There's a valid jihad in Islam by taking arms when the time calls for it. Defending your country is one them. I wish sheikh could explain those situations too.
Prophet Adams (pbuh) time sound like Buddhist the Non-Violence principle. Which is an idealistic principle because it is not Real in this Dunya. In Heaven and afterlife sure we'll be non-violent. Sometimes I use a filthy word like *******, then I've made an effort and struggeled to approach Vulgar X even if for the purpouse of annihilating it. Which maybe shouldn't be done? However it Vulgar X approaches me then surely I too can approach it and struggel with Jihad defending my country?
Sufi grave worshippers and ash'aris pantheist/atheists are the reason for why jews, christians and hindus invaded Muslim lands. The true enemy are these sufis mushriks
He says we should share our Haram Sharif (Bayt al Muqaddas) with a temple. Is this man even a Muslim ? I do not think so. He, like his teacher, is a perennialist! Search Husayn NaSr at Zaitoona
Hamas itself was a charity organization at first, it's Netinyahu who brought it up as an opposition political party and were also paid heavily and weponized by israel. With that said on oct 7 what happened was completely allowed by one of the most sophisticated army is completely questionable and may pose a reason and justification by israel to bomb and kill civilians. lastly there is a clear evidence coming out that israeli army themselves shot and killed their own people on Oct 7. Video evidence showing the homes, cars in that festival destroyed by missles, tanks. This all simply to attack back and take more land in gaza and West Bank.
Completely not true -- Hamas wasn't created by Israel , they tried to make use of Hamas because it was gaining support in gaza by the Palestinians to try and weaken the PLO but that was it . ( foolish of them to think The PLO is their greatest foe ) . same goes concerning oct 7th they got fooled because AI was left to monitor hamas in gaza while they were concerned in increasing the settlements in the west bank . When hamas broke through the fence on oct 7th and took control of the military and police stations around gaza the idf decided to shell bomb hamas and the israeli hostages .. Check 'The Hannibal directive' . keep in mind that Israel bombs gaza with or without justification just google previous gaza wars .. and they were devastating to for gaza it's you that is just catching up . last thing is .. netenyahu's career is DONE now .. there is no way this guy would allow the attack on oct 7th and jeopardize his career .. he is too narcissistic to do that .
Btw Hamas doesn't use suicide bombers, but their old leader did. Their last military raid into israeli territory was a bit of a suicide mission for some of them though, but it's because they lack the means and they are surveiled heavily and they are against people with better tech and higher numbers. And they managed to get a big reaction from Israel and now the whole world knows about palestinians and supports the cause, at least most people. Scott Ritter, the ex weapon inspector says it was a great military mission...
I agree. I am really disappointed with this interview. He should have stopped the reporter and clarified this to her. I was really bothered with this. Because I have a lot of respect for Hamza Yusuf and learned a lot from him. But in times of Fitna, he seems weak and always comes up short. Allah knows best. Maybe he has more wisdom and knows things we don't know. And May Allah forgive me if I am wrong in this analysis. Either way he is still a great scholar of Islam.
@@amoura4952 yes I am similar to you. I think people from Zaytuna such as Hamza Yusuf and Dr. Ali Ataie view Palestinian fighters as a bit extremist. But if zionists used atrocity propaganda, it means they couldn't find a real outrageous act from them... I think majority of the resistance practise the true islam as much as they can. They only took women and children as hostages because of the panic and urgency of the situation. It seems they treated them well and they are trying to exchange them for the hundreds of women and children imprisoned with no trial by the zionists... I don't know what else could they do, Netanyahu wanted to erase Palestine from the map and now many people think about 2 state solution. Hamas differentiates jews from the zionists and their goal is to end the political career of Netanyahu. Also, you can rarely find people of Gaza blaming the Hamas, they didn't believe the propaganda because they know them more than us.
The coverage of the event is blurry, I guess even though they're not all monsters like the media keeps pushing as the reality, maybe there were some bad apples and it's being extrapolated to them as a whole. Because how could they so firmly talk about those videos if it were all completely untrue.
He is not differentiating between Tawhid and Shirk. He says that you need a spiritual practice to mitigate mental illness. The listener could interpret that as continuing his Shirk. This man is a deviant.
I think sheikhs view on aggressive jihad is contrary to rashidun caliphs, yes Muslims should be peaceful but they must be able respond with force, because some people and nations are deaf to logic
but if we say that, the West says that we are agressive t*rrorists. Even though they have themselves have k*lled millions of indigenous people all over the world. Thats why Sheikhs have no choice but to talk about the peaceful side of the deen.
@@TheUneducatedTeacher Because the modern period war is literally never fought upholding the rules of the shariah. The only people who end up suffering are innocent people due to aerial bombardment
@@multanprarie2600please dont call other people bastard. It's unbecoming of a muslim. Even if u disagree Rasulullah forbade us from calling people names, what more using the word "bastard"... By doing so, u are acting like a "bastard".
Prophet said when violence became Neolithic be like the best of two sons Adam. But he also said: do not tolerate injustice. Rasulallah SWS said do not desire death…. And ask for a long life, so dying without a fight, isn’t that suside?
12:12 This must be clarified: Whenever any corpse passed by, the prophet (sallallahu wa sallam) was shown the world of angels, and he got up out of respect. He'd never honor a disbeliever of Allah.
vie in virtue but when we have been on the receiving end of violence and genocides, we must apparently sit back and turn the other cheek. we survived anyway guys. what happened to our right to defend our property, our lives????!!!!!!!!!
The trespass offering is like the sin offering. There is one law for them both: the priest who makes atonement with it, shall have it. ( The priest who offers anyone's burnt offering, shall have for himself the skin of the burnt offering, which he has offered = Leviticus 7:7. Then Moses wrote this law in Deuteronomy 31:9 and delivered it to the priests, the sons of Levi , and to all the elders of Israel. Those Numbers 29:39 , you shall present to the LORD at your appointed feasts! (( ... for good luck..))
Beg forgiveness.. Military Action & Martyrdom Is Compulsory In Al-Islam... That's the Truth.. But when we fight for our land, does that mean we are conducting real Struggle? Like Jihad
i feel like this speech should be directed to the Israelis! he refutes defending the land taken and all atrocities done against Palestinians so he basically just skirts the issues, also promoting his school.
11:49 don’t try to misguide Muslims. Prophets Muhammad ﷺ got up in the Jewish man’s funeral, not to honor the Jew, but rather to honor the angels of death. Sunan an-Nasa'i 1929 It was narrated from Anas that: a funeral passed by the Messenger of Allah and he stood up. It was said: "It is the funeral of a Jew." He said: "We stood up for the angels." أَخْبَرَنَا إِسْحَاقُ، قَالَ أَنْبَأَنَا النَّضْرُ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا حَمَّادُ بْنُ سَلَمَةَ، عَنْ قَتَادَةَ، عَنْ أَنَسٍ، أَنَّ جَنَازَةً، مَرَّتْ بِرَسُولِ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم فَقَامَ فَقِيلَ إِنَّهَا جَنَازَةُ يَهُودِيٍّ . فَقَالَ " إِنَّمَا قُمْنَا لِلْمَلاَئِكَةِ " .
He says wat isn't holy. Then why is it referred to as "fee sabilillah" "for the sake of Allah"? Then he quotes some companions of gandi. That's not proof, just more pacifists who don't know islam isn't a pacifist religion. Looks like HY has become weak in his old age and turned gandi and Buddhist methodology loving. His stance on so called Abraham accord which undermines islam and equates to just another of the 3 religions making it seem as though all 3 are acceptable which is kufr. Allah swt clearly says Ibrahim was not a Christian or Jew he was from the upright middle path, a believer. A muslim.
This man is an imposter . He is calling for us Muslims to share our Haram al Sharif, (Bayt al Muqaddas) with the non-Muslims. He is a perennialist. His teacher is Hoosein Nasr, the father of western perennialism. Hoosein Nasr visits Zaytoona quite often to lecture and teach "Muslims" perennialist thought, which is pure disbelief
Another example of why the ummah has declined when you have layman like yourself belittling scholars without even having the brain cells to understand who he was referring to when he mentioned "extremists".
I have watched a bigger segment of the interview and he was presenting both sides... the way this is edited is biased and I think it doesn't represent the position that he wanted to present
How many times you want to demolished that temple ??!!?? Just build a large "3 religion worshipping complex" on top@surrond the "historic"-ancient& original building.. Dare enough to build largest glass structure worshipping complex??!!??
Jihad is indeed the struggle against the own ego, which can be overcome trough a serial of steps which lead to the pure being. an-nafs as-safya, which can only be reached by great souls, for the Sufis this level is oneness or tawhid; in Hindu language it is the Atman (not the ego, ahamkara) who is one with Brahman; in Jesus' teachings (which are perverted by all churches) the dead of the ego leads to resurrection into the Christ-consciousness; in Buddhism the dead of the ego is the necessary event to enter Nirvana; even in Taoism the lower identity has to vanish so that Te and Tao are being one again. All traditions are circling around this core, the words and terms are different, but it is the ego which must be conquered to enter the truth - always. When you see the West with these eyes you feel disgusted by their egomania, ignorance, arrogance, stupidity and decadency, they are characterless, driven by lust, greed and the media, watch their politicians and you know their population. I live in Asia because I cannot bear the atmosphere in Europe where people think they would be free and same time they are celebrating the slavery of the system. So, every Muslim and Mosque, every Hindu-temple or Buddhist retreat in the West are like mountains standing out of the mud. Christianity? Is not existing, it is easy to prove: “No one can serve two masters; for either he will hate the one and love the other, or else he will be loyal to the one and despise the other. You cannot serve God and mammon." (Matthew 6, 24) It is quite clear who the master of Christianity was and is, so they are the Anti-Christ.
I think this clip is very misleading, when i first saw it i was very disappointed with shaykh hamza and then i watched the whole interview in rumble and it’s very different, please don’t just make videos that will make people misunderstand the shaykh’s perspective.
Isn't Jihad should be avoided in any circumstances but at the same time to defend ur mother land or defend against a group of oppressors also allowed, at the same time it is allowed to fight against our inner unholy desires or unreasonable angers inside etc...They way he described it unholiness, doesn't go accordingly with my learning
I was confused too. There is holy war does exist, it isn't something nice, and there's a hadith saying that, it isn't something pleasent but when it arrises you need to fulfill it. Defending your Muslim land is part of jihad. He's picking and choosing what to say
![Who Wrote a Short Story That Seriously Disturbed a Teacher? | Dirty Laundry x Smosh [Full Episode]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bvHAy_rKoEI/mqdefault.jpg)
Follow on Twitter, as RUclips is heavily restricting us - x.com/ahaqiquh/status/1720490670928859186?s=46
There's a valid jihad in Islam by taking arms when the time calls for it. Defending your country is one them. I wish sheikh could explain those situations too.
Prophet Adams (pbuh) time sound like Buddhist the Non-Violence principle. Which is an idealistic principle because it is not Real in this Dunya. In Heaven and afterlife sure we'll be non-violent.
Sometimes I use a filthy word like *******, then I've made an effort and struggeled to approach Vulgar X even if for the purpouse of annihilating it. Which maybe shouldn't be done? However it Vulgar X approaches me then surely I too can approach it and struggel with Jihad defending my country?
Hamza yusuf is a walking library and is very diligent about hadith and Islamic traditions
Sufi grave worshippers and ash'aris pantheist/atheists are the reason for why jews, christians and hindus invaded Muslim lands. The true enemy are these sufis mushriks
He says we should share our Haram Sharif (Bayt al Muqaddas) with a temple. Is this man even a Muslim ? I do not think so. He, like his teacher, is a perennialist! Search Husayn NaSr at Zaitoona
But when God sent him the final test HY failed, because he didn't speak up for the Muslim genocide
@@azmasalman9396I just Googled Quran Chapter 4 verse 24 and it allows for kidnapping of women in war. What am I missing?
Moreover, an occupier is not a civilian. A settler is not a civilian. All Israelis are reservists in the Army.
🌱 SUGAR COATED SERMONS 🍃
Sh. Hamza's words befitting his stature.. a wise man
Hamas itself was a charity organization at first, it's Netinyahu who brought it up as an opposition political party and were also paid heavily and weponized by israel. With that said on oct 7 what happened was completely allowed by one of the most sophisticated army is completely questionable and may pose a reason and justification by israel to bomb and kill civilians. lastly there is a clear evidence coming out that israeli army themselves shot and killed their own people on Oct 7. Video evidence showing the homes, cars in that festival destroyed by missles, tanks. This all simply to attack back and take more land in gaza and West Bank.
Completely not true -- Hamas wasn't created by Israel , they tried to make use of Hamas because it was gaining support in gaza by the Palestinians to try and weaken the PLO but that was it . ( foolish of them to think The PLO is their greatest foe ) .
same goes concerning oct 7th they got fooled because AI was left to monitor hamas in gaza while they were concerned in increasing the settlements in the west bank .
When hamas broke through the fence on oct 7th and took control of the military and police stations around gaza the idf decided to shell bomb hamas and the israeli hostages .. Check 'The Hannibal directive' .
keep in mind that Israel bombs gaza with or without justification just google previous gaza wars .. and they were devastating to for gaza it's you that is just catching up .
last thing is .. netenyahu's career is DONE now .. there is no way this guy would allow the attack on oct 7th and jeopardize his career .. he is too narcissistic to do that .
Btw Hamas doesn't use suicide bombers, but their old leader did. Their last military raid into israeli territory was a bit of a suicide mission for some of them though, but it's because they lack the means and they are surveiled heavily and they are against people with better tech and higher numbers. And they managed to get a big reaction from Israel and now the whole world knows about palestinians and supports the cause, at least most people. Scott Ritter, the ex weapon inspector says it was a great military mission...
I agree. I am really disappointed with this interview. He should have stopped the reporter and clarified this to her.
I was really bothered with this. Because I have a lot of respect for Hamza Yusuf and learned a lot from him.
But in times of Fitna, he seems weak and always comes up short. Allah knows best. Maybe he has more wisdom and knows things we don't know. And May Allah forgive me if I am wrong in this analysis.
Either way he is still a great scholar of Islam.
@@amoura4952 yes I am similar to you. I think people from Zaytuna such as Hamza Yusuf and Dr. Ali Ataie view Palestinian fighters as a bit extremist. But if zionists used atrocity propaganda, it means they couldn't find a real outrageous act from them... I think majority of the resistance practise the true islam as much as they can. They only took women and children as hostages because of the panic and urgency of the situation. It seems they treated them well and they are trying to exchange them for the hundreds of women and children imprisoned with no trial by the zionists... I don't know what else could they do, Netanyahu wanted to erase Palestine from the map and now many people think about 2 state solution. Hamas differentiates jews from the zionists and their goal is to end the political career of Netanyahu. Also, you can rarely find people of Gaza blaming the Hamas, they didn't believe the propaganda because they know them more than us.
The coverage of the event is blurry, I guess even though they're not all monsters like the media keeps pushing as the reality, maybe there were some bad apples and it's being extrapolated to them as a whole. Because how could they so firmly talk about those videos if it were all completely untrue.
he is man of wisdom
He is not differentiating between Tawhid and Shirk. He says that you need a spiritual practice to mitigate mental illness. The listener could interpret that as continuing his Shirk. This man is a deviant.
Ma sha Allāh. Shaykh Hamza always bring the optimism, hope, mercy as the foundational principles of the Islamic way of life.
I think sheikhs view on aggressive jihad is contrary to rashidun caliphs, yes Muslims should be peaceful but they must be able respond with force, because some people and nations are deaf to logic
but if we say that, the West says that we are agressive t*rrorists. Even though they have themselves have k*lled millions of indigenous people all over the world. Thats why Sheikhs have no choice but to talk about the peaceful side of the deen.
I think he left it ambigious because he has no knowledge as to when and how to apply defensive Jihad.
@@TheUneducatedTeacher Because the modern period war is literally never fought upholding the rules of the shariah. The only people who end up suffering are innocent people due to aerial bombardment
Love this dude
I respected hamza yusuf highly but after this video, in particular wanting to share Al Aqsa he is a heretic.
SHY is an asset for humanity and the ummah. May Allah give him a long healthy life and bless him in both worlds
He is saying that we should share our Haram Sharif with a jewish temple!!! And you are praising this b a s t a r d
@@multanprarie2600please dont call other people bastard. It's unbecoming of a muslim. Even if u disagree Rasulullah forbade us from calling people names, what more using the word "bastard"... By doing so, u are acting like a "bastard".
From the river to the sea Palestine will be free ❤
check: Palestine - The Heart of the Ummah | Shaykh Muhammad Yasir Al-Hanafi
Islam doesn’t teach Pacifism shaykh
Prophet said when violence became Neolithic be like the best of two sons Adam. But he also said: do not tolerate injustice. Rasulallah SWS said do not desire death…. And ask for a long life, so dying without a fight, isn’t that suside?
Very wise words … we need something stronger though.
If you guys are going to have me keep running the show we are never going to get anywhere
12:12 This must be clarified: Whenever any corpse passed by, the prophet (sallallahu wa sallam) was shown the world of angels, and he got up out of respect. He'd never honor a disbeliever of Allah.
vie in virtue but when we have been on the receiving end of violence and genocides, we must apparently sit back and turn the other cheek. we survived anyway guys. what happened to our right to defend our property, our lives????!!!!!!!!!
The trespass offering is like the sin offering. There is one law for them both: the priest who makes atonement with it, shall have it. ( The priest who offers anyone's burnt offering, shall have for himself the skin of the burnt offering, which he has offered = Leviticus 7:7. Then Moses wrote this law in Deuteronomy 31:9 and delivered it to the priests, the sons of Levi , and to all the elders of Israel. Those Numbers 29:39 , you shall present to the LORD at your appointed feasts! (( ... for good luck..))
He meant to repeat that it's prohibited to mutilate an enemy's body at 11:29
Beg forgiveness.. Military Action & Martyrdom Is Compulsory In Al-Islam...
That's the Truth..
But when we fight for our land, does that mean we are conducting real Struggle?
Like Jihad
i feel like this speech should be directed to the Israelis! he refutes defending the land taken and all atrocities done against Palestinians so he basically just skirts the issues, also promoting his school.
11:49 don’t try to misguide Muslims. Prophets Muhammad ﷺ got up in the Jewish man’s funeral, not to honor the Jew, but rather to honor the angels of death.
Sunan an-Nasa'i 1929
It was narrated from Anas that:
a funeral passed by the Messenger of Allah and he stood up. It was said: "It is the funeral of a Jew." He said: "We stood up for the angels."
أَخْبَرَنَا إِسْحَاقُ، قَالَ أَنْبَأَنَا النَّضْرُ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا حَمَّادُ بْنُ سَلَمَةَ، عَنْ قَتَادَةَ، عَنْ أَنَسٍ، أَنَّ جَنَازَةً، مَرَّتْ بِرَسُولِ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم فَقَامَ فَقِيلَ إِنَّهَا جَنَازَةُ يَهُودِيٍّ . فَقَالَ " إِنَّمَا قُمْنَا لِلْمَلاَئِكَةِ " .
thats not the only naration, i've read 2 which are different to the one you quoted.
sheikh Dr Hamza Yususf he is one of the "Koh i Nor" of our time, ALLAH bless him
He says wat isn't holy. Then why is it referred to as "fee sabilillah" "for the sake of Allah"?
Then he quotes some companions of gandi. That's not proof, just more pacifists who don't know islam isn't a pacifist religion.
Looks like HY has become weak in his old age and turned gandi and Buddhist methodology loving.
His stance on so called Abraham accord which undermines islam and equates to just another of the 3 religions making it seem as though all 3 are acceptable which is kufr. Allah swt clearly says Ibrahim was not a Christian or Jew he was from the upright middle path, a believer. A muslim.
Know the difference between a Mujahid and a Muharib.
This man is an imposter . He is calling for us Muslims to share our Haram al Sharif, (Bayt al Muqaddas) with the non-Muslims. He is a perennialist. His teacher is Hoosein Nasr, the father of western perennialism. Hoosein Nasr visits Zaytoona quite often to lecture and teach "Muslims" perennialist thought, which is pure disbelief
Another example of why the ummah has declined when you have layman like yourself belittling scholars without even having the brain cells to understand who he was referring to when he mentioned "extremists".
I have watched a bigger segment of the interview and he was presenting both sides... the way this is edited is biased and I think it doesn't represent the position that he wanted to present
How many times you want to demolished that temple ??!!?? Just build a large "3 religion worshipping complex" on top@surrond the "historic"-ancient& original building.. Dare enough to build largest glass structure worshipping complex??!!??
Jihad is indeed the struggle against the own ego, which can be overcome trough a serial of steps which lead to the pure being. an-nafs as-safya, which can only be reached by great souls, for the Sufis this level is oneness or tawhid; in Hindu language it is the Atman (not the ego, ahamkara) who is one with Brahman; in Jesus' teachings (which are perverted by all churches) the dead of the ego leads to resurrection into the Christ-consciousness; in Buddhism the dead of the ego is the necessary event to enter Nirvana; even in Taoism the lower identity has to vanish so that Te and Tao are being one again. All traditions are circling around this core, the words and terms are different, but it is the ego which must be conquered to enter the truth - always.
When you see the West with these eyes you feel disgusted by their egomania, ignorance, arrogance, stupidity and decadency, they are characterless, driven by lust, greed and the media, watch their politicians and you know their population. I live in Asia because I cannot bear the atmosphere in Europe where people think they would be free and same time they are celebrating the slavery of the system. So, every Muslim and Mosque, every Hindu-temple or Buddhist retreat in the West are like mountains standing out of the mud.
Christianity? Is not existing, it is easy to prove: “No one can serve two masters; for either he will hate the one and love the other, or else he will be loyal to the one and despise the other. You cannot serve God and mammon." (Matthew 6, 24) It is quite clear who the master of Christianity was and is, so they are the Anti-Christ.
I think this clip is very misleading, when i first saw it i was very disappointed with shaykh hamza and then i watched the whole interview in rumble and it’s very different, please don’t just make videos that will make people misunderstand the shaykh’s perspective.
theres a longer version on the channel, i only included the parts where he talks about whats happening in palestine,
He is ok but i guess because he did not live or went there, he could not see a full picture 😢
A disgrace, as his mocking of the Syrians was a disgrace, like his advise to Bush jr was a disgrace.
This guy is such a liar....I'm really over him, actually since he made fun of the Syrian people
Can you elaborate specifically on what the lying portion of his speech is? Genuinely would like to know. Thank you
Ridiculous
Isn't Jihad should be avoided in any circumstances but at the same time to defend ur mother land or defend against a group of oppressors also allowed, at the same time it is allowed to fight against our inner unholy desires or unreasonable angers inside etc...They way he described it unholiness, doesn't go accordingly with my learning
Oh hes being a typical apologetic
Lost all respect for this guy. Any scholar who is passive on this issue can never again be taken seriously
I was confused too. There is holy war does exist, it isn't something nice, and there's a hadith saying that, it isn't something pleasent but when it arrises you need to fulfill it. Defending your Muslim land is part of jihad. He's picking and choosing what to say