Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Israel: Who Are the Indigenous People? | 5-Minute Videos
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 авг 2024
- SUBSCRIBE 👉 www.prageru.co...
Subscribe to Noa Tishby's RUclips - www.youtube.co...
The Land of Israel has changed hands many times over the centuries. But it has always been the homeland of one particular people. Noa Tishby, author of Israel: A Simple Guide to the Most Misunderstood Country on Earth, explains.
Script:
When we think about indigenous people, we think about their deep roots and longstanding connections to the land they inhabit, often spanning centuries or even millennia.
For example, the Chinese are from China, the Egyptians are from Egypt, and the Indians are from India. But what about the Jews? Well, the Jews are from Judea, the modern-day land of Israel, where Jewish heritage stretches back over 3,000 years.
And like other indigenous people, the connection to the Jewish homeland is an integral part of the Jewish identity. Judaism is not just a religion, but the Jews are also a people with strong ties to the place from which they originated, the ancient land of Israel.
The practice of Judaism is directly connected to that land. It celebrates holidays like the harvest time and has prayers that are tied to the seasons in the Land of Israel.
Seven crop species, including olives, grapes, wheat, and barley, are cherished in Jewish symbolism because they represent Israel, the "Land Flowing with Milk and Honey."
For centuries, Jews have been saying L'Shana Haba'ah B'Yerushalayim, or “Next Year in Jerusalem,” never forgetting their connection to the Land of Israel.
But don’t take just my word for it. Historians and archeologists point to artifacts and historical writings that prove the connection between the land of Israel and the Jewish people.
Hebrew inscriptions have been found on thousands of artifacts dating as far back as the 6th century BC. Hebrew is my mother’s tongue and I can read those inscriptions. In addition to Jewish sources, an Egyptian document dating to approximately 1200 BC mentions a campaign in which an Egyptian ruler says he has defeated Israel.
“Israel is no more,” the document reads, probably the worst prophecy ever made about the Jews, since you know, I’m still here.
The Hebrew Bible is of course much more than a book of history, but there’s a lot of verified history in it. The fact that Jerusalem is mentioned 669 times in its pages confirms that the city is central to the Jewish identity.
Politically, the land of Israel swapped hands for thousands of years, but it was never anything other than a sovereign Jewish state.
Let me say that again: the only sovereign state that ever existed in the Land of Israel- forever-is a Jewish state.
The Jewish people have formed three nation-states in the Land of Israel throughout history. The first was the First Commonwealth, ruled by the House of David, and it lasted for more than four centuries. Israel was united by King David, and Jerusalem was the capital of that Jewish state. The First Temple built by King Solomon was a huge source of Jewish pride.
Then the Babylonians conquered the land, exiling most of the Jewish residents to Babylon. In 539 BC, Persia’s King Cyrus conquered Babylon and issued the Cyrus Decree, allowing the Jews to return to Israel, and many did. They rebuilt the country, including the Second Temple in Jerusalem on the site of the destroyed First Temple. Its Western Wall is still standing and today it is one of the holiest sites of the Jewish people.
For the full script, visit: l.prageru.com/...
#israel #indigenous
Why do critics of Israel ignore the fact that more than half of the Israeli Jewish population were refugees from Muslim nations and not Europe?
Yeah people ignore that Sephardic people has always been in Israel when Muslim empires held it and when the British took it.
Because it was Israel who created fear mongering propaganda to make the Jews in the middle east feel like they have no home but isreal because they initially rejected to go their
Palestine are those trying to steal land. Not the Jews.
Because they’re looking for smears, not facts
@riverdalehigh8r5tWhat does that mean?
When jews were ousted of their homeland centuries ago, many came to Bharath 🇮🇳. It was one of the few nations where they were not prosecuted. They lived with us Hindus, Buddhists, Jains, Sikhs and Christians (I am a Christian myself) for centuries with harmony and love. Many lived in my state Kerala too. Still some lives. But many have left for their ancestoral land ❤. Good to see my nation and Israel being great allies. 🇮🇳🤝🇮🇱.
But cannot say the same about Muslims. The kind of destruction they brought in India. They were so insecure they burned down world's oldest university just because they felt the knowledge stored in it is superior to them. The texts and books in it burned for six months. Knowledge of that amount cannot be retrieved. Such b@stards.
The funny thing is their Imams(religious scholars) teach them to stay dormant now when they are a minority and dominate when they are a majority. Reminds me of Lebonan 🇱🇧.
@@aadu.thoma44 Imams are Muslim.
@@mortimersnerd5172 Bro I was talking about Muslims. There was a comment before that. But YT deletes my comment.
@@aadu.thoma44 I understood your comment even without reading the other one you referred to that has been removed. Lebanon's history in the 20th century should be a wake up call for all western democracies. Hopefully we aren't past the tipping point yet. I was a soldier in the US army during the time that the marine barracks was hit with a suicide bomber in Beirut. I spent much time reading and trying to understand Lebanon. Bridgette Gabriel is a great source of information on that subject.
I'm a 75 year old retired U.S. Marine Corps combat veteran. Since my early childhood, I have found comfort in the Torah that my Maternal Grandfather gave me. Though he was a practicing Christian, he told me that I should delve deeply into the history and culture of the ORIGINAL 'Palestinians', the Jewish people. Never have I been impacted as I was by my Grandfathers vehement support of Israel and the Jewish people. He was an orphan who ran away from the orphanage at age 10 and who literally raised himself in the Dakota territory. Grandpa Baumgardner had a brilliant mind. What drove him I still don't know but he sought out an education. A mathematical genius with a beautiful Spencerian script, mainly self taught but most of all was his love of reading.
That being said, I listened to him carefully. He was a very hard man who not only worked hard and fought hard but he was also a man with an undying love for the land of Israel. I learned of Israel, Judea and Samaria, Jewish holidays, Jewish art, and Jewish history while still in grade school. As a young Marine, I attended Jewish services at the military chapels if a rabbi was there. Yes, I also attended the various denominations of Christian services from time to time but never did I have the sense of closeness, and purpose that I did when I attended Temple services.
What I learned that is also most fascinating. While I was always welcomed and treated like family by the Rabbi and Jewish Marines, was that I was NEVER proselytized or talked down to as I was in other religious services I went to. Perhaps, just perhaps it's because the Jewish people know just how hard it is to be Jewish in this spiteful world we live in. I still have that treasured old Torah my Grandfather gave me and it still brings me comfort ...... but I still can't read Hebrew. Transliteration yes but Hebrew?? Sighhhh.....
Maybe next year ..... in Jerusalem.
How very remarkably like my own history! Thank you so much for posting this. Before I read it I was convinced that I was unique; some sort of cultural misfit.
Your Grandfather sounds like an exceptional man. Perhaps you should write his biography?
It's part of the religion and culture not to proselytize because it's one of those things that is in Hashem's hands. We aren't here to convince anyone we are right, we can just have children and raise them by our ideals. Part of conversion is being denied over and over BECAUSE the weight of the world rests on the chosen people's shoulders, and someone has to understand that by accepting Judaism as their own it means they are both responsible for our mission and also will bear the same hatred and dangers we have faced for thousands of years. (It's also why we guard our practices, because doing the "fun part" is only for those of us doing the hard part too.)
Semper Fi!
Judaism is the religion, Jews are the people - the bloodline. There are Jews of many different religions. There was never, not once in history, a forceful spread of Judaism through-out any lands.
What a beautiful and moving story. I am grateful to your grandfather too and to you as well. Thank you!!!
Learned some of this stuff in 6th grade history class. It’s insane that all the people against Israel probably don’t even know this stuff or they deny it
Satanist mastered denying truth
I think it was about 8th grade here. But the 1968 and Yom Kippur Wars were well documented as well as SNAFUs like the USS Liberty.
But for this simple mind, it is a matter of observing the obvious, which is Palestine is a made up name, for people that believe entitlement comes from simply raising hell. They want everything yet have earned nothing.....even at best they have been an historic dependant and vassal state, and worst a 5th column of malignant, flea ridden, deadbeat, ghetto rat, inbred, idiots. The latest from these ghetto rats is........"Israel cut off our water, and electricity!" This the idiocy I am addressing. To claim on one hand that Israel must be destroyed and from the river Jordan named after the tribe of Dan to a sea the ancient Arabs called the Roman sea should be the new Palestine state replacing existing Israel , and yet squawk madly when the Israel cuts off their water and power that they are dependant upon........flea brains indeed.
it's because they don't want to acknowledge the truth of history so they can insist and claim that they actually own israel according to themselves
u repeat jewish narrative like a parrot instead of googling yourself. Please correct me if I am wrong:
1. People with E-M35 DNA marker(otherwise known as JEWS pls google if u did not know) came from Ethiopia to Egypt cause of MONEY
2. Egypt eliminated its competitor who controlled most of trade routes and who invented alphabet and who is the founder civilizaiton of Europe.
3. The name of the country was PHOENICIA and EGYPT USED JEWS TO ERASE THEM FROM THE FACE OF THE EARTH.
4. ENTIRE TORAH AND EVERY SINGLE JEWISH MANUSCRIPT WAS MERE COPY OF EGYPTIAN MANUSCRIPTS WHERE THEY CHANGED EGYPTIAN NAMES TO JEWISH NAMES AND SUBJECT PRONOUNS IN COMMANDMENTS TO CONVINCE JEWS THEY WERE CHOSEN BY ALMIGHTY TO GO TO PROMISED LAND(PHOENICIA) AND TO ESTABLISH THEIR COUNTRY THERE. AND AGENT 777 EXAGGERATED WEALTH AND RESOURCES OF PHOENICIA AT LEAST 10 TIMES FOR MORE MOTIVATION FOR POOR SLAVES.
5. THE OPERATION WAS LED BY EGYPTIAN SPY CALLED MOSES(aka agent 777).
6. EGYPT PROVIDED WEAPONS, FOOD, CLOTHES AND OTHER SUPPLIES FOR THE OPERATION.
7.AFTER EXTERMINATING PHOENICIANS JEWS ESTABLISHED ISRAEL(COLONY OF EGYPT).
7. MEANING THEY WERE ENEMIES TO ALL OF THEIR NEIGHBORS(ASSYRIANS, PERSIANS, ARMENIANS, ETC)
7. THEN THEY WERE EXPELLED FROM "THEIR" LAND BY THEIR NEIGBORS AND WENT AGAIN TO THE WEALTHIEST COUNTRIES(ROME AND GREECE)
8. THEN THEY CAME BACK TO "THEIR' LAND FIRST UNDER THE PROTECTION OF GREEK ARMY AND KILLED LOCALS AGAIN
9. THEN THEY WERE EXPELLED ONCE AGAIN FOR THE SAME REASONS.
10. THEN THEY CAME BACK AGAIN UNDER THE PROTECTION OF ROMAN ARMY AND KILLED THE LOCALS AGAIN
11. THEN THEY STABBED ROMANS IN A BACK AND WERE EXPELLED ONCE AGAIN FROM 'THEIR" LAND
12. THEN THEY QUICKLY FORGOT THEIR MISTAKE AND RETURNED TO ROME
13. THEN THEY SERVED ROMAN EMPIRE ONCE AGAIN AND ROMANS COPIED THEIR EGYPTIAN RELIGION AND ELEVATED IT TO STATE RELIGION(CHRISTIANITY) THOUGH MADE SOME AMMENDEMENTS TO IT TO ADAPT TO MITHRAISM TO UNITE HIGH RANKING OFFICERS AND LOW RANKING COMMONERS WHO HAD CONFLICT WITH EACH OTHER
14. THEN WHEN NEW WEALTHIEST EMPIRE OF ISLAM EMERGED SOME OF JEWS WENT TO ARABIA
15. ARAB JEWS LEARNED ALGEBRA, ALCHEMY, TRIGONOMETRY, MEDICINE, ETC THERE AND ESTABLISHED CONTACTS WITH EUROPEAN JEWS
16. THEY WERE THE FIRST TO INTRODUCE 0 TO EUROPE THANKS TO THEIR ARAB MASTERS
17. THEIR WEALTH SKYROCKETED FROM THAT MOMENT IN EUROPE DUE TO THE KNOWLEDGE THEY TOOK FROM ARABS
18. THEN THEY STARTED EXPLOITING THEIR EUROPEAN MASTERS
19. THEN THEIR EUROPEAN MASTERS STARTED PUNISHING THEM
20. THEN THEY SUFFERED AGAIN
21. FAST FORWARD THEN BRITISH CAME UP WITH THE IDEA TO GET RID OF THEM AND CREATED ZIONISM IN 19TH CENTURY
22. HOWEVER JEWS WOULD DIE RATHER THAN LEAVE THEIR WEALTHY MASTERS
23. THEN UK PAID SOME CASH TO SOME JEWS TO SMEAR THE NAME OF THE REST JEWS IN EUROPE AND IT WORKED
24. THOSE BRIBED JEWS WERE DUMB ENOUGH TO STAB GERMANY IN A BACK IN WW1 AND JEOPARDIZE LIVES OF ALL JEWS IN EUROPE
25. THEN ALL OF THEM WERE EXTERMINATED IN AXIS EUROPE BECAUSE OF THAT
26. THEN OIL IN ARAB COUNTRIES WAS DISCOVERED
27. THEN USA AND UK REESTABLISHED ISRAEL FORCEFULLY TO CONTROL OIL RICH COUNTRIES
28. AGAIN JEWS EXPELLED LOCALS FROM FORMER PHOENICIAN LANDS
29. THEIR TRADITIONAL ROLE OF DOG THIS TIME AGAINST OIL RICH COUNTRIES INDICATED THEIR INABILITY TO GET RID OF THE RELIGION ENFORCED ON THEM BY THEIR FORMER MASTERS(EGYPTIANS).
30. THEY KEEP REPEATING THE SAME MISTAKE OVER AND OVER AGAIN.
31. FISH MEMORY>Helsinki syndrome+stupidity
Nah, they believe that the first humans were cavemen called HOMO PALESTINIAS who are the irrefutable ancestors of the present day Palestinians - so called fact hidden by the ZIONIST BOLCHEVIK FREEMASON CONSPIRACY - the same people who secretly cooked that COVID-19 virus and released it in China. They believe that Israel is an apartheid colonizing state like in South Africa. And they believe that Palestine must be JEW FREE and run by those democratic HAMAS heroes who are slanderously are portraited as terrorists.
YEP, we all know that Shani Louk was a Mossad Agent and that picture of her mutilated body in the back of a pick-up truck was FAKE NEWS, part of the ZIONIST BOLCHEVIK FREEMASON CONSPIRACY.
And yet, when my mother visited Israel as a tourist, she NEVER saw a Restroom with a sign FOR JEWS ONLY next to a dilapidated one reserved for all ALL NON JEWS. And of course the story of this ARAB ISRAELI JUDGE sentencing a former president of Israel to jail for sexual assault is again FAKE NEWS. Also FAKE NEWS is that story of those tunnels under a children's hospital. We all know that is was the IDF who built all of those tunnels to discredit those nice guys from HAMAS.
And don't forget that those children and those 70 year old women dragged back to Gaza on October 7th are not hostages but prisoners of war.
YEP. that's the truth I guess - all of that CONSPIRACY STUFF.
But there is one thing I don't understand from this irrefutable truth of that genocide of the indigenous Palestinian People by that so called terrorist state called Israel :
How can this state be so competent in winning wars against it's Arab neighbours, AND YET so utterly inept in the fine art of GENOCIDE ? I always believed that AFTER a genocide there are CONSIDERABLY LESS PEOPLE.
MOREOVER :
And how can it be that the area of the SO CALLED PALESTINE LAND IN 1964 had excluded the West Bank when it had been annexed by Jordan AND Gaza when it had been annexed by Egypt ? And why was the word Palestine not mentioned in the 1947 UN Partition plan ? If you read the resolution carefully, it mentions A JEWISH STATE and an ARAB STATE.
It never mentioned A JEWISH STATE and a PALESTINIAN STATE.
FINALLY :
How can an indigenous people proudly bear the name coined by two of the greatest Empires, first the ROMAN EMPIRE after the fall of MESADA and second, the BRITISH EMPIRE after the fall of the OTTOMAN EMPIRE ?
END QUOTE :
And so I end with a quote from someone who knows better than me since he was the President for Life of Syria, namely Hafed Assad to that pistol toating PLO chairman Arafat ( An so called indigenous Palestinian who born in Egypt to Egyptian Family who died a billionaire ) :
“You do not represent Palestine as much as we do. Never forget this one point: There is no such thing as a Palestinian people, there is no Palestinian entity, there is only Syria. You are an integral part of the Syrian people, Palestine is an integral part of Syria. Therefore it is we, the Syrian authorities, who are the true representatives of the Palestinian people."
I am not Jewish, and I am amazed how much of this I already knew. Learned even more. Thanks.
There's a big lie they missed in this video however. The jews that are now in Israel are actually indigenous to Europe. They have some mixed ancestry with the ancient jews, but then again so do the Palestinians. Both the jews and the palestinians have common ancestors from the land of Israel, though they both are mixed with dna from other ethnicities through the many centuries of movement and conquests. That's why it makes absolutely ZERO sense for the jews in Israel today to act like THEY are indigenous to Israel, when their ancestors ceased living there a very long time ago, and the palestinian who were there for 1300 years continuously AT LEAST, are not.
@@Kprywatne So, where is the justification for Palestine. Look at how many years the Jews were there until they were driven out. It is way longer that the Jews were there than the mere 1300 for the Palestinians.
@@Kprywatne i wonder how people skip this
@@Kprywatne they were indigenous to Europe because their ancestors had to move there because they were forced out of those lands by Muslims. They are coming back after being hosted in Europe.
they were indigenous to Europe because their ancestors had to move there because they were forced out of those lands by Muslims. They are coming back after being hosted in Europe.
Very good explanation. I would note that Judea was occupied by the Romans prior to 70 AD . Around 70 AD the Jews revolted against the empire and said revolt was brutally crushed by Rome with their temples destroyed and its people scattered to the wind. The region was renamed Palestine by the Romans in a final stroke of genocide. It is important to note that even though Rome made this name change to a region of the empire there has never been a nation of Palestine nor has anyone ever had a "Palestinian" passport.
This is correct. The amount of disinformation and ignorant people we have worldwide today is mind boggling. For example Pierce Morgan brings in hothead after hothead to give rants on the situation between Israel and hamas and skew the reality.
What passports do Palestinians have?
@@BillyBobDingo1971 Wherever they were born or are citizens. Probably Jorden, Lebanon or others. There are Palestinians with Israeli passports but it's hard to say who is a Palestinian since it is a self identification and not something they are a citizen of.` Those born in Gasa are probably entitled to the citizenship of their parents.
@@TheBruces56 correct and to add- it is a political ideology, not an ethnic group. Most of them are descended from Turks, Azerbaijani, Roma, etc, many who came from nearby countries in the 1920s to work for the British. Sun never sets on the British Empire.
Can’t believe so few have even a basic understanding of history.
the cannaanites oddly were killed by the Zionist for worshipping the walling wall and having abortions
Honestly, I'm glad this has such a high dislike ratio. (50-50) This means that this video reached the opposite audience that this channel usually attracts, which is huge because they were finally exposed to a legitimate point of view for once.
Wher do you live. Because it’s impossible for me to see the dislikes in my country
Theyll just say its propaganda
They down-voters didn't watch, liberals don't like history and facts, only feelings.
From 2021 viewers cannot see number of dislikes, so don’t know how you can!
It's a browser extension. Go to your extensions and search for 'Return RUclips Dislike'.@@kirstymackenzie2437
I find it ridiculous that we live in a modern world where this still needs to be explained to western people.
and they are like: Oh this is propaganda
You're an ignoramus who doesn't understand what being indigenous means
A RUclips called bad empanada has done an in-depth video explaining what being indigenous is sociological speaking
And when you watch the video called "israelis are not indigenous" you'll see that this simpleton definition of indiginiety goes out the window
It's literally orwellian to call recent israeli settlers indigenous
I literally thought this was common knowledge until like a month ago. I don’t understand why it’s not. It seems so simple.
Because video games, long working hours, ignorance, and varied interest don't always allow this. It's up to you and I to make this common knowlege
It is simple, but in today’s shallow world , where tik tok became a source of “knowledge” , people are so ignorant, and instead of learning facts , they listen to famous people with money, who think because they have money and fame-they are actually smart . That’s the most ridiculous theory I’ve seen in my life. And these famous people really believe that they are smart , they like being called “influencers”.
Mr Taorut. Let me ask you this, in what country. In the Arab world are Arabs tolerant of any other religion other than Islam? And before you blame the British for the woes of the Arabs in Israel, If it wasn’t for the Brit’s the neither Jordanians nor Palestinians would even exist. Please read very basic history before spewing your hate so you can at least sound somewhat educated.
@@Tarout888Exactly. Palestine was an Arab region, which was controlled post 1917 by Britain against the wishes of the vast majority. The British occupiers allowed large scale colonisation by Jews. Then post 1945 huge numbers of Jews arrived from Europe, for obvious reasons. This video is full of lies, it is propaganda. The real story is actually quite complex, with two separate stories, both with some truth.
Yes, I ABSOLUTELY do not understand the anti-Jewish feelings/thoughts/ideas...
Well said, thank you, but it always amazes me that, no matter what proof and how much of it is presented to some people, they will still choose hate. This ancient conflict is not about land. It's about Jew hatred. The haters of the world use this and demonize Israel to justify their antisemitism.
Such typical jargon, your assimilation worked well.
Let me help you: A day is coming to all of humankind...when each will give an account of their life. For all humans born on this side of the Cross, they will answer for being a follower of Jesus and his way, or answer for rejecting him outright.
Land, hatred and "bloodline" (cough) will all be irrelevant on that day.
But for all born on this side of the Cross who reject Jesus the Messiah, it will not be a good day. Not my words, so save your silly "who are you to judge" nonsense.
you just said a PragerU video was "well said"
💯💯💯
Lol what a joke.
@@12B4Christ Absolutely correct. And BTW Neither the Jews nor the Palestinians who are Arabs are "indigenous" to the land of Canaan! They are BOTH invaders from Iraq who sprang from the lions of Abraham of Ur of the Chaldees. But as you rightly say even that is irrelevant. What is relevant is who you say Jesus is and what you choose to do about that.
The best explanation about the Jews and Israel that I have ever heard. Bless you for explaining it to us and for pointing out that it has always been Jewish lands from antiquity and still belongs to the Jews. And most importantly, they welcome all people and faiths in peace! Shallom
Ashkenazis aren't Jews. they're gentiles:
"And the sons of Gomer; Ashkenaz, and Riphath, and Togarmah. And the sons of Javan; Elishah, and Tarshish, Kittim, and Dodanim. By these were the isles of the Gentiles divided in their lands; every one after his tongue, after their families, in their nations.
- Genesis 10:3-5
וּבְנֵי, גֹּמֶר--אַשְׁכְּנַז וְרִיפַת, וְתֹגַרְמָה.
וּבְנֵי יָוָן, אֱלִישָׁה וְתַרְשִׁישׁ, כִּתִּים, וְדֹדָנִים.
מֵאֵלֶּה נִפְרְדוּ אִיֵּי הַגּוֹיִם, בְּאַרְצֹתָם, אִישׁ, לִלְשֹׁנוֹ--לְמִשְׁפְּחֹתָם,
[בְּרֵאשִׁית]
Do you live in USA? If so then practice what you preach and get off the Native Americans land please.
That is not true and you know it.
We are the semitic people in Alsham and Iraq thousands of years before any Jew walked on earth.
We are and not European jews who share smae DNA with Europeans
we will never forget or forgive ethnic cleansing of Palestine to establish apartheid Israel
if u believe the jewish story in the jewish bible, their god told them to go to Canaan/Palestine, kill all the natives and steal the land because they are humans while non jews are animals.
this story in the torah, if u believe it, it does not make them the natives of the land by any means, the natives since 8000 years ago are the Canaani Arabs
The Jewish faith calls for the killing of babies of Amalek:
"Now go and attack Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and do not spare them. But kill man and woman, infant and nursing child, ox and sheep, camel and donkey."
The Talmud holds that only Jews are true human beings and Gentiles are “goyim” (meaning cattle or beast).
The following are shocking but exact quotes from their various books.
Sanhedrin 59a: “Murdering Goyim is like killing a wild animal.”
The Hebrew text further calls for the killing of the entire nation of Amalek: "Now go and attack Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and do not spare them. But kill man and woman, infant and nursing child, ox and sheep, camel and donkey."
Abodah Zara 26b: “Even the best of the Gentiles should be killed.”
Sanhedrin 59a: “A goy (Gentile) who pries into The Law (Talmud) is guilty of death.”
Libbre David 37: “To communicate anything to a Goy about our religious relations would be equal to the killing of all Jews, for if the Goyim knew what we teach about them, they would kill us openly.”
Libbre David 37: “If a Jew be called upon to explain any part of the rabbinic books, he ought to give only a false explanation. Who ever will violate this order shall be put to death.”
(They contest the previous two)
@@paramezSo what’s the truth about Israel? Something you saw on Tik Tok, posted by a Communist or an Islamist? 🤣🤣🤣🤣 GTFO of here.
Her succinct explanation put tears in my eyes and joy in my heart. I am a Christian and I have a deep love for the land of Israel and the Jewish people. I believe that Christians who do not believe Israel is necessarily the land of the Jews are going to have a hard time explaining that to God.
The Egyptian "conqueror" she's referring to is Merneptah , son of Ramses II. His stele (the stone tablet where he had his accomplishments engraved) dates to about 1205 BC and is on display at the Cairo Museum where anyone can see it. The inscription about Israel is highlighted. It stands about 10' tall.
There were no Jews in Egypt then. They were either in Canaan or Yemen.
That tablet refers to an ancient Canaanite village called Yezra-El, not to any "Jews" or any 'Israelites' invented later on. That village was erased in May-August 1948 by the invading Khazar Jewish Nazi settlers-colonists
@@zackjalamani dang history wouldn’t agree with you
@@zackjalamani Muslim
@@zackjalamani Not a fan of truth are you ?
Blessed will you be forever for speaking up in this way. In less than 6 minutes you leave anyone speechless. May we all go back and read the history contained in the Bible. Shalom :)
I think your analysis is wrong.
Ashkenazi Jews are the descendants of a crossbreeding between Slavs and Kazhars, who converted to Judaism in the 8th century.
Sephardic Jews are Berbers who converted to Judaism mainly in the 7th century.
The most serious Israeli historians, especially Israel Bartal, have made it clear that the exodus of the Judeans in 70 A.D. was a pure myth !
The true descendants of the ancient Israelites are in fact the Arabic-speaking Palestinians.
Indeed, as the jewish historian Ahad Ha'am very well explained it, the Jews of Judea, but also those of Galilee, as well as the Samaritans of Samaria, converted massively to Christianity in the first centuries of our era, then after the Islamic conquest, they gradually converted to Islam.
Modern Jews are therefore not the descendants of ancient Judeans, but modern Palestinians are indeed the descendants of the Jews and Samaritans of ancient times.
I have heard this version of the history before, that the true descendants of the Jews and Samaritans of Roman times were actually the modern Palestinians.
This is what the Israeli historian Shlomo Sand wrote, in 2008, in his famous book “The Invention of the Jewish People”.
That was the conclusion I came to. Because Ashkenazi Jews have a distinctly European appearance. Sephardic Jews, on the other hand, have the same appearance as other people of North African origin, as the German Jewish anthropologist Franz Boas wrote in 1923.
The Palestinians, unlike the Ashkenazim and Sephardim, have a typically Levantine physical appearance, which indeed suggests that they have been present on this land for thousands of years. Israeli geneticist Eran Elhaik even demonstrated that they were descendants of Natufians.
We can therefore only conclude that the Palestinians are the only and authentic descendants of the ancient Israelites.
it’s a lot of misinformation from videos like this
There are so many reasons why the Kazhar theory is incorrect and has been widely debunked. Apart from the fact that Ashkenazi Jews continued to read, write and speak both Hebrew and Aramaic should be your first hint. These languages originated in Israel and continued to be spoken by Jews throughout Europe. The Lingua Franca was Yiddish, which is a blend of German, Hebrew and Aramaic. The music they played was all derived from Middle Eastern scales. There is no trace of Kazhar culture or language amongst Ashkenazi Jews. The most convincing piece of evidence however, are the genome wide studies showing that the genetic origins of Ashkenzi Jews are from the Levant (Israel) and southern Europe. The latter is presumed to be the result of intermarriage soon after the Jews were exiled by the Romans. Nevertheless, they retained their culture and heritage and always considered Israel to be their home. There is no genetic evidence linking Ashkenazi Jews to the Kazhar or the southern Turkic region which they inhabited. avotaynuonline.com/2020/03/the-genetic-origins-of-ashkenazi-jews/
@@dannyurbinder5965
Thank you for your interesting response.
Nevertheless, I recommend that you read the study done by Israeli geneticist Eran Elhaik. It's about a genetic comparison between Natufian remains and modern populations, whether Ashkenazim, Middle Eastern Mizrahim, or modern Palestinians. The Natufians being the partial ancestors of the Canaanites. The result of this genetic comparison, carried out by Eran Elhaik's team, is as follows:
"In a principle component analysis (PCA), the ancient Levantines clustered predominantly with modern-day Palestinians and Bedouins and marginally overlapped with Arabian Jews, whereas Ashkenazi Jews clustered away from Levantine individuals and adjacent to Neolithic Anatolians and Late Neolithic and Bronze Age Europeans."
So, the Jews of the Middle East have some of their ancestors who come from this region. There was in fact the destruction of the northern kingdom, the kingdom of Israel, by the Assyrians, and who effectively deported a small part of the population. But obviously the majority of the residents were not deported. Then the Babylonians deported part of the Judean elites in 586 BC. But in no case the Judean people.
So only the Mizrahim of the Middle East actually have part of their ancestors in this region.
For the Ashkenazim, things are far from settled. When you talk about exile by the Romans, you should know that it is a pure myth.
I quote the response that Israel Bartal gave to Shlomo Sand in the Haaretz newspaper :
« My response to Sand's arguments is that no historian of the Jewish national movement has ever really believed that the origins of the Jews are ethnically and biologically “pure.” Sand applies marginal positions to the entire body of Jewish historiography and, in doing so, denies the existence of the central positions in Jewish historical scholarship.
No “nationalist” Jewish historian has ever tried to conceal the well-known fact that conversions to Judaism had a major impact on Jewish history in the ancient period and in the early Middle Ages. Although the myth of an exile from the Jewish homeland does exist in popular Israeli culture, it is negligible in serious Jewish historical discussions. Important groups in the Jewish national movement expressed reservations regarding this myth or even denied it completely. »
Noa is just amazing with grace... & So darn smart it gives one chills....
Not to mention beautiful.
I am not sure if "we" are allowed to type those compliments, these days...@@Calango741
Sincere question: The world is mostly comprised of displaced peoples. It's the rule and not the exception. Are we saying the world is fair game for others to take back any land they have ties to, regardless of who currently resides there?
What about land with no deed of ownership that was considered public land under a sovereign ruler that no longer exists? Most of the land the early Zionists first settled was private land they purchased from absentee Arab and Turkish landlords, much of it wasteland, much of it malaria-ridden swamps, and paid for at high prices at the time. All public lands were ruled by the Ottoman Empire which dissolved after World War I. There was no golden age of Palestinian Arabs there. There was no Nation of Palestine. Ever. The claim there was is an invention of Yassir Arafat and the PLO with the help of the Soviet KGB which helped create and train the Arab terror groups that made up the PLO. The Soviet KGB even invented and helped spread the blood libel used by Leftists to this day that Israel is an apartheid racist genocidal state. The Arabs there were divided up among various clans and some village tribes. When Samuel Clemens aka Mark Twain toured the Land of Israel and wrote about his trip in his 1869 book "Innocents Abroad," he wrote of a desolate, depressing empty place. And of the Arabs who did live there and who became refugees during the 1948 War, there would have been no Arab refugees had the Arabs agreed to the UN's 1947 Partition Peace Plan. Instead, they launched a war to destroy Israel but lost. And those Arab refugees as well as further Israeli conquests of public non-deeded land far greater than anything the Jews would have had if the Arabs were willing to compromise along with previously occupied Arab villages as part of that war were absorbed into the restored Israeli state. "Brother" Arab states refused to absorb the refugees and kept them in refugee camps so they could serve as pawns in their propaganda war against Israel, and where they'd stay in poverty rather than having a chance to blend into the vast Arab land they were now living in. Meanwhile, 800,000 Jews had to flee the Arab lands they lived in for centuries due to persecution, confiscation of their property, and even cases of mass murder in revenge for Israel's victory in 1948. Those Jews were successfully absorbed into Israeli life.
Yah man, if your Greek just take back Constantinople. If your German, grab Danzig... all good right Jews?
That was then, before the UN made it illegal to just take any land you want. Warring and conquering was a way of life back then. But not anymore. Now we only have mergers and acquisitions and other lawful corporate takeovers.
What, exactly, do you mean by 'taking back the land'? Did Jews throw anybody off the land these people owned? Not really. With very few exceptions, Israel has scrupulously observed pre-existing land rights. Or do you mean re-estabslishment of the Jewish state? Then can you, maybe, tell us from whom this state was 'taken back'? There wasn't any other state in existence in these territories at the time. Maybe Jews disenfranchised non-Jewish residents of the land when Israel was re-established? Again, no. In fact, Arab and Christian citizens of Israel have MORE rights, not less, than their brethren in the neighboring Arab countries.
So, again, what exactly do you mean by 'taking back'? What, precisely, did Jews 'take back', and from whom?
@@bezkintsakintsa357 Nice strawman. Good luck beating it to death.
The Merneptah Stele, also known as the Israel Stele is an inscription by Merneptah, a pharaoh in ancient Egypt who reigned from 1213 to 1203 BCE. Discovered by Flinders Petrie at Thebes in 1896, it is now housed at the Egyptian Museum in Cairo.
It is sometimes referred to as the "Israel Stele" because a majority of scholars translate a set of hieroglyphs in line 27 as "Israel" and represents the earliest textual reference to Israel
specifically it doesn't mention them as a state it mentions them as a. people. read up on the translation of the inscriptions from the other people that were conquered
The latest find in north eastern Egypt has the Jewish people residing in the current Israel state in or around 3500 BC.
Oh and those rare & unique bricks in the fireplace mantle of your house were manufactured in my hometown…
Therefore, I own your house… get out…
Interesting historically but irrelevant to the formation and recognition of the state of Palestine in 1920.
@@Noone765 Freedom, democracy and Human Rights from the River to the Sea.
I love the way that an American is suggesting that an 'indigenous' people always own the land no matter who moves in. Bet she doesn't say that to the indigenous people of America...........bit hypocritical.
And who are the indigenous people of America? Unfortunately for the racist anti-white crowd, it was not the "Native Americans".
I'm not Jewish, but my heart and soul is with them always.
So you support them committing war crimes too then?
AMEN 🙏
By far the most civil and informative comments section of any video I’ve seen in a long time. There is much to consider.
Civil is nice but as long as people are allowed to say what they want then that is the beginning of understanding. As long as the dog is barking it's not biting
@@EndoftheBlock7224ok good to know,so this means Native Americans can reclaim their land back right?
What land did Native Americans own? @@mosijahi3096
@@mosijahi3096 Given that there were approximately 500 different Indian nations inhabiting the continent before the arrival of the newcomers, how would you propose we proceed with the reclaiming of the land. Given that Indian nations themselves were guilty of taking lands from other Indian nations, I think we would have a mess on our hands.
@@mosijahi3096Absolutely. If they can take it back, let them. Back in the 1400s and prior, countries were conquering nations. That’s what they did.
And should the land go to…..which tribe? But that’s another issue.
It was survival of the fittest and smartest. We no longer do that openly but it’s still done. So if the peoples who were here when White men arrived want the land, let them be stronger and take it.
Your argument is laughable. But you knew that, didn’t you? 😊
This is so obvious and so true and very greatly presented, just plain historical facts. The whole world seems to be blind at times. This whole telling of stolen land is just plain ridiculous.
Please correct me if I am wrong:
1. People with E-M35 DNA marker(otherwise known as JEWS pls google if u did not know) came from Ethiopia to Egypt cause of MONEY
2. Egypt eliminated its competitor who controlled most of trade routes and who invented alphabet and who is the founder civilizaiton of Europe.
3. The name of the country was PHOENICIA and EGYPT USED JEWS TO ERASE THEM FROM THE FACE OF THE EARTH.
4. ENTIRE TORAH AND EVERY SINGLE JEWISH MANUSCRIPT WAS MERE COPY OF EGYPTIAN MANUSCRIPTS WHERE THEY CHANGED EGYPTIAN NAMES TO JEWISH NAMES AND SUBJECT PRONOUNS IN COMMANDMENTS TO CONVINCE JEWS THEY WERE CHOSEN BY ALMIGHTY TO GO TO PROMISED LAND(PHOENICIA) AND TO ESTABLISH THEIR COUNTRY THERE. AND AGENT 777 EXAGGERATED WEALTH AND RESOURCES OF PHOENICIA AT LEAST 10 TIMES FOR MORE MOTIVATION FOR POOR SLAVES.
5. THE OPERATION WAS LED BY EGYPTIAN SPY CALLED MOSES(aka agent 777).
6. EGYPT PROVIDED WEAPONS, FOOD, CLOTHES AND OTHER SUPPLIES FOR THE OPERATION.
7.AFTER EXTERMINATING PHOENICIANS JEWS ESTABLISHED ISRAEL(COLONY OF EGYPT).
7. MEANING THEY WERE ENEMIES TO ALL OF THEIR NEIGHBORS(ASSYRIANS, PERSIANS, ARMENIANS, ETC)
7. THEN THEY WERE EXPELLED FROM "THEIR" LAND BY THEIR NEIGBORS AND WENT AGAIN TO THE WEALTHIEST COUNTRIES(ROME AND GREECE)
8. THEN THEY CAME BACK TO "THEIR' LAND FIRST UNDER THE PROTECTION OF GREEK ARMY AND KILLED LOCALS AGAIN
9. THEN THEY WERE EXPELLED ONCE AGAIN FOR THE SAME REASONS.
10. THEN THEY CAME BACK AGAIN UNDER THE PROTECTION OF ROMAN ARMY AND KILLED THE LOCALS AGAIN
11. THEN THEY STABBED ROMANS IN A BACK AND WERE EXPELLED ONCE AGAIN FROM 'THEIR" LAND
12. THEN THEY QUICKLY FORGOT THEIR MISTAKE AND RETURNED TO ROME
13. THEN THEY SERVED ROMAN EMPIRE ONCE AGAIN AND ROMANS COPIED THEIR EGYPTIAN RELIGION AND AGAIN MADE SOME AMMENDEMENTS TO IT TO ADAPT TO MITHRAISM TO UNITE HIGH RANKING OFFICERS AND LOW RANKING COMMONERS
14. THEN WHEN NEW WEALTHIEST EMPIRE OF ISLAM EMERGED SOME OF JEWS WENT TO ARABIA
15. ARAB JEWS LEARNED ALGEBRA, ALCHEMY, TRIGONOMETRY, MEDICINE, ETC THERE AND ESTABLISHED CONTACTS WITH EUROPEAN JEWS
16. THEY WERE THE FIRST TO INTRODUCE 0 TO EUROPE THANKS TO THEIR ARAB MASTERS
17. THEIR WEALTH SKYROCKETED FROM THAT MOMENT IN EUROPE DUE TO THE KNOWLEDGE THEY TOOK FROM ARABS
18. THEN THEY STARTED EXPLOITING THEIR EUROPEAN MASTERS
19. THEN THEIR EUROPEAN MASTERS STARTED PUNISHING THEM
20. THEN THEY SUFFERED AGAIN
21. FAST FORWARD THEN BRITISH CAME UP WITH THE IDEA TO GET RID OF THEM AND CREATED ZIONISM IN 19TH CENTURY
22. HOWEVER JEWS WOULD DIE RATHER THAN LEAVE THEIR WEALTHY MASTERS
23. THEN UK PAID SOME CASH TO SOME JEWS TO SMEAR THE NAME OF THE REST JEWS IN EUROPE AND IT WORKED
24. THOSE BRIBED JEWS WERE DUMB ENOUGH TO STAB GERMANY IN A BACK IN WW1 AND JEOPARDIZE LIVES OF ALL JEWS IN EUROPE
25. THEN ALL OF THEM WERE EXTERMINATED IN AXIS EUROPE BECAUSE OF THAT
26. THEN OIL IN ARAB COUNTRIES WAS DISCOVERED
27. THEN USA AND UK REESTABLISHED ISRAEL FORCEFULLY TO CONTROL OIL RICH COUNTRIES
28. AGAIN JEWS EXPELLED LOCALS FROM FORMER PHOENICIAN LANDS
29. THEIR TRADITIONAL ROLE OF DOG THIS TIME AGAINST OIL RICH COUNTRIES INDICATED THEIR INABILITY TO GET RID OF THE RELIGION ENFORCED ON THEM BY THEIR FORMER MASTERS(EGYPTIANS).
30. THEY KEEP REPEATING THE SAME MISTAKE OVER AND OVER AGAIN.
31. FISH MEMORY>Helsinki syndrome+stupidity
Yeah, "Palestinians" can't be indigenous to "Palestine" because it never existed. Canaan is a different story, but studies supposedly show both Jews and Arabs having Canaanite ancestry, so they don't have a leg to stand on..
Here's another analogy....What if today's black people (Caribbean, South American, or U.S. American) claimed rights to lands in their place of origin, Africa. Ridiculous, right? And they're ancestors left Africa only 500 years ago, not 2000 years. They'd be strangers to Africans.
@commentjedi
No one denies Africans the right to live in Africa. They are free to move there if they choose with no opposition.
Jews choose to live in Israel and the world challenges them even though the Bible is very clear on who the land belongs to.
Exodus 32:13
Romans 9:4
Psalm 105:8-11
Joshua 1:1-6
Genesis 13:14-16
On point. Can somebody please explain to me the "Palestinians are indigenous" mindset: if they think that Palestinians are indigenous people, does that mean that Jesus, according to them, was an Arab and a Muslim?
The Palestinians, before becoming Arabic-speaking and Muslim, they spoke Aramaic and were Christians. Indeed, the Palestinian Arabic dialect still contains many words of Aramaic origin.
And historians have established that there were several waves of conversion to Islam in the 7th century, the 11th century and the 16th century.
For their Arabic dialect, it is an Arabization of their original language which was Syriac. And finally, to conclude, you should know that the Palestinians, before being Christians, were in fact of Jewish or Samaritan faith.
Omg what a bad argument. The people you see and call Palestinians only speak arabic, they are not arabs. Palestinians are descendants of the Jews she's talking about in the video. They just became culturally arabized and changed their language and culture. Just like how Peruvians speak Spanish but most of them are indigenous. Now, please compare an average Palestinian face to this lady and tell me who looks more indigenous and middle eastern.
There are lots of other people who are indigenous to that land. There are Druz, Yemenites, and others. My family lived in Jerusalem until the Ottoman Empire was traded in for the British Mandate. Then they emigrated to the U.S. There were always Arabs sharing what is now Israel. My Ashkenazi grandmother was married in a Bedouin traditional Caftan and she remembered playing with the Bedouin children that shared their living space. Everyone celebrated everyone else's holidays. My grandfather helped pick the olives in the Arab olive orchards and earned a
portion of the oil for doing so. He spoke Yiddish, French and Arabic.
@sandramorey2529 Agreed!
@@johnpolitis7929 Just dont use words always.
And that is why the Druz, the Muslims the Bedouin and the Jew are all living in Israel and that’s why even in Israel’s Declaration of Independence it’s written that the 3 main languages are English, Hebrew and Arabic and every holy place, traditions and religions are kept and respected in Israel, even if there’s a fight and hate between the people, their religious beliefs are kept as holy as the Jewish beliefs
@@user-hb2oc9ol8h And the same would happen even more in a Palestinian state. It's in their charter. Only pre-1948 borders of Palestine with a one state binational solution is the only way to end the conflict.
@@johnpolitis7929 If you think for a minute that a Palestinian state would respect and care about other cultures and religions you don’t understand a little bit of Middle Eastern politics. A Palestinian state will immediately be taken over by every terrorist group in the Middle East- the Gaza Strip is an example of what would happen
The irony of Americans supporting returning land to Indigenous peoples will never not make me laugh💆🏾♂️
Never happen.
agree.
the anglo-americans (White americans) are not even the indegenous people in that land anyway😂😂😂
Atleast you don't disagree that jews are indegenous in that region, now tell your Arab friends to stop being delusional.
@@takdangkasaysayan9098 they built that land, without them it would be shithole like any other land in Americas today.
@@mabhodlelajj1195 Oh no, I'm just pointing out the irony of the claim. I find land claims an overall weird concept if they hinge on being born in a place. It's basically dibs which I don't find compelling💭😆. Factor in the violence of every single group and its even worse.
When I think about indigenous people I think about where they were born. If you are born in America you are indigenous to America ❤
That's not the way it works. You can ask a Moroccan being born in the Netherlands if the Dutch society sees him like a Dutch person.
@@p.willram1968 that is the way it works. It doesn't matter if others see you different than you are it's still what you are.
Your example would mean that person doesn't have Dutch ethnicity but they are still indigenous to the Netherlands and if they have offspring with an ethnic Dutch then their children are indigenous ethnic Dutch.♥️
The History of the imaginary Palestinian state:
1. Before Israel there was a British Mandate, not a Palestinian state
2. Before the British Mandate, it was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
3. Before the Ottoman Empire Was the Islamic State of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state.
4. Before the Islamic State of the Mamluks from Egypt, the Arab-Kurdish Empire was the Ayyubid, not a Palestinian state.
5. Before the Ayyubid Empire was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state.
6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem was the Umayyad and Fatimid empire, not a Palestinian state.
7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, the Byzantine Empire was not a Palestinian state.
8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were Sassanids, not a Palestinian state.
9. Before the Sassanid Empire was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state.
10. Before the Byzantine Empire was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
11. Before the Roman Empire it was a Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state.
12. Before the Hasmonean state was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state.
13. Before the Seleucid Empire was the Empire of Alexander, not a Palestinian state.
14. Before Alexander's empire it was the Persian Empire, not a Palestinian state.
15. Before the Persian Empire was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state.
16. Before the Babylonian Empire were the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state.
17. Before the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was no kingdom of Israel in the kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state.
18. Before the Kingdom of Israel, the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel was not a Palestinian state.
19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an accumulation of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state.
20. In fact, in this plot of land kingdoms fell and fell .. But there was never a Palestinian state or a peopl
But there were people living there that called that land their home, they were in the Ottoman Empire, the British did a deal with them, revolt against the Ottomans and help us defeat them and you can be your own State, (it has to have a name surely?) they were back stabbed after this and more and more land was given to the Jews and it created the huge mess it is today.
There will never be an end to the conflict, Israel will not back down and Palestinians will fight for their land.
Israel was built off international meddling and pressure, certainly not off any ‘glorious’ military campaigns or ‘Noble’ diplomacy between the two peoples.
What do you think should happen to these ‘stateless’ people? I’m curious to know what you think?
Because you are one of the few who know the facts and speak the truth, I am subscribing!
Thank you! 🙏🏼
I’ve seen hundreds of videos on this, from both sides. The torrent of claims and counter claims combined with clear and obvious Israeli propaganda is evident. However none of it is relevant. None.
The fact is that in 1947, after Allied remorse, the Palestinians were removed from their land so that Jews could have it. Over 700,000 Palestinians were instructed to leave the homes their families had lived in for hundreds of years. And it continues to this day as Jews evict Palestinians from their homes on the west bank using their army. That, and that alone, is the root cause of the problem. It really is that simple.
Jews 'believe' that the land is historically theirs - it isn't. The Jews (Israelites) were a small tribe and hadn't been in Canaan, as it was then called, in any great numbers, for thousands of years. They claim the Romans displaced them and that may be true but if it is then that’s happened throughout history to many people of all races and religions with too many examples to quote here. The demonym "Canaanites" serves as an ethnic catch-all term covering various indigenous populations-both settled and nomadic-pastoral groups-throughout the regions of the southern Levant or Canaan. There has never been any period of time since then that the land was exclusively Jewish - it’s always been shared by either other tribes or other religions. Additionally these claims are based on the Old Testament part of the Bible - hardly a fact-based source of historical accuracy.
The only resolution is a return to the two-state solution. Israel ceases immediately settling in the West Bank and Gaza is allowed self-autonomy. The UN should have troops in the area to ensure compliance. Jerusalem should become a UN protected enclave to all people. There are, again, many examples where the UN has sent troops to both ensure peace and protect civilians.
However if the western powers, who enable Israel, truly believe that the Jews have a right to their 'homeland' then every single non-indigenous person in the US should leave and the Indigenous Indians take their land. As should all the white people of Australia and New Zealand to the Aboriginals and Māori’s. All those of Spanish descent should leave Central and South America too. There are many other examples. And every single Jew should support that. If it works one way it works all ways.
I reject Hamas but I stand with Palestine.
So lemme get this straight: American Indian land changes hands through conquest ("politically") and that means that American Indians have no right to it, but Israel changes hands "politically" (through conquest) and despite this it's still fully Jewish the entire time including right now?
You act like you odn't know who owns the world you have your rights (as miniscule as they are) jews have special rights no one else has.
The point of the video is that for the left of the world to claim that Jews stole 'palestine' from the indigenous Palestinians is ridiculous on two fronts. 1. The Jews have lived there for thousands of years often becoming the minority. 2. The Jews conquered significant parts during a defensive war. So if we take your point about conquest and the point of the video about history we only strengthen the argument that the Jews have every right to live in their native land and without feeling guilty about it.
@@reln72 I think the point of the video is to provide vague and fabricated facts in an attempt to convince the viewer of the legitimacy of the illegitimate state of Israel.
@@reln72 Conquered throgh "defensive war" i know what kind of game you play :D and who's side are you on...
We conquered it again
Very important thought experiment.
How far back do we go to identify land ownership or heritage?
In the US there's continuous debate about who owns what or is owed what, based on heritage.
Groups of people from synagogues purchased the usless land from the then legal owners which was mostly desert and swampland for an inflated price because they wanted to live amongst the jews who were already there and it was their homeland. After years of planting trees and digging wells they transformed the land. Then the Arabs started trying to kill them for it. Imagine if large groups of Ethiopian African Americans decided to come together and buy up a small piece of desert in Ethiopia the size of New Jersey and return to their homeland and wanted to live Among the Ethiopian people who were already there whos ancestors weren't sent to America on slave ships .Now lets say the Nigerians who owned the land sold it to them and after it was terraformed the Nigerians along with surrounding African nations tried to kill them and take it back.meanwhile the rest of the world starts calling them white colonists. FYI jews arabs and north Africans are Caucasian.thats a fact anyone can Google for themselves. Plenty of jews living there before all this too. My grandparents left british Palestine in 1936 long before ww2 and 1948 because the arabs were Massacreing people. Alot of the arabs were moving into the region from the arab Peninsula to work for the British.I still have family there There were also lots of jews all over the middle east untill they were expelled in 1948 by the arab countries they were citizens of . Then They had nowhere to go but Israel.
Worth the watch! More people should see this video. 👏
Now do Europe.
How? Up until recently, the entire world was a part of one of the many European empires.
“Woe to him that buildeth a town with blood, and stablisheth a city by iniquity!”
- Habakkuk 2:12
@@MiguelDLewis You were dragged by Europeans from poverty, slavery and disease and you keep complaining and want to take revenge. All that tells me is we were wrong to treat you as nicely as we have.
@@TheAutistocrat Ad hominem attacks aside, that doesn't answer the question. How can PragerU do a video on Europe when the entire world became a apart of Europe?
@@MiguelDLewis It clearly didn't.
@@TheAutistocrat Japan and Ethiopia are probably the only two nations that didn't become a European colony/protectorate. But even they were occupied by European-Americans and Italians respectively. The whole continents of Africa and the Americas and the whole Indian subcontinent all became a part of Europe. Do you deny this fact?
Thank you for the historical correction. I was under the historical falicy that Great Britian, at the close of WWI, 'coined' the name Palestine. This newly 'coined' name ended up in the Balfour Treaty. Prior to that the Ottomans called the region Syria and the people there were known as the Sanjak.
Your historical explanation that it was in fact, the Romans who renamed the region as "Palestina" is immensely helpful at clearing up the historical chaos surrounding the topic.
Again, Thanks
Even Wikipedia gives the name change as being after the destruction of the Holy Temple and finally in 475AD, the Jewish remnant were forced to leave their land, what was called Judea but now Palestinia.
Romans called Judea Palestine, because they knew how both peoples hated one another. And by "both peoples" I mean the Peleshet - the Sea Peoples of Greek origin - & the Hebrews.
The peleshet were the sea peoples, relatives of Carthage and Hannibal, etc.
The current Palestinians are of Arab descent (came out of Saudi Arabia with Mohammed in the 7th century AD, long after Rome fell)
@@dunedainmom yes, modern Palestinians are a totally different people.
@@dunedainmom
only about 20% are of Arab extraction
being Negev Bedouins with the rest being Arabized Canaanites
Thank you for clarifying the history against the lies of the haters and the ignorant. Greetings from London.
Thanks SO much for this excellent statement of history. God bless Prager U!
As a Lebanese, we are tought by our elders & clergy that there was one land / one people. Canaan. Upper Canaan ( Lebanon ) and lower Canaan ( Israel ). Abraham was a foreigner and he brought Judaism to lower Canaan. Upper Canaan became Christian. Fast forward to today, the Lebanese still have Canaanite blood and Israel’s official language is the ancient Canaanite language revived ( Hebrew ). 🇱🇧🇮🇱
Your country is no longer your country
Next year in Beirut. 🇱🇧
Thanks for your input. It's interesting to know things from the perspective of the Lebanese, a few interesting facts I didn't know. As a Christian, I regard the people and history of Israel as sacrosant and I hope that neighbouring nations give the Jewish people the space they deserve and need to exist.
Isn't it strange how they omitted Canaan even though it is mentioned in the Hebrew Bible? Prager U is clearly pushing Zionist talking points.
Interesting..
That was excellent and concise. Thank you!
And a lie.
@@johnbreitmeier3268spot on, brother! PragerU is known for DEEP propaganda.
@@johnbreitmeier3268 so the history of kingdom of israel is a lie
@@iringyellow4327 no , stupid. Calling Israelis the indigenous people of the Land of Canaan is a lie. Neither the Jews nor the Palestinians who are Arabs are indigenous. Both are descendants of Abraham who arrived in Canaan to find plenty of Canaanites already living there. Actually read Genesis sometime. This video is lying propaganda which does NOT help the political problem in Canaan/Israel/Palestine.
@@johnbreitmeier3268 how?
Thank you for the great video. Incredible how many people fail to understand this very basic knowledge.
I frankly do not care about religion. I also don’t care that any people say their ancestors had that land 400, 800, or 2,000 years ago.
I care that the Israeli constitution protects people of all religions, both male and female. Nobody else in the region is doing that.
There are almost literally no parts of the planet that are inhabited by the same people since homo sapiens came into being. Even in Africa, usually assumed to be the place where humans originated, every area I can find a history of has changed hands a few times at least. As recently as 10,000 years ago, what is now the Sahara was covered by tropical rainforest. The current residents came there after the rainforest receded and the desert took over. By the way, the reason that there is oil under much of the Sahara is because of that tropical rainforest history.
The one who control and are the legitimate rulers of any country, are the ones who won it. the victors of war.
No one questions this and no one dispute this.
Except Israel. what is ok for other countries is wrong for the jews for some reason.
The Shoa.
That's true. I think if Germans have Germany (stretching back 2000 years as the Germanii, Alemanii etc.), Jews should have Israel (at least a thousand years before)
The Roma originated in Northern India. Perhaps they should go back there and claim it and begin making new settlements. Regardless of which tribe came and went in the Palestinian lands for over thoiusands of years, the truth is that the entity that is called Israel by some is merely a European colony inhabited by mostly Ashkenizi settlers who used violence to displace 500,000 arabs from their land killing many and destroying their olive groves and their animals. Of course there were some Jews living peacefully in the region as a minority but the British and the Americans decided to do what they had done to the Native Americans and confiscate their land for the benefit of the "chosen people." If the arabs ever unite like they should they will drive this European colony away and maybe they will find a place in Canada next to the Ukronazi emigres who killed so many of them during WWII.
@@bryanemmel6516 Nice selective memory you have there. The Americans did nothing to kick out the Arabs in Judea. Palestine never existed as a country. The British did more to keep out Jews than kick out Arabs. If you had an actual memory, you would remember that when the Arabs from all of the surrounding countries invaded after Israel declared itself an independent state, it was those Arab invaders who told the Arab residents to leave or encouraged them to become refugees to avoid the war that they were starting. The only thing America did was recognize Israel.as an independent state. Those Arabs who stayed are now citizens of Israel with the same rights as Jews in Israel. I would have no problem with any Arab who can prove that he was kicked out by Jews being allowed to return to Israel. Not his children, or grandchildren, or great grandchildren who never lived there, but the actual people who can prove that Jews kicked them out.
Now that rings true through all the obfuscating political noise. Thank you.
The nature of Israel is to provide a safe homeland for the Jewish people and live in peace with the rest of the world. Sadly one doesn't have to look very hard to see others who insist on spreading their religion or government as far as they can no matter what the cost.
I am not Jewish. However I have learned about Jews since I was able to read Bible in Sunday School. Jewish people are absolutely the indigenous people of Israel. Long live Israel!
No they are not
If those Jews convert to other religions are they and their decedents still indigenous?
I think the real indigenous people... are the friends we made along the way.
Bs
Real
Coddling feel good nonsense
What ???
Smashing! I approve this message
I have seen a few other accounts recently as i research this subject that agree with this account except for one thing. According to another account, by the 1800's the region of Israel/Palestine had become abandoned and uninhabited after the Jewish people were expelled. Sure there were wandering nomadic people passing through there. But it had become unsettled wasteland. There were no Palestinians living there since there were no Jewish people there either. until Jewish people slowly started returning and restoring a community there in this unwanted land. Dispelling the claim that the Jewish people took Israel from the Palestinians. The only reason Palestinians were ever their was to drive the Jewish people back to where they came from, or they thought the Jewish people came from. Europe, Russia. and other surrounding areas. You see, Palestinians deny the Jews were the first settlers of Israel. They think they were. That is why they call the Jews occupiers. But the Palestinians abandoned Palestine. Arab muslims do not want westerners to know that truth. The Jewish people were the indigenous people of Israel. They were driven out but returned.
What you say is true. They only began coming after the Jews made the desert blossom again. Even today, Israel needs to run Gaza's water and electric because they cant do it on their own, while assembling bombs and other such friendly devices
Back in the days, before imperial Catholic Christianity and Islam, religions were of people of a certain land. Judeans/Jews did not force the whole world to convert to their folklore, same as Tibetians did not attempt to, or the Kikuyu did not enforce their pre-christian religion on neighboring natives.
Thanks for the gems of truth. Love you Noah.
Thank you for all this historic explanation. I just hope that millions will view this because they obviously do not know true history. And you are beautiful.
So it’s about land rights from 2000 years ago. Cool.
Now Egypt comes along with their dates and entitlements.
3000 years ago
its about land rights on lands we were barred from and held as dhimmis for centuries,while muslim warlords handed here lands to people who helped them and held us dhimmis . when we came here and bought lands(till 1948 all the lands on which jews lived were purchased from owner registered in ottoman land registry) the muslims here attacked them(1884 attack on petsch tikva,1929 hebrin and safed massacre agains the ancient jewish communities there) and it was followed by muslim nations(same ones who held us dhimmis away from our lands)banishing all their jews. now we fighr for a portion of the land to have independence on and not living as dhimmis,and we agreed to partition plan in 1947,1999 and 2006. they refused all that consistently.
@@johnfish837jews were majority here till 3rd c.e,and its about us going back to our ancestors land after being banned ,like the ottomans who allowed here in the 19th cnetury alone tens of thousands of their muslim allies:
turkamen of abu zurayk,40k strong masrawa and el masri clans(literally means egyptians),bushbak bosniaks of keisaria who spoke bosniak till 1948,circassians of kama and rihania,algerians of kafr sabt.all while banning ottoman jews from settling in jerusalsm sanjak and banishing the jews of jaffa/tel aviv in 1914 and 1917...
3,000-3,500 of continuously and counting* land rights
❤❤❤Ezekiel 37:1-28
The hand of YE_HO_VAH 🇮🇱was upon me🇮🇱. The RUACH 🇮🇱YE_HO_VAH 🇮🇱carried me🇮🇱 out and set me🇮🇱 down in the middle of the valley. It was full of bones.
He🇮🇱 led me🇮🇱 all around them🇮🇱. BEHOLD, there were very many on the floor of the valley. BEHOLD, they🇮🇱 were very dry.
Then He🇮🇱 said to me🇮🇱, “Son of man, can these bones live?” I🇮🇱 answered, “YE_HO_VAH 🇮🇱ELOHIM🇮🇱, You🇮🇱 know.”
- EZEKIEL 37:1-3
“Prophesy over these bones,” He🇮🇱 said to me🇮🇱. “Say to them🇮🇱: ‘Dry bones, hear the WORD🇮🇱 of YE_HO_VAH🇮🇱!’ Thus says YE_HO_VAH 🇮🇱ELOHIM 🇮🇱to these bones: BEHOLD, I🇮🇱 will cause RUACH 🇮🇱to enter you🇮🇱, so you 🇮🇱will live. I🇮🇱 will attach tendons to you🇮🇱, bring flesh on you🇮🇱 and cover you🇮🇱 with skin. Then I🇮🇱 will put breath in you🇮🇱. You🇮🇱 will live. You 🇮🇱will know that I🇮🇱 am YE_HO_VAH🇮🇱.’”
- Ezekiel 37:4-6
So I🇮🇱 prophesied just as I🇮🇱 was commanded. As I🇮🇱 prophesied, there was a noise, and BEHOLD, an EARTHQUAKE. Then the bones came together, bone to its bone. I🇮🇱 saw, and BEHOLD, there were tendons on them🇮🇱, flesh came up and skin covered them🇮🇱 above, but there was no breath in them🇮🇱.
- Ezekiel 37:7-8
Then He🇮🇱 said to me🇮🇱, “Prophesy to the RUACH🇮🇱. Prophesy, son of man, and say to the RUACH🇮🇱, ‘thus says YE_HO_VAH🇮🇱 ELOHIM🇮🇱: Come from the four winds, RUACH 🇮🇱! Breathe upon these slain, that they🇮🇱 may live.’” So I🇮🇱 prophesied just as He🇮🇱 commanded me🇮🇱. The RUACH 🇮🇱came into them🇮🇱 and they🇮🇱 lived. They🇮🇱 stood up on their🇮🇱 Feet, a vast army.
- Ezekiel 37:9-10
Then He 🇮🇱said to me🇮🇱, “Son of man, these bones are the whole HOUSE 🇮🇱of ISRAEL 🇮🇱. Behold, they 🇮🇱say: ‘Our bones are dried up; our hope is lost; we🇮🇱 are cut off-by ourselves.’ Therefore prophesy and say to them🇮🇱, thus says YE_HO_VAH🇮🇱 ELOHIM🇮🇱: ‘BEHOLD, I will open your 🇮🇱graves. I🇮🇱 will bring you 🇮🇱up out of your 🇮🇱graves, My people🇮🇱. I🇮🇱 will bring you🇮🇱 back to the LAND 🇮🇱of ISRAEL 🇮🇱. You🇮🇱 will know that I🇮🇱 am YE_HO_VAH🇮🇱, when I🇮🇱 have opened your 🇮🇱graves 🇮🇱and brought you 🇮🇱up out of your 🇮🇱graves🇮🇱, My people🇮🇱. I🇮🇱 will put My🇮🇱 RUACH 🇮🇱in you 🇮🇱and you 🇮🇱will live. I🇮🇱 will place you🇮🇱 in your own LAND 🇮🇱. Then you 🇮🇱will know that I🇮🇱, YE_HO_VAH🇮🇱, have spoken and that I🇮🇱 have done it.’” It is a declaration of YE_HO_VAH🇮🇱.
- Ezekiel 37:11-14
The WORD🇮🇱 of YE_HO_VAH 🇮🇱came to me🇮🇱 saying: “You🇮🇱, son of man, take one stick and write on it, ‘For JUDAH🇮🇱 ’-for BNEI-YISRAEL🇮🇱 joined with him🇮🇱. Then take another stick and write on it, ‘For JOSEPH🇮🇱 ’-the stick of EPHRAIM🇮🇱 and all the HOUSE of ISRAEL 🇮🇱 joined with him🇮🇱. Join them🇮🇱 one to another for yourself, as one stick, so they🇮🇱 may become one in your hand. “When the children🇮🇱 of your people🇮🇱 speak to you🇮🇱 saying, ‘Won’t you🇮🇱 tell us🇮🇱 what you🇮🇱 mean by these?’ say to them🇮🇱, ‘thus says YE_HO_VAH 🇮🇱 ELOHIM🇮🇱: BEHOLD, I🇮🇱 will take the stick of JOSEPH 🇮🇱-which is in the hand of EPHRAIM 🇮🇱and the tribes of ISRAEL 🇮🇱joined with him🇮🇱-and I🇮🇱 will put them🇮🇱 together with the stick of JUDAH🇮🇱, and make them 🇮🇱one stick. They 🇮🇱will be one in My🇮🇱 hand.’ The sticks that you🇮🇱 write on will be in your🇮🇱 hand before their eyes.
- Ezekiel 37:11-20
“Then say to them🇮🇱, ‘thus says YE_HO_VAH🇮🇱 ELOHIM🇮🇱: BEHOLD, I🇮🇱 will take BNEI-YISRAEL🇮🇱 from among the nations, where they🇮🇱 have gone. I🇮🇱 will gather them 🇮🇱from every side and bring them 🇮🇱into their own LAND 🇮🇱. I🇮🇱 will make them 🇮🇱one nation in the LAND 🇮🇱, on the MOUNTAINS of ISRAEL 🇮🇱, and one (1)KING will be KING🇮🇱 to them 🇮🇱all. They 🇮🇱will no longer be two nations and never again be divided into two kingdoms. They 🇮🇱will never again be defiled with their 🇮🇱idols, their🇮🇱 detestable things, or with any of their🇮🇱 transgressions. I🇮🇱 will save them 🇮🇱out of all their dwellings in which they 🇮🇱sinned. I🇮🇱 will purify them🇮🇱. Then they 🇮🇱will be My people 🇮🇱and I🇮🇱 will be their GOD🇮🇱. My🇮🇱 servant DAVID🇮🇱 will be KING🇮🇱 over them🇮🇱. They 🇮🇱will all have ONE(1) SHEPHERD. They 🇮🇱will walk in My🇮🇱 ordinances and observe My🇮🇱 rulings and do🇮🇱 them. They 🇮🇱will live in the land 🇮🇱that I🇮🇱 gave to My servant JACOB🇮🇱, where your🇮🇱 ancestors 🇮🇱lived. They 🇮🇱will live there-they🇮🇱, their children, and their 🇮🇱children’s 🇮🇱children🇮🇱, forever, and My🇮🇱 servant DAVID🇮🇱 will be their PRINCE🇮🇱 forever. I🇮🇱 will cut a covenant of SHALOM with them🇮🇱-it will be an EVERLASTING COVENANT with them🇮🇱. I🇮🇱 will give to them 🇮🇱and multiply them🇮🇱. I🇮🇱 will set up My🇮🇱 SANCTUARY among them🇮🇱 forever. My🇮🇱 DWELLING PLACE will be over them🇮🇱. I🇮🇱 will be their GOD🇮🇱 and they 🇮🇱will be My🇮🇱 people 🇮🇱. Then the nations will know that I🇮🇱 am YE_HO_VAH who sanctifies ISRAEL 🇮🇱 , when My🇮🇱 SANCTUARY is in their🇮🇱 midst forever.’”
- Ezekiel 37:21-28❤❤❤
Well... the "indigeneity" argument is not really the basis for land/nationhood today. No one says, anymore, "let me look back 2000 years to see who the rightful sovereigns of the land are today." Greeks controlled most of coastal Turkey in 300BC , Vikings (Danes) in current England and Russia, Celts in Switzerland. If we still believed we should look back 2000 years then all the descendants of Europeans should leave the Western Hemisphere forthwith. That's not how we do things any more.
Really? The American Indians are the indigenous people of North America. Actually they aren't indigenous either. 10,000 to 12,000 years ago proto Mongolian tribes crossed the frozen Bearing Strait from what is now Russia to what is now Alaska. They spread all the way to the tip of South America.
Which group of people is “indigenous” is a stupid thing to argue about. No group of people is truly “indigenous” to a land, they always conquered it from someone else.
well, the Jews were the first on this land. so what metric is ok for you?
the ones who came to a land first? (the Jews)
The ones who the world agreed to have the land? (the Jews)
The ones who paid for the land from their INVADORS? (the Jews)
The ones who seized control threw war like most countries? (the Jews)
Make up a metric, and the jews will have the greater claim every time.
You obviously don’t know what the term “Indigenous” means as applied to groups of Homo Sapiens. This is a Cultural Anthropological term, and you may want to educate yourself by taking a look-see at the Martinez-Cobo Studies prior to blaring out your markedly ignorant opinions.
And there speaks colonizer justification, rationalization and prejudice, along with no comprehension what Indigenous means when applied to Humans.
i think that can be debated. but either approach you use - rights by conquest or rights by indigeniety - Israel ends up at least as legitimate as any other state.
@@dannydonnelly8198 Disagree, as per Martinez-Cobo Working Standards, the continuation of cultural practices and heritage is a primary factor in continuance of Indigenous status. And Jews, an Ethnoreligious People have maintained theirs. Just a note, Indigenous People’s define who they are, and who is, and is not them. Jews have two criteria by which they define themselves, which have been their standards since the Bronze Age. Whether you are Baque, Sami, Icelandic Viking, Māori or Lakota, Outsiders to any grouping of Indigenous People seeking to define them is unacceptable, and the arrogance of thinking such is an Outsiders privilege is regrettable.
Haaretz recently published an article about an ancient Jewish family found in Eretz Ysael around the first temple period. DNA was done. One of the females mtdna was published in the article and, surprise, it is the same as my Jewish mother, which is the same as mine. Her family were Prussian Jews who came to America in the late 1800's from Germany. They were Sephardic Jews. Maybe next year in Jerusalem. I am Israel Chai!
Wow!
Any relation to Ben Shapiro? Even if you are not, you have a cool last name. @@michaelshapiro1543
Being Christian and having been added to the Olive tree by Jesus I have always felt a kinship with the Jewish people. Despite the hatred felt down through the years even by supposed Christians. I find it upsetting that Christians would consider Jews as bad because of the crucifixion. Anyone who has studied the bible realized that it wasn't the Jews who crucified our Lord but those who needed Jesus to be dead because of what Christ represented to others. Even considering that Israel wasn't an integral part of the Jews just shows how asinine folks can be and how wilfully ignorant. The bible spells out how integral Isreal was to God's people. Of whom I now am a part. Simply by being grafted to my brothers in God.
Jews broke gods covenant
Bingo! At last, a Christian who isn't a replacement theologist. ❤
Thank you for doing this! People hopefully will understand 🙏❤️
The Canaanites called, asking "Really?"
Yes, the land of Israel is the promised land to the line of Jacob, but they had to conquer it first. And if the argument it was the land of Abraham first, well Abraham was a nomad from Ur, and he avoided the cities already established in what is known as Israel today.
I'm not saying this to argue against the points made in this video, but one should also examine the whole history.
you do know most historians dont support the thesis the hebrews came from egypt or iraq,and that the hebrew language is classified as canaanite and is practically identical to amonite,moabite,adomite and phoenician?most modern historiana believe hebrews to be canaanites gone monotheist and adopting canaanite god el as their single god. if you for some reason accept the bible narrative as historically accurate-the jews took this land on the orders of god.
and if you want to say "arab palestinians are indigenous too living here for centuries"-we aint the ones who initiated violence against them,from 1884 attack on petach tikva through 1929 hebron and safed lynching of the ancient jewish communities to 1947 war-we didnt initiate those clashses.
The Jews according to scholars and genetic scientists are a break-away Canaanite group. At some point they decided to stop identifying with them.
The Canaanites aren't complaining. (They no longer exist.)
That word "promised" is problematical. The people who lived there before the Jews murdered them must be the true indigenous people. And who was there before those people or doesn't that count? Can the Jewish people claim India or elsewhere if their God "tells* them to? Very dangerous road to go down is murder. Why didn't God tell Moses the other two Commandments, Thou shalt not be racist or sexist? And if Jesus came back wouldn't the Jews reject him again? Peace my backside. The Jewish and Palestinian atheists should have got together and run that country, well away from two bad religions. But what do I know, I'm just a worthless Gentile, no better than a dog or a swine.
@element2138 genetically Palestinians and levanese are primarily canaanites who were assimilated into arab cuture.
I learnt a lot watching this. Thank you.
Did you learn what the founders of Zionism had to say? "[It is the] iron law of every colonizing movement, a law which knows of no exceptions, a law which existed in all times and under all circumstances. If you wish to colonize a land in which people are already living, you must provide a garrison on your behalf. Or else-or else, give up your colonization, for without an armed force which will render physically impossible any attempts to destroy or prevent this colonization, colonization is impossible, not “difficult,” not “dangerous” but impossible!... Zionism is a colonizing adventure and therefore it stands or falls by the question of armed force. It is important to build, it is important to speak Hebrew, but, unfortunately, it is even more important to be able to shoot-or else I am through with playing at colonization.2" -Vladimir Jaobtinsky "The Iron Wall" 1923
Great, now maybe you can “learnt” how 2 be spellin wurdz an shit.
@@SarkisZaroukian the zionist jews are the zionist mentioned in the Bible multiple times.
The land of israel 'zion'
They're the people who had 2000% right to claim everything that belongs to them.
Even if the entire Arab world don't acknowledge them.
But history won't lie and hide the legend of how great the kingdom of David was
Considering what happened October 7, 2023, it's amazing how many people don't know or care about any of this. I've always known these basics, not because I grew up among Jews, but because I read the Christian Bible.
Thank you... midst the political lies, misinformation and hate, it's good to have a solid base in understanding the truth of Israel.
Jews weren't raised with hate; but Palestinians were.
womp womp
That is what a lot of people believe in and push that as lies. Israel doesn’t want genocide as it’s not in their nature. It is terrorist who are Islam who want genocide in the Jewish people.
@@crystophelia1268 whimpity womp
This is the most informative succinct and factual presentation - Thank you🙏
Notice how the same people that say Israel has no right to exist say that the USA is on "stolen land?"
What REALLY is "indigenous?" Humans evolved in Africa. That's the only place we're indigenous. Every other place we go to we are not. Different people, at different times, hold a particular piece of land. But only until another group of people decide to take that land. Then they fight. The winner gets the land.
The western wall is not the holiest site in Judaism ever, it is a outer wall for the Temple Mount which is where both temples have stood and the third will stand soon enough.
Excellent mini history lesson, thank you all for giving this to us
Well summarized. History is very clear.
NOW FREE ASSYRIANS ( NOT OKAY BECAUSE ASSYRIANS ARE CHRISTIANS...😂😂😂)
Assyria, the land of the indigenous Assyrians ["Our Smallest Ally"], was partitioned after World War I by the victorious Allies, and is currently under occupation by Kurds, Turks, Arabs and Persians.
The Assyrians are a stateless people and continue to be religiously and ethnically persecuted in the Middle East due to Islamic fundamentalism, Arabization and Kurdification policies, leading to land expropriations and forced emigration to the West.
Tell us everything you know about Jesus the Messiah...in summary...
God caved out the nation of Israel among all people to reveal his goodness and redeemtion plan for mankind. For God so love the world he gave his only begotten Son that non should perish but have everlasting live. Those who believe in him will be saved from eternal damnation. He came as a saviour 2000 years ago. He returns as as the King of Kings and the Lord of Lords.
And completely wrong. There were Canaanites in the land of Canaan before Abraham got there. Telling lies and falsely redefining words like indigenous do not help this mess. Both sides are children of Abraham and most of neither side have accepted Jesus as the Messiah, the God Yahweh come in the flesh to die for our sins. That being the case, the only land either most Jews or most Palestinians will inherit and be "indigenous" in is a Corner of the Lake of Fire or Hell. Repent while you still can.
Always was and always will be until you have the antisemetics declaring otherwise.
No, Israelis are not more indigenous to the land than Palestinians. Both Israelis and Palestinians have deep historical and cultural connections to the region, but Palestinians have a longer continuous presence in the land. Palestinians have a rich cultural heritage and a strong sense of identity tied to the land, and their ancestors have lived there for thousands of years.
While Israelis have a historical connection to the land through the ancient Israelites, many modern Israelis are descendants of immigrants who arrived in the 20th century. Israelis also have a right to self-determination, but it's essential to recognize the indigenous rights and history of Palestinians. Acknowledging the equal indigenous status of both groups is crucial for building a just and inclusive future.
1 - I don't disagree exactly, but where in the video does it say Palestinians aren't native? Or that Jews are more native or indigenous than Palestinians?
2 - wait are native & indigenous synonymous in this context?
3 - so yeah both Jews & Muslims/Arabs/Palestinians have a claim to part of the land right?
WE ARE JEWISH TOO FROM THE ISLAND OF FIJI WHICH MEAN: First Indigenous Jewish Island (FIJI)...
I grew up non baptized in a catholic family. If I convert to Judaism am I know tied to the land? This is what I don’t understand. In the USA White liberal Jews using it as a race card even though they’re obviously 90%+ European. Distinction between ethnic Jews and religious Jews is completely ignored and takes the legitimacy away from the claim of being ‘Jewish’ by blood rather than by religion. If I convert to Catholicism that does not inherently make me Roman/Italian since that is where it came from.
Judaism is a religion, not an ethnicity. Kuki Indians, Keifang Chinese, Igbo Nigerians, Mizrahi Arabs, and Kushi Ethiopians are Jews too.
@@MiguelDLewis Ethno-religion*
Israel is the homeland for the Jewish nation of people. Converts are akin to adopted children so it's their home too. "White" Jews genetically trace back to the ME as well, native Europeans don't. Secular and religious Jews are both Jews, so Israel is home to both.
@@starhopper1706 Religion*. Kuki, Keifang, Igbo, Mizrahi, Ashkenazi, Black Hebrew Israelites, and Kushi Jews are all different ethnicities with different cultures, languages, customs, and diets. Even Moses and his wife Sephora were two different ethnicities, yet they were both Hebrew.
"Moses married an Ethiopian."
- Numbers 12:1
@@MiguelDLewis So my dna test was tracing my religion? How do you suppose they managed that? lol .... Ethno-religion. All of the main branches of Jews are genetically connected and all trace back to the Levant. Those that are legitimate converts, are also part of the family. Any others claiming to be so, are larpers and wannabes. That Jews come in different skin tones, doesn't change any of that.
Simple example: Tamils are indigenous to India, but so are Bengalis, Punjabis, Malayalis and even European Romanis(Gypsies). The Romanis can't just show up to India today, displace the native indigenous indians and claim the entire country for themselves. They need to respect the fact that there are other indigenous people as well. The Palestinians are the descendants of indigenous canaanites who got arabised, and it doesn't make them less indigenous in any way. Its like saying that muslim or Christian Indians are no longer Indian because they chose a different faith
Indo Europeans of today also are not originally of Europe, but where did the Germans become the German people? The Italians? Europe.
Jews became a nation in Israel, 3000+ years ago, were expelled, and now want to move back to their own tiny piece of land.
The Romani are one nation of a huge subcontinent, filled with many nations. They immigrated to Europe and their becoming a nation happened there.
I'm all for self determination of Romanis in India, if they see it as their birthplace, but a. they don't, b. if they do, they can have some land, not all of it
@@davidtrak2679 they can have some of it meaning that they can show up in rajasthan, forcibly expel the current inhabitants of Rajasthan to make way for thier apartheid settlers, occupy some parts of Punjab and Maharashtra, allow any person of Roma ancestry in the world to claim citizenship while denying the same right to the expelled Rajasthanis and defend thier actions by saying "If I don't steal it, someone else will" or "God gave us the right to this land".
@@Muhammad_Ahmad_ No, they can live side by side. Just like Israelis do with Palestinians today.
Care to tell my Arab Israeli co-workers how exactly do I forcibly expel them?
Too much Sheikh Jarrah videos for you? Documenting Palestinian families not paying rent?
What is true, is that tensions arise. Exactly like how Pakistan was formed, and how to this day there are tensions for the remaining Muslims in India, I believe the land should be divided in the best manner possible to ensure the least conflict.
The Roma cannot prove linkage to all of the Indian subcontinent, but if they've been longing to go back to India for 2000 years, in their prayers, their culture and their language, they can have a part of it, yes.
But tell you what - they don't.
Palestinian Arabs are descendent of Arabs from Arabian Peninsula
Zionism was born centuries ago. It’s called the crusades.
נועה היקרה, אגיד זאת בשפת האם שלך: את א-ל-ו-פ-ה!!! זה התוכן שרציתי שירוץ ברשת, והופתעתי מכך שהאיכות עלתה על כל דמיון! את פשוט מדהימה ומרתקת!!
Thank you for pointing this out . I support the Jews and their homeland Israel. It is a beacon of civilization throughout the region.
I"m so glad you have addressed this issue.
And got it completely wrong. Indigenous means the FIRST people to live in a land, not the longest. The Jews are of the tribe of Judah, one of the sons of Jacob/Israel, the grandson of Abraham. The Palestinians are Arabs, not Canaanites. They descend from Ismael the son of Abraham with Hagar his mistress.
Abraham's children were NOT the first people to live in Canaan. Abe came from Ur of the Chaldees in what we call Iraq. There were already Canaanites living in Canaan when Abraham got there. Read Genesis sometime.
@@johnbreitmeier3268 Well said. Further, it's as if every descendent of Abraham has forgotten God's promises made in Deuteronomy 28. Especially the most applicable latter half of chapter 28. Everything that has happened has been their own fault AND THEY KNOW IT. They just feel better when they can fool others into believing they're just 'oppressed' by 'evil'. "Oppressed/Oppressor" is their own creation after all, victimhood is always more desirable than personal responsibility.
@@crforfreedom7407 Yes, everybody loves a good blessing, but everyone would rather skip the curses. The Jewish nation had an 1800 year run of consistent "bad luck" and yet refuses to connect that to 1900+ years of an ongoing rejection of Jesus as the Messiah they insist they are waiting for. No, all those generations are NOT responsible for the rejection of the Messiah by 90+% of the Jewish nation in 30 AD, BUT most of each generation IS guilty of repeating that same rejection.
Yes God returned Israel to the Holy Land in 1948 but it has not exactly been a bed of roses since then and still most Jews reject Jesus.
Real Old Testament Hebrew religion has not been practiced since 70 AD, because there is no Temple to perform sacrifices in. There has Not been a Day of Atonement sacrifice since 70 AD and the Talmud says that the last such sacrifice Yahweh accepted was in 30 AD. What we see today as Judaism is NOT Old Testament Hebrew worship. It is a Pharisee bastardization of that religion. The Old testament never provided for synagogues. It had no rabbis. All priests were from the tribe of Levi of the line of Aaron. It REQUIRED ongoing annual blood sacrifices performed by a high Aaronic priest in either the Temple or the preceding Tabernacle. None exists.
@@johnbreitmeier3268be careful of using religious texts, which have been altered, as historical records
@@oldschoolgamer-w4u Be careful, dunce, of believing lying, modern, satanic scholars who say the Bible has to have been altered. There is NO proof that occurred and we don't treat any other historical records that way.
So, fool, who do YOU think are the Indigenous people of Canaan and why??
The histories of BOTH the current Palestinians (The Koran) AND the Jews (Genesis) SAY that they are descendants of Abraham who BOTH say came to Canaan from what we call Iraq, SO neither one can claim to be indigenous in Canaan/Israel/Palestine.
Every day is a learning day. Thanks Noa, I didn't know that it was the Romans who changed the name to Palestine. Of course that makes perfect sense when I think about it historically. Put finger to my head and say red backwards.
The establishment of Israel as a sovereign nation isn’t being questioned by many in the west. What is being questioned is the fact that Palestinians (many of whom used to be Christian before fundamentalists took over Palestinians identity) lost their homes and were moved to virtual concentration camps without a viable long-term plan in place-the British thought this up, not the Jews.
Israel also includes ancient Samaria-a portion of the land in which 10 of the 12 tribes integrated with Assyrian conquerors creating a new culture. Christ grew up in the middle of this divide which caused silly debates about how Jewish are you and do you have enough Jewish blood to be legit? He stated that the evolution of Judaism was spreading the word about a Messiah who’d conquered death: 1st in Judaea; 2nd in Samaria; third in Greece; and lastly throughout the remainder of the world so that all peoples could be grafted into the heritage of Abraham due to a pre-existing Abrahamic mentor figure by the name of Melchizedek.
Your statements are correct, the question still remain, does a population that has been away more than 1500 years away has the right to move back in and divide the land and keep integrating more land as the time passes by without consideration of the palestinians civilians?, (no democratic vote).
And if they do (the right of return) why can't palestinians have the right to return to their own ancestors land.? What makes your claim stronger than theirs?( other than religious).
And if zionist wanted to return to israel (most jews as they were always jews living In palestinian land)
Do gypsies have the right to take back parts of India states and make their own country and after local fight agaisnt them, can they expell them and say gypsyphobia?
Why force such a state by war, didn't you know you were building a state not on empty land but with people had different thoughts, ambitions, ideologies and wanted a different kind of goberment?
Why don't you talk about the ilegal settlement under international law that israel has been building in palestinian land?
What would usa reaction would be if another country stole a part of their country?
They simply don’t care they don’t another see humans as “humans”
They aren’t indigenous they are just colonizers
Q: if they are “the indigenous people”, what were they doing in Egypt when Moses led them into Arabia? Doesn’t that make him indigenous Egyptians?
They were Slaves to the Egyptians
@@tonyhorsch9559From where were they enslaved?
@@mattjohnson9753 In Egypt
@@tonyhorsch9559Which makes them “indigenous Egyptians”.
They Migrated out of the Land of Canaan during a great famine (Most Likely caused by endless war) (Genesis- Story of Joseph ) that's how they ended up in Egypt. Jacob (Israel) is the Father of the 12 tribes. Were all born in the Land of Canaan .
“You take my water, burn my olive trees, destroy my house, take my job, steal my land, imprison my father, kill my mother, bombard my country, starve us all, humiliate us all, but I am to blame: I shot a rocket back.” - Chomsky
"When peace comes we will perhaps in time be able to forgive the Arabs for killing our sons, but it will be harder for us to forgive them for having forced us to kill their sons."
- Golda Meir
"Peace will come when the Arabs will love their children more than they hate us."
- Golda Meir
"We have liberated Gaza, but have we recognized Israel? Have we given up our lands occupied in 1948? We demand the liberation of the West Bank, and the establishment of a state in the West Bank and Gaza, with Jerusalem as its capital - but without recognizing [Israel]. This is the key - without recognizing the Israeli enemy on a single inch of land...
"Our plan for this stage is to liberate any inch of Palestinian land, and to establish a state on it. Our ultimate plan is [to have] Palestine in its entirety. I say this loud and clear so that nobody will accuse me of employing political tactics. We will not recognize the Israeli enemy. "
- Mahmoud Al-Zahhar
"Hamas must lay the foundation for a tomorrow without Zionists."
-Mahmoud Al-Zahhar
"This is the time for the third uprising... Resistance will continue through suicide missions."
- Khaled Mashaal
"Hamas will continue the resistance until the last drop of blood."
- Fawzi Barhoum
"If the Jewish state becomes a fact, and this is realized by the Arab peoples, they will drive the Jews who live in their midst into the sea.”
- Hassan Al-Banna
"The highest official in the League said that with 300 soldiers or North African Volunteers we could throw the Jews into the sea. The war started and His Excellency then said that with 3,000 North African Volunteers we could throw them into the sea."
- Dr. Fadhil Jamali
Chomsky is a radical leftist and a liar. Did he ever explain how he would resolve the conflict?
Chomsky is leftist stooge.
@@daerdevvyl4314 "Arab peoples"? Ah, the irony...
that's what you get from taking lands from others. Sorry, but time doesn't legitimized a colony occupied by colonial states, nor does it change the fact you are colonizers who lived on the lands stolen from the Jewish. What you are doing to Israel right now is pure, mindless terrorism.
Wonderful history lesson presented by a beautiful lady. Thank you!
Brilliant and Beautiful! Thank you for sharing! 💗🙏🌺
Thanks for another informative and helpful presentation. Much appreciated!
Weird how the indigenous European people aren't allowed to claim the same ties to their own lands, despite having often been in their homelands for even longer than the Jews have in Israel. Or how countries that were more recently founded by White people in the New World aren't given the same consideration either, even if they were vastly just White countries until quite recently.
Blame imperialism. You cannot claim Europe as belonging to anyone when it was built using the resources and labour of colonized nations.
“Woe to him that buildeth a town with blood, and stablisheth a city by iniquity!”
- Habakkuk 2:12
@@MiguelDLewis Yeah, because the nations that became England, France, Germany, etc. well over a thousand years ago had tons of black slaves building everything for them... Just get over your black fragility and envy of White people, enjoy and be grateful for the country you're taking advantage of and stop complaining.
Their, "Leaders", have sold out the Caucasoids. It not., Weird", but treacherous.
@@MiguelDLewis”Israel” was born of the genocide of the Canaanites by the Jews.
Even at the height of colonialism, the impact of it on the economy was minimal. Europe was certainly not built on it because 95% of the capital came from local trade.
What about Indigenous Europeans (Whites), Catholics (Christians), Eastern Orthodox (Christians), Protestants (Christian) and Armenians (Christian Middle East people)... What is our land? let's look at the historical background of the Holy Land (Cursade States) and Europe vs nowadays.
I love Israel. As a nation its values are superior to its neighbouring States. It is good to have them there in the Holy Land where they belong. No Israel, no bible, no Jesus, no Christianity, no Judaism. Without Israel humanity is doomed.
Your Jesus was a sand person and today Israelis genetically cluster with Europeans. 🤣
No
One thing Rome didn’t change the name right after they conquered the land. first Judea was a Client kingdom of Rome then a province starting in the year 6 until 135 and they didn’t changed the name until after they merged judea with another province and then gave it the name Syria Palestina which is more of a region name that included the Judea province
Yeah, she had to skip alot and made it crayon simple and thus it looks innacurate to those who know the history
@@franciscolaureano7703Lmao. Are you new here? Prageru does this all the time, and I'm fairly certain it's not "honest mistakes" either
Judea is not Israel. Just like the Tribe of Judah (Jesus) has nothing to do with Judea. Just like the religion of Judaism has virtually nothing to do with the Old Testament or the 10 Commandments. The modern political state of Israel is a globalist con, sucking more money and resources from guilt-ridden western nations while flooding those same nations with pre-industrialized migrants that they'd NEVER allow to immigrate to their own walled in (and exorbitantly defended) country. More are waking up.
@@WhiteOak61 It is 100% that the Romans changed the name to humiliate Jews. Jews at the time of the Romans represented a significant number as high as 10% of the entire empire. Now if you deny the Jewish connection to the land, let's hear your evidence.
@martondee1284. Yes, PragerU does this all the time. 5 minute videos on various topics keep people informed and interested. And we know this because if you wanted the unabridged version of this history, it would be hours long. Something tells me you wouldn’t have sat through that long of a video.
Absolutely great presentation.
Wow! Best explanation ever. Thank you! ❤🇮🇱
We love you Noa!
Thank you for this wonderful presentation
I’m glad Israel was recognized as a sovereign nation, but to call Jews indigenous to the land is a bit self serving and hard to swallow since the land was taken by the Jews from others under the leadership of Joshua.
And this was the first nakba(disaster, tragedy) in 1450 BC according to Deuteronomy 20:16-17 that served as the inspiration to the second nakba of 1948 when Israel stole Palestinian land just like the Europeans stole Native American land since 1492.
@@johnpolitis7929 But no one is questioning the right of the United States to exist. And the Nakba was caused by the Arabs, when they rejected Palestinian statehood and launched a war to destroy Israel.
@@clobar70 The Nakba was caused by the Zionists who forcibly displaced the Palestinians in 1948 with the creation of the illegitimate Zionist State or entity called Israel.
Yes, the United States legitimacy is questioned on its right to exist by The Mexica Movement and Native American Indians. And I agree here with the Mexicans and Indians. After all, the Europeans stole Native land in the same way that Zionists stole Palestinian land. And Palestinians question the legitimacy of the Zionist State called Israel also on its right to exist. And I agree with the Palestinians here.
Most Jews are European who came to the holy land as part of the Zionist movement and displaced the Palestinian (which includes Muslims, Christians, Jews, Druze…Arabs, Armenians…) population living there. Trying to connect themselves to biblical Jews and pretending it is a land without a people for a people without a land does not change the fact Israel is western colonial project and that there is a large population of indigenous people living there (many descendants of biblical Jews, Canaanite’s and every other group that passed through the region). Free Palestine 🇵🇸
No, it should go to the U.N as a neutral territory.
@emilyevans4176 nah that's facts
@emilyevans4176how
This is the first time in history that a nation arose (the Palestinians) Out of hatred and not out of a desire for freedom
I would bet that most critics of Israel don’t have a clue.
EVEN in Arabic, بيت المقدس, Bayt al-Maqdis, the Arabic name for Jerusalem (until they changed it for not wanting to say the truth, to Al-Quids), refers to the Hebrew Beit Hamikdash בית המקדש the place of Solomon’s Temple!
Cool. But it got destroyed. The only thing that’s really left is Masjid Al-Aqsa
@@IbnNuur905wrong. Yes, it was destroyed, but the Temple Mount and Western Retaining wall is still in tact. The Muslims didn’t come for many years after. Mohammed himself was only 1,400 years agoz
@@adamw8469 Again that’s fine. But that land wasn’t called Israel for a long time. Even when the Hebrews came from Egypt, the Philisitines were living there.
@@IbnNuur905 nope. The phillistines are an extinct race. In Hebrew, Plishtim. There’s no “p” sound or character in Arabic
@@adamw8469 the “ph” sounds like “f”.
Yes!🇮🇱🦁 As a Jew I feel strong connection to Judea, Israel and all people living there (it really doesn't matter if we believe in Hashem, Allah or no God, we are all cousins and should be proud of our Middle Eastern roots and heritage)🕊️
Anyone who clearly looks at the facts would have to say that they are indigenous.
Patriot Iranians stand with you as allies.
We have the same historical enemy till today .
Iran is still occupied by arab offsprings through Mullah's regime .
Help us to get our homeland and dignity back .
Beautifully said and explained. Well done Noa!
Not European Jewish converts.
The dna dosnt saporot that
The dna dosnt saporot that
Exactly. None of these idiots seem to recall God ejecting the real Jews out of Israel as stated multiple times in the bible.
@@itsytyt5192 What DNA? Abraham was Chaldean and Moses was Egyptian. What's the specific Haplogroup which connects Ashkenazim to Ur and Egypt?
Besides them, many Arab sources confirm the fact that the Holy Land was still Jewish by population and culture in spite of the Diaspora:
·In 985 c.e. the Arab writer Muqaddasi complained that in Jerusalem the large majority of the population were Jewish, and said that "the mosque is empty of worshippers..." .
·Ibn Khaldun, one of the most creditable Arab historians, in 1377 c.e. wrote:
"Jewish sovereignty in the Land of Israel extended over 1400 years... It was the Jews who implanted the culture and customs of the permanent settlement".
After 300 years of Arab rule in the Holy Land, Ibn Khaldun attested that Jewish culture and traditions were still dominant. By that time there was still no evidence of "Palestinian" roots or culture .
·The historian James Parker wrote: "During the first century after the Arab conquest [670-740 c.e.], the caliph and governors of Syria and the [Holy] Land ruled entirely over Christian and Jewish subjects. Apart from the Bedouin in the earliest days, the only Arabs west of the Jordan were the garrisons".
Even though the Arabs ruled the Land from 640 c.e. to 1099 c.e., they never became the majority of the population. Most of the inhabitants were Christians (Assyrian and Armenian) and Jews.
Listening to you had me in goose pimples from my toes up my spin to the top of my head. Thank-you for sharing the Truth.
When are reparations going to be paid to the Jews and Christians that we dispossessed of their land since 700 AD. Jews have never completely left Israel, so it is still theirs.
Much like indigenous Americans still have a right to live in the USA,
Please do a video on the Jewish groups that never left Israel; like the Samaritans and others. They lived under oppression and forced conversion for centuries but never left
Instead of reparations to AA in USA - fund an option for them to go back to A - that's the right thing to do.