The EU’s Migration Crisis Explained
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 май 2024
- The first 500 people to use my link will get access to one of Skillshare's best offers: 30 days free AND 40% off the first year of Skillshare membership: skl.sh/tldrnewseu1023
Looking at recent headlines, you might feel like Europe is really souring on immigration, with the rise of right-wing parties across Europe, and even some more liberal politicians asking for a better immigration system. In this video, we take a look at why immigration is such a hot topic in the EU, why the current system doesn't work, and whether the EU can fix it.
Has the EU finally solved Immigration? -@EUMadeSimple
• EU's New Pact on Migra...
🎞 TikTok: / tldrnews
💡 Got a Topic Suggestion? - forms.gle/mahEFmsW1yGTNEYXA
Support TLDR on Patreon: / tldrnews
Donate by PayPal: tldrnews.co.uk/funding
Our mission is to explain news and politics in an impartial, efficient, and accessible way, balancing import and interest while fostering independent thought.
TLDR is a completely independent & privately owned media company that's not afraid to tackle the issues we think are most important. The channel is run by a small group of young people, with us hoping to pass on our enthusiasm for politics to other young people. We are primarily fan sourced with most of our funding coming from donations and ad revenue. No shady corporations, no one telling us what to say. We can't wait to grow further and help more people get informed. Help support us by subscribing, engaging and sharing. Thanks!
////////////////////////////
1 - www.politico.eu/article/switz...
2 - www.spiegel.de/international/...
3 - home-affairs.ec.europa.eu/pol...
4 - www.euractiv.com/section/migr...
5 - www.consilium.europa.eu/en/in...
6 - www.statista.com/statistics/4...
7 - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenge...
8 - www.schengenvisainfo.com/sche...
9 - www.ft.com/content/6d47250b-0...
10 - brusselssignal.eu/2023/08/the...
11 - www.france24.com/en/live-news...
12 - www.dw.com/en/germany-says-ng...
13 - www.ft.com/content/435c6b91-9...
14 - www.economist.com/europe/2022...
15 - blogs.lse.ac.uk/europpblog/20...
16 - www.frontex.europa.eu/media-c...
17 - www.economist.com/europe/2023...
18 - www.statista.com/statistics/9...
19 - www.euronews.com/my-europe/20...
20 - ec.europa.eu/eurostat/databro...
21 - ec.europa.eu/eurostat/databro...
22 - www.economist.com/europe/2023...
23 - home-affairs.ec.europa.eu/pol...
23 - home-affairs.ec.europa.eu/pol...
24 - www.reuters.com/world/europe/...
25 - www.schengenvisainfo.com/news...
26 - www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-euro...
27 - apnews.com/article/tunisia-eu...
28 - commission.europa.eu/strategy...
29 - www.economist.com/europe/2023...
00:00 - Introduction
01:36 - Why the EU is Worried About Immigration
03:08 - Why the EU's Current System Doesn't Work
08:15 - The EU's New Migration Policy
12:04 - Sponsored Content
Most EU countries just don't have the capacity to integrate this amount of migrants, so what you end up with is massive separated communities of migrants with completely different cultures, religion and values, that causes friction with the original population.
Every country faces the same issues.
@@BesthinktwiceI simply love how English were "terrified" of eastern european while not being terrified by the shiv and shank people, turkish, arabs or other ones. The eastern europeans blend quite well (much better than the above mentioned ones) and their children will actually consider themselves english/brittish w.e, compared to how most of arabs/turkish and so on where they will consider themselves english only as the second answer (or first when them boys wanna use the strong passport you got.
Also about the "different people and therefore scared topic", I mean you can say it is somewhat true for some people but let me tell you this: When you know that there are some parts of the city where there is actual threat to your safety of the safety or your belongings, you tend to think: why is that? Well because it is massively populated by a minority i.e. arabs, blacks and so on, sooo you realize that the more they come, the more they group together and shit starts hitting the fan. And it aint solely white/black thing, notice how I never mentioned indians, asians and so on. Well coz they're mostly chill, adapting well and hard working. They don't cause issues. Nor do by far most of eastern europeans (you always got a retard here and there). So to sum it up: if you got certain groups which are more likely to cause issues, you will try to not let them in your home. As simple as that. Ain't about the race, rather about the damn behavior or those races/ethnicities and so on.
@@Besthinktwice look, I think there are definitely migrants that should be accepted, but you can't deny this causes issues in countries, sure accepting 20k migrants when your population is millions won't change anything even if they don't integrate well, but just look at Sweden they have a population of 7/8 mil and have accepted a million migrants, and everything I hear from Swedish friends is that it has made towns/neighborhoods significantly more dangerous, there was even a news piece of the army getting involved to help the cops. Btw would appreciate perspectives on the issue from other Swedes, my circle might be quite narrow.
@@Besthinktwice there is significant difference between migrants from the same cultural sphere like Western/Roman Europe than economical migrants( which should not be accepted by default) whose are from completely different culture/religion/sphere of influence.
Please tell me more about how well you understand London after visiting. I'm glad someone that doesnt live there like myself can tell me what I think. Thank you.
The main problem is that the distinction between economic migrants and refugees has been blurred. Both the left and right intentionally blurr it for different reasons.
Isn't the end effect similar in both cases though? A bunch of foreigners arriving in your country and causing a headache. The main difference is that economic migration is long-term, while asylum seekers arrive in waves. The problem is mainly illegal migrants and asylum seekers.
"the right" which is currently in charge of asylum system is making big buck out of this industry.
Overall the migrants are really just an attempt to bring up gdp and put money into the wallets of the government and capitalists. I personally don’t mind since I’m American, but I think relying on migrants has hurt poorer countries. It’s a literal brain drain.
@@Ruzzky_Bly4t maybe just pay reparations to the billions of people your countries are responsible for destroying and they wont be forced to flock to europe for the small chance of getting to be alive without having to experience literal torture every second of their existence? europe causes all these problems but never wants to be held responsible for all the damages. yall INVENTED INSURANCE but you cant even be honest about the damages you do.
It doesn't matter. I don't want either of them in Europe at this point.
Hot take: I think the 2015 migrant crisis was in part what scared the UK into voting for Brexit, in the misguided belief that it would stop mass migration
Don't think thats a hot take.
Facts.
That is so incredibly tepid a take
plus Russian interference...
That, social Media and fake news pushed on there
Why all those Muslims can't migrate to the super rich gulf States like Saudi Arabia, Katar, Emirates and others. If they have money for building golf fields or ice rinks in the desserts they should be able to help their brothers a bit.
Quite a lot do, but you more than likely pay no mind to them. And not everybody wants to be executed for Tweets
They use them as cheap labour treating them like slaves
Jordan’s 2.2 million Palestinians:
@@osheridan
Europeans don’t want to be replaced
@@Prideium9001 France 6 million muslims:
Immigration is difficult if there already is a massive housing crisis and staff shortage.
The housing crisis is a problem of capitalism
*capitalism
@arbiterargiros
Almost no-one likes capitalism, but do you have any non-populist suggestions?
And not enough time between immigration waves for people to assimilate
"housing crisis" you mean rich retired people living alone in 4 room houses
I actually firmly believe that immigration policies are the number 1 reason for the rise of populism in Europe. Not the sole reason, but the biggest contributor. I really don’t understand where the issue before a solution is found, there’s clearly growing frustration even in Western Europe. It’s not like there isn’t a will universally everywhere at this point. Australia has tight migration policies, Japan has tight policies etc. nobody is even batting an eye about them. I see no reason why we can’t follow their footsteps.
as an aussie myself, are migration policies really that tight???
There is a corporate left-wing interest to maintain a steady flow of immigrants. Corporations need immigrants because they can pay them below the national average, which means reducing the production costs and more profits for the shareholders. Left wing political parties see in immigrants an untapped electoral base, especially in local elections where immigrants are granted voting rights once they get permanent residence which is like an intermediary state before getting citizenship. Immigrants are much more likely to vote left wing parties because they facilitate their arrival and presence, as well as provide them with various benefits.
When it comes to people coming by boat they are pretty strict and effective at least compared to elsewhere. I mean Christmas island and similar are definitely pretty harsh.
Neither Australia nor Japan went to Africa and Middle East colonizing, exploiting people, drawing arbitrary borders, causing conflicts, etc.
If you look at where the immigrants are coming from and why, more often than not it goes back to the mess Europeans have caused.
It’s just coming back to haunt them. It’s like the kid you used to beat up in school is now coming back at you.
People always ignore the physicality of the issue.
Have you considered the Massive Coastline the EU has with the Mediterranean?
And im general the EU members have all signed the declaration of human rights. People come over without papers - when I mean people I mean tens of thousands - good luck investigating each one of them for their origin country and deport them there.
All the far right parties are also making promises they can’t keep.
The true solution, ladies and gentlemen, is to make the North African coast our own jurisdiction.
The solution is recolonization of Africa.
I think that the issue is that immigration in Europe especially with regards to the Syrian refugee crisis was that it was forced upon most EU countries without a democratic vote or even public debate. The anti-democratic nature of it all where citizens of these countries were just told “it’s happening, you can’t stop it, cry harder loser” is part of the reason there was so much of a backlash.
It’s that obvious disconnect where the intellectuals in their ivory towers, living in prime real estate and many times gated communities saw no conceivable downsides for them whereas regular EU citizens had to bare the brunt of the problems when you drop a large amount of people who are very poor and from a vastly different culture right into the nations with very little guidance or direction.
Happens weekly here, some village with 500 people gets 2500 immigrants, WHILE NOBODY WANTS THEM
Democracy they call that.
We are evil racists for not wanting our countries overrun by foreign migrating peoples trying to lay claim to our ancestral lands in the first place. That is always the only moral of the politically correct story. An ethic of cultural deconstruction, nay, self-destruction to be precise.
But it doesn't have to be like this. If the EU is indeed democratic as the claim is then it should be possible for its peoples to take completely other route and to chance the course into politics which is actually benevolent to Europeans.
Eu beinf antidemocratic? Where have I seen this before? 🧐
Gated comunities is more an americas phenomenon. I can literally ring the bell of the president of my country or find him swimming at the beach. Usa projection onto europe 😂
@@puraLusa The phenomenon known in America as white flight is recognizable in Europe as well. Those white people who can afford it live separately from mixed, often poorer communities where problems are more common. Suburbia such as in America simply make this more easily recognizable.
There is no migration crisis in Poland. Ukrainians or Belarusians who escape to Poland find work, open their own business, pay taxes, thrive. They are from the same culture, they are in huge majority respectful people (there are always exceptions) who learn language fast. The rest of migrants who come to Poland do that on work or student visa so we have no problem with them. If you come to Poland, you need to have a purpose because we don’t give benefits.
Why students are problem? Majority of the non-eu students are PAYING tuition fees and spending foreign money cuz you don’t have scholarships thus they boost ur economy. Especially Turkish ones. I understand you though on Arabic refugees crisis. It’s everywhere. Non-students are also coming there to open up businesses and pay taxes. Just don’t mistake Turkish ppl with Arabs or Africans generally. They are absolutely not the same.
ye poorland kind of a shithole, ngl
pls gief benefit
@@alensufli nah Muslims gonna be Muslims. Statistically higher rape rate, extreme sexism, and cutting people's heads off because they criticized Muhammad who married a child and the Quran that validates all the degeneracy above.
Turks aren't Europeans.@@alensufli
@@alensufli She said they are not a problem.
The right to claim Asylum needs to be reformed again. People use this as an excuse to enter illegally and also bring a bad name to those who enter legally. Those asylum seekers who are rejected should not apply for work permits. That is the loophole many are abusing it.
apply rule of law
@@AlexanderKarlsson3277in a region seeing falling birth rates, where immigration is the only thing preventing population decline?
Apply online to get preapproved? Like ETIAS
@@AlexanderKarlsson3277 without legal migration Scandinavia is gonna slowly fall apart so :)
It’s funny how your straight up quoting parts of Trumps 2016 campaign. Migrants are artificially keeping your countries young. The aging crisis isn’t going to be stopped until automation or natural selection catches up. Really there is no answer to it. For all you know you could be dooming yourselves.
When I passed through Marseilles it felt like I was in Algeria. As I walked down the street all I got were looks of disdain like I didn't belong because I'm not Middle Eastern.
That is rather common in many European cities. I can't walk parts of my own city because they have become so called no-go zones. I barely see a Swede when i visit the central part of the city.
Same in a lot of cities in the Netherlands
The Great Replacement.
@@aristocraticrebel It is happening but I don’t think it is orchestrated. I think it is from virtue signaling and ignorance.
It is 100% orchestrated.@@Kosovar_Chicken
Sweden and Germany are paying for ships to ferry thousands of muslim men from Africa to Europe every week.
😂😂😂😂
@@somerandomguyonlineforsome7870 It's true.
If the big old conventional parties refuse to tackle this serious problem the right and left extreme will.
Lol
Which is why the “far”-right have seen a rise in almost every country with significant immigration
@@user-jj5mp7ib1f lol
@@vignotum132I think this is because their stance against migrants make it far right, not the social liberty or economical policies.
extreme left wants wide open borders, mate.
As an immigrant I can clearly say EU and any other Region in the world for that matter, has a capacity for migration, that is simply not infinite. We have to face the facts. Migrations policies should be constantly updated and developped in a way it provides enrichement for the hosting population and for the minority of migrants. If you flood any country in the word with more migrants than it can handle, sooner or later friction will occur, which gives ground for extremism on both sides. Then there are economic factors which explain like 90% of immigration.
Tell your ppl back home if they want to enter EU they should come to Serbia, we are gladly pushing them thru our borders to EU just to make chaos in EU 😂😂
@@serbianwarrior385 Bro I never udnerstood the Serbia EU love hate relationship. liek u guys want to join so bad the EU but Hate the west and Nato at the same time. How do u manage? XD
@@serbianwarrior385thanks for showing your true colors. It’s always good to know which nation states are your enemies behind those false smiles.
Serbia should go join Putin and the rest of those failed corrupt states of needless human suffering. There’s a lot of them to choose from if that’s your preference. And just leave us be.
The highest number of immigrants and refugees EU can accept to move inside its borders should be defined annually by the market situation.
Open jobs minus how many unemployed people we have in EU. Roughly. Also, consideration of expected market development should be included into the analysis. Zero or negative result would mean zero accepted immigration or refugee applications that year. Period.
If we cannot provide for the people already in EU, we cannot provide for people entering the EU. It is that simple. People are slowly waking up to see this, which is the reason for changes in the common political views.
Focus in international aid should be put into the country of origin, or the country next to it. Refugee camps and humanitarian aid. Not into inviting all these people to EU area. People who want to help can volunteer to the aid organizations and travel to the camps and countries where the problems begin.
@@RaVNeFLoK False smiles??Sorry but what false smiles??Where are u from and what is your country?Us to leave u be??Oh brother we never even bothered u anything, u are ones(Western EU)that decided to attack us and to try take part of Serbia (Kosovo) and make it a independent country!Classy western hypocrisy!!!
When in Rome, do as the Romans do. Apparently this is difficult for a lot of people
Its racist apparently
@@user-dc9oq2pr6v What we do in France and we are called racists and Islamophobes. In France you do like the French and you stop all external proselytism. That's all.
@@user-dc9oq2pr6v enough of that goddamn term, getting redundant and overused
It is worth noting, the biggest driver of Brexit was immigration policy. The UK would all but assuredly still be un the EU if the migration crisis didn't exist.
So the effects of the EU immigration policy are very significant in the EU.
Yup. The economic situation in the UK outside of London is bleak and the Londoners don't care because their economic situation is much better. Same thing will continue to happen all across the EU with countries who are struggling unless they fix the immigration issue and allow countries to have their autonomy on border control again.
You know it's bad when even the Germans pull their heads out of their arses
Its just talk from them to try and stop AfD as I think this government has preposed to make it easier to get citizenship. I also think Germany has been blocking the idea of sending migrants to third party countries within eu discussion.
Just curious - has immigration at all affected your life, like, in any way?
@@soccerguy325yes it has
@@thatvexiolhow?
@@YuruCampSupermacy for a start, they drive prices up in a lot of areas, housing especially.
We want quality migration not quantity migration.
Ideally Europe should have a right of return for people of European descent worldwide. Non-Europeans shouldn't be here to begin with.
true
Big companies want cheap labour
Speak for yourself.
pick the ripe ones with an engineering degree among those who run away from bombings and floodings? Wow you have a golden heart
One point that wasn't addressed in this video is the effect this has on legal migrants. As a skilled worker migrant myself I can see what effects this has on my morality when I see the very people I was trying to get away from (i.e. Hamas supporters and terrorists) just become asylum seekers and ultimately are my neighbors again. This will soon change the demography of Europe and a drastic change in values. Legal immigrants will then definitely search for better places.
This is a good take. It's funny how legal migrants go through a thorough examination, yet a lot of those 'from the bottom of the barrel' folks got accepted in the blink of an eye
so being a Hamas supporter is really bad, but being an Israel supporter (as many people in Europe are), that's okay?
You are aware of how many more civilians Israel has killed than Hamas, right? It's roughly 10 times more -- although I'm happy to discuss the exact figures.
Solution shouldn't be to severely restrict immigration, it should be to better process and vet immigrants to let only the good, skilled workers who can provide a benefit to society in. I know so many of these intelligent, skilled immigrants who have been waiting for years/decades for their applications to be processed and their lives are hell while at the same time seeing many other immigrants lie and cheat their ways to citizenship. It's unfair. We need to reform the immigration department to favor a more extensive vetting process.
My family feels much the same in the US. My family is half Thai and many Thais have dealt with their own issues with religious extremists in Southern Thailand, and they also tend to hate the illegal immigrants from latin America since the illegal immigration makes it _so much harder_ to immigrate legally. I've got friends and family who had their marriages picked apart by government bureaucrats because so many Latin Americans abuse green card marriages, and they face the same issues getting work visas.
What's even funnier is that here in UK skilled worker visa fees have become higher because government can't cut money from the other areas to support their spendings on illegal immigrants. So, people who respect the country they moved to and who pay taxes now must pay extra for those who don't respect it and don't pay taxes.
Who'd not take free accommodation, healthcare, education and allowance simply for just arriving at a country?
🎯🎯🎯
Shit take
@@bobincognito?
And don't forget they are made of protected class of people
Yeee this should only work this way for people that live in eu not for every body. Also the fact the migrants try to force thier own rules in country they came in is just big midle figger from them. I mean there is fact that people need to stay in thier coumtry to make it more rich. Ukrains really escaped from war but wamt to go back as fast on posible while the arabian migrants not only want to staybin eu and live only from free money, but they allso steal ect.
It depends on what kind of migrants is coming. Sweden accepted about 180 000 migrants in 2015 and they said that that Sweden almost collapsed and they would never do it again and Sweden is still not recover from this event... Pretty much same populated Czech republic accepted 180 000 refugees from Ukraine in just a few weeks and total number is higher than 500 000. What happened to Czech republic? Literally nothing!
probably real estate crisis like in Poland rent went up 100%, 1 m^2 in Prague costs 10k euro in city center. This is the same number like in Seattle but salaries 3x higher in Seattle.
One of the reason is that Czech republic accepted people with relatively close culture. Ukranians can almost understand Czechs just through similarity of languages.
Also Czech republic do not provide a lot of support, so many people move somewhere else. AFAIK Czech republic has about 200-300k Ukrainians in the end. And about 100K found a job. Others in many cases are children.
@@michaelw7311 Nope. This happened in CZ(Prague) before. It is even cheaper to buy/rent a flat now than one year before. Max was 4Q 2021 - 1Q 2022.
Real estate prices went up crazily. I have a local Czech friend that pays the equivalent of 500 euros for a hotel room with no kitchen:)))) it did bring prices up and it made it a bit harder to find a job, just like it would anywhere
@@kirillshmidt3776 Not exactly. Do German and English understand each other? They have also similar language and both split cca 1500 years ago... Czech republic provide relatively relatively nice support, but you cannot live on luxury. And I think this is the main reason why Ukrainians(usually mothers with kids) are looking for jobs and much more of them did really find one in just a year, but immigrants in Sweden, Germany(overwhelmingly young men) etc could not after almost a decade...
Europe needs to make the point that people from the Third World can’t simply turn up on Europe s southern border in the tens of thousands and expect to all be taken care of but need to get a skill or trade first and then apply legitimately from their own countries.
Don't forget that our ancestors here in the US came from the third world in Europe: Ireland, Italy, Slavic countries were all "shitholes" as Trump would say. They were considered backwards, disease ridden, and filthy. Same as today with those people you are attacking. Most of our ancestors did not have skills or trade. I think having a generous social welfare state and a huge migration is kind of a bad idea, fortunately here in the US we don't have that combination. Our immigrants come and work, and work hard and pay taxes.
@@starxenoon8848they are not starving. They are seeking better opportunities. Majority of immigrants are males not children and elderly and not even females. They are aka invaders. I am central asian and i dont know how the fuck Europeans do not see how stupid it is to welcome invaders instead of fending them off.
it's weird how people think the west is an exception to typical laws and customs. It's normal for countries to protect their borders and restrict immigration, has been forever (even back in the middle ages you often couldnt just move into another country or village without some kind of paperwork and/or fee). The people fleeing to the west are often facing the same illegal immigration problems in their home country and they dont like it when it happens to them either. In the Americas for example people think the border with Mexico should be open but many Mexicans are moving because they're being displaced by central and south Americans and the Mexican government uses a lot of their security funding to try and block illegal immigration from their own southern border. Similar is happening across the Arab world as well.
Man, you really did say the quiet part out loud lmao. Racist much?
@@iminyourwalls8309Hmm, I see. So in essence "we go over there plunder the hell out of everything they have, come back home, and then we shut the doors when the people from over there are facing hard times and want to enter our society"
As a non eu student trying to study in Italy we can literally see the system failing in front of our eyes there is simply too many immigrants that are all processed by same agency. Getting right documents takes as much time as getting a degree here
Georgian?
Ok
Refugees really be walking 14.000 KM to the Nordic countries just to say that their country is better.
I mean, everybody loves their culture. It's pretty expected
@osheridan except Progressive Leftists that got all their rights from Western nations and hate those nations. "LGBTQ FOR ISLAM". LMAO
@@osheridan then dont come
@@henrygrant9650 Come where?
@@osheridan to europe. if you love your country so much, stay.
EU gives free money, subsidized housing, no borders, no need to integrate.
There, I did the explanation for you.
As russians
Whey made it super hard to even make visa
And even buying plane ticket from Russia to eu could cost you a too
I am a citizen of the Russian Federation, and the same problem begins in our country as in the EU with emigration from Central Asian countries. When there weren't many of them, you don't notice them, but when the population concentration starts to count in the tens of percent.... You start to notice a sharp increase in crime, drugs, rape, etc. But this is not the worst thing, none of them wants to integrate. Diasporas appear in your country and begin to indicate how to behave at home, forbidding you the holidays and traditions that are familiar to you.
Чел
Иногда славяне видут себя хуже любых мусульман
Numbers and types of migrants here in Sweden are ludicrously higher than the ability of the country's resources, institutions and economy to absorb them.
To make matters worse, the tax system locks people out of the kind of work that migrants traditionally took up to support themselves. VAT, the Eurotax, in Sweden has almost killed off market trading and tradesmen working independently. Meanwhile, earnings from crime are tax free.
All that before we even consider the differences in culture and values.
The result is a crime wave
many words to say that you are racist
@@sqoerrelwhite europeans have always been racist since ever.
who cares @@sqoerrel
@@sqoerrel Facts don't equal racism. OP never said a single thing to degrade the immigrants, just stated that the way in which Sweden's government has tried to integrate them has failed.
People who cry racism are fucking disgusting and have clearly never encountered real racism. I'm mixed race and I spit in your eye for crying racism when none was present.
@@sqoerrel You are pulling race card in face of same people who were massively pro-immigration. Their opinion started to shift as various problems were rising
The whole EU needs reform
Top to Bottom
needed it befor brexit, we warned them...
F HUMAN RIGHTS…..Why do Europeans want to be replaced???
If You Work on the border in Croatia You would see that 95 % of illegal immigrants are men of the age 16 to 30. Majority of them are captured , procesed and returned. Their Border Patrol are doing good job.
How is it not a good thing? They are work age adults
@@user-pj3zt8zd6w just because someone is work age doesnt mean you want them in your conutry. Most of them would only really be usefull for low skill jobs, almost none fit for the kinds of jobs currently needed
Invading hordes then. If you "migrate" you take women and children with you.
@@user-pj3zt8zd6whow millions of poor uneducated military aged hungry men swarming your streets a good thing? Especially when they have nothing to loose, there’s a reason there’s been so much more crime in the west…
@@user-pj3zt8zd6w You're assuming they would want to work. Spoiler alert they do not.
On a similar note, you can make an episode about Romania's and Bulgaria's failed accession into Schengen and how Austria is vetoing this decision.
As they should romania and bulgarian are two of the most incompetent countries of EU, you can't trust them to secure their borders against illegal immigration
My first guess is rampant human trafficking, crime and corruption.
Completely false on all accounts. The official reason is luck of strong borders and pretending immigrants come through here, but the vast majority don't even pass near our borders. Not to mention that the Schengen doesn't have anything to do with border control, we already have free access to the rest of Europe even as 2nd class citizens. Can't believe the brithplace of one of the world's worst people would be xenophobic.
@@KAMZA.Yes
Finally you said terror attacks instead of just attacks, thank you
@@SigFigNewton would you also call 9/11 an attack instead calling it what it is, a terror attack
@@SigFigNewtonthen don’t commit terror attacks and we won’t call you terrorists 🥰
@@SigFigNewton who ever commint a terror atack, is no human.
@SigFigNewton calling a terror attack a terror attack is dehumanizing? Boy oh boy.
I found out this channel lately, I really enjoy your content. Keep it up! :D
Migration Crisis have caused a rise of far right parties in all European states as nothing ever did. This situation should never really appear, it's destroying our European culture and dividing us. We gotta stay strong. Personally i'm a liberal person but on this single issue i strongly stay opposite way.
European cultures have been destroyed by the industrial revolution
It longer has any meaning
You cant have a strong welfare state when you litterally give out resources to foreigners who contributed nothing to the country before coming in.
Theres no actual social contract at that point. Its just glorified charity.
You accept these people out of PITY and not out of SKILL and wonder why shit ends up bad.
Maybe you will be considering stopping bombing oil rich countries and supporting autocracies first.Then there would not be migrants crises
What! Are you saying you dont just subscribe to one political spectrum or another!
Far right.. like Hitler.. Mussolini.. you consider them Far Right do you?
Thanks for keeping all of us updated on the world :D
The main issue is that when the EU faced its first issues with migrants they just opened the doors and let them all in, and now they cant close them anymore
Ireland had gotten so overwhelmed too. We have a housing crisis. So many homeless on streets already, a big number of that is women and children. But suddenly its an issue now because someone who migrated here is staying in tents and other accommodation. The news preaching how it's a disgrace that they seek asylum here and there in tents and hotel rooms. But Nothing is being said or done or even mentioned ahout the overwhelming numbers of native irish population on the streets.
Wasn't your chancellor saying he'll take all Palestinian inn if he could
@karankapoor2701 Dude it wouldn't surprise me if he did say that haha. Like I'm not against helping. But the government had already previously stated there is no cap on the amount of people they will take in. But when there's such a strain on every service already. From the health dept , especially the housing crisis and cost of living. Its just unfeasible.
@@karankapoor2701 dumkof we have prime minister and that was the scottish minister
@@davidrogers4480 The only way to fix this problem is by only allowing Asylum applications from non EU citizens in the embassies outside of the EU.
99.9% of them use a loophole by applying tor Asylum in the EU knowing perfectly fine that they won't get it and that they are not qualified enough to apply for a job in Europe over the regular ways.
The housing crisis is not because of immigration. It’s because of capitalism. Housing is use as an investment, so when housing prices go down. They stop building until the prices go up again. When housing prices are too high and people don’t want to buy for that price. The higher rents
The mood is turning in Europe, hopefully it’s not too late
It is, most have citizenship already. Big problem with 2nd and 3 generations.
This is irreversible
@@francoispignon7459 trust me, women still have the same problems in Europe.
@@guusgeluk3693 citizenship is just a piece of paper
@@aunnaqvi3133 please dont ever speak again
About a decade to late but better late than never i guess. Genuinely sick of this bs.
*too
Just wait when countries all over Africa and the Middle East continue to collapse. Europe should militarize its external borders now!
be longer than a decade be 20 years
There in no EU crisis, only crisis are in countries who allow the crisis to happen.
When Germany or France or Sweden will be fed up with it and they will become serious about solving it, it will be solved real quick.
europeans slaughtering every non european thing they can find? but they dont have thousands of years of history doing that already... wait... you guys never stopped doing that and got so greedy that you made it impossible for your own people to even have children without the strong possibility of being forced to watch them starve to death or forcing them to watch you starve to death.
Those are EU countries and the EU is demanding insane poliicies. Forced migration into the UK is a major reason that they left.
It could be solved quickly if the people who came (and their families), didn't have the right to vote and be voted and work in the public sector (especially government, police and military force). Since many of them now have these rights, it is over. Giving citizenship so easily, without waiting for these people to completely integrate, was a very bad idea.
If they don't feel Europeans, but their/their parents nationality/religion play a bigger role, Europe will be destroyed from within. The Israel-Palestine is a great example on this, a crisis away from Europe is brought in European cities because of all these people.
People are fed up with it but the government is lackadaisical.
Are we forgetting countries like spain, greece or Italy that don't even have the luxury to say "yes" or not ?
Europe forgot quality over quantity in regards to cultures of people when it comes to immigration.
Exactly.
It used to be only the most talented and skilled.
Now its just any illiterate medeival villager from your local third world shithole, that just gets imported in mass numbers to turn the place they just immigrated to, into the shithole they escaped from.
Fuck these people. Fuck all of them.
I say this as a guy born from immigrant parents too.
Third world countries are shitholes because of the people that live there.
Thats why you only allow the best and brightest to immigrate.
Its all gone to hell honestly. I feel uniquely in a position to say this without being labelled "racist" by some redditor whos only care in the world, is looking progressive to other countries.
Both.@@SigFigNewton
That's Nazi talk
thank you for this important content
This is literally first I heard that the relocation only goes FROM frontier countries to non-frontier ones. No one else bothered to mention this detail.
In which case I suspect something's wacky with the official definition of a frontier country (considering the amount of time our media and politicians devote to the issue, and complain about the pact) - Poland is literally on the eastern frontier.
Also the pact will do nothing to discourage irregular migration, it will only encourage more because their processing and housing will be spread across many countries.
(And comparing amounts of asylum seekers and work visas is disingenous at best - Polish work visas were given mostly to two groups, Russians/Ukrainians, or Asians (Vietnamese, Filipino etc. - neither of which is a source of asylum seekers)
polish visas were given out for money and bl0wj0bs. Same story in italy where "immaculate" policemen and carabinieri will pull out their c0cks literally in front of asylum seekers. Or pay their new Alfa Romeo with the bribes they impose on people running from misery and injustice.
"Poland is literally on the eastern frontier." AFAIR the relocations only southern countries as frontier, they also do not count Ukrainian refugees and such as migrants the country has taken. So Poland would still get fined for refusing relocations even while accepting Ukrainian refugees.
@@petris7 that would explain why Polish politicians are so against the relocation rules. Because seriously that is wacky that you only consider one border....
@@katm9877 I recall some of them saying that they'd be fine with the relocations if Ukrainian refugees would count as accepted migrants too.
What kind of a group is russians/Ukrainians? How many russians did Poland take lately?
Imagine someone you don't know comes into your home illegally, then hands you a request to stay. When you call the cops to have them leave or be removed your neighbor calls you racist and ungrateful for their presence.
palestine-israel in a nutshell
Stop invading, bombing and creating civil wars in their countries, problem solved.
@@andrevictor9665 sunnis and shiites don't need anyone's help to kill each other.
Stop blaming the west even for that.
The third world is too lazy to fix themselves, too stupid to know what should be done and too uneducated to stop breeding like bunnies to kids they can't feed.
And many Russians are having extremely hard time even getting a visa
Here is what i feel is missed in 90% of immigration discussions. people take stances of 'pro immigration' or 'anti immigration' when the reality is that migration is a constant part of state policy and absolutely needed... but also unsystematic and poorly managed migration is a disaster for all involved. And that's what I feel gets lost in these 'pro/anti' discussions: the question is not if we need immigration or not the question is how do we want to manage and integrate it into the rest of policy. As long as we don't have answers to that the rest is just angry noise.
Exactly! Unfortunately, balanced and complex neither give clicks to news articles nor do they win elections.
because only rich people could afford it. credit was not a thing for ordinary people so the financing of trafficking fees didnt exist like it does now.@@Besthinktwice
@@jonathanodude6660 Lol. There were like waves into USA and also some Western people like the Irish, Finnish, Italians were thought to be dirty, prone to violence etc useless shit because some skull measurer said so.
@@Besthinktwice In the Victorian era getting to the UK was also something that less than 1% of the population could afford. Times have changed to be fair 😉
It goes deeper. Because it's just another sign of the system in general not working. Nothing works, and our entire civilization is collapsing around us.
this is a deeply problematic situation which is very very hard to find an easy and humane solution. there's the issue of the people seeking asylum and their human rights. to reject their right of freedom, safety and stability is to completely shut your empathy for another human. it is a true humanitarian crisis. however the large influx of migrants in countries creates issues as well. many countries aree not prepared to receive this amount of migrants. and in the end of the day people worldwide should care about all the conflicts happening around the world and EU should promote peace worldwide. Libya is an example of the interferance of europe and america, which now turned libya into a route for migrants into europe. all the conflicts that happen worldwide can affect europe in the end of the day, therefore global peace is a necessity so people do not need to migrate anywhere in the first place. the poverty of other countries, the instability of other countries, the calamities that affect other countries should be a concern for everyone globally. the media in the west tends to downplay or not give enough cover or relevance to conflicts happening far away. and thats where the problem starts.
It so odd to me that only military aged men are the ones seeking asylum, no children, no women, no elderly. Just men.
Its not anyones "human right" to barge into another persons home. This whole notion is silly.
The EU needs skilled labor. Having an increasing supply of people who don't speak good English and/or cannot learn the native language of their new country fluently, and who don't have good enough skills and qualifications to work in high-skill sectors, are really hard to integrate into countries that have high productivity labor force with highly paid jobs. There is a definite limit of jobs that can be created in relatively low-skill sectors. The whole thing is unsustainable in the long run and there needs to be comprehensive immigration reform where all EU immigrants come from legal ways from non-EU countries. That means we have to get rid of the right to apply for asylum inside the EU for immigration that is not work-related. That would free lots of resources for work-related immigration and would be better for everyone. EU citizenship should also be something that you need to earn, not something you get only for staying in the country long enough. You should need to show you have integrated without larger hiccups, which means there needs to be straight work and crime history for everyone who is allowed to become an EU citizen.
No
Absolutely
In the long run? In the long run, they become more and more European.
NO! If you need skilled labor, educate your own people. To go the easy way and just get in foreigners who do NOT integrate worsens the problem to the extreme. Germany risks getting fascist again because of it. I have many foreign colleagues who are nice, diligent likable. But they do not integrate into democracy and law and order and free market capitalism. They don't actively operate against Germany but passively oppose our country, but expressively enjoy our freedom and social security.
I agree but as a legal skilled immigrant I am afraid that this reforms will evolve to be anti-foreginer.
Its not a crises. It could be stopped any time. Politicians want immigration.
Yes.
They forgot about belarussain - poland border and non stop migrants pressure organized by Russia and Belarus to engage part of poland military in border defense.
9:39 I love how 3 out of 5 mics are from Georgian news media 😂
Great content :). And thank you for mentioning my video in both the video and description :)
What can we say - it's a great video!
Could you do a collaboration on the CFA franc, EU should start immigration policy by dismantling its colonial past.
Great channel
Can you make a video in collaboration with Kurzgesagt.
Yours is one of the most abrasively racist channels I've ever seen without overtly xenophobe symbology attached on the front cover. But as I read the comment section I think maybe the blue flag with stars has become just that. And maybe besides the feel-good vibe the TLDR lads don't do much to distance themselves from the hate
So funny seeing EU struggle with something that was an obvious issue before it even started 😂
And it's even funnier when we see they are the major cause to begin with!
Not true for Hungary in either case. We locked the border down back in 2015, and we never colonized foreign countries like the UK or France.
Have a trip down to Subotica, my dear friend :D@@apokalypthoapokalypsys9573
@@apokalypthoapokalypsys9573 yet you still cling to the hope that you might one day steal parts of our countries again. Curious.
@@apokalypthoapokalypsys9573 Got nothing to do with colonisation, you tool. All people get conquered. That's not an excuse to illegally enter another nation. If that were the case, half of Europe would be allowed to enter Hungary freely.
Its called invasion.
My issue is rewarding those who circumvent the proper ways and steal the resources meant for actual refugees fleeing for good reasons.
"Refugees fleeing for good reason" is a slippery slope. That technically says that hundreds of millions in India qualifies as economic refugees. Should Europe accept an influx of people that will outnumber them?
@@hentype the "good reasons" typically means actual refugees like those fleeing war and genocide, not people who move for money and free welfare.
@@SigFigNewton Im sorry but migrant work force wont save us...
EU must invest in its own population by that i mean make life easier not harder, if that happens maybe babies will start popping up . Having families is the stepping stone to a strong country. The problem is that we have been waging wars on families since the 2000 at least in my shithole.
Bringing "Migrants" from the end of the world some of them couldn't live with animals is not the solution.
@@SigFigNewton I cant even have kids mister... How am i gona build a family if i cant have a stable life ? My life is literally on standby..
lol Eurpeans talking about "stealing resources"
lol
I am so tired of hearing the excuse "human rights abuses" whenever someone doesn't want immigration. So many kind people have been taken advantage of and now when pushback grows, we are of course "abusing human rights" What about our rights to live and keep our countries for ourselves
But simultaneously its fine to allow Eurpoean corporations to exploit the regions that migrants originate from, to worsen the living conditions in the name of profit? Either you have affordable goods made with slave labor and accept the responsibility when the exploited people come knocking looking for a better life, or you don't.
You can't have your cake and eat it
And wtf were yall doing in the middle east and northern Africa. You think they didn't want their country for themself. Stfu and suffer for what ur people did. I don't care if the people who started it are underground now. Should've thought it through before going into people's lands. Now you get enjoy the consequences.
"Human Rights abuses" is a misused term when it refers to the sense of entitlement to Force Entry & Settlement, and the expectation of every European country to be a doormat to uncontrollable numbers. Look how the most bleedingly obvious common sense turned out to be true in the US, when Forced Entry & Settlement was enabled, by being a total doormat.
The sancuary cities went from pure blissful, feel-good policy to being slammed by hard reality really quick.
3rd worlders having acess to your country and the culture that produces a high standard of living Is a human right, its writen here on the UN charter of Bullshit. Its okay once these refugees exhaust your society they'll leave to another develope nation and exhaust that country.
and make sure to worship the ground they tread on. Remember colonialism. You're gonna have have to pay the price for the sins of dead men.
A right to keep you country for yourself? That's not a thing
Thankfully Ireland is not part of Schengen, also as a separate island from the European mainland, it dramatically reduces immigration except those that are sought after.
@@Besthinktwicethe irish in america came legally, stopped at a legal port of entry, and accepted the culture and laws of the country they moved to.
Also many Irish went to America to flee the Famine during the 1840s, a legitimate reason to flee and the US had plenty of living space for the new residents who importantly integrated
How the big tech is treating you guys? they also creating a housing crisis over there from what I’ve heard
what is your problem with Irish in every comment
@@Besthinktwice
@@weird-guy The housing crisis was as a result of mismanagement by governments in being too strict to build. Not really due to a high influx of migrants though that is a contributing factor. Big tech and pharmaceutical companies do employ many people but of course this is centred around the several cities, but Dublin of course in particular.
I love how Kalinningrad oblast is an EU protectorate on your maps.
Send them back. Thats the only way to stop the smugglers just as Australia did.
When it goes from a guaranteed entry to a guaranteed rejection then no one will pay them amymore.
@@Besthinktwice Esu has tried to do it for a while now. Countries like Poland and Hungary has vetoed it.
Maybe try stop intervening on their homeland's politics and funding war?
@@Ezhil-dq8op Where has Sweden done that? Germany? Norway? Denmark? Italy? Stop blaming all of Europe for what the US and UK does
@@Ezhil-dq8op Most don't come from war torn countries lol. Besides when they cross 10 peaceful countries to go to the richest one they are not refugees.
@@Ezhil-dq8op Russia is intervening on their homeland's politics and funding wars. But the migrants still go to the west. To the wealth you love. Created by the freedom you hate.
Reality is, after the original settlers stock in the US (British isles inc Ireland), later immigrants were specifically picked because of their close ties to northern European culture with Belgium, Netherlands, German, France & Sweden. It was only after than they opened up to counties like Spain, Italy, Greece, Poland and the rest Europe with quotas. After that the US opened up to more foreign cultures, why would they do this? Cultural assimilation, something Europe has failed with massively with uncontrolled immigration from everywhere under the guise of 'blank slate' idealism.
Bullshit, there is cultural assimilation, in one generation most of them become europeans.
Which was the US' best period.@@Besthinktwice
No, they'll never become Europeans. Their DNA doesn't magically change.@@darioildiario3001
@@aristocraticrebel Best time for white men* I'm sure the black guy who got lynched for opening a business or the white women who was brutalized by her husband was having a great time.
The quotas were also placed because of sudden huge waves of immigration. Immigration rates were low of US history but in the mid to late 19th century there was a lot of upheaval in Eastern Europe including tons of pogroms against people like the Jews and countries like Russia essentially tried to expel all their Jews which coupled with war and other things led to huge waves of Slavs and Jews trying to move to the US. At the same time the US was pretty much finishing up the last of their homesteading so the "frontier" was mostly settled and they didnt have anywhere to send those immigrants like they had in the 16th, 17th, 18th, and early 19th centuries. The factories needed labor, true, but not in the kinds of numbers that were arriving especially since the US was leaning more and more towards automation in factories. Those quotes were also set in place to discourage uneducated, unskilled laborers which were the vast majority then as like now. Europe could use some unskilled labor but they're going more and more towards efficient use of labor, automating as much as possible, so they dont need thousands working on assembly lines or working on farms and mines and what they want is educated immigrants.
No matter the time period tons of foreigners moving into a country that are of a different culture, language, religion, and ethnicity who are also uneducated and lack useful skills are a destabilizing influence which is why even in centuries past and even in the pre-modern era were often restricted and controlled. In the middle ages for example you'd often need to pay some kind of fee or fine to move to another country and may face expulsion if you destabilize the country. If there isnt work that only makes things worse for the migrants and the host country as that leads to conflict from the local people that are losing jobs and if the migrants dont have jobs they're more likely to cause political agitation.
I like that youtube now updates the number of likes and views without someone having to reload the page
wasn't worth getting rid of the dislike button though
You love Javascript. Cambridge Analytica and the NSA do too.
Well, never saw that one coming!
Why the heck is Kaliningrad illustrated as part of Schengen? Is that right? I don't think that's right.
It's obviously not.
EU countries should mind their business in other countries' affairs especially the UK, France, and others who are the main problem. Leave West Africa alone, leave North Africa alone, and others. Maybe they will stop coming.
Yeah, Sudan is doing great, right?
@@bambina5604Well then people wont blame us and use guild as an argument.
FORGET what the politicians want and implement what the PEOPLE want !!!!!!
Some people want high immigration / cheap labour.
@@uanime11%
@@Doge811less than that
@@uanime1Maybe those people should just open a sweatshop in some third world country? It would be simpler.
@@gonzalomcampos Some people just have compassion for asylum seekers.
4:39 Malta is a frontier country too. However I have not heard that much lately of immigrant artivals.
Nice video!
Schengen is not just visa free, but border check free. Romanians and Bulgarians can travel without a visa in the Schengen area despite not being Schengen countries, but are subject to border checks e.g. showing IDs when crossing the Schengen border.
A good point. Many eurodreamers confuse "The Freedom of Movement" with the truly free movement within the Schengen zone. Practically in Europe, it is either the Schengen border, or a national border.
I strongly belive in fact that most people disagree that its healthy when you replace your own nation with other in the name of profit of some companies that need slaves on lowest possible wages from poorest and lowest educated countries. You can call it whatever you like, it's also not the way to 'fix' demographic problems by putting millions of people inside Europe. Same as it's not help for them in most cases. If you really care for them then you should be against that as well. Because living in worst part of 'random huge european city' with low wages, lack of work due to sad truth- lack of education and skills of majority of those people (I know you will call me racist, whatever, that's the truth ), growing up with violence and poverty for most of them. Then they got mistreated and used by natives, they have problems with language or work, live among crime, frustration grows easily as you can see it all across Europe.
And they childrens sadly grow up in that environment, a lot of them turn to crime or literal hate toward the country they were born and grow up in. And they love Algieria or Morocco but want to burn France or Belgium cause they hate their unlucky fate. It's already proven and in sight that mass, unhealthy immigration didn't work and don't work.
And one more sad fact, europeans don't own them anything. We don't need to help them and yet we do, but it needs to be done different. I don't want another ethnic war when french, brit, german, polish, italian nationalists might start another revolution cause they don't want X nation in their home. Cause all it's needed is unhappy people, some crisis and a spark in the name of some left/right wing govt who will be willing to 'clean up mess' with some enemy they might find. Cause people never change.
..."we Europeans don't owe them anything".
Are you actually kidding me right noe
We don’t, not our generation anymore, and they are killing with guns in the EU on the regular at this point
@AmeenRidwan And what is your point ? Am I or is my nation responsible for millions of people having worse rng in life? We are here to talk and share thoughts after all without closing our minds. Yes I don't think random Ryan from England, Marco from Serbia or Michael from germany is living his life to sponsor and keep afloat family of 4 from Syria when a lot of people barely go by with rent. When people feel unsafe you like it or not, when losing identity that was here for centuries feels bad. Yes we live better and we are more lucky. But life isn't fair. And we work for it as our families did. That's why I would completly support help in african/middle east countries. Immigration on mass do not help anyone.
@@AmeenRidwan bruh we don't keep crying that's like saying Genghis khans descendents owe China or Italians owe the French for the conquest of gaul or Greece owes persia for Alexander's conquest
Fact of the matter is Europe is importing millions of illiterate low iq medeival villagers, and then crying when housing, benefits, and the rest, end up drying up.
Import the third world, become the third world. Immigration is good when their not third worlders.
the funny thing is at the last part when politician is speaking, 5 microphones shown are of Georgian TV channels 😀
Cyprus and Malt are also EU Member States and are under a lot of pressure as EU external boarders
Poland is also dealing with illegal migration as a political attack from Belarus (which is angry about sanctions). Nicaragua has also picked up on this idea of using migration as a way to politically attack a country you are in conflict with (again over sanctions) and is chartering hundreds of flights from Cuba and Haiti full of migrants that it then sends north.
We let to much turk in germany and belgium.
I have an honest question because it makes me curious, I notice that when they make these videos they refer a lot to refugees and muslims but I know that a lot of latinamericans chose to study/work in Europe (I'm venezuelan and my own parents studied their PHDs in Spain) so if you're european from the EU, do you put latinamericans in the same sac as war refugees/middle easterns or is there a difference because of an easier integration due to more values in common? (If you answer please be polite)
Latin Americans can probably integrate a lot better
They do integrate a lot better overalo. No question, they are a bit more "Lazy" and "Unproductive" tho. But it's they will more easely adapt to european values.
There's a big problem with the housing in Berlin, probably in other cities too. Now it's hard to get an apartment, so people originally from here are very upset. You can't let everybody in just like that! Eventually this will lead to the destruction of EU, and if that happened, we'd be saying goodbye and leaving for a SAFE continent. Adios EU.
So its not racist when countries in the middle east wont let immigrants from other countries in the middle east in their country
We in Poland easily coped with the influx of immigrants from Belarus, why can't Italy act as well as we do?
Because you can't build a fence in the sea.
With your new government I doubt things will be good lmao
look at how many belarusians immigrants there were vs african irregular immigrants bro
@gior987 I am not entirely sure what do You mean but in case I guessed right: W have African and Far East migrants on border with Belarus. And some Belarusian migrants too that get processed via normal government channels.
Because we are tired of taking African immigrants due to other countries fucking their homeland up. Poland has always been eurosceptic, so dont lecture others plz
After what happened at the cologne train station on New Year’s Eve in 2015, I can’t blame Europeans for wanting these migrants gone. I have read stories of women in Germany talking about how they have migrants sexually harassing them on the street, and how many people have lost faith in the EU.
As an Australian, I used to look at the government with disappointment at their operation of detention centres on Nauru and Christmas Island, but now I understand what purpose it served.
This isn’t an issue born out of hatred for migrants, it’s an issue regarding religion and culture, and the allocation of money. Western culture and Islamist culture do not mix, and many governments prioritise giving financial support to migrants instead of their own citizens, and mention homeless veterans, and how they need to wait up to 1 year to get their veterans benefits, while migrants that give birth in places like the USA immediately get access to healthcare and financial support.
Up until this point, anyone against taking in refugees was considered “racist”, but now people are starting to realise they were right all along.
I don’t understand how German government could turn blind eye on the Cologne incident and start letting illegal immigrants still come in.
@@yulyaart6515 They can turn a blind eye because they're seen as future voters
And that wasn't anything to do with the EU...
This is bullshit. Even though Poland bears the burden of accepting refugees from Ukraine in larger numbers than emigrants from Africa, it is not considered a "frontier" country. We have dealt with over the milion people in last year so well that this problem was practically not felt at all in Western Europe, so no one there now cares about Ukrainians and that direction of immigration. And now we are being punished for this when countries that are much richer than Poland are trying to extort tribute from us for the immigrants they cannot cope with at other borders. Let's be serious. Every endurance has its limits.
Good. Poland is a big part of the war in region
I would happily have my country take on Ukrainians and help as much as possible. But my government is more concerned about taking care of Muslims instead of Europeans.
Meloni is the biggest fraud of them all. Never seem someone do a 180 so fast
just usual politician.
A Tony Blair loving "fascist". Utterly laughable.
@@rizkyadiyanto7922 yeah. As an American living in a very liberal area with a thriving gay community it was kind of hilarious seeing how many Democrats in the 90s and 2000s went from either refusing to weigh in on gay marriage or even opposing it to waving rainbow flags in a matter of a few years. There were some who even went from opposing gay marriage and saying only domestic partnerships should be allowed to pushing for gay marriage from 1 election to the next. Even icons like the Clintons went back and admitted their LGBTQ+ policies were terrible in the past in order to try and curry favor today. Many did hard 180s once the party line changed.
Yeah not so easy to stop them when you can do basically nothing and tons in the EU and at home work against you.
You didn't listen what the opposition wanted....... Basically taking everyone in.
An European strong solution is needed with different rules not single presidents. (how the hell can you stop them if you are forced to save them, you cannot have agreements and you have even to free them after some time, also the judges clearly opposed the government) more like either things change or people will look for someone that doesn't care about rules.....
She's just a fascist mate. They aren't known for being clever of for doing real work beside pocketing money while pouring kerosene on the hate and turning every problem into a worse problem for as long as they can keep the farce going.
Look it seems like we really need to invest heavily into effective immigration. Europe has 2 problems that are only getting worse. Obviously this, but also we are dealing with a pretty big lack of workforce especially with our aging populations.
Immigration is an incredibly nuanced topic with so many different values to balance. O really wish the political discussion would stop being immigrant good or immigrant bad. What we should be discussing is how immigrant best.
You guys talking about EU's "capacity" do realize that the highest yearly flux we've ever had is 0.15% of the european population, right? Or that even Italy has never seen 0.3% of its newly acquired population yearly being migrants... If the housing prices go up in London you should probably look more at the wealthy acquiring buildings as investment and keeping them empty in London, Milan, Rome, Lisbon, Bruxelles... At AirBnB millionaires who have found a simpler source of profit than hotels by making the city center inaccessible to anyone except tourists wealthier than you are. At thirty freaking years since the last time any EU politician has made anything to make schools and hospitals more accessible...
6:00 Maybe you should mention at that point (and to not skew the picture) that Poland has had a population where immigrants only made up 1%, whereas in France on Germany immigrants make up around 15%...!
I think Europe needs to be less concerned about the 'humans rights' of these overseas and more concerned about creating a better life for it's own people. And yes, that means no longer getting involved in greedy American wars that keep the third world a shithole to begin with.
Spot on
You don't think people being raped, tortured and kidnapped into forced labor is a problem? I agree about not participating in imperialist wars, but the rest of your statement boils down to ignoring human suffering just because you don't want to see it.
@@Theorimlig the mandate of a state is to look after its own citizens. Nothing more
Then maybe Europe should supporting the apartheid state trying to displace 2.2 million native people and eventually a total of 7 million native people. And after that it will start wars with its neighbours to create even more refugees.
@@danieldelaney1377So you would ignore the Holocaust cos the influx of refugees would be a strain?
8:51 Wait a second, how is Poland not considered a frontier country? Poland is literally the eastern frontier of the EU
Geographically speaking, yes, it is.
But using the same measurements it also applies to Ireland (which is a part of the North-West frontier)
The core difference here is the countries that border "the frointier".
In case of Ireland, there's only UK.
In case of Poland, there're Ukraine and Belarus (maybe only Ukraine, I am not sure about whether Poland closed its border with Belarus)
In case of Spain and Italy, there're African and Middle East countries.
Surely, Ukrainians are not the most desirable people on the planet, however they fit much-much better into the EU society than, for instance, arabs (do you remember any shit similar to what arabs regulary do in the European cities done by Ukrainians? Looting? Shooting?).
Want to mention that I'm definitely not a racist, but there's an obvious issue with those migrants from the South...
It's only frontier if there are brown people on the other side. White neighbors are considered "acceptable". Europe is racist, surprise!
@@user-li4vy8mp9o It's kind of depressing how people always try to make it a race issue when it isnt. Like in the US even many of those furthest to the right dont typically oppose all immigration or only want to stop immigration from non-White countries, they typically just want to stop illegal immigration and mainly as it pertains to Latin America where most of the crime, drugs, and foreign guns come from and they rarely if ever even mention slowing or stopping immigration from Asia. If it were a racial issue they'd oppose immigration from all non white countries, if it were a xenophobic/isolationist issue they'd oppose all immigration, but it's more about crime and people coming from Vietnam, Thailand, Japan, or Korea are rarely if ever bringing drugs or crime with them. Whereas the Mexican border looks more like a warzone than anything and its night and day if you ever go to Canada and cross the border there. Similar story with Arab immigrants in Europe: you rarely hear of Americans going to Europe and killing people so immigration from there isnt an issue, same goes for immigration from Asia, but with the Arab world it becomes an issue specifically because of the war and crime they bring with them.
@@user-li4vy8mp9o By which point, both Ireland and Poland should be considered frontier countries, just very much lower on the illegal immigration/asylum seeker intake. It's easily balanced by just making even frontier countries still have a quota, that simply gets readjusted as their illegal immigration/asylum seeker rates rise/fall.
@@user-li4vy8mp9o In case of Belarus, their dictator is waging a hybrid warfare by dumping some aggressive invaders... uhm... migrants at our border. So yes, thanks to him we clearly are a frontier country.
You completely left out Serbia (a non-EU country that's key in the Balkan migrant route) which get threatened by EU if not letting migrants trough to Hungary and Croatia. EU wants them in and that's the biggest problem.
To come to Serbia, migrants first have to enter in EU countries. So, the question is how they passed through those EU countries
@@duki995 True I was just pointing out he left out a country that's a part of the Balkan route.
@@petemitchell9996 Sorry, sorry, didn’t understand 😉
well explained
This is part of the reason why I didn't want to go to Europe. If you aren't part of their club, Europeans will always see you as less than human. It doesn't matter how much you suck up to them. So I think most immigrants would actually be better off going to North America if they have the chance and can pull it off logistically.
Lol...
Those massive migrations aleays happened in human history. The original european population was almost entirely replaced by indo europeans some thousand years ago.
.Difference is now we have clear notions of nation, state and many ethnic nationalisms.
As Polish citizen I would just clarify on 800k "work visa issued" by Poland.
In our system "work visa" means "work permit" and it doesn't replace Visa at all. It is a first step towards getting a Visa as a migrants have to justify reason to come - turism, work, studing, etc.
If someone got "work permit" it doesn't mean they are phisically in Poland/EU nor allowed to enter, but it means they are more likely to get a polish Visa once they submit a request.
Some of those requests will be rejected, some accepted. Many of them comes from Ukraine as Poland took a great number of Ukrainian refugees.
And It's odd to me that orher EU countires don't issue that many "work permits". The best way to get along with migrants is to work with them :>
Cheers to all!
I just love how Poland handles all issues and is actually much more farsighted than most eu countries that just seem to be screwing themselves up by their own hands. To control immigrations rules have to be in place, you cannot just be taking whoever. Why should all these people be causing threats to the locals who had built those couturiers?
Interesting. So it's like a pre-screening before they make the visa application? Sounds smart.
My spirit will rise from the grave, and the world will know I was right.
Historical speaking, a mass increase of immigration of a different language, culture, religious, etc... just different overall from the existing population, always causes conflict and harm unification. The uprising and protests from immigrants based off what happened to Israel is an example. Unfortunately, you doomed your country to be forever divided.
Immigration is one of if not the biggest reason to Europe’s shifting to the populist and far right. I think there needs to be a honest discussion on how immigration is affecting everyone.
Honest discussion:
It doesn’t matter how left or right wing you are, it doesn’t matter how tolerant and woke you claim to be, nobody likes endless waves of uneducated and disrespectful African and Middle Eastern migrants pouring into their nation. The majority aren’t even refugees, they’re technically economic migrants. If nothing is done in the present then a harsher approach will most definitely be taken in the future as the crisis grows and as tolerance wanes. I hope it never comes to that.
If the people sit in silent tolerance and governments sit in silent ignorance then this pressure will only build. Eventually the tolerance will wear out and the issue will grow to the point governments can no longer be blissfully ignorant. I hope it never builds to that point. It’s better to fix the borders now and deal with demographics shifting sooner to stop the extreme measures that will be taken later if nothing is done.
Empty powerless threats
@@okakokakiev787 like Jihad?
@okakokakiev787 Well don't cry when it happens eventually. Salut to you. When people rise up and fight, better hide.
@@SuperJibulus "jihad" (whatever that means) was invented and paid by the West
20 000€ is almost 4x more than my mother retirement pension over year , she live and work whole her life in Poland - and she isn’t only person in Poland who cannot answer why foreigners will cost polish gov more than own population. And this suppose to be punishment for not accepting migrants who want to live in Germany or France? How this suppose to be fair?
My country spends 22 billion a year on refugees and immigrants. Our own population can't afford housing. 2/3 of people on welfare are immigrants not even counting people who are not Dutch but they were born here and are counted like dutch. It's a sick fuckint world man.
Actually it wasn't really a hot issue in The Netherlands (except from bad governance, slow bureaucracy and budget cuts). Mark Rutte brought down the government for tactics, because every public service broke, poverty and inequality got worse than ever and there are elections in November. He used it as a scapegoat to save his own name and the party's name.
I know it was just a minor part of the video, you explained it very well! And all I can think of is: I'm so lucky and glad I've never had to flee my house to end up in this political shit show
kinda true, it still is a hot issue since it directly affects the main problem, the housing shortages!!! refugees get priority subsidised housing, just look at how long the waiting lists have gotten now.
exactly, according to Mark Rutte "study migrants" and Dutch students are even bankrupting the economy because they take out a 2000 euros loan per year to pay tuition fees; but 2 million euros (tax payer money) going into Shell is no problem
@@ysbrandd4908 but to be fair, that is such a small group of people, while the government released so many social houses into the free market and it didn't provide enough houses for starters. You can't blame the maybe tens of thousands immigrants in the past few years that there's a housing shortage of hundreds of thousands. Btw: this saturday housing protest in The Hague!! You should come!
@@MaxVersace On average 1000 new arrivals per week * 52 weeks * let's say 5 years = 260,000. This is not a problem to you in terms of integration and assimilation into society?
Round em up
Libyan parents at the beach: "Don't swim out to much children or the Germans will pick you up." 🤣
Controlled migration is good for a country, let in the people who are most likely to integrate and contribute to your country
Mass deportation, adjusting wages for cost of living costs and encouraging native births seem to be the solution.
Why is Romania highlighted in yellow in all chapters of the video and there's absolutely no word pronounced about Romania?
4:40 - So now Kaliningrad is in the Schengen area?
Send them to Saudi Arabia and their oil rich neighbours. They don't know what to do with all their cash anyway while the EU is struggling.
Send Israelis back to europe and maybe rich gulf countries might consider it😂😂
Fax