Tell me you haven't read the book without telling me you haven't read the book... The new movie that was inspired by the book completely missed the point of the book. Read the Book and then read Ernst Jüngers "In Stahlgewittern" (no Idea how it is called in English). And THEN watch the new movie. It is really insulting how wrong the new movie got the message of the book
@@PropagandalfderWeiße are you dumb? I said best movie. A movie stands on it's own. In westen nichts neues is a book, not a movie. If it misses the point or not, that's irrelevant. It's a good visual representation of WWI unlike 1917 for example, where everything is sanitized. That is all I'm saying. I never claimed to have read the book nor is it relevant to what I'm saying.
Nah. It is a very bad adaption of the book. It completely missed the the point of the book. Even the title of the book says it all. The book is calleed that way, because after all that these young men went through, all the friends they lost, death has been so normalised that their death is summarised in the daily armys report as "all quiet". The movie completely flips this message on its head by making this young man from the tragic, but statistical and meaningless death into the last dead soldier of the whole war.
I'll say it: the best WWI movie about the struggle in the trenches, right there with the original 1930's version
Tell me you haven't read the book without telling me you haven't read the book...
The new movie that was inspired by the book completely missed the point of the book. Read the Book and then read Ernst Jüngers "In Stahlgewittern" (no Idea how it is called in English). And THEN watch the new movie. It is really insulting how wrong the new movie got the message of the book
@@PropagandalfderWeiße are you dumb? I said best movie. A movie stands on it's own. In westen nichts neues is a book, not a movie.
If it misses the point or not, that's irrelevant. It's a good visual representation of WWI unlike 1917 for example, where everything is sanitized. That is all I'm saying.
I never claimed to have read the book nor is it relevant to what I'm saying.
One of the best anti-war movies ever! What honor is there is stealing? What glory in murder? What courage in sending others to die?
Nah. It is a very bad adaption of the book. It completely missed the the point of the book. Even the title of the book says it all. The book is calleed that way, because after all that these young men went through, all the friends they lost, death has been so normalised that their death is summarised in the daily armys report as "all quiet". The movie completely flips this message on its head by making this young man from the tragic, but statistical and meaningless death into the last dead soldier of the whole war.
I was wondering how long it take for this to happen
You will not fight anymore!
Ww1 ❤❤❤
SCHOLZ THE UBER COWAED
ukraine 2024