I am Polish. When our neighboring countries attacked us and divided our land among them in the 18th century, we disappeared from the map for a 100 years. We lived under the occupation of three different countries at once. We fought back. And we are on the map again. They apologized. The wounds are still there but we live in relative peace. And I wish it for both Palestinians n Israelis.
Did you also reject peace plans that will give you a state? Did you also target civilians as a policy of terror? Did you also not compromise on anything (Lviv, Vilnius etc.)?
Poland only exists because of the Soviet Union then NATO after it. You are not Ireland or Algeria or Palestine or South Africa. Maybe stop supporting NATO and the whole world can stop hating Poland. Poland has turned into the most hated eastern European country, worldwide.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
@@Tommytakanawayes some people just want everything to be over and don’t care for the war if it ends the war I think many would prefer to coexist with each other
Hamas recently formed organization . Palastinians suffering is 70 years old . Can u justify your comment ? Why people getting killed in West Bank then ?
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
Solution might be complex, but the conflict itself isn't: there was a land with people in it; another people wanted that land and, with the help of a great power, went and took it by force, expelling its original population and instilling an apartheid regime against those who were allowed to stay. 9:57 - "Hamas doesn't accept Israel's right to exist". Well, isn't it exactly the same as Israel towards Palestine? Hamas and Israel are the same; both target civilians, kill children, take hostages, and violate international law. Why only Hamas is deemed a terrorist organization?
Because israel does not target civilians. Because israel does not murder babies and laugh about it or celebrate the deaths of Palestinians. Because israel offered peace multiple times and was ready to have a Palestinian state but the Palestinian side refused
@@pocarisweet8336 You want real education ? How about the fact that Israeli officials have admitted to creating and funding Hamas as a means to sabotage the secular PLO and Fateh parties and make sure Palestinians never unite under a single banner.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
This is basically what happens when a blood feud reaches the national scale. Even if they've reached a ceasefire agreement, a splinter group that really hates the other party would emerge and strike the other one, regardless of collateral damage. The other party would strike back causing collateral damage as well, fanning the flames again, combine that with other factors, like who gets certain pieces of territories of interests to them and that cycle would continue.
It’s complicated because of our double standard. For decades we have pretended that we can’t see the illegal occupation of Palestinian land by Israel. If we held Israel to the same standards of international law as we do with other nations this conflict will no longer be that complicated
The same double standard of complete silence as long as Jordan and Egypt occupied most of the land that the UN meant for the Palestinians? The double standard of saying Israel is wrong while the arabs who stayed there have full rights but the Palestinians in arab countries have no civil rights?
@@alonys what on earth are you talking about. Israel against countless UN resolutions is not only continuing its illegal occupation of Palestinian land but years after year, has accelerated demolishing Palestinian homes and forceful displacement of Palestinians from their homes to build illegal settlements. The UN, and all European nations and US accept this. No one questions that Israel is illegally occupying Palestinian land, we just don’t hold them to the same standard as we hold other nations.
@@anthonyhulse1248 the illegal occupation of Palestinian land for 50+ years that has been recognised by the UN. Even UN and EU which are allies of Israel accept that Israel is illegally occupying Palestinian land.
Yes of course it can be solved. Stop supporting Israeli apartheid and force them to make a fair settlement with the Palestinian people that gives them their own contiguous state and the problem will end.
Could a solution be: the West push israel to leave occupied territories and stop the war. In exchange arab leaders and china push russia to leave ukraine and stop the war. For security concern both Israel and Ukraine join NATO and Palestine join russian Collective security Pact
@@frederikpedersen689 Yes the Nato as a defense pact wanted russia to come for Cuba on their doorstep with nuclear presence. Dangerous halfknowledge. After shooting protetsters and cops at maidan in Ukraine US needs to expand the former warshaw pact states promising there will never be an east expansion...............Get fascist and terror your minoritys. Like in this ongoing civil war at US.
The two-state solution would leave apartheid Israel largely intact. It is the 'solution' of apartheid South Africa's bantustans. The only solution, really, is a democracy with equal rights for all.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
for your biased information - the biased video in favour of israel stated "state militants from the Hamas terrorist group" - the militants are actually Al-Qassam - Hamas is the Government What makes this video biasedand wrong is it like all western countries and media because it never calls the terrorist organisation the israel govt a terrorist which it certianly is by the strict definition - all the destruction including the genocide right now in Gaza is a prime example.
DW fails to mention the 1937 Peel Commission plan (the first actual two-state solution, refused by the Arabs) as well as the pre-1967 occupation of the Gaza Strip and the West Bank by Egypt and Jordan respectively (without creating a Palestinian state).
@@calitaliarepublic6753 They have to learn to share and live in peace, else they'll have wars forever. The whole 'colonizer' terminology is wrong. There are two peoples living in this land and they have to find a way to coexist in peace. Forcing your narrative on the situation is just dishonest.
@@projekcja Arabs share?!? They want everything, they come to the west and try to force us to change our cultures to make them feel better. It is literally impossible to get them to agree over there, one side will always keep attacking and the other will always be told they are being too mean when defending themselves.
@@calitaliarepublic6753 Everyone has ancestors who took land from another group, might be 1000 years ago but it happened. If they want continuous conflict, they will have it and lose badly. They want this conflict, it's bred right into them.
She failed to mention that the Palestinian state was created first in 1921; its called Jordan. She also failed to mention that if countries declares war, then loses that war they lose all claims and rights to previous grievances.
I think you are not aware of historical facts. After the demise of Ottoman rule, it was Palestine and was neither the state of Palistine or Israel. A large part of it came under the rule of Jordan and Egypt including Gaza and the west bank, only to be liberated by Israel.
offcourse Certainly! Jewish people accepted the land as it originally belonged to Palestine before it was divided into 70% Israel and 30% Palestine.Muslim Palestinians did not agree with this division. did not accept this division.
Agreed, US dropped two a-bombs on Japan and now are close military and economic allies. US carpet bombed Vietnam and lost to them, not also on good terms. This conflict is not just about nation/states.
@@tessiowasalwayssmarter Even so! Each hostility is unique but at the end it is hostility and someday should come an end. This just stagnates people/nation growth. Let’s see how long it takes more to be realized
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
France isn't occupying Germany nor are they building settlements in Berlin. While PLO recognised Isreal as a state isreali still dispute all of remaining Palestinian territory.
I'm not against Israel right for being safe as a state but if hamas weren't as violent as they are the Israeli government will definitely build as many illegal statement in the Gaza strip as what they already have done in the west bank ignoring the UN decisions ! You need to fix the cause not the symptoms
And also because there are way too many people in a region that does not have enough food, water, space and other resources to support such a huge population.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
If you listen to Israelis talk about it you might have hope, but all you have to do to realize there will never be peace is listen to Palestinians talk about it.
There are some groups of Israelis and Palestinians that protest together for peace and their always have been. Unfortunately these united groups are mainly ignored by all types of media
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
@fotter9567 Palestinians have had entire families wiped out in Israeli air strikes along with countless children who never even made it to their first birthday, it’s incomprehensible to compare the two in terms of their magnitude and effect on one’s daily life.
@@iparty98 bro i'm not on anyones side except the side of everyone who wants peace. You can't come with the victim approach, the reason Isreal moves mad is because it is full of traumatised people in the first place. We need healing. For everyone. Both countries need new governments and America needs to step tf back and get it's greedy oil fingers out of the middle east. United we stand, big picture thinking
I don’t think this conflict will ever be resolved unless one party leaves the land for good. They just hate one another. How can they create a two state solution as the UN and allies suggest?!!!
I personally think it should be one state since the two state solution has basically sailed with young people. One based on equal rights and democracy. There were centuries of peaceful coexistence, it's only been the last hundred years when the violence and ethnic cleansing started. Peaceful coexistence can happen again but it's impossible when people like Netanyahu, Ben Gvir, and Smotrich have so much power to continue extremist politics that divide and hurt people.
@@ricardobarahona3939 Arabs don't know democracy bro. Israel is the one and sole legit Democracy in the Middle East. And if you think Israel will just leave the land which was given to them by God more than a thousand years before Islam well your dreaming.😄
@@Icarus7c04Where do you think Palestinians came from? They came from the sky? Palestinians have always lived in that land, Gaza, Ashdod, Ashkelon, Ekron and Gath.
With criminal Netenyahu and Hamas a 2 state solution is impossible. A 2 state 2 solution would also mean Isreal have to give up east Jersualem and pull out the 700k illegal settlers in the west bank.
It feels like one side is much more religious, extreme, irrational and stubborn. The Palestinians must provide courage leaders who are not afraid to speak against violence and terror.
Agreed. the Israeli should stop being so superficially religious, itrational, and stubborn. and remove Naranyahu like they were about to do before the war.
That's because you only view sources from one side. The West Bank has no Hamas and Israel doesn't recognize it and implements apartheid all the same. Hamas is just an excuse.
@@gdf_6cThe west bank has plenty of Hamas, Israel has arrested over 800 Hamas members from the west bank since the war started. Palestinian violence did not start with this war, it's been there since before Israel was founded (i.e. 1929 Hebron massacre). Hamas has been engaged in terror attacks in an (unfortunately successful) effort to derail the peace process since it started.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
@fotter9567 I responded to the wrong comment. Jordan thought West bank belonged to them. Egypt tried to establish an All-Palestine Government, but refused to invest in it, so it collapsed.
Since Germany did what they did, my question as a Palestinian, why would we pay for your mistake? Please give me an intelligent answer not a stupid one. Why don’t you give them a piece of Germany?
Matthew 5:21-22 "You have heard that it was said to those of old, 'You shall not murder, and whoever murders will be in danger of the judgment.' But I say to you that whoever is angry with his brother without a cause shall be in danger of the judgment.
@@pokemonjt Sure, give back to Israel their "historic" lands and go talk to Spain and explain that you have "historic" rights for Spain. But if you not ready to face consequences of "historic" rights argument, then just don't use it.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
What a hatchet job...when you try to destroy a country and lose territory in a war, that territory is not occupied. Btw Judea and Samaria aren't occupied territories....and the lack of interviewing anyone from that area shows how truly biased this report is. Another hatchet job in journalism.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
God is in everyone’s hearts and minds and everywhere…God do not hold on to a thing or a location. it’s Man who created this division/separation and possession. Please look into yourself and find God and Peace
How did most Arabs left thier native Homeland in the arabian peninsula and took over other peoples land up to spain until forced back to northern Africa?
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
Gaza with 80% unemployment and relied on humanitarian world food program from UN for the last 15 yrs ??? And people still want to stay here ??? Why ???
There are other parts of the world where people live in the same community while not having the same religion, particularly in the east, where non-theist and polytheist religions coexist and flourish. It seems to me that the root of the problem is with monotheistic religions, and exacerbated when two of them collide in the same territory. As is common in human beings, religion is one's way of coping with their own death, by denying it, by creating an idea of immortality and following it devoutly. When you say: mine is the only God, you are condemning everyone who doesn't believe in it and it's their problem, but when someone else says that theirs is the only God, they are condemning you, they are not only attacking your religion, because such a claim cannot be true for both religions, but they are attacking your idea of immortality, therefore they are attacking your life, as Ernest Becker suggests in The Denial of Death. If both religions were to come out and acknowledge and embrace the existence of the other, they could live and die in peace next to each other.
@@NPCONSULTING247-jy3pz Full citizens, about 130,000 stayed after UN VOTED Israel a secular state in 1948. 20% is now 1.8 million Arabs, they've done well.
Great reporting as usual DW 👏 You lay out the facts without taking sides or putting opinion into the news. We need more news outlets to follow your lead. Horrific situation, my heart breaks for both sides 💔
"Trying to pass the buck and whitewash history is like trying to wear lederhosen to a disco - it might be a bold fashion statement, but it won't change the fact that you're dancing around the real issues."
It is interesting to note that Palestine is neither mentioned in the Quran, nor the Bible, or the Talmud, or the the Assyrian Prism of Records, or the Chinese Jih-li Records of the Royal Imperial Court of the Emperor of Zhongguo [China], nor the Kebra Nagast Records of the Royal Imperial Court of the Negusa Nagast (Emperor) of Abbysinia (Ethiopia), or any of the ancient world records. So when did it start existing? So many others are mentioned including Edom which was destroyed, Jordan, Moab (Petra), Syria, Seba (Sheba), Egypt, Persia land of the Medes, Lebanon, but no mention of Palestine. So when did it start existing?
Yes it can be solved by the Arabs accepting Israel is a Jewish homeland and Jewish Country. And groups like Hamas being dismantled. Why did the Arabs reject the 1947 Partition plan??? Thank you for this video.
Israel has won every war fought against it, yet has still had to give up all the lands it captured as a result of being victorious. 😂 What’s the incentive for the Arabs to stop fighting Israel… every time they lose they get a free pass, and a chance to try again in the future. 🤷♂️🤣
That is strange, because Israel accepted the UN partition. Israel made multiple offers for a Palestinian state, but they were rejected by the Palestinians. Sorry, you can lie all you want, but the truth is clear.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
If Israelis and Palestinians were allowed to have children together and be full citizens, this would eventually stop. But Israel strictly forbids this.
"Born in isriel and ethnicity Palestinian? No government rights for you! Ha, as if we'd treat people fairly if they were born wrong in our country" apparently said an Israeli politician to thunderous applause 👏
Isreal has tried solving it 5 times. Its no longer their problem to solve. They have to solve the security of their nation, first and foremost. Nothing else is more important than that. If people want to help get a peaceful solution, then you will have to demand that Hamas and Gazans submit to demands first.
Das Sprichwort sagt: „Lügen Sie, dann lügen Sie, bis Sie sich selbst glauben und von Ihrer Lüge überzeugt sind.“ Jeder kennt den Apartheidstaat, sogar gegen die Juden selbst, und die Juden sind ein friedliches Volk, das an den Taten Israels unschuldig ist.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
Is not. Let Israel make country in europe. Not in asia. Palestine did not any othrocities againts european jews, and should never madr to pay europe and USA sins.
There's no international law that defines "Palestinian territory". There was never a country called Palestine. A Palestinian state was created by Britain in 1922 - Trans-Jordan (now Jordan). At least DW is finally calling Hamas terrorists.
Jordan was not a sovereign nation until 1946 The Emirate of Transjordan was established in 1921 by the Hashemite, then Emir, Abdullah I, and the emirate became a British protectorate. In 1946, Jordan gained independence and became officially known in Arabic as the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan.
Was there a legal basis for establishing Israel? Any property right to be claimed after booting out the people who had lived there without consent? No terror committed when the people were booted out? Do you mean that only the results of the wars would determine territories?
@@nuqwestr 1946 is when they got independence. Britain had no right to divide the mandate given to it & give 78% of the territories to the Hashemites, who used to rule part of Arabia.
The coast and hinterland in antiquity was known as Canaan the land where Jesus was born. Attested by Egyptian and Assyrian records but no mention of Palestine. The people called the Country Eretz Israel, the land of Israel, using the names Israel and Judah to designate the two Kingdoms split after the death of King Solomon (Suleiman)…The Judge must be very wise and sober not to give what belongs to one to the other or vice-versa. Israel was gracious enough to offer this land to the “Palestines” as an independent state but they refused. They want everything.
Nonsense, there were many names, the ancient Greeks called it Pale(stina), the name is Greek, and Pales means "Wrestle", which is the same meaning as the name Israel.
@@nuqwestr I honestly don't understand what the point is? What has the State name got to do with forcible eviction of people who actively live in a region, then the proceeding occupation and refusal to allow a Palestinian state to exist? The encroaching of territory by settlers is also internationally illegal right now. The name is completely irrelevant. Palestinians descended from ancient Israelites, specifically Samaritans. They have every right to live in Israel, yet the international community refuses to acknowledge that.
You cherry pick religious texts and ignore historians of the time who do write of Palestine. Ukrainians had a different name too. Do they not exist as well?
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
First you need to understand that they are Terrorists and committed crimes against Israel and took Hostages. We need protestors to protest Hamas and see what they think. Hezbola said that it wasn’t Hamas but that it was Palestinians that committed the crime if killing so thats why its difficult resolve.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
"So it's not a complex issue. That's the big thing. It's super simple. There's one group that has enormous power, it's the most powerful country in the middle east, it's backed by the United States, it acts on another population of people with total impunity, and it is never held accountable for anything. So there's no symmetry in the relationship. Period." Michael Brooks
Yes all that is needed is Israel needs a Solution to the Palestinian Question. Lots of possible solutions. They could make all Palestinians Israeli citizens, whether they want it or not, or like it or not.
@@Icarus7c04 your reply is an implicit recognition of the validity of his statement. remember always that you could have been born Palestinian and seeing people on the internet enjoying the annihlation of your country would not be as "funny".
Land land land.. what has Palestine done in 31 years with the Land, what has Gaza done 31 years with the LAND ... but it is all Israel Fault, what you had 1 trillion total AID you still haven't build mega houses in the WEST BANK... in GAZA all those houses were paid by 80% by the West and 20% by the Arabs. so do tell me what have you done with the LAND in 31 year time.
WRONG🤦🏻 The land NEVER belonged to them. Palestine was colonised by the British in 1918 (read about the Balfour Declaration) and then the British handed it over to the European Jews in the 1940s.
I say "its hard to resolve" because people refuse to take in the WHOLE timeline of history - its cherry-picked to paint whatever picture the person wants
Nothing to do with religion. Most people usually don't care with other people beliefs. People start to care when someone use religion to opress others. Or to make personal profit using religion.
@@i.k.8868 who control who using religion? I this case of hamas-Israel? At least from my point a view, no one is exercising control in the situation. It is just out of control. 🙏
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
in India we have so many language and religion but we all live in peace though some small conflicts occur not like a war...just wondering why one country with two religion and two language is not possible,,,,it looks for me pure politics tat is keeping the people separate for their benefits..peace will come if palestine n israel people sit n resolve issues by themselves..
If someone suddenly come into your house and divide into 2 parts, would you still like to sit, resolve and accept to the facts that now you need to share your house with someone else?
@@bachhongtran Err. Which human right you are talking about? Israel already have been condemned in more than 40 times by UN Human Right Councils. In 2022 alone, Israel is condemned more than all other country combined.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
Attempting to cleanse one's conscience by shifting blame onto the innocent is like trying to wash away your past mistakes with a muddy river. Let's all strive for accountability and learn from history, rather than rewriting it.
I am Polish. When our neighboring countries attacked us and divided our land among them in the 18th century, we disappeared from the map for a 100 years. We lived under the occupation of three different countries at once. We fought back. And we are on the map again. They apologized. The wounds are still there but we live in relative peace. And I wish it for both Palestinians n Israelis.
I wish no peace for Poland
@@chinavirus841love to Poland 🇵🇱 forever ❤😊
Did you also reject peace plans that will give you a state? Did you also target civilians as a policy of terror? Did you also not compromise on anything (Lviv, Vilnius etc.)?
The name of the land is Palestine according to all historical scientic records to start with.
Poland only exists because of the Soviet Union then NATO after it. You are not Ireland or Algeria or Palestine or South Africa. Maybe stop supporting NATO and the whole world can stop hating Poland. Poland has turned into the most hated eastern European country, worldwide.
Thanks for trying to present the topic without emotions or polarization. It's brave to leave the comments section open
what's brave about letting people speak?
@@Icarus7c04what did they censor of what you wrote?
@@Hehehepo They censored my comments uncensored on other mainstream channels e.g. MSNBC, BBC news, CNN.
@@Icarus7c04 Ok. I will try it from a different account. Curious now
@@mimikrya8794those channels, I am not that surprised.
The problem is, that there is a lack of trust on both sides.
Why would anyone trust Hamas?
@@Scar-jg4bn
Why would anyone trust Netanyahu? The guy stated countless of times that he's against a Palestinian state.
Both governments are extreme and absolutists. It won't truly get better until both governments switch leaders.
@@Scar-jg4bn tell me a lie that hamas told.
Not question of trust. The Arab camp is sure that Israel is doomed and it is just a matter of time
Peace comes when both sides want it.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
Yes, but Hamas won't ever want it.
Palestinians spit on peace time and time again.
@adamredwine774 would you if you were occupied?
@@Tommytakanawayes some people just want everything to be over and don’t care for the war if it ends the war I think many would prefer to coexist with each other
Finally a more equilibrated video, thank you!
Free Palestine from hamas
do you like selective human breeding?
Hamas fouded by Israel to get rid of PLO
Hamas recently formed organization .
Palastinians suffering is 70 years old .
Can u justify your comment ?
Why people getting killed in West Bank then ?
@@Kamar.chakra Hamas is new but their ideology goes way back
@@returnofCrusade
So palstibians deserve to be persecuted ? All their children deserve to die ? What is ur point ?
npt a coflict. was never a conflict. it was always a war and a genocide. stop using the term conflict to understate people's plight
We must look and understand Palestine Israel before WW2 to have the full truth.
The better question is how to stop hezbola, the masters and controlers of hamas
Could you elaborate please? I don‘t have a clue about the conflict yet tbh
@@pixlord9773Yeah I'd appreciate this too
Google History of Israel prior to WW2 instead of making him write an essay.
@@IsaacMinkler I get what you're saying, just know that your comment is literally useless.
"When man meets an obstacle he can't destroy, he destroys himself" Ryszard Kapuscinski
Well-said. Sad but true.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
It’s not complex it’s easy to solve if only the West helped Palestinian to get a state instead of arming Israel to the teeth
Solution might be complex, but the conflict itself isn't: there was a land with people in it; another people wanted that land and, with the help of a great power, went and took it by force, expelling its original population and instilling an apartheid regime against those who were allowed to stay.
9:57 - "Hamas doesn't accept Israel's right to exist". Well, isn't it exactly the same as Israel towards Palestine? Hamas and Israel are the same; both target civilians, kill children, take hostages, and violate international law. Why only Hamas is deemed a terrorist organization?
Because israel does not target civilians. Because israel does not murder babies and laugh about it or celebrate the deaths of Palestinians. Because israel offered peace multiple times and was ready to have a Palestinian state but the Palestinian side refused
Get yourself some education.
Most “Palestinians” or Jordanian or Saudi Arabian. There’s no such ethnicity as Palestinian.
😂😂😂 insert trump saying"wrong"
@@pocarisweet8336 You want real education ? How about the fact that Israeli officials have admitted to creating and funding Hamas as a means to sabotage the secular PLO and Fateh parties and make sure Palestinians never unite under a single banner.
the brits effed everything up
Equal rights for all regardless of race religion or gender.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
Simple concept but almost impossible to achieve. It is a global problem.
Money dont work like that
You treating the chosen people the same as the "human animals", talk to Israel about that
Is there a single Arab country that has that, or even wants to have it?
Excellent work! Straight to the point and exposing the issues directly.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
@user-pm7ft5fv5z fair point. They did more unbiased reporting than most these days tho (on either side)
This is basically what happens when a blood feud reaches the national scale. Even if they've reached a ceasefire agreement, a splinter group that really hates the other party would emerge and strike the other one, regardless of collateral damage. The other party would strike back causing collateral damage as well, fanning the flames again, combine that with other factors, like who gets certain pieces of territories of interests to them and that cycle would continue.
in a case of the tail wagging the dog ?
It’s complicated because of our double standard. For decades we have pretended that we can’t see the illegal occupation of Palestinian land by Israel. If we held Israel to the same standards of international law as we do with other nations this conflict will no longer be that complicated
The same double standard of complete silence as long as Jordan and Egypt occupied most of the land that the UN meant for the Palestinians? The double standard of saying Israel is wrong while the arabs who stayed there have full rights but the Palestinians in arab countries have no civil rights?
@@alonys what on earth are you talking about. Israel against countless UN resolutions is not only continuing its illegal occupation of Palestinian land but years after year, has accelerated demolishing Palestinian homes and forceful displacement of Palestinians from their homes to build illegal settlements. The UN, and all European nations and US accept this. No one questions that Israel is illegally occupying Palestinian land, we just don’t hold them to the same standard as we hold other nations.
What illegal occupation?
Da, nobody above international UN law
@@anthonyhulse1248 the illegal occupation of Palestinian land for 50+ years that has been recognised by the UN. Even UN and EU which are allies of Israel accept that Israel is illegally occupying Palestinian land.
Yes of course it can be solved. Stop supporting Israeli apartheid and force them to make a fair settlement with the Palestinian people that gives them their own contiguous state and the problem will end.
Could a solution be: the West push israel to leave occupied territories and stop the war. In exchange arab leaders and china push russia to leave ukraine and stop the war. For security concern both Israel and Ukraine join NATO and Palestine join russian Collective security Pact
@@frederikpedersen689 Yes the Nato as a defense pact wanted russia to come for Cuba on their doorstep with nuclear presence.
Dangerous halfknowledge. After shooting protetsters and cops at maidan in Ukraine US needs to expand the former warshaw pact states promising there will never be an east expansion...............Get fascist and terror your minoritys. Like in this ongoing civil war at US.
It wouldn't solve anything. Extremists that don't want to cede an inch of territory would use their state for more attacks.
The two-state solution would leave apartheid Israel largely intact. It is the 'solution' of apartheid South Africa's bantustans. The only solution, really, is a democracy with equal rights for all.
@@RebeccaTurner-ny1xx If Israel was dealing with sane humans that might be possible, but they are not.
The problem is antisemitism .... Look at the history
Militants? No. Terrorists. Video discredited as soon as it started lol.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
for your biased information - the biased video in favour of israel stated "state militants from the Hamas terrorist group" - the militants are actually Al-Qassam - Hamas is the Government
What makes this video biasedand wrong is it like all western countries and media because it never calls the terrorist organisation the israel govt a terrorist which it certianly is by the strict definition - all the destruction including the genocide right now in Gaza is a prime example.
DW fails to mention the 1937 Peel Commission plan (the first actual two-state solution, refused by the Arabs) as well as the pre-1967 occupation of the Gaza Strip and the West Bank by Egypt and Jordan respectively (without creating a Palestinian state).
Why should the colonized concede even one inch of their territory to the colonizers?
@@calitaliarepublic6753 They have to learn to share and live in peace, else they'll have wars forever.
The whole 'colonizer' terminology is wrong. There are two peoples living in this land and they have to find a way to coexist in peace. Forcing your narrative on the situation is just dishonest.
@@projekcjaThey are recent arrivals of uncontrolled migration implementing their will on the native population?
@@projekcja Arabs share?!? They want everything, they come to the west and try to force us to change our cultures to make them feel better. It is literally impossible to get them to agree over there, one side will always keep attacking and the other will always be told they are being too mean when defending themselves.
@@calitaliarepublic6753 Everyone has ancestors who took land from another group, might be 1000 years ago but it happened. If they want continuous conflict, they will have it and lose badly. They want this conflict, it's bred right into them.
She failed to mention that the Palestinian state was created first in 1921; its called Jordan. She also failed to mention that if countries declares war, then loses that war they lose all claims and rights to previous grievances.
How if i said also..she failed mention if Palestinian was Kanaan land😂
I think you are not aware of historical facts. After the demise of Ottoman rule, it was Palestine and was neither the state of Palistine or Israel. A large part of it came under the rule of Jordan and Egypt including Gaza and the west bank, only to be liberated by Israel.
@@neizekhotuoyhome1570and for thousands of previous years before when there was no such word as Palistine?
Thats right. Unfortunately, people are hiding away from this reality. And we don't care.
@neizekhotuoyhome1570 Isreal is the only progressive people there, others embrace death yet don't want to die in peace but to bother Isreal.
Britain's mistake, why divide the country based on religion.
if there is no Israel state like today, the word "Israel" would not exist anywhere...
Blame the Romans.
@@Sir3gar ? It's same about Palestine bro, Palestine was only a province from Israel biblical land
Is this the first mistake from Britain? They did the same in subcontinent and created many wars
Not their first
Because US and EU sided with Israel. So simple.
fashisten kaput!
Cry😂
offcourse Certainly! Jewish people accepted the land as it originally belonged to Palestine before it was divided into 70% Israel and 30% Palestine.Muslim Palestinians did not agree with this division. did not accept this division.
If Germany and France made peace back in the time, any other states can make too.
Agreed, US dropped two a-bombs on Japan and now are close military and economic allies. US carpet bombed Vietnam and lost to them, not also on good terms. This conflict is not just about nation/states.
No. They were successful as Islam was not involved. It discriminate not assimilate
@@tessiowasalwayssmarter Even so!
Each hostility is unique but at the end it is hostility and someday should come an end.
This just stagnates people/nation growth. Let’s see how long it takes more to be realized
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
France isn't occupying Germany nor are they building settlements in Berlin. While PLO recognised Isreal as a state isreali still dispute all of remaining Palestinian territory.
I'm not against Israel right for being safe as a state but if hamas weren't as violent as they are the Israeli government will definitely build as many illegal statement in the Gaza strip as what they already have done in the west bank ignoring the UN decisions ! You need to fix the cause not the symptoms
It’s difficult to resolve because too much blood has been spilt and all sides can’t accept defeat for one reason or the other.
And also because there are way too many people in a region that does not have enough food, water, space and other resources to support such a huge population.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
If you listen to Israelis talk about it you might have hope, but all you have to do to realize there will never be peace is listen to Palestinians talk about it.
There are some groups of Israelis and Palestinians that protest together for peace and their always have been. Unfortunately these united groups are mainly ignored by all types of media
Probably because Palestinians have seen air strikes fall on their innocent families ever since they were born 💔
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
@fotter9567 Palestinians have had entire families wiped out in Israeli air strikes along with countless children who never even made it to their first birthday, it’s incomprehensible to compare the two in terms of their magnitude and effect on one’s daily life.
@@iparty98 bro i'm not on anyones side except the side of everyone who wants peace. You can't come with the victim approach, the reason Isreal moves mad is because it is full of traumatised people in the first place. We need healing. For everyone. Both countries need new governments and America needs to step tf back and get it's greedy oil fingers out of the middle east. United we stand, big picture thinking
I don’t think this conflict will ever be resolved unless one party leaves the land for good. They just hate one another. How can they create a two state solution as the UN and allies suggest?!!!
I personally think it should be one state since the two state solution has basically sailed with young people. One based on equal rights and democracy. There were centuries of peaceful coexistence, it's only been the last hundred years when the violence and ethnic cleansing started. Peaceful coexistence can happen again but it's impossible when people like Netanyahu, Ben Gvir, and Smotrich have so much power to continue extremist politics that divide and hurt people.
@@ricardobarahona3939 Arabs don't know democracy bro. Israel is the one and sole legit Democracy in the Middle East. And if you think Israel will just leave the land which was given to them by God more than a thousand years before Islam well your dreaming.😄
@@Icarus7c04 Ah yes, I almost forgot about all the palestinians Settlers claiming more and more land over the years. Thank you for reminding us.
@@Icarus7c04Where do you think Palestinians came from? They came from the sky? Palestinians have always lived in that land, Gaza, Ashdod, Ashkelon, Ekron and Gath.
@@deanally91
Your illegal is our legal.
With criminal Netenyahu and Hamas a 2 state solution is impossible. A 2 state 2 solution would also mean Isreal have to give up east Jersualem and pull out the 700k illegal settlers in the west bank.
It feels like one side is much more religious, extreme, irrational and stubborn. The Palestinians must provide courage leaders who are not afraid to speak against violence and terror.
Agreed. the Israeli should stop being so superficially religious, itrational, and stubborn. and remove Naranyahu like they were about to do before the war.
That's because you only view sources from one side. The West Bank has no Hamas and Israel doesn't recognize it and implements apartheid all the same. Hamas is just an excuse.
The internationally recognized apartheid regime that's called " Israel" must return all the stolen land.
@@Hehehepo Israelis are much more secular than the Palestinians.
@@gdf_6cThe west bank has plenty of Hamas, Israel has arrested over 800 Hamas members from the west bank since the war started. Palestinian violence did not start with this war, it's been there since before Israel was founded (i.e. 1929 Hebron massacre). Hamas has been engaged in terror attacks in an (unfortunately successful) effort to derail the peace process since it started.
Of course Britain is involved is how it started
Why did Egypt and Jordan not create what is termed a Palestinian state when administering those areas?
The Israeli politician that was about to broker the historic agreement was assassinated by an Israeli terrorist.
Look up Y-i-t-z-h-a-k R-a-b-i-n
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
@fotter9567 I responded to the wrong comment.
Jordan thought West bank belonged to them.
Egypt tried to establish an All-Palestine Government, but refused to invest in it, so it collapsed.
Since Germany did what they did, my question as a Palestinian, why would we pay for your mistake? Please give me an intelligent answer not a stupid one. Why don’t you give them a piece of Germany?
militants? for real?
Palestinians are paying for Germany's crime.
You totally missed the 10 million Palestinian diaspora which is a core thing to be considered in any resolution.
Matthew 5:21-22
"You have heard that it was said to those of old, 'You shall not murder, and whoever murders will be in danger of the judgment.' But I say to you that whoever is angry with his brother without a cause shall be in danger of the judgment.
Judea (Kingdom of Juda c. 930 BCE -c. 587 BCE) and Samaria (Kingdom of Israel or Kingdom of Samaria c. 930 BCE-c. 720 BCE).
And 1000s of years of "palestine", at this logic, can you please give back spain and portugal to the arabs, it was an arabic penninsula for 700 years
@@pokemonjt Sure, give back to Israel their "historic" lands and go talk to Spain and explain that you have "historic" rights for Spain.
But if you not ready to face consequences of "historic" rights argument, then just don't use it.
@@abynor8687 The Spanish King started to cry as the now in Bosnia living Jewes played their ancient music.
Spain and Portugal aren't mentioned in Exodus 6:8, that's the BIG difference.@@pokemonjt
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
What a hatchet job...when you try to destroy a country and lose territory in a war, that territory is not occupied. Btw Judea and Samaria aren't occupied territories....and the lack of interviewing anyone from that area shows how truly biased this report is. Another hatchet job in journalism.
"It's like they're playing the blame game with a never-ending deck of cards, hoping we'll forget their hand in history."
Hezbola?
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
God is in everyone’s hearts and minds and everywhere…God do not hold on to a thing or a location.
it’s Man who created this division/separation and possession. Please look into yourself and find God and Peace
Why are only people from Tel Aviv invited to speak here?
Open border solution is the most disastrous and way for perpetual conflict.
surrealistic dreams
True.
How did most Arabs left thier native Homeland in the arabian peninsula and took over other peoples land up to spain until forced back to northern Africa?
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
Gaza with 80% unemployment and relied on humanitarian world food program from UN for the last 15 yrs ??? And people still want to stay here ??? Why ???
Because it's their land and they will keep fighting for it.
There are other parts of the world where people live in the same community while not having the same religion, particularly in the east, where non-theist and polytheist religions coexist and flourish. It seems to me that the root of the problem is with monotheistic religions, and exacerbated when two of them collide in the same territory. As is common in human beings, religion is one's way of coping with their own death, by denying it, by creating an idea of immortality and following it devoutly. When you say: mine is the only God, you are condemning everyone who doesn't believe in it and it's their problem, but when someone else says that theirs is the only God, they are condemning you, they are not only attacking your religion, because such a claim cannot be true for both religions, but they are attacking your idea of immortality, therefore they are attacking your life, as Ernest Becker suggests in The Denial of Death.
If both religions were to come out and acknowledge and embrace the existence of the other, they could live and die in peace next to each other.
FYI, there are 20% Arabians in Israel, it is unfair for u to callout both sides.
@@crystal2484 20% left after occupation
@@NPCONSULTING247-jy3pz Full citizens, about 130,000 stayed after UN VOTED Israel a secular state in 1948. 20% is now 1.8 million Arabs, they've done well.
Religions arising in the Middle East are particularly violent and greedy. It's best to avoid them.
@@nuqwestr130k to 2 million? That’s high population growth.
In short: we are in this mess because of the British Empire misdeeds..
Great reporting as usual DW 👏 You lay out the facts without taking sides or putting opinion into the news. We need more news outlets to follow your lead. Horrific situation, my heart breaks for both sides 💔
ain't no conflict more complicated than this
An occupation.
May the Lord bless Israel
@sofianelaridi9182 So Hamas is damned, then?
Free Palestinians from Allah and their terrorist leaders.
Free Isreal from their corrupt government
"Trying to pass the buck and whitewash history is like trying to wear lederhosen to a disco - it might be a bold fashion statement, but it won't change the fact that you're dancing around the real issues."
andt that is?
@@nuqwestr
Something the person danced around stating.
It is interesting to note that Palestine is neither mentioned in the Quran, nor the Bible, or the Talmud, or the the Assyrian Prism of Records, or the Chinese Jih-li Records of the Royal Imperial Court of the Emperor of Zhongguo [China], nor the Kebra Nagast Records of the Royal Imperial Court of the Negusa Nagast (Emperor) of Abbysinia (Ethiopia), or any of the ancient world records. So when did it start existing? So many others are mentioned including Edom which was destroyed, Jordan, Moab (Petra), Syria, Seba (Sheba), Egypt, Persia land of the Medes, Lebanon, but no mention of Palestine. So when did it start existing?
We also note that Quantum Physics is not mentioned either
They fell from the sky
who cares? project super human in action...
Hogwarts exists in the Harry Potter books, does that make it real too?
So what?
The Occupation is the problem.
Yes it can be solved by the Arabs accepting Israel is a Jewish homeland and Jewish Country. And groups like Hamas being dismantled. Why did the Arabs reject the 1947 Partition plan??? Thank you for this video.
So Israel got most of the land still needs a piece of Westbank? Like how greedy can one possibly be.
You didn't mention that Israel created Hamas and also helped them to rise past . So they can weakened PLO and two state solution become impossible .
Israel has won every war fought against it, yet has still had to give up all the lands it captured as a result of being victorious. 😂
What’s the incentive for the Arabs to stop fighting Israel… every time they lose they get a free pass, and a chance to try again in the future. 🤷♂️🤣
it's because israel want all the territory and dont want a palestinan state as simple as that
That is strange, because Israel accepted the UN partition. Israel made multiple offers for a Palestinian state, but they were rejected by the Palestinians. Sorry, you can lie all you want, but the truth is clear.
What a poor bised narrative! Shame! 😢
It is not complicated, it is about an occupying country, and countries that support the occupation
Yes!! free Tibet!
The conflict can never be resolved by humans because it is conflict between Allah and God of Isreal.
I think the people of Gaza need to be asking Hamas why don't you release the hostages so the bombing can stop
They are not reflective about the whole situation, not even before Oct 7th. It's "poor me" & blame game.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
If Israelis and Palestinians were allowed to have children together and be full citizens, this would eventually stop. But Israel strictly forbids this.
"Born in isriel and ethnicity Palestinian? No government rights for you! Ha, as if we'd treat people fairly if they were born wrong in our country" apparently said an Israeli politician to thunderous applause 👏
Isreal has tried solving it 5 times. Its no longer their problem to solve. They have to solve the security of their nation, first and foremost. Nothing else is more important than that. If people want to help get a peaceful solution, then you will have to demand that Hamas and Gazans submit to demands first.
Das Sprichwort sagt: „Lügen Sie, dann lügen Sie, bis Sie sich selbst glauben und von Ihrer Lüge überzeugt sind.“ Jeder kennt den Apartheidstaat, sogar gegen die Juden selbst, und die Juden sind ein friedliches Volk, das an den Taten Israels unschuldig ist.
DW NEWS has too many opinions. They are better off to stick to the facts. When they begin speculating I turn them off.
The devastation of war reminds us why peace and diplomacy are invaluable."
War is horrible but there is worst things than wars. And looking for peace at all cost often lead to worst things than war.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
Is not. Let Israel make country in europe. Not in asia. Palestine did not any othrocities againts european jews, and should never madr to pay europe and USA sins.
There's no international law that defines "Palestinian territory". There was never a country called Palestine. A Palestinian state was created by Britain in 1922 - Trans-Jordan (now Jordan). At least DW is finally calling Hamas terrorists.
Jordan was not a sovereign nation until 1946
The Emirate of Transjordan was established in 1921 by the Hashemite, then Emir, Abdullah I, and the emirate became a British protectorate. In 1946, Jordan gained independence and became officially known in Arabic as the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan.
Was there a legal basis for establishing Israel? Any property right to be claimed after booting out the people who had lived there without consent? No terror committed when the people were booted out? Do you mean that only the results of the wars would determine territories?
@@nuqwestr 1946 is when they got independence. Britain had no right to divide the mandate given to it & give 78% of the territories to the Hashemites, who used to rule part of Arabia.
Yes, then this isn't, legally, a war, but an occupier vs the occupied. Only two states can be at legal war.
@@yahiiiaplays1252 So the war against ISIS wasn't legal? They weren't states either. Israel hasn't occupied Gaza for 18 years.
Its not hard... ceasefire and let the innocent people leave
At least let the red cross and aid supplies in. Denying that makes 0 sense and is horribly wrong
The coast and hinterland in antiquity was known as Canaan the land where Jesus was born. Attested by Egyptian and Assyrian records but no mention of Palestine. The people called the Country Eretz Israel, the land of Israel, using the names Israel and Judah to designate the two Kingdoms split after the death of King Solomon (Suleiman)…The Judge must be very wise and sober not to give what belongs to one to the other or vice-versa. Israel was gracious enough to offer this land to the “Palestines” as an independent state but they refused. They want everything.
Nonsense, there were many names, the ancient Greeks called it Pale(stina), the name is Greek, and Pales means "Wrestle", which is the same meaning as the name Israel.
@@nuqwestr I honestly don't understand what the point is? What has the State name got to do with forcible eviction of people who actively live in a region, then the proceeding occupation and refusal to allow a Palestinian state to exist? The encroaching of territory by settlers is also internationally illegal right now.
The name is completely irrelevant. Palestinians descended from ancient Israelites, specifically Samaritans. They have every right to live in Israel, yet the international community refuses to acknowledge that.
You cherry pick religious texts and ignore historians of the time who do write of Palestine. Ukrainians had a different name too. Do they not exist as well?
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
How is it that the three biggest religions in the world all havea god that was born in the same spot as the others.... 😂
Excellent reporting!!
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
First you need to understand that they are Terrorists and committed crimes against Israel and took Hostages. We need protestors to protest Hamas and see what they think. Hezbola said that it wasn’t Hamas but that it was Palestinians that committed the crime if killing so thats why its difficult resolve.
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
"So it's not a complex issue. That's the big thing. It's super simple. There's one group that has enormous power, it's the most powerful country in the middle east, it's backed by the United States, it acts on another population of people with total impunity, and it is never held accountable for anything. So there's no symmetry in the relationship. Period." Michael Brooks
One tiny country of a few million people in a sea of violent antagonistic hateful racist hundreds of millions...
Yes all that is needed is Israel needs a Solution to the Palestinian Question. Lots of possible solutions. They could make all Palestinians Israeli citizens, whether they want it or not, or like it or not.
Umm.. because of the unconditional support from colonialist countries?
@@Icarus7c04If there wasn't that support and actual pressure then there would have to be change to more peaceful coexistence.
They recolonise the world by artificial poverty.
@@Icarus7c04 your reply is an implicit recognition of the validity of his statement. remember always that you could have been born Palestinian and seeing people on the internet enjoying the annihlation of your country would not be as "funny".
Land land land.. what has Palestine done in 31 years with the Land, what has Gaza done 31 years with the LAND ... but it is all Israel Fault, what you had 1 trillion total AID you still haven't build mega houses in the WEST BANK... in GAZA all those houses were paid by 80% by the West and 20% by the Arabs. so do tell me what have you done with the LAND in 31 year time.
Us doesn’t want them to stop, just like Ukraine
But doesnt the whole land belong to Israel?
WRONG🤦🏻 The land NEVER belonged to them. Palestine was colonised by the British in 1918 (read about the Balfour Declaration) and then the British handed it over to the European Jews in the 1940s.
And before 1918 it was which country history master?
@@yuvanti intelligent question! They never answer this question
I say "its hard to resolve" because people refuse to take in the WHOLE timeline of history - its cherry-picked to paint whatever picture the person wants
Is this a pro Neanderthal message?
MIDDLE EAST CONFLICT 🙄🙄🙄 Always trying to show to the world that MIDDLE EAST in general are chaotic. Habibi come to Dubai! And lick some golds. 👊🏻
Actually not that hard to resolve. A land has been stolen from its owners and should be returned to them. Basta
Why doesn't their god help them?
Who’s god?
Religion is the most insane concept mankind has ever dreamed up.
2 state solution and Jerusalem open to people from all countries and religions. Give peace a chance.
This conflict is not complex at all.
Religion.
Nothing to do with religion.
Most people usually don't care with other people beliefs.
People start to care when someone use religion to opress others. Or to make personal profit using religion.
@@Jocky8807 Religion is an instrument to control the people.
Religion is irrelevant in this situation! It’s about power and territorial integrity!
@@i.k.8868 who control who using religion?
I this case of hamas-Israel?
At least from my point a view, no one is exercising control in the situation. It is just out of control. 🙏
Excuses
Truly complex!
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
Thanks for the brief overview of the history of the conflict. This war must stop to avoid further killings of civilians.
We didn't learn anything from covid.
You occupy someone's country, there bound to be issues until you leave
in India we have so many language and religion but we all live in peace though some small conflicts occur not like a war...just wondering why one country with two religion and two language is not possible,,,,it looks for me pure politics tat is keeping the people separate for their benefits..peace will come if palestine n israel people sit n resolve issues by themselves..
India is very special. But Pakistan shows us you been divided. Divide to rule......old roman principe. Shanti
If someone suddenly come into your house and divide into 2 parts, would you still like to sit, resolve and accept to the facts that now you need to share your house with someone else?
@@humanity2914 Divide to rule is their roman wisdom.
@@bachhongtran Err. Which human right you are talking about? Israel already have been condemned in more than 40 times by UN Human Right Councils. In 2022 alone, Israel is condemned more than all other country combined.
instead of wondering read history.
Why not have the Israelis move out of the West Bank, then both team up to fight Hamas
"killed people. Took hostages" is a great example of minimalisation.
This is such a superficial glance at what u call a complex conflict, pitiful
Hamas ist ein Terrorist, weil sie Zivilisten getötet hat, aber Israel hat 75 Jahre lang jeden Tag Zehntausende Zivilisten getötet, und niemand hat gesagt, dass es ein Terrorist ist. Das ist Heuchelei ohne Grenzen, aber die Zeit wird zeigen, wer derjenige ist, der getötet hat Bei den meisten israelischen Zivilisten handelte es sich um die israelische Armee, denn es ist eine Armee, die nicht zwischen unschuldigen Israelis und Kämpfern unterscheidet, und es gibt Aussagen von Bürgern. Die Israelis haben dies bestätigt
history says enough
Attempting to cleanse one's conscience by shifting blame onto the innocent is like trying to wash away your past mistakes with a muddy river.
Let's all strive for accountability and learn from history, rather than rewriting it.
Grand Mufti of Jerusalem. Lots of history there worth checking out. Amin al-Husseini.
Why so hard to resolve? Because Israel doesn't belong there. All the problems are there because of that US backed smudge on the map ... ^^