Israelis: As former refugees, do you feel sympathy for Palestinian refugees?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 июл 2019
- The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
Please donate to the project at:
* www.paypal.me/coreygilshuster
* / askproject
.
Want to know what Israelis and Palestinians in the Middle East really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers.
‘You should not look back to the past but look towards the future’ ironic coming from Israelis when all they talk about is that they lived in Palestine 2000 years ago
And constantly reminding the world of Holocaust that happened more than 70 years ago. What a hypocrisy.
Looking to the future is what everyone must do, no matter the race or religion.
Its what the people of the region did when they were conquered by the successive muslim regimes, Muhammadans who conquered arabia and that land was never returned. Umayyads who conquered an empire stretching from the middle east to spain, and were trying to invade France. They were kicked out of Spain, but not Morocco, etc.
Palestinianism isnt a religion, islam is, to see the root of the conflict one must look there. The scapegoating and demonization of jews is ancient.
@@wildec2 it's not Jews,as alot of Jews are against what Israel are doing,it's zionists.
@@wildec2 Muhammadans LOL. What is that? Can I call Jews Mosans, Christians Jesusan/Paulans? lol
@@PK_Diaspora jesus is called christ, hence christians, its not rocket science. The religion is built around Muhammad not god, all 3 of the abrahamic faiths ultimately worship God, faith in God is not where the conflict comes from.
First one said if you left bye bye
So Jews they say we left long time back
So it's bye bye to you too
@Nir Hakimian after you
Pity he didn't say that to him.
@@alimohammedabd
He will never say it he is Zionist
@@thebig3864 maybe he just didn't think of it at the time.
@@alimohammedabd maybe
the main problem in Algeria is the colonialism. Algeria was conquered in 1830, in 1870, the law of indigenous people "la loi des indigènes" would grant all jews of algeria french citizenship. while Arabs would continue for almost a century without having it. this created many tentions, and in 1934 in my city Constantine there is was a huge civil war between the two happening.
Thus why many Algerian jews have french citizenship.
Edit : one more thing for justice, most of indigenous Arab jews in algeria actually sided with the local population, they were not granted french citizenship and lived amongst the Algerians, later they would dissolve into Arabs and even become Muslims and we have many family names today who were Jews before the colonialism, but now are Muslims while the same name in Morocco or Tunisia are Jews (family names like Halimi and Zerbib etc)
@Skov The Nomad we were under occupation, they were french citizens, nobody would be able to touch them.
@Skov The Nomad yep, my grand mother remembers the events (i am from Constantine) and I already mentioned it if you have fully read my comment, and i don't want to rewrite again.
123 viva Algerie
most of the indigenous jews of north africa fled they didnt convert to islam not in algeria or tunis or morocco and they were not arab
@@mizrahiwithattitude2733 I am not a specialist but I know dozens who converted, like Halimi and Zerbib
So it's not ok for Palestinians to return after being thrown out but it was perfectly ok for jews to return?
Pure demagogue. There are no refugees today. There are 4th generation of decedents of refugees in the best case. They are no abandoned arabs villages as well, but roads, parks and tall buildings instead. So, be serious, where you want to "return" exactly?
Humans are all the same , they have power, they oppress, they are the minority, they are victims!
@@gershonsavitsky6620 u "returned" after hundreds of générations and u are tellting us that s impossible to the 4th generations of decedents of palestinians refugees to return to their homes
@@gaddour5791 Your misconception is in what you you are calling home. For jewish immigrants empty land between Syria and Egypt was "jewish national home" - place where they can develop, build new cities etc. But syrians and lebanonians - 4th generation of decedents of arab refugees don't want place to build new cities. They want "their houses" which is a fiction as you understand. Villages abandoned by their grandparents where demolished somewhere in 50s, and new highways, parks and cities came there (for 740k of jewish refugees from arab countries particularly) . So the claim is not something mature, but just pathetic artificial obstacle in order to prevent the peace and normalization. Realistic claim is the claim to arab world to compensate them from the lost jewish property found. Israel can add $1to each $1of such found.
Arabs should return to arabia.
They just feel awkward and weird when they hear the word "Palestinian". They are s much isolated from the reality.
Its a roman name. The roman empire dosnt exist.
@@dogbert52 free Palestine 🇵🇸
@@dogbert52 hhhhh
Palestine for ever son u will leave
@@talaatbhaise542 i dont live in the roman empire son.
@@dogbert52 ok it's a roman name but the people was there already
Israel must deal with the thousands of Palestinian refugees who still live in refugee camps, after 70 years, in terrible conditions and with no identity and rights. I know a lot of Palestinian refugees and I saw how they live, I listened to their stories and their experiences. It's an unsolved injustice. And I don't want to mention the massacres that took place in these camps, it would be too long to explain and too sad. As Israel is now a democratic country with beautiful things (don't wanna say the contrary), and since it was founded on the memory of more than 2000 years before (2000 years not 70!) it should deal with the memory of the other people who still used to live there and who is still paying the consequences of the 1948 forced mass exodus!
The last lady is wrong. Her confidence is based on Israel being a military super power. First of all her family has the right to return. They may choose to exercise it or not. isreal doesnt accord Palestenians that right.Secondly, is she okay with Isrealis being expelled and then someone say ' Accept the status quo and lets look for other solutions'? Jews refused other solutions for more than 2000 years.
Jews didn't committed terrorist attacks on their host countries for 2000 years
@@snowwhite7704 Israel let's Jews return not Israelis. There is a difference.
@@snowwhite7704 A Jewish American isn't an Israeli citizen. He is an American citizen. Ur incorrect.
@@snowwhite7704 Wat r u talking about?? 😂😂😂😂 Palestenians are from Palestine which Israel had 56% of Palestine. They are from Palestine.. Ben Gurion and the European Jews were immigrants. 😂😂😂😂😂
The answer is all in the attitude, imo
This question is HUGE in meaning : from the answers the people give , you can see that no jew sees himself as a refugee. Yet, they were refugees. This way of seeing themselves as active and not passive is the key difference between them and the Palestinians... Think about that...!
Actually a lot of them said their ancestors were emigrants. Why should that be surprising? Jews move, like other people, when an opportunity looks good. Better weather, better business, family, politics, etc. are all draws.
No, the key difference is that the Palestinians have no country that they are encouraged to immigrate to. Had the United States been open to Palestinian immigration, the refugee situation would have been solved already. But it isn't so they remain stateless.
@@bjornlindqvist8305 Best posting. If I could give you a hundred thumbs up....
@@bjornlindqvist8305 They could have had a country in Jordan in 1948 but chose war.
The first secretary General of the UN offered a solution for them. He wanted to the Arab countries to absorb them. It was refused.
@@Linda43 Why should they move to Jordan? Why not stay in their home. Oh, yes. They were driven out with guns and bombs.
Lots of people in this video have a misconception of what refugees are. You don't have to be thrown out by law in order to be a refugee. As recognized by the U.N., a refugee is "someone who is unable or unwilling to return to their country of origin owing to a well-founded fear of being persecuted for reasons of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group, or political opinion". So the first interviewee, for example was exactly describing his family as refugees, but doesn't think of them as refugees.
Jews who fled from Arab countries to Israel and became refugees refuse to see themselves as refugees.
Arabs who moved 20km in the same land hold on to refugee status for generations.
The questioner is stupid. He should have explain it.
And compare that with Palestinians who are 4th generations removed from being refugees, living in Jordan, Syria and Lebanon and still identify as refugees.
Refugees is nothing else than way of thinking... Jews were expelled from many countries, also from Arab countries but they never felt refugees... They believed that it's God punishment and they went on... Even during the Shoah...
If you don't want to be stuck in the past why you came back after 2000 years as you claim
We could say the same thing about the Palestinians, stuck on the past.
The Fantastic Five it’s not about being stuck on the past. It’s about the now a days Israeli Jews claiming to be genetically Israelis after so long, because before 1948 there wasn’t such a thing called Israel so why did they take like 1300 years to make it Israel...so the now a days Palestinians who had to leave 71 years ago can claim their lands as well bc Israelis did, so why can’t they?
That's an interesting point. Jews were dispersed among many nations (although there was always a Jewish population throughout history in what Romans called "Palestine"). While culturally and religiously they always remained attached to the holy land they didn't try to recreate a nation-sate because a) they didn't have the means, and b) they accepted their fate as long as they could practice their religion and live in peace. However, living as a minority in different countries was often difficult. They were victims of much discrimination and violence. This eventually led to the holocaust. When they finally realized that they can't rely on others to protect them they decided it's best to have a Jewish state to protect themselves. The historical and religious bonds to the holy land made it the natural best choice. I don't think it's correct to say that one should forget the past, however it's important to look for positive solutions that make sense in the present and for the future. The Jewish people tried other solutions for almost 2000 years but recreated a nation state when the timing and necessity was there. It's a shame that the so called "Palestinian" people didn't accept the original UN proposal in 1948 for their own state.
Because history teaches us that every place the Jews went (or forced to go actually), they were under threat or even massacre in some places, so what was your opinion if your people went through all that and finally returned to their historical home that they were forced out of thousands of years ago? Btw that looked like a useless desert.
@@vivaldesque It isnt true that Jews always remained religiously attached to the 'holy land'. Jewish history was also secular at times and disconnected to Judaism. Thats why they were exiled. What other solutions did Jews try? Jews thrived under Muslims (It was so called it has been called the Golden age of Jewish history) and had thrived before the Holocaust. Great Jews (Marx, Einstein)were prominent in almost every sphere of human life.
They're not happy in Gaza ..
They're not happy in Egypt ..
They're not happy in Libya ..
They're not happy in Morocco ..
They're not happy in Iraq ..
They're not happy in Yemen ...
They're not happy in Afghanistan ...
They're not happy in Pakistan ..
They're not happy in Syria ..
They're not happy in Lebanon ..
SO... WHERE ARE THEY HAPPY?
They're happy in Australia ..
They're happy in Canada ..
They're happy in England ..
They're happy in France ..
They're happy in Italy ..
They're happy in Germany ..
They're happy in Sweden ..
They're happy in the USA ..
They're happy in Norway ..
They're happy in Holland ..
They're happy in Denmark ..
They're happy in Israel...
Basically, they're happy in every country that is not Muslim and unhappy in every country that is!
AND WHO DO THEY BLAME?
Not Islam.
Not their leadership.
Not themselves.
THEY BLAME THE COUNTRIES THEY ARE HAPPY IN !
AND THEN- They want to change those countries to be like, THE COUNTRY THEY CAME FROM WHERE THEY WERE UNHAPPY!
Larrypint you got it wrong, its more like end the Zionist threat and we will be happy everywhere
they are happy in germany, as long as no one forces them to
a) work
b) keep their religion for themselfes
c) accept german law
@@mobana3012 always blame the Israelis, that's how you get brainwashed since childhood. You don't see that? It's nearly the same as the nazis blamed the Jews for everything. Greetz from Germany
Larrypint its the Nazi thing again, this is how they brainwashed you telling you that Arabs are gonna do what the Germans did
The holocaust is a terrible thing indeed, but we don't have to pay for it, solve your mental issues away from me
@@mobana3012 en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_exodus_from_Arab_and_Muslim_countries
And the antijudaism is part of Islamic teaching (banu quraiza, Al ghardad)
This solution they keep mentioning that Palestinians can “go to any other Arab country” is just absurd. Technically, many “Arab” nations aren’t actually “Arab” in reality -for the most part- it’s a just a political stamp, and neither are the Palestinians ethnically “Arabs” themselves... it’s such a narrow way of thinking to believe that all “””Arab states””” (between a million quotations) are the same, they are completely different culturally and in the life style people carry there, the Levant is different from Arabia, for Egypt, Norther Africa, etc... also a lot of people keep giving the uneducated argument that they can go live in any “Islamic country that abides by Islamic law” not considering the fact that at that time (1948) almost all Middle Eastern regions were operating more on a secular basis and religion was very personal, the eruption of religious politics started much later, in the 1970’s in Egypt (not mentioned Wahhabism in KSA) and leaked to some other areas and groups in the region. Also, keep in mind that perhaps 30% (+/-) of Palestinian refugees were actually Christian families, so this whole narrative of “Just go to any other Arab and Islamic country and you’ll fit it well is totally bullocks”... the Palestinians are a distinct people with a distinct indigenous culture.... the argument that Palestinians arrived to the land during the “Arab/Islamic Conquest” in the 7th century AD is also meaningless and empty, as genetic testing has proven -many times- that Palestinians (as well as many Jews) have a significant amount of DNA from the indigenous population of the region, mainly the Canaanites, up to 80% in many cases, and you can still see an incredible amount of Canaanite elements in Palestinian culture for example the dances/dabke, some still carrying Canaanite names until today (e.g: Ala Dal’ona, which translates to: “onwards to help”, as peasants used to do this dance while crushing vines using their feet to make wine, or squashing olives to extract olive oil)... cheers. Time for peace
I agree that any group of people leaving together even one generation will create an distinctive unique culture. Jews from Russia living in Canada, Mexicans in LA, Turks in Germany... But does it mean they all deserve a country?
A also agreed that palestinians have not much with arab conquest of 7 century. If arab-speaking population of Palestine in 19 century was tinny 300k and after start of jewish immigration project jumpt to 1.3 in 70 years, its obvious that 70% of palestinians were just work immigrants from Syria and Egypt of that time (beginning of 20 century).
I also agree that it's meaningless to calculate today who is "more indigenous" and try to send each other to Europe /Arabia, but its necessary to do peace in today's condition.
Why do the other arabs not give the israeli arabs shelter? Why dont they takr them in?
@@dogbert52 Shelter to israely arabs??? 🙂 Israely arabs live 100 times better than any of their neighbors (Syrians Jordanian Egyptians), economically, civil rights wise, all, so its very funny to imagine that they have to look shelter there.
@@dogbert52 who should they? This is their homeland, why should they go live somewhere else?
The guy with the glasses doesn't even seem to know what 'ashkenazi' means lmaoo being an Algerian from France doesn't make you ashkenazi my dude
All of his talk is bullshit... He even says I am ashkenazi with being full of himself. This guy is full of bullshit
@@FaisalHelwa Ashkenazi is also about tradition and prayer. You are not ones to decide his ethnicity
@@thehunterbr5056 Most of isreali people are not semitic, are buch of converse to judaism to live in israel free.
@@maxdamage4919 these are the Russians. There aren't many converts here. Most have bloodline of Jewish tradition
fair question , good to see at least few of them talked with "relative fairness"
Notice how nobody thought of themselves or their families as refugees.
Exactly. The Jews accepted that the door to history is closed. Like one of them said: we have to play the hand that we are dealt. Very pragmatic. As opposed to the Arab Palestinians that cannot get over their loss and want to turn back the clock.
Pride.
@@a.brekkan4965 If the door to history is closed why create Israel- an entity and demographic entity which had not existed for thousands of years?
Cos they have been brainwashed by nationalism and have been taught to deny their diasporic roots. That's why.
@@Sam-gy3ok It can be done but it might take 2,000 years:)
I am surprised by the answers truly..and the first lady was quite honest. Good question..
@Son of Mountain Also in Turkish and Persian. Guess you're not that special after all.
@Son of Mountain Yeah ofc they live in the same region
Can I ask how you were surprised? How was it different to what you were expecting?
@@joblower9961 I expected the opposite which they would never feel sympathy towards the Palestinians refugees..you never know the struggle in someone's life until you live it or walk a day in their shoes.
shireen Ibdah me too. I was pleasantly surprised.
Cognitive dissonance 101
Why do so many Israelis say they "don't know"? Are there knowledge of their own country's history that bad? Them not knowing about the Nakba/"population transfer" of 1948 is like Germans not knowing about WW2.
Starhopper he is too busy destroying his own Scandinavian country with Islamists.
@Starhopper Why are you posting propaganda and lies Starhopper? Most Palestinians were civilians (fellahin) and didn't participate in the war on either side. Consequently, any rational person can admit that they did not deserve the fate that was bestowed upon them. It is only racist Israeli Jews (like you, but not all Israeli Jews) and their supporters who bend and twist logic to justify their dream of a racially pure state.
@Starhopper, you do post a lot of lies, fallacies and foolishness. I think it is your career. It seems to be all that you do.
Corey asks "Where is Nash Didan?"at 2:37.
Not where, but who or what?
Like the young lady says, the community was in Urmiah, Azerbhaijan province of Iran (Turkish-speaking, adjacent to the now-independent country o Azerbaijan that was once part of the USSR). The Jews in Urmiyah, like the Jews who are called "Kurdish" Jews (who lived in Kurdish-majority regions of Iraq, Iran and Syria but didn't speak Kurdish per se) spoke a Jewish dialect of neo-Aramaic. The ones from Urmiah called themselves "Nash Didan" which means in Aramaic "our people".
I was a bit confused when she said she was descended from the Jews expelled from Spain in 1492, because to my knowledge they never settled in and around Urmiyah (maybe some few individuals did) but then I realized she is also of Moroccan- and Turkish-Jewish background too, and those countries received large influxes of Sephardic Jews who were expelled from Spain in 1492.
I bet not a lot of people have heard of Umiyah before, or that there were Jews there. One suspects that they might have been in the area for a very long time.
Lots of Israelis and Palestinians both are stuck in their narratives. This land has been conquered and reconquered hundreds of times; It has mostly been under the occupation of big empires, from the Egyptians to the Babylonians to the Ayyubids to the British. In the meantime it was where Canaanites, Jews, Amorites, Arameians and so many more, all became ancestors of the Israelis and the Palestinians of now. This is a family feud, and should be dealt with as such. If everyone remembers they are family and related so closely it will be possible to make peace and mitigate the mutual propaganda and mistrust. Let's keep hope it will happen in the end.✿ ♡‿♡
One of the best questions you asked Gorey?
It is so embarrassing that it was hard to answer spontaneously. Why don't they simply answer they can have sympathy to Palestinians refugees as they experimented the same situation but they are afraid to see millions Palestinians coming and transform Israël to non-jewish state.
yeah there are about 6 million Palestinian refugees
yesss agreedddd
I agree, the fact their families are refugees and suffered GREAT racism and discrimination, and they don't have sympathy for Palestinians is a travesty. It was even more offensive when the woman said that oh, the Palestinians will come back here and not make it a Jewish state anymore. How offensive. The fact of the matter it besides the rest of the conflict is that Israel cannot be a Jewish state and a democracy at the same time, because that means a Jewish state would mean NO democracy. Even politicians in America expressed this fear, because a Jewish state would imply that rights only apply to Jews, not non-Jews (i.e. Palestinian Arabs for example), therefore creating an apartheid state. This is WAY FAR from a "democracy in the Middle East".
So in all, I agree with you definitely.
The Palestinians are the only one in the world to be considered refugees after 3 generations... The children of the refugees are NOT refugees... Less than 500 000 arabs left Palestine and now they say they are 5 millions refugees... Stop lying and complaining... Create your future in the states you live in instead of playing this victime character all the time...
2:15 the guy saud that if you leave a land then bye bye no return ?
Then why jews came back to the land they left thousand of years ago?
Or isnt the "bye bye "concept is applied to them !!!
Plus Isn't burning and killing people and force them to leave your* holy land* is basically the same that Algerians did (if that wasn't made like the rest of your stories)
And why you are allowed to expell people and not the others?
we couldn't com back for 1400 years cus islam rulers off the land dident let jews stay in israel -thats way when you look in israel for the earliest arab families in the land they all have Jewish or Samaritan roots all the rest off the arabs came from Egypt mostly and siria and iraq in last 300-100 yeas ago -that is historic fact Muslim ruler told the people off the land that if they dont convert to Islam they haft to leev
Lol you people cant handle any criticism.
@@huntinginpoland2396 are you polish?
@@nirprizant4228 I was replying to the muslim not u hahaha
@@nirprizant4228 im not polish
To the first guy: you think the Palestinians have no reason to come back again, because they left their land. Please tell me who gave you the right to come to Israel since your ancestors left that land thousands of years ago?
Arabs should live in arabia.
in fact are the nabatean and cannan the true owners.
GOD gave them that land it is written in the divine book.
Why is it only the Palestinians have the right to return to their homes? Since the end of WWII there have been over 50 million refugees around the world. If you ask "why" then why should apply to every other people on the planet. During the partition of INDIA ,which happened at the same exact time for almost identical reasons, 8-10 million Hindus, and Muslims became refugees as a result. The border changed and people were forced to flee. Has anybody asked the millions of Hindus who once lived in the northern part of their country whether they can return to their homes inside Pakistan? Suppose they all have the keys to their homes as well. Why can't they return? Vice-versa. How about the millions of Muslims living in Pakistan? Will India accept them back? We hear no mention of it anywhere. It only seems to apply to Israel. If you want a more recent example, how about the 1.5 million Syrians that are now living in Germany? Is Bashar Assad going to invite them back into their own country where they always lived? I doubt it. He wanted them gone and now they're gone. Yet we have to go through life with never ending guilt and anxiety over the Palestinians as if only they became refugees. And why are they defined as refugees generation after generation without exception? If you're a refugee from British Mandatory Palestine, why do your great-grandchildren get classified as refugees. Nobody else has ever done that. Not even the Armenians and Greeks who fled Turkey under absolute terror have done that. Anybody out there care to answer?
why israeli only have the right to back to the "fake promised land"
Good point!
I don't know what your point is!@@nashmi-8609
Only answer: arabs /Muslims always Claim to be the victims, thats why...
Instead of working for a better Future!
@@nashmi-8609 because Israel's god is real, and all heard from him.
...guess where you got your belief from.
For having served and spread the word about god around the world, jews deserve their country back.
palestinians are refugees in all the countries of the world they are living, and they have the right to return to Palestine. But they are not refugees in their own land , as some interviewers are suggesting
Keep living in the past. That will never happen, sorry, my country won't accept you just like everyone expeled us.
That's how the world goes. You can keep crying or try to improve your reality.
Haneen Oak
Fine... let them go to their country and ask to be citizens. Israel had never been and will never be theirs.
How possible, a whole society can live in such a hypocrisy and lies, no one can answer to a simple question...this is tell a lot on the situation there.
Btw Algerian did not kicked out Jews, we kicked out all traitors after taking our independence regardless of their religion, During the war against France we had many Algerian Jews in our side and they are still Algerian.
These Zionist are very clever. They would NEVER tell their true feelings on the camera. These people are extremely racists, hateful, and very cruel.
Okay, buddy.
Please tell me about the flourishing synagogues (that weren't burned down or ransacked), and please tell me if you actually met an Algerian Jew, would be interesting in knowing that there are way less than 100 left. In a country that had 150.000 Jews.
@@fusionvision7013 We still have few jews families in Algiers and Constantine, it is true that most of the Algerian jews left in 62, the rest left during the civil war in the 90s..but once again we did not kick out Christians or jews just because of their religion. Btw, hundred of them called '' pied-noir'' are still coming as a tourist each year....in Algeria we make a difference between jews and Zionist....zionist are just nazis, full of hates and with a weird project, which is giving a country to a religion!!
Don't try to play a victim, it is enough.
@@mingushill8416 Your comment really shows the brainwashing going on in terms of what a 'Zionist' is. 90+% of all Jews are Zionists. If you ask us what it means in Israel or abroad, most will say "The belief for Jews to self determine in their ancestral homeland". And no, this should not affect Palestinians in theory but please understand the context of war in this.
I won't have you compare my family and friends to Nazis, just because it suits your agenda.
Algeria didn't kick them out because of their religion? Highly doubt it...
If that is the case, Algeria kicked Jews out because they were different. It wasn't, and isn't, safe to be Jewish in Algeria. You didn't answer my question about the synagogues btw.
@@fusionvision7013
1- '' just because it suits your agenda''.
I do not have any agenda, I'm just a humanist, thinking with logic, not with a religious book, all movements around the world based on religious books, conducted the world to many wars and crimes.
2- ''Algeria didn't kick them out because of their religion? Highly doubt it...''
That's your right to have doubts, it's certainly not black or white, but the fact is, among the Algerian delegation negotiating for our independence, we've got one Christian, many of our leaders were not religious at all, and publicly. Many of our artists were jews, and still at least have contact with Algeria with any threats, as guaranteed by our constitution.
3- ''If that is the case, Algeria kicked Jews out because they were different''.
They were not different at all, they are just like all other Algerians, same dialect, same race, more than that, they contributed a lot to Algerian culture, especially music, they are Algerian from centuries (Reinette l'oranaise, Remond....the list is very long) I will avoid mentioning Enrico Macias for example, because his family was against Algerian revolution, they stand with France, in add he's a zionist.
To resume, we kicked out Christian, Muslims (Harki) and Jews, because they chose France, it's a purely political act, in that time Algeria was communist which means basically not believing in any religion, and guess what? because your friends, Saudi Arabia, Algeria turned to Wahabite and Salafist movement who started a civil war during 10 yeaars.
4- '' You didn't answer my question about the synagogues''.
The government closed all the synagogues and churches, during the civil war, for security reasons, for the safety of these communities, many attacks were committed against non-muslim (and Muslim too), 90 jews were killed in the 90s...but you have to know that most of Algerian are willing to protect their jews brothers, in my opinion, they are the first and principal enemy of the Zionist movement.
For your info btw, most of the Algerian jews who left Algeria, by fear or other reason, they went to Israel in the 60s but they left Israel for many reasons, essentially political, now the biggest community is in France (the south) and believe me they don't feel Israeli at all.
Another info, because of zionist propaganda, and your powerful media, simple people start not making difference between jews and zionist, because the goal of zionist is to remove this difference, so any critic against Zionsite become against jews, and this is what you are trying to do now with me ;)
Many studies have shown that most Jews living in Israel are jews only for a few generations, due to the mix and disparity.
THIS IS JUST NONENSE.
I’m so glad I found your channel 💚
There are millions of refugees today, and we are talking here about refugees from the first half of the 20th century.
There are millions of refugees today, and we are talking here about refugees from 200 BC
That's right, *Jonathan Rotem* we are talking about refugees created by the Jews of Israel back in 1948, and still that utterly depraved country, Israel, has not let the refugee families return. The fact that the UN and USA have not made Israel let those refugee families return shows how corrupt and depraved those entities are.
Do something, *Jonathan Rotem* to help those refugee families get their land back.
@@ChristineQ-wr6iv well said.
You admit the only reason you pretend to care is to satisfy your cancerous jew hate and bloodlust.
@@chugalongway01 Jews are refugees no more
@@ChristineQ-wr6iv
And millions of other also didn't return... the germans were kicked out of Czechia, poland and Russia for their aggression. They didn't return. They built themselves new lives in Germany. The Palestinians who left should be resettled and absorbed, not kept in camps
the Palestinian leader of the government in Gaza, Ismail Haniyeh, complained that Egypt should help their cause as "we all know we are Egyptians" - did you mean to return from were their great grandparents came into the British Mandat of Palestine?
Yasser Arafat was born in Cairo. First leader of Palestine, so there you go.
Fu** Haniya. I am a refugee from 1948 . Originally a Saudi . Haniyah needs to go back home to Egypt
@@da3v1ls93 And majority of israels first leaders where not born in the holy land.
@@AQWOMAR9 1948 it was founded before then there were quotas set up by the british mandate on how many they would let into the country. 90% of Palestinians today are descendents from the 1967 was and were originally from Jordan and Egypt.
@@da3v1ls93 proof it hahahahh proof that 90 of the palistinan are from jordan and egypt hahahah because DNA proof u wrong buddy
One of the best questions
quite telling that all the Arab jews are saying they were never expelled except the Algerians who low key were saying their parents were pied noirs
12:16 You have put his weak logic where it belongs Corey.
The First Lady interviewed is quite beautiful....she looks naturally beautiful....inside and out.....
The Jews in America that I see are unattractive but apparently in Israel they're much nicer looking. I wonder why.
Agreed. I just loved that rack :D
@Random Guy 75% of the top Israeli models look pretty Aryan or Slavic to me bro. I think people that don't mix in Israel tend to be religious fanatics, they don't really care about appearance. Not trying to step on anyones toes here but just writing Aryan as the stereotypical descriptive term of northern europeans.
@Eternal Fisherman lol
So ugly when compared to Lebanese
Great interviews
By definition, a child of a refugee is not a refugee
A person that moved within same country is also not a refugee.
The difference being Jews were horrifically persecuted, & exiled or killed, for being Jews. Civilian Jews. Many of them patriotic civilians to their host countries, before the atrocities. While our comparative subject here - Arab League & Palestinian Arabs nationalist movement instigated conflict against local Jews (this is historically accurate), leading to war, leading to expulsion of some of the Arab communities during the war, and some others fled at the promise of Arab League on radio - that they'll kill all the Jews, and after they can return home happy.
All that said, some Arab civilians of the time, did not have a political agenda against Jews living as self-determined people in the region. But were caught up in the war and mass movements, and lost their homes without a possibility of return. For those, as an Israeli Jew, I do have sympathy. But I don't have sympathy for their American/Australian great-grandchildren who claim to be "Palestinian from Jaffa" and never seen the middle east before.
interestingyoutubechannel You’re right you should not have sympathy for us. As an American whose parents are Palestinian, I can say our lives abroad are great. I’m content living here and I can’t say I want to go back and live in a place where my grandparents lived. However, if one day Palestinians abroad decide to return, there is not much you can pose against that considering Jews from abroad coming to Palestine in the 1940s had never seen the holy land either. In fact, they aren’t even genetically Semitic. I’m not arguing that an Israeli state isn’t necessary and valid, but don’t claim that the Palestinian diaspora doesn’t have a right to return to a place their parents and grandparents lived.
@@aymenazhari5424 Jews are an actual nation, and it's in our culture that every year for millennia we yearn for home, for Jerusalem. Palestinian Arab nationalism took hold in the 1960s. Not the same. Grandchildren of Palestinian Arabs are not 'from Palestine', in the same way that Jewish descendants are, well, Judean. "Genetically Semitic" - why do people like you always bring up nazi points like that, what's your blood saying! Lol.. in any case, DNA mass testing showed European & Middle-eastern Jews all have strong genetic links to the Levant, with genetic admixture from their respective host countries of exile.
Right of return is for Jews and not for Arabs because it's a place for Jews to be self-determined, with equal rights for Arabs. Not self-determination for Arabs, this is done in about 22 other countries. We just need our home, a small home at that. "Palestinian diaspora" - you're talking of a nationalist movement whose very existence is solely for the destruction of the Jewish state. If they really wanted self-determination or felt that they are distinctive from Syrians, then it would've happened 5 times over. In reality, in the west bank they say they are bilad al Sham, the same as Syrians & Lebanese. But they don't want Israel to exist.
@@aymenazhari5424 semitics is not genetics idiot. Ethiopians, Maltese and Lebaneses are all semitic, but they have nothing in common
As an Iraqi refugee I can understand how Jewish refugees had hard times living in outside land where they have been suffering from discrimination
Ashraf Barkat Question I have been dying to know from an Iraqi. What percentage of Iraqis would prefer their country now (USA removed Saddam) versus would have preferred to still be under Saddam?
are you now in england ?
Solving Politics most Iraqis don’t like Saddam but they think iraq was better during Saddam regime than now
Solving Politics Saddam was secularist and feminist but unfortunately he was authoritarian
Ashraf Barkat Ok, so what percentage do you think would still prefer to live under Saddam?
There are no palestinian refugees. This status can't be inherited.
It's WEIRD because jordania won't accepte them as Citizens. It's easier And economicaly more confortable to be forever refugee.
Well, he's not asking refugees either.
@@dragonlaughing That's because they died of old age.
@@matejfele9971
List of Palestinian refugee camps
*Gaza Strip*
*The Gaza Strip has 8 refugee camps and 1,221,110 registered refugees*
1948, Al-Shati (Beach camp), 87,000
1949, Bureij, 34,000
1948, Deir al-Balah, 21,000
1948, Jabalia, 110,000
1949, Khan Yunis, 72,000
1949, Maghazi, 24,000
1949, Nuseirat, 66,000
1949, Rafah, 104,000
*West Bank*
*The West Bank has 19 refugee camps and 741,409 registered refugees*
1948, Aqabat Jaber, 6,400
1948, Ein as-Sultan, 1,900
1949, Far'a, 7,600
1949, Fawwar, 8,000
1949, Jalazone, 11,000
1949, Kalandia, 11,000
1949, Am'ari, 10,500
1949, Deir 'Ammar, 2,400
1949, Dheisheh, 13,000
1950, Aida, 4,700
1950, Al-Arroub, 10,400
1950, Askar, 15,900
1950, Balata, 23,600
1950, 'Azza (Beit Jibrin), 1,000
1950, Ein Beit al-Ma' (Camp No. 1), 6,750
1950, Tulkarm camp, 18,000
1952, Nur Shams, 9,000
1953, Jenin camp, 16,000
1965, Shuafat camp, 11,000
*Syria*
*Syria has 13 refugee camps and 499,189 registered refugees* Three of these camps are unofficial (*).
1948, Sbeineh, 22,600
1949, Khan Eshieh (ar), 20,000
1948, Neirab, 20,500
1949, Homs, 22,000
1948, Jaramana camp, 18,658
1950, Daraa camp, 10,000
1950, Hama camp, 8,000
1950, Khan Dannun, 10,000
1967, Qabr Essit (ar), 23,700
1955-6, Latakia Camp*, 10,000
1957, Yarmouk*, 148,500
1962, Ein Al-Tal (ar)*, 6,000
*Lebanon*
*There are twelve refugee camps in Lebanon and 448,599 registered refugees*
1948, Bourj el-Barajneh, 17,945
1948, Ain al-Hilweh, 54,116
1948, El Buss, 11,254
1949, Nahr al-Bared, 300 families
1949, Shatila, 9,842
1948, Wavel, 8,806
1952, Mar Elias, 662
1954, Mieh Mieh, 5,250
1955, Beddawi, 16,500
1955, Burj el-Shemali, 22,789
1956, Dbayeh camp, 4,351
1963, Rashidieh, 31,478
*Jordan*
*There are ten refugee camps in Jordan and 2,034,641 registered refugees*
1949, Zarqa camp, 20,000
1952, Jabal el-Hussein, 29,000
1955, Amman New Camp (Wihdat), 51,500
1967, Souf, 20,000
1968, Baqa'a, 104,000
1968, Husn (Martyr Azmi el-Mufti camp), 22,000
1968, Irbid camp, 25,000
1968, Jerash camp, 24,000
1968, Marka, 53,000
1968, Talbieh (it), 7,000
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palestinian_refugee_camps
How about after 2000 years eh?
5 million? There weren't even that many people in the area in 1948. The ones that actually left in 1948, most of them are dead. How people can come back to some place they never been before? All of the people who left Algeria, Tunisa, Russia, wherever... would those places offer them land back? Why Arab countries don't absorb the "falestinaim" the way Israel absorbed jewish refugee?
they multiply every year, they marry other random arabs and those arabs also automatically become "palestinians" even though none of their ancestors were ever here.
You are right. Arab nations are playing a game. They deliberately do not want the Palestinian problem solved. They always make as Israel's fault. Blame Jews. Blame Israel. People always playing the blame game..
So what your saying is the jews had no right to return to Israel?
@@billyhunt2120 so are you saying Jews do have a right to return to Israel?
@@dors.sc1 well going by the logic of this post and the comments under it, no they dont have a right especially considering the Palestinians were only kicked out about 70 years ago and the jews about 2000 years ago and also considering the Palestinians are more semitic than 90% of modern jews and also considering that Judaism itself States they are to remain in exile until there massiah returns, which is hasn't happened, I'm pretty that no they have no more right to be there than anyone else
Look how different is the approach of the Israelis to their past from the approach of the Palestinians. Although historically the Jews have been pushed out from almost every country they lived in, not only by violence but rather inequality and anti semitism, which forced them to look for a new home, their kids, not only that they don't see themselves as refugees they don't realize that their parents were refugees fleeing a country without a penny and without being able to sell their property. This is just not something we think about. We are focused on our new life trying to build a future for our kids. And the Palestinians, although being refugees much less than the Jews had to be, pass on their hard feelings to third generation making their kids feel as if they are some sort of refugees although those kids were born and raised in the country they are at now, living on refugee camps and pitying themselves without being able to absorb in the state they live in. Dude this is sad.
Yup.
when they were being pushed away, it was ottomans Muslim who rescue them and allowed them to settle in Palestine and other ottomans land. If you were pushed away from Spain for example, then you have the right to claim going back to Spain and not on Palestine
Not true. Jews prayed for more than 2000 years about returning. They refused to give up the idea till it was achieved. They insisted on not assimilating, intermarrying till it was achieved. If Jews kept up a dream of return for 2000 years so can Palestinians. Jews still receive compensation for the holocaust today. The past is essential to every Jew and they still live in it. If it isn’t relevant let the Palestinians return.
@@deficrypto1234 why does this matter? Remembering your past striving to build your future in the ancient homeland has nothing to do with the feelings of discrimination someone might feel. In the case of palestinians the feel as if they have been discriminated for their grand parents being refugees. Its a very sad thing. It has nothing to do with their reality. This kind of education literally means exploiting your kids for political reasons.
Good question. Why does Hiroshima, the second world war. Jewish exile in 70CE, Jewish pogroms and the Holocaust matter? First of all, we must strive for justice. Time doesnt errode justice. No amount of time will make the Holocaust justified. I wouldn't dare saying to anyone with a Holocaust history to forget the past. Secondly we have laws and time doesnt nullify the laws. Thirdly, Palestinians refugee are still alive and want to come back. No one who has inflicted an injustice on anyone has the right to tell them to forget it . Especially when they are making decisions to prevent the righting of the justice.
the difference between us Israelies and the Palestinians is that we don't preserve a refugee consciousness. our grandparents didn't inherit that to us. We have a lot of compassion in our heart even towards the Palestinians. but, yes, we won't give up our land (although i personally don't mind giving up the WB) because it is the only one we've got. we would love the Palestinians to live by our side peacefully but they are not ready to settle on anything less than destroying the Israeli state.
I just want to make sure you understand this: as an Iranian living in The Netherlands I stand with Israel and wish your state well. Persians and Israelis have a lot in common. I am genuinely sorry the Iranian government is so hostile towards the Jewish state. The son of our Shah recently visited your country and reiterated quite correctly our respect for your state!
@@alishalilehwhat's ironic is the Jewish people originate from a place in mesopotamia that correspond to present day Iran so if people tell them to go back were they came from 12000000 of them would go to Iran.Not sure Iran would be to happy about that,😂
@@alishalilehtotally agree with you... When Iranians will put down this islamic regime, we will be friends again. No doubt
@@abee4138... Its not Iran, it's Irak... And they weren't jews, they were Hebrews... And in the Torah, God didn't promised Iran to the jews. He promised the Canaan land which is Israel today...
@@Aricboccara actually the area was Iran and irak where the river Euphrates and Tigris meet in the persan gulf where a river called shatt Al-Arab on the border of Iran - Irak.I used Iran because the irony is even bigger since Iran are the one financing Hezbollah.They were called Hebrew(still) but since we are talking about the Jews in Israel it applies and it gives an idea for people who don't know who the hebrews are.
The logic of many of the answers is weak or at least evasive, but the emotion is strong.
9:14 I liked what he said till her mentioned resistance. So how come he would for sure support Irgun, Hagganah, and Lehi being active during the British Mandate against Palestinians and expelling them outta their land/ country or killing them? Then he says let us be quiet and refugees wont go back to their land. We can get a long in love an respect but no returning.....Excuse me raining here...Taxi! Nice Logic and good work Corey
The first guy, they didnt kick us out they made us leave, THEY ARE DOING THE SAME TO PALESTINIANS, they making them leave but they are not going
For me it's complicated. I do feel pity but in the same sense that I pity the German and Japanese civilians who were killed in Allied bombing attacks. They were victims of their warmongering genocidal leaders. Had the Palestinian Arabs not attacked us in December 1947 and started a war it wouldn't have happened. That applies to those who were actually innocent. I have less pity regarding those who actively murdered Jews during the Civil War period.
The facts say that over 300 000 Palestinians were evicted months before by Zionist vermin .....before the Arab armies intervened .....the Zionist intention to expel the non-Jews of Palestine are well known since they clearly repeatrdly stated it, in print....starting from Herzl.
@@albertdupont3339 Chosen?
@@chugalongway01 They left because their leadership told them to leave. They were promised a" Jew free" land and the Jewish possessions and property.
@@chugalongway01 And you know why they fled? In the context of a civil war they started right after the Partition resolution passed. They had the Jewish population under siege, shooting up our traffic and settlements and cutting off Jerusalem's Jewish areas to near starvation levels, until April 1948 when the Haganah went on the offensive.
Then when the British left the Arab nations, who had armed, funded, and encouraged the Palestinian Arab attempt to wipe us out, invaded.
@@albertdupont3339 More like, as a culture, Jews have been living in cities since Egypt and the Pharoahs. They have developed some specialized castes. Countries don't "use" them. Business people go where the opportunities are. However, many Jews do not assimilate and become citizens of the state. States require citizens be in small units so that their power doesn't challenge the operation of a state. For example, the Chinese, early in historical times, broke up the large, named, families, demanding that it's citizenry start individual households if no more than there generations.
The ones (Jewish or not) who don't assimilate try to maintain a group identity by shared religion, language and cultural memes. Promoting a "them vs us" meme reinforces intra-group ties. However, it can lead to feelings if isolation and inferiority.
I could go on. . But the thing I have noticed if that nowadays there is a lot of Israeli government propaganda promoting these memes. Whereas before it was simply part of the culture.
I looked at Netinyahoo's Twitter. He's got a lot of "appeal to history" going on in "his" postings. Perhaps that's his most innocuous spiel. But it doesn't matter. The reality is, the Palestinians are suffering in poverty, in camps. And the Israelis are starting to look a lot like the old South Africans. Seemingly polite, but behind that, pretty nasty fellows.
I don't get what the third guy means when he says he's algerian on one side and french on the other.. Majority of french Jews are either Maghrebi, Middle Eastern or Ashkenazi, unless his french side of the family is non-Jewish
There are plenty of French Jews who have been in France for several hundred years now, who didn't arrive there recently. Sure it's not the majority of Jews in France today, but they still exist.
I think you answer your own question, perhaps without knowing it. France controlled Algeria until its independence and there was influence by french jews over algerian jews in that period.
But then again, people often have imperfect memory of what they were told about their family history.
The last girl is 100% right. Especially the last thing she said "you shouldn't be stuck in the past but look at the future".
if only Palestinians would understand it..
Isn't that why both parties are upset? "In the past", both were tied to this land and feel they are the rightful owners? So aren't they both technically living in the past? She's right, so how do they both move forward? Neither side seems to be that good at math lol.
@@user-yg4pu7to9f The reality of today is that the leading state is Israel. So they just have to comply and accept it and live well with that. Simple.
@@user-yg4pu7to9f israel is thriving and evolving, i wouldn't say both live in the past.
@@marierose214 I can 100% agree. In that case can they call themselves a democratic society if one side controls all the fundamental values of the state? The original fight for the Jews was religious freedom and their birth right to this land, and now the majority don't even follow the faith. So what is the true objective they fight for? The past or the future? I think both parties are confused at what they are dealing with.
@@Benadon I see your point. You're right that they have emerged themself after a model of democracy from the west, but the state(maybe not all the people) still carries this idea that this land is for the jews. That is where they are in the past. Not to say it's not prophetic, who really knows the full scope of all this. That's where the Palestinians live in the past. None of this really matters, it should be how do we work together towards the future.
09:15 the interviewer is trying so hard to get the guy to say no to Palestinians returning, even saying they are 5 million people and they want their homes back etc
💯 he has an agenda that is very clear.
They got 2 corners of the mouth. One corner says one thing, the other says another.
so true
This is one of many differences between Israelis and the so-called Palestinians. Israelis don't consider themselves or their ancestors as refugees. Even though many of them were persecuted and expelled from Arab countries. They don't consider themselves as refugees. They went to Israel or France or America or any other place in the world and built their life and thrived. The ”Palestinians” did exactly the opposite. They have an interest to remain “refugees” , miserable and to live a life of refugees. This is their tactic to receive money from the UN from UNRWA. Of course this is an interest of all Arab countries as well.
This is the mentality of those who want to succeed and those who want to be poor.
hahahaha wtf u are drunk, " Israelis don't consider themselves or their ancestors as refugees." the jews came back after fkn 2000 years. If the jews returned after 200 years then the palestinian can return after 70 years.
French converted and you call that refugee ?
It`s insane how the guy who literally is originally from Algeria with convert background finds he has more right to the land?! Like whoa
Where he says he is a convert ?
Your questions are armed to the eyeball ... insisting that jews were expelled from nearby countries and the first four people you spoke to refuted this and said ... we left on our own accord.
Secondly, for those who dont just get it. The Palestinians have been robbed of their homes by an occupying force, there was never a war never a discussion ... just a blatant inhumane occupation. They have every right to return to their homes and retake their lands.
Right?! I got so annoyed he kept insisting their families were refugees when they all clearly said they weren`t?!
@@pyruvicac.id_ maybe just try learning the history: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jewish_exodus_from_Arab_and_Muslim_countries
@@colbywinfield i think they are addicted to lying .....
Sorry I missed you at Rami Levy Tsomet Hagush :( my mom was a refugee in Uzbekistan and then in Canada. She has less sympathy for Palestinian refugees than anyone I know. However - it isn't one sided. She had the same total lack of sympathy for the people expelled from Gush Katif. She sat there watching them on TV and was like "don't be such a cry baby. nobody in your family died, you just moved to a new place that's all. you have nothing to complain about. just pick up your life and move on". When they came to Canada as refugees in 1949 no one did anything for them. They worked hard and made a life. and that is what she expects from everyone else!
While nobody may help you, deliberately hindering you is indeed problematic. Refugee camps is a very good way of perpetuating the difficult situation of refugees. This is why they have persisted for so long.
@@SimonKanner-si3it I don't think she does. But she doesn't remember a time in the US when Muslim was just another religion and no one noticed or cared.
@@SimonKanner-si3it Ilhan Omar don't hate america wtf
She is entitled to her opinion. However the law gives refugees the right to return.
@@snowwhite7704 What if u were kicked out? Since Palestine was a state, a war doesn't negate ur citizenship. Ur incorrect. Fleeing a country due to war is never the definition of a traitor..
14:10 לא נכון. That's not right
You're right!
Go tell the 1.6 billion loons that.
wtf the quran forbids killing jews and christians . i really get angry from from the people that talks shit and don't know what they are saying
Its written in talmud torah that people whom not jew(or pegans) are pigs and dogs something like that and ppl whom not jew are not human
He mixed stuff up
he is confused. He probably refers to their Holy Book.
It is so sad how traumatized we Jewish people have become.
There were never a state called Palestine
Ashraf Barkat because the nation of Palestine was under the rule of the ottomans. State or not, the nation of people known as Palestinians have existed.
@@silverhawk923 the land of plastine was named by hordos after the philistinies to de legitimize the hebrews which wasn't even arabs ...
@@leoncamel4153 Philistines are not Palestinians.
@efopo than I mistaken but it is still true taht palestine has nothing to do with arabs who lived in the region
Until 1948, there was never a country called Israel, and even now, Israel is not a proper country. It is an insane mishmash of internal and external borders, none of which are viable, in the long term.
pepper in the eyes of others does not burn
But a mouth full of garlic affects everyone. It just stinks like Arab lies.
@@Linda43 That's ironic because here in the UK Jews were considered to be 'garlic eaters' until European food came along in the 1970s.
@@marksimons8861
Another contribution of Jews to humanity.
A potato on the head of a chef is not french fries
The Algerian French origin Jew doesn't know what he is talking about when spinning is own view on the Quran.
Are you a Canadian refugee ?
no. but his parents were probably refugees when they came to Canada?
@@esther_margolis Gran, I believe.
identity is a strange thing. you cant go to someone and say your father was a thief! even with swift proof, he/ she wont believe you and think you are offending him/her and think you are his enemy wanting to steal his identity. we`re dealing with even greater identity issue here, the concept of home and motherland and the land that belonged to you that was stolen is so intense that will bend any rational thinking human against their human nature.that`s why they are ignorant of the pool of plalestinian blood that is fundation of their sweet homeland israel.
"First, they must stop the call to prayer at 5 O'clock in the morning. Nobody likes to be woken up at five in the morning. Next, they must stop the terror attacks." I like his priorities.
😂
Corey Gil Shuster, please check the translations. The bold white print is superimposed by the smaller black print in the beginning of the clip. Makes it difficult to read either.
I suggest you turn off "Captions" in the RUclips parameters. Corey inserts subtitles in the videos so when you have RUclips auto generated captions at the same time it's difficult to read.
The Czech's stories are worthy of a movie
'Palestinians' in 1948 fled only out of one reason: So that the arab armies can start a war against israel, and that after this war - in projection that the arabs will succeed and kick the jews out - they can return back.
Well, it came the other way round...
Irony of fate.
Its also a miracle. It avoided needless bloodshed on both sides.
The Zionist, with all the institutions of a state, have never been able to prove that lie, ......... all radio broadcasts during that period are still available and are held by the BBC in London. All the newspaper articles during that period are also available.......which proves beyond doubt that the ZioNazis intentions were always about uprooting the native non- Jewish population.....and in print.
Andy Power You might have forgotten to mention the genocides your country has committed against the Palestinians, here is an example, educate your self
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deir_Yassin_massacre
@@chugalongway01 well my friend, it is a fact that more than 60% of arabs (palestinians) of 48 NEVER faced an israeli soldier, because they fled.
There is clear proof that leaders of palestinians told their own people to leave their houses, so that arab armies can attack israel straight without having to worry, to hurt arab people.
On the same day, that israel was founded, 5 arab armies declared war on israel.
This was a well planned strategy of the arabs.
Even before that, with the mufti of jerusalem, many attacks were performed against jews.
That mufti, maybe you want to doubt that to, created during WW2 a fascist muslim SS division.
When there was an offer of the nazis, to send 4000 jewish children to 'palestine' in order to not kill them, this son of a bitch mufti interrupted and forced the children to stay there / not come to 'palestine', so all of them were murdered.
And you are standing behind this completely, I bet.
that's so wrong, Zionist militias massacred many Palestinians in the cost were there were no Arab armies but locals fighting zionist terrorism also zionists threatened Palestinians that if they don't leave they will be killed and those who remained in villages were killed
wonderful job. :D
it's fairly interesting because the actual number of 'indigenous' people in the area is very small.. basically an enormous number of arab immigrants came to the area after ww1 to work for the british and we all know the jews landed after ww2. in effect this means that immigrants are actually fighting over the land and the truly indigenous peoples are just stuck in the middle.
Can someone explain : is not virtually anyone who can provide for himself welcome to move (back) to Israel? Or are there special rules for Palestinians?
Watching Corey’s videos make you feel like there is a chance for peace
Reading the comments you feel the other way around
This is the channell where the fascist israelis get together to chant some " Israeli power" songs.
Starhopper I am semitic, and i cant handle your lies all over the comments section
@@mobana3012 Don't say liar when yourself are an idiot
Starhopper True the term Anti-semitic has been brought up by the Jews to tag any person with a different opinion than a Jew with racist mark, that difference of opinion could be related to Ice cream flavors, yet if you don’t like what the Jew likes the you’re an Anti-semitic Nazi. Pathetic
@@mobana3012 I prefer Jew hater. Better. ....
Wait: Israelis UNEQUIVOCALLY know that this land is theirs because of genetics, the bible, whatever. And so, they have the right to return. But when you ask them if the Palestinians have the same right, it becomes a “complicated question”?? Seriously, Israel is so screwed.
I think Israeli people wouldn't mind if Palestinians lived there too. The problem is that Palestinians, by and large, don't want Jews to be there at all. It's a case of two sides, side A and B. Side A has everything, and they keep offering to share what they have with side B, but side B keeps rejecting because side B insists that side A give them everything they have. So side A rejects and the status quo stays the same. If side B just accepted to share, there would be peace.
You have to also understand that when arab nations attacked israel, they told arabs/palestinians to leave and come back when we have destroyed israel, they weren't kicked out. But the arab nations lost the war to israel. Imagine if germans today wanted to return to pre ww2 germany and demand land from poland and other countries.
@@tyren818 that’s BS that you are brainwashed into thinking in your schools in Israel or Jewish religious schools. There is plenty of evidence to show Palestinians being imprisoned by Israelis in 1948 for months on end without charge and their business permits being taken away from them and their homes being demolished. It’s happening to this day!
What they left Algeria during the ww2 to go to the nazis 4:55
That is it make sense ?
4:50 *before* the second world war
So many people are of an Algerian-from-France non-refugee lineage. 🤔
@@SimonKanner-si3it Not true. most of them said they emigrated voluntarily
@@SimonKanner-si3it because they sided with the french .. they betrayed algerians
*---* *THE FACTS ABOUT THE SO-CALLED PALESTINIANS* *---*
There has never been such a country called Palestine. Israel was re-formed on land previously ruled by the Ottoman empire, similarly to other countries in the region such as Lebanon, Iraq and others. There is no such thing as "Palestinian people". It's worth noting that newspapers such as the 'Palestine post' were Jewish newspapers (this one for example turned into the 'Jerusalem post'). This is also true about other official "Palestine" related stuff from the time before Israel was re-formed. Hebrews were the majority in Jerusalem even before the birth of the Zionist movement in the 19th century. If someone happened to use the term "Palestine" before the re-formation of Israel, he was referring to the homeland of the Jevvs (the land of Israel) - not the Arabs. It's worth noting that the flag of the "Palestinian Authority" is the flag of Hejaz.
The British Mandate over the land, after the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, actually included also what is now Jordan (which includes the "east bank" - part of historic Israel), and according to the League of Nations (precursor of the UN), this Mandate was to become a national homeland for the Jevvs (the Arabs would get their own independent lands in all the rest of the greater middle-east, an area which makes the land of Israel insignificant in comparison). Note that according to the UN's constitution, all the past resolutions of the League of Nation are valid.
The British Authorities, due to their own interests with the Arabs (among others - future oil dealings), gave them 77% of the land - which later became what is now Jordan. There are over 20 Arab countries, and almost 60 lsIamic countries - each on average way bigger than Israel, but the Arabs couldn't tolerate the existence of tiny Israel, even after being given most of the land of the mandate. Instead, they tried to annihilate it by force with the Arab armies the moment it was officially independent (and have attempted to do so several times again since then).
The coIoniaI term "Palestine" was discarded after it was brought to life under the British rule, as it should have been, because the original name for the land - Israel, has been restored (Israel is not Palestine, just like Jerusalem is not Aelia-Capitolina, and Schehem is not Nablus).
It is only in the mid 1960's that the Arabs hijacked the term, and its widespread usage only took off after the 1967 Arab-Israeli war. The Arabs used this terminology as a political propaganda tool to de-legitimize Israel, after they failed to steal the Hebrew homeland by force with the Arab armies, by invading and attempting to conquer the land. Ironically, the term "Palestinian" originate from the term 'Pleshet' to describe INVADERS by the Hebrews. Those who willingly identify as "Palestinians" are declaring themselves to be invaders/colonizers in Hebrew land.
It's important to note that this propaganda tool was supported by the Communists/Soviets. On the other hand, just a few decades before that, the Arab "Palestinians" were hand in hand with the Nazis. They have aided them under the leadership of the mufti Amin Al-Husseini - who is often regarded as the 'founding father' of the Arab "Palestinians". During WW2 he became an SS general, but he had anti-Jewish genocidal ideology long before the Nazis rose the power. He has incited and caused violence and terror against the Jewish people in their homeland since the early 1920's (for example: 1929 Hebron massacre).
"Palestinians" are nothing more than bands of foreign invaders, squatters and illegal immigrants from all over the Islamic world - mostly the Arab world (some of them even originating from places that are not part of the middle-east, such as Bosnia), as well as several other places. The overwhelming majority of them first settled in the land of Israel in recent centuries - mostly in the 19th and 20th centuries. Some of them even came to Gaza, Judea and Samaria from Egypt and Jordan while these areas were under Egyptian and Jordanian occupation in the period between 1948 to 1967.
Informative quotes from Arab "Palestinian" leaders:
"There is no such country as Palestine. 'Palestine' was invented by the Zionists. There is no Palestine in the bible ...Palestine is ALIEN to us" - Arab "Palestinian" leader Awni Abdul Hadi, Peel Commission, 1937.
"The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity... Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people, since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct "Palestinian people" to oppose Zionism. Yes, the existence of a separate Palestinian identity exists only for tactical reasons, Jordan, which is a sovereign state with defined borders, cannot raise claims to Haifa and Jaffa, while as a Palestinian, I can undoubtedly demand Haifa, Jaffa, Beer-Sheva and Jerusalem. However, the moment we reclaim our right to all of Palestine, we will not wait even a minute to unite Palestine and Jordan." - Arab "Palestinian" leader & PLO member Zuheir Mohsen, 1977.
"I don’t think there is 'Palestinian People', I don’t think there is a 'Palestinian Nation' at all… 'Palestinian Nation'? I think that is a colonial invention. When were there ever 'Palestinians'?" - Arab "Palestinian" leader Azme Bishara, TV Interview.
"We all have Arab roots, and every Palestinian in Gaza and throughout Palestine can prove his Arab roots - whether from Saudi Arabia, Yemen or anywhere else." "... Half the Palestinians are (Arab) Egyptians and the other half are (Arab) Saudis" - Arab "Palestinian" Hamas minister Fathi Hammad, 2012.
Here are some common "Palestinian" families and their place of origin:
Saudi, Al-Husseini, Al-Hassan, Hijazi, Tamimi, Erekat, Barghouti, Qureshi, Badawi - Saudi Arabia
Yamani, Azad - Yemen
Haddadins - Yemen (Ghassanids)
Masri, Masrawa, Tartir, Bardawil, Fayumi - Egypt
Abu Kishk, Shakirat, Zabidat, Aramsha, Abu Sitta, Abu Sutta, Shaalan - Egypt (Bedouins)
Turki, Sultan, Uthuman - Turkey
Iraqi, Baghdadi, Faruqi, Tachriti, Zoabi, Abbas - Iraq
Nashashibi, Hurani, Allawi, Halabi - Syria
Lubnani, Tarabulsi, Sidawi, Surani - Lebanon
Bushnak - Bosnia
Khamis - Bahrain
Afghani - Afghanistan
Mughrabi - Maghreb
Araj - Morocco
Djazair - Algeria
Kurd - Kurdistan
Hindi - Indian Subcontinent
Abid - Sudan
Yasser Arafat, the most famous "Palestinian" and leader of the PLO terrorist organization, was not native to Judea. He called himself a "Palestinian refugee" but spoke Arabic with an Egyptian accent. He was born in 1929 Cairo, Egypt. He served in the Egyptian army, studied in the University of Cairo, and lived in Cairo until 1956! His full name was Mohammed Abdel Rahman Abdel Raouf Arafat Al-Qudwa Al-Husseini.
Yasser Arafat also proudly stated in his authorized biography that: "If there is any such thing as a Palestinian people, it is I, Yasser Arafat, who created them."
Genetic data for "Palestinians":
According to a 2010 study by Behar et al. Palestinians tested clustered genetically close to Bedouins, Jordanians and Saudi Arabians which was described as "consistent with a common origin in the Arabian Peninsula".
A study found that the Palestinians, have what appears to be Female-Mediated gene flow in the form of Maternal DNA Haplogroups from Sub-Saharan Africa. Palestinian individuals tested, carried maternal haplogroups that originated in Sub-Saharan Africa. The explanation for the presence of predominantly female lineages of African origin in these areas is that they trace back to women brought from Africa as part of the Arab slave trade, assimilated into the areas under Arab rule.
In a genetic study of Y-chromosomal STRs in two populations from Israel and the Palestinian Authority Area: Christian and Muslim Palestinians showed genetic differences.
A 2013 study of Haber and et al. found that "The predominantly Muslim populations of Syrians, Palestinians and Jordanians cluster on branches with other Muslim populations as distant as Morocco and Yemen."
The authors explained that "religious affiliation had a strong impact on the genomes of the Levantines. In particular, conversion of the region's populations to Islam appears to have introduced major rearrangements in populations' relations through admixture with culturally similar but geographically remote populations leading to genetic similarities between remarkably distant populations."
Even the Quran:
And thereafter We (Allah) said to the Children of Israel: "Dwell securely in the Promised Land. And when the last warning will come to pass, we will gather you together in a mingled crowd" [17 : 104]
O my people (Jevvs)! Enter the Holy Land, which God has assigned unto you [5 : 21]
We (Allah) settled the Israelites in a blessed land and provided them with good things [10 : 93]
It was our (Allah's) will to favor those who were oppressed (Jevvs) and to make them leaders of man, to bestow on them a noble heritage and to give them power in the land (of Israel) [28 : 5-6]
We (Allah) gave the persecuted people (Jevvs) dominion over the eastern and western lands which We had blessed (the east and west banks of the Jordan River). Thus your Lord's gracious word was fulfilled for the Israelites, because they had endured with fortitude [7 : 137]
Watch:
ruclips.net/video/IJggz2HIkS4/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/SN838zu6iio/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/u8ELap2uhkA/видео.html
*-------* *THE ORIGIN AND MEANING OF THE TERM PALESTINE* *-------*
The origin for the term Palestine is a term to describe INVADERS by the Hebrews. Anyone who willingly identify himself as a "Palestinian" declares himself to be a colonizer/invader in Hebrew land.
The Philistines were an ancient sea-faring people who invaded the coast of ancient Israel from the islands of the area of the Aegean Sea. The term Philistines was not their actual name or the original term used to describe them - it is nothing more than a later bastardized term in English that holds no real meaning.
The original name of what they were called, comes from how they were called by the Hebrews - which was not their actual Aegean name, but a term that was derived from what they were - invaders. The name was Plishtim, and the small area they colonized on the coast of the land of Israel was called Pleshet (which basically meant 'area/land of invaders', and parallels to the English term Philistia). These words hold meaning, as they come from the root-word to describe INVADERS in Hebrew (and indeed the Philistines were invaders in Hebrew land). Philistia was only a very small strip of land on the coast that the Philistines managed to capture from the Hebrews and occupy it (note that this small territory had never reached near places like Jerusalem, Hebron and other places in Judea and Samaria).
Due to their fighting with the Israelites, the Assyrian conquests, and the Babylonian conquests, the Philistines went completely extinct more than 2600 years ago. What remained of them has been completely assimilated into the nations of the region, and what little remained of them in the land of Israel has been assimilated into the Hebrews.
The Philistines were actually part of a larger group of people that were known as the "Sea People" (because they invaded from the sea), who also invaded other lands (such as Egypt).
The term Palestine is a bastardized English term, which comes from the bastardized Roman coIoniaI term Palestina for Pleshet (what we now call Philistia) - which itself comes from a bastardized Greek term for Pleshet, and in the end originate from Pleshet (what we now call Philistia).
The term was first implemented by the Romans after the final Jevvish-Roman war around 135 CE. The merciless Romans decided that mass ethnic-cleansing, massacre and slavery of Jevvs wasn't enough - they would rename the province of Judea into Palestina in order to further humiliate the Jevvs by renaming their homeland after their ancient enemies (the Philistines), and attempting to erase Jevvish connection to land.
Throughout the centuries this foreign coIoniaI term was forgotten and was no longer in use. The Ottomans, who ruled the land for centuries up until the end of the first World War did not make use of the term.
When the British took control over the land after World War 1 they revived/popularized the incorrect and coIoniaI term Palestine, but even then it wasn't simply known as "Palestine", but as 'Palestine (Land of Israel)'. It was obvious to the British authorities that the land was the homeland of the Jevvs - the land of Israel, and "Palestine" was simply a technical/geographical term, not a term related to any "Palestinian people".
Modern-day Arab "Palestinians", most of which have first came to the land of Israel as recently as the 19th and 20th centuries, have nothing to do with the ancient Aegean Philistines from thousands of years ago (that went completely extinct a several centuries after their invasion to the land of Israel, more than a thousand years before Islam was even created), expect that they were both foreign invaders in Hebrew land and the term they (the Arabs) adopted, which originate from the term to describe INVADERS in the native tongue of the land - Hebrew.
The adoption of the term "Palestinians" (as a new identity) by the Arabs happened only in the mid 1960's (and took off after the 1967 war), as part of an attempt to de-legitimize Israel through false propaganda after they failed stealing the homeland of the Hebrews from them by force with the invading Arab armies. This Plan, which was aided by the Communists/Soviets actually worked quite well for them (as we can see today) due to bias, stupidity, and ignorance, of people around the world.
Despite the success of their anti-Israel propaganda, by identifying as "Palestinians" they (ironically) declare themselves to be invaders in Hebrew land. Another absurd thing is the fact that Arabs can't even pronounce 'p' in their own language (it does not exist in Arabic, and they end up pronouncing it as 'f' or 'b'), thus being unable to properly pronounce their own "original" name for their own "original" invented nation, in their own language.
You can clearly see the sheer hypocrisy, absurdity and dishonesty of Arab "Palestinians", who often complain about Western imperiaIism, in their misuse/propaganda/perpetuation of the foreign coIoniaI term "Palestine" in order to promote their goal of implementing their Pan-Arab-lsIamic imperiaIism in Judea.
Israel is not and never has been "Palestine", just as Jerusalem is not Aelia-Capitolina (another foreign term introduced by the Romans - a name that comes from the family name of the Roman emperor Hadrian. The Arabs, who came later and did not know any better, first called it Aelia, not Al-Quds - which is a bastardized Arab term from the Hebrew term HaQdosha, that was used by them in a much later period), and Shechem is not Nablus (a bastardized Arab term for Neapolis - another foreign colonial term).
*-------* *THE FACTS REGARDING AL-AQSA* *-------*
Today, Jerusalem's holiness to Sunni MusIims as the third most holy city, is based on a late and political interpretation of a Quranic verse. To Shi'ite MusIims, the third holiest city, ranked below Mecca and Medina, is the city of Najaf in southern Iraq.
Early lsIamic sources state that the "Al Aqsa Mosque" (literal meaning: 'the farther mosque'), mentioned only once in the Quran, was one of two mosques located near Ji'irrana, a village located between Mecca and Taif in Hejaz. One of the mosques was called "al-Masjid al-Adna", meaning the "closer mosque" and the other "al-Masjid al-Aqsa", the "farther mosque". When the Quran refers to the Al Aqsa mosque while telling the story of Muhammad's night time journey from the "holy mosque" of Mecca to Al Aqsa, that is, the "farther mosque", it is referring to the mosque in Ji'irrana.
It's also interesting to note the following Hadith:
Narrated Abu Dhar: I said, “O Allah’s Apostle! Which mosque was first built on the surface of the earth?” He said, “Al-Masjid-al-Haram.” I said, “Which was built next?” He replied “The mosque of Al-Aqsa.” I said, “What was the period of construction between the two?” He said, “Forty years.” - Sahih Al-Bukhari Volume 4, Book 55, Number 585 ; Sahih Al-Bukhari Volume 4, Book 55, Number 636
Al-Aqsa Mosque can't possibly be referring to the mosque which was built in Jerusalem decades after the time of Muhammad's death.
In 682 C.E., fifty years after Mohammed's death, Abdallah Ibn al-Zubayr, the tough man of Mecca, rebelled against the Umayyads who ruled Damascus and would not allow them to fulfill the Hajj in Mecca. Since the Hajj pilgrimage is one of the five basic lsIamic commandments, they decided to choose Jerusalem as their alternative for a pilgrimage site. In order to justify choosing Jerusalem, the Umayyads rewrote the story told in the Quran, moving the Al Aqsa mosque to Jerusalem, and adding, for good measure, the myth of the night time journey of Mohammed to al Aqsa. This is the reason the Sunnis now consider Jerusalem their third holiest city.
Shia lsIam, mercilessly persecuted by the Umayya Caliphate, did not accept the holy Jerusalem canard, which is the reason the third holiest city to Shi'ites is Najif in Iraq, the burial place of Shi'ite founder Ali bin Abi Talib. Many of the Shi'ite elders - Iranian and Hezbollah - only began to call Jerusalem holy after the Khomeni rebellion in 1979 so as to keep the Sunnis from accusing them of being soft on Israel.
The first lie, in that case, is the spurious claim that the "farther mosque" is in Jerusalem.
More lies were piled on to the first one, the main prevarication being the exact location of this so-called Al Aqsa mosque, which until not very long ago, was the silver-domed building on the southern end of the Temple Mount.
The entire area of the Temple Mount is known as al-Haram al-Sharif - "the holy and noble site"- but a change came about after the Six Day War, when Jevvish voices could be heard, calling for the establishment of a synagogue on the Mount. Immediately after the war, a prominent rabbi also said that he wanted to celebrate religious events on the Temple Mount. It was felt that the MusIims would not object, since Al Aqsa was on the southern edge of the compound and the synagogue would not be nearby.
As a result, however, the MusIims decided to announce that the Al Aqsa mentioned in the Quran refers not only to the mosque on the southern end of the compound, but is the name for the entire Temple Mount area, abandoning the original name, al-Haram al-Sharif. The renaming of the Temple Mount is clearly a canard, with two documents, one known and one less known, revealing the truth.
The source that is more widely known is a booklet prepared in 1924 by none other than the openly Jevv-hating (and later on an SS general) Mufti Hajj Amin Al-Husayni and reprinted many times in the years following its first publication. The booklet's title is "A Brief Guide to al-Haram al-Sharif - Jerusalem". Note that the area is not called Al Aqsa. The Al Aqsa Mosque appears as a chapter in the booklet, after the chapter on the Dome of the Rock, the golden-domed structure in the middle of the compound. It is clear that to Hajj Amin Al-Husayni, the Mufti of Jerusalem, the Al Aqsa Mosque was simply the silver-domed building on the southern end of the compound.
The lesser known of the two documents is an ordinary Jordanian tourist map of Jerusalem that was executed in 1965, two years before the 1967 Six Day War. At that time, East Jerusalem was still illegally occupied by the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, while the entire world kept silent and uttered not a word against this totally illegal occupation. The map was drawn by a Jordanian named Abd al-Rahman Rassas who worked as an official surveyor and was authorized by the Hashemite Tourism Authority of Jordan. The map bears the words: "recommended and approved by the official Jordanian Tourist Authority".
A perusal of the map shows that in 1965 the Temple Mount compound was still called "al-Haram al-Sharif", that it was on "Mount Moriah", and that the "Al Aqsa Mosque" was simply the silver-domed building on the southern end of al-Haram al-Sharif. In other words, thirty years before the peace agreement between Israel and the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, the Jordanians identified Al Aqsa as no more than an edifice on the southern end of al-Haram al-Sharif, which in turn is built on Mount Moriah.
Those who lie and deceive in the name of lsIam decided to "expand" Al Aqsa - whose real location is actually in Ji'irrana (in Hejaz) - to encompass the entire Temple Mount area only after the Jevvs liberated the site of their Temples in the 1967 Six Day War.
For example, Sheikh Ikrima Sabr, Mufti of Jerusalem 1994-2006, in a speech given on Friday, January 4th, 2002, said the following: "Oh ye MusIims (all over the world), when we talk about the blessed Al Aqsa Mosque, we mean a mosque whose area is 144 dunam (the size of al-Haram al-Sharif in its entirety) including the walls, the al-Buraq Wall (their name for the Western Wall), the passages, hallways, entrances and squares, in addition to the part that is roofed (the building in the southern end), the part that is ancient (under the roofed part) and the Foundation Stone (under the Dome of the Rock), the Marwani prayer site (Solomon's Stables), all are Al Aqsa…"
Another lie, revealed as such by the very same map, follows on the heels of this one. It concerns the site of the Jevvish Holy Temples. Some lsIamic preachers even claim nowadays that al-Haykal al-Maz'oum - "the supposed (Jevvish) Temple" - was never in Jerusalem. The Jordanian map puts paid to the lies of every one of these lsIamic orators.
Of course, those who deny the existence of the Temple in Jerusalem also simply contradict the well-established history of the land.
Watch: ruclips.net/video/cZrLD6TXPtc/видео.html
@@mideastruth
No one ever reads the crazy crap you post.
Christine Q not even crap because he tell it truth with full of sources
@@ChristineQ-wr6iv False !I did it for all the 3 texts and it's so refreshing for my cultural knowledge. Now, I can understand all this "Palestine" BS stuffs with a clear mind.
The man and woman at the end are 100% correct. There is no occupation since Israel legally CONQUERED all the territories in defensive wars. Judea and Samaria, the Golan snd even Gaza are legally conquered Israeli territories.
Please, answer this: since when is the defeated loser of a war rewarded with the very same territories that the defeated loser used as a launching pad in an aggressive war - a war that the defeated loser started in the first place? What other nation on earth are obligated to return legally conquered territories to its enemy whom they rightly defeated in a defensive war? That's ridiculous!
Also, the so called 'palestinians' are all Arabs. They aren't a unique people of any sort. They are all Arabs originating from Arabia. They are foreigners and invaders of Eretz Yisrael. Jews are called Jews since they originate from Judea. Arabs are called Arabs since they originate from Arabia. So the real question is actually what the Arabs of Arabia are even doing in the Jewish land of Judea to begin with?
There is no such thing as legally conquered
dragonlaughing Yes there is. If hostile nations attacks you (like Jordan, Egypt and Syria) and you defeat them in self-defense along with winning/conquering territory, then that territory is now legally and rightfully conquered and owned by the nation which was attacked and won the war. Judea and Samaria, the Golan Heights and Gaza are all legally and rightfully conquered Israeli territory.
@@dragonlaughing really? So Germany should get back Prussia, Slesia and Pomerania? Italy should get back Istria, Corsica and Dalmazia? Greece should get back Cyprus, Smyrna and, why not, Costantinopoli?
@@krisssmike3378 They had the right to do so, before they got peace agreement.
After they got peace if those nations they decided what land belong to whom
"legally conquered " sounds like a heavy oxymoron! !
Why there is so much talk of antisemite ,why is no one to talk about ant anti muslim like the guy at13:00,is he not being anti muslim ;and this type of talk is not uncommon in mainstream european media.
Why don't the arab countries don't give back the properties that they confiscated from the jrws??? And the same goes to european countries
The solution is 1947 borders for all with equal rights for all.
These folks are shockingly humane considering what they live with.....
"in" .... you missed that out.
Thinks he means the Palestinians are humane .....
We know what it's like to live in a Jewish colony like the west . Not humane
No such a thing as a humane Zionist......they are all Jewhadis
@@lastunctives2095 Where would you be happy? On the moon.....
Great comments, it shows a well mannered and civilized culture
Absolutely
*Make* *Judea* *ISRAEL* *Again!* 😊🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱💪
@An A
Basic history and Archaeological finds. 😊
Very shameful answers they don't want to see reality
The entire Jewish population of Pakistan was kicked out in 1947 along will MILLIONS of Hindus, Sikhs, Jains or Buddhists. Why is no one talking about them?????
Okay, for anyone to say that Oriental Jews came here as refugees.....it De facto implies that they DID suffer Im Muslim lands.....
Corey still at it again. Most of the Jewish Algerian's in this video said they weren't thrown out, yet he insists on asking if they were thrown out when they stated they weren't (they were threatened at home but not expulsed) . You would think after a few people or a whole bunch, saying their family were not thrown out of Algeria that he'd stop asking "where they thrown out?", and adjust his questioning, but he didn't. It's quite disheartening to hear him repeat over and over again very obvious questions. I enjoy and love Corey's video's and the time and effort he puts into his work and his main attraction who are the people he interviews.
I just wish he could think a little more and listen before asking more questions, for example, a woman (second interviewee), she stated she was born in Israel, he asks what's her experience like being a refugee? You can't be a refugee in a country you're born in (she stated she was born in Israel). He sometimes is a bit pushy with his interviewees(second and third interviewees) that aren't aware of ,not familiar with or not willing to share what he's asking of them. Again, I love his videos, and wish him the best.
Peace will come when the Arabs will love their children more than they hate us
-Israel PM Golda Meir
Anthony R That will be on the 12th of Never!
@@matiasbrachini8741 don't be gay in gaza.
@@anthonyr963 don't be black in Israel or they will shoot you in the head.
Never gonna happen. They think their children 's life has very few value. They see their children as expendable, replaçable.
@@matiasbrachini8741 TGE treatment black jew community recieves is an other complicated topic.
The first guy is confusing he says they cut up uncle and burt down bussinesses but left of own choice?
The first guy is right. Tough luck.
During the Israeli bombardment and shelling of the Gaza Strip last summer, an Israeli soldier approached a 74-year-old Palestinian woman Ghalya Abu-Rida to give her a sip of water. He gave her the water, took a photo with her and then he shot her in the head from a distance of one metre. He then watched as she bled to death... The spokesman of the Israeli army, Avichay Adraee, shared the photo of an Israeli soldier holding the water bottle as an example of the “humanity” of the Israeli army towards the civilians in the Gaza Strip.
Pallywood. She died by strikes after missiles were fired, months after the photo was taken.
Hamass probably put the missiles near her home on purpose.
Putin should stop killing indigenous Ukrainians on Ukraine's land.
What a heartbreaking story of Russian style propaganda lies.
And we should just believe you that that's exactly how the story went, just like we are supposed to believe you're a Russian Jew and ex-IDF officer... FOH
The Protector you're a genocidal maniac
Starhopper
The more we look into Epstein’s saga, the more it appears to have the characteristics of a gargantuan espionage operation. If so, then Epstein was running a multi-million intelligence apparatus set to accumulate dirt on some of the world’s most influential people. The walls of his Caribbean island palace were rigged with cameras, and likely for reasons other than his personal libidinal gratification. Epstein didn’t work alone. Press reports allege that Ghislaine Maxwell functioned as Epstein’s ‘madam.’
Ghislaine is the youngest child of the flamboyant Jewish media tycoon Robert Maxwell, a long-time agent for the Mossad who died under mysterious circumstances in November 1991.
This intelligence postulate raises a crucial question. If Epstein was a spy, who did he work for? Was it the Russians? *I only ask because every time Tel Aviv comes up as a likely suspect American media tends to blame the Russians.*
If it was the Mossad, they likely enjoyed significant support from within the American intelligence community. I assume that Alan Dershowitz, Epstein’s former attorney, may be able to answer some of these questions.
The question was a bit strange; because the Jewish "refugees" who came to Israel, made a great life in the NEW place. None of the Israeli's you talk to want to go back to the place they are refugees "from". Therefore there really isn't any parallel to speak of at all.
Why would they. Europe is full of Algerians and Moroccans who don't want to go back. When people move to a new country they most often leave again within a few short years. Once they have put down roots it gets tough to leave, especially when their extended families are to hand.
correct
Apply the logic of 2000 years, what about nabatean ? cannanean ? are the true owners historicaly not biblical.
Jews are from a Canaanite tribe
Jews didn’t just come out of no where.
The owner of the British Mandate Palestine, divided the country. The Britain’s choices are what matter in the end because they owned the Land and therefore they could give or divide the land however they like.
4:40 we didint throw thene out yes that true but they leave by theire self bcz they know what they did to us shameeeeeeeeeeeeeee shameeeeeeeee shameeeeeeee
Kinda skipped the part where the guy said they got his uncle disemembered in a bag on their doorstep?
I hope the europeans treat you well.
Free Tommy Robinson! 🇦🇺🇮🇱
Da 3v1ls free him he did nothing. The uk is literally an Orwellian parody
@@IsraelLuisGeerRivera-ff4cg my thoughts exactly. Israel should take Tommy in with open arms. UK government have turned authoritarian where people are not even allowed to be journalists if they are true conservatives. Orwellian is right! In Australia (where i live) you can be jailed for saying things that might be classed as "hate speech". So supporting a guy like Tommy who is against Islamisation in the West could land you in hot water.
Everything thing is complicated when it is about logical stuff, but why it is not complicated, when it is about 2000 or 4000 years in the history
It would have been interesting if he asked non-white Zionists this question for example the Ethiopian-Israelis
The issue is that Palestinian refugees are defined differently than any other type of refugee in the world. No one else gets to pass their refugee status onto their grandchildren and great-grandchildren. Being a refugee by definition means you are to be resettled as soon as possible, not sequestered into "camps" for decades on end. Right of return is the #1 sticking point of any final status negotiation.
Not at all. They cannot return.
@@Linda43 You say no, they say yes. Hence the sticking point.
@@theprotector6099
No sticking point. Even Arab states gave up on immigration of Muslim Arab descendants of people who in first half of last century lived for different period of time in British Mandatory Palestine, not to mention USA or EU, or any peace proposal.
Not true. Refugee status is ALWAYS passed on to children. If it weren't then a state could just kick an unwanted ethnic group out of the state, keep it the out for a generation and claim it is not culpable.
@@bjornlindqvist8305 It is NEVER conferred onto grandchildren and great-children! That is a unique case created by UNRWA, and differs from the general definition of refugee as defined under int'l law.
11:48 This is a very interesting “sub-question” …. It’s water under the bridge now, but why were Jews not more amenable to the idea in the 1940s of a New Israel in South America or Africa requiring zero displacement of any indigenous communities? Things could have gone in a very different direction, that’s for sure….
Edit: Please consider this as the main question for a future video
Because the Jews didn't displace anyone, therefore your question is invalid. Did God bring the Jews to South America or Africa and rell them it was the Promised Land?
What, you didn't pose the question to an Ultra-orthodox, who but a minority wield tremendous power over all things, Israel? Israel is populated with the most interesting mix of Art, Science Religion and Politics. A great country with great People, would wish myself an apartment over the Old City??
I sometimes wish Corey would ask me about my family because they come from Wales. I'll bet there aren't many Israelis he meets who can say that! As it happens, he very rarely finds Israelis who have come from the UK, Canada, Australia or New Zealand, though they are there too.
If you take this video as an example, he finds so many from North Africa, Central and Eastern Europe, France, Asia and USA, perhaps fewer from Latin America. It seems to me that there must be a reason for this.
You are the norm ..........Nearly all Israeli Jews come from somewhere other than Palestine.
Surely its anti-welshism! As welsh are actually the majority of israelis
There was a recent study that found Wales to be the most anti-semitic part of the UK. Not sure if this is really true or not.
@Starhopper I agree. Middle East Report has written a report on it. If he goes to that prison his survival is certainly at risk. He needs our prayers.
Shabbat Shalom ve' mevurach
@Starhopper tommy is a racist slimebag just like your president