Good analysis overall. But I don’t believe China will strike first unless pushed like Nehru’s aggressive forward policy. So the ball is indeed in India’s court.
@@kenkarko5432then what India needs to do is don't provoke China right? But it's not seems like this as Indian stablisment and govt continuously bothering China by closing it self towards West specially USA that should be real concern for Indian people why don't they protest on this against govt as you can change your friends but not your neighbors
@@kenkarko5432 china would pay a hefty price whether it is militarily, diplomatically oe economically. It isn't 1962..we would join American camp completely.. Americans would be much happier supplying arms for decades.. If they can waste trillions of dollars in Afghanistan then think about what America would do for containing china. Indians have abundant of population.. Jst needed to be trained and armed. It would go decades and both countries would be ruined.. and I haven't talked abt sanctions on china similar to Russia yet. I hope Chinese authorities would assess everything before taking steps. Mind it Indians have hardly anything to loose. We have jst started the journey..Many unemployed youth ready to join military 🤗
@@nishantshrivastava9674 --- A Chinese victory will be easier today than in 1962. America's supply of arms is not free, India will be repaying the debt for eternity leaving little for anything else.
Mr. Sawhney, As a Chinese American, I am totally in agreement and respects your assesement in Chinese-Indian Relationship. I think the Neocon (Us govt) wants to push for India-China war. If this is happening, they will be sitting at home laughing at the Chinese and Indian As I said many times, I think Modi will try to push China into the corner, and may caused a potential war. A war with China will not benefits to the citizens of both countries. War is nothing but created destruction, chaos, and suffering for the people of that country. I hope Mr. Modi is wise enough to understand US govt is not India friend and US govt is self serving interests to meet their goal and objective. Neocon main objective in their foreign policies is to create dissension , and to destabilize all the countries around the world.
@@manh9105 Recently, Dalai Lamai said "Tibet is part of China". Does tibetian people look more Chinese or Indian? Do tibetian people have yellow skin or black skin?
It's in PLA's interest to settle borders with India! Unless China wants the Anglo Tibetan agreement of 1914. China and/or Tibet as a part of China ( with whom India has an existing agreement) must be agreed to! 10:09
@@SteveTrinh-e4b Modi isn't doing anything.. Lecture this to authoritarian CCP who has active border dispute with 22 countries. Chinese absurd provocative claim of dash 6 line in China isn't because of Modi🤡 China must know world can't be driven like they drive their population under the their thumb
Sir: I really complement you for not sugar coating the realities. Majority of Analysts on Military/foreign Affairs seem like maroons by hiding truth and creating false nationalism which self serves them. I am also surprised by strange behaviour of our Government which does not show any depth, foresightedness and matured behaviour in Foreign Affairs. We want to grab anything whatever is being offered to us, forgetting the real meaning of it. If Russia is offering discounted oil, we run towards it, if US offers defence deals, we run towards them and if BRICKS offers discounted interests in loans or dealing in local currencies, we run towards them. We want our feet in every boat forgetting we are destined to drown if we do so. We are doing anything which US is wanting us to do. They destroyed Ukraine by making them agree to join NATO. We have lost Iran, Afghanistan and several African Countries where we had a lot of sway. Looks like we do not have any foreign policy and Profit Seeking is the only Mantra at National Level.
this guy said taliban and PAk together will create nightmares for India when US left Afghanistan .... what happened ???? taliban hammering PAk army daily .... Nancy Pelosi went to China inspite of so many threat....what happened.. remember what he said ???? He talks rubbish and his paid analysis from Chine put in trash,,, all he is here to fool the public, TRUST MODI AND HIS LEADERSHIP
@@satendrasingh420 Profit > loyalty = fake nationalism. In America: Corp/Fed/lobby$$$ > govt. = oligarchy colonization. There will be a time when the top 1% in India owns over 80% of the wealth. If you are not in that top 10%, you will go hungry too, like the untouchables....
You are very clear in your Vlog. Chinese are very intelligent people and their leadership is very strong. I understand that the Chinese are interested in business that’s why they are going slowly. American are only interested in their own interests. If india jumped into American side would be not good for us. It’s our concern.
Great analysis! There's so much India and China can achieve and profit together. As the world's two largest and one of the oldest civilisations, there lies the strength in unity to topple the western stranglehold on the world.
1) What are the other political parties in India like? Are they also wanting a war with China? 2) What are their chances of winning the next general elections??
Wrong, China, it's leaders and people are very arrogant, they are misreading the world, they unnecessarily picked up a fight with India & undermined India by backing Pakistan. They will regret it for a long time to come
All this so called tension between the two countries comes from one thing : China's sin of fast development and progress, that proves Indian government's incompetence of developing the country, instead of carrying out meaningful effort to improve people's living standard, they fired up people's animosity toward China. The Chinese government, on the other hand, did not promote any anti-India sentiment in the country, and it can be seen as shown by many Indian vloggers who are living in China. Chinese people in general have a very good and warm acceptance of Indian people.
India is also busy wiping off Ethnic and religious minorities. "MASSIVE, SYSTEMATIC & DANGEROUS" Human violation in India is clearly laid out in UN report 20 Sept 2023-USCIRF
First Jab was trudeau. Second hard punch was "MASSIVE, SYSTEMATIC & DANGEROUS"(just type to find) Human violation in India is clearly laid out in UN report 20 Sept 2023-USCIRF. And Indian still think the blow is from CANADA India got dazed and couldn't believe where the punches were coming from, but can only remember Canada was there! India intotal self denial thinking India was absolutely indispensable to the west as counter to China, that they executed Nijjar on canadian Soil. How can you assassinate on "ally" soil? That punctured the trust. Ego so big that it blew up
First Jab was trudeau. Second hard punch was "MASSIVE, SYSTEMATIC & DANGEROUS"(just type to find) Human violation in India is clearly laid out in UN report 20 Sept 2023-USCIRF. And Indian still think the blow is from CANADA India got dazed and couldn't believe where the punches were coming from, but can only remember Canada was there! India intotal self denial thinking India was absolutely indispensable to the west as counter to China, that they executed Nijjar on canadian Soil. How can you assassinate on "ally" soil? That punctured the trust. Ego so big that it blew up!
Based on what Mr. Pravin Sawhney has said. India is the problem not China. The best way to solve the border issue for these 2 countries is to go back to the old, old map of both countries that they agreed, recognized and lived with it for many centuries before the colonizer came to India. Forget the map that was created by the evil colonizer that they are only too happy to see these 2 neighbors quarreling of what they have created. China India disputes are created by the evil colonizer and if these 2 countries start a war, they the colonizer and their allies will be too happy to celebrate, laughing and to happy to sell weapons to India. How they wish India and China keep quarreling and instead of peace. Peace means both countries have more times and resources to concentrate to develop further and faster, which they the western countries don't wish these 2 countries to develop further and faster and surpass them. But I am sure most Indians don't understand this and still see China as their worst enemy. Sad indeed.
lack of political will. no party will address the border issue because one party will always give away too much, in reality India occupied lands belonged to Myanmar, Sikkim, and others based on the redrawn borders. India can't afford to open that can of worms.
India didn't exist before colonisers came to Indian continent and created British Indian empire. Before that there was only empires and kingdoms. Countries and empires are not same. Empires can be created on dozens of nations anywhere in world with no limits
@@SatpalVerma000 By that argument did China exist before 18th century? Wasn't it a kingdom and empire. Also by your asinine argument does Britain exist as it a kingdom and was an Empire ? Where do dimwit people like you come from?
I hope both parties can resolve this thorn or rather the border issue. Siding with the American can only bring harm and destruction to India. Simply look at what happened to the Native Indian in North America. The ones who help the American to fight other native Indian were eventually betrayed. The American are from the same stock as the British Raj. Don't make the same mistake as before. Don't let USA use India to fight China. Nothing good will come out of this. Resolve the border issue. Best wishes to both parties.
But unfortunately, your crazy Modi is stepping on the wrong foot and keeps stumbling in geopolitical situation. The move he made these past few years is inviting separation from the once cordial relationship between neighbours over a few centuries, long before USA was borne. Indian politicians must go back to your Upanishad and others to understand the confusing world that was contaminated by he Western Democracy ideology.
My guess is by 2049. Why? Hong Kong was given back to the Chinese in 1997 and the Chinese allowed Hong Kong to use the western model to govern herslef but China was the boss. Fifty years from 1997 which will make 2047, Hong Kong is to used only the governing aspects of the CPC. Maucao was given back to the Chinese from the Portugese in 1999 and China let Maucao continued to be govern by what the Portugese put in place but again China is the boss. Fifty years from 1999 would be 2049. Macao will be govern by the CPC. China in 1949 had the 100 years manifesto that by 2049 China will once again be the most powerful country on earth. China would like to have Taiwan inplace before 2049 and maybe there will be no war because in 10 to 15 years China plans to be self-sufficient in semi-conductor chips which will make TSMC obsolete for China. This will give China leverage. Taiwan will have no choice but to aligned herself with China. Another way China can get Taiwan is simple. The trade between China and Taiwan is like 180-240 billion which is 1/3 of Taiwain's economy. China may be waiting for her economy to get a little bigger and threaten to cut off trade with Taiwan which will collapses the Taiwanese economy. A lot of Taiwaenese say that a war with China will last one week, so the hype fo the USA is just fake.
Much thanks for bringing upto date the current situation - I grew in my little country in the West Indians with Indians from age 5 years - and throughot my life I have always taken and interest in all things Indian - I am now 82 and I feel very sad for india - Leaders in India - who could propel India foward are murdered - while Imbeciles are allowed to lead India down the path to destruction - lead by Amerika - What a tragedy fir India - I am very sorry
this guy talks rubbish.. he also said India will get isolated after the US left Afghanistan , he said Pak and taliban together means nightmare for India, today same taliban is hammering Pakistan , sir with China its all about trade , after Modi's Greece visit , Adani will buy ports over there means India gets strategic entry into Europe which Chine does not like, China will never go to War as its afraid India will stop all its ships carrying goods through Indian occean ,economic slowdown , unemployment big worry for China, open Europe map and see Greece, this guy talks nonsense and his place should be in trash can
@@dinks_k1633 You are indoctrinated by the Lying Corp medias. Over 90% of all medias are owned by few of the same people on the same team. It is rare to have an Indian speaks the truth like this man. Indians like you are just 'emotional damaged' by the truth. India's global investment is peanuts compare to China. And there is absolutely no comparison between India and China. Unemployment right now a problem in China, but they are socialist, they won't have people become homeless, unlike in India. Just look at slumps in India, I can tell you slumps in here in NY......
Modi and his racist party is leading India down the garden path.....he thinks he is popular by hugging everyone........he's not putting wool over everyone's eyes.....they know he bends like a weed and cannot be trusted !! Give him another term and India will be rubble !!!
Strongly agree, part of the problem is the current wave of Indian over-confidence. Not to minimize many great Indian achievements but India is getting "way over of its skis" and a rude awakening is brewing.
Part of the problem is Chinese over confidence.😆😆😆😆 Chinese and pakistani must understand that they should surrender their lands to india and bring india into their camp . This will defeat Americans.
@@santhugowda7179what are you weeding? This arrogant behavior of Indians will cost India heavy price sooner or later and USA and west won't come to help mark the words
@@IronMan-nu3rb Bharath narrative entire kashmir including pakistan occupied Kashmir and gb is part of india. Pakistan narrative Kashmir is bilateral dispute between india and pakistan. 🫣🫣🫣🫣🫣🥴🥴🥴🥴🥴😆😆😆😆 Chinese entire arunachal pradesh is South Tibet only in Chinese maps. 😆😆😆😆🥴🥴🥴🥴 Tibet and Taiwan are sovereign countries of the world.😆😆😆😆
Modi best PM ever , this guy fools people and ignore him. Modi is very smart , geo politics all about trade and no leader in the world better than Modi to exploit that , he knows the pulse of every leader
It's not the US alone, every other country is laying traps for others too. China, Russia have traps too. Wise policy for Modi Government is to sense and avoid traps, and go ahead independently like it's going.
Excellent vlog, Sir, as always! India's defence and strategic ties with US may be the most ominous and pernicious thing that could have happened in the past eight years or so. If we see this in the backdrop of the Ukrainian Army's near-decimation in its war with Russia, it shoiuld have sent the alarm bells ringing and red lights flashing with our defence planners and political leadership. It reminds us of the famous Henry Kissinger quote, "To be an enemy of US might be dangerous, to be its friend can be fatal." Our political and military leaderships seem to be a few light-years away from this simple reality. They seem to be existing in a blissful xanadu where none of this should matter. One shudders to think what might be the outcome of a full-scale war with China. .
One Chinese old saying " One does not know how to shed tears until he sees his own coffin" Meaning people normally don't learn lessons from other examples until they go through the hardship themselves.
Well done Mr. Sawhney. People in Delhi are snoozing, they are biting what they don't have the capacity to chew. The Chinese will devastate Indians, diplomatically, economically and militarily.
imho no need for chinese to intervene in india. they just have to wait and look how indians fight among themselves and one group supressing the other and the country remaining weak and poor.
@1:00, …”one China policy is the bases”… Wrong! Historically, borderline issue was the headaches between the two neighbors. Every since India took on its English master’s borderline, India has had headaches internally. And it got worse when india swallowed up Sikkim and Tibet South. All of “Indian” neighbors was alerted and defensive of India’s land grabbing ways. To date, Sikkim kingdom royalty is still here in New York wanting their land back. And China was definitely alerted.
@@TheSoftwareJunction Tibet have been a part of China since the Mongolian rule. In fact, when the CPC took over, they re-enforced the relationship with the only condition from the CPC is that they end slavery in lower Tibet and work towards ending slavery in upper Tibet. The young Dalai Lama agreed and signed on to it. It was the CIA that came into Tibet, bribed, armed, and orchestrate terrorism and when they were cracked down on, they fled the country into India with the young Dalai Lama.
First Jab was trudeau. Second hard punch was "MASSIVE, SYSTEMATIC & DANGEROUS"(just type to find) Human violation in India is clearly laid out in UN report 20 Sept 2023-USCIRF. And Indian still think the blow is from CANADA India got dazed and couldn't believe where the punches were coming from, but can only remember Canada was there! India intotal self denial thinking India was absolutely indispensable to the west as counter to China, that they executed Nijjar on canadian Soil. How can you assassinate on "ally" soil? That punctured the trust. Ego so big that it blew up!
You know, war might be good because Kashmir on Indian side wants independence. Plus Nagaland + 7 sister states, Sikkim, etc...And I think also good for the untouchable soulless bottom of Indian population. China can free them from Indian Hinduism caste system.
If a two front war happens India is going to nuke Pakistan first and then focus on china to minimize the damage. One thing is sure that in this scenario biggest casualty will be Pakistan. It's human nature to beat the shit out of weaker adversiry and try to be diplomatic with stronger.
@@IronMan-nu3rb Honestly, IMO China is not interested. War is actually bad for China as a country who want to do business with the world, peacefully. Just want to be richer for their people. But if is 'forced' like Ukraine war, they will have to. Since India mess with China's internal affair in Taiwan and ignore One China policy. IMO, China have every Right to support Kashmir, Sikkim, etc, but I don't think China would. Truth is, it shows how mature China's politicians are.....I am someone who wasn't born in China and never been to China. But I been to Bombay India in the early 80's. If Russia + China alliance lose, we will have ONE global central power that control the whole world - depopulation comes next - India would love to get rid of their untouchables...As for Pakistan, their military is owned by Americans because we (USA) sent aid $$$ to them. Iron brothers or not, will have see if it happens...
Any Chinese CCP member here...just remember...Ladakh, Kashmir and South Tibet needs to be Feed from India. These locations are of very very strategic importance and matter of sovereignity. For that BOTH China and Pakistan needs to work together
@@IronMan-nu3rb yes - punjab, POK, baluch, all want to be rid of the paki ctrl & mis-rule. not breaking up pak into 10 pieces will turn out to be biggest folly by the modi group. they were only sabre-rattling.
Considering global geopolitics...India needs to align with anti-colonial, anti-imperial forces Russia and China. In that respect China's position on India-China relations is correct. If India continues with its Pro-USA stance...it will be kicked out of BRICs...deservedly.
This is the only indian channel that talks sense. India is the only country going against China and cozing up with US and the West in the BRICS group. It is better for Modi to move out of BRICS and join NATO which is waging a war against Russia. US is a very un-reasonable country, they and the West can attack and sanction any countries but when Russia does it for valid reasons, they talk about sovereignty. Modi is not a smart politician and is already imagining India has become a super power. In today's world neither the West or US can afford a war, physical or economic war without getting itself destroyed in the process. If the West and US go on a war with China or Russia, they will get weaker in the process. So at this stage, India being a developing nation, must stay neutral and take effort to establish good relationship with its neighbours. But Modi and his foreign relations minister Jayashankar have very strong ego's.
Good analysis. PM Modi has fallen into the trap set by Biden during the visit to USA. He got same response in US Congress as Zelenskyy. Biden wants to use Modi in the same way as Zelenskyy as US doesn't want direct fight with either Russia or China but fight through proxies. The ball is definitely in India's court if they want to normalise relationship or go to war for a border issue. Americans will love India to go to war with China. But provocations by India on behest of USA that directly leads to damaging China's interests may also lead to war. So PM Modi has to be very careful. In international relations no one is enemy or friend, everyone cares about their own interests only
Why you keep referering India as a nation in your lectures. I have told you multiple times that India or Pakistan are not nations. They are union of nations. Bangladesh is a nation state based on bangla nation. For simplicity nation states are called nations. Punjab Kashmir Baluchistan gujarat Maharashtra sindh pashtun, Bengal nagas, Tamils etc are nations
Pakistan is a federation... A union is your word.... And it doesn't make sense. Pakistan is based on Islam. So your analysis about nation states etc is null and void since Pakistan was a unique political creation. Israel was close behind and 6 months later they also announced that their state will be based on Judaism. India was confused in 1947 Nd appears it still is. You still can't decide what the world should call you... India or Bharat.. Lol Nehru created the confusion by saying he wanted to keep the British introduced word INDIA... JINNAH protested... But ignronance prevailed and 75 years later Indians are still unsure exactly what their country is called!
@@sabtaingopinath9652 you can name them whatever you want it doesn't change the fact that india and Pakistan are not nations. You can name India as bharat or Hindustan or jambudeep or Pakistan as Punjab or Islamisatan or whatever. Doesn't change nothing. Pakistan is union of nations. Just like India is based on Hinduism, Pakistan country is based on Islam. But they are both union of nations. Union of Islamic and Hindu nations (India has non Hindu nations as well that's why it does drama of secularism in order to keep them in the union). Bangla nation revolted against the Islamic union of nations in order to create their own nation state based on bangla nation and with the help of India they established their own sovereign independent bangla nation state called Bangladesh. Baluch, Kashmiri (both Pakistan and india occupied kashmirs), Punjabi Sikhs, Tamils, nagas, A large number of pashtuns in Pakistan and Afghanistan, etc been also struggling to establish their own nation states independent of union of India and Pakistan. India and Pakistan are fake countries and destined to disintegrate eventually. Afghanistan is also union of nations with dari nation belonging to Iran, and tajik nation belong to Tajikistan. Khyber Pakhtunwa which was annexed by sikhs in Sikh Empire (later annexed by British in British Indian empire) belongs to pakhtunistan. Just like India and Pakistan, Afghanistan is fake country too and destined to disintegrate eventually
@@SatpalVerma000 that's literally nearly every nation on earth. Pakistan is a more organic nation than India.... India is a Subcontinent of nationalities.... That's why Jinnah and many Hindus at the time didn't like the term UNION OF INDIA. It's misleading.
@sabtaingopinath9652 nope, in other civilised world, all countries are based on one nationality or one nation dominates. See Europe, Russia, China, Bangladesh, or American continent (countries based on English, Spanish, Portuguese nations). Whereas India Pakistan are fake countries and mere extension of British Indian empire that was split between two empires based on religions. Just like Bangladesh revolted, baluch and pashtoons, kashmiris would follow and create their nation states one day. They been already struggling for it. It's same in india. Punjabi (sikhs), kashmiri, north east nations, Tamils been struggling for same. You can't unite Arabs, persian, Turks, Kurds, Greek (muslims) or some other European nation Muslims, Yemen under one country system and call it organic. Ottomans empire was union of these Islamic nations who fought against Islamic union and established their own nation states. Saudi has banned Ertugrul Ghazi Netflix series bcz it supports and promotes the Islamic union where all Islamic nations in Middle East are controlled by one central authority and united in one country. It's unreal. For this reason, Pakistan would disintegrate eventually. Same for india.
@@SatpalVerma000 what on earth are u talking about? 😂 Indians really do live in a parallel reality... No wonder the world is hesitant to engage India as a great power. You are a subcontinent of nationalities... Your founders blatantly lied when they said they are secular and India is a proper nation. Pakistan is centred on the ancient geographical location of the Indus Valley civilization... Along with Indus basin and Indus River.... Add Islamic unity to the mixture and it's a pretty robust social understanding. Indians have a very fragile social understanding between the north and south .... Take out the secular aspect and the whole thing comes crumbling down because religion or language alone won't unite India... Eventually the north India will become friendly with Pakistan because the north Indians come from Indus Valley (pak)... South Indians will never accept Hindu domination... Therefore it's wholly possible India is balkanized and broken up... Just like how the Muslim Mughals ruled it before the British came along.
In 1962, America saved India's backside, looks likely it will do the same again. The only difference being, it's not the same China, it's a much more powerful China.
Modi will escalate tension a little bit but not to the extent to start a war. Modi is not that stupid. Modi hope a war between US and China while India sitting on the fence. US too dont want to fight against China but hoping either Taiwan or India to do it like Ukraine. At the end of the day peace will prevail and the biggest winner in peace time is China because China knows best how to benefit most of peace time for its economy
India will always be on the fence, either way they will be left behind just look at their economic growth in comparison to China, hell just look at other Asian nations growth. India is an absolute embarrassment, the west has fked them and continues to fk with them. It’s so sad.
hahahaha, how does China invade itself? The only time China will be forced to reignite their 1949 civil war is if the Japanese DPP govt. declare independence.....Right now Taiwan has a puppet govt. funded by NED...
India should grow up the problem is India is trynna compete with Chinese economy bro y'all are 5th and way to go to get there and y'all can get there but with peace not through war
Plz remember, the army said they were ready to fight a "two and half front war". What happened to that "half war"? India should first honourably settle the Indo-Naga issue. One time during the 1960s and 1970s there were about 2,00,000 Indian army troops tied up in the NE particularly in Naga areas. Even today, there is about 1,00,000 troops and paramilitary tied up in the Naga territories. Can India afford this? This also has an impact in their training and mindset approach to war and conflict.
The fact that the Chinese have not had an Ambassador in New Delhi for more than a year is a very alarming sign. Hopefully our Government, especially the Prime Minister and his close advisors are fully cognizant of the consequences of this diplomatic snub. Most importantly I hope that the Chiefs of the Armed forces and the Joint Chief of all our forces is fully aware of this situation and are prepared for a battle with the PLA.
China gave nuclear & missile technology to India's adversary Pakistan. China undermined India at various international forums like backing Pakistan & it's terrorists.China plays games against India in Sri Lanka, Nepal, Maldives etc On top of it Galwan, Ladakh & Arunachal Pradesh How is it possible to have good relations with such a country
Secretary of state, Janet Yellen made 4 trips to India within last 10 month and America started construction in Indian ocean. Multiple defence contracts r signed.
There can be no cogent reasons available for next Sino-Bharat war not to happen again. That's almost a certainty, though Joe Biden is right to say that Xi Jinping is the last person wanting that war to take place. Just before 1962 China-India war, Chou en Li visited JLN and implored him to avoid war, but JLN was all hell bent on having the war. We all wish history doesn't repeat here again.
@@santhugowda7179 yes yes... even entire china is conquered by Modi ji... Xi is just a rubber stamp actually Modi ji rules China.. even Modi ji defeated USA (may be in a fa#t competition)
First Jab was trudeau. Second hard punch was "MASSIVE, SYSTEMATIC & DANGEROUS"(just type to find) Human violation in India is clearly laid out in UN report 20 Sept 2023-USCIRF. And Indian still think the blow is from CANADA India got dazed and couldn't believe where the punches were coming from, but can only remember Canada was there! India intotal self denial thinking India was absolutely indispensable to the west as counter to China, that they executed Nijjar on canadian Soil. How can you assassinate on "ally" soil? That punctured the trust. Ego so big that it blew up!
India cannot win a war with China even with help from the USA. Did you hear him talk about war with China in more details in another video? The Chinese have the better weapons and the Chinese have a very large hacking team that will bring down the India's top weapons. The war will not be based on man power. I don't think Modi wants war but Modi is from the BJP which is a right-winged anti-China group that tells MOdi what to do. Modi better be smart. In 1962, the Chinese could have destroyed India and rule India but Mao said no, we just want our part of the border. Mao did not want to destroy India and thought China and India could have good relations. This time if there is war, China is going to really destroy India. Indians are too emotional. China has solved all the border issues with the other ocuntries including Russia except for Bhutan and India. Why Bhutan border with China is not solved? Bhutan is controlled by the Indian government and takes the same stance-not smart at all.
@@Indu-uw3nz2rt9i India cannot win. You don't undertsand. China has a massive hacking team that can bring down India's weapons and Quantan computing that cannot be hacked. This war is not like the old days where soldiers are fighting. This war is going to be cyber war, AI, hacking, missile technology, drones, robots, and others--China way ahead in these areas. Chinese missiles are even ahead of the USA like the DF 17 hypersonic and nothing can stop it. China can manufacture weapons quickly as well. India has no chance.
First Jab was trudeau. Second hard punch was "MASSIVE, SYSTEMATIC & DANGEROUS"(just type to find) Human violation in India is clearly laid out in UN report 20 Sept 2023-USCIRF. And Indian still think the blow is from CANADA India got dazed and couldn't believe where the punches were coming from, but can only remember Canada was there! India intotal self denial thinking India was absolutely indispensable to the west as counter to China, that they executed Nijjar on canadian Soil. How can you assassinate on "ally" soil? That punctured the trust. Ego so big that it blew up!
Is disputed land got natural resources ? What is the financial status of ppl living in that area. America is going to use as Ukrainian Zeleskey, will land lease indian land and sell weaponry.
Frankly I have always said that the Chinese are our dharmic brothers and China is hindus punyabhoomi.. The great mountains of Wut Shian and putuo of China are as sacred to hindus as China. The National dance of CCO China is the Famous Apsara hindu...dance...
CHINA needs to take these border regions by force , Indians need to concentrate on lifting whole of India out of the Slums and into the Modern world ... Modi needs to stop taking orders from Washington and give up the land to build bridges with China ❤....
7:05 & 8:56. The first and only maps of India that I ever come across that comes from an Indian that shows the de facto reality on the ground in Kashmir. That is, not all of Kashmir is within the borders of India as is normal in all maps presented by Indians. We see in this map that Pravin Sawhney, though an Indian, is subtly telling Indians that India should stop fantasizing that it owns all of Kashmir when it actually does not and reality check says that India will never ever gets control of Pakistan- and China-administered parts of Kashmir unless it wants to be annihilated in a total war with both Pakistan and China. I am sure Sawhney is deliberate in presenting these maps just to send that message to Indians, not just one map, but 2 maps from him showing an "adjusted" India without all of Kashmir😊.
Don't think China is going to have a conventional war but would work on a Economic & Strategic tactics. China sees India as a future market. They have already been working on strategic move by funding & having project partnership with regional nations.
Sir a lot of things have been happened since your last video.. i am eagerly waitng your analysis on G20 along with canada issue...plz make your video asap. Thanks
Forgets India navy NEVER have a small chance to sails closer to Taiwan island aid Taiwan independence forces in Taiwan island to pushes Taiwan island walks aways from China PRC motherland now.
A very in depth analysis and Col Sawhney is a very well researched Defence analyst .My sense is that India's renewed arrogance under Modi will force China into a another War humiliating India much worse ethan 1962 The trigger for the conflict will be when Modi feels he is losing 2024 elections.Lord grant us wisdom. Col Manjit/ Goa
First Jab was trudeau. Second hard punch was "MASSIVE, SYSTEMATIC & DANGEROUS"(just type to find) Human violation in India is clearly laid out in UN report 20 Sept 2023-USCIRF. And Indian still think the blow is from CANADA India got dazed and couldn't believe where the punches were coming from, but can only remember Canada was there! India intotal self denial thinking India was absolutely indispensable to the west as counter to China, that they executed Nijjar on canadian Soil. How can you assassinate on "ally" soil? That punctured the trust. Ego so big that it blew up!
1. Are you saying IN is wrong in supporting an international ruling for the Philippines ? Then why blame the Americans for behaving like cowboys, imposing their own laws everywhere ? 2. Xi-CN stabbed Modi in the back once, don't think he's gonna trust CN again as long as Modi's in charge. 3. Appreciate your confidence in CN mil. capability, but did you expect IN to take this laying down, without a fight ? 4. On TW, I don't see how IN is answerable to any foreign power except for the well-being and security of her people, just as CN does her own, i.e.: do you see Xi dialing up Modi every time he makes a foreign policy decision ?
One respects this analysis but it would have been more balanced had the speaker accounted for China’s single-minded focus on diminishing India’s growth aspirations and physically occupying large swathes of disputed territory on the LAC.
All information shared here is coming mostly from Chinese media and seems more China centric wherein the intent is coming as India must refrain from doing any progress against China and must abide by China’s expansion policy. Sorry to say but current approach is perfect, wherein we have to show we can fight and China will keep on pressuring India as and when India will strengthen Laddakh Infra as it makes China fearsome from Aksai Chin perspective and then they start pressing issue of Arunachal. So in nutshell,we have to keep strengthening our economy and defence and that will keep China at distance.
It's in PLA's interest to settle borders with India! Unless China wants the Anglo Tibetan agreement of 1914. China and/or Tibet as a part of China ( with whom India has an existing agreement) must be adhared to!
India either withdraw from the BRICS or get kicked out soon.
Also from SCO
Seriously...India should not have given SCO membership
India was 1/5 in BRICS, India is 1/11 in BRICS+. it will be even less in 2024 with another 10 or so new members.
Bricks, G20 or UNO are all useless organisations..Only show pieces. Might is right is what rules the world
Sad to say, I doubt this will happen.
YES K!CK 0UT IND!A FR0M BR!CS AND SC0 S00N IT'S BETTER!!!
Good analysis overall. But I don’t believe China will strike first unless pushed like Nehru’s aggressive forward policy. So the ball is indeed in India’s court.
Chutiye...at least nehru has the guts
@@kenkarko5432then what India needs to do is don't provoke China right? But it's not seems like this as Indian stablisment and govt continuously bothering China by closing it self towards West specially USA that should be real concern for Indian people why don't they protest on this against govt as you can change your friends but not your neighbors
@@kenkarko5432 china would pay a hefty price whether it is militarily, diplomatically oe economically.
It isn't 1962..we would join American camp completely.. Americans would be much happier supplying arms for decades.. If they can waste trillions of dollars in Afghanistan then think about what America would do for containing china.
Indians have abundant of population.. Jst needed to be trained and armed.
It would go decades and both countries would be ruined.. and I haven't talked abt sanctions on china similar to Russia yet.
I hope Chinese authorities would assess everything before taking steps. Mind it Indians have hardly anything to loose. We have jst started the journey..Many unemployed youth ready to join military 🤗
Most Indians are not told of Nehru's aggressive forward policy. I am glad you brought it out.
@@nishantshrivastava9674 --- A Chinese victory will be easier today than in 1962. America's supply of arms is not free, India will be repaying the debt for eternity leaving little for anything else.
Mr. Sawhney, As a Chinese American, I am totally in agreement and respects your assesement in Chinese-Indian Relationship. I think the Neocon (Us govt) wants to push for India-China war. If this is happening, they will be sitting at home laughing at the Chinese and Indian As I said many times, I think Modi will try to push China into the corner, and may caused a potential war. A war with China will not benefits to the citizens of both countries. War is nothing but created destruction, chaos, and suffering for the people of that country. I hope Mr. Modi is wise enough to understand US govt is not India friend and US govt is self serving interests to meet their goal and objective. Neocon main objective in their foreign policies is to create dissension , and to destabilize all the countries around the world.
True.
Dear Mr American Chinese , do you accept the sovereignity of Tibet? If not you are the part of the problem.
@@manh9105 Recently, Dalai Lamai said "Tibet is part of China". Does tibetian people look more Chinese or Indian? Do tibetian people have yellow skin or black skin?
It's in PLA's interest to settle borders with India! Unless China wants the Anglo Tibetan agreement of 1914. China and/or Tibet as a part of China ( with whom India has an existing agreement) must be agreed to!
10:09
@@SteveTrinh-e4b Modi isn't doing anything.. Lecture this to authoritarian CCP who has active border dispute with 22 countries.
Chinese absurd provocative claim of dash 6 line in China isn't because of Modi🤡
China must know world can't be driven like they drive their population under the their thumb
Sir: I really complement you for not sugar coating the realities. Majority of Analysts on Military/foreign Affairs seem like maroons by hiding truth and creating false nationalism which self serves them. I am also surprised by strange behaviour of our Government which does not show any depth, foresightedness and matured behaviour in Foreign Affairs. We want to grab anything whatever is being offered to us, forgetting the real meaning of it. If Russia is offering discounted oil, we run towards it, if US offers defence deals, we run towards them and if BRICKS offers discounted interests in loans or dealing in local currencies, we run towards them. We want our feet in every boat forgetting we are destined to drown if we do so. We are doing anything which US is wanting us to do. They destroyed Ukraine by making them agree to join NATO. We have lost Iran, Afghanistan and several African Countries where we had a lot of sway. Looks like we do not have any foreign policy and Profit Seeking is the only Mantra at National Level.
this guy said taliban and PAk together will create nightmares for India when US left Afghanistan .... what happened ???? taliban hammering PAk army daily .... Nancy Pelosi went to China inspite of so many threat....what happened.. remember what he said ???? He talks rubbish and his paid analysis from Chine put in trash,,, all he is here to fool the public, TRUST MODI AND HIS LEADERSHIP
You spoke my mind, spot on💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐💐 good one.
Insightful comment, wish Indian policy makers take note
What's wrong in putting nation first??
Why should we care about others?
@@satendrasingh420 Profit > loyalty = fake nationalism. In America: Corp/Fed/lobby$$$ > govt. = oligarchy colonization. There will be a time when the top 1% in India owns over 80% of the wealth. If you are not in that top 10%, you will go hungry too, like the untouchables....
You are very clear in your Vlog. Chinese are very intelligent people and their leadership is very strong. I understand that the Chinese are interested in business that’s why they are going slowly. American are only interested in their own interests. If india jumped into American side would be not good for us. It’s our concern.
Great analysis! There's so much India and China can achieve and profit together. As the world's two largest and one of the oldest civilisations, there lies the strength in unity to topple the western stranglehold on the world.
1) What are the other political parties in India like? Are they also wanting a war with China? 2) What are their chances of winning the next general elections??
Wrong, China, it's leaders and people are very arrogant, they are misreading the world, they unnecessarily picked up a fight with India & undermined India by backing Pakistan.
They will regret it for a long time to come
Foreign NGOs will decide who will be running the Great Bharat.😊
Chinese expansionist will be given a bloody nose if they threatened indias sovereignty. 😊
All this so called tension between the two countries comes from one thing : China's sin of fast development and progress, that proves Indian government's incompetence of developing the country, instead of carrying out meaningful effort to improve people's living standard, they fired up people's animosity toward China. The Chinese government, on the other hand, did not promote any anti-India sentiment in the country, and it can be seen as shown by many Indian vloggers who are living in China. Chinese people in general have a very good and warm acceptance of Indian people.
India is also busy wiping off Ethnic and religious minorities. "MASSIVE, SYSTEMATIC & DANGEROUS" Human violation in India is clearly laid out in UN report 20 Sept 2023-USCIRF
First Jab was trudeau. Second hard punch was "MASSIVE, SYSTEMATIC & DANGEROUS"(just type to find) Human violation in India is clearly laid out in UN report 20 Sept 2023-USCIRF. And Indian still think the blow is from CANADA India got dazed and couldn't believe where the punches were coming from, but can only remember Canada was there! India intotal self denial thinking India was absolutely indispensable to the west as counter to China, that they executed Nijjar on canadian Soil. How can you assassinate on "ally" soil? That punctured the trust. Ego so big that it blew up
I appreciate your courageous analysis of factual reality of Sino-Indian relationship
Most eloquent explanation without bias
I feel sorry for India being sooooo UNWISE!!!
I feel happy for Chinese begging for peace with india. It is Chinese being very wise 😉😉😉😉
First Jab was trudeau. Second hard punch was "MASSIVE, SYSTEMATIC & DANGEROUS"(just type to find) Human violation in India is clearly laid out in UN report 20 Sept 2023-USCIRF. And Indian still think the blow is from CANADA India got dazed and couldn't believe where the punches were coming from, but can only remember Canada was there! India intotal self denial thinking India was absolutely indispensable to the west as counter to China, that they executed Nijjar on canadian Soil. How can you assassinate on "ally" soil? That punctured the trust. Ego so big that it blew up!
@@santhugowda7179 Hello, has the British Empire ended its colonization of India?
Based on what Mr. Pravin Sawhney has said. India is the problem not China.
The best way to solve the border issue for these 2 countries is to go back to the old, old map of both countries that they agreed, recognized and lived with it for many centuries before the colonizer came to India. Forget the map that was created by the evil colonizer that they are only too happy to see these 2 neighbors quarreling of what they have created.
China India disputes are created by the evil colonizer and if these 2 countries start a war, they the colonizer and their allies will be too happy to celebrate, laughing and to happy to sell weapons to India. How they wish India and China keep quarreling and instead of peace. Peace means both countries have more times and resources to concentrate to develop further and faster, which they the western countries don't wish these 2 countries to develop further and faster and surpass them. But I am sure most Indians don't understand this and still see China as their worst enemy. Sad indeed.
lack of political will. no party will address the border issue because one party will always give away too much, in reality India occupied lands belonged to Myanmar, Sikkim, and others based on the redrawn borders.
India can't afford to open that can of worms.
India didn't exist before colonisers came to Indian continent and created British Indian empire. Before that there was only empires and kingdoms.
Countries and empires are not same. Empires can be created on dozens of nations anywhere in world with no limits
@@SatpalVerma000 By that argument did China exist before 18th century? Wasn't it a kingdom and empire. Also by your asinine argument does Britain exist as it a kingdom and was an Empire ? Where do dimwit people like you come from?
@@SatpalVerma000really stop tslking nonsense
@@SurendarCasula-bo7gfplease stop resisting new information to your brain.
Good to see there are so many clear-minded netizens in India, though a small portion of people are making senseless comments promoting war.
War will not happen.
India pakistan war will happen.😊
I hope both parties can resolve this thorn or rather the border issue.
Siding with the American can only bring harm and destruction to India.
Simply look at what happened to the Native Indian in North America.
The ones who help the American to fight other native Indian were eventually betrayed.
The American are from the same stock as the British Raj. Don't make the same mistake as before.
Don't let USA use India to fight China.
Nothing good will come out of this.
Resolve the border issue.
Best wishes to both parties.
What do you mean both ? Washington pulls the strings also
But unfortunately, your crazy Modi is stepping on the wrong foot and keeps stumbling in geopolitical situation. The move he made these past few years is inviting separation from the once cordial relationship between neighbours over a few centuries, long before USA was borne. Indian politicians must go back to your Upanishad and others to understand the confusing world that was contaminated by he Western Democracy ideology.
My guess is by 2049.
Why?
Hong Kong was given back to the Chinese in 1997 and the Chinese allowed Hong Kong to use the western model to govern herslef but China was the boss. Fifty years from 1997 which will make 2047, Hong Kong is to used only the governing aspects of the CPC.
Maucao was given back to the Chinese from the Portugese in 1999 and China let Maucao continued to be govern by what the Portugese put in place but again China is the boss. Fifty years from 1999 would be 2049. Macao will be govern by the CPC.
China in 1949 had the 100 years manifesto that by 2049 China will once again be the most powerful country on earth.
China would like to have Taiwan inplace before 2049 and maybe there will be no war because in 10 to 15 years China plans to be self-sufficient in semi-conductor chips which will make TSMC obsolete for China. This will give China leverage. Taiwan will have no choice but to aligned herself with China.
Another way China can get Taiwan is simple. The trade between China and Taiwan is like 180-240 billion which is 1/3 of Taiwain's economy. China may be waiting for her economy to get a little bigger and threaten to cut off trade with Taiwan which will collapses the Taiwanese economy.
A lot of Taiwaenese say that a war with China will last one week, so the hype fo the USA is just fake.
Much thanks for bringing upto date the current situation - I grew in my little country in the West Indians with Indians from age 5 years - and throughot my life I have always taken and interest in all things Indian - I am now 82 and I feel very sad for india -
Leaders in India - who could propel India foward are murdered - while Imbeciles are allowed to lead India down the path to destruction - lead by Amerika - What a tragedy fir India - I am very sorry
this guy talks rubbish.. he also said India will get isolated after the US left Afghanistan , he said Pak and taliban together means nightmare for India, today same taliban is hammering Pakistan , sir with China its all about trade , after Modi's Greece visit , Adani will buy ports over there means India gets strategic entry into Europe which Chine does not like, China will never go to War as its afraid India will stop all its ships carrying goods through Indian occean ,economic slowdown , unemployment big worry for China, open Europe map and see Greece, this guy talks nonsense and his place should be in trash can
@@dinks_k1633 You are indoctrinated by the Lying Corp medias. Over 90% of all medias are owned by few of the same people on the same team. It is rare to have an Indian speaks the truth like this man. Indians like you are just 'emotional damaged' by the truth. India's global investment is peanuts compare to China. And there is absolutely no comparison between India and China. Unemployment right now a problem in China, but they are socialist, they won't have people become homeless, unlike in India. Just look at slumps in India, I can tell you slumps in here in NY......
@@dinks_k1633China afraid of Endia😁😂😂🤣
Bhag bsdk...u dont know abt Geopolitics
lol limited knowledge, pity of pakis like you who sawhney has fooled so well@@IronMan-nu3rb
Modi and his racist party is leading India down the garden path.....he thinks he is popular by hugging everyone........he's not putting wool over everyone's eyes.....they know he bends like a weed and cannot be trusted !! Give him another term and India will be rubble !!!
Strongly agree, part of the problem is the current wave of Indian over-confidence. Not to minimize many great Indian achievements but India is getting "way over of its skis" and a rude awakening is brewing.
Part of the problem is Chinese over confidence.😆😆😆😆
Chinese and pakistani must understand that they should surrender their lands to india and bring india into their camp .
This will defeat Americans.
@@santhugowda7179what are you weeding? This arrogant behavior of Indians will cost India heavy price sooner or later and USA and west won't come to help mark the words
@@santhugowda7179 Surrender??
Pele jaoge tum...vacate Kashmir and South Tibet Asap
@@IronMan-nu3rb
Bharath narrative entire kashmir including pakistan occupied Kashmir and gb is part of india.
Pakistan narrative Kashmir is bilateral dispute between india and pakistan. 🫣🫣🫣🫣🫣🥴🥴🥴🥴🥴😆😆😆😆
Chinese entire arunachal pradesh is South Tibet only in Chinese maps. 😆😆😆😆🥴🥴🥴🥴
Tibet and Taiwan are sovereign countries of the world.😆😆😆😆
@@IronMan-nu3rb hehehe. To pel na. Yaha randi rona kyo kar raha hai?
Hope Modi does not fall deeper into US trap thinking that US will support India in any escalation
Modi best PM ever , this guy fools people and ignore him. Modi is very smart , geo politics all about trade and no leader in the world better than Modi to exploit that , he knows the pulse of every leader
@@dinks_k1633Yeah...Modi is very smart😂😂😹🤣
Sums up for your geopolitics knowledge.
lol , he has got highest civilian awards from 14 countries including Muslim countries @@IronMan-nu3rb
Modi.. just another indian gangster.
It's not the US alone, every other country is laying traps for others too. China, Russia have traps too. Wise policy for Modi Government is to sense and avoid traps, and go ahead independently like it's going.
U only person speak true,
We always wait for ur video.mashallah.
India should leave BRICS!!!
Sco will be destroyed.
Brics will be okay 😊😊😊
Excellent vlog, Sir, as always!
India's defence and strategic ties with US may be the most ominous and pernicious thing that could have happened in the past eight years or so. If we see this in the backdrop of the Ukrainian Army's near-decimation in its war with Russia, it shoiuld have sent the alarm bells ringing and red lights flashing with our defence planners and political leadership.
It reminds us of the famous Henry Kissinger quote, "To be an enemy of US might be dangerous, to be its friend can be fatal." Our political and military leaderships seem to be a few light-years away from this simple reality. They seem to be existing in a blissful xanadu where none of this should matter.
One shudders to think what might be the outcome of a full-scale war with China.
.
One Chinese old saying " One does not know how to shed tears until he sees his own coffin" Meaning people normally don't learn lessons from other examples until they go through the hardship themselves.
Very well explained and I appreciate the unbias narrative. Excellent as always
Excellent analysis. China doesn't want war but will definitely fight when it comes it. And they will fight hard till the end. The only winner is USA .
This clown 🤡 pravin would bring another blog saying how G20 failed🥱🥱🤦🏽♂️
Superb analysis, very lucid and succinctly said. Thank you 🙏
Well done Mr. Sawhney. People in Delhi are snoozing, they are biting what they don't have the capacity to chew. The Chinese will devastate Indians, diplomatically, economically and militarily.
NONSENSE
imho no need for chinese to intervene in india. they just have to wait and look how indians fight among themselves and one group supressing the other and the country remaining weak and poor.
Chinese and Pakistanis needs to Free Ladakh, Kashmir and South Tibet from India
@@IronMan-nu3rb Certainly, if India can take care of its minorities, have-nots and the existing poverty.
@@dinks_k1633 you are talking about, China, a 23 trillion dollar economy, with no slums and the best record on poverty alleviation?
Thank you to Dr Pravin Sawhney ji
A very good video Sir
@1:00, …”one China policy is the bases”…
Wrong! Historically, borderline issue was the headaches between the two neighbors. Every since India took on its English master’s borderline, India has had headaches internally. And it got worse when india swallowed up Sikkim and Tibet South. All of “Indian” neighbors was alerted and defensive of India’s land grabbing ways.
To date, Sikkim kingdom royalty is still here in New York wanting their land back. And China was definitely alerted.
Yeah as if China didn't swallow Tibet. So innocent China is.
@@TheSoftwareJunction Tibet have been a part of China since the Mongolian rule. In fact, when the CPC took over, they re-enforced the relationship with the only condition from the CPC is that they end slavery in lower Tibet and work towards ending slavery in upper Tibet. The young Dalai Lama agreed and signed on to it. It was the CIA that came into Tibet, bribed, armed, and orchestrate terrorism and when they were cracked down on, they fled the country into India with the young Dalai Lama.
@@winchesterlyon FYI there was no INDIA before British... The world respects real history not BS prooagated in Watsupp
@@jeniljebajosin5967 I think you replied to the wrong post because your FYI does not refutes or contradict anything in my post.
First Jab was trudeau. Second hard punch was "MASSIVE, SYSTEMATIC & DANGEROUS"(just type to find) Human violation in India is clearly laid out in UN report 20 Sept 2023-USCIRF. And Indian still think the blow is from CANADA India got dazed and couldn't believe where the punches were coming from, but can only remember Canada was there! India intotal self denial thinking India was absolutely indispensable to the west as counter to China, that they executed Nijjar on canadian Soil. How can you assassinate on "ally" soil? That punctured the trust. Ego so big that it blew up!
Making peace with China will be in
India's best $$ interest in many ways.
Can India withstand the continuous onslaught and afford to be disintegrated?
You know, war might be good because Kashmir on Indian side wants independence. Plus Nagaland + 7 sister states, Sikkim, etc...And I think also good for the untouchable soulless bottom of Indian population. China can free them from Indian Hinduism caste system.
@@loveblindhate9318True
And for that both China and Pak needs to work Together. But is China interested...that is main question
@@loveblindhate9318okay firstly Seven sisters Sikkim are mongoloids and love china more and Kashmir will be under Chinese with PAKISTAN too
If a two front war happens India is going to nuke Pakistan first and then focus on china to minimize the damage. One thing is sure that in this scenario biggest casualty will be Pakistan.
It's human nature to beat the shit out of weaker adversiry and try to be diplomatic with stronger.
@@IronMan-nu3rb Honestly, IMO China is not interested. War is actually bad for China as a country who want to do business with the world, peacefully. Just want to be richer for their people. But if is 'forced' like Ukraine war, they will have to. Since India mess with China's internal affair in Taiwan and ignore One China policy. IMO, China have every Right to support Kashmir, Sikkim, etc, but I don't think China would. Truth is, it shows how mature China's politicians are.....I am someone who wasn't born in China and never been to China. But I been to Bombay India in the early 80's. If Russia + China alliance lose, we will have ONE global central power that control the whole world - depopulation comes next - India would love to get rid of their untouchables...As for Pakistan, their military is owned by Americans because we (USA) sent aid $$$ to them. Iron brothers or not, will have see if it happens...
Any Chinese CCP member here...just remember...Ladakh, Kashmir and South Tibet needs to be Feed from India. These locations are of very very strategic importance and matter of sovereignity.
For that BOTH China and Pakistan needs to work together
Punkab should be freed too
@@karangputih If the people of Punjab wants then...Yes. They should.
Should be CPC (communist party of China). They have around 95m members as far as I know.
@@IronMan-nu3rb yes - punjab, POK, baluch, all want to be rid of the paki ctrl & mis-rule. not breaking up pak into 10 pieces will turn out to be biggest folly by the modi group. they were only sabre-rattling.
Do it if you can😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
americans and western countries put a bait to catch a fish,,, they did this to Pakistan, now they are doing same to India,,,
Thank you sir for telling the truth about China to our Indian friends.
Great presentation.
Considering global geopolitics...India needs to align with anti-colonial, anti-imperial forces Russia and China. In that respect China's position on India-China relations is correct.
If India continues with its Pro-USA stance...it will be kicked out of BRICs...deservedly.
Well explained as Always Sir
Appreciate
Thanks for the careful analysis.
Nice analysis 👍
This is the only indian channel that talks sense. India is the only country going against China and cozing up with US and the West in the BRICS group.
It is better for Modi to move out of BRICS and join NATO which is waging a war against Russia. US is a very un-reasonable country, they and the West can attack and sanction any countries but when Russia does it for valid reasons, they talk about sovereignty.
Modi is not a smart politician and is already imagining India has become a super power. In today's world neither the West or US can afford a war, physical or economic war without getting itself destroyed in the process.
If the West and US go on a war with China or Russia, they will get weaker in the process. So at this stage, India being a developing nation, must stay neutral and take effort to establish good relationship with its neighbours. But Modi and his foreign relations minister Jayashankar have very strong ego's.
He is.chinese pimp
A thought provoking discussion on Indo-China relations.
Assalamualaikum...may I know where r u from? India or Pak?
@@IronMan-nu3rbporkistan
I am surprized that this was not like another Palki- like china bashing. I hope India does the smart move for all our sakes!
Yes India will send you to Xi Jinping in exchange
Excellent update👍🙏
Sir, your analysis is very good and we are free to use your useful knowledge.
Good. Learn from bharath
Madarasa soowar mootra pakistani knowledge.😆😆😆😆😆
Good, clear and explicit summary of the position.
Last time you explained Pakistan has won Afghanistan 😂😂😂, that we have recently witnessed what happened in area of chitral with Pakistan forces 😂😂😂😂
Good analysis. PM Modi has fallen into the trap set by Biden during the visit to USA. He got same response in US Congress as Zelenskyy. Biden wants to use Modi in the same way as Zelenskyy as US doesn't want direct fight with either Russia or China but fight through proxies. The ball is definitely in India's court if they want to normalise relationship or go to war for a border issue. Americans will love India to go to war with China. But provocations by India on behest of USA that directly leads to damaging China's interests may also lead to war. So PM Modi has to be very careful. In international relations no one is enemy or friend, everyone cares about their own interests only
Why you keep referering India as a nation in your lectures. I have told you multiple times that India or Pakistan are not nations. They are union of nations.
Bangladesh is a nation state based on bangla nation. For simplicity nation states are called nations.
Punjab Kashmir Baluchistan gujarat Maharashtra sindh pashtun, Bengal nagas, Tamils etc are nations
Pakistan is a federation... A union is your word.... And it doesn't make sense.
Pakistan is based on Islam. So your analysis about nation states etc is null and void since Pakistan was a unique political creation. Israel was close behind and 6 months later they also announced that their state will be based on Judaism.
India was confused in 1947 Nd appears it still is.
You still can't decide what the world should call you... India or Bharat.. Lol
Nehru created the confusion by saying he wanted to keep the British introduced word INDIA... JINNAH protested... But ignronance prevailed and 75 years later Indians are still unsure exactly what their country is called!
@@sabtaingopinath9652 you can name them whatever you want it doesn't change the fact that india and Pakistan are not nations. You can name India as bharat or Hindustan or jambudeep or Pakistan as Punjab or Islamisatan or whatever. Doesn't change nothing.
Pakistan is union of nations. Just like India is based on Hinduism, Pakistan country is based on Islam. But they are both union of nations. Union of Islamic and Hindu nations (India has non Hindu nations as well that's why it does drama of secularism in order to keep them in the union).
Bangla nation revolted against the Islamic union of nations in order to create their own nation state based on bangla nation and with the help of India they established their own sovereign independent bangla nation state called Bangladesh.
Baluch, Kashmiri (both Pakistan and india occupied kashmirs), Punjabi Sikhs, Tamils, nagas, A large number of pashtuns in Pakistan and Afghanistan, etc been also struggling to establish their own nation states independent of union of India and Pakistan.
India and Pakistan are fake countries and destined to disintegrate eventually.
Afghanistan is also union of nations with dari nation belonging to Iran, and tajik nation belong to Tajikistan. Khyber Pakhtunwa which was annexed by sikhs in Sikh Empire (later annexed by British in British Indian empire) belongs to pakhtunistan. Just like India and Pakistan, Afghanistan is fake country too and destined to disintegrate eventually
@@SatpalVerma000 that's literally nearly every nation on earth.
Pakistan is a more organic nation than India.... India is a Subcontinent of nationalities.... That's why Jinnah and many Hindus at the time didn't like the term UNION OF INDIA.
It's misleading.
@sabtaingopinath9652 nope, in other civilised world, all countries are based on one nationality or one nation dominates. See Europe, Russia, China, Bangladesh, or American continent (countries based on English, Spanish, Portuguese nations). Whereas India Pakistan are fake countries and mere extension of British Indian empire that was split between two empires based on religions.
Just like Bangladesh revolted, baluch and pashtoons, kashmiris would follow and create their nation states one day. They been already struggling for it.
It's same in india. Punjabi (sikhs), kashmiri, north east nations, Tamils been struggling for same.
You can't unite Arabs, persian, Turks, Kurds, Greek (muslims) or some other European nation Muslims, Yemen under one country system and call it organic. Ottomans empire was union of these Islamic nations who fought against Islamic union and established their own nation states. Saudi has banned Ertugrul Ghazi Netflix series bcz it supports and promotes the Islamic union where all Islamic nations in Middle East are controlled by one central authority and united in one country. It's unreal.
For this reason, Pakistan would disintegrate eventually. Same for india.
@@SatpalVerma000 what on earth are u talking about? 😂
Indians really do live in a parallel reality... No wonder the world is hesitant to engage India as a great power.
You are a subcontinent of nationalities... Your founders blatantly lied when they said they are secular and India is a proper nation.
Pakistan is centred on the ancient geographical location of the Indus Valley civilization... Along with Indus basin and Indus River.... Add Islamic unity to the mixture and it's a pretty robust social understanding.
Indians have a very fragile social understanding between the north and south .... Take out the secular aspect and the whole thing comes crumbling down because religion or language alone won't unite India...
Eventually the north India will become friendly with Pakistan because the north Indians come from Indus Valley (pak)... South Indians will never accept Hindu domination... Therefore it's wholly possible India is balkanized and broken up... Just like how the Muslim Mughals ruled it before the British came along.
In 1962, America saved India's backside, looks likely it will do the same again.
The only difference being, it's not the same China, it's a much more powerful China.
Modi will escalate tension a little bit but not to the extent to start a war. Modi is not that stupid. Modi hope a war between US and China while India sitting on the fence.
US too dont want to fight against China but hoping either Taiwan or India to do it like Ukraine.
At the end of the day peace will prevail and the biggest winner in peace time is China because China knows best how to benefit most of peace time for its economy
India will soon find out that there are barbed wires on top of the fence.
India will always be on the fence, either way they will be left behind just look at their economic growth in comparison to China, hell just look at other Asian nations growth. India is an absolute embarrassment, the west has fked them and continues to fk with them. It’s so sad.
@2:08 Those three retired Indian military Chiefs announced India promised to go to war with China if Taiwan is invaded.
hahahaha, how does China invade itself? The only time China will be forced to reignite their 1949 civil war is if the Japanese DPP govt. declare independence.....Right now Taiwan has a puppet govt. funded by NED...
😂 yea india will get raped
Why?? Why India wants to get Nuked for Taiwan?😂🤷♂️
Bring it on China slaughter the cow......!!!!!!!!
How much were those military chiefs paid by US?
India should grow up the problem is India is trynna compete with Chinese economy bro y'all are 5th and way to go to get there and y'all can get there but with peace not through war
Plz remember, the army said they were ready to fight a "two and half front war". What happened to that "half war"? India should first honourably settle the Indo-Naga issue. One time during the 1960s and 1970s there were about 2,00,000 Indian army troops tied up in the NE particularly in Naga areas. Even today, there is about 1,00,000 troops and paramilitary tied up in the Naga territories. Can India afford this? This also has an impact in their training and mindset approach to war and conflict.
Namastye sir, I always waiting your video and explanation of international gio politics and Indo-chaina bilateral relationship ❣️🙏❣️🙂Thanks
Thanks pravin swine. 😊
The fact that the Chinese have not had an Ambassador in New Delhi for more than a year is a very alarming sign. Hopefully our Government, especially the Prime Minister and his close advisors are fully cognizant of the consequences of this diplomatic snub. Most importantly I hope that the Chiefs of the Armed forces and the Joint Chief of all our forces is fully aware of this situation and are prepared for a battle with the PLA.
Share the month please
What an analysis by a great and honest unbiased yet patriotic indian....
China gave nuclear & missile technology to India's adversary Pakistan. China undermined India at various international forums like backing Pakistan & it's terrorists.China plays games against India in Sri Lanka, Nepal, Maldives etc
On top of it Galwan, Ladakh & Arunachal Pradesh
How is it possible to have good relations with such a country
Mr.Swahney, my good man, please let us know when China does not respect "One India Policy" why India should respect "One China Policy?"
Great commentary
With Pravin here, China does not need it's Ambassador...!
Welcome sir....👏👏
Secretary of state, Janet Yellen made 4 trips to India within last 10 month and America started construction in Indian ocean. Multiple defence contracts r signed.
Modi has been talking smack, unable
to deliver in the neighborhood.
Good only war can be declare who is the winner.
I don't think this is reported in India media.
ruclips.net/video/ep07efLE8EU/видео.html
There can be no cogent reasons available for next Sino-Bharat war not to happen again. That's almost a certainty, though Joe Biden is right to say that Xi Jinping is the last person wanting that war to take place. Just before 1962 China-India war, Chou en Li visited JLN and implored him to avoid war, but JLN was all hell bent on having the war. We all wish history doesn't repeat here again.
how does JLN hell bent in "wanting a war"?
@@sureshnaidu201 Read JLN's aggressive Forward Policy.
Modiji and his team are far shrewder than you can think. Our nation's interests are best served
like giving the enemy 900 sqkm without even firing a single bullet and also giving them clean chit by saying "No one entered our territory"
@@jeniljebajosin5967
1200 km right Chinese paper reported india captured 😆😆😆😆😆
@@santhugowda7179 yes yes... even entire china is conquered by Modi ji... Xi is just a rubber stamp actually Modi ji rules China.. even Modi ji defeated USA (may be in a fa#t competition)
@@jeniljebajosin5967 No.. U f00l China has reached to Delhi🥱🥱🤡
First Jab was trudeau. Second hard punch was "MASSIVE, SYSTEMATIC & DANGEROUS"(just type to find) Human violation in India is clearly laid out in UN report 20 Sept 2023-USCIRF. And Indian still think the blow is from CANADA India got dazed and couldn't believe where the punches were coming from, but can only remember Canada was there! India intotal self denial thinking India was absolutely indispensable to the west as counter to China, that they executed Nijjar on canadian Soil. How can you assassinate on "ally" soil? That punctured the trust. Ego so big that it blew up!
Sir great analysis
I am not a Modi supporter but India is not going to budge down this time.
Great analysis as usual.
You are telling what China not likes, but China should understand what India don't like.
Listening to Mr. Sawhney it Looks like we are doomed both militarily & Diplomatically. RIP?
India cannot win a war with China even with help from the USA. Did you hear him talk about war with China in more details in another video? The Chinese have the better weapons and the Chinese have a very large hacking team that will bring down the India's top weapons. The war will not be based on man power.
I don't think Modi wants war but Modi is from the BJP which is a right-winged anti-China group that tells MOdi what to do. Modi better be smart.
In 1962, the Chinese could have destroyed India and rule India but Mao said no, we just want our part of the border. Mao did not want to destroy India and thought China and India could have good relations. This time if there is war, China is going to really destroy India.
Indians are too emotional. China has solved all the border issues with the other ocuntries including Russia except for Bhutan and India. Why Bhutan border with China is not solved? Bhutan is controlled by the Indian government and takes the same stance-not smart at all.
@@PheejThao “never underestimate your enemy “ if you do so the consequences will be ruinous for BOTH
@@Indu-uw3nz2rt9i India cannot win. You don't undertsand.
China has a massive hacking team that can bring down India's weapons and
Quantan computing that cannot be hacked. This war is not like the old days where soldiers are fighting. This war is going to be cyber war, AI, hacking, missile technology, drones, robots, and others--China way ahead in these areas.
Chinese missiles are even ahead of the USA like the DF 17 hypersonic and nothing can stop it. China can manufacture weapons quickly as well. India has no chance.
First Jab was trudeau. Second hard punch was "MASSIVE, SYSTEMATIC & DANGEROUS"(just type to find) Human violation in India is clearly laid out in UN report 20 Sept 2023-USCIRF. And Indian still think the blow is from CANADA India got dazed and couldn't believe where the punches were coming from, but can only remember Canada was there! India intotal self denial thinking India was absolutely indispensable to the west as counter to China, that they executed Nijjar on canadian Soil. How can you assassinate on "ally" soil? That punctured the trust. Ego so big that it blew up!
China got India by the balls! They can play with the waterway sources at the Himalayas, and they should play god to INDIA.
The problem is India's colonial conditioning to please their masters
Your analysis is cogent. Thank you sir.
Is disputed land got natural resources ? What is the financial status of ppl living in that area.
America is going to use as Ukrainian Zeleskey, will land lease indian land and sell weaponry.
Frankly I have always said that the Chinese are our dharmic brothers and China is hindus punyabhoomi.. The great mountains of Wut Shian and putuo of China are as sacred to hindus as China. The National dance of CCO China is the Famous Apsara hindu...dance...
ruclips.net/video/ztInNtdjODE/видео.html&si=W8_f4rGHLrfH8tIj
ruclips.net/video/lD7SBgLvjqY/видео.html&si=ibiPkV0CPSnKW1wX
Stop this nehruvian n0nsense of Hindi chini bhai bhai 🤡🤡
They aren't.
They only understand language of deterrence and thank god we have nukes🤗🤗
CHINA needs to take these border regions by force , Indians need to concentrate on lifting whole of India out of the Slums and into the Modern world ... Modi needs to stop taking orders from Washington and give up the land to build bridges with China ❤....
Mr Parvin China has no sovereign right to Tibet, Xinjiang, Taiwan. Can you explain instead of just talking in air cloud.
7:05 & 8:56. The first and only maps of India that I ever come across that comes from an Indian that shows the de facto reality on the ground in Kashmir. That is, not all of Kashmir is within the borders of India as is normal in all maps presented by Indians. We see in this map that Pravin Sawhney, though an Indian, is subtly telling Indians that India should stop fantasizing that it owns all of Kashmir when it actually does not and reality check says that India will never ever gets control of Pakistan- and China-administered parts of Kashmir unless it wants to be annihilated in a total war with both Pakistan and China. I am sure Sawhney is deliberate in presenting these maps just to send that message to Indians, not just one map, but 2 maps from him showing an "adjusted" India without all of Kashmir😊.
White House 🏡 is hoping wars happen anyway,,
Don't think China is going to have a conventional war but would work on a Economic & Strategic tactics.
China sees India as a future market.
They have already been working on strategic move by funding & having project partnership with regional nations.
Sir a lot of things have been happened since your last video.. i am eagerly waitng your analysis on G20 along with canada issue...plz make your video asap. Thanks
India is heading to war with China? China is ready 24/7 but would prefer to talk and negotiate with India for a win-win solution
How can China and India who are BRICS members be able to topple the US DOLLAR if they will not help each other?
Dollar can never ever.😉😉😉😉
Ball is in Chinese court if they continue their aggressive salami slicing then India is ready to give them a bloody nose. 😊
close nieghbors should always be on friendly terms more so than with another nation that is so far away....
Interesting, incisive!
Forgets India navy NEVER have a small chance to sails closer to Taiwan island aid Taiwan independence forces in Taiwan island to pushes Taiwan island walks aways from China PRC motherland now.
Damn this channel is a gold
A very in depth analysis and Col Sawhney is a very well researched Defence analyst .My sense is that India's renewed arrogance under Modi will force China into a another War humiliating India much worse ethan 1962 The trigger for the conflict will be when Modi feels he is losing 2024 elections.Lord grant us wisdom.
Col Manjit/ Goa
First Jab was trudeau. Second hard punch was "MASSIVE, SYSTEMATIC & DANGEROUS"(just type to find) Human violation in India is clearly laid out in UN report 20 Sept 2023-USCIRF. And Indian still think the blow is from CANADA India got dazed and couldn't believe where the punches were coming from, but can only remember Canada was there! India intotal self denial thinking India was absolutely indispensable to the west as counter to China, that they executed Nijjar on canadian Soil. How can you assassinate on "ally" soil? That punctured the trust. Ego so big that it blew up!
What will be the consequences and results of India china war?
Similar to Ukrainian war.. Only difference is flying nukes over Beijing and Delhi🤗🤗🤗
We Indians hardly cares.. We already r overpopulated..
LAC has been violated by India.
1. Are you saying IN is wrong in supporting an international ruling for the Philippines ?
Then why blame the Americans for behaving like cowboys, imposing their own laws everywhere ?
2. Xi-CN stabbed Modi in the back once, don't think he's gonna trust CN again as long as Modi's in charge.
3. Appreciate your confidence in CN mil. capability, but did you expect IN to take this laying down, without a fight ?
4. On TW, I don't see how IN is answerable to any foreign power except for the well-being and security of her people, just as CN does her own, i.e.: do you see Xi dialing up Modi every time he makes a foreign policy decision ?
One respects this analysis but it would have been more balanced had the speaker accounted for China’s single-minded focus on diminishing India’s growth aspirations and physically occupying large swathes of disputed territory on the LAC.
China should focus on internal issues: highly leveraged property sector, unemployment, lack of consumer confidence.
Mr. Pravin Sawhney can u plz tell ur viewers why u were kicked out of Indian Army!
All information shared here is coming mostly from Chinese media and seems more China centric wherein the intent is coming as India must refrain from doing any progress against China and must abide by China’s expansion policy.
Sorry to say but current approach is perfect, wherein we have to show we can fight and China will keep on pressuring India as and when India will strengthen Laddakh Infra as it makes China fearsome from Aksai Chin perspective and then they start pressing issue of Arunachal.
So in nutshell,we have to keep strengthening our economy and defence and that will keep China at distance.
Sir, thank you for your dispassionate analysis, I hope India can avoid the war although US would want it.
Good video.
Interesting.
Always Good to hear chinese side prospective from CCP man in India
endia is an american prata..
Praveen . Indias support for Israel, means most of world will support china .
It's in PLA's interest to settle borders with India!
Unless China wants the Anglo Tibetan agreement of 1914. China and/or Tibet as a part of China ( with whom India has an existing agreement) must be adhared to!