Supreme Court Allows Sub-classification Of SC/ST For Quotas | India Today News

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 окт 2024

Комментарии • 203

  • @sk.-tv2fo
    @sk.-tv2fo 2 месяца назад +54

    They don't want half Sc to come under general that's why they are coming up with the idea quota within quota.
    Funny....
    They can't remove caste based discrimination but are eager to remove reservation.
    They could have just removed casteism and said people who are above creamy layer will come under general category but sadly they won't do it...

    • @subhadeep_2001
      @subhadeep_2001 2 месяца назад +6

      @@sk.-tv2fo exactly. Why should there be any creamy SC-ST? Rather make them general upper caste. I sincerely think many people especially the poor ones in the village side will rather want to be treated equally in society than getting an IIT seat with lesser marks.

    • @EightTuber
      @EightTuber 2 месяца назад

      A Govt job for those poors will make their life less difficult and Help them climb the socio-economic ladder​@@subhadeep_2001

    • @sk.-tv2fo
      @sk.-tv2fo 2 месяца назад +1

      @@subhadeep_2001 yeahh and still today people who say there is not caste discrimination should go and read the news about caste discrimination cases in 2024.... Even after 75 years we r still at the same place with the same foolish mindset.... Supreme court hmesha hee reservation ke against verdict nikalti hai but sahi cheej kr nhi skti.... Jo creamy layer ke upr aarhe hai unko general consider Krna shuru krdo... Kahi reservation nhi milega unko.... But general mei aayenge vo... Aisa kbhi koi logical decision ni lenge kyuki chahte ni hai.... Lower caste upper caste stupidity at its peak.....

    • @Anomander5622
      @Anomander5622 2 месяца назад +1

      Bas apna privelege bacha ke rakho aap log. Mai ST hu . 50% QUOTA Meena kha jate. Justice hona chahiy. Sub classification aaj ki sabse badi need hai. Karte raho aap log andolan. Ham ulta andolan karenge aap ke khilaaf

    • @subhadeep_2001
      @subhadeep_2001 2 месяца назад +2

      @@Anomander5622 Iye andolan reservation se zyada proper societal position ki hai. What's wrong with considering creamy SC-ST as General caste people? Why still those people called lower caste if they are affluent?

  • @sudhakarbadiger6251
    @sudhakarbadiger6251 2 месяца назад +13

    SC is nothing to do with creamy layer,
    Untouchable is the only criteria for reservation

    • @shravaniagrawal1525
      @shravaniagrawal1525 2 месяца назад +2

      @@sudhakarbadiger6251 bro if you have even if you are middle class you'll be treated normally that's the thing
      Reservation should NOT be a birth right

    • @lakshmikanth9535
      @lakshmikanth9535 2 месяца назад +1

      Your correct @sudhakarbadiger6251

    • @lakshmikanth9535
      @lakshmikanth9535 2 месяца назад

      ​@@shravaniagrawal1525 there is no question on the reservation here sister, it's about being delivered to the right people in it. Untouchable has been backward from decades pls give chance for them to grow.

  • @sudhakarbadiger6251
    @sudhakarbadiger6251 2 месяца назад +11

    Zero ST’s in IIM,
    6 SC’s in IIM,
    Zero divide it,
    SC bench divide

    • @Anomander5622
      @Anomander5622 2 месяца назад +1

      uhlelelel reservation ka maltab ye nahi ki insaan qualified hi nahi to le lenge. Neeche se aage badhenge log to a jayenge. No body cares about caste in IIMs. We care about merit

    • @sudhakarbadiger6251
      @sudhakarbadiger6251 2 месяца назад

      Thousands of year se out of wealth and education keeps by upper caste people,
      Conduct exam for HC and SC judge posts ,
      Why suprem Court scared to Judicial Appointment Commision

    • @sudhakarbadiger6251
      @sudhakarbadiger6251 2 месяца назад

      Kitnaa hai sankyabaari utna hi issedari

    • @akhilkohli8861
      @akhilkohli8861 2 месяца назад

      @@Anomander5622 so what you're saying is they can't find suitable enough candidates from SC/ST in the country with largest population in the WORLD? And if literally this is the case we need to look upon why they're not qualified enough maybe there's some discrimination going on maybe there's something we're not aware of what is it? We all are citizens of India and are given equal opportunity or representations DON'T we? Or maybe not? why there are not enough candidates available? why this is happening it should be questioned don't you think?

    • @lalitprasad9572
      @lalitprasad9572 Месяц назад

      @sudhakarbadiger6251 Who told you before telling go and check first. I have seen many people who get into NIT on the reserved category. But after course completion when placement comes they even are not able to clear first round of technical discussions. But now you and your leader Rahul Gandhi kind of people tell while selection to company also they should consider cast instead of technical knowledge. In US Rahul Gandhi told no reservation in beauty contest such as Miss India.

  • @subhadeep_2001
    @subhadeep_2001 2 месяца назад +11

    Will the creamy layer then considered in general caste? Will the creamy layer people get married to the general castes, especially Brahmins? Will the discrimination because of caste stop after this? If all this happens i think people will be ready to give away reservation

    • @sanju5634
      @sanju5634 2 месяца назад

      Tum logo ko brahmin se shaadi karne ki itni chull kyu hai?

    • @basaiahable
      @basaiahable 2 месяца назад +5

      It's not for marriage. It is to uplift downtrodden. If you once eaten top cream your son or daughter can't continue to eat the top cream of milk . That's why Creamy layer are excluded let other first generation eat the cream

    • @manju2793
      @manju2793 2 месяца назад +1

      Even post graduation reservation should be abolished,if one gets mbbs seat thru quota,he should not get in post graduation

    • @subhadeep_2001
      @subhadeep_2001 2 месяца назад +4

      @@basaiahable Sorry you did not answer my question. Yes it's true that the poor are not getting the advantage and they should get those privileges. They have to. I even don't mind if the reservation is no longer there for creamy layer. But my question is totally different here. This reservation was actually caste based and not based on economic status in the first place. So if now these people do not get reservation, are they now upper caste people? Do these people now get the same societal privileges as other upper castes? Or still these people will get discriminated at every walk of life and still not get reservation. And yes intercaste marriage is one thing to abolish castes. Why supreme court is not focusing on the root cause and not trying to abolish caste first?

    • @subhadeep_2001
      @subhadeep_2001 2 месяца назад

      @@manju2793 Yeah totally agree in this one.

  • @lightbringers1883
    @lightbringers1883 2 месяца назад +8

    SC Reservation was introduced for representation of socially oppressed classes of Hindu society for 1000s of years, that is why a Christian or Muslim convert of such caste is barred from SC caste reservation.... ST reservation was introduced for representation of people based not only for social causes but also indigenous rights as they are the original inhabitants of these lands before other people migrated and dominated this subcontinent.. a tribe conversion to Abrahamic religion does not disqualify him from ST status..
    Economic factor is not at all the criteria for all such reservation.. For economic upliftment though helpful due to these quotas is mainly done from Government poverty elevation programs and not from reservation and quotas for such classes..
    These reservations are meant solely for representatives purposes of such people and the right of such people to compete within themselves, mind it, they are still competing amongst themselves for their allotted seat, be it poor or rich SC and ST community ..
    I think the decision to introduce sub classification within these group should be in consultation and involvement of these people.. Judiciary has already caused a major law and order problem from such parliamentary subjects such as in Manipur where the violence and warlike marginalization of two groups is still happening..The ruling Government has to bear the consequences of these ill conceived decisions.. BJP lost in Manipur from both warring factions constituency and is still not being able to face save itself.. Government should stop the Judiciary from interference in parliamentary affairs where thousands of life and law and order problems may arise just that few highly privileged Judges with no ground knowledge of reality interprets the constitution in a vague and illconceived manners..
    If these differences and knowledge of constitutional provision is not understandable, then people have to start reading the constitution once more.. Jai Hind.
    On a personal note, it would be good if there is a decree from the government to ban all caste and forbid the uses of caste surname like in the western nations since we are adopting and doing everything western..

  • @ashok-p3h
    @ashok-p3h 2 месяца назад +52

    hahaha....below 10% people got 10% EWS quota, people who opposed reservation got it,and the income limit is 8,00,000/- pa...the supreme court judgement lacks the justice and the judgement lacks the social understanding

    • @booksquotes948
      @booksquotes948 2 месяца назад +13

      They pay most taxes. U r a freeloader.

    • @vemmanr
      @vemmanr 2 месяца назад

      @@booksquotes948 the poorest pay the most taxes w.r.t their earnings. The real freeloaders in this country and world are MNCs

    • @jeush4949
      @jeush4949 2 месяца назад +5

      @@booksquotes948 who said he's a free loader? Only some st communities belonging to and residing in 6th schedule areas don't pay income tax. The rest do.

    • @UMEGowtham
      @UMEGowtham 2 месяца назад

      ​​@@ashok-p3h and you having lesser age than the chi's experience understood it better than them just in sake of missing privilege phobia 🤡

    • @PaswanSaheb
      @PaswanSaheb 2 месяца назад +5

      There is urgent need for change in Indian judicial system.

  • @asharma6419
    @asharma6419 2 месяца назад +8

    Can advocate tell me, why Meena are better representation than others??? I can see Meena-Meena everywhere with no Sehariya or Nana ....it is reality

    • @dev7155g
      @dev7155g 2 месяца назад +4

      Ab maza aayega reservation ka khel dekhane ka, ab samne aayega discrimination within and among SC ST OBC, ab tak to bach jate the general category ko blame karke aur sab malai kha jate the😅

    • @prolifeseeker4013
      @prolifeseeker4013 2 месяца назад +2

      @@dev7155g kuch nahi hoga .... ye kuch din ka dikhawa he..... kuch creamy layer nahi hone wala hai ...

    • @dev7155g
      @dev7155g 2 месяца назад +1

      @@prolifeseeker4013 but atleast they drop caste census demand due to fear for creamy layer among them

    • @prolifeseeker4013
      @prolifeseeker4013 2 месяца назад

      @@dev7155g hoga kuch nahi ... sc st walo ko kamzoor mat samjho.... wo log hone bhi nahi denge ... ye sab kuch di ka dikhawa hai bas

    • @prolifeseeker4013
      @prolifeseeker4013 2 месяца назад

      @@dev7155g ews aur obc creamy layer main bhi scam chal raha hai bhai .... jo ek bar 8 lakh se upar wala job leraha hai wo phir se ews aur obc creamy layer through multiple jobs le rahe hain ..... desh me pura system hi ghotala hai ...

  • @Abhishek-ox3qk
    @Abhishek-ox3qk 2 месяца назад +4

    Landmark judgement 🎉

  • @Amarnath-hc9ub
    @Amarnath-hc9ub 2 месяца назад +5

    Yes.what is wring in that.If a SC caste , becomes a collector, what is yhe need for reservation for his family.

    • @lalitprasad9572
      @lalitprasad9572 2 месяца назад

      Yes it is correct. The idea of reservation was for that once a person get benefitted then he should not opt for reservation for their kids if that person got good position and financially sound. So that other poor deserving EWS people get benefitted

    • @samarthchohan106
      @samarthchohan106 Месяц назад

      ​@@lalitprasad9572 what caste you have

    • @lalitprasad9572
      @lalitprasad9572 Месяц назад

      @@samarthchohan106 You leave about my cast. You ask your favorite leader & fool Rahul Gandhi cast first. In US recently he mentioned he want reservation in Beauty contest such as Miss India/Miss world. Also in future he will tell reservation Indian cricket team, Olympic player selection etc etc. As per him in stead of talent/skill/stamina/energy he want selection should be happen on the basis of cast.

    • @samarthchohan106
      @samarthchohan106 Месяц назад

      @@lalitprasad9572 I oppose reservations

  • @travelinginvestors8275
    @travelinginvestors8275 2 месяца назад

    Thanks Farasat Sir

  • @saimandebbarma789
    @saimandebbarma789 2 месяца назад +38

    Why general people are always jealous of st /sc reservation . If they want so much improvement come to face and face in ground level in North East state and solve the problem first instead of giving judgment.

    • @Kashmiri-r6y
      @Kashmiri-r6y 2 месяца назад +17

      @@saimandebbarma789 we are not jealous,we are being discriminated,general population is middle class not highfy class..our income is 8 lakh per annum.thats it.

    • @jichublackpink6663
      @jichublackpink6663 2 месяца назад

      Why a sc/st person with per annum income of 20lakh should get reservation!?????? Stop this bullshit and beat the people of general in exams if you can!!!!! God didnt give you a less brain 🧠

    • @hareethaathul
      @hareethaathul 2 месяца назад +2

      ​@@Kashmiri-r6yIf ur being discrimanated.. Then what u are doing till now.. Form ages before to still know what u peoples are doing
      discriminating peoples by saying u r upper class religion...did u ever see humans as human Discriminating muslims,christians discriminating lower caste..
      😡😡😡

    • @asharma6419
      @asharma6419 2 месяца назад

      SC /STs takes all government expenditures from Free meals (PM Ann yojna)to free education (Article 21A) to free hospital (Ayushman Bharat) to free home (PM Awas) etc. You want more??? Fight bro...SC/STs are mental PWDs who don't want to fight but want everything at home. It is reality.

    • @dev7155g
      @dev7155g 2 месяца назад +10

      General people are not jealous, there is also caste system and caste discrimination with in and among SC ST and OBC also but blame on non reserved category, after this judgement discrimination within thease caste will come out 😅😅😅😅

  • @Manishkumar-zg4sd
    @Manishkumar-zg4sd 2 месяца назад +5

    When they have had reservations by manipulating, humiliating, and excluding SC/ST communities from 100% of jobs for over 1,000 years, which allowed their bloodlines to accumulate generational wealth, why shouldn't SC/ST communities receive the same reservations for an equal number of years? We don't wish to engage in any caste- or religion-based discrimination, but we want wealthy representatives within our caste and society to represent us. We seek the opportunities and wealth that were never granted to us. Forget about being given them-we weren't even allowed to attain them.

  • @udayakumarmeivelu4736
    @udayakumarmeivelu4736 2 месяца назад +1

    Empirical data is already available with all states. The high school/ higher secondary students caste data and numbers are available with education department for the past atleast 60 years.
    The no of students joining professional and higher education is available with govts. Also PSCs have data for employment. Therefore from these data each state can identify under represented groups in sc/sc/obc category and grant quota within quota. Only vested interests want countrywide caste census for implementation knowing well that the centre is not going to concede the demand.

  • @vandanasrivas8221
    @vandanasrivas8221 2 месяца назад +7

    First of all it's "quota within quota" . It doesn't mean it excluded all the creamy SC's from reservation .
    Quota within quota means if 10% is reserved for SC quota out of 10% for example 6% would be reserved for sub-quota .
    This is the real meaning of quota within quota . Otherwise they would have been said all the SC creamies are now in general .

    • @himanshusingh4815
      @himanshusingh4815 2 месяца назад

      there are two judgements one concerning quota within quota other concerning creamy layer in sc,st

    • @subhadeep_2001
      @subhadeep_2001 2 месяца назад

      @@vandanasrivas8221 Bro it's better to bring these creamy layer in general upper castes. Why call them lower caste and not give reservation?.

    • @vandanasrivas8221
      @vandanasrivas8221 2 месяца назад +1

      ​​@@subhadeep_2001I agree , but that's not possible because who got the benefit they will use reservation in future for promotion.
      Aisa to nhi hai ki ek baar reservation ka use krliya fir bss jis post pr job mili hai ussi post pr rhenge , promotion wagara bhi to reservation ke through he lenge , unki next generation bss reservation ka use nhi kr payegi . Or aisa to hai nhi parents agar SC quota ka use krke job le rhe to unke children ko quota nhi milega to wo general mein aa jayenge or upper caste bn jayenge.
      Ek he ghr mein SC , General to nhi ho skte na .

    • @sk.-tv2fo
      @sk.-tv2fo 2 месяца назад

      @@vandanasrivas8221 as of now I don't think promotions mei reservation milta hai..... Toh promotion ka topic lana is stupidity... If 6 people in general are getting selected then only 1 sc seat is available ( teaching sector mei) ....Phele ye different tha abb nahi hai..... Nd jo creamy layer ke upr aate hai unn sbki caste general ke under aajani chahiye even if it's a job, ug, pg... Baki people who earn less will come under sc,st but there should be no discrimination cuz of caste....... Ye verdict bhi nikl skte thee ye log.. But chayenge nhi ki sc general mei aaye...... Hypocrisy.....

    • @tusharkumar9283
      @tusharkumar9283 2 месяца назад

      ​@@vandanasrivas8221 toh jo ye 6% hai unki cutoff alag se niklegi?
      Like SC Creamy ki alag aur non creamy ki alag?

  • @francisarulanandam2441
    @francisarulanandam2441 2 месяца назад +2

    Will there be a moral and social recognition if they're out of quota

    • @Anomander5622
      @Anomander5622 2 месяца назад

      Quota se kaisa moral recognition. Quota walo ko to freerider mante. Utni ijjat nahi milti kyunki merit se nahi ate. Bina quota se ane pe jyada recognition milta

    • @Creatives-x2bb
      @Creatives-x2bb 17 дней назад

      @@Anomander5622 then why did you took ews?? 😂😂

    • @Creatives-x2bb
      @Creatives-x2bb 17 дней назад

      ​@@Anomander5622😂😂

  • @venkateshp4313
    @venkateshp4313 2 месяца назад +2

    What will be its impact on the existing employees of central govt offices

    • @basaiahable
      @basaiahable 2 месяца назад +1

      If you are employee then you will sent to jail for missusing 😂😂. It's not retrospective

  • @mr.vikrant3583
    @mr.vikrant3583 2 месяца назад +1

    Yes. Absolutely

  • @satyem0053
    @satyem0053 2 месяца назад +9

    SC judgesment is totally brainless. Because this will not come in the SC judiciary. First of all, this problem should be discussed in parliament and the central govt should take decision on it. Even how state govts. will decide of this kind of complocated issue. The SC judhement is totally against to constitution.

    • @Anomander5622
      @Anomander5622 2 месяца назад +1

      Govt had already taken decision. To give place to whom jatavs and meena are not giving

    • @keshavkumar-bl6im
      @keshavkumar-bl6im Месяц назад

      You need to read a lot bro. Supreme Court hasn't given this judgement on its own. Government of Punjab brought this case to Supreme Court. The government seeked permission to continue quota within quota which is already in place in Punjab. This judgement is mere a permission to all states. It is not mandatory and binding on every state. Creamy layers is not in ruling itself. So, creamy layer is not part of judgement. It is media which is talking ton of nonsense. Any judge is supposed to write his thoughts, conclusion, reasons, analysis, observations as record alongwith judgement seperately. It is in this section this creamy layer comment came which is not part of judgement. This part which is written alongwith judgement is for future references. As new judges will start ahead only by reading these points and decide what to do next.

  • @MLakshmi-u1n
    @MLakshmi-u1n 2 месяца назад +4

    Yes definetly...during 1953..1972 when i studied crorpahis of muslims & christians labelled as minority got very advantage..while i was a FC i was living 5 days a meal per month...what a pitty...!!

    • @rinkusanjeeb
      @rinkusanjeeb 2 месяца назад +1

      Reservation was based on social stigma and untouchability . From when economic back ground come . It’s not obc . Can u abolish social discrimination . Not at all . This will surely cause block of future ambitions of bjp .

    • @surendhar1572
      @surendhar1572 2 месяца назад

      U living 5 days meal per month what a lie 😂

  • @user-jh9kj5hk8h
    @user-jh9kj5hk8h 2 месяца назад

    Good reaching out

  • @satyem0053
    @satyem0053 2 месяца назад +5

    Creamy layer in SC ST reservation is not at all neccessory. Its fun how SC put creamy layer in its judge ment is suspectable. It creates doubt about the jidges involved in it actually have any basic undersyanding on the SC ST conditions?.

  • @tylert9875
    @tylert9875 2 месяца назад

    Why is SC (predominantly of higher castes) so eager to dilute SC quota for select groups while maintaining its own creamy layer, creamy layers in bureaucracy, in army, in private sectors etc.

  • @kainadys
    @kainadys 2 месяца назад

    This judgment may lead to conversion of scheduled caste communities who are facing differential treatment or marginalization or oppression and deprived of reservation.
    They will certainly think that why they are remaing as scheduled caste.

    • @mbbharath2659
      @mbbharath2659 2 месяца назад

      If they convert then they have to come under the bc-c category.

    • @kainadys
      @kainadys 2 месяца назад

      @@mbbharath2659 If they are excluded from reservation on account of the survey in SC category, they will get another reservation after conversion as you said.

  • @rockr8840
    @rockr8840 2 месяца назад +3

    Even the wealthy ST/SC s don't have enough epresentatives in both public and private sectors..
    Out of 100% SC/ST population,only small percentage may hold good position in both public and private sector.. The vast majority of ST population are still socially educationally and economically backward..
    I aslo believe that it is not yet time to bring subclassification..

    • @lalitprasad9572
      @lalitprasad9572 2 месяца назад

      @rockr8840 Sir, Reservation is fine for govt jobs but no one is stopping to show the talent and be a CEO/CFO/CTO of a company. You can not tell I want to be in a those kind of big technical positions with cast but not with technical knowledge. Some positions are filled due to their talent not with reservation. Now you will ask do you think SC/ST people are not talented. I know.

    • @rockr8840
      @rockr8840 2 месяца назад

      @@lalitprasad9572 sir iam not talking about reservation in private companies.. i am just saying they are not represented enough in both sectors..
      some ST/SC may be talented but majority are not.. so govt put reservation in government institutions..

    • @lalitprasad9572
      @lalitprasad9572 2 месяца назад

      @@rockr8840 Sir, I commented like that as you mentioned "not enough representation in private sectors" in your first comment. So obviously private company will see who can deliver irrespective of cast and color. May be you understand and you are not telling but Rahul Gandhi kind of fools are expecting to make CEO of Google or Microsoft on the basis of Cast and reservation. You must have seen where ever Rahul Gandhi goes asks people their cast, tell me your surname etc etc.. He always speaks "Bharat mei saare bade Company kaa maalik kyun SC/ST se nahi hei". No one has stopped to become like Elon Musk or Mukesh Ambani but they are self made. Govt jobs with routine work is fine to fill with reserved candidates.

    • @palindrome4737
      @palindrome4737 2 месяца назад

      @@rockr8840 for those economic backward people this judgement is benefited for

  • @SIDDHARTHA1041
    @SIDDHARTHA1041 2 месяца назад +5

    *☝️⁉️నిజానికి వర్గీకరణ వెనుక చంద్రబాబు రాజకీయ చతురత ఏమిటా అని విశ్లేషణ చేస్తే అప్పుడు మా, కాన్షిరాం గారు BSP పార్టీని పాత ఆంధ్రప్రదేశ్ రాష్ట్రంతో పాటు దేశం అంతటా విస్తరించే క్రమంలో ఉవ్వెత్తున ఎగిసి NTR గారు TDP పార్టీ పెట్టిన కూడా BSP ఒంటి చేత్తో గెలిసి పోతుందని అన్ని వర్గాల ప్రజల మద్దతు కూడ గట్టి అధికారం వైపు వేగంగా అడుగులు వేశారు. అయితే అప్పుడు BSP కి కొత్తగా పార్టీ పెట్టిన టీడీపీ 60 సీట్లు ఇద్దామని నిర్ణయం కూడా చేసినా కూడా నాయకుల అనైక్యత మరియు అతి ధీమా కారణంగా అధికారమే మాకు వస్తుందని సర్వేలు చెబుతున్నాయని మా, కాన్షిరాం గారి మాటలను కూడా పెడచెవిన పెట్టారు. ఒంటరిగా పోటీ చేసి గెలుస్తామని సినిమా వాళ్లకు రాజకీయం ఏం తెలుసు అన్న స్థాయి నుంచి అంతర్గత రాజకీయాలను అదుపులో ఉంచక ఘోరంగా దెబ్బ తిన్నారు. అప్పుడే మొదటిసారి 1983 లో 10 నెలల ప్రచారంతో TDP అధికారంలోకి వచ్చింది. ఆ తర్వాత BSP ఎప్పుడైనా ప్రభంజనం వస్తుందేమోనన్న అనుమానం TDP వాళ్లలో ఉంది. అనుకున్నట్లుగానే 1995 లో UP లో రాజకీయ స్తబ్దత నుంచి ఐరన్ లేడి బహెన్ కుమారి మాయావతి గారు ముఖ్యమంత్రిగా అధికారంలోకి వచ్చారు. ఆ భయం వాళ్లలో పెరిగుతూనే ఉంది, అదే సందర్భంలో NTR గారు ఇక్కడ మళ్ళీ అధికారంలోకి వచ్చి 1994-95 లో ఊపుమీద ఉన్నారు కానీ లక్ష్మీపార్వతి రూపంలో అదృష్టం చంద్రబాబు తలుపు తట్టిందా లేక ఆ గేమ్ ను చంద్రబాబే వేశారా? అన్నది ఇంకా క్లారిటీ లేదు ఎందుకంటే అప్పుడు లక్ష్మీపార్వతికి దగ్గరగా ఉన్న వ్యక్తి కూడా ఈ శిఖండి నాయకుడే అని నాదెండ్ల మరియు ఇతరుల ఇంటర్వ్యూ లు చెబుతున్నాయి. ఏదోలా వైశ్రాయ్ హోటల్ నాటకాల ద్వారా ముఖ్యమంత్రి అవడం ఆ తర్వాత వెంటనే BSP భయం పెనుభూతం కాకముందే ఏదో చెయ్యాలనే పథకంతో SC ల వర్గీకరనే లక్ష్యంగా మంద ఎల్లయ్య ఉరఫ్ మంద క్రిష్ణను తయారు చేసుకున్నాడు. ఈ నాయకుడికి అప్పుడు నక్సలైట్ లీడర్ కూర రాజన్న వర్గంతో సత్సబంధాలు ఉన్నట్లుగా సమాచారం సోషల్ మీడియాలో ఉంది. అలాగే SC లను విభజించక పోతే ఏ రకంగానూ మనం అధికారం చెలాయించలేమని తెలిసి మాల మాదిగలను విభజించి పాలించే లక్ష్యంతో చీకట్లో చేతులు కలిపి SC లకు ద్రోహం చెయ్యడానికే నడుం కట్టాడు అన్నది నిజం. అప్పుడు వాళ్ళ బామ్మర్దులను నమ్మని వాళ్ళ మీద కుట్రలు చేసే నాయకునికి మనమీద ప్రేమ ఎందుకు ఉంటుంది మన తెలివి తక్కువ కథ కాకపోతే. ఇలా వలలో పడ్డ చేపకు అప్పటినుంచి ఇప్పటి వరకు ఉప్పు కారం మాసాల పూస్తూ వచ్చాడు చంద్రబాబు జి, దానికి ఇంకొంత మందిని వాడుకున్నాడు వాళ్లెవరో మీకు తెలుసు. అప్పుడు మా, కాన్షిరాం గారు చెప్పింది విని అలయెన్స్ చెయ్యక మంద క్రిష్ణ పుట్టుకకు మనవాళ్లే కారణమై BSP ని పాతాళానికి తొక్కారు దానికి బహెన్ గారి తప్పుడు నిర్ణయాలు కూడా తోడైనవి మంద క్రిష్ణన్నకు ఊపునిచ్చాయి. SC వర్గాల్లో అంతగా చదువుకున్న వాళ్ళు లేని రోజులు అవి కనుక చంద్రబాబు గారి చతురత బాగా పని చేసింది. కనుకనే అప్పటి నుంచి CM అవుతూనే ఉన్నాడు కనీసం సరైన మంత్రి పదవులు కూడా ఇవ్వలేదు. ఈ సారి మాత్రం ఒకటి పనికొచ్చేది ఇచ్చాడు దానికి జబ్బలు చర్చుకుంటున్నారు. ఇలా మనల్ని రాజకీయంగా పర్మనెంట్ గా విభజించాలనుకున్నాడు. కానీ మోడీ జి దగ్గర పేలక రాజ్యాంగ సవరణ కుదరక జడ్జీలను మేనేజ్ చేసే దాక వచ్చినారు కానీ అది కూడా రాష్ట్రాల దగ్గర లేని అధికారం ఉందని మన మంద క్రిష్ణన్నను తిరిగి మంద ఎల్లయ్యను చేశారు. ఆయనకు అది అర్థం కాక మళ్ళీ డప్పులు కొట్టే కార్యక్రమం చేస్తున్నాడు వాళ్ళను కూడా బలికి సిద్ధం చేశాడు. కారణం పోరాడి అలసిపోయానని ఒక కపట నాటకంకు తెర తీశాడు అన్నగారు. అందుకే ఇప్పుడు చంద్రబాబుకు ఇంకో నాయకత్వం కొరకు చూస్తున్నాడు. కానీ చంద్రబాబు దిమాక్ ను ఇట్టే చదివే చతురత కల్గిన నాయకులు ఇప్పడు మాలల్లో ఉన్నారన్నది రాబోయే ఎన్నికల్లో తెలుస్తుంది. ఎన్ని నాటకాలు వేసిన చంద్రబాబు కథలు కంచికే అలాగే ఇక్కడ తెలంగాణలో కూడా ఎవ్వరైనా ఆ కథలకు తెర తీస్తే రాజకీయంగా బొంద పెట్టడం ఖాయం. మమ్మల్ని రాజకీయంగా ఎదగకుండా చిల్లర నాటకాలు వేసి, శాశ్వత బానిసలుగా మారుస్తారా? ఏమంటే దేవుని కథల సెంటిమెంట్ లతో మాకు అయిన్మెంట్ పూస్తారా? అక్కడ మోడీ కి ఇక్కడ చంద్రబాబుకు ఖచ్చితంగా గుణపాఠమే. BJP TDP OUT THIS TIME. జైభీమ్ జైఫూలే జైపెరియార్ జైభారత్ ✅️💯🇮🇳🙏*

    • @rinkulahre1698
      @rinkulahre1698 2 месяца назад

      True 😊

    • @rajababu1385
      @rajababu1385 2 месяца назад +1

      Chandrababu Divided and rule support for manda Krishna baabu jithula marina nakka😮😮😮

  • @neilphilip1604
    @neilphilip1604 2 месяца назад +6

    Those among the beneficiaries of reservations if they have cream in their income 😊 should definitely not be availing the reservations benifits.

    • @SenthilKumar-pb3nu
      @SenthilKumar-pb3nu 2 месяца назад

      Wish ur ancestors thot that way...they had no problem enjoying benefits for centuries by oppressing others

    • @truthtobetold9915
      @truthtobetold9915 2 месяца назад

      Bewakofi ki height he

  • @Theedgesearch-12
    @Theedgesearch-12 2 месяца назад +1

    I saw this from mile awy after the budget of 2024

  • @hkwease3588
    @hkwease3588 2 месяца назад +2

    Totally divisive.

  • @pradhanmandi1300
    @pradhanmandi1300 2 месяца назад

    First supreme should clarify what is base of reservation. What is the SC/ST, OBC population in our country? Which census is caste base census after independence? Then the question of judgement.

  • @jwalapsd
    @jwalapsd 2 месяца назад +1

    Sir with all due respect i wanted to ask " will economy equity(well this is also not there in absolute terms)will do away with social and religious inequality"??
    Never , then basis for categorisation itself is wrong which is also baseless without any data or facts.

    • @santhosh2513
      @santhosh2513 4 дня назад

      No but you're anyways giving it to the same section of people

  • @arjita4468
    @arjita4468 2 месяца назад

    The creamy layer system should be applied on general category at first.

    • @Anomander5622
      @Anomander5622 2 месяца назад

      Lol koi reservation hoga tab to creamy layer hogi. Aur inko naukri chahiy

  • @kumaraswamykaramcheti7547
    @kumaraswamykaramcheti7547 2 месяца назад

    Creamy layer should be implementd

  • @narasimhabhagavatula8360
    @narasimhabhagavatula8360 2 месяца назад

    Creamy lowers ftrm sc to be treated as obc
    Similarly dreamy layers of open category happening any how

  • @Racerm25
    @Racerm25 2 месяца назад

    Remove creamy layer from. Reservation

  • @devarajubs3960
    @devarajubs3960 2 месяца назад

    Creamilayer to untouchables is' incompatible.

  • @rsv6603
    @rsv6603 2 месяца назад +1

    Y rich ppl need quotas at all no matter what community they come from? Will centre n state collect tax based on community n stop seeing one's income? 🤔🧿🤞🏼🙏🏼!

  • @mr.saim_7725
    @mr.saim_7725 Месяц назад

    Shadan farasat is right 👍

  • @thefoodie9062
    @thefoodie9062 2 месяца назад +1

    Excellent and bold decision by supreme court. It has only asked to remove people who have got SC/ST reservation benefit and uplifted, and only the underprivileged SC/ST should get the benefit. What is the wrong with it , why the benefited and uplifted SC/ST people should get benefit ?

    • @subhadeep_2001
      @subhadeep_2001 2 месяца назад +2

      @@thefoodie9062 Nothing wrong. Just make those people general upper caste.

    • @truthtobetold9915
      @truthtobetold9915 2 месяца назад

      Bro read judgement. Why so excited? Half knowlwdge is dangerous

  • @meetkumarrana09
    @meetkumarrana09 2 месяца назад

    I hate 5th rule ask a question about this

  • @kok-kubui7556
    @kok-kubui7556 2 месяца назад +1

    Quota within quota should be implemented for all the categories...UR is also a Reservation.... There are creamy layers in all the categories..... determination for creamy Layer should be Rs.2.0 lakh limit per year

    • @manonwheels5125
      @manonwheels5125 2 месяца назад

      Is ur a reservation...fool...😂🤣🤣

  • @meetkumarrana09
    @meetkumarrana09 2 месяца назад

    Only one time quta is use fule to sc cast family'

  • @rti5897
    @rti5897 2 месяца назад

    Farasat is talking nonsense. Why can't be there Creamy layer?

  • @utpalray2486
    @utpalray2486 2 месяца назад +3

    Charity begins at home... The same benevolent theory applies to the able weaker heterogeneous groups in general castes who must replace the homogeneous groups in the general castes holding top posts in the country by virtue of nepotism and favouritism without having due merit.

  • @ankitbasetia8581
    @ankitbasetia8581 2 месяца назад +1

    Regressive

  • @VishalTiger-jo4vk
    @VishalTiger-jo4vk 2 месяца назад +4

    But according to the article 16(4) reservation for sc st is for their adequate representation in govt institutions..and it is based on social backwardness..then how can supreme court be so immature even they don't know abt the articles of the constitution..there is no any mention abt the economical backwardness in the constitution..can it apply on reservation in parliament and legislative assemblies also?..how can you sort the candidates as creamy and non creamy during the election process😂😂... supreme court bhaang khaa kar judgements dai rha hai

    • @garyhunter.1501
      @garyhunter.1501 2 месяца назад

      Yes brother, you are absolutely right. The reservation is for the backwardness and profound representation of the Scheduled Caste, Scheduled Tribes and OBC. I don't know what the judges were taking before coming to this verdict

    • @Randhaiya
      @Randhaiya 2 месяца назад +2

      @@VishalTiger-jo4vk if u know so much about constitution, u should better know that reservation was only for 10 years.

    • @VishalTiger-jo4vk
      @VishalTiger-jo4vk 2 месяца назад

      @@Randhaiya yes you are right...yeah bas bola gya tha ki 10 saal tak hona chaiya initially..but govt can extend this time limit.. constitution pad kar aao pehlay..hawa baazi m baat MTT kro..agar pdnay k liya book nahi apkay paas toh ..jo article mainay mention Kiya hai usko Google m search kro clear ho jaya ga

    • @debanjandey8961
      @debanjandey8961 2 месяца назад +3

      Income 8 lakh above hoga toh creamy layer hoga... Same as OBC

    • @ajaykumarsingh702
      @ajaykumarsingh702 2 месяца назад

      ​@@Randhaiya
      Incorrect.
      Reservation was suppose to be in effect until a social reform comes in India society.
      And No social reform came until now regarding abolishing caste system.
      So reservation will never end and neither any government has the guts to do this.

  • @meetkumarrana09
    @meetkumarrana09 2 месяца назад

    I hate 5th rule

  • @meetkumarrana09
    @meetkumarrana09 2 месяца назад

    I hate of 5 rule

  • @meetkumarrana09
    @meetkumarrana09 2 месяца назад

    Hate 5 rule

  • @meetkumarrana09
    @meetkumarrana09 2 месяца назад

    I hate 5 rule

  • @dev7155g
    @dev7155g 2 месяца назад +4

    Ab maza aayega 😅😅😅 reservation ka Khel dekhne ka 😅😅😅

    • @RAGHUJIMALAON
      @RAGHUJIMALAON 2 месяца назад +2

      EWES wala bhi dekh liye hote

    • @dev7155g
      @dev7155g 2 месяца назад

      @@RAGHUJIMALAON sab vote bank ka khel hai, Dalit pichhde kisan aadivasi Maratha jaat cast census, ab khel main aur maza aayega 😂😂😂

    • @Demon_Slayer_010
      @Demon_Slayer_010 2 месяца назад

      And you know what's gonna happen 🤷

    • @garyhunter.1501
      @garyhunter.1501 2 месяца назад

      ​@Demon_Slayer_010 What's gonna happen?

    • @vandanasrivas8221
      @vandanasrivas8221 2 месяца назад

      ​@@garyhunter.1501andolan.