got a German colonial officer to come from a German colony to inspect our boys, however the main reason it failed was because of the general in charge wasn't the original pick for it the original one was accidentally shot dead by police when his driver didn't stop at a police checkpoint set up to try and catch a few bank robbers the stand in for the original pick didn't have the knowledge and experience to lead such a large army and after a few talks gave up and handed over the soldiers under him only one guy was hanged and it was some random guy who had joined them after running away from the place he was working as a guard. This rebellion was the reason we didn't consript our boys for the ww2. Most of the Boers where of German/Dutch decent with the otherside being britsh and the smallest group being French so they feared another rebellion and only sent volunteers
Mad respect to the men of the Canadian Corps. Did what no one else could and took the ridge, at the cost of many lives unfortunately. A shoutout to the British, ANZAC, and other commonwealth forces and allies who also gave their blood to the cause, may they rest in peace.
Max respect to ALL of the young men, no matter which side they were on. There was no ‘Right Side’ in WWI. The British only cared about ensuring there was no competition for their empire and sacrificed their child nations to achieve their goals (often throwing Canadians into the worst of the front or tossing ANZAC soldiers into irresponsible, near certain death at Gallipoli) The Germans thought they were defending a friend. There was no right or wrong.
Pulls no punches with its verisimilitude in showing the futility of war. The poetic narration, music & visual depiction of hell that must have been Passchendaele.
A long time ago, in my early youth, I experienced similar emotions from reading the Erich Maria Remarque " All quiet on the Western front". And now I have strong flashbacks from the video and the song. Great book. Great song. Respect for Sabaton from Russia.
@@shaydowsith348 what a superficial and utterly useless take! since you have such good ideas, why not propose a way to accomplish these goals? one that's feasible and doesn't involve endangering civilians
This song displays the waste of the lives in fruitless charges against enemy fortifications. "What's the price of a mile?" Turns about, about 2,000 men. The rest of their songs bring light to tragedies, heroes, and other points, and people, of history. They bring the past to life, and ensure those who gave so much, who sacrificed more than any other, will never be forgotten.
@@FokkeWulfe they want us to learn from history because that's the way it never happens again (well it still happens but we don't think war is something to want)
Сейчас такие же бои под Бахмутом и на Запорожском направлении. Вечная слава простым солдатам обработанным капиталистической пропагандой и погибшим за интересы капиталистов. Мир - хижинам, война - дворцам!
Great video again. Thank God for being born 60 years later and not joining this senseless war and shooting people I would not have known. Best regards from Germany.
Respect to all that fought in WW1 and died, but even more respect to the ones who survived and fought in WW2. I can’t even imagine how horrible that had to be. The men who actively fought in combat during both wars and ended up surviving them are true legends, no matter what side they were on.
I'd like to think that the men who fought and died would feel honored to be memorialized in such a spectacular song. Sabaton is so amazing when it comes to telling stories through song and getting people interested in learning more about history.
it's always politics, the propaganda comes through the news, people believe everything and then there is war.in this order, industry the politicians the media ! the People die for fantasies. it's always like this.
In this war's case it was Europe building tension and alliances and the someone shot someone very important to one group and the smaller party's bro's came to back Serbia up and it turned into a meat grinder thanks to modern weapons and tactics from a hundred years ago
Thank you for all your texts in honor of all these men who died for peace. Thank you it resonates being a military nurse, many soldiers too young, are still dead or crippled for strictly geopolitical reasons
Great footage. My great-grandfather was at Ypres. He was part of several operation in which he engaged the enemy in close quaters combat, among which was a bayonet charge in which he stabbed several Canadians. When I was very young, he would reminisce fondly, about those Canadians panicking, even though my great-grandfather and his mates were with just about 15 dudes against a whole trench, a company, whatever. They killed a lot of them! Remember and respect the veterans!
Une pensée à tout ces Soldats mort pour sa partie. A tout ces courageux âgé entre 15 et 65 ans. Une pensée au familles des victimes Triste de perdre 1, 2 voir 3 proche. Mais cette guerre nous a tous aussi appris des chose... malheureusement, nous les Hommes, tous autant que nous sommes, nous sommes capables à faire de grande chose, bien ou mal. Reposés en paix brave soldat. 🕊️🕊️🕊️
Nouvelle chaîne d'histoire. La vie d'Hitler et autre (rien à voir avec les documentaires et ce que l'on nous dit pas ) ruclips.net/video/mYBsm9m3pQk/видео.html La première guerre vue du côté allemand.
Сколько погибает людей в бессмысленных войнах и ради чего - ради прихоти правителей и их игры кто сильней они сами не идут воевать и живут в своих замках - так может пора задуматься людям простым что нам на этой земле нечего делить - ведь жизнь человека и так коротка и надо ее ценить -- а ребята хорошо поют есть над чем задуматься
велика дяка всім нашим партнерам! зараз як і тоді, нам також допомагають боротись против коричневої чуми ! велика вдячність сша, британцям і всім європейцям!
Through action,a man becomes a hero. Through death,a hero becomes a legend. Through time,a legend becomes a Myth. And by learning from the Myth,a man takes action. "It only takes 1 epic and uplifting music to turn the comments section to a poetry treasure hole" "They say light is the fastest thing in the universe, but darkness is already there before light comes" "Honor died on the beach, the Khan deserves to suffer" - Jin Sakai
Read in a ww1 history book once, A soldier was taking a break in the medical whatever you call it, He saw a soldier on a bed trying to lite a match for his pipe, but couldn't get it, So the guy helped him, then he noticed that the soldier on the bed's jaw had been blown away, So the guy lit the pipe so the wounded fellow could at least smell it, Yeah had to take a long walk after reading that,
I read about a French dude who’s army had just captured a fortress by shelling it to rubble. When he got into the fortress he found a mangled pile of goo and gore that was still moaning in agony. The guy’s face was blown off, legs were missing, one of his hands was gone, his guts were splattered all around him and he was still alive. I was like 12 when I read this book and it really freaked me out.
@@obi-wankenobi1750 People commit suicide by cutting their wrists and yet you believe someone just lives on and on with a hand blown off? And their legs?
@Furioclasse people have jumped on grenades and survived. People have fallen 10,000 feet out of an airplane and lived. Phineas Gage survived a meter long railroad spike being blown through the bottom of his jaw and out the top of his head. Yes, people can survive, for a small amount of time, losing hands and legs.
The worst part of WW1 is that all those men died literally for no reason at all while their generals cluelessly threw more and more bodies in the meatgrinder.
My great great grandpa went through WW1, Spanish Civil War(as a republican volunteeer) and WW2 and met the end of the war in Berlin... This will most probably get lost in the comments, but i just want you all to know how much of a fucking gigachad my great great grandpa was... This is our family's song of 9th of May, we always pour one for our family's greatest hero and I end up drinking it in silence. Rest in peace great great grandpa Andrew and great grandpa Ivan(died in Stalingrad in 1942)
Fighting in mud sucks and this is a common issue for every soldier in modern day warfare. At least simple bolt actions are easier to deal with compared to a modern semi-auto when that happens.
The thing I can never get over, no matter how much emotion and effort we put into Cinematic and Musical Recreations of such events we are still basically looking at a Single BRICK out of a SKYSCRAPER. We cant even Scratch the SURFACE of the REALITY of what it was like for our Grandparents and Great Grandparents. O.o
It is in my blood, ace fighters. My second name is Georg, which comes from my Grand Grand Uncle who was a fighter for the Kaiser. Praise to you. Also for my banat bulgarian in the family, who died in a airplane crash in Hungary for the Austro-Hungarian Empire. He was also a fighter
A truly brutal video, a video that NEEDS to be made and shown to remind all, that war is horror, but against evil it is often the only tool to defeat that evil.
The only thing wrong with this is the tiresome depiction of the Germans as combat incapable. Very typical of Anglo-American narrations of the world wars. In fact at Passchendaele they inflicted more casualties on the British Empire than they received. Everything else is grimly realistic, underpinned by Sabaton's haunting indictment of the futility of war.
Perhaps because the Germans were defending in this campaign. Altough yes I´d agree it´s generally speaking too many movies where Germans are portraied poorly.
@@RAEJDER 2cnd world wars later stagees the germans were working with fresh new recruits and yeet the amount of shit the alliess had to go through was impessrive still si in that case young mane were manning the walls at omha its just the way things are portryayed ww1 gemrany were um.................................................... BRUTAL!
It doesn't matter how many casualties you inflict - if they are chewing through your best men while you are chewing through their ill-trained cannon fodder, the quality of your army is irreversibly being destroyed.
@@Ensign_Cthulhu not wrong but as the "most efficient" fraction in WW1 its still not realistic to portray them that foolish, also you forget that the same counts for french, British AND especially the US. Everyone threw in fresh troops wich were pretty likely to die soon.
Просто бомба!!!сам воевал!знаю всё это дерьмо!но даже у меня слушая припев мурашки бегут по коже и я снова вспоминаю тот,страх и ужас который меня поменял на всю жизнь!!!
велика дяка всім нашим партнерам! зараз як і тоді, нам також допомагають боротись против коричневої чуми ! велика вдячність сша, британцям і всім європейцям!
Eu trabalho com jovens em minha igreja a anos , nos é ensinado a ver , e alimentar o potencial de cada um deles e direcionar isso para ajudar os outros , creio que Deus ve em cada jovem um potencial imenso para fazer o bem , mais saber que tantos jovens morreram na lama , alguns nem puderam se reconhecidos ou se quer sepultados , um mar de corpos , um mar de sonhos e potencial perdido . " Poucas milhas conquistadas , meio milhao de homens perdidos" Essa frase me tirou uma lagrima dos olhos ...
Incredible book, I've read my copy of it to tatters over the years. The story of Paul Baumer and all his friends in that awful war still brings tears to my eyes no matter how many times I read it. I can't recommend it enough, they don't write em like they used to.
If this song and movie describe how brutal the western front was, I don’t want to imagine neither a movie nor a song about the Italian front. Being under a general who thinks that a 11th assault will break through the enemy’s lines would be unthinkable nowadays
Fun fact, if we do the math, we find that each FOOT of land gained cost the Allies 12 lives. Just Allies. It cost about the same for Germany. That means each foot of land gained by the Allies in the battle of Passchendaele cost about 24 lives. 24 brothers, sons, fathers, husbands, and friends died for a 12 inches. That also means that 2 people died for an inch. An INCH. In my opinion, this was the most costly battle in history.
My family lost 2 great uncles in the Great War, One at the Somme and one at Gallipoli never foget the sacrifices of the NZEF and all the others who never came home, Lost but never forgotten, Lest we forget.
Hear the sound of a machine gun Hear it echo in the night Mortals firing rains the scene Scars the fields That once were green It's a stalemate at the front line Where the soldiers rest in mud Roads and houses All is gone There is no glory to be won know that many men will suffer Know that many men will die Half a million lives at stake Ask the fields of Passchendaele And as the night falls the general calls And the battle carries on and on How long? What is the purpose of it all What's the price of a mile? Thousands of feet march to the beat It's an army on the march Long way from home Paying the price in young men's lives Thousands of feet march to the beat It's an army in despair Knee-deep in mud Stuck in the trench with no way out Thousands of machineguns Kept on firing through the night Mortars blazed and wrecked the scene Guns in the fields that once were green Still a deadlock at the front line Where the soldiers die in mud Roads and houses since long gone Still no glory has been won Know that many men has suffered Know that many men has died Six miles of ground has been won Half a million men are gone And as the men crawled the general called And the killing carried on and on How long? What's the purpose of it all? What's the price of a mile? Thousands of feet march to the beat It's an army on the march Long way from home Paying the price in young men's lives Thousands of feet march to the beat It's an army in despair Knee-deep in mud Stuck in the trench with no way out Young men are dying They pay the price Oh how they suffer So tell me what's the price of a mile That's the price of a mile. Thousands of feet march to the beat It's an army on the march Long way from home Paying the price in young men's lives Thousands of feet march to the beat It's an army in despair Knee-deep in mud Stuck in the trench with no way out
It doesn't matter how glorious American films make it seem, they can't hide the pure suffering of both sides in trench warfare. There was no heroism, only death and pain.
This is Canadian, and was Saving Private Ryan “heroic” at all? Medic mumbling for his mama after being shot, American being stabbed in the chest slowly as he begs for help from his coward friend.
There is literally no American film about world war one that tried to make it seem heroic to fight in trench warfare. You've actually just made something up to get mad at.
Sabaton, a band that deserves FAR more recognition for their faithful coverage of history in their songs and especially for their dedication to the idea that war is hell for all who fight in them.
"War is hell, but still pretty fucking badass" - Sabaton, probably
Wsh bien les gars moi je galère en histoire sur cette musique
@@rasinoArm Ca parle de la bataille de Passchendaele en 1917 et du sacrifice de millier dhommes pour environ 1km de terre
Absolutely there's a history lesson on every video
And this totally unbiased video where just the germans are being slaughtered
"It is good that war is so terrible, lest we grow fond of it." R. E. Lee.
Awesome song, made me shed a tear for the fallen of both sides.
Uhhh
@@matty9699 what don't you get?
WW1 was a useless war that caused the second one two
Its sad Germany was classified as antagonists they only wanted a bigger empire. WW2 on the other hand
@@thebritishempire8754 they got dragged in by allies too but land was defiantly a big factor, the first war was just something they got dragged in too then became the biggest factor in and got blamed for.
"In peace, sons bury their father. In war fathers bury their sons."
♥ 😢
noone burries the dead sons... they lie in mass graves after being blown to pieces...
@@jonasnaumann7763 most the time they’re recovered and brought back so idk where you get your information
@@jonasnaumann7763 They just rot in the sun, while people avoid them.
Man stop watching to many action movies
I love the ending though in which the enemy just got up on his knees, and the men in the trenches does not shoot. Then the enemy nods his head as a way of showing his graciousness and thankfulness for not shooting him while the boy miraculously survived. And then the sky clears indicating the light at the other end of the tunnel. Some sign of humanity in the darkest hours.
There are no enemies in war
@@rolandrozsavolgyi1168 The real enemy is war itself.
@@thepizzafoogle5481 That is true
"We push. They push. Every once in a while, we push hard enough that the light breaks through the clouds. So the world beyond the war glimmers, just out of reach."
@@frankdrebin3988 I haven’t heard that in a while
War never changes. Old men talk, young men die.
There's a book called "Bloody Red Tabs" that gives the details of all British senior officers killed or wounded in WW1. It's quite the tome. What you also have to remember is that right up until at least the first world war, quite a lot of those Generals (especially the British) had seen hand to hand combat in colonial wars as junior officers - and many WW2 generals had been frontline combat officers in WW1.
all men die ....only how
@@henrydarren6654 valar morghulis?
@@mikeschlau4501 honi soit quot mally pance
@@henrydarren6654 a truth for the most of all wars.
A soldier lies in a wasteland of mud. A another soldier crawls through the mud to him and says "Where's the frontline mate? The soldier replied "You're in it mate."
From the film Passchendaele.
This reminds me one war joke about III Battle of Ypres (Battle of Passchendaele):
There's a soldier travelling around the no man's land. Then, suddenly, he falls neck deep into mud. He finds another soldier in the same situation, and asks him:
,,Where is the trench?"
,,You're standing in it"
There canadian not brits
Давным-давно, в ранней юности, испытал схожие эмоции от прочтения Ремарка "На западном фронте без перемен". И сейчас, просматривая клип и слушая песню отхватываю неслабых таких флешбэков. Респект Сабатону. Великая песня. Всем мир!
Пока не истребишь (буквально!) всех разжигателей и выгодоприобретателей войн - мира не будет!
всегда будут войны и истребление людей - людьми, ради выгоды, власти, холопов и дальнейших войн...
Сегодня вышел фильм по книге. Очень сильно. Рекомендую
"Older men declare war but it is the youth that must fight and die" --- Herbert Hoover.
Thats why wars are pure bullshit
wow i have never agreed so much in my life old people are drunk jerks
This is the Early Days of ww3 and most of us are above 18
@@Random_JapGuy excuse me *W H A T*
Never seen a more stupid comment in name of anti war
that boy sitting in the mud perfectly describes the saying "Older men start wars, But it is the youth that must fight them."
Политики начинают войны, а солдаты их заканчивают.
@@Колян-м4у agreed, i wouldnt want to stand shoulder to shoulder with this knew generation of 🌈 warriors, ill stick to the middle aged watching my back thanks, not some feckless, gutless little millenial turds..
@@Колян-м4уpoliticians start the war, why should they go out to fight? They leave their roles up to the poor.
-Ozzy
@@792slayer But it was started by a gypsy who killed Archduke Franz Ferdinand
@@james_andrey a political action by political people, who themselves would never fight in the war.
The hand-to-hand combat is what scares me the worst. Using anything like rocks, shovels butts of rifles etc. Truly horrific.
Your not rong
Well its war after all. Kill or be killed
It is the most terrifying thing, but God it looks god
@@darren_khy That doesn't mean it's not terrifying
haven't you ever fought?
My great-great grandfather fought at this battle. He lost his hearing, 3 of his best friends and his brother. He was never the same. He was only 17. Rest in Peace Private Aquila Barber
Rest in peace... I salute your Great-great Grandfather. For fighting to peace and... His friends too.
Sorry for bad English
Rest in peace... I salute your Great-great Grandfather. For fighting to peace and... His friends too.
Sorry for bad English
Rest in peace and honor!
Rest in peace for that man who got thrown in this nightmare may he be honored just like all the ones who fought for the stupidity of their governement
Lest we forget
The kid in the middle of the battle that's completely shocked brings a tear to my eye. He looks like my little brother.
To think that kids that age would see the worst face of humankind is truly horrific.
I don't know what to say about that. But I wish it didn't have to be like that
The most sad part is he probably enlisted himself lying about his age
And now he's sitting there like what have I gotten myself into
@@intolerablepunk you have no idea what war is, like you said, you talk like a kid, heroism doesn’t exist, life is not a movie nor a game
@@maxencelavigne5406 Until certain ages kids do not understand concept of death.
Welcom to WW2 i know this reply is harsh but that is just a fact and i cant imagine to see the bravery of everyone of these kids to just have the courage to kill a person if necessary or if you have eye contact with the enemy i can tell storys of my great grandpa who saw it all.
Спасибо Сабатону за Пашендаль. Прослушал с десяток клипов и понял, что пик у них впереди. Дай, Боже!
WW1 was just so savage and apocalyptic. Trenches, mud, tremendous artillery barrages, melee combat since bolt actions were too slow for close combat, chemical weapons...
This song is based on the Battle of Passchendaele. You can look up real photos of the battlefield in 1917. It's the closest thing to hell on Earth.
“I died In hell, they called it Passchendaele” -Unknown German soldier
The man who wrote The Hobbit fought at the Somme and he described it as the guns, artillery and screaming all being so loud it all became one loud tinnitus sound. You couldn't hear anything, just see the destruction.
Это как сейчас в Авдеевке. При наличии внятных ПВО с обеих сторон ничего особо не летает и деремся на танках и ближний бой
@@Mere-LachaiselongueI remember there was also a movie about him named after his name too.
@@levu579 Tolkien I think
Something I love about sabaton is they take the perspective of history not a nation's.
I know it's already been said but I still wanted to say it.
SPARTA
@@swolzer fair enough
I think you're incorrect
@@abhi5504 yeah probably but I know I'm probably wrong I haven't heard every one of their songs
Madness.
As a former Australian mechanised infantry officer (2/14 Light Horse) I think that video is a brutally realistic portrayal of what war looked like in that era.
The senior officers who thought that was a way to fight a war were criminally insane, in my opinion.
Haig was by far the worst of the madmen.
All war is madness. The Great War was one of the worst.
And it’s sad it was a good defense tactic
Another sad thing is the fact the Germans actually cared for the men in trenches keeping the trenches clean as dirt can be and even having men have food and not in water so they can catch teen foot yet they lost
@@ziz9087 what a load of horse manure. The Germans didn't give a shit, seeing as how they didn't rotate soldiers away from the front for rest like the French did. In the German army you stayed in the trenches until you died or the war was over. The French had monthly rotations every other month.
@@SelfProclaimedEmperor I’m like 90% sure that the Germans couldn’t accomplish that they had to deal with a much larger front to the east
If you want a both amusing and depressing read, look up Konrad von Hötzendorf, commander of the Austria-hungarian army
Can’t Imagine my great grandfather went through this multiple times in his life. Stationed in Verdun in the first and went into Russia with the Windhund Division in the Second World War. No matter on which side you fought, wars are dreadful for everyone, and the ones who survive have to live in horror for the rest of their lives. That’s the ultimate sacrifice and we can’t forget them.
Yikes...he was born at the right (wrong?) time to be stuck in BOTH wars...did he survive? The eastern front? (Clearly he survived Verdun)
@@mamavswild he was lucky that his division split, because the other half went to Stalingrad. He went on to the Black Sea where his commanding officer surrendered, eventually being in a Soviet and later British POW camp. He died peacefully at age 102. I can’t imagine the misery and horror all the soldiers that fought in these wars had to go through. His company had to survive on rats and their horses. Let’s appreciate this period of peace and let’s hope it lasts.
@@prussianangler Oh my gosh that’s...just amazing. I’m so glad he was able to help build a better life for himself after the war.
I’m an Army Officer (US) and we read and research books on theory, warfare, tactics and strategic decision making all the time as part of our professional development...one of the books that is required reading for US Army Officers (according to army.mil and the war college) is ‘The Forgotten Soldier’ by Guy Sajer, a soldier who fought in the Grossdeutschland Division. I wrote a thesis following the read and basically it said that I learned...
....I learned that I would rather SAW OFF MY OWN HEAD than be a Soldat on the Ostfront.
Fuuuuuuk that!
I have tremendous respect for your grandfather being able to make it through such a difficult time. What most people fail to realize is, the young men who fought and struggled to survive/die in the Wehrmacht were just aged 7-13 when Bad Mustache Man came to power (it was the saintly WWI generation who voted he and his party in! Of course, it was more complicated than that and many lived to regret that decision and besides he never had more than 34% of the vote but hey that’s another discussion)...they were as innocent as anyone else. What they got for their innocence was a militarized boyscout program, indoctrination and more indoctrination. Then a brutal 6 years only half survived, then a lifetime of being told that they were pieces of shit. I’m humble enough to know that had I been born with the same accident of time and geography, my ass would’ve been out on the ostfront too.
@@mamavswild yes it must’ve been really bad. I really like it that you got to read literature about the other side. Every soldier suffered tremendously, no matter what side. Many German soldiers were also drafted, such as my great grandfather in WW2. We should all respect the men and women that put their life and sanity on the line to fight for their country. That’s why I admire the American tradition of honoring your servicemen and women and your veterans as heroes, which they are. Here in Germany people have no respect for our soldiers and even talk bad about them for our involvement in Mali and co, which is still for a good cause. To the point of Hitler getting voted, that is absolutely true. The people that voted him were also super desperate, because the Great Depression and the Versailles treaty were really hard for the German people. I am absolutely disgusted by what we’ve done in WW2, but people have to understand the whole story before judging and blaming returning soldiers.
@@prussianangler И вы снова как всегда раз в сто лет идете всем западом на Россию!Все равно какая она советская,царская или современная!
This song has to be the most depressing Sabaton song to date. The way the story is told, the sounds of everything, just everything about this song buries itself deep in your heart.
Geez
Wow. Sabaton has a very special and unique gift with telling history through music and it often gives me chills and brings a tear to my eye. This video and song complement each other very well. Nice job.
it gives me chills too and makes me research more about war
Yes true
Mnnmm
yes
I agree with everyone who has replied
Maximum respect to my German great-great grandfather Ernest Zimmermann, of Bavarian Regiment 14, 5th Bavarian Division, who fought in the Battle of the Somme.
Is he the one in your profile pic?
@@pandamilkshake No, it's a picture of an unknown German soldier during The Somme.
@@nlann.33 Thanks, buddy
Mine did it to in the french army. Hurt by a german 88 he lost 20% of his leg.
@@gael1049 War is hell...
I'm sorry for what happened to your old man
"Whoever said war is hell is wrong. Hell is where sinners are punished, war is where innocents are murdered in the most brutal ways imaginable. Those in Hell chose to sin. Those in war are thrown into a fire that destroys anything that comes out of it".
-Me.
Found my high school yearbook quote right here!
Damn dude you're so right with that
Your right.
From the first season of M*A*S*H: "Hawkeye:
War isn't Hell. War is war, and Hell is Hell. And of the two, war is a lot worse.
Father Mulcahy:
How do you figure, Hawkeye?
Hawkeye:
Easy, Father. Tell me, who goes to Hell?
Father Mulcahy:
Sinners, I believe.
Hawkeye:
Exactly. There are no innocent bystanders in Hell. War is chock full of them - little kids, cripples, old ladies. In fact, except for some of the brass, almost everybody involved is an innocent bystander."
@@mrpotatonutz9154 Fuck i was too late for this comment so i cant use this
Europe : What's the price of a kilometer?
1 mile it's a 1,6 kilometres
@@СеменШевченко-й6э Это мы знаем, но какова *цена* километра.
@@sjalkzjziskzkzo как видишь, 600 тысяч жизней..
@@mrdenkom255 Это цена 6 миль, мы пытаемся установить цену одного километра
@@sjalkzjziskzkzo смотри: миля грубо говоря 1,5 км. Всего 6 миль. Всего (6×1,5)=9 км. Теперь 9÷600000=100500 жизней (все расчёты примерные). То есть примерно цена 1 км это 100500 жизней... Понятно что считать цену км или миль жизнями юношей и мужчин, дедов это глупо и ненормально, но командование тех времён считало это обычным ежедневным делом, сам знаешь...
I can only imagine the suffering these men went through. I am glad that I never have to experience this kind of war. Thank you for your sacrifice.
*pain*
tyranny encroaches on the unaware and unsuspecting during times of peace... History will repeat itself
yeah mad respect to all those vets (and animal vets too ig lol)
На украине сейчас точная копия. Приезжай. Заценишь.
This song keeps getting more relevant to me and my family the longer I'm alive.
Thank you for mentioning the rarely mentioned Canadian Corps, who get rare attention yet contributed so much in these times of sheer brutality. RIP the Newfoundland Regiment... May your lives never be forgotten..
Same could be said for the South Africans fighting in both world wars and the Korean war only to have our war hero's now be "Britsh war hero's only born and lived in South Africa and fought in our army, air force"
@@Gidi66 That is so VERY true. It is truly sad that those soldiers are not recognized as SOUTH AFRICANS... South Africa is a strong, independent and self sustaining nation with it's own identity. It is a very unique and beautiful place. Like everywhere, it is not without it's troubles though. Respect to your ancestors who fought for their brothers in arms in an unjust conflict that should never have happened and which they should never have been involved. Brave people all.
@@_M_a_r_t_i_n_M yea my people went from British concentration camps in 1902 to trench warfare in the battle of the Somme
@@Gidi66 Damn.... That is brutal.. A lot of the unrest in modern day Africa is due to European meddling in the area in the first place.. Such a beautiful continent yet a few greedy individuals ruin it for the sake of their own greed. And that part about going from concentration camps to 'friendly' lines in one of the most brutal battles of history is just... I simply don't have words for that. May God bless their souls. Canadians fought voluntarily and with enthusiasm. These people had no choice yet still fought like lions. I am going to have to do some proper research on this subject now as it is a very important piece of world history.. I have always had a fascination with the continent of Africa, yet it has so much history that it is impossible to learn all of it. You just fed me an excellent bit to study up on. Thank you for your contribution here.
@@_M_a_r_t_i_n_M some Boers didn't like fighting for the British the people who had conquerd us in war and let 27 thousand women and children starve in the camps and some 30 thousand native allies of the Boers, and they where mostly if German descent so they rebelled, it's was the reason why South African soldiers didn't sent troops abroad in the first month or 2. An old general went to the military academy where a lot of new recruits where gathered for their final ceremony and gave a speech and the young men joined him to actively try and join the Germans hell they even got a German colonial officer to come from a German colony to inspect our boys, however the main reason it failed was because of the general in charge wasn't the original pick for it the original one was accidentally shot dead by police when his driver didn't stop at a police checkpoint set up to try and catch a few bank robbers the stand in for the original pick didn't have the knowledge and experience to lead such a large army and after a few talks gave up and handed over the soldiers under him only one guy was hanged and it was some random guy who had joined them after running away from the place he was working as a guard. This rebellion was the reason we didn't consript our boys for the ww2. Most of the Boers where of German/Dutch decent with the otherside being britsh and the smallest group being French so they feared another rebellion and only sent volunteers
The real price of war...young men's lives
And to think their leaders are cousins after all
@ColdPetRat2.99 thx woman
@ColdPetRat2.99 okay woman
"thousands of feet march to the beat it's a army on the march long way from home paying the price in young mans lives"
@ColdPetRat2.99 maybe you are kind of 10 old girl. I can say that the til and the mens on the front have same important work
Mad respect to the men of the Canadian Corps. Did what no one else could and took the ridge, at the cost of many lives unfortunately. A shoutout to the British, ANZAC, and other commonwealth forces and allies who also gave their blood to the cause, may they rest in peace.
Max respect to ALL of the young men, no matter which side they were on.
There was no ‘Right Side’ in WWI.
The British only cared about ensuring there was no competition for their empire and sacrificed their child nations to achieve their goals (often throwing Canadians into the worst of the front or tossing ANZAC soldiers into irresponsible, near certain death at Gallipoli)
The Germans thought they were defending a friend.
There was no right or wrong.
@@mamavswild
You do know far more British soldiers died at Gallipoli
Табуны мурашек по коже от этой песни, никогда так не ревела от музыки. Спасибо сабатону за их творчество
Пробирает до мурашек - отлично смонтировано
girls in dodgeball: omg Stacy you got shotttttttt!
Boys in dodge ball:
Oh yeah. Barbed wire and all.
Poor jimmy
God rest his soul
True
I once got a triple with 1 ball, 3 little noobs grouped up just talking. Ahh good times.
this was the first song of Sabaton that i heard, really thank you for introducing me in this great world called "Sabaton"
Pulls no punches with its verisimilitude in showing the futility of war. The poetic narration, music & visual depiction of hell that must have been Passchendaele.
A long time ago, in my early youth, I experienced similar emotions from reading the Erich Maria Remarque " All quiet on the Western front". And now I have strong flashbacks from the video and the song. Great book. Great song. Respect for Sabaton from Russia.
Save your young men! Don't make war in Ukraine! Get rid of Putin for sending your young men to die.
@@shaydowsith348 what a superficial and utterly useless take! since you have such good ideas, why not propose a way to accomplish these goals? one that's feasible and doesn't involve endangering civilians
great depiction of how Canadian soldiers fought in Ypres, God rest all the souls in that terrible conflict.
Heavy Metal about history. Double win! Much respect for all men who lost their lives during these wars.
“Everyone thinks of himself as a strategic, seeing the fight from the outside”
- Shota Rustaveli, Georgian writer
And than there are people asking "is Sabaton glorying war?"
They do it not.
then*
@@wintermetal1513 okay
This song displays the waste of the lives in fruitless charges against enemy fortifications. "What's the price of a mile?" Turns about, about 2,000 men. The rest of their songs bring light to tragedies, heroes, and other points, and people, of history. They bring the past to life, and ensure those who gave so much, who sacrificed more than any other, will never be forgotten.
@@FokkeWulfe they want us to learn from history because that's the way it never happens again (well it still happens but we don't think war is something to want)
Сейчас такие же бои под Бахмутом и на Запорожском направлении. Вечная слава простым солдатам обработанным капиталистической пропагандой и погибшим за интересы капиталистов. Мир - хижинам, война - дворцам!
Great video again. Thank God for being born 60 years later and not joining this senseless war and shooting people I would not have known.
Best regards from Germany.
this was from ww 1. so over 100 years ago.
Самая сильная песня. Отдаю честь всем солдатам, ведь война не знает наций.
🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺
зараз нам також допомагають боротись против коричневої чуми ! велика вдячність сша, британцям і всім європейцям!
@@knifereserve144 thanks
@@knifereserve144 Зараз так як і тоді...
Скільки коштує життів кілометр фрону?
Hale to the fallen
Respect to all that fought in WW1 and died, but even more respect to the ones who survived and fought in WW2. I can’t even imagine how horrible that had to be. The men who actively fought in combat during both wars and ended up surviving them are true legends, no matter what side they were on.
legends?lucky bastards more like although they never thought so
@@acustomer3518 so everything is about luck?
@@andreig475 in war yes luck of the draw or how the fuck did any body survive the dday landings with all them bullets flying around
Мой прадед прошел всю 1 мировую сапером и 2 года 2 мировой на юдном фронте(1941-1943).
I'd like to think that the men who fought and died would feel honored to be memorialized in such a spectacular song. Sabaton is so amazing when it comes to telling stories through song and getting people interested in learning more about history.
Killing someone you don't know, and don't hate.....
The other side... why are we doing this?
Because there guy bad
it's always politics, the propaganda comes through the news, people believe everything and then there is war.in this order, industry the politicians the media ! the People die for fantasies. it's always like this.
And it worked, just look at America
Because capitalists need more profit. And more...
In this war's case it was Europe building tension and alliances and the someone shot someone very important to one group and the smaller party's bro's came to back Serbia up and it turned into a meat grinder thanks to modern weapons and tactics from a hundred years ago
Thank you for all your texts in honor of all these men who died for peace. Thank you it resonates being a military nurse, many soldiers too young, are still dead or crippled for strictly geopolitical reasons
Big respects to those who fought and died during WW1 and WW2
3:53 man really caught that with his hand ouch
otherwise would've went through his chest to be fair
@@conorforsythe8726 still ouch
@@dickkickem8980 true true
Shit I didn't get notifications for these comments 🤣
On gawd indeed
If you are wondering what this clip is from, this is a clip from the Canadian WWI Movie Passchendale.
Those trench fights were absolutly terrifying...
One of the best music videos. Thank you !
"6 miles of ground has been won, half a million men are gone" hits hard as always.
Great footage. My great-grandfather was at Ypres. He was part of several operation in which he engaged the enemy in close quaters combat, among which was a bayonet charge in which he stabbed several Canadians. When I was very young, he would reminisce fondly, about those Canadians panicking, even though my great-grandfather and his mates were with just about 15 dudes against a whole trench, a company, whatever. They killed a lot of them!
Remember and respect the veterans!
It greatly depicts hand to hand combat but is sad to me as a Canadian
Une pensée à tout ces Soldats mort pour sa partie.
A tout ces courageux âgé entre 15 et 65 ans.
Une pensée au familles des victimes
Triste de perdre 1, 2 voir 3 proche.
Mais cette guerre nous a tous aussi appris des chose... malheureusement, nous les Hommes, tous autant que nous sommes, nous sommes capables à faire de grande chose, bien ou mal.
Reposés en paix brave soldat.
🕊️🕊️🕊️
Nouvelle chaîne d'histoire.
La vie d'Hitler et autre (rien à voir avec les documentaires et ce que l'on nous dit pas )
ruclips.net/video/mYBsm9m3pQk/видео.html
La première guerre vue du côté allemand.
German?
Malheureusement l'homme n'est bon qu'à tout détruire.
As a Canadian thanks for covering this battle. I enjoy your music.
Сколько погибает людей в бессмысленных войнах и ради чего - ради прихоти правителей и их игры кто сильней они сами не идут воевать и живут в своих замках - так может пора задуматься людям простым что нам на этой земле нечего делить - ведь жизнь человека и так коротка и надо ее ценить -- а ребята хорошо поют есть над чем задуматься
велика дяка всім нашим партнерам! зараз як і тоді, нам також допомагають боротись против коричневої чуми ! велика вдячність сша, британцям і всім європейцям!
The folly of war as felt through GREAT Rock!! Thank you for your service, Sabaton!!
Сабатон це вічний музончік👍👍👍
I was waiting for that shovel guy
A death corp of krieg fan I see.
Warhammer 40000
@@Stronghand-yw1lk nice profile picture
I subscribed to you
@@raleighthomas8326 thank you kindly friend.
Through action,a man becomes a hero.
Through death,a hero becomes a legend.
Through time,a legend becomes a Myth.
And by learning from the Myth,a man takes action.
"It only takes 1 epic and uplifting music to turn the comments section to a poetry treasure hole"
"They say light is the fastest thing in the universe, but darkness is already there before light comes"
"Honor died on the beach, the Khan deserves to suffer" - Jin Sakai
Dzięki za wszystko co robicie 💪💝💝🥰😍💝 Sebastian pozdrawiam
Hallo! Wunderscöne video mit groβatriger musik🎶 ich mag✨✨
Read in a ww1 history book once,
A soldier was taking a break in the medical whatever you call it,
He saw a soldier on a bed trying to lite a match for his pipe, but couldn't get it, So the guy helped him, then he noticed that the soldier on the bed's jaw had been blown away,
So the guy lit the pipe so the wounded fellow could at least smell it,
Yeah had to take a long walk after reading that,
I read about a French dude who’s army had just captured a fortress by shelling it to rubble. When he got into the fortress he found a mangled pile of goo and gore that was still moaning in agony. The guy’s face was blown off, legs were missing, one of his hands was gone, his guts were splattered all around him and he was still alive. I was like 12 when I read this book and it really freaked me out.
@@obi-wankenobi1750 was that book named "putain de guerre" or something like that
@@obi-wankenobi1750 People commit suicide by cutting their wrists and yet you believe someone just lives on and on with a hand blown off? And their legs?
@Furioclasse people have jumped on grenades and survived. People have fallen 10,000 feet out of an airplane and lived. Phineas Gage survived a meter long railroad spike being blown through the bottom of his jaw and out the top of his head. Yes, people can survive, for a small amount of time, losing hands and legs.
Dear God, how horrible
The worst part of WW1 is that all those men died literally for no reason at all while their generals cluelessly threw more and more bodies in the meatgrinder.
The first war with modernizing technology and they used outdated tactics for years and years
My great great grandpa went through WW1, Spanish Civil War(as a republican volunteeer) and WW2 and met the end of the war in Berlin... This will most probably get lost in the comments, but i just want you all to know how much of a fucking gigachad my great great grandpa was... This is our family's song of 9th of May, we always pour one for our family's greatest hero and I end up drinking it in silence. Rest in peace great great grandpa Andrew and great grandpa Ivan(died in Stalingrad in 1942)
Descanse en paz
2:38 his gun jammed when he pushed the bolt forward
Fighting in mud sucks and this is a common issue for every soldier in modern day warfare. At least simple bolt actions are easier to deal with compared to a modern semi-auto when that happens.
What a tribute to those so and too young men ... on the both sides ... Thank you for them Sabaton ! Cheers from Belgium.
I like how at 0:22 the explosions sync to the beat
Это потрясающе)
The thing I can never get over, no matter how much emotion and effort we put into Cinematic and Musical Recreations of such events we are still basically looking at a Single BRICK out of a SKYSCRAPER. We cant even Scratch the SURFACE of the REALITY of what it was like for our Grandparents and Great Grandparents. O.o
It is in my blood, ace fighters. My second name is Georg, which comes from my Grand Grand Uncle who was a fighter for the Kaiser. Praise to you. Also for my banat bulgarian in the family, who died in a airplane crash in Hungary for the Austro-Hungarian Empire. He was also a fighter
its actually a devastating thought how these young men had to charge the enemy without any chance of survival
A truly brutal video, a video that NEEDS to be made and shown to remind all, that war is horror, but against evil it is often the only tool to defeat that evil.
The only thing wrong with this is the tiresome depiction of the Germans as combat incapable. Very typical of Anglo-American narrations of the world wars. In fact at Passchendaele they inflicted more casualties on the British Empire than they received. Everything else is grimly realistic, underpinned by Sabaton's haunting indictment of the futility of war.
Perhaps because the Germans were defending in this campaign. Altough yes I´d agree it´s generally speaking too many movies where Germans are portraied poorly.
@@RAEJDER 2cnd world wars later stagees the germans were working with fresh new recruits and yeet the amount of shit the alliess had to go through was impessrive still si in that case young mane were manning the walls at omha
its just the way things are portryayed ww1 gemrany were um.................................................... BRUTAL!
Toward the end of both world wars, germany's usage of child soldiers was very high, due to the catastrophic casualties among German men.
It doesn't matter how many casualties you inflict - if they are chewing through your best men while you are chewing through their ill-trained cannon fodder, the quality of your army is irreversibly being destroyed.
@@Ensign_Cthulhu not wrong but as the "most efficient" fraction in WW1 its still not realistic to portray them that foolish, also you forget that the same counts for french, British AND especially the US. Everyone threw in fresh troops wich were pretty likely to die soon.
Bakhmut front looks exactly like Paschendale, just on a smaller scale.
War, war never changes
I love your channel!
Просто бомба!!!сам воевал!знаю всё это дерьмо!но даже у меня слушая припев мурашки бегут по коже и я снова вспоминаю тот,страх и ужас который меня поменял на всю жизнь!!!
@Свирдов Виталий +++
велика дяка всім нашим партнерам! зараз як і тоді, нам також допомагають боротись против коричневої чуми ! велика вдячність сша, британцям і всім європейцям!
I love reading books of ww1 and learn about this often overlooked war.
Eu trabalho com jovens em minha igreja a anos , nos é ensinado a ver , e alimentar o potencial de cada um deles e direcionar isso para ajudar os outros , creio que Deus ve em cada jovem um potencial imenso para fazer o bem , mais saber que tantos jovens morreram na lama , alguns nem puderam se reconhecidos ou se quer sepultados , um mar de corpos , um mar de sonhos e potencial perdido .
" Poucas milhas conquistadas , meio milhao de homens perdidos"
Essa frase me tirou uma lagrima dos olhos ...
super! браво, Сабатончик!!
This is a very good music and nice video man.
I forgot this open and fell asleep, as soon as i woked up i realized i was watching this while sleeping
the young guy who just sits is perfect for the book cover of "All Quiet on the Western Front" Remarque
Incredible book, I've read my copy of it to tatters over the years. The story of Paul Baumer and all his friends in that awful war still brings tears to my eyes no matter how many times I read it. I can't recommend it enough, they don't write em like they used to.
immagine being 14 in the middle of that field.
Congrats on 400K!
That German soldier in the videos is just casually sitting like nothing is happening
He is in shock.
He looks underaged
@@clexmce3569 He most likely is
@@JagMan78 This.
i love that scene. somehow tells you everything
as músicas do sabaton são contagiantes, expressam os acontecimentos pós guerra.
Amazing editing on the video it’s awesome!!!!!
J'adore Sabaton 😉 vos chansons sont géniales !!!!
Ils sont grandioses. C'est un super groupe 👍
"I died in hell, they called it Passchendaele" -Siegfried Sassoon
If this song and movie describe how brutal the western front was, I don’t want to imagine neither a movie nor a song about the Italian front.
Being under a general who thinks that a 11th assault will break through the enemy’s lines would be unthinkable nowadays
Согласен. Еще немцы, те немцы, которые немцы, достойны звания героев
So true❤
Nice clip from the Canadian film Passchendaele by Paul Gross, works great with the song.
Amazing video mate!
Fun fact, if we do the math, we find that each FOOT of land gained cost the Allies 12 lives. Just Allies. It cost about the same for Germany. That means each foot of land gained by the Allies in the battle of Passchendaele cost about 24 lives. 24 brothers, sons, fathers, husbands, and friends died for a 12 inches. That also means that 2 people died for an inch. An INCH. In my opinion, this was the most costly battle in history.
Stalingrad: 👽
I cry every time I hear this song 😢
The toughest song for me is Gallipoli, but this is tied for second along with the Swedish version of A Lifetime of War
I nearly cry
How much is a mile worty?
-Nothing.
(leaves then turn around)
-Everything!
My family lost 2 great uncles in the Great War, One at the Somme and one at Gallipoli never foget the sacrifices of the NZEF and all the others who never came home, Lost but never forgotten, Lest we forget.
Hear the sound of a machine gun
Hear it echo in the night
Mortals firing rains the scene
Scars the fields
That once were green
It's a stalemate at the front line
Where the soldiers rest in mud
Roads and houses
All is gone
There is no glory to be won
know that many men will suffer
Know that many men will die
Half a million lives at stake
Ask the fields of Passchendaele
And as the night falls the general calls
And the battle carries on and on
How long?
What is the purpose of it all
What's the price of a mile?
Thousands of feet march to the beat
It's an army on the march
Long way from home
Paying the price in young men's lives
Thousands of feet march to the beat
It's an army in despair
Knee-deep in mud
Stuck in the trench with no way out
Thousands of machineguns
Kept on firing through the night
Mortars blazed and wrecked the scene
Guns in the fields that once were green
Still a deadlock at the front line
Where the soldiers die in mud
Roads and houses since long gone
Still no glory has been won
Know that many men has suffered
Know that many men has died
Six miles of ground has been won
Half a million men are gone
And as the men crawled the general called
And the killing carried on and on
How long?
What's the purpose of it all?
What's the price of a mile?
Thousands of feet march to the beat
It's an army on the march
Long way from home
Paying the price in young men's lives
Thousands of feet march to the beat
It's an army in despair
Knee-deep in mud
Stuck in the trench with no way out
Young men are dying
They pay the price
Oh how they suffer
So tell me what's the price of a mile
That's the price of a mile.
Thousands of feet march to the beat
It's an army on the march
Long way from home
Paying the price in young men's lives
Thousands of feet march to the beat
It's an army in despair
Knee-deep in mud
Stuck in the trench with no way out
It’s pass the fields of passchendaele not ask passchendaele
Una de mis bandas favoritas .thanks my friend
Marine: runs out of ammo
Also marine: picks up a rock and hits the enemy in the head
Those actually weren't Marines they are Just regular foot soldiers but I see your point in hand to hand combat its scary
@@kurtgeraldtomada4451 I believe they’re supposed to be Canadian special forces
@@Foxdidnothingwrong They are
😂👍
Just awesome song and video!
It doesn't matter how glorious American films make it seem, they can't hide the pure suffering of both sides in trench warfare. There was no heroism, only death and pain.
This is Canadian, and was Saving Private Ryan “heroic” at all? Medic mumbling for his mama after being shot, American being stabbed in the chest slowly as he begs for help from his coward friend.
There is literally no American film about world war one that tried to make it seem heroic to fight in trench warfare.
You've actually just made something up to get mad at.