Simone Weil Her Life and Philosophy

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 июл 2024
  • Visit my new website: www.wescecil.com A lecture delivered at Peninsula College by Wesley Cecil Ph.D. on the life and works of Simone Weil. Part of the Modern Philosophers lecture series
    For information on upcoming lectures, essays, and books by Wesley Cecil Ph.D. go to / humanearts

Комментарии • 78

  • @chuckbosio2924
    @chuckbosio2924 Год назад +7

    I am so happy that you mention Kurt Goedel at 51 minutes. The incompleteness theorem was proposed in 1931 and it seems like no one has heard of it. Goedel also implies that the universe is an open system. Goedel also starved himself to death, but that is another story.

  • @mariwittenbreer6865
    @mariwittenbreer6865 6 лет назад +16

    There are some wonderful pieces available on Simone Weil. This is the frat-boy SNL version. I would suggest the BBC4 In Our Time "Simone Weil" segment. Goto In Our Time at BBC 4 and under A-Z choose S for Simone Weil. Really worth the time.

    • @christopherm5958
      @christopherm5958 5 лет назад +1

      thank you so much

    • @trombone7
      @trombone7 Год назад

      The BBC4 in our time is on youtube :
      ruclips.net/video/BS961W-Y8Uk/видео.html
      ------------------
      Also this is part 1 of a podcast "Philosophize This" that just came out a month ago :
      ruclips.net/video/4RkMns4ZXhc/видео.html

  • @rupe5h
    @rupe5h 10 лет назад +7

    Ph.D Wesly Cecil’s humorous lecturing style is fantastic that attracts the audience attention. At the same time, the way how he cohesively exhibits his serious understanding on any philosophers is unbelievable.

    • @markhunt4618
      @markhunt4618 8 лет назад

      +oblong You sound like a barrel of laughs

  • @EphesianRose
    @EphesianRose 4 года назад +8

    Ok so professor clearly doesn’t speak French, but the lecture was one of the better summaries of Simone Weil’s life’s out there! Much appreciated.

  • @alan2here
    @alan2here 5 лет назад +2

    Stepping into another's mind like this, can be the most unsettling.

  • @wScott905
    @wScott905 11 лет назад +6

    Pascal's question was asked,"What makes our human experience have human value"?
    The professor asked the students to ponder on this then gave Weil's answer. The student response: Laughter, bar room laughter.

  • @leecorey1
    @leecorey1 9 лет назад +32

    Bros her name is pronounce 'see mon vey'.

  • @cheri238
    @cheri238 Год назад +1

    Another extraordinary female philosopher is Simone Weil.
    What a journey of her distinguished travels and insights. She was complicated and always searching for the truth
    I love her as I had to study her work to place myself "as if" in her shoes.
    Gravity and Space, Waiting for God, Abboltion of Political Parties.
    Those years of turbulence in her life as the world flames insane.
    She burned her way through it indeed.
    Get rid of religion, the world is irrational. We don't need more, we need less. (The human heart). We all are only human. Perfect 🥰 That spark of goodness that is sacred, that is grace. Capitalism did not work, socialism, fascism, what is left?
    You, with a heart for understanding human suffering

  • @icandigitbabe
    @icandigitbabe 10 лет назад +3

    Very Well constructed and informative piece on Weil Wes, would like to hear a follow up on some of her insightful writings on gravity grace beauty etc

  • @hakim_alrooh
    @hakim_alrooh 2 года назад +2

    Thank you Wes

  • @melissasmind2846
    @melissasmind2846 Месяц назад

    This is great!

  • @melissasmind2846
    @melissasmind2846 Месяц назад

    I love her! ❤

  • @saulorocha3755
    @saulorocha3755 Год назад

    Sometimes during Wes lectures I wonder if I’m watching a standup comedy LOL

  • @Heyfield2008
    @Heyfield2008 4 года назад +5

    We will remember Simone Weil long for her refined thinking on some big issues long after Wes Cecil departs this mortal coil. I therefore suggest that Wes Cecil develop a bit more respect for the ideas and work of others; in particular women.

    • @RocketKirchner
      @RocketKirchner 3 года назад

      agreed . Jillian -- i first discovered her book ''Waiting on God '' and it blew me away . also - a great work of hers is '' The abolition of all political parties ''.

    • @maycan01
      @maycan01 Год назад

      At least he helps people like philosophy.

  • @divinefireangels1617
    @divinefireangels1617 4 года назад +6

    Simone Weil is the Greatest Woman and the Greatest Christian Philosopher of the 20th Century! Everything in her is so deep, real, authentic - she is a little New Jesus Christ!
    In Her magnificent philosophical work there is Christian Ontotheology, as well as Christian Ethics, Epistemology, Aesthetics and Infinite Love for the Truth - Jesus Christ!
    God bless Her! She is Divinely Pure and God-inspired in Everything!

  • @jamesbarclay431
    @jamesbarclay431 6 лет назад +29

    Dr. Cecil, This is a very poor review of Simone Weil's (See mun' Vay) life, politics and philosophy. She was raised as an intellectual with her mother, father and her brother, the famous mathematician Andrew Weil. She got the highest and not the second highest marks on her entrance exam to Ecole Normale' Superieur. After that she was a school teacher. She was most interested in the condition of the Common Person, his and her suffering. She hated the Bourgoisee concept and she vehemently denied her Jewishness sayin "I am French". Her brother Andrew was NOT smarter than Simone except that his talents were in mathematics. Otherwise, he was apolitical. She wanted the abolition of all political parties because she determined that politics was evil. I think her best works are "Gravity and Grace", "Waiting For God" and "On the Abolition of Political Parties". She did indeed participate in the Spanish Civil War on the Loyalist side. but as a scullery where she got injured and getting sent back to France. She worked in the Citroen automobile factory, but they found she could not operate any kind of machinery and was finally fired. She identified most greatly with the Catholic Church. Yes, Simone liked Buddhist philosophy and could read and write Sanskrit. Her comments to those she dismissed was "I do not accept your persona." The Catholic group that loves her most is the peace anarchist Catholic Worker Movement. Dr. Cecil, I find you very entertaining, but you are in no way qualified to lecture on Simone Weil.

    • @user-gn4kq9il4y
      @user-gn4kq9il4y 2 года назад +4

      Dr. Cecil is an American, that is degenerated Puritan after 300 years of secularism, the students very not serious about life, because the religious life of the US in the college is meager, so no metaphysical philosophy will be understood, people are basically materialists, so no Christianity is there or spirituality, so death of philosophy, so examined life, so no dignified person in secular college in general in US. Socrates will fail here, because the Athenian citizens are cultured people, they join the tragedies and comedies, US is quite below that level. Happy pigs, as it were.

    • @PiceaSitchensis
      @PiceaSitchensis 2 года назад +1

      Loyalist side? That seems like a very odd way to describe it. She fought with the anarchists, the CNT-FAI.

    • @PiceaSitchensis
      @PiceaSitchensis 2 года назад +2

      @@user-gn4kq9il4y I wish the US had 300 years of secularism hahahaha. What did you smoke today?

    • @vijinanadu1962
      @vijinanadu1962 2 года назад

      @@PiceaSitchensis I am a Yogi,hence vegetarian,I presume you are one of the degenerate !

    • @juvenalhahne7750
      @juvenalhahne7750 3 месяца назад

      De fato, a comédia começa por uma cumplicidade entre o comediante e a plateia que não tem nada a ver com os modernos espíritos revolucionários, todos contrários precisamente a falência geral do presente...

  • @RachelAndCayleaShow
    @RachelAndCayleaShow 11 лет назад +4

    No kidding! And if you're going to lecture on her then please, please pronounce her name properly!

  • @melissasmind2846
    @melissasmind2846 Месяц назад

    She reminds me of Maud Gonne. ❤

  • @jackcoltman
    @jackcoltman 9 лет назад +1

    What is the 'ism' he mentions Simone arrived at which meant 'God has left'?

  • @melissasmind2846
    @melissasmind2846 Месяц назад

    Meeting Pluto suffering grace.

  • @artsyg33k
    @artsyg33k 11 лет назад +2

    Your implied concept of faith falls outside of a wide spectrum of thinkers, from Richard Dawkins (a critic of the very idea of faith) to CS Lewis and a whole host of people between them. Faith is seen by all of them as sustained belief despite evidence to the contrary. I was also puzzled that you left out her refusal of baptism and the reasons behind it, which strongly reflect her ethical principles.

  • @GloriaCompton
    @GloriaCompton 11 лет назад +6

    i can' t laugh when i think about her.

  • @rickyboysernal3000
    @rickyboysernal3000 3 года назад +2

    pronounce it properly 'Weil- Vey'

  • @Over-Boy42
    @Over-Boy42 9 месяцев назад

    Waiting for God is now on my reading list.

  • @tparty22
    @tparty22 8 лет назад +2

    WWII ended for some in early '90s. Thanks to England escaping their fighting allies.

  • @jeromeThailande
    @jeromeThailande 5 лет назад

    The french kings didnt have bathroom they never washed but put powder and the chaise percée pearced chair was brought and taken away

  • @kennethspencer221
    @kennethspencer221 7 месяцев назад

    Well, two mistakes in the first 5 minutes: end of WW2 1947 (WTF, excuse my French) and misnaming Weil as Beauvoir. I switched off... shame.

  • @olavhessellund4472
    @olavhessellund4472 8 лет назад

    Good Grief!

  • @matthewgabbard6415
    @matthewgabbard6415 7 лет назад +1

    The professor sounds exactly like Kevin Costner haha. He is good though, I don't remember ever giving my professors applause

  • @robertcondepsychologist
    @robertcondepsychologist 7 лет назад +1

    It's French ...Weil = Vay
    De bu va

    • @burnellking
      @burnellking 5 лет назад +1

      VEIL not VAY! Oy vey! Simone W( double v) EIL !

    • @inb4play167
      @inb4play167 3 года назад

      LeviOsa

  • @greilcook
    @greilcook 5 лет назад +3

    This guy doesn't even know when WWII ended...

    • @sachinaraszkiewicz785
      @sachinaraszkiewicz785 4 года назад +4

      Actually, the end of WW2 is highly debatable. The Americans were done in '45, but much of East Europe and Asia was still on fire.

  • @leststoner
    @leststoner Год назад

    I just wanna be puuure!

  • @thetruthoutside8423
    @thetruthoutside8423 Год назад

    Not 45 but still raging wars , never ending stupidity and killing.

  • @gavinsewell7151
    @gavinsewell7151 9 лет назад +14

    If you want to learn about Simone Weil this probably shouldn't be your introduction. The speaker believed the Second World War ended in 1947 and had to be corrected by the audience; it didn't get better after that. We all have bad days and perhaps Mr. Cecil is a really great teacher, but this lecture did not go well at all...

    • @christopherm5958
      @christopherm5958 5 лет назад +1

      I agree anything you can offer for someone just learning about Simone.?

    • @post-structuralist
      @post-structuralist Год назад

      It's in bad faith to judge the entire lecture for just the first minute.

  • @SoFunnyYouExplode
    @SoFunnyYouExplode 11 лет назад +2

    Weil (pronounced Vey).

    • @burnellking
      @burnellking 5 лет назад +1

      VEIL... desolee mais je crois mieux placee pour repondre a ca.

  • @deirdredowling2251
    @deirdredowling2251 4 года назад +2

    Full of inaccuracies

    • @matjazmazi8405
      @matjazmazi8405 3 года назад

      American "intelectuals" ... :-)

    • @xelaphilia
      @xelaphilia 9 месяцев назад

      @@matjazmazi8405 intellectuals is written with 2 l's

  • @Grace-fc8zx
    @Grace-fc8zx Год назад +1

    Too flippant.

  • @matjazmazi8405
    @matjazmazi8405 3 года назад

    WTF.press : When an American fahidiot konfabulates about Simone Weil ...

  • @barbechivo
    @barbechivo Месяц назад

    Ridiculous and frivolous examination of Simone Weil. Lecturer sounds misogynistic at the very least.

  • @JohnVKaravitis
    @JohnVKaravitis 8 лет назад +1

    Why have there never been any hot babe philosophers? WTF???

    • @TempestTheBlaze
      @TempestTheBlaze 8 лет назад +5

      Why does there have to be? Hegel wasn't particularly handsome.

    • @JohnVKaravitis
      @JohnVKaravitis 8 лет назад +1

      Mr. Nexus It's different if you're a MAN, and if YOU were a MAN, you'd know! Idiot!

    • @JohnVKaravitis
      @JohnVKaravitis 8 лет назад +1

      Mr. Nexus You sound like a butthurt little bitch.

    • @TempestTheBlaze
      @TempestTheBlaze 8 лет назад +1

      John Karavitis You sound like a stupid lil dumbass. What're you doing here anyways? Can you even read any of the texxt talked about on this channel

    • @JohnVKaravitis
      @JohnVKaravitis 8 лет назад +2

      Mr. Nexus
      Why you so BUTT-HURT, beeyatch?

  • @Poemsapennyeach
    @Poemsapennyeach 5 лет назад +1

    Travesty....lock this lecturer up in the unworldly closet he came from.