This is my favorite song of all time, and I didnt expect much, but now that I've listened to it.. man! This really is a fantastic cover. I like alot of your own takes on the solos and acoustic parts, it all sounds great.
@@mileswilbur9348 Most keyboard arrangements that would be consider music are not possible with the limits of two arms with five fingers each. Search RUclips for Black MIDI, for example here is Queen's Bohemian Rhapsody with over 2 million keyboard notes. ruclips.net/video/HjwzR3BqMZ4/видео.html
I’ll be complete when I can give that blood curdling sinister laugh, anyways this is fantastically done and now I know IT IS possible to closely replicate the fathers of sound
One of my fave floyd songs, you did an extremely good job. The videos are excellent and great to view. Superb vocals, extremely similar to the original. And I love the dog sounds :) Well done mate
Are there differences with the original? Sure. Does it matter? Not at all. The production of this is superb! All of the important parts are spot on, mix is great, vocal effects are great. I'm a fan!
To borrow from some others here... Extraordinary, superb, excellent, amazing... I don't think Pink himself ("Oh, by the way..." ;-) ) could have recreated this any better!
You nailed the trippiest part of the whole song, the "Dragged down by the stone...stone...stone...stone..." My favorite part! (But Nick plays single notes on the kick drum, on the "one" of each bar, for 16 bars, then switches to doubles on the "one" after - just a minor nag). Great job, you guys! It's fantastic!!!
Except for the strumming pattern, just the tiniest bit off, except for that it was HUGE! Excellent cover.... Man, that must have been difficult. Cudos on the vocal performance, Dave would have approved..
Sorry but this is absolutely amazing good job I love this song so much and to see it done like this makes me feel so happy and has inspired me to put the time in and actually learn it thank you
really people, your going to be negative to someone who obviously put a lot of time effort into a project like this....not perfect but damn good,,,Kudos to you sir..
Molti prima di commentare dovrebbero sciacquare la bocca. Complimenti vivissimi. Sei un grande. Solo un appassionato può svolgere un lavoro del genere. Bravissimo.
Pretty cool Karl! I had no idea you were this talented because I didn't even like Pink Floyd until now. Just thinking back to our old BP days in San Mateo. Hope you and the old BP team are well and good luck to the new BM venture. Let me know if I need to move back to help Paul.
Pink floyd, c'est comme la musique classique, on l’écoutera encore pendant des années ! J’espère que les générations à venir joueront ce grand groupe aussi bien que vous 😊 super reprise @+ Jos
This is epic. Very faithful including all the dog samples and other echoes. Your singing tone has improved massively over older videos too. (just found you through Bass Player mag BTW)
Goddamnit you're still making those awesome covers and it took 3 months for RUclips to tell me. Eddie your content is amazing and your name isn't stupid :-)
Massive Floyd fan here. That was absolutely brilliant...I wish I had a tenth of your talent! I have to say one thing though and I know everyone's probably thinking the same thing but...when was the last time those instruments saw a damp cloth or a duster man? My autism was off the scale...!
The dude sang, played bass, drums, electric guitar and acoustic guitar and you guys complain about the acoustic rhythm pattern? Wow! Congrats, man!
Maybe or probably they didn’t understand that is one man who playing all instruments…
Well when it sucks, it sucks.
Hahahaha ! Well said love it
But the rhythm pattern was wrong on the acoustic 😂
And you forgot edited his own video
It's like the another RUclips guy who plays Burzum Jesus tods cover with all instruments.
This keyboard solo part was awesome👏
You've really outdone yourself this time, my friend. It's an honor to have been a part of this ~20 year odyssey. Truly extraordinary work!
Great work! 🎹
My favorite Pink Floyd song. You did it justice man, good job 👏
This cover is sooo good I had to watch till the end. I think this is Floyds best album, why did it take 5 years to show up in my feed?
Serioulsly? No one's gonna talk how quickly he detuned that bass in the final D? Just amazing
Superb. Animals is generally not as highly rated as other albums but I've always loved it so many thanks for showcasing it.
This is my favorite song of all time, and I didnt expect much, but now that I've listened to it.. man! This really is a fantastic cover. I like alot of your own takes on the solos and acoustic parts, it all sounds great.
FRICKIN SOUND'S EXACTLY LIKE THE ALBUM... FROM 1-10... I'LL GIVE Y'ALL A 9 !!
10:55 I like that extra finger on the keyboard
Lol wtf
@@mileswilbur9348 Most keyboard arrangements that would be consider music are not possible with the limits of two arms with five fingers each. Search RUclips for Black MIDI, for example here is Queen's Bohemian Rhapsody with over 2 million keyboard notes. ruclips.net/video/HjwzR3BqMZ4/видео.html
I think he means that there are two keyboard players @@mileswilbur9348
absolutely incredible! This is the best cover of this song I've ever heard and done by two people. Just brilliant
I don't usually like pink floyd covers but man you nailed this one.
I’ll be complete when I can give that blood curdling sinister laugh, anyways this is fantastically done and now I know IT IS possible to closely replicate the fathers of sound
Incredible work, regards from another Pink Floyd fan doing their songs
One of my fave floyd songs, you did an extremely good job. The videos are excellent and great to view. Superb vocals, extremely similar to the original. And I love the dog sounds :) Well done mate
Amazing cover for such an underrated song!
Are there differences with the original? Sure. Does it matter? Not at all.
The production of this is superb! All of the important parts are spot on, mix is great, vocal effects are great. I'm a fan!
It’s a tough cover and you did so much better than I could. Please keep up the hard work. Proud of your work!
Guys, you nailed both Dogs and Sheep perfectly, this is AMAZING!! :)
Just shows you how much effort went into making this masterpiece. Very well done on recapturing the magic in your own unique way.
This was really, really nicely out together. Very well done top down
Best prog album by PF.
Love your voice, and the "band" is amazing. :-P
Greetings from Italy.
Oh by the way, which one's Pink?
Wow !! There is a lot of work to realize that performance. Great Job Guys !!! It is so nice to hear. Thanks for sharing.
To borrow from some others here... Extraordinary, superb, excellent, amazing... I don't think Pink himself ("Oh, by the way..." ;-) ) could have recreated this any better!
Stunning! Such talent - my favourite band, and my favourite covers by far. You smashed all your Floyd covers. Utererly awesome
Been waiting for awhile for this and it was sooooooo worth the wait !
This is just fucking fabulous.
you should be so proud of yourself for this. It's so good.
You nailed the trippiest part of the whole song, the "Dragged down by the stone...stone...stone...stone..." My favorite part! (But Nick plays single notes on the kick drum, on the "one" of each bar, for 16 bars, then switches to doubles on the "one" after - just a minor nag). Great job, you guys! It's fantastic!!!
Thanks!! I didn't check but I seem to remember doing that with the kick drum. It starts with a triplet feel and then straightens out.
I've waited so much for this. You're awesome! Cheers from Brazil!
That’s just crazy, incredible! Keep going, love from Italy!
Except for the strumming pattern, just the tiniest bit off, except for that it was HUGE! Excellent cover.... Man, that must have been difficult. Cudos on the vocal performance, Dave would have approved..
So NOW you do this! Brilliant...awesome love these kinds of videos...keep 'em coming...so many skills and talent!!!
I think this man's voice should be the next choice if David Gilmore is not singing ❤️
P. S. This is the best recreation of the song.
Cheers
Sorry but this is absolutely amazing good job I love this song so much and to see it done like this makes me feel so happy and has inspired me to put the time in and actually learn it thank you
I'm obsessed with this song. Nice job! Must have taken some time.
I'm very happy they put in the time to add this to the compendium of human entertainment. May this video last for centuries.
Good work. And it's nice to see another video of yours after all that time. I'm glad you're well.
That hit me as hard as the first time that i've listen to Dogs... Thanks, dude.
Wow simply amazing this was. I’m a huge PF guy. This was incredible to watch thanks I WILL BE BINGE WATCHING YOUR CHANNEL
Well done! Enjoyed watching and listening to this!
So awesome brings a tear to my eye
EC... Another magnificent piece of work. I can't get enough.
8:00 this part always makes me cry
Thats pretty damn good!! I think the strumming pattern on the acoustic is a bit different from the original. But it sounds good nonetheless
Very talented artist really .....not every one can play the legends songs except those who are talented and this gentleman is one of them......
In its complexity, there nothing more difficult than to recreate such song, not only to get it right, but in making it relevant that matters!
fucking amazing man....what effort and care to get every part so right. Top notch
Incredible voice! Sounds so similar to Roger Waters, impressive!
my friend, just beautiful, thank you !!
Such creativity! Great cover.
great job on this! lot of work put into this and it shows!
This is just brilliant, guys...chapeau!
Best Dogs Cover i ever see! Just perfect! Congrats!
This is one of the best songs guys did a great job this is my favorite favorite song
re-do the acoustic strumming pattern and this would be spectacular
Found this sick Dogs cover that nails the acoustic and everything, deserves more way more views: ruclips.net/video/7OawR5jI4Lw/видео.html
@@-S-M Holy shit that cover is amazing. Best version on RUclips - yet barely any views?!
really people, your going to be negative to someone who obviously put a lot of time effort into a project like this....not perfect but damn good,,,Kudos to you sir..
No doubt!! If people want perfect BUY THE ALBUM!! THESE GUYS ARE FUKN FABULOUS!!!
Fooking incredible he took that song and made it his own for 10 minutes
Decent cover but not sure you truly understand 'making it your own' in musical terms..
Just amazing all the effort
Play this song, bend the strings, lose control, reap the harvest you have sown
Wow Damn fine job guys. Really solid. I'll be that must have been a blast!! Peace, Love, Courage from David in Detroit.
WHAT!? This is amazing
it's a great masterpiece. you guys have a feeling for music.
It's all one guy isn't it?
@@eileensianez6766 it’s 2
This is absolutely perfect! You guys are very talented!
Awesome dogs cover its the best cover on youtube :)
Molti prima di commentare dovrebbero sciacquare la bocca.
Complimenti vivissimi. Sei un grande. Solo un appassionato può svolgere un lavoro del genere. Bravissimo.
Condivido le tue parole, un grande
hats off.impressive.
Pretty cool Karl! I had no idea you were this talented because I didn't even like Pink Floyd until now. Just thinking back to our old BP days in San Mateo. Hope you and the old BP team are well and good luck to the new BM venture. Let me know if I need to move back to help Paul.
Божественно! Моя любимая композиция.
read the description; how the hell did you get your neighbor’s dog to bark exactly how the dog in the original song barked?
LOL I recorded the dog for a half hour and then sampled I think 13 different barks and then sequenced that pattern in MIDI
Pink floyd, c'est comme la musique classique, on l’écoutera encore pendant des années ! J’espère que les générations à venir joueront ce grand groupe aussi bien que vous 😊 super reprise @+ Jos
This is epic. Very faithful including all the dog samples and other echoes. Your singing tone has improved massively over older videos too. (just found you through Bass Player mag BTW)
Awesome eddie great work on this.
Goddamnit you're still making those awesome covers and it took 3 months for RUclips to tell me. Eddie your content is amazing and your name isn't stupid :-)
Very good! Perfect! Amazing!
With soul❤ it is that type of a cover
Thanks bro, you did it great again! Good work!
Now.....that's a good voice !
Well, well, well. Look who it is. Great job. Welcome back. 👍👍👍
3:50 your pedal is fucking perfect thank you so much for finding the right match
awesome job as usual. the acoustic strumming threw me off though, it's like another brick in the wall pt is slipping into it :)
Very good,that makes mu day
Been waiting years for this one!
Muito bom! Parabéns! Congrats! Perfeita produção!
Excellent tasteful devoted lostinpinkfloyd
thought u were gone, perfect cover greetings from Peru
You made me cry. Thanks
incredible voice! and sound ... just perfect cover. You have the same emotion in your voice than Waters ! very very good job, a pleasure to ear !!
Fantastically done.
Welcome back! Love it
It says "covers" not exact replicas. I like what you did here. Keep'em coming. Thanks!!
The keyboards are just amazing 👌🏻👌🏻
Excelente viejo, lo hiciste magistral!!!!
Esto es oro, chicos
Excellent work!
Extraordinary! Should be Pink Floyd lead singer.
This is amazing work! impressive!
Massive Floyd fan here. That was absolutely brilliant...I wish I had a tenth of your talent!
I have to say one thing though and I know everyone's probably thinking the same thing but...when was the last time those instruments saw a damp cloth or a duster man? My autism was off the scale...!
Absolutely fucking amazing job. Ridiculously accurate.
This is so good!
Really well done! Enjoyed this immensely
This is really well done. The singing is great! Such a fantastic song.