@@LuisTren7 It's SO frustrating. One channel can upload the song playing all the way through with no stops and doesn't get flagged, and some upload a video with 30 seconds playing without interruption and get a worldwide BLOCK. You can appeal the block, but that takes time and then you miss the excitement for the song. I've talked to other channels, and talked to RUclips also and no one really has an answer.
@@chrisliepe I see. Thanks Chris for replying. You have such great analysis and love your passion for what u did.Thank you! I know you are busy with lists music to react to. If you have the time can you react to vocal group south korea called "Mamamoo" love your breakdown of their song "HIP" mv or "Piano man" Besides their top unique vocals, their label does really interesting things with their music productions in sounds that think might be interesting to hear prfo of what's going on in music.. Thanks Chris.
I love the way you react and explain things so much I feel like you’d like diving into will wood (and the tape worms) like cotards solution (anatta, dukkha, anicca) Front street jimmy mushrooms last drink bedtime in Wayne love, me normally Well better than the alternative blackbox warrior OKULTRA The Song with Five Names, a.k.a. Soapbox Tao, a.k.a. Checkmate Atheists! a.k.a. Neospace Government, a.k.a. You Can Never Know He has so many genres and I never find good reactions to his vocal abilities and how he goes from screaming like a lunatic to singing softy in things like Misanthrapologist highly recommend his music he does so many genres
Rosé plays the piano, the guitar and the drums, she's also a songwriter and has co produced her upcoming debut album droping on december 6th. She's an amazing artist that needs to be more recognized. You should listen to her song GONE, is a beautiful pop ballad.
I fell in love with Rosé after watching Light Up the Sky documentary on Netflix and saw how much she loves music. She is obsessed with music and stays up all night because she can’t stop thinking about ideas. She also does extra studio sessions trying out new things and experimenting. She truly loves music.
@@chrisliepe APT its her song, she sent 3 songs to bruno and he decided to do this and she almost erase this song cause is about a Korean drinking game
@@arminarlert6871 if you got a notification that someone disliked your comment, that was just me tapping the wrong icon. I actually like it and changed my reaction 👍
@@judymowatt3904it's so beneath him" what? Rosé literally sent him 3 demos and out of thise three, this is what he chose so it's evidently not something he was hesitant about. Plus, knowing a bit of context is often helpful. The lyrics chant 아파트 (ah-pah-teu) in the chorus, which is the Korean word for apartment. More importantly tho, the repetition of apt in that specific rhythm is the chant of a Korean drinking game. Even before the actual song starts, Rosé says (in Korean) "Chaeyoung's (Rosé's Korean name) favorite random game, random game, game start" which is what is said between the different rounds of the drinking game. Not all lyrics have to be hard hitting or elaborate, sometimes having fun is enough. It seemed to be for Bruno Mars at least, because he wanted to join the song before he even knew what it is about. So it's kind of crazy to me that you seem to decide what is below or befitting for him when he obviously doesn't think that way. Plus, I think it is pretty impressive for Rosé to get people worldwide to sing the chant of a pretty niche Korean game and promote her culture that way. That in and of itself is pretty meaningful to me
I love how every reaction is people giving Rose her flowers and then when they come to Bruno they say well it’s BRUNO he don’t need farther introduction
Rose came with the idea for the song and wrote it and sent to Bruno Along with 2 other songs. Bruno liked this song and then they with other writers completed the song. Bruno Mars is the main producer for this.
Both Rose and Bruno have achieved their biggest streams for a song on Spotify with APT, both also had biggest debut of their career on Spotify with APT. APT broken streaming records on multiple Asian countries. It was a guaranteed hit in Asia since the song about Korean drinking game and Rose has like crazy number of fans in Asia especially korea and China.
For Bruno Mars, I think it's still Die With A Smile (his song with Lady Gaga), since it is still the number one in terms of daily streams based on his spotify.
Thank you!! Your encouragement is wonderful and lifts me up... It's so funny haha... (sort of) I got this comment and then right above it one that said: "This kid talks too much". I guess people see/hear things more differently than I can even relate to.
I love the lightheartedness and fun in this collab. The complexity of the production is just chef kiss! Bruno is an amazing producer and Rose and him killed it!!
Rose just hit #1 on the Global & US Spotify charts. A first for a Korean Female or Asian artist. Also, broke the top 10 on Itunes charts. Again a first for a female Korean artist. Rose just keeps breaking her own records, so Goated!! 🌹🔥
She hit jackpot by collabing with Bruno Mars, she's getting those records bc of him, yes she maybe the main writer of the song but without Bruno's name and production on the song, she wouldn't be able to get these records
In 2021, Rosé released her first solo song, "On the Ground", and it achieved two Guiness world records. #1 for being the first artist to reach number one on a Billboard Global chart as a soloist and as part of a group. #2 for the most viewed RUclips music video in 24 hours by a solo K-pop artist with 41.6 million views
@Vee_nazzWashington Did you know Bruno picked APT out of the tracks Rose sent him? There were three in total, and Rose almost deleted it because of the fears about the inspiration. Credit where it's due here. It takes two to make a collaboration work. Don't ride Rose off here just because it has Bruno Mars in the title, just saying. :/
@@theresag.4188 I think no, the other one I think most successful member, the one who performed at Victoria's Secret, Rose only getting her spotlight now after collaborating with Bruno
Just when I thought I couldn’t love Bruno Mars’ voice and talent any more. Thank you for the detailed analysis and helping me appreciate the art even more!
You are so right about Bruno, he is a perfectionist when it comes to his Music. That is why he takes time in making albums, so we just have to be patient.
She is a main singer and lead dancer in Blackpink Whatever song she sings She sings with emotions and deliver it 💯 Watch all her covers especially collection cover from sea of hopes And pachinko season 2 song 🎵 👌 ❤
The difference why Bruno songs always slap is because he actually makes music. The words are front and center. They aren’t drowning in a sea of cover up drunks and pads. This song is fucking great.
This collab is really a breath of fresh air from all the "baddie" vibes kpop (which I'm a fan of) releases. Really love it. I love the geeky guitar part you explained too! Made me appreciate it more!
Bruno is the whole package: singer, songwriter, multi-instrumentalist, producer, dancer, choreographer, and music video director. People tend to forget what a talented producer he is even though he has twice been nominated for Grammy's Producer of the Year, Non-Classical. Bruno produced this song with Rogét Chahayed, Omer Fedi, and Henry Walter (Cirkut). Would assume the other three are producing the additional songs for Rosé's new album.
I'm glad I found ur reaction man... I've noticed some ppl really like the song but also mention how it's great and "simple" when in fact there's so much detail that bruno had inserted in that u picked out that made this song so much more ez on the ears
Omg, what a great reaction! loved the knowledge, it's great to understand why we like the things we like in songs, hope you do one of these when rosé releases her album on december 6th
I like your reaction ! You really deep dive into those small details that 99% of us don't every catch, and it really improves our perception of the song in its entire complexity :) Your passion is really communicative and likeable !
You haven’t heard of Rosé before? You’re in for a treat. Sometimes I’m jealous of people who haven’t heard Sea of Hope or her many covers on the Blackpink RUclips channel. Rosé is Korea’s Golden Voice and such a unique talent who is in love with music.
Damnnnnnnnn i love how you break this down! Very technical like it comes from a sound engineer. As an engineer myself i love to hear the technical nuances that makes the details so important
Everyone glazing Rosé so I might as well Glaze Bruno. He can play drums, guitar, piano, and ukelele. He also produces his own songs. He adds in a dancs break in songs like Perm, Finesse, 24k Magic and Runaway Baby. These are just phenomenal. He's also made countless songs for other people. He made All I ask for Adele, Forget You for Ceelo Green, and Young Wild & Free. Forgot to mention that this song isn't even his best vocal performance as compared to When I Was Your Man (The official audio has nothing else except him and his piano he played live), If I knew, Gorilla, Too Good to say Goodbye, All I ask (The live studio recording on BBC), majority of silk sonic, live btw. I highly recommend checking these out. Good examples of his great collabs where he flexes his vocals are Lighters, Mirror and Please Me. Bruno also has a great amount of variety in his songs. He can make any type of song from Rock (Runaway Baby), Reggae (Show Me), and obviously pop. Not listing all. Proof of him playing Guitar and Singing at the same time is his live studio recording of Locked out of heaven. For Piano, he's played When I was your man on Piano while riffing extremely difficult notes LIVE. And on top of that he's extremely underrated despite his many famous songs like Just the way you are. Even with his amazing vocals, he's fine with not being the lead and letting others take the spotlight like here with Rosé. He could've done so much but he decided to be Rosé's back up because he's so humble. Despite his popularity, people aren't giving him enough credit man!!!
You hit the nail on the head on this song in terms of vocals - no noticeable auto tune at all - no robotic like sounds. Real vocals finessed in the studio. Wonderful review. Because the song didn’t have a lot of frills, people think it’s simple. But it’s really not -it’s because it is well-produced, and Bruno and Rosé actually sing that they make it look easy. Thank you for explaining the discipline it takes to create something that sounds ‘simple’. One of Rosé 2 earlier singles released in 2021 - a folksy love song ‘Gone’ was often described as simple - but the beauty of it is in its seeming simplicity. The instrumentation does not have a lot of frills, so you get to focus on her voice which then carries the story and emotion and heartbreak of the song. And by the way, she co-wrote this song too - ruclips.net/video/K9_VFxzCuQ0/видео.htmlfeature=shared
I just love the way that you are not only so genuinely excited by the musicality, but how you are able to essentially explain to me in fairly simple terms what it is about that musicality that makes me love this song so much. I knew right from the get-go that I loved this track, it's been on repeat for me since it dropped, but now I have some insight into why that is!
Because of all the stuff you noticed in the first half I didn’t even consider, I caught on the “Whatevah” noise on Bruno’s verse before you even mentioned it. I think you just made me more observant of all these production tactics haha. Great review man. I love to see all the different perspectives on this. Appreciate how this one is so production focused. I’ve also seen a reaction by an editor that’s geeking out about the music video concept and editing.
Thank you for your amazing reaction and analysis!! I have very little knowledge about music production /theory /technique. I just listen. So watching you point out many details of the song makes me enjoy listening more and more ☺ (Not just this one, but the other many songs on your reaction channel too!!) Great job as always.
Great reaction video! I’ve watched this music video 50 times at this point and you pointed out some great harmonies I missed 😂 bc they’re so understated but so amazing once you notice it. I’m so happy to see Rosé happy and having superstar success as a solo performer. Her album on December 06 is going to be the album of the decade. Her voice is so unique and powerful.
That remark about Bruno Mars recording for hours for one moment reminds of that maxim. (Pardon if I mess it up) "Record like you can't mix, mix like you can't master." It's a cool song. It reminds me of "That's not my Name" song. Same vibe or groove maybe.
Thanks so much for this great review and breakdown! Here's one of Rosé's other solo hits: ON THE GROUND (solo) ruclips.net/video/CKZvWhCqx1sF/видео.html ...and PLEASE check out her performances on SEA OF HOPE, a TV show about celebrities who opened a seaside café, they cooked, and performed on the beach for the customers. Rosé was the first special guest on the show, she played guitar and keyboards on a few songs as well: *THE ONLY EXCEPTION* by Paramore ruclips.net/video/2DUdg4dnse8/видео.html *READ MY MIND* by the Killers ruclips.net/video/_r92v-T4gSU/видео.html ...and her heartbreaking cover of *TIME SPENT WALKING THROUGH MEMORIES* by Nell (turn on subtitles) ruclips.net/video/mrUU_L-pfRU/видео.html
Terrific analysis and breakdown. It's worth noting that Mike Chapman, responsible for multiple 70s-80s hits, was involved in the songwriting. Worth also noting, this is ROSÉ's song, her project, and bringing Bruno in on it was her idea. The major kudos for how it turned out must go to her. Her years of training at YG and recording with Teddy and Blackpink and her natural ear hasn't gone to waste. You can hear her use of layered harmony on her other previous solo work, especially in On The Ground, and with Blackpink.
Glad you added this. I've been surprised to find a lot of the Bruno reactors have no idea who Rose is, which is pretty wild eight years after Blackpink's debut. Blinks know though that Rose lives and breaths music. She's soaked up all the lessons from Teddy and applied them to a song that at least has to harken back to all those pop songs she loved singing in the car when the family was driving someplace. I knew Rocker Rosie was in there someplace but I never expected anything like this. I know it's a huge hit, but it also feels like Rosie has finally blossomed and created something both nostalgic and modern at the same time. I can't imagine what the rest of the songs on the album are going to be like, but we're probably just going to be stunned. Her talent has ripped free of the YG bonds and she's shown us what she's capable of. Just awesome...
Might dont know but she born in New Zealand and lived in Australia ,before moved Korea so some of her words like "hearth" are also has Aussie accent which makes her English singing even better. and for 4:32 , Yes she is a drummer, she can play drums, gitar, piano and even ukulele , she showed before.
Holy crap. This reaction is NEXT LEVEL. Totally subscribing. I learned a lot!! Although I was surprised, given your incredible attention to detail, that you didn’t notice the Breakfast Club dance moves. But you were very distracted by the musical stuff. Really great reaction video!! I actually shared it with some people, and I almost never share reaction videos. 🤷♀️💘🏆
Welcome to Korea's "Golden Voice" Rosie! I'm an American and quickly became a Blink which is what the Fandom of BlackPink the group Rosie is part of. There are 4 just as equally talented ladies who have smashed global records from Guiness to maaannnny countries charts. Rose in particular is aptly called The Golden Voice.I suggest listening to her other 2 solos so far On The Ground and Gone to hear her range and vocal abilities. I don't know if you are planning on trying BlackPink which I highly recommend. (Just check out reviewers numbers.) We show up to reviews for the ladies in droves and we are legion. Supporting our girls, loving seeing them be discovered as well. She and Bruno are at 89 million views as I type and still steadily going. It's the duo I didn't know I needed. Also, also all 4 of the girlies have solos between their BlackPink albums. The world tour was sold out so fast a year or so back that they gave us an encore tour in many cities and even love and appreciate their fans enough for Jennie to rework and make a music video dedicated to us I appreciation.
Great analysis from a real expert so I joined the channel! This is so well done, and a great visual layout where the artists image occupies mor space than the reviewers. This song will really wake people up tpo the fact that Rose is a true musician/singer/songwriter of Blackpink. She will be innundated with collab requests from Western artists!
for reference the song is based on a korean drinking game the "apateu apateu apateu" is the chant you say while playing the game and she conceptualized it with such fun word play with the "meet me at the apateu" (which stands for apartment in english) it's so clever!! thanks for showing her love! this was a really great review super informative on just how excellent this production is💗
I love how you broke down the details! So informative & you do it in such a way where now i want to learn from you! A new subscriber here! Im an avid kpop listener&I love Rosé and Bruno so much! Thank you for reacting to this song.
THANKFUL U REACTED TO ROSÉ WHICH LED TO MY DISCOVERY OF U !! sooo technical so good ! hope u can react to rosé’s album out on dec 6 she worked on all 12 songs
Big BlackPink fan here, and who doesn't love them some Bruno Mars. This collab seemingly came out of nowhere, and I love it! You made me appreciate the song that much more. Loved the analysis!
Hey Chris. First time to your site. I’ve been searching and watching whatever reaction videos I’ve found bcuz I wanted to see if other people had a similar reaction to mine. Doing this was a first too. Basically broke down into, “opinions, like bellybuttons, everybody has one”….mostly based on personal preference (for and against), and occasionally on knowledge of music and or video construction--like yourself. Your analysis at the end was money. People can like it or not for whatever reasons, your breakdown was refreshing. All the subtleties that go into building the video seem to be missed by reactors and just grouped into a larger….I Like It effect. This is for the sound and visuals, both of which are used so effectively for the transitions. Components less mentioned, occasionally, but not often, in reactions: two-tone black & pink color scheme (connection to the BP group), lightening animations at impact/accent points, including finger snaps, throwback dance moves--- the Carlton, breakfast club movie, and earlier to the 1960’s Monkees show, excessively large, non typical bass drum, switch of forward position between Bruno and rose, in the video set, on the drums, and in the vocal mix, when they are featured, the build in the layers of harmony and fill instrument volumes across the track from more sparse to full, and…., as you point out, in the “Hold on” section, your expectations are set up with the 3-time repeated Bm, A, D, B progression, then on the transition at the 4th, they do Bm, A, then drop in the E and bang on it instead of the D. Masterful. The only time it appears in the song. If you watch the faces of people doing reaction videos, the faces of the ones paying attention change to a surprised look on that one chord. This video is like a great soup with all kinds of interesting ingredients that combine beautifully. And the beat is infectious, the whole thing is addicting.
APT is Apart(아파트)=Korean Apartment Complex, also Korean famous Drinking game with kiss, dance game start with 아파트 아파트~ 아파트 아파트~ only two people, black n pink color, one room pure art n the show "Simple is Best" best 2024 song 😍
You know? Bruno Mars is the directer of this song's music video. He is the one of the songwriters and he arranged this song. He is also the producer. This is not just Rose's song. If you think so, you don't deserve this song's music video first. Some people are so rude to Bruno Mars. Bruno Mars is not just something. Bruno Mars is The something. Thank you for the great reviews, sincerely.
![Stromae, Pomme - “Ma Meilleure Ennemie” (from Arcane Season 2) [Official Visualizer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1F3OGIFnW1k/mqdefault.jpg)
Learn to connect with your own voice and pull true character and interest out of it. Join my free course! chrisliepe.com/free-your-voice/
chris just curious, i saw 100 reactions same song here. Only 2 had some filter on? Their reason why some get copyright and the rest dont?
@@LuisTren7 It's SO frustrating. One channel can upload the song playing all the way through with no stops and doesn't get flagged, and some upload a video with 30 seconds playing without interruption and get a worldwide BLOCK. You can appeal the block, but that takes time and then you miss the excitement for the song. I've talked to other channels, and talked to RUclips also and no one really has an answer.
@@chrisliepe I see. Thanks Chris for replying. You have such great analysis and love your passion for what u did.Thank you! I know you are busy with lists music to react to. If you have the time can you react to vocal group south korea called "Mamamoo" love your breakdown of their song "HIP" mv or "Piano man" Besides their top unique vocals, their label does really interesting things with their music productions in sounds that think might be interesting to hear prfo of what's going on in music.. Thanks Chris.
5ㅇ 5🎉5ㅇ 나 23@@LuisTren7
I love the way you react and explain things so much I feel like you’d like diving into will wood (and the tape worms) like
cotards solution (anatta, dukkha, anicca)
Front street
jimmy mushrooms last drink
bedtime in Wayne
love, me normally
Well better than the alternative
blackbox warrior OKULTRA
The Song with Five Names, a.k.a. Soapbox Tao, a.k.a. Checkmate Atheists! a.k.a. Neospace Government, a.k.a. You Can Never Know
He has so many genres and I never find good reactions to his vocal abilities and how he goes from screaming like a lunatic to singing softy in things like Misanthrapologist highly recommend his music he does so many genres
Rosé plays the piano, the guitar and the drums, she's also a songwriter and has co produced her upcoming debut album droping on december 6th. She's an amazing artist that needs to be more recognized. You should listen to her song GONE, is a beautiful pop ballad.
Wow! So multi talented!
I fell in love with Rosé after watching Light Up the Sky documentary on Netflix and saw how much she loves music. She is obsessed with music and stays up all night because she can’t stop thinking about ideas. She also does extra studio sessions trying out new things and experimenting. She truly loves music.
And i recommend her other singles... hard to Love and On the Ground... ITS cool. ..Please listen @@chrisliepe 🤗👍🏻🌹
@@chrisliepe APT its her song, she sent 3 songs to bruno and he decided to do this and she almost erase this song cause is about a Korean drinking game
She's a part of BLACKPINK. You should check out their music! They got like 95 million subs on youtube.
@@arminarlert6871 if you got a notification that someone disliked your comment, that was just me tapping the wrong icon. I actually like it and changed my reaction 👍
SHE HAS ONE OF THE MOST BEAUTIFUL VOICES ON THE PLANET ❤
One of the finest APT reviews ever seen. Great
I think THE BEST review
No Doubt, best review
This song is a catchy tune/beat, but it's so beneath him...the lyrics are so LAME. Ah pt?! Really?
@@judymowatt3904it’s not ah pt. it’s the name of korean drinking game (rose’s fave) and it’s a continuous topic of the song from the beginning
@@judymowatt3904it's so beneath him" what? Rosé literally sent him 3 demos and out of thise three, this is what he chose so it's evidently not something he was hesitant about. Plus, knowing a bit of context is often helpful. The lyrics chant 아파트 (ah-pah-teu) in the chorus, which is the Korean word for apartment. More importantly tho, the repetition of apt in that specific rhythm is the chant of a Korean drinking game. Even before the actual song starts, Rosé says (in Korean) "Chaeyoung's (Rosé's Korean name) favorite random game, random game, game start" which is what is said between the different rounds of the drinking game. Not all lyrics have to be hard hitting or elaborate, sometimes having fun is enough. It seemed to be for Bruno Mars at least, because he wanted to join the song before he even knew what it is about. So it's kind of crazy to me that you seem to decide what is below or befitting for him when he obviously doesn't think that way. Plus, I think it is pretty impressive for Rosé to get people worldwide to sing the chant of a pretty niche Korean game and promote her culture that way. That in and of itself is pretty meaningful to me
I love how every reaction is people giving Rose her flowers and then when they come to Bruno they say well it’s BRUNO he don’t need farther introduction
Rose came with the idea for the song and wrote it and sent to Bruno Along with 2 other songs. Bruno liked this song and then they with other writers completed the song. Bruno Mars is the main producer for this.
Rosé is known as golden voice of Korea. I think the record needs to be extended as the 'world"
She's BLACKPINK's main vocalist after all.
*Golden voice of Australia
@@BogoBob*Golden voice of New Zealand
@@BogoBobif you wanna be technical. I wasn’t gonna correct them, but if you feel like correcting them, then get it right. She was born in New Zealand.
Both Rose and Bruno have achieved their biggest streams for a song on Spotify with APT, both also had biggest debut of their career on Spotify with APT.
APT broken streaming records on multiple Asian countries.
It was a guaranteed hit in Asia since the song about Korean drinking game and Rose has like crazy number of fans in Asia especially korea and China.
For Bruno Mars, I think it's still Die With A Smile (his song with Lady Gaga), since it is still the number one in terms of daily streams based on his spotify.
@@rangercynthNo, Rosé and bruno mars's apt is #1 on global spotify charts as of now surpassing die wit a smile
I didn't realize how big this song was! 🤯
You've got to have like the best possible reaction videos on youtube. SO informative and SO nerdy and passionate I LOVE IT!
Thank you!! Your encouragement is wonderful and lifts me up... It's so funny haha... (sort of) I got this comment and then right above it one that said: "This kid talks too much". I guess people see/hear things more differently than I can even relate to.
@@chrisliepe Some people forget the point of a reaction video, its fine 😂
I love the lightheartedness and fun in this collab. The complexity of the production is just chef kiss! Bruno is an amazing producer and Rose and him killed it!!
Rose just hit #1 on the Global & US Spotify charts. A first for a Korean Female or Asian artist. Also, broke the top 10 on Itunes charts. Again a first for a female Korean artist. Rose just keeps breaking her own records, so Goated!! 🌹🔥
She hit jackpot by collabing with Bruno Mars, she's getting those records bc of him, yes she maybe the main writer of the song but without Bruno's name and production on the song, she wouldn't be able to get these records
In 2021, Rosé released her first solo song, "On the Ground", and it achieved two Guiness world records. #1 for being the first artist to reach number one on a Billboard Global chart as a soloist and as part of a group. #2 for the most viewed RUclips music video in 24 hours by a solo K-pop artist with 41.6 million views
@Vee_nazzWashington Did you know Bruno picked APT out of the tracks Rose sent him? There were three in total, and Rose almost deleted it because of the fears about the inspiration.
Credit where it's due here. It takes two to make a collaboration work. Don't ride Rose off here just because it has Bruno Mars in the title, just saying. :/
I don't know much about BlackPink. Would you say she is the most successful out of all of them so far?
@@theresag.4188 I think no, the other one I think most successful member, the one who performed at Victoria's Secret, Rose only getting her spotlight now after collaborating with Bruno
Just when I thought I couldn’t love Bruno Mars’ voice and talent any more. Thank you for the detailed analysis and helping me appreciate the art even more!
You are so right about Bruno, he is a perfectionist when it comes to his Music. That is why he takes time in making albums, so we just have to be patient.
most in depth analysis of the song on youtube. gotta give u your props for that 👍
I noticed a lot of stuff in background that i'd missed, must be tricky to produce a track so complex and to make it "seem" simple.
Damn bro.. your details its crazy 🤘🏻🤘🏻
She is a main singer and lead dancer in Blackpink
Whatever song she sings
She sings with emotions and deliver it 💯
Watch all her covers especially collection cover from sea of hopes
And pachinko season 2 song 🎵 👌 ❤
Don't promote blackpink here it's about Rosé
Ohhh ...
That's true
I forgot
❤❤❤😮
I be cautious ⚠️ 🫂💃
@@krishnabali5054 but he can listen to blackpink too, after all rose's voices shines in all bp songs, and they are gonna have comeback next year
@@mero2627 then what? It's about Rosé
@@krishnabali5054 and what? is Rosé not in Blackpink anymore? Calm down, there's only so much Rosé solo content.
Bruno is a musical genius!
The difference why Bruno songs always slap is because he actually makes music. The words are front and center. They aren’t drowning in a sea of cover up drunks and pads. This song is fucking great.
Wow! Excellent analysis and reaction! Thank you
This collab is really a breath of fresh air from all the "baddie" vibes kpop (which I'm a fan of) releases. Really love it. I love the geeky guitar part you explained too! Made me appreciate it more!
This is the best reaction for APT.
Please react Rose solo songs- On the ground,
Gone,
hard to love.
All 3 have heavy guitar sound.
8:11 어떻게 한번에 듣고 조옮김(transposition)을 바로 정확하게 짚어내시는지 대단하십니다. 이 영상이 대단히 도움이 되었습니다. 감사합니다. 한국(남한)에서 드립니다.
Bruno is the whole package: singer, songwriter, multi-instrumentalist, producer, dancer, choreographer, and music video director. People tend to forget what a talented producer he is even though he has twice been nominated for Grammy's Producer of the Year, Non-Classical. Bruno produced this song with Rogét Chahayed, Omer Fedi, and Henry Walter (Cirkut). Would assume the other three are producing the additional songs for Rosé's new album.
I love the music theory you added!!! lots of learning :)
I'm glad!
I'm glad I found ur reaction man... I've noticed some ppl really like the song but also mention how it's great and "simple" when in fact there's so much detail that bruno had inserted in that u picked out that made this song so much more ez on the ears
Great reaction and review. I've been waiting for you to come in and show me all the nuances, and you did. Thank you. 😊❤
Amazing work dude. You got a new subscriber 🎉
Thank you!
Omg, what a great reaction! loved the knowledge, it's great to understand why we like the things we like in songs, hope you do one of these when rosé releases her album on december 6th
Rosie posie ❤❤❤
Our kind and lovable princess 👸
Watch Rose vogue cooking interview from yesterday, she talks about how the collab happened.
Production has Bruno’s style all over it, sounds a lot like one of his songs, specially around his 2010’s stuff
Wow.. i've learn more of APT mv from your details observation and explamations..thank you so much
loved your reaction so much omg it was so informative. rosé is also releasing her first ever full album on dec 6 hope you'll react to it too
Yes, this explains why I am addicted to this song. It’s a simple, easy-listening track, but every detail is executed perfectly.
Best reaction of APT. Period.
리액션 흥미롭게 잘 보고 갑니다 ^0^
I like your reaction ! You really deep dive into those small details that 99% of us don't every catch, and it really improves our perception of the song in its entire complexity :) Your passion is really communicative and likeable !
She's the golden voice of kpop. Fyi, her official "VIVA LA VIDA" on (Pachinko OST) is breathtaking.
You haven’t heard of Rosé before? You’re in for a treat. Sometimes I’m jealous of people who haven’t heard Sea of Hope or her many covers on the Blackpink RUclips channel. Rosé is Korea’s Golden Voice and such a unique talent who is in love with music.
She is an Aussie first sorry lol. Her outgoing and friendly attitude are inherent to Australian 😂
You have a great gift for getting people to geek out with you about music. Keep doing what you're doing.
Damnnnnnnnn i love how you break this down! Very technical like it comes from a sound engineer. As an engineer myself i love to hear the technical nuances that makes the details so important
Everyone glazing Rosé so I might as well Glaze Bruno. He can play drums, guitar, piano, and ukelele. He also produces his own songs. He adds in a dancs break in songs like Perm, Finesse, 24k Magic and Runaway Baby. These are just phenomenal. He's also made countless songs for other people. He made All I ask for Adele, Forget You for Ceelo Green, and Young Wild & Free. Forgot to mention that this song isn't even his best vocal performance as compared to When I Was Your Man (The official audio has nothing else except him and his piano he played live), If I knew, Gorilla, Too Good to say Goodbye, All I ask (The live studio recording on BBC), majority of silk sonic, live btw. I highly recommend checking these out. Good examples of his great collabs where he flexes his vocals are Lighters, Mirror and Please Me. Bruno also has a great amount of variety in his songs. He can make any type of song from Rock (Runaway Baby), Reggae (Show Me), and obviously pop. Not listing all. Proof of him playing Guitar and Singing at the same time is his live studio recording of Locked out of heaven. For Piano, he's played When I was your man on Piano while riffing extremely difficult notes LIVE. And on top of that he's extremely underrated despite his many famous songs like Just the way you are. Even with his amazing vocals, he's fine with not being the lead and letting others take the spotlight like here with Rosé. He could've done so much but he decided to be Rosé's back up because he's so humble. Despite his popularity, people aren't giving him enough credit man!!!
Rosé killed it here tho props to her 🔥
Thank you! He is so talented!
True Bruno fan right here!!
You hit the nail on the head on this song in terms of vocals - no noticeable auto tune at all - no robotic like sounds. Real vocals finessed in the studio. Wonderful review. Because the song didn’t have a lot of frills, people think it’s simple. But it’s really not -it’s because it is well-produced, and Bruno and Rosé actually sing that they make it look easy. Thank you for explaining the discipline it takes to create something that sounds ‘simple’. One of Rosé 2 earlier singles released in 2021 - a folksy love song ‘Gone’ was often described as simple - but the beauty of it is in its seeming simplicity. The instrumentation does not have a lot of frills, so you get to focus on her voice which then carries the story and emotion and heartbreak of the song. And by the way, she co-wrote this song too - ruclips.net/video/K9_VFxzCuQ0/видео.htmlfeature=shared
I just love the way that you are not only so genuinely excited by the musicality, but how you are able to essentially explain to me in fairly simple terms what it is about that musicality that makes me love this song so much. I knew right from the get-go that I loved this track, it's been on repeat for me since it dropped, but now I have some insight into why that is!
Your enthusiasm is contagious. This was a fun watch!
Because of all the stuff you noticed in the first half I didn’t even consider, I caught on the “Whatevah” noise on Bruno’s verse before you even mentioned it. I think you just made me more observant of all these production tactics haha. Great review man.
I love to see all the different perspectives on this. Appreciate how this one is so production focused. I’ve also seen a reaction by an editor that’s geeking out about the music video concept and editing.
Thank you for your amazing reaction and analysis!! I have very little knowledge about music production /theory /technique. I just listen. So watching you point out many details of the song makes me enjoy listening more and more ☺ (Not just this one, but the other many songs on your reaction channel too!!) Great job as always.
Great reaction video! I’ve watched this music video 50 times at this point and you pointed out some great harmonies I missed 😂 bc they’re so understated but so amazing once you notice it.
I’m so happy to see Rosé happy and having superstar success as a solo performer. Her album on December 06 is going to be the album of the decade. Her voice is so unique and powerful.
Wow you gave really great analysis, thank you for the reaction ❤
That remark about Bruno Mars recording for hours for one moment reminds of that maxim. (Pardon if I mess it up) "Record like you can't mix, mix like you can't master." It's a cool song. It reminds me of "That's not my Name" song. Same vibe or groove maybe.
You nailed it! And we need more musicians to think that way!
Came for a simple reaction, left with a Bachelor's in vocals and music video production. Love love your in depth perspective!
Thanks so much! Glad you enjoyed it.
love your explanation on how you analyzed this great job!!!
Love the in depth analysis. Keep making videos like this. This is a great reaction/review for a song.
Most analytical reactions yet, LOVE it!!!
This song makes the world ONE!😊
loved your reaction and analysis :)
I truly enjoyed this. A true passionate review of experiencing an amazing song
welcome to the the Rosé's world mate.. she is incredible
Great review. Allow me to love the song even more.
I love watching nerds nerd out over their passions! Your giddiness is awesome.
Thanks so much for this great review and breakdown! Here's one of Rosé's other solo hits:
ON THE GROUND (solo) ruclips.net/video/CKZvWhCqx1sF/видео.html
...and PLEASE check out her performances on SEA OF HOPE, a TV show about celebrities who opened a seaside café, they cooked, and performed on the beach for the customers. Rosé was the first special guest on the show, she played guitar and keyboards on a few songs as well:
*THE ONLY EXCEPTION* by Paramore ruclips.net/video/2DUdg4dnse8/видео.html
*READ MY MIND* by the Killers ruclips.net/video/_r92v-T4gSU/видео.html
...and her heartbreaking cover of *TIME SPENT WALKING THROUGH MEMORIES* by Nell (turn on subtitles) ruclips.net/video/mrUU_L-pfRU/видео.html
True, very little production, just raw amazing vocals "Sea Of Hope" sets Rose as one of the best.
In parts she reminds me of the Ting Tings singer.
That was the first thing that came through my mind. It reminds of _That's Not My Name_ (2008).
@@neelo821 The video too a little bit I guess as well.
Hit song❤❤❤❤
Love your super detailed and passionate analysis!!❤🎉 I’m learning so much from you!!!!
리뷰 진심이네 이횽님......😂
다양한 의견에 대해 들을 수 있어서 좋아요~ 리뷰 감사합니다
Love it when you get down and nerdy 🤓 Fantastic analysis. 🙌 Time to got check out more from both these artists.
awesome reaction
Terrific analysis and breakdown. It's worth noting that Mike Chapman, responsible for multiple 70s-80s hits, was involved in the songwriting. Worth also noting, this is ROSÉ's song, her project, and bringing Bruno in on it was her idea. The major kudos for how it turned out must go to her. Her years of training at YG and recording with Teddy and Blackpink and her natural ear hasn't gone to waste. You can hear her use of layered harmony on her other previous solo work, especially in On The Ground, and with Blackpink.
Glad you added this. I've been surprised to find a lot of the Bruno reactors have no idea who Rose is, which is pretty wild eight years after Blackpink's debut. Blinks know though that Rose lives and breaths music. She's soaked up all the lessons from Teddy and applied them to a song that at least has to harken back to all those pop songs she loved singing in the car when the family was driving someplace. I knew Rocker Rosie was in there someplace but I never expected anything like this. I know it's a huge hit, but it also feels like Rosie has finally blossomed and created something both nostalgic and modern at the same time. I can't imagine what the rest of the songs on the album are going to be like, but we're probably just going to be stunned. Her talent has ripped free of the YG bonds and she's shown us what she's capable of. Just awesome...
Might dont know but she born in New Zealand and lived in Australia ,before moved Korea so some of her words like "hearth" are also has Aussie accent which makes her English singing even better.
and for 4:32 , Yes she is a drummer, she can play drums, gitar, piano and even ukulele , she showed before.
ofc she's is ICONIC iykyk
The Best review, Period. !!!!!!
Talented dude.
Holy crap. This reaction is NEXT LEVEL. Totally subscribing. I learned a lot!! Although I was surprised, given your incredible attention to detail, that you didn’t notice the Breakfast Club dance moves. But you were very distracted by the musical stuff. Really great reaction video!! I actually shared it with some people, and I almost never share reaction videos. 🤷♀️💘🏆
P.S. I know probably everyone is already telling you this, but: please do more Rosé and BLACKPINK analysis. You are gonna love it.
Thanks for watching and enjoying!! And for sharing! I will react to more for sure!
Welcome to Korea's "Golden Voice" Rosie! I'm an American and quickly became a Blink which is what the Fandom of BlackPink the group Rosie is part of.
There are 4 just as equally talented ladies who have smashed global records from Guiness to maaannnny countries charts.
Rose in particular is aptly called The Golden Voice.I suggest listening to her other 2 solos so far On The Ground and Gone to hear her range and vocal abilities.
I don't know if you are planning on trying BlackPink which I highly recommend. (Just check out reviewers numbers.) We show up to reviews for the ladies in droves and we are legion. Supporting our girls, loving seeing them be discovered as well.
She and Bruno are at 89 million views as I type and still steadily going. It's the duo I didn't know I needed.
Also, also all 4 of the girlies have solos between their BlackPink albums. The world tour was sold out so fast a year or so back that they gave us an encore tour in many cities and even love and appreciate their fans enough for Jennie to rework and make a music video dedicated to us I appreciation.
Great analysis
Great analysis from a real expert so I joined the channel! This is so well done, and a great visual layout where the artists image occupies mor space than the reviewers. This song will really wake people up tpo the fact that Rose is a true musician/singer/songwriter of Blackpink. She will be innundated with collab requests from Western artists!
for reference the song is based on a korean drinking game the "apateu apateu apateu" is the chant you say while playing the game and she conceptualized it with such fun word play with the "meet me at the apateu" (which stands for apartment in english) it's so clever!! thanks for showing her love! this was a really great review super informative on just how excellent this production is💗
Great analysis. Thank you.
I love how you broke down the details! So informative & you do it in such a way where now i want to learn from you! A new subscriber here! Im an avid kpop listener&I love Rosé and Bruno so much! Thank you for reacting to this song.
THANKFUL U REACTED TO ROSÉ WHICH LED TO MY DISCOVERY OF U !! sooo technical so good ! hope u can react to rosé’s album out on dec 6 she worked on all 12 songs
I was waiting for your reaction! Haven't seen too many who's picked up on the production aspect.
Wow really great analysis, I loved it before but your nerd out on the details made me appreciate it even more!
Their voices combined soooooo gooooodddddd omggg loved the collab 😍😍😍 And I loved your reaction. Can you react more to Rosé ‘s song?
I think I'm headed down another rabbit hole!
I like your nerdy feeling to it ! haha ... loved your review ....thanks!
Big BlackPink fan here, and who doesn't love them some Bruno Mars. This collab seemingly came out of nowhere, and I love it! You made me appreciate the song that much more. Loved the analysis!
Hey Chris. First time to your site. I’ve been searching and watching whatever reaction videos I’ve found bcuz I wanted to see if other people had a similar reaction to mine. Doing this was a first too. Basically broke down into, “opinions, like bellybuttons, everybody has one”….mostly based on personal preference (for and against), and occasionally on knowledge of music and or video construction--like yourself. Your analysis at the end was money. People can like it or not for whatever reasons, your breakdown was refreshing.
All the subtleties that go into building the video seem to be missed by reactors and just grouped into a larger….I Like It effect. This is for the sound and visuals, both of which are used so effectively for the transitions. Components less mentioned, occasionally, but not often, in reactions: two-tone black & pink color scheme (connection to the BP group), lightening animations at impact/accent points, including finger snaps, throwback dance moves--- the Carlton, breakfast club movie, and earlier to the 1960’s Monkees show, excessively large, non typical bass drum, switch of forward position between Bruno and rose, in the video set, on the drums, and in the vocal mix, when they are featured, the build in the layers of harmony and fill instrument volumes across the track from more sparse to full, and…., as you point out, in the “Hold on” section, your expectations are set up with the 3-time repeated Bm, A, D, B progression, then on the transition at the 4th, they do Bm, A, then drop in the E and bang on it instead of the D. Masterful. The only time it appears in the song. If you watch the faces of people doing reaction videos, the faces of the ones paying attention change to a surprised look on that one chord. This video is like a great soup with all kinds of interesting ingredients that combine beautifully. And the beat is infectious, the whole thing is addicting.
APT is Apart(아파트)=Korean Apartment Complex, also Korean famous Drinking game with kiss, dance
game start with 아파트 아파트~ 아파트 아파트~
only two people, black n pink color, one room
pure art n the show "Simple is Best" best 2024 song 😍
Fun song, love it ❤ Rose is fire 🔥 She nailed it ❤ I already preordered her new audio CD releasing Dec-24 😊
You know? Bruno Mars is the directer of this song's music video. He is the one of the songwriters and he arranged this song. He is also the producer. This is not just Rose's song. If you think so, you don't deserve this song's music video first. Some people are so rude to Bruno Mars. Bruno Mars is not just something. Bruno Mars is The something. Thank you for the great reviews, sincerely.
Ok…
Excuse me? No, Bruno Mars did not write this song. Rose did. You need to do more research
God this was such a fun reaction, I was wondering why I loved that transition out of the bridge so hearing the theory on that was really really fun
im literally new to the channel but gotta admit... THAT IS A REACTION LADYS AND GENTLEMANS.
Thank you! So glad you enjoyed... And welcome to the channel!
@@chrisliepe Respect all your knowledge and passion for music.
Now you have a fan from Brazil! Hahaha
See you the covers of Rose.....incredible singer
❤❤❤
after watching this, first ever reaction channel i subscribed too. incredible and in depth. I learned a lot. thank you!
So glad you're enjoying the channel and learning along the way!
Thank you for your love of song and ours Rosie I love your reaction 😍
I've listened to this song about 100 times since it released, but I only noticed the background when you mentioned it
I love this song and keep on listening many many times. You did a good reaction too.
nice review sir very detailed