My husband and I are Muslim (I am a revert) and we moved to Northern Florida and have NO Islamophobia issues. It's a great place to live compared to the D.C. area we came from.
ma sha Allah, brother paul is undoing and correcting the misguidance of paul-- one of the founders of the trinity. a paul for monotheism to sort out every paul for polytheism.
The main thing is God does not vindicate one of these Dr's or theologians with the SUPERNATURAL because there INTERPRETATION is way of the beaten path... 3:7 Surely the Lord GOD will do nothing, but he revealeth his secret unto his servants the prophets. Amos 3:7
@@ElCineHefe Paul inserted doubt where there was clarity. That's why he fought with the disciples of Jesus(pbuh), it's often mentionned in his epytres. Whereas the disciples saw and obeyed, Paul is merely saying he met Jesus(pbuh) as a vision. Yet how was the result, now we can evaluate. Christians follow Paul, not Jesus(pbuh), not his disciples... how they erred so far is obvious. Sure the romans had a hand in it, but saying Paul wasn't malicious in his preaching is also looking at his job in a skewed manner. He didn't preach Jesus(pbuh), he preached himself, and it worked.
@@Ersilay The Disciple of Jesus said, Paul speaks (writes) in a complex manner. The unlearned misunderstand to their ruination. That led to an opportunity for the polytheists to insert their triune gods before the one and only God Almighty. That effect is by design. Jesus himself said, few Christians would be saved. Understanding the parables of Jesus would be just as difficult as understanding Paul, except Jesus explained his sayings. Paul did at great length, which go over most people's heads.
Salam Mohamed A. Please always capitalise all of Allah’s blessed names even if they are in the second part of the word like Mash’Allah. Jazak Allah Khair.
@@rainman7769 There's positive and negative envy... I believe this is a positive and there's nothing wrong with admiring someone's success and supporting them.
I just finnish watching this interview video at 3:26 am. It's very interesting. I slept a bit in the middle but woke up to continue till finish. Salam.. from Sarawak, Malaysia Borneo.
Hello Mr. Paul, I came across your site 10 days ago and since then I have been following it daily. I want to express my great admiration for your culture, your objectivity, and your interest in the opinions of various parties, and this is a rare thing these days. Regarding the issue of the coming of the Mahdi or the return of the Messiah again, I would like to draw attention to the fact that most religions (Islam, Judaism, Christianity, Hinduism) are waiting for someone to come, and they are unanimously agreed that he will be on their side to face the rest and that he will spread justice and peace in The earth after it was filled with injustice and chaos. It is ironic that everyone is waiting for him to support them and to eliminate the rest, and they are all confident that he will be on their side. However, the important question that every believer in these religions must ask is: Am I on the right path in order to be fortunate to be one of its followers?
another brilliant post. Impressed with Dr Ali's eloquence and grasp of the subject under discussion. Would like to read his work on commercial ethics...
Jinn in the Qur'an has to be judged from the following logical, Qur'an based, deduction: Step 1: The Qur’an Says It Has No Contradictions and Many Will Try To Mislead You. 4:81 They express verbal allegiance, “Obedience!” But when they go away from you a party of them spends the night in planning other than what you tell them. God records what they plan by night. But, ignore them and put your trust in God. For God is enough as Trustee. [6:106] 4:82 Will they not then, try to understand this Qur’an? If it were from other than God they would have found in it much contradiction and inconsistencies. Step 2: The Qur’an Is Guidance for Mankind. 2:185 The month of Ramadhan has been chosen for this collective training since this is the month in which the Qur’an was revealed, a Guidance for mankind [insaan], clearly explaining the ‘why’ of every Rule. And it is the Criterion of right and wrong. Step 3: Angels Sent as A Messenger To Angels, Man Sent As A Messenger To Men. 17:93 "Or unless you have a dazzling house of gold or unless you climb into the sky. But, nay, we will not believe your climbing unless you bring a written book that we can read." Tell them, “Glorified is my Lord! Am I more than a human, a Messenger?" 17:94 Yet whenever guidance came to people, nothing kept them from believing as much as this objection, "Would God send a mortal man as His Messenger?" 17:95 Say, "If angels walked about and dwelled on the earth, We would have sent an angel from the heaven as Messenger." [43:60] 17:96 Tell them, "God suffices as witness between me and you. Surely, He is fully Aware of His servants." [The outcome through His laws will prove who is right] Step 4: We Have Arabic Words Translated Into English Except For Those When Deception Is Involved. 6:130Ya maAAshara aljinni waal-insi alam ya/tikum rusulun minkum yaqussoona AAalaykum ayatee wayunthiroonakum liqaa yawmikum hatha qaloo shahidna AAala anfusina wagharrat-humu alhayatu alddunya washahidoo AAala anfusihim annahum kanoo kafireena Yusuf Ali translation 6:130. "O ye assembly of Jinns [Arabic] and men[English]! Came there not unto you apostles from amongst you, setting forth unto you My signs, and warning you of the meeting of this Day of yours?" They will say: "We bear witness against ourselves." It was the life of this world that deceived them. So against themselves will they bear witness that they rejected Faith. We may interpret Jinn as invisible creatures that are NOT HUMAN, MANKIND, INSAAN but if the Qur’an is guidance for mankind and Allah only sends messengers to their own kind, then it brings up a gross contradiction to these two clear verses by interpreting jinn in this way. It is difficult enough sometimes as the same word can have more than one meaning, but if we look for contradictions in our understanding as well cross referencing with other verses, then we can narrow down the interpretations closer to the truth. The four points listed above leaves us with only one conclusion; Jinn cannot be other than human beings. Let me repeat, since the Qur’an is Guidance for mankind, revealed to a man to deliver to men [male and female], to be addressed and followed by men, then when it says “jinns and inns”, it cannot mean another creature [invisible beings] and man.
@@truehikma you wrote all that just to say there human. Here is a playlist of videos to say a different point if your open to hearing. ruclips.net/p/PLWszdKS7reJXAqpOuC449VEPwKnZdCfQj
@@3-Kashmir Thank you for the videos and I will watch them, but I did not say all that to prove they were humans, I used what the Qur'an says to show that they cannot be anything else but human or else you create contradictions between the verses. We know the Qur'an says it has no contradictions and we make them in it by understanding terms that go against clear verses, and we have to look at them and not take what our ancestors have given us to believe.
This eschatology subject is so important for every son of Adam to know and prepare himsf to defend and save from the tribulations the magnitude of which is unknown to the mankind. Sheik Nazar Hosein is very competent and expert on this subject and I wish Mr Paul makes video with him on the show.
I totally agree with you. Sheikh Imran hosein is learned and has focused his life on Escathology it definitely would be great if there could be a discussion with Mr Paul.
What about those lying in their graves……what it helps to know or prepare. Besides it’s all nuclear & in seconds before one can answer the cell phone it’s all over.
The difference between Jesus and Dajjal i have realised is that on Jesus return he doesn't have to tell people he is Jesus nor do miracle to them for them to believe him as the army of the mahdi before the salah starts they will see him coming down, whereas the Dajjal however he will try and get the people to believe in him but doing things etc
@@seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388 To mislead people like you. The Dajjal will attract Christians who believe a mere man can be God. If he says he's the Messiah, God, will claim to be Jewish, do miracles, etc. How will you fair on that test? Will you follow the prophet of God, Jesus Christ. Or will you follow a man claiming to be God and Jesus? One of those choices will lead you to hell. Be wise.
@@seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388 Weird question. You can't figure out why someone would want others to believe they are God? Seems pretty self-evident.
@@seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388 u need to learn more son. Open up your heart and mind. Jesus never founded “christianity”. Jesus always prayed to one God he called Allah. Research it son. May u not go astray till the end.
Brother Paul! Masha Allah! You were a reason for another mu'min and a brother to accept Islam! Subhan Allah! It's the latest video in the channel "One Message Foundation"! It made me happy and thought I should let you know! 😊
Hey paul... I've been watching your channel from the time you had less than 10k subs. It's unbelievable,the growth of this channel. Continue the search of Haq. Assalamualaikum brother.
Great interview Paul.You have been on a roll ,the last few interviews were very fascinating I have really learnt tons of new stuff . Edit: I think these are better videos , we can see a more deep and intellectual conversation rather than a shouting match at speakers corner.
Mr. Paul, I would suggest to you (if i may) to search for the reason why the story of Jesus, peace be upon him, speaking as a child, is not mentioned in the Bible as opposed to the Qur’an. And this is an important topic in my opinion, because it is logical that everyone’s belief in the miracle of the birth of Christ, peace be upon him, from a mother without a father, means that just seeing her carrying that child in front of the Jews will lead to accusing her of adultery and therefore stoning her to death, and nothing will save her from this except what the Qur’an mentioned that the miracle of Christ’s speaking when he was a child with people to absolve his mother of adultery, and if some argue that she convinced everyone that he is the son of Joseph, how did the story of his miraculous birth spread among people at that time (did he himself mention that in the Bible?) salam and thank you for all your efforts
Great interview as always. Thank you brother Paul. BT has reached its audiences. Paul it would be fantastic if you could interview Sheikh Imran Nazar Hosein about Islamic Eschatology and IMF. He is brilliant Scholar fluent in English.
If anyone watch lectures and discussions of Imran hussain about Prophesies by Prophet Muhammad (pbub), he is inconsistent and changing position and interpret the ahadeeth as he wish.
Wallahi that man is probably the most unreliable RUclips preachers, and he is a danger to himself and the those that are willfully ignorant of their religion.
My dear brothers, increase your understandings in every field of the Divine knowledge. Listen more, read more and debate with knowledge. Sheikh Imran knowledge, experience and wisdom based on age... extract what is sound knowledge and leave what is not 'Haq' (right).
@@greencagar1355 Age and experience is not really what makes you a good scholar. I give you one example, in his RUclips clip regarding the Island as to where Dajjal is, is nowhere in any hadeeth narrations, that is purely his opinion. When Tammim Ad-Dari came to the prophet salalahhu alayhi wa salaam, he said, they did not know where they were. So surely Britain at the time was populated and this companion would have said, they saw other people as well. So this is just one example where he he speaks his own opinion. The question is always do you just listen to everyone, what about those scholars who the prophet salalahhu alayhi wa salaam warned us about. As Ibn Thawbaan reported from the prophet salalahhu alayhi wa salaam where he said, "I Fear for you more than Dajjal, misguided scholars." (Buhari)
Keep up the good work Brother Paul, i have watched all of your speakers corner videos and have to say i have great respect for you and your efforts in spreading the Truth of Islam. May Allah SWT bless you in this life and the next.
Great Interview ... I quiet like this channel. As an American Pakistani 2nd generation I don't usually find this kind of intellectual content anywhere other then a few Western Speakers like Shaikh Hamza Yusuf, etc. Paul I would kindly request if you can invite or interview a Western Sufi about Sufism and Tasawuff
How did i listen to this 1 hour 30 min long video... Of course its captivating and paul kept asking questions that actually cross my mind.. Both the Dr and paul kept me hooked.. Keep them coming paul. Good video.
Great video once again brother Paul ma shaa Allah Paul your videos are full of truth and great history of Islam unlike other's who don't understand and have hardly any knowledge on topics when the trying to tell their viewers. Whereas you have done your homework and very informative on the topic discussed. A Mexican brother took his shahada in balboa Park he said he was influenced by watching your videos Alhamdulillah he was at Brother Uthmaan's dawah booth. I've always said your videos are easy to understand the way you break it down. May Allah swt reward you immensely for your efforts Aameen Paul Thank you I really appreciate you my brother ☝️ ❤️
@@BloggingTheology Thank you Paul for inspiring us all i am going to try my upmost best to advertise your channel cos the topics you discuss will help born Muslims and also open the eyes of non Muslims and give them something to think about cos alot of them are not getting enough information on Islam and you also discuss Christianity and the confusion of trinity etc. Love your videos gona share and promote your channel thanks Paul.
Also what we ignore as a huge sign of the وعد , is the احزاب or the six nations mentioned in Quran , the nation of Lot ( which is there already so check ), nation of thamud ( also check ), nation of midian ( check) , nation of Aad (check) , nation of the pharaoh/ abrham (check ) and Noah ( I believe these too checked ) .. all these nations have their characteristics whom we do not study nor observe and they are part of our promise : هذا ما وعدنا الله و رسوله و صدف الله و رسوله
This is who the Shaykh was referring to, Sayyid Ahmad Barelvi (1786-1931). journals.openedition.org/samaj/3410?fbclid=IwAR2R-YZk8B4yjd6awvjCKPq0UK4NWqrl7uTMlIJN3rixRVNuzt7b5AtxD8M
@@shaykhsaif To say the least he was not precise and is ignorant of the history of this issue. In this case he has engendered confusion. It is taken as read by sub-continental Muslims of all stripes - this being highly documented - that Mirza did claim to be the Mahdi at one point so to preface his reference to Mirza by saying "it is attributed to..." and then listing the 2 figures beginning with Mirza gives the distinct impression he is saying they did in fact claim it. We can conclude that he is concedes 2 things: 1. That he mis-spoke re Ahmad Raza Khan - though this is unconvincing. 2. He doesn't know that Mirza did in fact claim mahdiyyat - which explains why he would refer to an attribution to him as opposed to positively asserting he did claim it. If we take his word for it when he says that meant Sir Sayyid, then we can safely infer that he thought Sir Sayyid and Ahmad Raza Khan (ARK) were one and the same as in the video he goes to great pains to repeat a few times that Ahmed Barelvi was the 'founder 'of the 'Barelwi faction/sect' of Muslims from the sub-continent. Even the claim that ARK founded a sect is highly contentious and smacks of ignorance.
Jazakum Alaahou Khairan brother Paul and brother Ali, very interesting conversation and the Mahdi and a Muslim's potential approach to some of the current events.
Brother Paul salaam alaikum what an excellent guest you brought may I suggest to you please find a way to include the reminder button in your next podcast because apparently I have missed many of your most recent podcasts by the span of 1 hour or 2. What is the name of the book of Ibin Taymiyyah that Dr Abdullah Ali translated?
These times kind of feel apocalyptic . The entire world stopped during the covid lockdown, has something of this magnitude that spread to every corner of the world ever happened before ?
Not necessarily diseases, but there have been problems that plagued the world. The 2008 global financial crisis toppled the world economy and destroyed many peoples lives and businesses in nearly all countries. The corona crisis for me feels easier than the hard times of 2008.
@@samwats7892 In 2008 we felt no recession in Morocco because we re always in recession . Other countries, like Australia, were able to avoid it. This feels bigger .
Hmmm not particularly because i think when the Spanish flu happened, pretty sure people thought the same thing at that time, But for our times now i think i can see why especially with LGBT thing quickly gaining uprising which is kinda what the prophet proclaimed/ prophesied about, and with the arab world being very week, then yeah i can see stuff are happening fast.
Excellent talk and discussion. Dr Ali didn't mention Ghazwa-e-Hind (Battle of Hind-India-South Asia), an important incident of the end-times, and how the forces of Khorasan-Hind will assist Mehdi A.S. and Isa A.S..
@@snekjuce That’s true, but he does make some good points that make sense. Sheikh Imran invites people to disagree with him, he doesn’t force anything on anyone.
@@mistert8775 oh don't get me wrong, i love the dude haha. But be careful. At the end of the day we keep it very simple. Quran and Sunnah. Anything else is secondary and could mostly be deemed unnecessary. I only say unnecessary because all else is individual opinion and personal preference. Yes there is a method to reach an "educated" opinion but it still remains subjective inquiry. At the end of the day, there is a reason why God gave us some knowledge explicitly and also left out some knowledge. Whatever the reason is a wisdom beyond us.
@@snekjuce Allah says in the Quran humans are the most intelligent creation of all creations. Believe it and realise the truth. We are that smart we act dumb amongst dumb people.
The Muslim community should be less worried about some savior and focus on working together to make the ummah strong again! No one guy is gonna come and unite the billions of Muslims that are in numerous sects with no acceptance and understanding. As Muslims we should not hope for fairytales and instead work together to set an example for a better world that is free from violence and injustice instead of judging each other and staying ignorant to a changing world. Inshallah we all embrace the unity Allah outlined for us in the Quran.
Shaykh Asrar Rashid clearly explains using the Qur'an and The Sunnah and without personal opinion on the End times. Please check out his videos as they are in good detail. Jazakallah
Shaykh Imran Hosein his Islamic Eschatological analysis andexplanations are based on the Holy Quran and Sahih Ahadith.. You agree or disagree , that is your rights.. He never said that you must accept his wiews blindly..
I would request you to answer this question or have discussion on this please. How is it decided by God (Allah SWT ) that a certain person will be born in certain family with a specific faith, gender etc. By this I mean why I was born in certain race and with a particular social religious background; and is it not an advantage to find the truth as a born Muslim (as a Muslim we believe Islam is truth) compare to a non-born Muslim?.
When it comes to Islamic Escathology it is Highly recommended to read the works of the only Pioneer in the field, Sheikh Imran Hosein, Paul. Read it, critique it, challenge it and see how it deals with contemporary issues
@@MuhammadAli-vp7qt Ma Sha Allah we are awake and the majority are simple sheep. Thinking outside the box is not easy if you been thinking in a box for too long.
Really Imran Husein? That guy will corrupt your Aqeedah in no time. His escathology is pure fairy tale, made up theories with no basis in Quran or Sunnah..and he uses weak hadith in Eschatology. Imran Husein is a fraud, no one should listen to him. The recent talk he did on Palestine is embarassing. 0 minutes spend on the suffering of Palestinians but only talking about his fairy tale escathology.
Dear Paul, I would request and humbly recommend to bring along Shaykh Asrar Rasheed for theological discussions, an Ashari theologian in the UK, and Shaykh Omar Baloch, student of Shaykh Imran Hossein for interesting discussions on Islamic Eschatology. I must emphasise that it is untrue that shaykh Ahmad Raza Khan claimed to be Mahdi. I have never heard this before
Thanks for the wonderful videos sir. It would be great to do a series on this difficult subject (Signs of the end times) with Shaykh Hamza Yusuf also. His insight on the subject is something else.
@@SiMakhlouf22 I am very careful not to miss anything he says. He is just amazing. I recommend him to you and everyone else. May Allah guide and keep us all on His path. Salam!
There's nothing new for Muslims to know in this, but it's informative for non-Muslims for sure. As a result that "Yathreb" was originally the old name of the Medina now days, this term which was mentioned in the Hadith, was a reference to a certain civilized city where Al Mahdi came out from. So, there's a lot of misunderstanding of texts. The term Mahdi isn't a name of this figure, Mahdi is adjectivally his title, which means the righteous guided. The Mahdi isn't the antichrist as many Christians ideologically misinformed, or mean to distorting his image. The Mahdi is the humanity hope and salvation from Corporatocracy and it's modern slavery.
Actually, Jonathan Brown has cleared up his position. I suggest watching the Mohammed's Hijab's podcast episode with him on his channel that should help you understand his position.
The hadiths on the Mahdi are considered tawatur, meaning that so many people from so many different isnads have narrated it that it is not possible for it to not be authentic) for the brother to give the opinion that it is considered weak even if it is a very minority opinion is quite troublesome.
The Mahdi is from the lineage of Both Hassan (as) and Hossien(as). Hassan's (as) daughter married to Hossien's (as) son and the Mahdi is from this lineage.
Paul, as someone who really admires you, I am really disappointed that you did not ask an important question to the professor. If ALLAH (SWT) Who is undoubtedly The Most Gracious and Merciful, would stop rain and vegetation of 1/3rd followed by 2/3rd and none at all before the Dajjal comes. Trust me, there is a very, very good reason for this question.
Thank you this makes he most sense. Anything that is not in the explicite mentioned in the Quran is not concrete, and should be taken with a grain of salt.
We have an entire rich Islamic Escathology Database directly from the mouth of the Prophet Muhammed peace be upon him, backed up by the Qur'an. It is foolish to to not look it up or refrain from everything just for "the fear of making mistakes". The Qur'an was brought down "to a people who think" critically. Humans will always make mistakes, but Allah ordered us to engage in critical thinking nonetheless. We do our best and say "knowledge rests with Allah".
@@mohamedab9033 Exactly, humans will make mistakes. So my trust Hadith on par with Quran if Quran comes from Allah. Even Buhari has had Hadith were he claimed the prophet slept with all of his women on the same night and other weird and suspect claims. May Allah guide us all and let’s engage each other civilly Inshallah.
@@mohamedab9033 Exactly, humans will make mistakes. So I do not trust Hadith on par with Quran because it comes from Humans who error, Quran comes straight from Allah who I can trust. Even Buhari has had Hadith were he claimed the prophet slept with all of his women on the same night and other weird and suspect claims. May Allah guide us all and let’s engage each other civilly Inshallah.
@@mohamedkamara8225 I'm saying the Hadith science is reliable that can sift real reports of our Prophet of forgeries, it's just that we need to go back to it when we're not. Anyways, Dajjal and end times Mahdi reports are a real deal. Perhaps not all the hadiths, but enough to create a robust vision of Endtimes Escathology. It's foolish to dismiss them all.
i don't like to wait for the Mehdi to fix the world if he is real than he will come ,but i ain't waiting for him nor care to be honest. Allah does not change what's in people until they change what's in themselves.
The last line in your comment is usually a misused one. It is used in situations opposite to what people think. The normal state of any people is believing in Allah and doing good, so they are in general in a good situation . Once they go astray and their hearts change, they are condemned by Allah and corruption prevails. Just a note.
1. The Antichrist, according to Mathew 24:4-8 will come in the name of Jesus. The antichrist must be someone who worships Jesus as God. Imam Mahdi will prohibit such an action and will instruct Christians to worship God not a man. (Revelation 19:10) As Jesus himself foretold, the antichrist will be among people who claim to be followers of Jesus; that is "Christians." I understand that they are not true Christians, however, they claim so. Some try to introduce Imam Mahdi as the antichrist! No Muslim can fit in this category, let alone Imam Mahdi. 2. As the Old Testament in the Dead Sea scrolls (4Q76) states, there will be two saviors at the end time, a Prophet and a divine ruler. (Malachi 3:1-2) The book of Zechariah puts it in a beautiful way: There will be a council of Islam (עצת שלום etzat shalowm) between the two. (Zechariah 6:13) The prophet is Jesus, and the ruler is Imam Mahdi. They will work together to establish peace and justice on the globe. Jesus will pray behind Imam Mahdi. He will be the minster of Imam's government. For those who seek truth, I recommend: The Spirit of Truth, Bible the Herald of Quran (www.lulu.com/en/ca/shop/esmail-hemmati/the-spirit-of-truth-bible-the-herald-of-quran/ebook/product-1rvvegew.html?page=1&pageSize=4)
Right, I don't understand why he thinks the Mahdi and the hadith concerning him to be weak, when its almost universally considered tawaatur. It's really odd.
He mentions to protect yourself from the fitnahs of the dajjal you should read the first 10 ayahs or the last 8 and in some narrations 3 ayahs. When all my life all I've heard from other Muslims was the ten verses , so why mention the ones that differ when they are a small minority. And before that implies that the Mahdi and hadiths regarding him are not authentic (which is odd considering that it's considered tawaatur) and mentions that few scholars believe them to be weak even though majority of them believe in the coming of the Mahdi, he really and truly did talk in circles. He himself seems skeptical on the authenticity of the concept of the Mahdi. It was almost infuriating just how much he was going around in circles, I feel like he has opinions that don't match with majority of the scholars when it comes to the Mahdi but for some reason chose to beat around the bush instead of address them head on. And then says that the yajuuj wa majuuj are a people that *apparently* have been trapped. Apparently ???
@@UnknownSend3r Exactly, he was telling this (i'm assuming non muslim) man about differences in opinions from scholars on something that is pretty much factual. I think when giving dawah that is a very bad move because from the non-muslim perspective they will think Islam is a mess and the scholars can't even agree on something basic.
Dr. Ali was honest enough to admit that the currently accepted sunni hadiths regarding the Mahdi are not in the Sahi books of Bukhari, Muslim, and others. He also mentioned that the Mahdi will come from the lineage of Ali and Fatima. It is a fact that the shia clerics in Iran have in their midst prominent members who can trace their lineage directly to Ali and Fatima and the Mahdi is described in great detail in their hadeeths from birth, lineage, to physical attributes and qualities and significant events in and around his time together with the second coming of Jesus Christ.
Imam Mahdi is the 12th imam and he will come with prophet Jesus .. Iran is paving the way for the reappearance of the 12th imam Mahdi and messiah Jesus
PLEASE STOP PUSHING YOUR SHIA MAKE BELIEFS, YOU DENYING THE TRUTH, WHEN THE TRUTH IS EVIDENT....... LEAVE YOUR SHIA INNOVATIONS OUT OF THE PERFECT DEEN
To me the description of the mahdi that shias give, sound a lot like they are talking about the Anti-.khrist. It seems like they are paving the way for the antikrist. And Allah knows best. Allah subhanAllah says in the Quran " and don't become Shias" (don't separate and become sects). Can you imagine Allah warning the Muslims not to break into sects and yet you choose to walk around the world calling yourself a SHIA? The exact word Allah subhanah uses in the Quran, that wich you should avoid? DONT BECOME SHIAS. SHIAS: WE ARE SHIAS.
Also what we ignore as a huge sign of the وعد , is the احزاب or the six nations mentioned in Quran , the nation of Lot ( which is there already so check ), nation of thamud ( also check ), nation of midian ( check) , nation of Aad (check) , nation of the pharaoh/ abrham (check ) and Noah ( I believe these too checked ) these nations are the ahzab as mentioned in suret ص .. all these nations have their characteristics whom we do not study nor observe and they are part of our promise : هذا ما وعدنا الله و رسوله و صدف الله و رسوله سوره الاحزاب ، و الله اعلم
My husband and I are Muslim (I am a revert) and we moved to Northern Florida and have NO Islamophobia issues. It's a great place to live compared to the D.C. area we came from.
ma sha Allah, brother paul is undoing and correcting the misguidance of paul-- one of the founders of the trinity. a paul for monotheism to sort out every paul for polytheism.
The main thing is God does not vindicate one of these Dr's or theologians with the SUPERNATURAL because there INTERPRETATION is way of the beaten path...
3:7 Surely the Lord GOD will do nothing, but he revealeth his secret unto his servants the prophets. Amos 3:7
Paul did not fabricate the Trinity, the Romans soiled the faith with that blasphemy.
@@ElCineHefe Paul inserted doubt where there was clarity. That's why he fought with the disciples of Jesus(pbuh), it's often mentionned in his epytres. Whereas the disciples saw and obeyed, Paul is merely saying he met Jesus(pbuh) as a vision. Yet how was the result, now we can evaluate. Christians follow Paul, not Jesus(pbuh), not his disciples... how they erred so far is obvious. Sure the romans had a hand in it, but saying Paul wasn't malicious in his preaching is also looking at his job in a skewed manner. He didn't preach Jesus(pbuh), he preached himself, and it worked.
@@Ersilay
The Disciple of Jesus said, Paul speaks (writes) in a complex manner. The unlearned misunderstand to their ruination.
That led to an opportunity for the polytheists to insert their triune gods before the one and only God Almighty.
That effect is by design. Jesus himself said, few Christians would be saved.
Understanding the parables of Jesus would be just as difficult as understanding Paul, except Jesus explained his sayings. Paul did at great length, which go over most people's heads.
Salam Mohamed A. Please always capitalise all of Allah’s blessed names even if they are in the second part of the word like Mash’Allah. Jazak Allah Khair.
Wow, your channel is growing really fast. Already at 53k. Keep up the good work, Paul!
Say mashaallha dont envy brother Paul
@@rainman7769 There's positive and negative envy... I believe this is a positive and there's nothing wrong with admiring someone's success and supporting them.
@@MonicaSĪGÑofJõñãhYUNIS I meant it's good to say mashaallha if you Muslim . much respect
@Iyas kelu there is Mahdi whats wrong with that
@Iyas kelu ARE YOU GOD?
I know I'm NOT... Sooo.... I stay away from making such FINITE claims....
Great RESPECT to you and to your guest. Very Interesting discussion. Your are doing an amazing job with your chanel. Thank you.
Great work brother Paul! MashaaAllah. Invaluable content for us western, English speaking Muslims. Much appreciated indeed.
I just finnish watching this interview video at 3:26 am. It's very interesting. I slept a bit in the middle but woke up to continue till finish. Salam.. from Sarawak, Malaysia Borneo.
Hello Mr. Paul, I came across your site 10 days ago and since then I have been following it daily. I want to express my great admiration for your culture, your objectivity, and your interest in the opinions of various parties, and this is a rare thing these days.
Regarding the issue of the coming of the Mahdi or the return of the Messiah again, I would like to draw attention to the fact that most religions (Islam, Judaism, Christianity, Hinduism) are waiting for someone to come, and they are unanimously agreed that he will be on their side to face the rest and that he will spread justice and peace in The earth after it was filled with injustice and chaos. It is ironic that everyone is waiting for him to support them and to eliminate the rest, and they are all confident that he will be on their side. However, the important question that every believer in these religions must ask is: Am I on the right path in order to be fortunate to be one of its followers?
Great discussion, I’ll be sure to watch it!
I love this type of conversation.
47:00 minutes awesome please make sure to understand this point what he mentioned it I hope really beneficial for brothers&sisters
Allah bless Dr. Abdullah Ali.
Many thanks for this nice conversation, jazakAllah.
Thanks for liking
Great interview! And well informed, most perceptive interviewer as well 👏
another brilliant post. Impressed with Dr Ali's eloquence and grasp of the subject under discussion. Would like to read his work on commercial ethics...
I would love to see Paul do a video about Jinn in the Quran.
Jinn in the Qur'an has to be judged from the following logical, Qur'an based, deduction:
Step 1: The Qur’an Says It Has No Contradictions and Many Will Try To Mislead You.
4:81 They express verbal allegiance, “Obedience!” But when they go away from you a party of them spends the night in planning other than what you tell them. God records what they plan by night. But, ignore them and put your trust in God. For God is enough as Trustee. [6:106]
4:82 Will they not then, try to understand this Qur’an? If it were from other than God they would have found in it much contradiction and inconsistencies.
Step 2: The Qur’an Is Guidance for Mankind.
2:185 The month of Ramadhan has been chosen for this collective training since this is the month in which the Qur’an was revealed, a Guidance for mankind [insaan], clearly explaining the ‘why’ of every Rule. And it is the Criterion of right and wrong.
Step 3: Angels Sent as A Messenger To Angels, Man Sent As A Messenger To Men.
17:93 "Or unless you have a dazzling house of gold or unless you climb into the sky. But, nay, we will not believe your climbing unless you bring a written book that we can read." Tell them, “Glorified is my Lord! Am I more than a human, a Messenger?"
17:94 Yet whenever guidance came to people, nothing kept them from believing as much as this objection, "Would God send a mortal man as His Messenger?"
17:95 Say, "If angels walked about and dwelled on the earth, We would have sent an angel from the heaven as Messenger." [43:60]
17:96 Tell them, "God suffices as witness between me and you. Surely, He is fully Aware of His servants." [The outcome through His laws will prove who is right]
Step 4: We Have Arabic Words Translated Into English Except For Those When Deception Is Involved.
6:130Ya maAAshara aljinni waal-insi alam ya/tikum rusulun minkum yaqussoona AAalaykum ayatee wayunthiroonakum liqaa yawmikum hatha qaloo shahidna AAala anfusina wagharrat-humu alhayatu alddunya washahidoo AAala anfusihim annahum kanoo kafireena
Yusuf Ali translation
6:130. "O ye assembly of Jinns [Arabic] and men[English]! Came there not unto you apostles from amongst you, setting forth unto you My signs, and warning you of the meeting of this Day of yours?" They will say: "We bear witness against ourselves." It was the life of this world that deceived them. So against themselves will they bear witness that they rejected Faith.
We may interpret Jinn as invisible creatures that are NOT HUMAN, MANKIND, INSAAN but if the Qur’an is guidance for mankind and Allah only sends messengers to their own kind, then it brings up a gross contradiction to these two clear verses by interpreting jinn in this way. It is difficult enough sometimes as the same word can have more than one meaning, but if we look for contradictions in our understanding as well cross referencing with other verses, then we can narrow down the interpretations closer to the truth. The four points listed above leaves us with only one conclusion; Jinn cannot be other than human beings. Let me repeat, since the Qur’an is Guidance for mankind, revealed to a man to deliver to men [male and female], to be addressed and followed by men, then when it says “jinns and inns”, it cannot mean another creature [invisible beings] and man.
There's an hour long video out (a complete summary about Jinn) on one of the popular Islamic channels
@Yasser I agree with you. I am just interested to know if other scriptures make any mention of Jinn.
@@truehikma you wrote all that just to say there human.
Here is a playlist of videos to say a different point if your open to hearing.
ruclips.net/p/PLWszdKS7reJXAqpOuC449VEPwKnZdCfQj
@@3-Kashmir Thank you for the videos and I will watch them, but I did not say all that to prove they were humans, I used what the Qur'an says to show that they cannot be anything else but human or else you create contradictions between the verses. We know the Qur'an says it has no contradictions and we make them in it by understanding terms that go against clear verses, and we have to look at them and not take what our ancestors have given us to believe.
Excellent production once again my brother, this is real good content ❤️❤️
👍
This eschatology subject is so important for every son of Adam to know and prepare himsf to defend and save from the tribulations the magnitude of which is unknown to the mankind. Sheik Nazar Hosein is very competent and expert on this subject and I wish Mr Paul makes video with him on the show.
Ameen
I totally agree with you. Sheikh Imran hosein is learned and has focused his life on Escathology it definitely would be great if there could be a discussion with Mr Paul.
What about those lying in their graves……what it helps to know or prepare. Besides it’s all nuclear & in seconds before one can answer the cell phone it’s all over.
Why do you think no muslim teachers are speaking out about the snake oil?
@@jeyjmohamed4181 Asrar Rashid videos on Islamic end times is the most clear and concise based on the Qur'an and the Sunnah.
The difference between Jesus and Dajjal i have realised is that on Jesus return he doesn't have to tell people he is Jesus nor do miracle to them for them to believe him as the army of the mahdi before the salah starts they will see him coming down, whereas the Dajjal however he will try and get the people to believe in him but doing things etc
@@seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388 To mislead people like you. The Dajjal will attract Christians who believe a mere man can be God. If he says he's the Messiah, God, will claim to be Jewish, do miracles, etc. How will you fair on that test? Will you follow the prophet of God, Jesus Christ. Or will you follow a man claiming to be God and Jesus? One of those choices will lead you to hell. Be wise.
@@seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388 Weird question. You can't figure out why someone would want others to believe they are God? Seems pretty self-evident.
@@seekthetruthandthetruthwil2388 u need to learn more son. Open up your heart and mind. Jesus never founded “christianity”. Jesus always prayed to one God he called Allah. Research it son. May u not go astray till the end.
Even mahdi willn't announce to anyone that he's mahdi, people will recognise him.
ruclips.net/video/5St3JocJIVY/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/6rFRhhNwc3o/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/Y7z0yb08zTI/видео.html
Thanks Paul,it has been a very educational and constructive session.Greetings from Turkey.
Glad it was helpful!
Y
This was amazing. Thank you.
great video Paul! Loved it. God Bless you!
Great discussion, very informative 👍
Brother Paul! Masha Allah! You were a reason for another mu'min and a brother to accept Islam! Subhan Allah!
It's the latest video in the channel "One Message Foundation"! It made me happy and thought I should let you know! 😊
thanks!
@@BloggingTheology mubarakallah ❤️
Could you please share the video link?I love listening to reversion stories
is he muslim ?
@@starscream5055 he did the shahadah alhamdulillah.
May Allah guide us to the straight path and give us the patience and courage to stay on it.
Hey paul... I've been watching your channel from the time you had less than 10k subs. It's unbelievable,the growth of this channel. Continue the search of Haq. Assalamualaikum brother.
Great discussion, Thanks Paul.
Great interview Paul.You have been on a roll ,the last few interviews were very fascinating I have really learnt tons of new stuff .
Edit: I think these are better videos , we can see a more deep and intellectual conversation rather than a shouting match at speakers corner.
Very much so agreed on the institutional oppressiveness. It is almost crippling how strong such forces can be on an individual and a family level.
Mr. Paul, I would suggest to you (if i may) to search for the reason why the story of Jesus, peace be upon him, speaking as a child, is not mentioned in the Bible as opposed to the Qur’an. And this is an important topic in my opinion, because it is logical that everyone’s belief in the miracle of the birth of Christ, peace be upon him, from a mother without a father, means that just seeing her carrying that child in front of the Jews will lead to accusing her of adultery and therefore stoning her to death, and nothing will save her from this except what the Qur’an mentioned that the miracle of Christ’s speaking when he was a child with people to absolve his mother of adultery, and if some argue that she convinced everyone that he is the son of Joseph, how did the story of his miraculous birth spread among people at that time (did he himself mention that in the Bible?)
salam and thank you for all your efforts
Woah very good point! Well done
Haven’t thought about that myself!
It's mentioned in the lost gospel of Thomas that the baby Jesus (saws) spoke, a copy was recently found in a priest's grave.
Enlightening and comprehensively informative..thank you both!
Subhaan Allah! Share this around the world! in shaa Allah
Gog and Magog have been released. Since the time of the Prophet SAW.
Alhamdulillah Tq Paul.
what a great teacher man i m impressed
Thank you brother for this
Great interview as always. Thank you brother Paul. BT has reached its audiences. Paul it would be fantastic if you could interview Sheikh Imran Nazar Hosein about Islamic Eschatology and IMF. He is brilliant Scholar fluent in English.
If anyone watch lectures and discussions of Imran hussain about Prophesies by Prophet Muhammad (pbub), he is inconsistent and changing position and interpret the ahadeeth as he wish.
Wallahi that man is probably the most unreliable RUclips preachers, and he is a danger to himself and the those that are willfully ignorant of their religion.
I can't agree with both brothers regarding Imran Hussain, very inconsistent, comes up with his own opinions. He is also pro Shia.
My dear brothers, increase your understandings in every field of the Divine knowledge. Listen more, read more and debate with knowledge. Sheikh Imran knowledge, experience and wisdom based on age... extract what is sound knowledge and leave what is not 'Haq' (right).
@@greencagar1355
Age and experience is not really what makes you a good scholar. I give you one example, in his RUclips clip regarding the Island as to where Dajjal is, is nowhere in any hadeeth narrations, that is purely his opinion. When Tammim Ad-Dari came to the prophet salalahhu alayhi wa salaam, he said, they did not know where they were. So surely Britain at the time was populated and this companion would have said, they saw other people as well. So this is just one example where he he speaks his own opinion. The question is always do you just listen to everyone, what about those scholars who the prophet salalahhu alayhi wa salaam warned us about. As Ibn Thawbaan reported from the prophet salalahhu alayhi wa salaam where he said, "I Fear for you more than Dajjal, misguided scholars."
(Buhari)
Keep up the good work Brother Paul, i have watched all of your speakers corner videos and have to say i have great respect for you and your efforts in spreading the Truth of Islam.
May Allah SWT bless you in this life and the next.
Brother Paul we appreciate your hard work educating us about some important subject
Jazakallah khayran brothers 🇵🇰
Great Interview ... I quiet like this channel. As an American Pakistani 2nd generation I don't usually find this kind of intellectual content anywhere other then a few Western Speakers like Shaikh Hamza Yusuf, etc. Paul I would kindly request if you can invite or interview a Western Sufi about Sufism and Tasawuff
How did i listen to this 1 hour 30 min long video... Of course its captivating and paul kept asking questions that actually cross my mind.. Both the Dr and paul kept me hooked.. Keep them coming paul. Good video.
❤️
What a beautiful video!
Thank you Mr Paul for this great and interesting discussion. May God reward you well in both lifes for the good things that you do. Nice continuation.
Great video once again brother Paul ma shaa Allah Paul your videos are full of truth and great history of Islam unlike other's who don't understand and have hardly any knowledge on topics when the trying to tell their viewers. Whereas you have done your homework and very informative on the topic discussed. A Mexican brother took his shahada in balboa Park he said he was influenced by watching your videos Alhamdulillah he was at Brother Uthmaan's dawah booth. I've always said your videos are easy to understand the way you break it down. May Allah swt reward you immensely for your efforts Aameen Paul Thank you I really appreciate you my brother ☝️ ❤️
Thank you Samir!
@@BloggingTheology Thank you Paul for inspiring us all i am going to try my upmost best to advertise your channel cos the topics you discuss will help born Muslims and also open the eyes of non Muslims and give them something to think about cos alot of them are not getting enough information on Islam and you also discuss Christianity and the confusion of trinity etc. Love your videos gona share and promote your channel thanks Paul.
@@samhadiliya Thank you again!
There is something in surah kahaf, a msg that can enlighten us about the dajjal. It has to be read and reread with deep understanding to gain insight.
Tigris river is drying up sadly, there are in fact documentaries of it on RUclips itself
Also what we ignore as a huge sign of the وعد , is the احزاب or the six nations mentioned in Quran , the nation of Lot ( which is there already so check ), nation of thamud ( also check ), nation of midian ( check) , nation of Aad (check) , nation of the pharaoh/ abrham (check ) and Noah ( I believe these too checked ) .. all these nations have their characteristics whom we do not study nor observe and they are part of our promise : هذا ما وعدنا الله و رسوله و صدف الله و رسوله
Can you please provide the reference where Ahmed Raza Khan (Barelvi) claimed to be Mahdi? This is the first time I heard this point.
The shaykh has been contacted and has acknowledged it was a mistake and he intended to say sayyid ahmad khan ( different person entirely)
@@Waqarali-rs1mc he needs to publish a retraction; his claim that he was referring to Sir Sayyid is implausible.
This is who the Shaykh was referring to, Sayyid Ahmad Barelvi (1786-1931).
journals.openedition.org/samaj/3410?fbclid=IwAR2R-YZk8B4yjd6awvjCKPq0UK4NWqrl7uTMlIJN3rixRVNuzt7b5AtxD8M
@@shaykhsaif
To say the least he was not precise and is ignorant of the history of this issue. In this case he has engendered confusion.
It is taken as read by sub-continental Muslims of all stripes - this being highly documented - that Mirza did claim to be the Mahdi at one point so to preface his reference to Mirza by saying "it is attributed to..." and then listing the 2 figures beginning with Mirza gives the distinct impression he is saying they did in fact claim it.
We can conclude that he is concedes 2 things:
1. That he mis-spoke re Ahmad Raza Khan - though this is unconvincing.
2. He doesn't know that Mirza did in fact claim mahdiyyat - which explains why he would refer to an attribution to him as opposed to positively asserting he did claim it.
If we take his word for it when he says that meant Sir Sayyid, then we can safely infer that he thought Sir Sayyid and Ahmad Raza Khan (ARK) were one and the same as in the video he goes to great pains to repeat a few times that Ahmed Barelvi was the 'founder 'of the 'Barelwi faction/sect' of Muslims from the sub-continent. Even the claim that ARK founded a sect is highly contentious and smacks of ignorance.
Excellent. Soon insha'Allah
Great interview!
Brother Paul, The top 5 Sunni books and all Shia books say follow the Quran and the Alhul-Albayt and you shall never go astray.
Jazakum Alaahou Khairan brother Paul and brother Ali, very interesting conversation and the Mahdi and a Muslim's potential approach to some of the current events.
Awesome content brother Paul 👍
Thanks brother Paul. Very informative. Could you invite Yasir Qadhi and Hamza Yusuf in your channel please
I will try
Not YQ he is spreading fitna in the community and making the emotional Christian and the Islamphobi happy
The Maliki legend has finally come😤
Divisive!
@@Leah-zg7mv Naah
@@zaidan296 very divisive comment
Wjp cares what's his mazhab? Like muslims need this now
@@Leah-zg7mv maddhab. stop with your bid'ah and pronounce the letter properly
@@salim4512 right. So what's what's deal with the maliki business?
Thank you very much coming up with this topic since we are living in the end of times
Assalamu Alaykum Paul: I enjoy ur channel Mashallah.🥰 Please keep up the great work.
Thank you so much 😊
Keep up the good work, sir!
I really like your act of drinking water using the right hand!
Brother Paul salaam alaikum what an excellent guest you brought may I suggest to you please find a way to include the reminder button in your next podcast because apparently I have missed many of your most recent podcasts by the span of 1 hour or 2. What is the name of the book of Ibin Taymiyyah that Dr Abdullah Ali translated?
lamppostedu.org/in-defence
I am learning lots from your channel
Thanks
Mashallah so much knowledge
Brother Paul...
It would be interesting to have Rabbi Singer on your channel with Dr. Ali Ataie to discuss theology and etc.
*_Hopefully, Sheikh Zaid Shakir, Sheikh Hatem Bazian and Sheikh Hamza Yusuf Hanson, all from Zaytuna College will follow as guests in BT._*
❤️
Thanks Paul, could you interview/ discuss this topic with Sheikh Imran Hussain?
These times kind of feel apocalyptic . The entire world stopped during the covid lockdown, has something of this magnitude that spread to every corner of the world ever happened before ?
Not necessarily diseases, but there have been problems that plagued the world. The 2008 global financial crisis toppled the world economy and destroyed many peoples lives and businesses in nearly all countries. The corona crisis for me feels easier than the hard times of 2008.
@@samwats7892 In 2008 we felt no recession in Morocco because we re always in recession . Other countries, like Australia, were able to avoid it. This feels bigger .
Hmmm not particularly because i think when the Spanish flu happened, pretty sure people thought the same thing at that time,
But for our times now i think i can see why especially with LGBT thing quickly gaining uprising which is kinda what the prophet proclaimed/ prophesied about, and with the arab world being very week, then yeah i can see stuff are happening fast.
Very interesting discussion
Yajooj Majooj have been released long time ago. The last wave will be at the time of Isa AS.
Stop spreading false news
ruclips.net/video/5St3JocJIVY/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/6rFRhhNwc3o/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/Y7z0yb08zTI/видео.html
They pierced a hole during the time of the Prophet Muhammad may Allah's peace and blessings be upon him.
@@jackwilliam2965 yeah and?
nope. reports indicate that they will be released after jesus. no proof of them being released before that.
People of faith need to stick together! And fight for the values determined by GOD
Excellent talk and discussion. Dr Ali didn't mention Ghazwa-e-Hind (Battle of Hind-India-South Asia), an important incident of the end-times, and how the forces of Khorasan-Hind will assist Mehdi A.S. and Isa A.S..
Loving the content brothers
Dr. Ali does a great job, another person to listen to is Sh. Imran Hosein, he has an interesting perspective on eschatology.
yea but take what anyone says with a grain of salt, he too has some pretty farfetched opinions.
@@snekjuce That’s true, but he does make some good points that make sense. Sheikh Imran invites people to disagree with him, he doesn’t force anything on anyone.
@@mistert8775 oh don't get me wrong, i love the dude haha. But be careful. At the end of the day we keep it very simple. Quran and Sunnah. Anything else is secondary and could mostly be deemed unnecessary. I only say unnecessary because all else is individual opinion and personal preference. Yes there is a method to reach an "educated" opinion but it still remains subjective inquiry. At the end of the day, there is a reason why God gave us some knowledge explicitly and also left out some knowledge. Whatever the reason is a wisdom beyond us.
ruclips.net/video/5St3JocJIVY/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/6rFRhhNwc3o/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/Y7z0yb08zTI/видео.html
@@snekjuce Allah says in the Quran humans are the most intelligent creation of all creations. Believe it and realise the truth. We are that smart we act dumb amongst dumb people.
Amazing to see my Fav. Shaikh.
The Muslim community should be less worried about some savior and focus on working together to make the ummah strong again! No one guy is gonna come and unite the billions of Muslims that are in numerous sects with no acceptance and understanding. As Muslims we should not hope for fairytales and instead work together to set an example for a better world that is free from violence and injustice instead of judging each other and staying ignorant to a changing world. Inshallah we all embrace the unity Allah outlined for us in the Quran.
What do you mean by "Fairytales?" Imam Mehdi ( A.S ) is real and he is going to come in the future.
Utopia....
Shaykh Asrar Rashid clearly explains using the Qur'an and The Sunnah and without personal opinion on the End times.
Please check out his videos as they are in good detail.
Jazakallah
On eschatology you should Invite Sheikh Imran hossein.
He talks out his back side you are a fool if you follow him
Shaykh Imran Hosein his Islamic Eschatological analysis andexplanations are based on the Holy Quran and Sahih Ahadith..
You agree or disagree , that is your rights..
He never said that you must accept his wiews blindly..
ruclips.net/video/F18C1fzcgM8/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/5St3JocJIVY/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/6rFRhhNwc3o/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/Y7z0yb08zTI/видео.html
I would request you to answer this question or have discussion on this please. How is it decided by God (Allah SWT ) that a certain person will be born in certain family with a specific faith, gender etc. By this I mean why I was born in certain race and with a particular social religious background; and is it not an advantage to find the truth as a born Muslim (as a Muslim we believe Islam is truth) compare to a non-born Muslim?.
Paul is thirsty for knowledge.
I'd love to see a discussion between Paul and Shaykh Asrar Rashid
When it comes to Islamic Escathology it is Highly recommended to read the works of the only Pioneer in the field, Sheikh Imran Hosein, Paul.
Read it, critique it, challenge it and see how it deals with contemporary issues
ruclips.net/video/5St3JocJIVY/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/6rFRhhNwc3o/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/Y7z0yb08zTI/видео.html
Imran Hosein methodology is spot on.
@@jackwilliam2965 rightly said..
But it is so sad that Islamic scholars/ Muslims doesn't want to learn from him..
@@MuhammadAli-vp7qt Ma Sha Allah we are awake and the majority are simple sheep. Thinking outside the box is not easy if you been thinking in a box for too long.
Really Imran Husein? That guy will corrupt your Aqeedah in no time. His escathology is pure fairy tale, made up theories with no basis in Quran or Sunnah..and he uses weak hadith in Eschatology. Imran Husein is a fraud, no one should listen to him. The recent talk he did on Palestine is embarassing. 0 minutes spend on the suffering of Palestinians but only talking about his fairy tale escathology.
Dear Paul,
I would request and humbly recommend to bring along Shaykh Asrar Rasheed for theological discussions, an Ashari theologian in the UK, and Shaykh Omar Baloch, student of Shaykh Imran Hossein for interesting discussions on Islamic Eschatology.
I must emphasise that it is untrue that shaykh Ahmad Raza Khan claimed to be Mahdi. I have never heard this before
Thanks for the wonderful videos sir. It would be great to do a series on this difficult subject (Signs of the end times) with Shaykh Hamza Yusuf also. His insight on the subject is something else.
You better be careful by listening to hamza yusuf
@@SiMakhlouf22 afraid of possibly listening to the truth?
@@SiMakhlouf22 I am very careful not to miss anything he says. He is just amazing. I recommend him to you and everyone else. May Allah guide and keep us all on His path. Salam!
@@kifanebki waleikom salem
Plz add subtitles to your videos
The fact that Dr's are struggling to do there job with integrity is a real concern to us all.
Explain
What’s more concerning is your misuse of “there”
@@kalkhaldi80 Thank you for your English lesson. As if making a mistake is so much concern to you, go and read a book you nerd.
@@jackwilliam2965 🤓
Tha k u for hardwork
There's nothing new for Muslims to know in this, but it's informative for non-Muslims for sure.
As a result that "Yathreb" was originally the old name of the Medina now days, this term which was mentioned in the Hadith, was a reference to a certain civilized city where Al Mahdi came out from. So, there's a lot of misunderstanding of texts.
The term Mahdi isn't a name of this figure, Mahdi is adjectivally his title, which means the righteous guided.
The Mahdi isn't the antichrist as many Christians ideologically misinformed, or mean to distorting his image.
The Mahdi is the humanity hope and salvation from Corporatocracy and it's modern slavery.
Any English literature I can refer to? Thanks.
@@nycguycpt What do you by English literature?
@@joyfulfrequencies5391 sorry my comment was not clear. Looking for books on this subject in English. Thanks.
Actually, Jonathan Brown has cleared up his position. I suggest watching the Mohammed's Hijab's podcast episode with him on his channel that should help you understand his position.
If you are not able to do Hijra at least move to the country side. - Sheikh Imran Hossein
I always point your videos out to my non Muslim friends in hopes they find Islam interesting.
The hadiths on the Mahdi are considered tawatur, meaning that so many people from so many different isnads have narrated it that it is not possible for it to not be authentic) for the brother to give the opinion that it is considered weak even if it is a very minority opinion is quite troublesome.
I invite everyone of you to listen Muslim Scholars please don't skip it
The Mahdi is from the lineage of Both Hassan (as) and Hossien(as). Hassan's (as) daughter married to Hossien's (as) son and the Mahdi is from this lineage.
where are you getting this from?
Paul, as someone who really admires you, I am really disappointed that you did not ask an important question to the professor.
If ALLAH (SWT) Who is undoubtedly The Most Gracious and Merciful, would stop rain and vegetation of 1/3rd followed by 2/3rd and none at all before the Dajjal comes.
Trust me, there is a very, very good reason for this question.
No one know the future except Allah. Even Prophets don't have this power, otherwise will be mentioned in Quran.
Thank you this makes he most sense. Anything that is not in the explicite mentioned in the Quran is not concrete, and should be taken with a grain of salt.
We have an entire rich Islamic Escathology Database directly from the mouth of the Prophet Muhammed peace be upon him, backed up by the Qur'an.
It is foolish to to not look it up or refrain from everything just for "the fear of making mistakes". The Qur'an was brought down "to a people who think" critically. Humans will always make mistakes, but Allah ordered us to engage in critical thinking nonetheless.
We do our best and say "knowledge rests with Allah".
@@mohamedab9033 Exactly, humans will make mistakes. So my trust Hadith on par with Quran if Quran comes from Allah. Even Buhari has had Hadith were he claimed the prophet slept with all of his women on the same night and other weird and suspect claims. May Allah guide us all and let’s engage each other civilly Inshallah.
@@mohamedab9033 Exactly, humans will make mistakes. So I do not trust Hadith on par with Quran because it comes from Humans who error, Quran comes straight from Allah who I can trust. Even Buhari has had Hadith were he claimed the prophet slept with all of his women on the same night and other weird and suspect claims. May Allah guide us all and let’s engage each other civilly Inshallah.
@@mohamedkamara8225 I'm saying the Hadith science is reliable that can sift real reports of our Prophet of forgeries, it's just that we need to go back to it when we're not.
Anyways, Dajjal and end times Mahdi reports are a real deal. Perhaps not all the hadiths, but enough to create a robust vision of Endtimes Escathology. It's foolish to dismiss them all.
Need another interview with the Dr about his economics work.
i don't like to wait for the Mehdi to fix the world if he is real than he will come ,but i ain't waiting for him nor care to be honest. Allah does not change what's in people until they change what's in themselves.
The last line in your comment is usually a misused one. It is used in situations opposite to what people think. The normal state of any people is believing in Allah and doing good, so they are in general in a good situation . Once they go astray and their hearts change, they are condemned by Allah and corruption prevails. Just a note.
1. The Antichrist, according to Mathew 24:4-8 will come in the name of Jesus. The antichrist must be someone who worships Jesus as God. Imam Mahdi will prohibit such an action and will instruct Christians to worship God not a man. (Revelation 19:10) As Jesus himself foretold, the antichrist will be among people who claim to be followers of Jesus; that is "Christians." I understand that they are not true Christians, however, they claim so. Some try to introduce Imam Mahdi as the antichrist! No Muslim can fit in this category, let alone Imam Mahdi.
2. As the Old Testament in the Dead Sea scrolls (4Q76) states, there will be two saviors at the end time, a Prophet and a divine ruler. (Malachi 3:1-2) The book of Zechariah puts it in a beautiful way: There will be a council of Islam (עצת שלום etzat shalowm) between the two. (Zechariah 6:13) The prophet is Jesus, and the ruler is Imam Mahdi. They will work together to establish peace and justice on the globe. Jesus will pray behind Imam Mahdi. He will be the minster of Imam's government.
For those who seek truth, I recommend: The Spirit of Truth, Bible the Herald of Quran
(www.lulu.com/en/ca/shop/esmail-hemmati/the-spirit-of-truth-bible-the-herald-of-quran/ebook/product-1rvvegew.html?page=1&pageSize=4)
This 'professor' talks round and round in circles. He just confused everyone even more.
Right, I don't understand why he thinks the Mahdi and the hadith concerning him to be weak, when its almost universally considered tawaatur. It's really odd.
He mentions to protect yourself from the fitnahs of the dajjal you should read the first 10 ayahs or the last 8 and in some narrations 3 ayahs. When all my life all I've heard from other Muslims was the ten verses , so why mention the ones that differ when they are a small minority.
And before that implies that the Mahdi and hadiths regarding him are not authentic (which is odd considering that it's considered tawaatur) and mentions that few scholars believe them to be weak even though majority of them believe in the coming of the Mahdi, he really and truly did talk in circles. He himself seems skeptical on the authenticity of the concept of the Mahdi. It was almost infuriating just how much he was going around in circles, I feel like he has opinions that don't match with majority of the scholars when it comes to the Mahdi but for some reason chose to beat around the bush instead of address them head on.
And then says that the yajuuj wa majuuj are a people that *apparently* have been trapped. Apparently ???
@@UnknownSend3r Exactly, he was telling this (i'm assuming non muslim) man about differences in opinions from scholars on something that is pretty much factual. I think when giving dawah that is a very bad move because from the non-muslim perspective they will think Islam is a mess and the scholars can't even agree on something basic.
@@rebellion7463 I’m pretty sure Paul is Muslim.
@@consequenceandmorality9937 His way of speaking is confusing enough to even confuse a muslim, unfortunately.
Dr. Ali was honest enough to admit that the currently accepted sunni hadiths regarding the Mahdi are not in the Sahi books of Bukhari, Muslim, and others. He also mentioned that the Mahdi will come from the lineage of Ali and Fatima. It is a fact that the shia clerics in Iran have in their midst prominent members who can trace their lineage directly to Ali and Fatima and the Mahdi is described in great detail in their hadeeths from birth, lineage, to physical attributes and qualities and significant events in and around his time together with the second coming of Jesus Christ.
Imam Mahdi is the 12th imam and he will come with prophet Jesus ..
Iran is paving the way for the reappearance of the 12th imam Mahdi and messiah Jesus
PLEASE STOP PUSHING YOUR SHIA MAKE BELIEFS, YOU DENYING THE TRUTH, WHEN THE TRUTH IS EVIDENT....... LEAVE YOUR SHIA INNOVATIONS OUT OF THE PERFECT DEEN
@@truthprevails556 he’s stating a fact ... why does it bother you so much? Because it goes against your not so foreward thinking!
To me the description of the mahdi that shias give, sound a lot like they are talking about the Anti-.khrist. It seems like they are paving the way for the antikrist. And Allah knows best.
Allah subhanAllah says in the Quran " and don't become Shias" (don't separate and become sects). Can you imagine Allah warning the Muslims not to break into sects and yet you choose to walk around the world calling yourself a SHIA? The exact word Allah subhanah uses in the Quran, that wich you should avoid? DONT BECOME SHIAS. SHIAS: WE ARE SHIAS.
The biggest tradition and studies about imam Mahdi will be found in Shia literature and it is strong tradition
Yes, exactly...Ya Ali! Ya Mahdi!
@@majorpremise this is shirk.
authentic sources...?
The One Eye is symbolic. He’s not gonna really have one bad one and one good
one eye is also the illuminati symbol especially left eyes, in islam dajjal will have right eye blind
Symbolic according to whom? The Prophet pbuh didn't speak in riddles as they'll be no point in that. No one credible has ever said it's symbolic.
It’s not symbolic.
@@Theocracy8 I won’t say I’m right or ur wrong, but u should look into it.
Also what we ignore as a huge sign of the وعد , is the احزاب or the six nations mentioned in Quran , the nation of Lot ( which is there already so check ), nation of thamud ( also check ), nation of midian ( check) , nation of Aad (check) , nation of the pharaoh/ abrham (check ) and Noah ( I believe these too checked ) these nations are the ahzab as mentioned in suret ص .. all these nations have their characteristics whom we do not study nor observe and they are part of our promise : هذا ما وعدنا الله و رسوله و صدف الله و رسوله سوره الاحزاب ، و الله اعلم