Metal Musician Reacts to MODERN Rock

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 1,8 тыс.

  • @NikNocturnal
    @NikNocturnal  3 года назад +3404

    *Metal is heavier than rock*
    Smash like so we can all become elements on the periodic table

  • @LP004
    @LP004 3 года назад +3834

    Basically anything with guitars but considered too soft for metal

    • @centralia83
      @centralia83 3 года назад +19

      Makes sense lol.

    • @TheErazar
      @TheErazar 3 года назад +2

      This but the other way around.

    • @AM-eg2kw
      @AM-eg2kw 3 года назад +22

      @Call Me, BLEGH Me, If You Wanna Reach Me I don't think anyone calls ID rock? At most they're called alt-rock, which is already a very loose genre to begin with

    • @akaededeval374
      @akaededeval374 3 года назад +30

      More like, basically anything considered slightly edgier than any pop tune

    • @ShadowFlame420
      @ShadowFlame420 3 года назад

      lol gonna delete my comment now

  • @LucentBlack
    @LucentBlack 3 года назад +950

    At the end of the day, if a song sounds good to you then it is good.
    Doesnt matter if it sounds exactly like old rock/metal or really modern.

    • @foolishxhero
      @foolishxhero 2 года назад +25

      yeah it heavily depends on personal taste

    • @Blackmoonsoulx
      @Blackmoonsoulx 2 года назад +3

      Agree!

    • @purplealien9604
      @purplealien9604 2 года назад +32

      I absolutely agree, because music taste is subjective. But on the other hand it should be placed in correct genres so it's easier to find what you are in the mood to listen to.

    • @ether2275
      @ether2275 2 года назад +4

      Good music is good music

    • @noelvaldez96
      @noelvaldez96 2 года назад

      Exactly.

  • @Will-wx3lb
    @Will-wx3lb 3 года назад +3411

    I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again,
    Trying to understand everyone’s terminology for metal/rock is like learning quantum mechanics.

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  3 года назад +339

      Yes, math scary

    • @tevildo9383
      @tevildo9383 3 года назад +120

      “If you think you understand quantum mechanics, you don’t understand quantum mechanics.”
      -Richard Feynman

    • @chasechilders3672
      @chasechilders3672 3 года назад +49

      I mean at least quantum mechanics has definitive answers. There's just no understanding music genre terminology.

    • @f67739
      @f67739 3 года назад +13

      state of music education in NA

    • @cius2112
      @cius2112 2 года назад +11

      @@chasechilders3672 naw its actually super simple. Metal is a subgenre of Rock. So by definition it is Rock.

  • @paxtongerhart6863
    @paxtongerhart6863 3 года назад +221

    As a person who will listen to pretty much anything that sounds good, I like how diverse rock has become. There is something for everyone, and that’s great.

    • @paxtongerhart6863
      @paxtongerhart6863 2 года назад +6

      @@Azrayl that’s fine that you think that, but one mans trash buddy

    • @man4437
      @man4437 2 года назад +6

      @Arachebae Honestly as someone who likes a wide variety of music, I don't listen to any rock past the 2000s. Or really before the 80s, but for different reasons. Rock music nowadays is admittedly fairly stale and bands are using pop elements to get something new to it, while rock that's older is just not for me. I mostly listen to rap, extreme metal, experimental rock and electronic experimental music

    • @paxtongerhart6863
      @paxtongerhart6863 2 года назад +5

      @@man4437 that’s a fair assessment, and I can get behind that opinion. But I’ve always had a rule when listening to new music. It’s called the 3 pros rule. I listen to an album from an artist, and if I can’t find 3 things in the album that I like, I feel fair saying I don’t like it. I’ve found a lot of music that I like that I previously would’ve wrote off.

    • @laurachiriac1336
      @laurachiriac1336 2 года назад +4

      ​@@paxtongerhart6863 Good point. I listen to all kinds of stuff too. And I also have a rule where I listen to like 10 songs of an artist I dont exactly like from different albums/eras/years to see if I actually enjoy something. If I dont, well, maybe it really isnt for me, but to be honest I almost always find at least one song/sound they go for thats kinda good.​

    • @paxtongerhart6863
      @paxtongerhart6863 2 года назад +2

      @@laurachiriac1336 yeah there’s very few artists that I entirely dislike. There’s usually at least one or two songs that I like

  • @Jimmy-dw7uz
    @Jimmy-dw7uz 3 года назад +6796

    there are so many rap fans who call anything with a guitar "rock"

    • @djentyboi6878
      @djentyboi6878 3 года назад +723

      And I hate it

    • @hxlaspxwn
      @hxlaspxwn 3 года назад +271

      im 100% convinced its normies who labeled modern "rock", this stuff is for SURE metal

    • @gustavofring4363
      @gustavofring4363 3 года назад +338

      @Call Me, BLEGH Me, If You Wanna Reach Me I don't think he shat on rap at all. He's just stating how rap people call anything with guitar rock. And tbh I think he's kinda right. Cause all the rap kids are the ones stuck on one genre and these pop ones listen to anything the media tells them to lol

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  3 года назад +922

      But guitars are made out of wood

    • @indrarasmana3782
      @indrarasmana3782 3 года назад +33

      @@NikNocturnal Dad joke
      Peace

  • @wewantthecup
    @wewantthecup 3 года назад +81

    I know Muse has lots of pop and electronic elements, but if you have ever seen them live, you'd conclude that they are ultimately a rock band.

    • @aaronszyszkoofficial4776
      @aaronszyszkoofficial4776 2 года назад +6

      Even The 2nd Law and Simulation Theory still very much had good amounts of pure alt rock and pop rock

  • @ramiropalacios7660
    @ramiropalacios7660 3 года назад +26

    You should try The Warning. They are 3 mexican sisters doing hard rock and it sounds so cool. It's a little bit radio friendly but still good. I personally recommend the new ep, specifically the song named Z or the one named Animosity.

  • @sponthemon
    @sponthemon 3 года назад +761

    Rock is like a schrödingers cat, it's rock and isn't rock at the same time

    • @jaygage1555
      @jaygage1555 2 года назад +9

      Perfect analogy actually lol

    • @AnonyMous-jf4lc
      @AnonyMous-jf4lc 2 года назад +3

      That would only apply until you listen to it. At that point the state is known, and it's crap.

  • @ptr_does_music7042
    @ptr_does_music7042 3 года назад +72

    I'm pretty fine with the fact that this playlist contains many different styles/subgenres (pop/punk, Post-Hardcore, rap/rock). I believe this is quite better for rock/metal than its earlier state which was pushing a specific style till it's tiresome (e.g. grunge, nu metal, hair metal). And the best part is that the playlists at least aren't dominated by painfully bland artists (though some of them are, lol).

  • @KaijuTango
    @KaijuTango 3 года назад +992

    The thing is that pop punk and late 2010s emo rap has very much influenced the rock scene of today. It’s not as clear cut as it was during the early, mid and late 00s were you would listen to a band like the Foo Fighters or Audioslave and go “oh yeah, they’re rock”. Now everything is becoming more fused and mixed together. Which isn’t a bad thing, it just makes it harder to categorize what’s a rock song now and what’s a lower end metal song or a pop song with guitars.

    • @Kaladin_Stormblessed
      @Kaladin_Stormblessed 3 года назад +53

      Especially with so much pop being infused into metal. The three kind of become one in a way.

    • @TheErazar
      @TheErazar 3 года назад +35

      @@Kaladin_Stormblessed yeah mainstream metal is so pop its not funny anymore

    • @deathangel1187
      @deathangel1187 3 года назад +8

      At least audioslave have a legendary frontmen..same with foo fighter maybe

    • @nikkid7963
      @nikkid7963 3 года назад +6

      Like Nothing, Nowhere his emo rap is absolutely amazing. He’s very underrated.

    • @Werewolf914
      @Werewolf914 2 года назад +11

      F in chat for Rock music, I'll be sticking to the Classics for sure. Granted Metal isn't innocent either I love Spiritbox it's great but when Courtney is just doing cleans it's Poppier than Poppys Nu Metal.

  • @RJW14
    @RJW14 3 года назад +18

    rock is literally everything from softpop with an electric guitar to extreme metal.

  • @CometTheMicroraptor
    @CometTheMicroraptor 3 года назад +603

    Maneskin is probably the most "classic rock" sounding rock band rn, their Eurovision song "Zitti e Buoni" reeeeeeeeally hits those vibes

    • @sebastianpacheco9846
      @sebastianpacheco9846 3 года назад +78

      Yes, but sadly with each new song they put out, they get further away from that sound.

    • @danielegiuliani2700
      @danielegiuliani2700 3 года назад +48

      @@sebastianpacheco9846 They literally released only one song after the album "Zitti e Buoni" is in

    • @brunopragosa9308
      @brunopragosa9308 3 года назад +1

      Listen to We Are Harlot

    • @juicicles5881
      @juicicles5881 3 года назад +20

      Greta Van Fleet

    • @lehtokurppa7824
      @lehtokurppa7824 3 года назад +9

      @@juicicles5881 Copycats don't count.

  • @ivetatran
    @ivetatran 3 года назад +37

    MÅNESKIN -ZITTI E BUONI
    Song that won eurovision and is really energetic, can be considered as rock, thank you! :3

  • @charizardmaster13
    @charizardmaster13 3 года назад +395

    Its nothing like old school rock but thats what makes it great. If bands still sounded like they did in the 80s it would be so boring and mundane and music would never progress

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  3 года назад +176

      But I'm old and mundane

    • @yeeeeeet704
      @yeeeeeet704 3 года назад +3

      @@NikNocturnal lmfao 🤣

    • @Nightknight1992
      @Nightknight1992 3 года назад +10

      @@NikNocturnal so basicially greta van fleet then?

    • @nicojoubert9338
      @nicojoubert9338 3 года назад +3

      @@NikNocturnal I'm also old school with my music taste it needs that feel of certainly to clarify what genre it falls into can't have rock sound like metal and then hard rock like metalcore or death metal. Then I can just be called a Rocket bangs head to Rock music like a Metal head bangs head to death metal.

    • @daviddavies3637
      @daviddavies3637 3 года назад +15

      You call this progress? It's like taking a guitar off Slash and giving it to a Neanderthal that's just been thawed out from a block of ice.

  • @benjaminschulman4033
    @benjaminschulman4033 3 года назад +52

    I feel modern rock like many genres now is very eclectic sounding. For more classically sounding rock groups I would check out Halestorm, Greta Van Fleet, or Billy Talent

    • @orlock20
      @orlock20 3 года назад +2

      My favorite "new" rock band is Starcrawler.

    • @ni_quack
      @ni_quack 2 года назад +4

      Highly Suspect and Bad Flower too!

    • @nataliebookout186
      @nataliebookout186 2 года назад

      Dirty honey and Dorothy are some of my favorite new rock bands

  • @Jopeymessmusic
    @Jopeymessmusic 3 года назад +518

    Yo, that Gojira scrape is the proper way to start a tune. Guess I'm a fan of Wolfgang/Mammoth now. 😅😂😂

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  3 года назад +45

      TRUE

    • @thelostpsychosis
      @thelostpsychosis 3 года назад +5

      Hs music is really good

    • @mason3872
      @mason3872 3 года назад +4

      Yeah, it’s not my style personally but it’s pretty cool

    • @ethanwilke9334
      @ethanwilke9334 3 года назад +1

      @@thelostpsychosis any album suggestions?

    • @Dream_elixir_band
      @Dream_elixir_band 3 года назад +2

      He’s a big periphery fan too and frequently comments on their stuff

  • @timothygardner4012
    @timothygardner4012 3 года назад +26

    You glanced over Foals for a few seconds, but as a long time metal listener, please give them a listen! They have little metal influence but by god are they a phenomenol band. 5 dedicated musicians pumping out extremely consistent, well-composed albums.

    • @jemappellejade6455
      @jemappellejade6455 3 года назад +1

      Yes!!! Commented something similar myself, Foals are brilliant.

    • @MrSAIVIBO
      @MrSAIVIBO 2 года назад +1

      I broke my nose in a Foals mosh pit and I guess that's pretty metal

    • @average_youtube_commenter
      @average_youtube_commenter 10 месяцев назад

      yeah, stuff of theirs like inhaler is such a vibe

  • @Busenbacher
    @Busenbacher 3 года назад +343

    Gotta love Nothing but Thieves, f***in amazing band. Broken Machine is a masterpiece

    • @michalfaic1332
      @michalfaic1332 3 года назад +8

      I discovered them this year and became immediately fan. I would describe them as a mixture of Led Zeppelin and Muse but being 100% fresh and new.

    • @anja4314
      @anja4314 3 года назад +3

      Agree! Amazing songs.

    • @chloestarshine
      @chloestarshine 3 года назад +13

      The vocals are absolutely top tier

    • @carazy123_
      @carazy123_ 3 года назад +8

      I heard a few things from them years back when they had a slightly different sound (Sorry, Amsterdam), but Futureproof has a sick, grindy tone to it

    • @LRM12o8
      @LRM12o8 3 года назад +5

      Yeah, absolutely. Plus Connors voice is just insanely good!

  • @terrancejordan7484
    @terrancejordan7484 3 года назад +24

    The best rock, hard rock, and metal is coming out of Japan, BAND-MAID, Lovebites, Nemophila, Mary's Blood, Trident, and Hanabie.

    • @banditkeithkingofduelmonsters
      @banditkeithkingofduelmonsters 3 года назад +2

      Check out Glim Spanky 愚か者たち for a pretty old school and catchy rock song from japan.

    • @darkowl8908
      @darkowl8908 2 года назад +1

      Hard rock maybe, but fuck no, not metal at all

    • @Repeaterbeater
      @Repeaterbeater 2 года назад +2

      @@darkowl8908 laughs in Maximum the Harmone.

    • @theaceofspace6110
      @theaceofspace6110 2 года назад +1

      Yes! Lovebites is great

    • @stephanb.4031
      @stephanb.4031 2 года назад

      Someone mentioning Band Maid under a video of Nic Nocturnal?
      I can die in peace now, thank you :D

  • @SergeyPupkoMusic
    @SergeyPupkoMusic 3 года назад +257

    Metal musician is confused by what modern rock is.
    Fixed title

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  3 года назад +49

      True, but title then is too long D:

    • @carazy123_
      @carazy123_ 3 года назад +6

      “Metal Musician is confused by Modern Rock”

  • @Nemesislord001
    @Nemesislord001 2 года назад +11

    There’s also the fact that a lot of people categorise indie as rock or horror core as metal. I’ve got nothing against these genres but can be a bit frustrating when I’m trying to find certain new songs.

  • @nickcube1136
    @nickcube1136 3 года назад +390

    Seems like nowadays anything, that has overdriven guitar in it, counts as rock

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  3 года назад +78

      Guitar go brrrrr

    • @daelinblack6681
      @daelinblack6681 2 года назад +5

      Now if we can get some good vocals with minimal mixing we're good, honestly most guitar in most new songs sounds good, then the singer opens his/her mouth..

    • @simonebaffi9079
      @simonebaffi9079 2 года назад +3

      Back in the days it was considered grunge, and metal even before.
      Time goes on, just the names are changing

    • @sexopimbada
      @sexopimbada 2 года назад +4

      @@simonebaffi9079 early grunge and nu metal was way better than anything related to them nowadays

    • @michaels1326
      @michaels1326 2 года назад +1

      I mean, yeah. As has always been the case.

  • @bobbirdsong6825
    @bobbirdsong6825 2 года назад +16

    rock is a very broad genre, it's like saying "classical" music. the term classical denotes dozens of styles, several eras, different continents and countries, but classical music has certain defining characteristics. same thing with rock. rock and roll would be more blues, where as hardcore is still rock but a very different form that has its own individual tradition

  • @Anon-21j
    @Anon-21j 3 года назад +232

    Never thought I'd see Nothing, Nowhere. mentioned in a Nik video... his old stuff is an INCREDIBLE mix of rap and midwest emo.

    • @HEADASSLOOKINGAHHH
      @HEADASSLOOKINGAHHH 3 года назад +10

      His new record has a lot of punk/grunge influences, specially the song Death with a breakdown lol it's amazing how he has changed his sound but still kept his style there.

    • @Anon-21j
      @Anon-21j 3 года назад +6

      @@HEADASSLOOKINGAHHH Yeah.. his stuff after Ruiner isn't my thing personally, Reaper was peak N,N. Either way I recommend people check him out, he's a great artist

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  3 года назад +30

      But I can't find them

    • @t-bonewrecks290
      @t-bonewrecks290 3 года назад +1

      @@NikNocturnal check out his stuff with Travis Barker.. not bad at all

    • @Bucboy1001
      @Bucboy1001 3 года назад +12

      Yes!! N, N has been underrated for years. Great guitarist too if you check out his live one-take tracks. Nik you have to check out the track "Death" for a nice little breakdown.

  • @chloestarshine
    @chloestarshine 3 года назад +11

    Nothing but Thieves is amazing rock and definitely some of their songs have slight metal elements lately!

  • @MrDouglas014
    @MrDouglas014 3 года назад +75

    As a metalhead, I think Nothing But Thieves are so fucking good!
    "Can you afford to be an individual" BANGER!!!

  • @nothingnowheremusic
    @nothingnowheremusic 3 года назад +15

    there’s a person named nothing,nowhere.

    • @YourzzTrulyy
      @YourzzTrulyy 2 года назад

      Nothing Nowhere!!! :)

    • @vvirgil153
      @vvirgil153 2 года назад

      Holy crap it's actually you. I LOVE YOUR MUSIC KEEP IT UP!!!!

  • @ryanbollinger1759
    @ryanbollinger1759 3 года назад +492

    The alternative and emo scene right now is absolutely thriving. I can’t be more proud of Poorstacey, Ghost Killer Entertainment, Jeris Johnson, Yungblood, and BMTH is helping bring all of these guys into the spotlight while also taking inspiration from them. It’s a great time to be a fan of this style.

    • @rithvikO_o
      @rithvikO_o 3 года назад +11

      yesss! MGK upto some extent too

    • @ryanbollinger1759
      @ryanbollinger1759 3 года назад +23

      @@rithvikO_o MGK definitely helped influence the style! I don’t think his comments about Slipknot where great at all and I think he stepped out of line, but I would be lying if I said I didn’t enjoy his rock music. It’s great and it’s forward-thinking.
      And then Slipknot just put out a song recently that doesn’t sound any different than anything else they’ve done since 2014 and I got pretty disappointed. Oh well. I still would probably take Slipknot’s side on the matter, but they’ve gotta get heavier. Corey’s screams compared to people like Spencer Charnas, Courtney LaPlante, Will Ramos, etc? It’s laughable.

    • @ryanbollinger1759
      @ryanbollinger1759 3 года назад +18

      @Call Me, BLEGH Me, If You Wanna Reach Me My favorite non-metal album ever is The Black Parade by MCR. It’s an absolute masterpiece Imo.

    • @ryanbollinger1759
      @ryanbollinger1759 3 года назад +1

      @Call Me, BLEGH Me, If You Wanna Reach Me Early AFI is killer man.

    • @rithvikO_o
      @rithvikO_o 3 года назад

      @@ryanbollinger1759 I completely agree with you

  • @taylorgang2237
    @taylorgang2237 2 года назад +5

    Rock is now anything with an actual guitar. The bar is literally buried at this point

  • @Zechariah340
    @Zechariah340 3 года назад +37

    Nik, Måneskin actually won the 2020 Eurovision Song Contest with their song Zitti E Buoni, and the rock band Blind Channel from Finland got 6th with their song Dark Side

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  3 года назад +17

      I need to watch Eurovision

    • @Zechariah340
      @Zechariah340 3 года назад +15

      @@NikNocturnal maybe do a reaction video to both songs, that would be awesome. And yes Eurovision is no stranger to metal, in 2018 the band AWS represented Hungary in the contest with a Post Hardcore song called Viszlát Nyár.

    • @xzocker9247
      @xzocker9247 3 года назад +3

      Blind Channel has songs in a game called Wreckfest, that game has a pretty solid soundtrack
      Also FlatOut 2 (has songs from Papa Roach, Rob Zombie, Megadeath etc.) which was made by the same devs as Wreckfest

    • @andyventures6574
      @andyventures6574 2 года назад

      @@NikNocturnal And The Rasmus were Finland's entry this year ... Sadly with a very subpar song by their standards.

  • @misterj9616
    @misterj9616 3 года назад +24

    I think Royal Blood are one of the best rock bands out there. Its just two guys, the bassist/singer and the drummer. They are playing hard rock / alternative rock / garage rock. Honorable mention: Don Broco

    • @mattharris904
      @mattharris904 3 года назад +2

      Don Broco & Royal Blood are both fantastic, possibly my two favourite albums this year

    • @lihclore
      @lihclore 2 года назад +1

      love them, they remind me of some edm type beats and alternative (my two favorite genres)

    • @laurachiriac1336
      @laurachiriac1336 2 года назад +2

      Yeah, wanted to say something about them heh. They're really great! I also like Reignwolf!

  • @Pr1NceGan3Ta
    @Pr1NceGan3Ta 3 года назад +113

    Yoo I'm glad Nothing But Thieves was included in this man. :D I've really gotten into these guys, give their back catalog a spin whenever you get the chance to. They're like, 'modern rock' mixed with other influences as well. Their 2017 album Broken Machine would be a pretty good place to start imo. Love your content my guy!

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  3 года назад +29

      They’re dope!

    • @TheErazar
      @TheErazar 3 года назад +5

      They are great, the mixing on their albums is always perfect

  • @jamesmiddleton8335
    @jamesmiddleton8335 2 года назад +6

    nothing but thieves are one of my favourite bands, absolutely love their songs. Royal blood are the obvious modern rock band to me, probably my favourite rock band. Little band I found recently called moriaty which are fucking so cool, but if you want proper rock guitar solos, I would say the band is inglorious right now. Listen to the solo in she won't let you go by inglorious, it's like slash but cleaner and more shreddy, but by no means too much. These are all British bands, the rock scene in the UK is really good right now. Also the two piece rock band is getting big in the UK, royal blood and moriaty are both two piece bands with huge sounds. You've also got like death from above, they're Canadian but again, two piece rock band with a huge sound.

  • @Daemonesse
    @Daemonesse 3 года назад +111

    The only rock band I really listen to now would be Palaye Royale. Their album The Bastards really nailed it.

    • @Sykokinetic
      @Sykokinetic 3 года назад +5

      Seriously dope band.

    • @danieldoloski6470
      @danieldoloski6470 3 года назад +20

      FINALLY OTHER PEOPLE THAT KNOW THEM! They're so good and criminally underrated. So excited to see them with YUNGBLUD next year!

    • @Snikabarz
      @Snikabarz 3 года назад +8

      honestly i specifically hate that band, they are so bad imo. Sounds like modern more generic adema mixed with pop from the few songs i heard

    • @theirishpotato6588
      @theirishpotato6588 3 года назад

      They are

    • @robikeagatya3231
      @robikeagatya3231 3 года назад +5

      My only issue with them is their attitude: they cancelled their headlining dates, which were already delayed by 2 years, just to be a support for Yungblud. Honestly one of the biggest dick move I’ve ever seen just for a couple more bucks.

  • @peterbatten596
    @peterbatten596 2 года назад +4

    This is the perfect example or encapsulation of my relationship with “Lacuna Coil” when you said “These are basically metal heads that want to play rock songs”. Because when they first started, they were more of a streamlined version of Katatonia with My Dying Bride (I say that in a good way). But then they pretty much veered into, well modern rock. Part of me wished that they would have continued to evolve more towards that doom/gloom/goth type of playing with the ambient/melodic approach.

  • @cantfindafreenick
    @cantfindafreenick 3 года назад +68

    "Well, there's guitars"
    - Nik Nocturnal

  • @emkayg612
    @emkayg612 3 года назад +12

    ROCK gives me energy.
    BAND MAID gives me energy.
    BAND MAID Is ROCK.

    • @tsukidoragonx
      @tsukidoragonx 3 года назад +3

      Oh hell yes, BAND-MAID is life 🤘💯

  • @ianmcpeck424
    @ianmcpeck424 3 года назад +45

    Guess I gotta check out some Mammoth. Wolfgang starting out with a Gojira pickscrape? Hells yeah! Gojira rules!!! 🤘🤘🤘

  • @warworldme
    @warworldme 3 года назад +22

    That poorstacy track was produced by oli Sykes and Jordan fish from bmth so thats why it's so good.

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  3 года назад +8

      Makes sense

    • @warworldme
      @warworldme 3 года назад +2

      @@NikNocturnal yeah every artist they choose to work with/for turns out to be really really good

  • @AnqaOdyssey
    @AnqaOdyssey 3 года назад +46

    It gets serious when anyone opens Paint.

  • @crowhite
    @crowhite 3 года назад +11

    Nothing But Thieves is such an amazing band!

  • @djentyboi6878
    @djentyboi6878 3 года назад +48

    Måneskin means moonshine in danish, but not like the alcohol. But literally like the light that we see from the moon

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  3 года назад +17

      Oh, moons are pretty good

    • @evilemuempire9550
      @evilemuempire9550 3 года назад +4

      That’s an odd choice for an Italian band

    • @djentyboi6878
      @djentyboi6878 3 года назад

      @@evilemuempire9550 I was thinking that too

    • @kaspersrensen3540
      @kaspersrensen3540 3 года назад +4

      @@evilemuempire9550 the bass player is half Danish

    • @evilemuempire9550
      @evilemuempire9550 3 года назад +1

      @@kaspersrensen3540 That makes a lot more sense then, though I suppose there are a lot of American bands that take Scandinavian names anyways

  • @nikkid7963
    @nikkid7963 3 года назад +6

    Nothing nowhere, is absolutely amazing! Especially, his older albums.

  • @Replicaate
    @Replicaate 3 года назад +89

    The breakdown is the new guitar solo. What a wild new world this is, eh?
    Anyhow, I think simply that modern rock is now just so different from the classic version that saying one is objectively better than the other is moot. I don't have any problem with it, there's some amazing newer bands out there now especially if one leans towards the more flamboyant emo-alt side of things - Palaye Royale, Badflower, Måneskin, etc. and the electro-flavored stuff like Starset or Nothing More. Which I do.
    All the same, I don't begrudge anyone who doesn't find anything satisfying in the current rock world - I'm sure people felt the same way when stuff like the Beatles and Buddy Holly gave way to Grand Funk Railroad and Bad Company.

    • @berserkerman11272134
      @berserkerman11272134 3 года назад +5

      Some other kick ass modern bands are cleopatrick, highly suspect, grandson. They all have so much grime, I just consider them dirt or grime rock 😂

    • @berserkerman11272134
      @berserkerman11272134 3 года назад +4

      Also not to mention, there are kickass rock bands from across the lands that sound more rock than some north american guys as well.

    • @NikNocturnal
      @NikNocturnal  3 года назад +13

      I miss guitar solos

    • @theirishpotato6588
      @theirishpotato6588 3 года назад

      Agreed

    • @ryanbollinger1759
      @ryanbollinger1759 3 года назад +10

      @Muck Hard disagree. It’s a buildup and a release of tension to hype people up and it adds such a great energy to the song. I LOVE breakdowns, and I say this as someone who has a distaste for jumpscares in horror films, and prefers more atmospheric horror.

  • @disthymia6929
    @disthymia6929 2 года назад +11

    If anything, the "rock" playlist should be split into a mix of metal, punk, and rock.
    The only problem is, these genre mix A LOT. Pop punk is punk and alt-rock together. Metalcore is metal and hardcore punk together, etc. And a lot of bands like Breaking Benjamin, Papa Roach (maybe?), do both alt-metal and alt-rock.

  • @ColtonFromTexas
    @ColtonFromTexas 3 года назад +36

    I actually enjoy a lot of Slash and Myles Kennedy’s catalog.

    • @slashthe2nd
      @slashthe2nd 3 года назад +1

      Same.
      They are the only artists i rely on .

    • @HeavyMetal-jy4vj
      @HeavyMetal-jy4vj 3 года назад

      Stupidly underrated post

  • @erikdahlgren6656
    @erikdahlgren6656 3 года назад +5

    Great video as always!
    6:44 that is pronounced like a soft or dragged out o in Sweden, Norway and Denmark. The name means moonshine (not the alcoholic kind, but the poetic). They are the Italian band that won Eurovision last time. The girl in the band are from Denmark I believe and she got to name the band.
    Love from Sweden!

  • @UltimateGamerCC
    @UltimateGamerCC 3 года назад +35

    it's kinda like the story to Brutal Legend, where the guy sets up for a rock concert and the band ends up playing some really poppy shit, that's what a lot of this was... sad how Rock has gotten like this.

  • @MokePops
    @MokePops 3 года назад +5

    You cant talk about rock and not mention Poppy's new album Flux. It has 90s alternative rock written all over it and it sounds fantastic.

  • @joaodepaula3957
    @joaodepaula3957 3 года назад +19

    stand atlantic is one of the best bands of these new pop punk scene, listen to their record called skinny dipping, it's so good!!

  • @RockNRollaMAC
    @RockNRollaMAC 2 года назад +3

    I'd love to hear your take on a band like Foals - they've some heavy songs and some not so heavy songs, very much in the indie vein but goes into heavier rock, but they're really creative and underrated imo

  • @centralia83
    @centralia83 3 года назад +94

    I think when it all comes down to it, people don’t actually know what rock is. When I think of rock today, I think of black veil brides, alter bridge, shinedown, nickleback, airbourne. Stuff like that, whether or not it’s called hard rock or not. Even though a lot of the stuff I named is metal influenced also. Tremonti and sevendust could be considered hard rock or rock with metal influences.

    • @cameronhumphries2377
      @cameronhumphries2377 3 года назад

      i just think of anything with guitar bass drum set up is rock, may be too broad of a definition tho

    • @travisspaulding9540
      @travisspaulding9540 3 года назад +1

      I feel like sevendust is whatever the hell they want to be.

    • @allonblack49
      @allonblack49 3 года назад +4

      those are all extremely mid or below average bands

    • @مسخلود-ص2ز
      @مسخلود-ص2ز 3 года назад +1

      Breaking Benjamin too

    • @nicojoubert9338
      @nicojoubert9338 3 года назад +1

      I'd not but black veil brides as Rock music maybe Andy biersack on his own as Rock artist but the band is more metal than Rock looking at songs like fallen angles, knives and pens, ect. But like all bands that start off metal or hardcore they probably have gone over to Rock. Example would be how bmth went from hardcore to electronic Rock.

  • @XxMATTxXist
    @XxMATTxXist 2 года назад +1

    Rock bands popular right now... Foo fighters.Shinedown. Breaking Benjamin. Badflower. Highly suspect. Ayron jones. Chevelle. MammothWVH. Greta Van Fleet.

  • @jamesflaherty1236
    @jamesflaherty1236 3 года назад +15

    They forced the man to make a whole chart

  • @reapercometh
    @reapercometh 3 года назад +8

    The best rock band currently is from Japan. Band Maid. They play with so many genres. You'd probably love the unseen world album

    • @wibs0n68
      @wibs0n68 3 года назад +1

      Japan releasing both the weirdest and the best bangers

    • @Fel1xF7W
      @Fel1xF7W 3 года назад +5

      check out babymetal too

    • @entitledkidyourtoysaremine930
      @entitledkidyourtoysaremine930 2 года назад

      Yeah Japan is a great and weird place at the same time. I guess there is a cost for having great bands like band maid and Babymetal and that cost is known as anime

    • @Fel1xF7W
      @Fel1xF7W 2 года назад +1

      @@entitledkidyourtoysaremine930 i dont have a problem with anime but it's so damn popular and its everywhere and i dont give a damn

  • @nickkohlmann
    @nickkohlmann 3 года назад +52

    My dude killed off Maneskin in the intro where half the instruments are still missing :/

  • @KrixiusTV
    @KrixiusTV 2 года назад +2

    You hear a guitar with any distortion whatsover, its rock nowadays. I used to only listen to Rock when I was a teen but I can't anymore, just feels like pop to me now lol. Metal babyyyyyy

  • @Silent.Gun_
    @Silent.Gun_ 3 года назад +11

    You definitely should record a single video only listening to Måneskin, cause they represente a side of rock that not everyone gets at first. Whether you like them or not, just give it a try.
    You could listen to Lividi sui Gomiti, For Your Love, Zitti e Buoni, close to the top, coraline, vent'anni

  • @alanfox8928
    @alanfox8928 3 года назад +5

    I can't believe this is how I found out that Foals had a new song out

  • @NOVGORODMUSICAL
    @NOVGORODMUSICAL 3 года назад +26

    aye yo, now this is epic

  • @-ljk-
    @-ljk- 2 года назад +1

    all the best rock songs have been made already

  • @yeet_za
    @yeet_za 3 года назад +6

    FOALS are actually fantastic live. Saw em a few years ago.

  • @Bassio
    @Bassio 2 года назад +2

    That's hilarious surf curse was on this list and you roasted it. I grew up playing shows with them all the time in the LA garage rock music scene back in high school. That made me chuckle because all of the music was basically exactly like that XD

  • @MetalMan1245
    @MetalMan1245 3 года назад +38

    You know what, most of it was not even too bad at all, but I agree, what the hell is Rock?

  • @lewisgrant7622
    @lewisgrant7622 2 года назад +3

    It’s like when rappers call themselves rockstars

  • @lewisgrant7622
    @lewisgrant7622 2 года назад +3

    I hate when I come across RUclips made rock playlists and it has songs like holy wars, master of puppets, freak on a leash and duality. I’m literally saying in my head these arent rock they’re metal. it’s like RUclips can’t tell the difference between ROCK and METAL.

    • @a_cats
      @a_cats Год назад

      nothing beats when the autogenerated rock playlist recommended to me had infant annihilator as the thumbnail

  • @raphaelcastro1332
    @raphaelcastro1332 2 года назад +3

    Nothing but thieves is pretty sick. I listened to their discography on loop everyday for 2 years on the bus ride to college

  • @OldboyRaf
    @OldboyRaf 2 года назад +3

    You should have listened to all "i wanna be your slave" the chorus rocks the hell out really ! And no metal influance !

  • @AlexPies1
    @AlexPies1 3 года назад +19

    the Måneskin riff actually goes kinda hard, a little sad he didn't stick it out

  • @gsmith3755
    @gsmith3755 3 года назад +5

    Måneskin is one of my favorite bands right now and so it Nothing But Theives

  • @xiqzoh
    @xiqzoh 3 года назад +1

    ''there's a person named nothing,nowhere?''
    yeah and im wearing his merch right now

  • @samuelbrantfisher7441
    @samuelbrantfisher7441 3 года назад +6

    Nothing But Thieves is so, so good ❤️❤️❤️

  • @guardsmansteven4128
    @guardsmansteven4128 3 года назад +2

    My favourite “rock” bank is red hook definitely recommend checking them out

  • @puff5074
    @puff5074 2 года назад +3

    Wait till he finds out what Jeris Johnson has been calling "rock"

    • @just1bandfan104
      @just1bandfan104 2 года назад +1

      lmaoo Ikr like I really like some Jeris Johnson songs but they're not really rock and it's pretty obnoxious of him to be like "I'm bringing rock back" like whaaat

  • @elitefitrea
    @elitefitrea 2 года назад +5

    I think the general audience is so disconnected from rock that it's just become 'the music with guitars'

  • @proximityclockworkx1572
    @proximityclockworkx1572 3 года назад +15

    When people says "rock music" or "metal music", they really have no idea about any of them xd
    Architects USED TO BE metalcore gods, Nik.
    Ending reminds me of "the One Direction song that has guitar in it" from Steve T

    • @alp_traume
      @alp_traume 3 года назад

      Used to be?

    • @مسخلود-ص2ز
      @مسخلود-ص2ز 3 года назад

      nah mate, architects still are metalcore gods
      opinions.opinions.

  • @jpslaym0936
    @jpslaym0936 3 года назад +2

    You're point I came to last week when I looked at "New Rock" on spotify and I was completely disoriented and mostly by just the lack of any trends or "genres " It is very hard work to go thru it cause 50% I cant stand

  • @originbliss9488
    @originbliss9488 2 года назад +26

    Honestly, not saying this just as a Muse fan, but they are literally the last massive rock band left that are still fully active and loved. Mainly because unlike a lot of bands, Muse adapted with the times, still kept the heart of rock but incorporated so many other genres.

    • @plusfictionband
      @plusfictionband 2 года назад

      foo fighters?

    • @MW-dd8vk
      @MW-dd8vk 2 года назад +3

      Early 2000’s bands like Foo Fighters, Queens of The Stone Age, The White Stripes, The Black Keys, Green Day, Linkin Park and Arctic Monkeys we’re all pretty big right alongside Muse.
      Bands such as Bring Me The Horizon, Royal Blood, The Pretty Reckless, Greta Van Fleet, Nothing But Thieves, KALEO, and The Struts have all got relatively large platforms and have the ability to sell out arenas and I think those bands are a step in the right direction.

    • @matomi02
      @matomi02 Год назад

      @@MW-dd8vk You just forgot Billy Talent 😅

  • @andrewchaisson588
    @andrewchaisson588 Год назад

    I saw MWVH at BFD 2021 with my 13 year old last year. He was SICK!!!!!
    Also had POD, Candlebox, and The Offspring

  • @talkuper4030
    @talkuper4030 2 года назад +3

    I think Royal Blood could be an example of what modern rock is, its differen't from oldschool rock but still heavily based on blues and rockn'roll and is not as soft as soft rock nor heavy as metal and post hardcore

  • @atomicpunkkk
    @atomicpunkkk 2 года назад +1

    I freaking love Mammoth WVH, I saw them at their first and second concert ever and was so lucky and got a signed record!! You should check out Dirty Honey too, they toured with Mammoth and they aren’t too bad

    • @Betta66
      @Betta66 Год назад

      I saw that tour. Both good live acts

  • @Crash787b
    @Crash787b 2 года назад +11

    Spotify playlists are basically pop and rap playlists influenced by Billboard (managed by pop and rap lovers, obviously), so for them, everything else that has an electric guitar = rock, there's no more genres for them.

  • @SmileyNoteblock
    @SmileyNoteblock 2 года назад +1

    6:43, that's an å, used in the Norwegian/Swedish/Danish alphabet :)

  • @patrickhaley1312
    @patrickhaley1312 3 года назад +3

    Only two rock bands I know of who consistently put out gold are Alter Bridge and Band-maid.

  • @Randuski
    @Randuski 2 года назад +1

    Surf Curse is great. They're like a garage rock band. They're from my home town Reno. Super cool dudes

  • @gamefan6142
    @gamefan6142 3 года назад +3

    What did we learn? Rock of 2021 is basically metal.

  • @cakestealer5983
    @cakestealer5983 Год назад +1

    It’s all rock
    Metal? Rock
    Rap? Rock
    Jazz? Rock
    Renaissance? You guessed it. Rock.

  • @gangstagrinder81
    @gangstagrinder81 3 года назад +3

    With all these new mixes of “rock music” being released, I can’t pick up my guitar without thinking what music really is

    • @beatrices.4601
      @beatrices.4601 3 года назад

      Easy answer: technical death metal. :P

  • @soyoudv
    @soyoudv 2 года назад +3

    I was sure you would like Poorstacy. This guy is so creative and his songs are so cool.
    I concider it as metal even if it's more a kind of emo rap btw.

  • @vultig
    @vultig 2 года назад +3

    Måneskin is an Italian band that found out they needed metal cred so they looked at the their half-danish bassist and chose the Danish word Måneskin (which translates to moonlight btw) for their 1/8 Danish band.

    • @bcepni00
      @bcepni00 2 года назад

      Denmark isn't exactly the country when I think of when people talk about metal. The only band that comes to mind is King Diamond / Mercyful Fate and I had to double check.

  • @sp00g37
    @sp00g37 3 года назад +1

    if you listen to earlier nothing but thieves, you can hear the early british post hardcore sound. reminds me a bit of we are the ocean

  • @davidnissim589
    @davidnissim589 3 года назад +10

    I would actually say that rock and metal is more diverse now than it's ever been, you just have to look for it. There's lots of good bands out there right now.

  • @wereboarder2009
    @wereboarder2009 2 года назад

    Its like this across so many styles of music now. The EDM umbrella is an absolute nightmare to decode and categorize as well.

  • @MrsMedicate
    @MrsMedicate 2 года назад +5

    Maneskin makes some very decent rock music. They won the last Eurovision with an italian song. That shit slapped

  • @shashinnosamurai
    @shashinnosamurai 2 года назад

    2:36 - Best description of Wolfgang's playing style. Man was in Tremonti's band for a reason.

  • @fueledbypaintwater
    @fueledbypaintwater 3 года назад +13

    If this is my generation of rock, I think I'll stick to the 2000's stuff until I make some music of my own. 😂

    • @orlock20
      @orlock20 3 года назад +1

      My favorite "new" rock act is Starcrawler.

    • @fueledbypaintwater
      @fueledbypaintwater 3 года назад +1

      @@orlock20 the only band I've found recently that is about 5 years old or younger is Saint Asonia, but that is because the singer used to be the singer of Three Days Grace. Most of the other bands I like have been around for 15-20 years or so.

  • @Dracomandriuthus
    @Dracomandriuthus 2 года назад +1

    Music in general, because of how many distinct genres we have, is going to see a *bunch* of mixes. Metal alone has had multple multiple different things that have come in to influence it, from Symphony Orchestra, Opera, to Electronic all coming in and spicing up the genre. Genre mixing is just going to happen going forward and lines are going to get blurred. I personally like it as someone who likes multiple different things.

  • @steph_hunt6007
    @steph_hunt6007 3 года назад +17

    Rock has so many sub genres. It kind of seems repetitive with these ones. Poppy rock drip down effect

  • @jemappellejade6455
    @jemappellejade6455 3 года назад +2

    Foals used to be Math Rock, and are actually really good. I was a massive fan back when I was at university in 2010-2014, even have their lyrics tattooed on me (sad but true) 😂