The thing with Lady Gaga is that she instantly develops an insane and convincing chemistry with whoever male leads. And her voice fits any genre. She is an artistic chameleon!
I think Bruno is the star here, amazing voice and such a lovely personality, Gaga is of course fantastic as well. It's actually a great match musically.
LG can sing anything. To sing with Bruno, Metallica, Tony Bennett, Ariana grande, Bradley cooper, Florence Welch, and Beyoncé really proves that she’s probably one of the most versatile vocalists in music.
it’s because dude knows what he’s talking about and how to explain it properly. that’s why I also like it when a reactor is more specific (in this case a vocal coach, or others like a video editor reacting to a cool music video, or maybe a dancer reacting to the dance)
Absolutely love Bruno Mars. I had actually not heard that much about him a couple of years ago, then he was interviewed on a show here in Sweden and I was floored by his laid back & funny personality. He's an amazing musician.
This!!!! It's also the reason why it's hard to cover his songs. You can maybe hit the high notes but the delivery and technique to convey the emotional depth and impact of the song will always fall short.
I never liked his first album... but with his second album he definitely stepped into his retro pastiche bag. He studies the greats, definitely. And so does Gaga.
This is what happens when two perennial musical students pair up. Their tonal quality is almost like a yin and yang. He leans toward more aspirate and she leans toward more chord closure. They also use their vocal fry similarly. But their blend is beautiful. And the play between minor and major chords really tugs at the heartstrings. It also has that brill building wall of sound feel in the production. Literally no other two artists could have pulled this off. This won’t trend on tik tok but it should to teach these kinds on that platform how to construct a perfect pop song.
I commented this in the actual music video, but gosh this is so 2010s IN A GOOD WAY and they both seems to be enjoying the project so much... oh simpler times....
Beautiful performance. Awesome analysis. The highlight for me was… “They take their work seriously but when it comes to their presentation they have fun… they are free… confident not arrogant.” Yes, you feel it. You see it and it draws you in. Every video you do speaks to the vocal student in me in different and specific ways. Thank you again Chris 🙏🥰
I'm no expert in music, but what I really, really admire and appreciate about Bruno Mars is that whenever he sings his songs he makes it a point to change the arrangement a little bit (but not making it too different) especially in concerts and TV shows. He puts a new perspective on it whether it be an amazing new addition to the choregraphy or adding an extra musical instrument to highlight some parts, etc. He makes his own songs "new" again to the eyes and ears of the listeners. But more importantly, it's his big effort that I appreciate most in pleasing his fans and his audience. I mean, he can just sing and we will all go ga-ga over him! But, nope, he goes the extra mile and make everything fresh again. And, he never runs out of ideas even though he sings the same hit song! It's amazing! He is a genius!!! Thank you, Bruno! Glad you are in this generation!
Would like to add he has that great laid back personality as well. Seems as if he doesn't take himself too serious if you know what I mean. Whilst there are other musicians out there, great ones yes, but sometimes with egos so big, they seem to think they are greater than greatest and some gift to humanity... which unfortunately at times, clouds ones feelings about the music they make. Bruno is definitely not in that category.
@@anniezion Very true! Bruno has no superiority complex whatsoever even though he is so talented! He has been writing songs for famous artists, and yet he has no problem taking the back seat! A totally classy guy!
This song instantly took me back to the early 70's as a 12 yr old girl with hints of the Carpenters harmonizing and and mix of minor and major keys. Wow, what a song. It made me tear up at the end!! ❤❤❤
Bruno Mars and Lady Gaga’s musicality chemistry is OUT OF THIS WORLD. Their ranges as duos is really fire 🔥. I’m just dying of full joyfulness in my heart. I do love your reactions so good and sincere, full of soul.
This is a great reaction! I read this somewhere else, so take it for what it is, but apparently LG went back into the studio to re-record the part where she has the cigarette in her mouth, by having an actual cigarette in her mouth so that it would sound more authentic. If this is true, and it completely sounds to me like something she would do, that's exactly the kind of authenticity I expect from her. The professionalism of these two together is really astounding. And it looks like they were actually enjoying themselves too!
I heard this only a couple of minutes ago and followed a link and it brought me to you. I’m so glad it did, as you reacted to this song the same way as I did, my heart just melted! I could listen to this over & over for the next 20 years! ❤ I can watch your video the same 😊xxx
Fantastic reaction and analysis. I love listening to a vocal expert and teacher go deeper into Bruno Mars' singing ability and vocal technique. He is so unique in his tone and style. Of course, Gaga is a powerhouse and they blended together so so well. I'm glad I found your channel. (Liked and subscribed) ☺
Lady Gaga is literally one of if not the best Fem Artists of today, the way she can just insantly synergize with multiple male leads instantly and the way she's so powerful with it at the same time blows me away
I knew there was a reason the first time I heard this i was totally all in and totally captivated hairs stand up and chills up my spine so powerfully affected my soul angels singing!!!
Bruno is a perfectionist. With that much confidence there's no room for insecurities. It's how he envisions it. Awesome composition. The collaboration, just beautiful.
The combination of the tempo, lyrics, note choices, precise and intentional vocal performances (on the part of both artists) feels so melancholy, which really grips and draws me in. Finally a song with real singing!
this song brought me to tears immediately the first time i heard ! i wait for gems like this to occassion come around with full melodies beautiful arangements and emotion for dayreal melodie 16:20and 16:34 arrangements and incredable depth of
You might have added: (1) he says the word "I" *twice* at the opening, beautifully guiding the audience to *listen* carefully; (2) he hits that "d" at the end of the word "hold" just hard enough to stress that he means it, literally, as in "hold onto you"; and (3) they both drop down softly when they say, separately, "just for a while", and both go big and dramatic -- reminding us we're talking about the possible end of the world -- when they sing it together during the close. That "just for a while" a great phrase to place in the lyric just before the words "and *DIE*", which they hit extra hard. Romance and the apocalypse sit right next to one another. Thanks for your wonderful, enlightening explication.
Best Reaction and breakdown ever. I just love that you don't pause every 2 seconds. You listen, take your time, break it down and listen again. Also so much valuable information for me, that just lines up how I felt listening to that song the first time. Now I know why it felt so good... thanks for that
❤the best reaction so far. Really enjoyed it. I love Bruno Mars the first part is amazing til the end with Lady Gaga harmonizing... Genius, legends. Streaming hard now. You earn my sub. Thank you.
I absolutely love this song,it's insanely good I didn't realise we needed this collab but we 100% did!! I've listened to it everyday more than twice. I even love gaga's dancing it's my favourite part..
The first 2 times I was able to hear just snippets of this song I had zero clue who was involved yet INSTANTLY deeply appreciated how pretty the voices and rest of how the song was crafted. Zoned in Wishing and waiting for it to repeat so I could capture what it was. So now....I can't stop listening to it. Thankfully no longer crying lol What a beautiful rendition of painful longing and lose. That's my take.
OMG ! I just heard this! First song I’ve heard in years that inspired me. Was so excited to find your video as I desperately wanted to discuss it with someone who had the same feeling I had!! It’s so so brilliant- not just the brilliant vocals but the brilliant songwriting!! 🎉🎉🎉
Wanna learn to sing? Start here... Join my free course! chrisliepe.com/free-your-voice/
The first proper song that truly deserves to be in the charts in years.
Amen 🙏
after Leave the Door Open?
I wouldn't say the first in years, but defo more worthy than the large majority of music in the charts
i must say 2023 and the first half of 2024 were shit
Bruno killed it once again💯🔥
The thing with Lady Gaga is that she instantly develops an insane and convincing chemistry with whoever male leads. And her voice fits any genre. She is an artistic chameleon!
❤❤And thats why she is Mother Monster, put your paws up Little Monsters ❤❤
This! I swear this is why I have loved her since forever!🤩
She's pure art.
🌹
i saw this exact comment under another video😂
She really has overflowing charisma without singing a note. Your eye is just drawn to her.
Gaga and Bruno did NOT disappoint
Stefanie and Peter did not disappoint
Gaga is a great vocalist, a true artist. A wonderful duo.
I think Bruno is the star here, amazing voice and such a lovely personality, Gaga is of course fantastic as well. It's actually a great match musically.
LG can sing anything. To sing with Bruno, Metallica, Tony Bennett, Ariana grande, Bradley cooper, Florence Welch, and Beyoncé really proves that she’s probably one of the most versatile vocalists in music.
And let’s not forget the ROLLING STONES🥰😍
Don’t forget the Rolling Stones and Elton John, powerhouses in the business
Her sound of music performance at the Oscars is the most vocally impressive thing she’s done
💯
She definitely went back and rerecorded singing the ciggy part so that it sounded like she had a cigarette. It sounds nuts... but she CLEARLY did it.
Yes!!! I was waiting for someone to say this!
@@evanalexandr I love it! So so fun
Ty yes
Most of the time I hate reactors who keeps repeating each part but when it comes to this I like those reactors repeating each part of this song 😂
it’s because dude knows what he’s talking about and how to explain it properly. that’s why I also like it when a reactor is more specific (in this case a vocal coach, or others like a video editor reacting to a cool music video, or maybe a dancer reacting to the dance)
Same, and then it's helpful with the replay to hear what they explained
Because the song is sooo good that each part is okay to be repeated over and over again
Well, watching people react with zero knowledge in music can get boring quickly
This is the song of the year 2024.
Thank me later 😁🙌
Totally agree ❤
Thank ME later❤
Espresso and birds of a feather are good competition but yeah, Bruno Mars might be too legendary for both Billie and Sabrina.
Really hope it's thrown somewhere in Joker 2, just to get a shot for an Oscar. A solid contender.
Bruno Mars never fails, it's insane. I already KNOW the album is gonna be a Classic ✅
I’m listening to it the second it comes out
@@Juanthemtg same ✅
I heard it's not going to be in either of their albums. That it's just a single they duet'ed.
what album?
Absolutely love Bruno Mars. I had actually not heard that much about him a couple of years ago, then he was interviewed on a show here in Sweden and I was floored by his laid back & funny personality. He's an amazing musician.
we all missed bruno mars so much 😩 he takes forever to make new music but its such a heavenly treat when he does
it's so refreshing when artists come back strong and stay true to their sound without trying to chase the current trends
What an amazing reaction to a timeless classic of a song. Gaga’s unexpected run to enter the song always gets me and their voices blend so well
Me too! That soft run is everything!!!❤
Bruno's songs always have nuance. Make you imagine a story behind.
This!!!! It's also the reason why it's hard to cover his songs. You can maybe hit the high notes but the delivery and technique to convey the emotional depth and impact of the song will always fall short.
I never liked his first album... but with his second album he definitely stepped into his retro pastiche bag. He studies the greats, definitely. And so does Gaga.
I cannot WAIT to see this performed at the Grammys!!❤
This is real music. A complete well made song. Haven't heard one in a long while. Bruno Mars is a true legend with the perfect voice.
I bet Lady Gaga re-recorded her section just for the video. It does sound like she sings with a cigarette and it’s NOT on the audio version 😂
Yea I think so too. Just for the theatrics 🤣
This is what happens when two perennial musical students pair up. Their tonal quality is almost like a yin and yang. He leans toward more aspirate and she leans toward more chord closure. They also use their vocal fry similarly. But their blend is beautiful. And the play between minor and major chords really tugs at the heartstrings. It also has that brill building wall of sound feel in the production. Literally no other two artists could have pulled this off. This won’t trend on tik tok but it should to teach these kinds on that platform how to construct a perfect pop song.
I commented this in the actual music video, but gosh this is so 2010s IN A GOOD WAY and they both seems to be enjoying the project so much... oh simpler times....
Or late 2000s Toni Braxton and Babyface type of duets back in those days
This gives classic '70s duets the house down boots. '10s was too much EDM and trap hip hop for me.
2 artists I don't really listen to very often but this song is a damn treat.
Beautiful performance. Awesome analysis. The highlight for me was… “They take their work seriously but when it comes to their presentation they have fun… they are free… confident not arrogant.” Yes, you feel it. You see it and it draws you in. Every video you do speaks to the vocal student in me in different and specific ways. Thank you again Chris 🙏🥰
Also each of the facial expressions in the video is very detailed! Not only music wise! the fun look really is a serious work! so gooood!
That's real music right here!! I was missing songs like this one
6:57 the “OH” 😂 Yes, it gave me goosebumps, too
😂
I'm no expert in music, but what I really, really admire and appreciate about Bruno Mars is that whenever he sings his songs he makes it a point to change the arrangement a little bit (but not making it too different) especially in concerts and TV shows. He puts a new perspective on it whether it be an amazing new addition to the choregraphy or adding an extra musical instrument to highlight some parts, etc. He makes his own songs "new" again to the eyes and ears of the listeners. But more importantly, it's his big effort that I appreciate most in pleasing his fans and his audience. I mean, he can just sing and we will all go ga-ga over him! But, nope, he goes the extra mile and make everything fresh again. And, he never runs out of ideas even though he sings the same hit song! It's amazing! He is a genius!!! Thank you, Bruno! Glad you are in this generation!
Would like to add he has that great laid back personality as well. Seems as if he doesn't take himself too serious if you know what I mean. Whilst there are other musicians out there, great ones yes, but sometimes with egos so big, they seem to think they are greater than greatest and some gift to humanity... which unfortunately at times, clouds ones feelings about the music they make. Bruno is definitely not in that category.
@@anniezion Very true! Bruno has no superiority complex whatsoever even though he is so talented! He has been writing songs for famous artists, and yet he has no problem taking the back seat! A totally classy guy!
Bruno could easily be a rock vocalist, his controlled grit/distortion in his voice is always satisfying to hear
This has the potential to be one of the greatest love songs ever!
A masterpiece. Totally took me back to the 70's in the best way.
Right. Gotta love the seventies sound!
This song instantly took me back to the early 70's as a 12 yr old girl with hints of the Carpenters harmonizing and and mix of minor and major keys. Wow, what a song. It made me tear up at the end!! ❤❤❤
WOW! OMG! Lyrics are unbelievable heart-wrenching!
Bruno Mars' placement shifts are FUCKING heavenly.
Bruno Mars and Lady Gaga’s musicality chemistry is OUT OF THIS WORLD. Their ranges as duos is really fire 🔥. I’m just dying of full joyfulness in my heart. I do love your reactions so good and sincere, full of soul.
This song gives me legitimate goosebumps.
Two of the best singers and it didnt dissapoint. Absolutely beautiful
You can tell that Bruno Mars studied Michael Jackson’s gritty singing style growing up because you can hear it in his screams.
Best reaction to this music video. Love how you explain the intricacies of good vocal production.
Bruno's use of dynamics through power and grit is so rare in a mainstream artist. Your analysis of this track is the best ive seen :)
IM SO GLAD YOU CAUGHT THAT MINOR NOTE AND MAJOR NOTE RIGHT BEFORE THE HOOK!!!!! That note made me scream
IKR???!!!! I’ve watch so many reaction videos to this video and I’ve only seen 2 people mention it!!
I love how giddy he got, it was the same reaction I had when I first heard it! Too bad so many people keep missing it in their reaction videos!
love that you literally went into it with no intro. this song was fucking amazing
So happy that Bruno is back. He is a major creative!! Everything about this song is perfection! Duo w GaGa is brilliant!! ❤❤❤
This song is a masterpiece in writing, vocal performance and production! Amazing!
This is a great reaction! I read this somewhere else, so take it for what it is, but apparently LG went back into the studio to re-record the part where she has the cigarette in her mouth, by having an actual cigarette in her mouth so that it would sound more authentic. If this is true, and it completely sounds to me like something she would do, that's exactly the kind of authenticity I expect from her. The professionalism of these two together is really astounding. And it looks like they were actually enjoying themselves too!
She did, that was confirmed, only she would commit that much to authenticity 🙈🤣🤣
I heard this only a couple of minutes ago and followed a link and it brought me to you. I’m so glad it did, as you reacted to this song the same way as I did, my heart just melted! I could listen to this over & over for the next 20 years! ❤ I can watch your video the same 😊xxx
The best part of this video is Chris' excitement. Like a kid that just got a new puppy.
Thank you Chris, you are always a treat!
Actually one of the best songs in a while…. 🩵🤍
Great reaction🤩Bruno is an absolute perfectionist and so creative, that is why he takes his time in making music. He also co directed the video😍
Agree, he's👌
Fantastic reaction and analysis. I love listening to a vocal expert and teacher go deeper into Bruno Mars' singing ability and vocal technique. He is so unique in his tone and style. Of course, Gaga is a powerhouse and they blended together so so well.
I'm glad I found your channel. (Liked and subscribed) ☺
Literally two musical geniuses together. I was not expecting that but it was incredibly delivered.
Lady Gaga is literally one of if not the best Fem Artists of today, the way she can just insantly synergize with multiple male leads instantly and the way she's so powerful with it at the same time blows me away
I knew there was a reason the first time I heard this i was totally all in and totally captivated hairs stand up and chills up my spine so powerfully affected my soul angels singing!!!
Yes i think we all heard that part gaga singing with a cigarette in her mouth in sync with the video, thats such a power move and it's fun😂
This was pure ART! Something we haven't seen or heard in DECADES! ❤❤❤❤
I'm so glad someone else reacts to every note of this song exactly the same way as I did!!!!! Chills!!!
Love your reaction. Bruno is always amazing
He is so interesting & talented describing how this song sounds technically ❤ love Bruno & Ga Ga 😍
That minor to major flip was insane! Loved this
"I'd wanna hold you JUST FOR A WHILE"
my heart melts ❤
Bruno is a perfectionist. With that much confidence there's no room for insecurities. It's how he envisions it. Awesome composition. The collaboration, just beautiful.
I thought I loved this song enough already, but your analysis and genuine reaction has me even more obsessed with this track 😖
The combination of the tempo, lyrics, note choices, precise and intentional vocal performances (on the part of both artists) feels so melancholy, which really grips and draws me in. Finally a song with real singing!
I just need to confirm this song is going to be one of the very best of All time.
By far the best reaction I’ve seen. Very thorough. Loved it!
You give the most intelligent review that I’ve watched of this song.
Appreciate your musical knowledge.
When they both sang with their grit voices before the second chorus, it's game over for me 😅 Loved your detailed reaction
So glad you did this video. I've had this song on repeat for the last 3 days straight.
LADY GAGA!!!!!!!!! YOU ARE A TALENT!!! AND BRUNO MY GOD!! BEST VOICE!! BOTH OF YOU ROCK
It’s always the vocal coaches that interest me to watch these reactions. They validate the artistry of these legends! ❤
this song brought me to tears immediately the first time i heard ! i wait for gems like this to occassion come around with full melodies beautiful arangements and emotion for dayreal melodie 16:20and 16:34 arrangements and incredable depth of
They are two of the best singers on the entire planet hands down... they sound AMAZING together!
What a great song
Bruno Mars🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I think this is Bruno's best song ever. It's iconic
You might have added: (1) he says the word "I" *twice* at the opening, beautifully guiding the audience to *listen* carefully; (2) he hits that "d" at the end of the word "hold" just hard enough to stress that he means it, literally, as in "hold onto you"; and (3) they both drop down softly when they say, separately, "just for a while", and both go big and dramatic -- reminding us we're talking about the possible end of the world -- when they sing it together during the close. That "just for a while" a great phrase to place in the lyric just before the words "and *DIE*", which they hit extra hard. Romance and the apocalypse sit right next to one another. Thanks for your wonderful, enlightening explication.
Bruno is 🔥 him & lady gaga put a masterpiece collaboration together that is awesome!! Love this song!!😀👍
Never enjoyed any analysis of a song like this one. You are good Chris...much love❤🇿🇦
Best Reaction and breakdown ever. I just love that you don't pause every 2 seconds. You listen, take your time, break it down and listen again. Also so much valuable information for me, that just lines up how I felt listening to that song the first time. Now I know why it felt so good... thanks for that
❤the best reaction so far. Really enjoyed it. I love Bruno Mars the first part is amazing til the end with Lady Gaga harmonizing... Genius, legends. Streaming hard now. You earn my sub. Thank you.
This for the Joker movie that she is in. and it is so beautiful!
One of the best reaction I’ve seen… perfection! Love it. New subscriber here!
I absolutely love this song,it's insanely good I didn't realise we needed this collab but we 100% did!! I've listened to it everyday more than twice. I even love gaga's dancing it's my favourite part..
Thank you for being the only one to react to that heavenly picardy third 🥺
The first 2 times I was able to hear just snippets of this song I had zero clue who was involved yet INSTANTLY deeply appreciated how pretty the voices and rest of how the song was crafted. Zoned in
Wishing and waiting for it to repeat so I could capture what it was.
So now....I can't stop listening to it. Thankfully no longer crying lol
What a beautiful rendition of painful longing and lose. That's my take.
❤ your reaction!
Back again. Please do their live performance.
This is the song of the year , it’s stunningly beautiful in every way. This will be a classic song
Song of the year
You nailed every best parts of Bruno and Lady Gaga! The best review of this song. ❤
17:39 I think it sounds more like film ticking and clouds moving at the end, like the credits of a movie, (joker 2 end credits maybe?)
I this is a great song and a duet a beautiful song ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤Bruno and my lady the best
OMG ! I just heard this! First song I’ve heard in years that inspired me. Was so excited to find your video as I desperately wanted to discuss it with someone who had the same feeling I had!! It’s so so brilliant- not just the brilliant vocals but the brilliant songwriting!! 🎉🎉🎉
Amazing analysis! 10:52 that high note is crazy
Profound analysis. The best I have seen and known so far.
That breathy ending is also in Lady Gaga's song "I'll Never Love Again extended version"❤❤
So flipping amazing!
The thought of an album collaboration doing duet.. omg
The best reaction so far of this song! Love the repeat😂
is so fucking good, I can't wait to dedicate this to my loved one
you did the best reaction to this beautiful music, I think!!!
Powerhouse collab ❤
Eargasm!!!
So far! You made the best reaction video to this song!! Thanks, Chris~