I love how very different the rankings are for most people, just shows how amazing each of these games are and whatever aspects grasps us the most ends up being our favorite. The grotesque horror narrative of Bloodborne as well as it's gothic setting is something I absolutely adore thus it being my number 1!
Finally someone who rates the game as it is and not trying so hard to be unique. Its very hard to rank the top5, still you balanced the ranking quite well. Nice video man.
Finally someome acknowledges bloodbornes poor base game line up of bosses. Ds3s bad levels. Personally i feel the artstyle and graphics in ds1 is the best in the dark souls trilogy, ds1 isnt even my first
Bloodborne has a fine base game lineup of bosses. Father G, gehrman, and martyr logarius are all top tier fights. Even fights like ebrietas, cleric beast, shadows of yharnam (an actually good and well balanced gank fight) are good too. Ds1 has the same issue but even worse when it has stuff like 3 asylum demons, bed of chaos, centipede demon, Capra demon, and ceaseless discharge all in the same game. I think you’re just trying to find reasons to discredit the game without actually understanding how it affects the game. I don’t really think ds1 has the best art style either, I’d give it second or third behind demon souls mainly cuz the medieval thing is extremely overdone and I find cosmic horror a lot more Ukraine and interesting and I’d say it’s harder to pull off because it’s hard to capture the true scale of it especially in a videogame.
My personal ranking: 7. Demons Souls 6. Dark Souls 2 5. Dark Souls 1 4. Dark Souls 3 3. Elden Ring 2. Sekiro 1. Bloodborne True ranking 7. Dark Souls 2 6. Demons Souls 5. Dark Souls 1 4. Dark Souls 3 3. Sekrio 2. Bloodborne 1. Elden Ring Great video
I am on PC so i am using a 'Next GEN Fake RTX Reshade' Mod for DS3. This reshade respects the Artstyle of original and tones down the greyish look of the game and add colous. Many reshades for games are trash but this one is surprisingly superb. And no performance loss
@@shayanali8771I searched it up but couldn’t find any pics in nexus mods but I can imagine how superb it would look I wish I could use it but I’m own the game on ps5 thx tho
My personal list is 7. Dark Souls 1 (great levels but game is ruined after O&S, it's very bad after that ngl) 6. Demon's Souls (simplistic start of the genre but there are many mechanics that need fixing) 5. Dark Souls 2 (creative ideas but clunky and bad execution, could be a great game) 4. Bloodborne (Great weapons and fun but most bosses suck and it's a bit too unforgiving) 3. Dark Souls 3 (amazing bosses but the level design is really bland, they could do better) 2. Sekiro (best video game combat but there are some bad-annoying bosses, good overall) 1. Elden Ring (astonishing variety and crazy exploration but it is too big and empty of a world with repetative encounters on the way)
@@MimicMora it's like a 6/10 imo (that's not ''that'' bad, not great either), boss quality was pretty much nonexistent, level design was immaculate but i can't ignore the second half, even if my first playthrough took only 11 hours and i first tried most bosses i just felt it wasn't my kind of thing. I played some years ago on my ps3 and it had issues at some bosses and places as you may know so that factored in my view. Also, i did not play the dlc, but don't worry i plan on playing the remastered version (+dlc) on the ps4 once i finish up with Elden Ring Dlc and Demon's Souls Remake (which is better only for the graphics, sound, and a bit of parry nostalgia). And i still fully believe that Dark Souls 2 is consistently bad, at least you can have your expectations low from that game but DS1 really let me down on that second half. Anyways, have a nice day :)
I like the gimmicky bosses in Demon’s Souls. The bosses usually come after gruelling levels with very few checkpoints. The game had a roguelite element to it, where the challenge was getting through the whole level, while acquiring the knowledge to beat the bosses. In the later games, the bosses mostly became roll spamming encounters.
I haven’t anyone say that before but yk ur lowkey changing my mind about demon souls but problem is I played it after all of the other games soo the boss quality bar was to high
@MimicMora I played them in order of release. I see Sekiro as kind of being the opposite of Demon's Souls. It's a lot more focused on bosses than level design. The bosses and minibosses can be brutally difficult, but the levels and most normal enemies can be beaten easier or sneaked past.
@@gilgamesh310 that’s very true but tbh areas in demon souls ain’t all that maybe in like 2-3 worlds there alright but the rest are very mid and bosses yeah
@@MimicMora my number one is Elden ring also and i only played it 2-3 times I don’t think you should play Elden ring a lot of times and that’s not a negative some games are just meant to be played 1 time that first experience that you will cherish and I accept that I feel like that’s why the dlc is so big also
@@xtcymafai Ik that some games are meant to be played once specially story games like rd2 but one of the best features from souls is that they probably are the most repayable games out there
@1xtcy compared to ds1 and ds2 I think eldenring has more replayablitiy but sekiro with just having to sit at a budha statue to fight a previous boss puts it as the most replayable after I beat sekiro I went on a 2 month streak logging in playing inner genichiro and isshin
I don’t think bloodborne needs a remake we need a blood-borne 2 bc the base game bosses are so effy but if they take what they learned from the dlc and makes that an actual game it would be too 3 for sure
1. Elden ring 2. Sekiro 3. Ds3 4. Ds1 5. Ds2 6. Do not have a playstation and what I have seen for Blood Bourne the fans craze over it I swear ever since I bought elden ring for christmas in 2023 I have been addicted to game and boss ranking and when bloodbourne is not in the top three their is savages in the comments posting whole essays about how it is literally the second coming of jesus christ and even if i had a Playstation i would prob put those two at bottom anyways because of the exlustivity
Same top 3 but in a different order. For me it’s like 1a.Dark souls 1(give it the edge because it has the most complete lore) 1b.Elden ring 2.Sekiro(would probably be my favorite if the games development was given more love. Really the only fromsoft game I want a sequel from) I truly believe these 3 games offer the best qualities of any fromsoft game.
From what I’ve played 5. Elden ring 4. DS3 3. DS1 2. Bloodborne 1. Sekiro I like Elden ring (haven’t played dlc yet) but I think it has a lot of issues
@@MimicMora It’s kinda hard to say since it’s been so long since I played it; just I didn’t have the same level of wonder and general fun that I did with any of the other games, and I just have by far the least hours in Elden Ring compared to other games. I made one melee character on my first playthrough, one magic character, and one incantation character. In every other game I had at least gotten to 10 characters
It’s weird I like in sekiro you get one weapon and use it for the whole game but when I played bloodborne I didn’t enjoy having very little variety of weapons.Everygame has one or two things that are in the other games that would make it perfect.
Im confused why people say elden ring is overrated while everyone in the comment section is hating on you for placing it no.1, personally i 100% agree with elden ring in no.1 but i think ds3 is better than ds1
Ah! Some DS1 respect. I also believe DS1 has my favorite lore, even though ER has my favorite characters and questlines. I think you needed to point out some flaws with Sekiro since it sounded like a flawless game (although I don't believe it is part of Soulsborne). And yeah, great list overall and I can understand your arguments.
@@enman009 ds1 lore is amazing and same with Elden ring and mb with the sekrio I’m still trying to improve on my scripts they aren’t the best rn thx tho :)
W ranking bloodborne is piss poor when it comes to base game bosses. The dlc carries that part of the game immensley. Also ds3 having uninteresting levels is smth i also agree with. If it had better levels itd be my #2 ovr
If you switch ds3 and ds1 you would have my exact list. Everything you said is valid, but I think it was just that I prefer faster gameplay over slower gameplay and it’s my first souls game so I might just be bias. Otherwise I agree with your list.
1:12 if you ever run out of healing items in Demon's souls.. that is the biggest skill issue I have ever heard. 4:00 Mimics are pretty fun to fight for me.
@@MimicMora It is still not a problem I see because you can carry 200+ healing items with you into a bossfight. It is limited yes, but every op system in a Fromsoft game usually has a flaw.
Sekiro DS3 Bloodborne Elden Ring DS1 Demon Souls I have immense respect for DS1 but I was late to the souls train so I don’t have a personal affinity to it as much as others. Also Elden Ring would be higher on the list if it was scaled down and got rid of all the cookie cutter content (repeating bosses, samey catacombs, etc.)
Never understanded why elden ring is so popular. It has bad boss design with heavily inflated difficulty due to animation reading, a dlc thats not worth it considering the fact that its 40 dollars, decent lore (if you watch 3 hours of lore videos) and an open world thats just.. boring by fromsoft standards, seriously compare crossing all of limgrave vs central yharmam, in yharnam in yharnam you are facing CONSTANT traps and ambushes, raving madmen in the streets that actually speak to you saying some of the best voicelines in gaming like “AWAY AWAY” people inside their homes that you can save, talk to, get told to f off, multiple really good npcs that have some sick questlines, 2 very decent bosses that teach you the basic mechanics of the game and just to lead directly to odean chappel and cathedral ward, a very important area you constantly come back too. Now compare that to limgrave.. basic dragon fight thats reused 20 times, npc quests 99% of people are gonna miss dungeons and catacombs filled with basic enemies that are given a boss health bar, evergaols that do the same thing, a sea that you fall right trough(cause fromsoft still has no swimming mechanics in 2022/2024 despite the game taking place on an island) a tree sentinel boss thats also reused 80 god damn times, a caravan and mausoleum that are also reused 90 times troughout the game, kale an actually decent npc to talk to that had his questline cut, all leading to stormveil that houses margit, a boss thats reused as a common ass enemy in leyndell, and godrick(one of the fucking demigod shardbearers) thats reused in an evergaol also in leyndell… (limgrave is one of the best areas in the game btw) what mental gymnastics do you have to go trough to put that on number one and bloodborne at 4? The only thing you have against bloodborne is the other main game bosses are just kind of decent and the game is carried by the dlc but.. the game of the year edition for bloodborne is 25 dollars my dude… its so utterly ridiculous to fault a 15 dollar game for having its best content in a 10-5 dollar dlc meanwhile you are glazing elden ring, a 70 dollar game that reuses half of its content and has a 40 dollar dlc.. elden ring is decent, its the thing it got me into the souls series to begin with but its by far the worst edition to it tied with ds2. I understand you are doing it to not anger the elden ring fanboys who have not even played the other games but come on my dude. (Also i love how you said chalice dungeons are “worthless and add nothing to the game” despite them being crucial to the lore + having a couple pretty fun bosses and locations and then you went ahead and said nothing about elden rings caves and catacombs that are legit smaller, more copy and pasted versions of the chalice dungeons that are not only completley irrelevant to the lore but also have no unique enemies and bosses in them unlike the chalice dungeons)
@@nevenneven8159 ur comparing Elden ring to bloodborne 1 to 1 a open world to a semi open world and saying that Elden ring has bad bosses is ironic as bloodborne has one of the worst boss line ups and I don’t take price into consideration at all cuz it’s irrelevant when deciding which game you enjoy most and if you think I put Elden ring cuz of the fans your wrong as if I was scared I wouldn’t have put bloodborne at 4
@@MimicMora Elden rings a semi open world game. Rdr2 is what an actual open world game looks. 90% of elden rings bosses are recycled multiple times, even main ones like godrick,margit and then godfrey and moghs first phases as well to name a few. And the few that are not can either be absolute jokes due to spirit summons or they take 500 attempts to beat. You dont see a problem with that cause you are a youtuber that makes a living off of games like elden ring, you have the time to spend 8 hours a day learning every single pattern a boss has to perfection. 90% of the playerbase does not have that luxury. Im gonna bring up price as a factor cause you brought up bloodbornes best areas mostly being in the dlc as a bad thing despite the fact that the dlc and base game are so ridiculously cheap its not an issue at all to just get the GOTY edition. The same cannot be said for elden ring cause the dlc for elden ring is expensive enough to be a modern AAA game(and it definitely does not have the best areas in the game cause its the first dlc in fromsoft history to get mixed reviews). Also i find it funny how you said the chalice dungeons are absolute trash but then said nothing about about the copy and pasted catacombs, caves, evergaols, ruins, churches and graves in elden ring that serve the exact same purpose the chalice dungeons do but without everything people liked about the chalice dungeons like random generation and cool lore. Elden ring is a good game. But compared to every other souls game including sekiro? At the end of the day its just dark souls 3 if 80% of dark souls 3 was recycled filler. Also saying that bloodborne has the worst boss line up out of any souls game comes down to purely opinion. The same cannot be said with the mass recycling of content and bosses with artificially inflated difficulty in elden ring that is just bad no matter how you look at it.
@@nevenneven8159 how is rdr2 open world different from Elden ring interms of it being an open world and lmao I don’t make a living of games I don’t even earn money from RUclips man idk why your soo pressed about me enjoying a game a lot than another I’m sorry bloodborne isn’t my favorite
@@MimicMora An open world game is described as a game where the player can approach objectives freely opposed to a world with a more linear and structured gameplay. In an elden ring playtrough you can choose to fight 2 shardbearer bosses before fighting morgot, then fire giant, then malekith, then gideon then godfrey and then the final boss. A couple of other mandatory bosses will be required to be beat so you can get to malekith for example. Outside of having to pick what 2 shardbearers you will fight elden ring is completley linear in terms of its main objectives. All the legacy dungeons where those bosses and the actual content of the game is located are linear. The paths that connect those points of intrest have nothing to do in them. No hunting, no fishing, no random encounters, no towns to go to, no npcs to talk to that actually matter outside of the main hub of the game, all the patrols lead to nowhere and wont start moving unless they see you, nothing. The world is completley linear and artifical. Now compare that to rdr2: every single npc has a daily routine, animals will hunt and be hunted without you ever being involved, random encounters are all across the map, you can approach each chapter in your own order, sometimes you get to make a choice that affects how the story will end, you have an honor system that will affect how people view you and how the story will end, you can donate money to your gangs camp if you have some to spare allowing the npcs in the camp to generally be happier, you have to maintain your horse by feeding it, brushing it, patting it aswell as actually bond with it affecting how much it listens to you while riding, unlike torrent that somehow has worse horse mechanics then ps2 shadow of the collosus. Commiting a crime in a town does not go unpunished once you restart the game, not only will the law in that state now be after you and the townspeople will be angry the next time they see you with some shops in the town not wanting to serve you cause of it. And even thats just barely scratching the surface of how much more stuff red deads world has then elden ring (and thats not even mentioning the fact that it absolutley dunks on it in terms of graphics despite being 4 years oldes and on last gen hardware)
My top: 1.DS3 (Lorewise and bosswise i love this game so much, proly fav oat. I love the color work on this one, as its the ending of the whole story and it means to be dark themed and shi) 2.Elden ring( dont have to say more, greatest open world game + martin was making lore so couldnt expect less) 3.Sekiro(best fighting system no diff, Japanese setting which feels so cool in comparison to dark fantasy themed setting in othe fromsoft games) 4.DS2(gonna be thrown tomatoes but i really dont dislike the game at all. The versatility this game gives you is immaculate. I love the dlcs sm and ofc, DA DRIP😈) 5.DS1 (atmosphere is just on another level. The world building is crazy. Buuut, the mid and endgame feels kinda junky imo. Could have easily competed in top 3 but the tomb of giants, bed of chaos and seath feel just so off.) 6. BB(i cant say i dislike the game, i just dont like it as much as any other games on list, boss quality in main game is...well...u get it. Only liked like gherman, nurse and maybe amelia. But dlc slaps) Looking forward to play demon souls but still no ps5((( Ps. I love every single game in its own way, theres none i dislike/hatr
Never play demon souls My ranking 1. Elden Ring 2.Dark Souls 1 3.Dark Souls 3 4.Blood Borne 5.Sekiro .. .. 6.Dark Souls 2 (Difficulty in this game doesn’t make me feel any challenged, but it make me annoyed)
@@MimicMora I really liked it overall but I find it kinda annoying to replay because of how much downtime it has compared to the other games, not a huge open world fan overall tho so it’s mostly a me thing, also I think it kinda falls apart near the end similarly to ds1 in terms of balancing especially the game still hella delivered on level design, atmosphere, lore, etc and some of the bosses are among from’s best
Mine (top 3 are interchangeable) 1. Dark Souls 2. Bloodborne 3. Sekiro 4. Elden ring (used to be lower but the dlc really bumped it up) 5. Demons souls 6. DS3 7. DS2
@@MimicMora I didn’t like base game Elden ring as much. I was burned out by open world games at that point and didn’t enjoy the boss designs in general. However the DLC was near fucking perfect. I think originally I had it at 5 or 6
I always felt that dark souls was better than dark souls 3, solely because of the horrendous, boring areas that are after Vordt of the Boreal Valley, to the Abyss Watchers. This is literally enough to turn me away from replaying the game over dark souls
Stop hating on Elden ring bruh it’s not a big deal… plus it’s his opinion and who cares if it’s “open world” and not souls like. Elden ring is a perfect game so shut y’all bullcrap..
Fantastic list. This is exactly mine with the exception of swapping Demon's Souls and DS2. Almost all areas in DS2 are below average with rather boring bosses imo. As linear as they are I at least enjoy most of the ones DeS. Also, finally someone else out there puts DS3 where it belongs. It's a great game but pretty overrated imo. The levels are boring but the bosses were some of the best, at one point in time. They have since been eclipsed by both Sekiro and ER and I find them kind of simplistic now lol
Thanks very true with ds2 but for me idk why I didn’t enjoy des as much it’s probably the bosses and ds3 is the perfect game to boss rush the whole game in. It’s crazy How the next souls game will outclass ER bosses atleast some of them
Funny how bloodborne gets critism about main game bosses yet there’s dark souls 1 in top 3 which has a terrible second half of the game. Horrible bosses, terrible level design, shit areas and annoying enemies. Funny
In my opinion elden ring is the best first playthrough but the worst one to replay. But I think these games should be graded based on their first playthroughs
@@MimicMora I love replaying elden ring after I get out of luirnia. I think the early game is so boring to replay though I now I just skip almost everything and only pick up the weapons/talismans I want and golden seeds and tears. The dlc is much more fun to playthrough on its own because of how condensed it is. Thankfully I had like 5 lvl 150 characters just sitting on standby to play it when it came out
ER is worst ssouls game. Im playing dlc right now and I hate open world with a passion. Legacy dungeons are good tho, still I miss DS times without open world crap. My ranking: BB>DS2>DeS>DS1>DS3>ER
@@ReadyAimFire_ wow I understand you hate the open world but it being the worst is kinda crazy but fine and your list has to be the most interesting list fair enough
Bloodborne bosses truly are horrible, I'm playing through it for the first time and I'm surprised no one has ever said it. 99% of bosses are the same monster but with slight variations
Are you being serious? Have you fought father G, gehrman, martyr logarius? Or even shadows of yharnam, ebrietas, and cleric beast? That’s not even mentioning the old hunters which has 3 of the best fights in the souls series. Ds1, ds2, and ER have the same issues arguably to a worser extent
i think sekiro is a really good game but after playing i don't know what it is but there's just something about it strongly dislike also felt like very tidias imo and being honest i really didn't enjoy it, i didn't think to myself after i beat the game how much of a great game it was, i thought to myself that im glad its finally over and don't have to play it again
@@MimicMora i haven't played demon souls or bloodborne because i don't have a playstation but i've played the the dark souls trilogy, sekiro and elden ring. i'd have to say my favourite from what i've played is definetly either elden ring or dark souls 3, my main complaint with dark souls 1 is after ornstein and smough the bosses go down hill and dark souls 2 well i don't talk about that because it was cruel pain and torture
Only correct list 7.ds2 as ive not finished it 6.demons souls due to the death mechanic 5.elden ring 3-4.ds3 or ds1 interchangeable depending on my mood 2.sekiro 1.bloodborne
Completely agree with this list, especially with ER because while it is a great game some flaws are just too noticeable for me like the duo fights so I'd personally also put it under Sekiro, ds3, ds1 and BB
@@J0C0M The duo fights are not a problem if you actually summon LOL. In fact it's the only game where gank bosses can be fun. Problem is with the players not summoning against gank for some reason
@@MimicMora i meen the trend of hating DS2 there were many cool idea in ds2 all of it applicated in eldin ring and people loved it and ds1 bosses are pretty similar to ds2 but everyone say ds1 bosses were better 🤷 like you said it's just an opinion
7. Demons Souls 6. DS2 The quality gets way better from here: 5. Sekiro ( Best Bosses in the genre and great fighting mechanics. But zero weapon variety and the level design and exploration are the weakest in the entire series) 4. DS3 ( Great Bosses and overall a very solid game with few negatives. However the world and levels are not interconnected well like the other games, and not alot of originality) 3. DS1 ( Best semi open world ever made, the world design and interconnection between levels is second to none. Sadly the bosses in the base game are not good) 2. BB ( Like DS1 the world design is great and art direction is superb, the bosses even though still not comparable to the newer games were a big improvement over DS1 and DS2. The big negative for me is the build variety and weapons, you can literally play the whole game without feeling the need to change weapon and there is very little build variety. Compare that to the many build options you can try out in Elden Ring its insane) 1. Elden Ring ( Greatest open world ever made. Its one of the very few games out there that makes you live out your fantasy dream. The world building and biome variety are excellent. And unlike other games if you are stuck with a boss you can explore and come back stronger than ever. Build variety is insane with so many cool build options you can try out. The legacy dungeons, medium dungeons, small dungeons the open world all make very unique experiences when meshed together. Only negative for me is the repeat bosses but I dont really hate them)
@@youssefessam3164W list and explanation I do wish that sekiro had some weapons like in ninja gaiden but yeah and the thing with bloodborne is soo true i never change my weapon
We have the same "worst" and best in our list but all the rest is totally different lol Here's mine: 1: Elden Ring 2: DS3 3: Sekiro 4: DS2 5: Bloodborne 6: DS1 7: DeS
@@MimicMora Elden Ring was my first soulsborne game 2 yrs ago 😅 after 3 playthroughs I started playing DS3, then DeS but only a little bit before moving to Sekiro. After that I played DS1 and then DS2. The last game I started playing was Bloodborne. I never really finished DeS but it always feels like a chore and I'll see when I will finish it A big factor for me are the bosses and I think ER mainbosses, DS3 and Sekiro are a league on their own. I share the same opinion with you about BB's bosses and I think DS1 and DeS really disappointed boss wise. Only O&S, artorias and Manus where standouts for me while there where a lot of bad ones like Capra demon and Bed Of Chaos. I do think I enjoyed DS2 more than the average souls player. Idk man but I always was so excited about playing it when I was in my playthroughs. I can't really tell you what it was but It had something only ER had for me. If it wasn't for the BS like ADP, the hitboxes and the Runbacks, it would rank even higher.
@@MimicMora i must say i really like every one of them with the exception maybe of DeS. all the rest are A's and S tiers for me, the fact that DS1 and BB are lower doesn't make it bad for me. they're still one of the best games ever played. I also love the world building of DS1 and seeing Anor Londo for the first time. or the whole vibe and combat and music of BB. also lady maria is top 10 FS boss ever for me. they're all masterpieces ;) and im curious to see what DS2 would have been if they had more time to develop the game
My top 3 would be: 1) Bloodborne 2) Dark souls 3 3) Sekiro Also i don't really agree with the critiques to Bloodborne that much. The bosses in the base game were just normal for the most of it, as the hunter couldn't costantly face super duper hunters and had also to focus on Kins and failed experiments. The only really bad ones in my opinion are Micolash due to him being just a strong npc and the witches of Hemwick for just their poor design. The chalice dungeons varied in beauty and hatred, as some were fabulous with good bosses while others were straight up hard mode things or farming material, you either hate it or love it, they are not useless nor unplayable, they just.. it depends on wether or not you're trying to get a platinum. I cannot understand unfortunately your love for Elden Ring, i finished it 3-4 times by now with even another character but.. i despise it, i seriously despise most bosses to the point the black bell hunter is my favourite. I don't like to explore that much, i think fighting is much more important in a game than just get into many good areas. And this is the same reason why i don't like by *that* much dark souls 1, good exploration but most of the times boring or bad bosses (some demons + BOC + Seath), and i were not used to blocking as neither DS3 or Bloodborne told me that as my first games.
I think in ur case as y played the much faster ones first then went on to the slower/ worse ones u have already experienced amazing combat but then went and amazing bosses from ds3 but then u went to ds1 which is completely different but Elden ring if you don’t like open world and exploration same thing with me I hate open world rpgs but Elden ring is an expection For bloodborne I said the plat is annoying because of the chalice dungeon and the bosses a lot of them are bad most of them are
@@MimicMora Well, it depends on the chalice dungeons, wether it's that of Amygdala or Yahnram (which was a good boss fight tho). And could you tell me which bosses on bloodborne's base game annoyed you the most? I did not want to fight fairly just Micolash, maybe the One reborn and the Witches of Hemwick. But the others were pretty clean to me.
@@MimicMora Moon presence was underwhelming i give you that, but a fit boss after having fought Gehrman. Ebrietas was not that bad and pretty enterataining. Celestial Emyssary is not bad, it's easy. Rom is just a pain for speedrunners but he isn't that bad and actually teaches you about patience. Also Mergo's wet nurse, the shadows of Yahrnam and the Dark beast Paarl were honestly fun in my opinion.
Finally a person who loves Blood Bourne hates Elden Ring but does not say it's a bad game you just said you personally did not like the bosses which is much better than the kids in one of the top comments have a war over it
Ironically I put Bloodborne, sekiro And Bloodborne at S rank Bloodborne was my first souls game so it’s special for me Ds1 and ds3 at A tier Ds2, DS at B tier Maybe demon souls at C tier but still liked it
Oh god where do I start with this list. Well firstly, I think bloodborne is better than Elden ring. Bloodborne has unmatched aesthetic and combat, and also contains my favorite boss of all time. Elden ring’s open world does nothing but put artificial distance between you and the content, forcing you to look up how to get to secret main bosses. Having DS1 in the top 3 is disgraceful and in bad taste, especially being above bloodborne. Dark souls 1 is clunky and garbage in comparison to fromsoft’s other games. I don’t care how good the world building is, the game has to be fun to PLAY. I’m sure it was good in 2011 or whatever, but catch up to the current generation will you? Also the second half is straight garbage. Dark souls 3 is an improvement on dark souls 1 and 2 in every possible way, yet it’s somehow lower than 1? Interesting. Nostalgia must carry DS1’s ranking. Sekiro is overrated, that’s for sure. The combat was built for 1v1 encounters yet only like 10% of the game is actually that. They stuff every mini boss arena full of enemies and it’s stupid difficulty that’s not even fun. The bosses are good, so I wish they made up more of the game. So personally: DS1 < DeS =< DS2
@@Travisaurus bloodborne combat and atmosphere is amazing but my main criticism is the bosses and I also criticize the open world in Elden ring For me I enjoy dark souls 1 to this day I’m like on my 6th playthrough and is the game clunky yes but using ninja flip ring it feels pretty good 2nd half is garbage sure but I still enjoy the game and always find my self coming back to it Dark souls 3 didn’t improve everything imo it has the worst areas and I hate most of them Sekrio combat is amazing and is made for 1v1 which all the actual main bosses are. But the mini bosses u can kill the enemies using stealth
You’re supposed to use stealth to take out the enemies around the mini bosses. Also why they give you all the ninjutsus, you use those enemies to your advantage. You missed out almost all the positives of sekiro. Great level design, it 100% feels the best to play out of all the games due to the new movement system and the modernised style of gameplay instead of their age old slow style they normally use, combat that actually allows you to stand toe to toe with enemies instead of rolling around everywhere. DS1 connectivity is on another level, I’ve never seen anything like it. You mention that bosses are only a small portion of the game for sekiro but ignore that the exact same argument can be used for DS1 in reverse You can’t name the flaws of things you dislike and ignore the flaws of the things you like. You said bloodborne has your favourite boss and ignored all the mid bosses it has. I like them but the difference is quality against sekiro, DS3 and elden ring boss wise is heavy and that has to be mentioned. Horrendous healing system too, also has a lot of clunkiness. You spent half your comment complaining about clunkiness and ignored that sekiro is the least clunky game lol
Bloodbourne having the best combat is opinionated the main game bosses average at a Low a teir yes the dlc trio highly carries the boss ranking the mid bosses in BB overwhelm the great ones in the main game looking at elden ring the main bosses their are 2 actually bad bosses needed to beat the game fire giant and foreskin duo back to back is a sour taste but then you get maliketh Godfrey and radagon which have movesets that have great combo mix ups that are told by where you ate positioned
I disagree. DS3 is kind of the "average" Fromsoft game at this point. What does it actually do best? Music maybe? ER and Sekiro beat it in level and boss design. And DS1 still has the best overall world in any of From's games
I don’t really agree with the bloodborne criticism tbh. Blood vials become inoffensive after around halfway into the game and they feel good to use too, and chalice dungeons are entirely optional so I’ve never understood criticizing them to make the whole game look worse. Removing chalice dungeons wouldn’t make the game better in any way, and it’d even lose cool weapons like the chikage which is a more mechanically complex weapon than anything in DS1 or ER. The base game boss lineup is also very contradictory because ds1 has a similair issue to an even bigger extent because that game literally has like only 1 truly great fight in the base game being orenstein and smough. Elden ring suffers from the same issue and even its best bosses in the base game have heavy issues. The only boss in ER base game that id say is truly S tier is mohg because he actually has a nice flow to his fight and isn’t inconsistent with his attack timings.
@@MimicMorayea I agree chalice dungeons are bad for trying to platinum but I personally dont rlly use platinum trophy difficulty to weigh in whether a mechanic is bad or not but that’s understandable. I personally would’ve ranked it atleast higher than ds1 mainly cuz the game never really falls off the same way ds1 did after lordvessel. I also think ds1 bosses are worse on average imo, and the dlcs are super close but old hunters edges it out cuz all 3 levels are amazing.
@@MimicMora I think my previous comment got deleted but yes it’s understandable that it may be annoying to try and platinum with the dungeons but I personally don’t weigh platinum trophy difficulty as negatives to a game. I would’ve personally atleast ranked it higher than ds1 cuz I feel like ds1 is inconsistent in its quality whereas bloodborne never really falls off the same way ds1 does. I also think the bosses are generally better in the base game especially. DLCs are very close but I think old hunters edges out mainly cuz of all 3 levels (hunters nightmare, research hall, and fishing hamlet) all being amazing.
I mean if you discount chalice dungeons because they are options that's like saying Ash Lake, painted world of Ariamis, Archdragon Peak and most of the other optional content in the games do not matter because they are optional. The content is in the game, it should be criticised.
fact that you are calling demon's souls bosses gimmicky because of ankle breaking whilst fire giant in elden ring 14 years later uses the same mechanism- goes to show how dumb and subjective your rankings are. Limited healing? dude its the upside of having unlimited healing with all the grass you can farm similar to how you farm souls in between bosses. Your list is a derivative lip service to all videos in your echo chamber. demons souls is the og and deserves to be goated for all the inspiration. And for the love of god you dont even have bloodborne in top 3 😂
Well obviously my ranking is subjective that’s the whole point and each souls has a gimmick boss but most des bosses are gimmicky. I didn’t say it’s bad I said it’s the worst compared to others and how is it fun to farm for healing
@@MimicMora what gameplay the combat is slow and janky and most of the areas are terrible like catacombs and blight town, same bosses again and again and no fast travel . only lore is amazing thats it
Elden Ring number one? Another cringe normie tier list. Elden Ring can't be in the frist place by any means cuz souls formula don't work in openworld. I don't say elden ring is bad but it can't be on first place that's it. It's litterally dark souls 3 without any fresh experiance for players who played thousands of hours in ds3.
@@mikhailkalinin6536 yeah sure good point, shame what half of the game we have to ride horse at empty map. If game would be only legacy dugeones with few more insted of empty map it would be much better.
Mabye your just butt hurt over an opinion dude. Mabye he's like me, like many others who love open world games, esspessally a souls open world. His tier list isn't the word of god so don't get upset over it
![[TF2] The Russian Bear Trap](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YFNSwz2_rOA/mqdefault.jpg)
I love how very different the rankings are for most people, just shows how amazing each of these games are and whatever aspects grasps us the most ends up being our favorite. The grotesque horror narrative of Bloodborne as well as it's gothic setting is something I absolutely adore thus it being my number 1!
@@Hakarasan honestly that’s why I love ranking stuff so I can hear yalls favorites and criticizemem bloodborne atmosphere is unmatched
I hate Bloodborne fans, it's so rare to see sensible one! Kudos to you , man!
That moaning in dark souls 1 always gets me😂
Finally someone who rates the game as it is and not trying so hard to be unique. Its very hard to rank the top5, still you balanced the ranking quite well. Nice video man.
@@Jaiprasad11 thanks man appreciate it
Another day another soulsborne ranking that starts with demon’s souls and DS2 rip
Really tried to like ds2 it just ain’t it For me
Just like Elden ring is a bad game for me, for you it's ds2, every person has their own likes and dislikes
@@bikashit even then majority of people place ds2 and demon's souls last and thats a fact, including myself
Finally someome acknowledges bloodbornes poor base game line up of bosses. Ds3s bad levels. Personally i feel the artstyle and graphics in ds1 is the best in the dark souls trilogy, ds1 isnt even my first
@@bricksflygood5949 omg marry me I thought I was the only one
@@MimicMora I felt like I was locked in a straight jacket in the astral clock tower by bloodborne fans
Based, Sekiro was my favorite before Elden Ring, i really Hope we get another Sekiro esque Game.
@@lilfence4728me too it’s the dream
Bloodborne has a fine base game lineup of bosses. Father G, gehrman, and martyr logarius are all top tier fights. Even fights like ebrietas, cleric beast, shadows of yharnam (an actually good and well balanced gank fight) are good too. Ds1 has the same issue but even worse when it has stuff like 3 asylum demons, bed of chaos, centipede demon, Capra demon, and ceaseless discharge all in the same game.
I think you’re just trying to find reasons to discredit the game without actually understanding how it affects the game. I don’t really think ds1 has the best art style either, I’d give it second or third behind demon souls mainly cuz the medieval thing is extremely overdone and I find cosmic horror a lot more Ukraine and interesting and I’d say it’s harder to pull off because it’s hard to capture the true scale of it especially in a videogame.
My personal ranking:
7. Demons Souls
6. Dark Souls 2
5. Dark Souls 1
4. Dark Souls 3
3. Elden Ring
2. Sekiro
1. Bloodborne
True ranking
7. Dark Souls 2
6. Demons Souls
5. Dark Souls 1
4. Dark Souls 3
3. Sekrio
2. Bloodborne
1. Elden Ring
Great video
I am on PC so i am using a 'Next GEN Fake RTX Reshade' Mod for DS3. This reshade respects the Artstyle of original and tones down the greyish look of the game and add colous. Many reshades for games are trash but this one is surprisingly superb. And no performance loss
@@shayanali8771I searched it up but couldn’t find any pics in nexus mods but I can imagine how superb it would look I wish I could use it but I’m own the game on ps5 thx tho
For me it’s elden at top, second I can’t choose between blood and sekiro, the story in Bloodborne is so dark, and I love it
@@ongeh1358 bloodborne for story and atmosphere skiro gameplay
My personal list is
7. Dark Souls 1 (great levels but game is ruined after O&S, it's very bad after that ngl)
6. Demon's Souls (simplistic start of the genre but there are many mechanics that need fixing)
5. Dark Souls 2 (creative ideas but clunky and bad execution, could be a great game)
4. Bloodborne (Great weapons and fun but most bosses suck and it's a bit too unforgiving)
3. Dark Souls 3 (amazing bosses but the level design is really bland, they could do better)
2. Sekiro (best video game combat but there are some bad-annoying bosses, good overall)
1. Elden Ring (astonishing variety and crazy exploration but it is too big and empty of a world with repetative encounters on the way)
Pretty good list but except for the no 7 spot cmon ds1 isn’t that bad
@@MimicMora it's like a 6/10 imo (that's not ''that'' bad, not great either), boss quality was pretty much nonexistent, level design was immaculate but i can't ignore the second half, even if my first playthrough took only 11 hours and i first tried most bosses i just felt it wasn't my kind of thing. I played some years ago on my ps3 and it had issues at some bosses and places as you may know so that factored in my view. Also, i did not play the dlc, but don't worry i plan on playing the remastered version (+dlc) on the ps4 once i finish up with Elden Ring Dlc and Demon's Souls Remake (which is better only for the graphics, sound, and a bit of parry nostalgia). And i still fully believe that Dark Souls 2 is consistently bad, at least you can have your expectations low from that game but DS1 really let me down on that second half. Anyways, have a nice day :)
and it's a bit overrated imo ngl, anyways! ^^
@@WeirdTroll666 ok plz try out the remastered with the dlc and tell later when u beat it how u feel about the game
@@MimicMora sure! i'm looking forward to it, but it may take a while
I like the gimmicky bosses in Demon’s Souls. The bosses usually come after gruelling levels with very few checkpoints. The game had a roguelite element to it, where the challenge was getting through the whole level, while acquiring the knowledge to beat the bosses. In the later games, the bosses mostly became roll spamming encounters.
I haven’t anyone say that before but yk ur lowkey changing my mind about demon souls but problem is I played it after all of the other games soo the boss quality bar was to high
@MimicMora I played them in order of release. I see Sekiro as kind of being the opposite of Demon's Souls. It's a lot more focused on bosses than level design. The bosses and minibosses can be brutally difficult, but the levels and most normal enemies can be beaten easier or sneaked past.
@@gilgamesh310 that’s very true but tbh areas in demon souls ain’t all that maybe in like 2-3 worlds there alright but the rest are very mid and bosses yeah
@@MimicMora The Tower of Latria is one of my favourite levels in the series.
@@gilgamesh310 can you plz tell me what’s good about it I hear everyone saying it’s the best but never u understood why😭😭
No way smb actually talks about bloodbornes base game and it’s negatives good job 👍🏾 I think DS3 should be higher tho!! Good list
@@xtcymafai thanks man and I fully understand why ds3 should be higher but ds1 is too special to me
@@MimicMora my number one is Elden ring also and i only played it 2-3 times I don’t think you should play Elden ring a lot of times and that’s not a negative some games are just meant to be played 1 time that first experience that you will cherish and I accept that I feel like that’s why the dlc is so big also
@@xtcymafai Ik that some games are meant to be played once specially story games like rd2 but one of the best features from souls is that they probably are the most repayable games out there
@@MimicMora true
@1xtcy compared to ds1 and ds2 I think eldenring has more replayablitiy but sekiro with just having to sit at a budha statue to fight a previous boss puts it as the most replayable after I beat sekiro I went on a 2 month streak logging in playing inner genichiro and isshin
I don’t think bloodborne needs a remake we need a blood-borne 2 bc the base game bosses are so effy but if they take what they learned from the dlc and makes that an actual game it would be too 3 for sure
@@xtcymafai we need both. And since fromsoftware have improved sooo much interms of everything it will defo be game go the year
i find almost all the main game bosses enjoyable but i am slightly bias as it was my first souls game.
the dlc wasn't all good either Laurence was absolute bullshit
1.Elden Ring
2.Dark Souls 3
3.Bloodborne
4.Sekiro
5.Dark Souls 1
6.Dark Souls 2
7.Demons Souls
W list
@@MimicMora thanks, top 3 are interchangeable.
@@noahg4083 they can be ngl
That's actually my ranking
1. Elden ring
2. Sekiro
3. Ds3
4. Ds1
5. Ds2
6. Do not have a playstation and what I have seen for Blood Bourne the fans craze over it I swear ever since I bought elden ring for christmas in 2023 I have been addicted to game and boss ranking and when bloodbourne is not in the top three their is savages in the comments posting whole essays about how it is literally the second coming of jesus christ and even if i had a Playstation i would prob put those two at bottom anyways because of the exlustivity
Nice list and the bloodborne thing is very very true 😭😭
The disrspect to cookbooks 💀 8:55
Same top 3 but in a different order.
For me it’s like
1a.Dark souls 1(give it the edge because it has the most complete lore)
1b.Elden ring
2.Sekiro(would probably be my favorite if the games development was given more love. Really the only fromsoft game I want a sequel from)
I truly believe these 3 games offer the best qualities of any fromsoft game.
Amazing list
From what I’ve played
5. Elden ring
4. DS3
3. DS1
2. Bloodborne
1. Sekiro
I like Elden ring (haven’t played dlc yet) but I think it has a lot of issues
@@takashi-lee3943 nice list what’s your issues with it
@@MimicMora
It’s kinda hard to say since it’s been so long since I played it; just I didn’t have the same level of wonder and general fun that I did with any of the other games, and I just have by far the least hours in Elden Ring compared to other games.
I made one melee character on my first playthrough, one magic character, and one incantation character.
In every other game I had at least gotten to 10 characters
love the respect on ds1 :)
It’s weird I like in sekiro you get one weapon and use it for the whole game but when I played bloodborne I didn’t enjoy having very little variety of weapons.Everygame has one or two things that are in the other games that would make it perfect.
@@Itsblase01 wow I actually never thought about that
Demon’s Souls is not worse than the Gank nightmare that is Dark Souls 2 or the unfinished mess that is Dark Souls 1.
I found it to be the least enjoyable for me but it’s just my opinion
Sekiro > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Every other game.
Personally I think for me, it’s:
1.Elden Ring
2.Bloodborne
3. DS3
4. Sekiro
5. DS1
6. Demon Souls
7. DS2
@@jamestucker5089 very good list :)
Im confused why people say elden ring is overrated while everyone in the comment section is hating on you for placing it no.1, personally i 100% agree with elden ring in no.1 but i think ds3 is better than ds1
@@creeperYT9824 yeah I don’t really know but thanks and yeah ds3 can defo be better than ds1
Ah! Some DS1 respect. I also believe DS1 has my favorite lore, even though ER has my favorite characters and questlines. I think you needed to point out some flaws with Sekiro since it sounded like a flawless game (although I don't believe it is part of Soulsborne).
And yeah, great list overall and I can understand your arguments.
@@enman009 ds1 lore is amazing and same with Elden ring and mb with the sekrio I’m still trying to improve on my scripts they aren’t the best rn thx tho :)
W ranking bloodborne is piss poor when it comes to base game bosses. The dlc carries that part of the game immensley. Also ds3 having uninteresting levels is smth i also agree with. If it had better levels itd be my #2 ovr
@@nozerc very true. If dark souls 3 had good areas man top 3 atleast
Valid list, sekiro is so good man
@@A.H.goose1it really is
Imma be honest i think ds1 is extremely overrated crosses the line between difficulty and just a chore
@@jacrispybbq how is it a chore just don’t play it if u don’t enjoy the game don’t waste time on it
@@MimicMora because everyone puts masterpiece on it and im waiting for that masterpiece moment cuz they game seems like il be amazing when it happens
@@jacrispybbq what part are u in
@@MimicMora the sewers just beat that dragon dude with like 80 teeth
@@jacrispybbq ight keep going and play the game tilll a certain moment u prob already know then come back and tell em if u enjoy the game yet or no
If you switch ds3 and ds1 you would have my exact list. Everything you said is valid, but I think it was just that I prefer faster gameplay over slower gameplay and it’s my first souls game so I might just be bias. Otherwise I agree with your list.
Defenintly makes sense to do so but we all would rank out first souls game at the top of their list
@@MimicMoraMy first souls game was DS1 I would rank DS3 above it easily.
1:12 if you ever run out of healing items in Demon's souls.. that is the biggest skill issue I have ever heard.
4:00 Mimics are pretty fun to fight for me.
@@luisesteves5929 yeah but still limited specially on ng+ is soo annoying and mimics are good but too much in ds3
@@MimicMora It is still not a problem I see because you can carry 200+ healing items with you into a bossfight. It is limited yes, but every op system in a Fromsoft game usually has a flaw.
Sekiro
DS3
Bloodborne
Elden Ring
DS1
Demon Souls
I have immense respect for DS1 but I was late to the souls train so I don’t have a personal affinity to it as much as others. Also Elden Ring would be higher on the list if it was scaled down and got rid of all the cookie cutter content (repeating bosses, samey catacombs, etc.)
Never understanded why elden ring is so popular. It has bad boss design with heavily inflated difficulty due to animation reading, a dlc thats not worth it considering the fact that its 40 dollars, decent lore (if you watch 3 hours of lore videos) and an open world thats just.. boring by fromsoft standards, seriously compare crossing all of limgrave vs central yharmam, in yharnam in yharnam you are facing CONSTANT traps and ambushes, raving madmen in the streets that actually speak to you saying some of the best voicelines in gaming like “AWAY AWAY” people inside their homes that you can save, talk to, get told to f off, multiple really good npcs that have some sick questlines, 2 very decent bosses that teach you the basic mechanics of the game and just to lead directly to odean chappel and cathedral ward, a very important area you constantly come back too. Now compare that to limgrave.. basic dragon fight thats reused 20 times, npc quests 99% of people are gonna miss dungeons and catacombs filled with basic enemies that are given a boss health bar, evergaols that do the same thing, a sea that you fall right trough(cause fromsoft still has no swimming mechanics in 2022/2024 despite the game taking place on an island) a tree sentinel boss thats also reused 80 god damn times, a caravan and mausoleum that are also reused 90 times troughout the game, kale an actually decent npc to talk to that had his questline cut, all leading to stormveil that houses margit, a boss thats reused as a common ass enemy in leyndell, and godrick(one of the fucking demigod shardbearers) thats reused in an evergaol also in leyndell… (limgrave is one of the best areas in the game btw) what mental gymnastics do you have to go trough to put that on number one and bloodborne at 4? The only thing you have against bloodborne is the other main game bosses are just kind of decent and the game is carried by the dlc but.. the game of the year edition for bloodborne is 25 dollars my dude… its so utterly ridiculous to fault a 15 dollar game for having its best content in a 10-5 dollar dlc meanwhile you are glazing elden ring, a 70 dollar game that reuses half of its content and has a 40 dollar dlc.. elden ring is decent, its the thing it got me into the souls series to begin with but its by far the worst edition to it tied with ds2. I understand you are doing it to not anger the elden ring fanboys who have not even played the other games but come on my dude. (Also i love how you said chalice dungeons are “worthless and add nothing to the game” despite them being crucial to the lore + having a couple pretty fun bosses and locations and then you went ahead and said nothing about elden rings caves and catacombs that are legit smaller, more copy and pasted versions of the chalice dungeons that are not only completley irrelevant to the lore but also have no unique enemies and bosses in them unlike the chalice dungeons)
@@nevenneven8159 ur comparing Elden ring to bloodborne 1 to 1 a open world to a semi open world and saying that Elden ring has bad bosses is ironic as bloodborne has one of the worst boss line ups and I don’t take price into consideration at all cuz it’s irrelevant when deciding which game you enjoy most and if you think I put Elden ring cuz of the fans your wrong as if I was scared I wouldn’t have put bloodborne at 4
@@MimicMora Elden rings a semi open world game. Rdr2 is what an actual open world game looks. 90% of elden rings bosses are recycled multiple times, even main ones like godrick,margit and then godfrey and moghs first phases as well to name a few. And the few that are not can either be absolute jokes due to spirit summons or they take 500 attempts to beat. You dont see a problem with that cause you are a youtuber that makes a living off of games like elden ring, you have the time to spend 8 hours a day learning every single pattern a boss has to perfection. 90% of the playerbase does not have that luxury. Im gonna bring up price as a factor cause you brought up bloodbornes best areas mostly being in the dlc as a bad thing despite the fact that the dlc and base game are so ridiculously cheap its not an issue at all to just get the GOTY edition. The same cannot be said for elden ring cause the dlc for elden ring is expensive enough to be a modern AAA game(and it definitely does not have the best areas in the game cause its the first dlc in fromsoft history to get mixed reviews). Also i find it funny how you said the chalice dungeons are absolute trash but then said nothing about about the copy and pasted catacombs, caves, evergaols, ruins, churches and graves in elden ring that serve the exact same purpose the chalice dungeons do but without everything people liked about the chalice dungeons like random generation and cool lore. Elden ring is a good game. But compared to every other souls game including sekiro? At the end of the day its just dark souls 3 if 80% of dark souls 3 was recycled filler. Also saying that bloodborne has the worst boss line up out of any souls game comes down to purely opinion. The same cannot be said with the mass recycling of content and bosses with artificially inflated difficulty in elden ring that is just bad no matter how you look at it.
@@nevenneven8159 how is rdr2 open world different from Elden ring interms of it being an open world and lmao I don’t make a living of games I don’t even earn money from RUclips man idk why your soo pressed about me enjoying a game a lot than another I’m sorry bloodborne isn’t my favorite
@@MimicMora An open world game is described as a game where the player can approach objectives freely opposed to a world with a more linear and structured gameplay. In an elden ring playtrough you can choose to fight 2 shardbearer bosses before fighting morgot, then fire giant, then malekith, then gideon then godfrey and then the final boss. A couple of other mandatory bosses will be required to be beat so you can get to malekith for example. Outside of having to pick what 2 shardbearers you will fight elden ring is completley linear in terms of its main objectives. All the legacy dungeons where those bosses and the actual content of the game is located are linear. The paths that connect those points of intrest have nothing to do in them. No hunting, no fishing, no random encounters, no towns to go to, no npcs to talk to that actually matter outside of the main hub of the game, all the patrols lead to nowhere and wont start moving unless they see you, nothing. The world is completley linear and artifical. Now compare that to rdr2: every single npc has a daily routine, animals will hunt and be hunted without you ever being involved, random encounters are all across the map, you can approach each chapter in your own order, sometimes you get to make a choice that affects how the story will end, you have an honor system that will affect how people view you and how the story will end, you can donate money to your gangs camp if you have some to spare allowing the npcs in the camp to generally be happier, you have to maintain your horse by feeding it, brushing it, patting it aswell as actually bond with it affecting how much it listens to you while riding, unlike torrent that somehow has worse horse mechanics then ps2 shadow of the collosus. Commiting a crime in a town does not go unpunished once you restart the game, not only will the law in that state now be after you and the townspeople will be angry the next time they see you with some shops in the town not wanting to serve you cause of it. And even thats just barely scratching the surface of how much more stuff red deads world has then elden ring (and thats not even mentioning the fact that it absolutley dunks on it in terms of graphics despite being 4 years oldes and on last gen hardware)
All you said is gameplay mechanics and not a thing about open world just npcs
My top:
1.DS3 (Lorewise and bosswise i love this game so much, proly fav oat. I love the color work on this one, as its the ending of the whole story and it means to be dark themed and shi)
2.Elden ring( dont have to say more, greatest open world game + martin was making lore so couldnt expect less)
3.Sekiro(best fighting system no diff, Japanese setting which feels so cool in comparison to dark fantasy themed setting in othe fromsoft games)
4.DS2(gonna be thrown tomatoes but i really dont dislike the game at all. The versatility this game gives you is immaculate. I love the dlcs sm and ofc, DA DRIP😈)
5.DS1 (atmosphere is just on another level. The world building is crazy. Buuut, the mid and endgame feels kinda junky imo. Could have easily competed in top 3 but the tomb of giants, bed of chaos and seath feel just so off.)
6. BB(i cant say i dislike the game, i just dont like it as much as any other games on list, boss quality in main game is...well...u get it. Only liked like gherman, nurse and maybe amelia. But dlc slaps)
Looking forward to play demon souls but still no ps5(((
Ps. I love every single game in its own way, theres none i dislike/hatr
All valid criticisms and praises W
Never play demon souls
My ranking
1. Elden Ring
2.Dark Souls 1
3.Dark Souls 3
4.Blood Borne
5.Sekiro
..
..
6.Dark Souls 2 (Difficulty in this game doesn’t make me feel any challenged, but it make me annoyed)
@@ruttyong114 W list ds2 difficulty is mostly just artificial difficulty
1. Bloodborne
2. Dark Souls 3
3. Dark Souls 1
4. Sekiro
5. Elden Ring
6. Dark Souls 2
7. Demon’s Souls
@@froakie1404 pretty good list but why is Elden ring so low what u don’t like abt it
@@MimicMora I really liked it overall but I find it kinda annoying to replay because of how much downtime it has compared to the other games, not a huge open world fan overall tho so it’s mostly a me thing, also I think it kinda falls apart near the end similarly to ds1 in terms of balancing especially
the game still hella delivered on level design, atmosphere, lore, etc and some of the bosses are among from’s best
@@froakie1404 u have the exact same critics as me so I fully understand
Mine (top 3 are interchangeable)
1. Dark Souls
2. Bloodborne
3. Sekiro
4. Elden ring (used to be lower but the dlc really bumped it up)
5. Demons souls
6. DS3
7. DS2
Yo nice list but honestly surprised by Elden ring at the fact that it used to be higher is mad to me
@@MimicMora I didn’t like base game Elden ring as much. I was burned out by open world games at that point and didn’t enjoy the boss designs in general.
However the DLC was near fucking perfect. I think originally I had it at 5 or 6
@@ZaddyGohan fair enough open worlds games can get soo boring
I always felt that dark souls was better than dark souls 3, solely because of the horrendous, boring areas that are after Vordt of the Boreal Valley, to the Abyss Watchers. This is literally enough to turn me away from replaying the game over dark souls
@@juanlongoria4827 same exact feeling
Ds3, bloodborne or Elden ring as my number 1 can’t pick
@@lynxregions6724 all of them are anazing
W list but I personally love bloodborne the most
Elden Ring will always be number 1, then Sekiro at number 2, Bloodborne 3rd for me.
Stop hating on Elden ring bruh it’s not a big deal… plus it’s his opinion and who cares if it’s “open world” and not souls like. Elden ring is a perfect game so shut y’all bullcrap..
1. Bloodborne
2. DS3
3. DS1
4. Elden Ring
5. Demon’s souls
I havent played ds2 or sekiro yet 😔
Sekiro is a must play u have to
Play it
@@MimicMora ik i really want to, specially cuz rn its $10 less than sote
@@Keknov4962 try to plzzzzz
Demon's Souls is very overlooked by the community smh
Still a good game
@@MimicMora Still very overlooked
Fantastic list. This is exactly mine with the exception of swapping Demon's Souls and DS2. Almost all areas in DS2 are below average with rather boring bosses imo. As linear as they are I at least enjoy most of the ones DeS.
Also, finally someone else out there puts DS3 where it belongs. It's a great game but pretty overrated imo. The levels are boring but the bosses were some of the best, at one point in time. They have since been eclipsed by both Sekiro and ER and I find them kind of simplistic now lol
Thanks very true with ds2 but for me idk why I didn’t enjoy des as much it’s probably the bosses and ds3 is the perfect game to boss rush the whole game in. It’s crazy How the next souls game will outclass ER bosses atleast some of them
Funny how bloodborne gets critism about main game bosses yet there’s dark souls 1 in top 3 which has a terrible second half of the game. Horrible bosses, terrible level design, shit areas and annoying enemies.
Funny
@@JDisclmd I just enjoy ds1 more that’s it. That’s why it’s subjective
In my opinion elden ring is the best first playthrough but the worst one to replay. But I think these games should be graded based on their first playthroughs
They are but I just love coming back to play these games repeatedly it and again it’s my fav one soooo
@@MimicMora I love replaying elden ring after I get out of luirnia. I think the early game is so boring to replay though I now I just skip almost everything and only pick up the weapons/talismans I want and golden seeds and tears. The dlc is much more fun to playthrough on its own because of how condensed it is. Thankfully I had like 5 lvl 150 characters just sitting on standby to play it when it came out
@@DreyfusLagoon very true first area is hella boring 2nd time around and dlc u can just boss rush instantly if u want
ER is worst ssouls game. Im playing dlc right now and I hate open world with a passion. Legacy dungeons are good tho, still I miss DS times without open world crap.
My ranking: BB>DS2>DeS>DS1>DS3>ER
@@ReadyAimFire_ wow I understand you hate the open world but it being the worst is kinda crazy but fine and your list has to be the most interesting list fair enough
Bloodborne bosses truly are horrible, I'm playing through it for the first time and I'm surprised no one has ever said it.
99% of bosses are the same monster but with slight variations
No one has said it because bloodborne fans just glaze the game constantly
this is the most common criticism of bloodborne, alongside framerate
Exactly. It gets repetitive after a while
Are you being serious? Have you fought father G, gehrman, martyr logarius? Or even shadows of yharnam, ebrietas, and cleric beast?
That’s not even mentioning the old hunters which has 3 of the best fights in the souls series.
Ds1, ds2, and ER have the same issues arguably to a worser extent
@@Sephirothkingdom782 I said there are 4 good bosses for bloodborne and said that old hunters dlc bosses are amazing I literally say that
Never let bro cook again..
Why? Because he said his opinion?
I liked the bloodborne chalice dungeons, even though they were repetitive (I'm excluding the nightmarish cursed and defiled chalice dungeon)
One of the rare people who actually likes them fair enough
i think sekiro is a really good game but after playing i don't know what it is but there's just something about it strongly dislike also felt like very tidias imo and being honest i really didn't enjoy it, i didn't think to myself after i beat the game how much of a great game it was, i thought to myself that im glad its finally over and don't have to play it again
I’ve never heard anyone not like sekrio but I’m interested why you don’t like it and what ur fav in the series
@@MimicMora i haven't played demon souls or bloodborne because i don't have a playstation but i've played the the dark souls trilogy, sekiro and elden ring. i'd have to say my favourite from what i've played is definetly either elden ring or dark souls 3, my main complaint with dark souls 1 is after ornstein and smough the bosses go down hill and dark souls 2 well i don't talk about that because it was cruel pain and torture
@@yomrwhite607 very understandable choice just imagine if ds1 wasn’t rushed and actually had a good 2nd half
@@MimicMora ikr it might of been even better than elden ring
@@yomrwhite607 fr
Only correct list
7.ds2 as ive not finished it
6.demons souls due to the death mechanic
5.elden ring
3-4.ds3 or ds1 interchangeable depending on my mood
2.sekiro
1.bloodborne
Not bad list but Elden ring way too high but if u don’t like open world then good list
Completely agree with this list, especially with ER because while it is a great game some flaws are just too noticeable for me like the duo fights so I'd personally also put it under Sekiro, ds3, ds1 and BB
@@J0C0M The duo fights are not a problem if you actually summon LOL. In fact it's the only game where gank bosses can be fun. Problem is with the players not summoning against gank for some reason
@@youssefessam3164Totally agree
@@J0C0Myou’re allowed to summon for dual fights so it’s fair game for me
DS2 is Way better than ds1 and demon souls but people just follow the trends 😐
@@peshunter9630 ain’t a trend game isn’t that good and it’s just a opinion
@@MimicMora i meen the trend of hating DS2 there were many cool idea in ds2 all of it applicated in eldin ring and people loved it and ds1 bosses are pretty similar to ds2 but everyone say ds1 bosses were better 🤷 like you said it's just an opinion
@@peshunter9630 I praised ds2 for its good ideas just needs a remake
7. Demons Souls
6. DS2
The quality gets way better from here:
5. Sekiro ( Best Bosses in the genre and great fighting mechanics. But zero weapon variety and the level design and exploration are the weakest in the entire series)
4. DS3 ( Great Bosses and overall a very solid game with few negatives. However the world and levels are not interconnected well like the other games, and not alot of originality)
3. DS1 ( Best semi open world ever made, the world design and interconnection between levels is second to none. Sadly the bosses in the base game are not good)
2. BB ( Like DS1 the world design is great and art direction is superb, the bosses even though still not comparable to the newer games were a big improvement over DS1 and DS2. The big negative for me is the build variety and weapons, you can literally play the whole game without feeling the need to change weapon and there is very little build variety. Compare that to the many build options you can try out in Elden Ring its insane)
1. Elden Ring ( Greatest open world ever made. Its one of the very few games out there that makes you live out your fantasy dream. The world building and biome variety are excellent. And unlike other games if you are stuck with a boss you can explore and come back stronger than ever. Build variety is insane with so many cool build options you can try out. The legacy dungeons, medium dungeons, small dungeons the open world all make very unique experiences when meshed together. Only negative for me is the repeat bosses but I dont really hate them)
@@youssefessam3164W list and explanation I do wish that sekiro had some weapons like in ninja gaiden but yeah and the thing with bloodborne is soo true i never change my weapon
We have the same "worst" and best in our list but all the rest is totally different lol
Here's mine:
1: Elden Ring
2: DS3
3: Sekiro
4: DS2
5: Bloodborne
6: DS1
7: DeS
@@bjeurn2273 wow that’s completely different which games was ur first
@@MimicMora Elden Ring was my first soulsborne game 2 yrs ago 😅 after 3 playthroughs I started playing DS3, then DeS but only a little bit before moving to Sekiro.
After that I played DS1 and then DS2. The last game I started playing was Bloodborne.
I never really finished DeS but it always feels like a chore and I'll see when I will finish it
A big factor for me are the bosses and I think ER mainbosses, DS3 and Sekiro are a league on their own.
I share the same opinion with you about BB's bosses and I think DS1 and DeS really disappointed boss wise. Only O&S, artorias and Manus where standouts for me while there where a lot of bad ones like Capra demon and Bed Of Chaos.
I do think I enjoyed DS2 more than the average souls player. Idk man but I always was so excited about playing it when I was in my playthroughs. I can't really tell you what it was but It had something only ER had for me. If it wasn't for the BS like ADP, the hitboxes and the Runbacks, it would rank even higher.
@@bjeurn2273 playing the best ones first then moving to the worser ones must feel bad honestly ds2 had soo much potential
@@MimicMora i must say i really like every one of them with the exception maybe of DeS. all the rest are A's and S tiers for me, the fact that DS1 and BB are lower doesn't make it bad for me. they're still one of the best games ever played. I also love the world building of DS1 and seeing Anor Londo for the first time. or the whole vibe and combat and music of BB. also lady maria is top 10 FS boss ever for me.
they're all masterpieces ;)
and im curious to see what DS2 would have been if they had more time to develop the game
@@bjeurn2273 of course they are all masterpieces but I meant u went from best quality to lowest quality if u get me
My list:
1-Elden ring
2-Dark souls 1
3-Sekiro
4-Dark souls 3
5-Bloodborne
Still no play Demon souls or Dark souls 2
We have a similar list just flip them around W list
My top 3 would be:
1) Bloodborne
2) Dark souls 3
3) Sekiro
Also i don't really agree with the critiques to Bloodborne that much.
The bosses in the base game were just normal for the most of it, as the hunter couldn't costantly face super duper hunters and had also to focus on Kins and failed experiments.
The only really bad ones in my opinion are Micolash due to him being just a strong npc and the witches of Hemwick for just their poor design.
The chalice dungeons varied in beauty and hatred, as some were fabulous with good bosses while others were straight up hard mode things or farming material, you either hate it or love it, they are not useless nor unplayable, they just.. it depends on wether or not you're trying to get a platinum.
I cannot understand unfortunately your love for Elden Ring, i finished it 3-4 times by now with even another character but.. i despise it, i seriously despise most bosses to the point the black bell hunter is my favourite.
I don't like to explore that much, i think fighting is much more important in a game than just get into many good areas.
And this is the same reason why i don't like by *that* much dark souls 1, good exploration but most of the times boring or bad bosses (some demons + BOC + Seath), and i were not used to blocking as neither DS3 or Bloodborne told me that as my first games.
I think in ur case as y played the much faster ones first then went on to the slower/ worse ones u have already experienced amazing combat but then went and amazing bosses from ds3 but then u went to ds1 which is completely different but Elden ring if you don’t like open world and exploration same thing with me I hate open world rpgs but Elden ring is an expection
For bloodborne I said the plat is annoying because of the chalice dungeon and the bosses a lot of them are bad most of them are
@@MimicMora Well, it depends on the chalice dungeons, wether it's that of Amygdala or Yahnram (which was a good boss fight tho).
And could you tell me which bosses on bloodborne's base game annoyed you the most? I did not want to fight fairly just Micolash, maybe the One reborn and the Witches of Hemwick. But the others were pretty clean to me.
@@ThefrenziedMercury moon prescience rom ebrieatas celestial emesery u said the others and the rest are like a 6/10 expect for a few
@@MimicMora Moon presence was underwhelming i give you that, but a fit boss after having fought Gehrman.
Ebrietas was not that bad and pretty enterataining.
Celestial Emyssary is not bad, it's easy.
Rom is just a pain for speedrunners but he isn't that bad and actually teaches you about patience.
Also Mergo's wet nurse, the shadows of Yahrnam and the Dark beast Paarl were honestly fun in my opinion.
Finally a person who loves Blood Bourne hates Elden Ring but does not say it's a bad game you just said you personally did not like the bosses which is much better than the kids in one of the top comments have a war over it
Bloodborne 4 😂😂
Ironically
I put Bloodborne, sekiro And Bloodborne at S rank
Bloodborne was my first souls game so it’s special for me
Ds1 and ds3 at A tier
Ds2, DS at B tier
Maybe demon souls at C tier but still liked it
Pretty valid tier list but bloodborne was soo good u had to put it twice
@@MimicMora haha that’s funny
Cough cough Lies Of P
First time I agree 100% with the list lol. Weeeell....maybe switch ds3 and bb. But that's a big maybe.
Personally, BB and ER are tie as number 1
DS1 number 2
DS3 and Sekiro tie as number 3
DS2 number 4
Demons souls number 5
@@cletokings4302 pretty valid list
Oh god where do I start with this list.
Well firstly, I think bloodborne is better than Elden ring. Bloodborne has unmatched aesthetic and combat, and also contains my favorite boss of all time. Elden ring’s open world does nothing but put artificial distance between you and the content, forcing you to look up how to get to secret main bosses.
Having DS1 in the top 3 is disgraceful and in bad taste, especially being above bloodborne. Dark souls 1 is clunky and garbage in comparison to fromsoft’s other games. I don’t care how good the world building is, the game has to be fun to PLAY. I’m sure it was good in 2011 or whatever, but catch up to the current generation will you? Also the second half is straight garbage.
Dark souls 3 is an improvement on dark souls 1 and 2 in every possible way, yet it’s somehow lower than 1? Interesting. Nostalgia must carry DS1’s ranking.
Sekiro is overrated, that’s for sure. The combat was built for 1v1 encounters yet only like 10% of the game is actually that. They stuff every mini boss arena full of enemies and it’s stupid difficulty that’s not even fun. The bosses are good, so I wish they made up more of the game.
So personally:
DS1 < DeS =< DS2
@@Travisaurus bloodborne combat and atmosphere is amazing but my main criticism is the bosses and I also criticize the open world in Elden ring
For me I enjoy dark souls 1 to this day I’m like on my 6th playthrough and is the game clunky yes but using ninja flip ring it feels pretty good 2nd half is garbage sure but I still enjoy the game and always find my self coming back to it
Dark souls 3 didn’t improve everything imo it has the worst areas and I hate most of them
Sekrio combat is amazing and is made for 1v1 which all the actual main bosses are. But the mini bosses u can kill the enemies using stealth
You’re supposed to use stealth to take out the enemies around the mini bosses. Also why they give you all the ninjutsus, you use those enemies to your advantage. You missed out almost all the positives of sekiro. Great level design, it 100% feels the best to play out of all the games due to the new movement system and the modernised style of gameplay instead of their age old slow style they normally use, combat that actually allows you to stand toe to toe with enemies instead of rolling around everywhere.
DS1 connectivity is on another level, I’ve never seen anything like it. You mention that bosses are only a small portion of the game for sekiro but ignore that the exact same argument can be used for DS1 in reverse
You can’t name the flaws of things you dislike and ignore the flaws of the things you like.
You said bloodborne has your favourite boss and ignored all the mid bosses it has. I like them but the difference is quality against sekiro, DS3 and elden ring boss wise is heavy and that has to be mentioned. Horrendous healing system too, also has a lot of clunkiness. You spent half your comment complaining about clunkiness and ignored that sekiro is the least clunky game lol
Bloodbourne having the best combat is opinionated the main game bosses average at a Low a teir yes the dlc trio highly carries the boss ranking the mid bosses in BB overwhelm the great ones in the main game looking at elden ring the main bosses their are 2 actually bad bosses needed to beat the game fire giant and foreskin duo back to back is a sour taste but then you get maliketh Godfrey and radagon which have movesets that have great combo mix ups that are told by where you ate positioned
I don’t know why people refuse to acknowledge the levels of ds3 being boring
@@nickzanoni582 fr man
yea ds3 is way better than bloodborne lmao
They interchangeable they both have good combat bloodborne areas are better ds3 bosses are better
@@MimicMora 30 fps just makes bloodborne so mid only reason why i struggled on orphan of kos
@@habu257 yeah it defo is hella annoying but don’t make the game mid
bloodborne too high
@@dedde1311 nah bro
ds1 is ranked too high the game has too many flaws and ds3 is too low it has some of the best bosses in souls series
Yeah Ik but i personally enjoyed playing through ds1 much much more than ds3
I disagree. DS3 is kind of the "average" Fromsoft game at this point. What does it actually do best? Music maybe? ER and Sekiro beat it in level and boss design. And DS1 still has the best overall world in any of From's games
Ds3 is average, it’s right where it should be. I agree ds1 should be lower though, the second half is irredeamable garbage
I don’t really agree with the bloodborne criticism tbh. Blood vials become inoffensive after around halfway into the game and they feel good to use too, and chalice dungeons are entirely optional so I’ve never understood criticizing them to make the whole game look worse. Removing chalice dungeons wouldn’t make the game better in any way, and it’d even lose cool weapons like the chikage which is a more mechanically complex weapon than anything in DS1 or ER.
The base game boss lineup is also very contradictory because ds1 has a similair issue to an even bigger extent because that game literally has like only 1 truly great fight in the base game being orenstein and smough. Elden ring suffers from the same issue and even its best bosses in the base game have heavy issues. The only boss in ER base game that id say is truly S tier is mohg because he actually has a nice flow to his fight and isn’t inconsistent with his attack timings.
@@Sephirothkingdom782 I talk abt all this in the vid and I only said chalice dungeon is bad for the platinum
@@MimicMorayea I agree chalice dungeons are bad for trying to platinum but I personally dont rlly use platinum trophy difficulty to weigh in whether a mechanic is bad or not but that’s understandable.
I personally would’ve ranked it atleast higher than ds1 mainly cuz the game never really falls off the same way ds1 did after lordvessel. I also think ds1 bosses are worse on average imo, and the dlcs are super close but old hunters edges it out cuz all 3 levels are amazing.
@@MimicMora I think my previous comment got deleted but yes it’s understandable that it may be annoying to try and platinum with the dungeons but I personally don’t weigh platinum trophy difficulty as negatives to a game.
I would’ve personally atleast ranked it higher than ds1 cuz I feel like ds1 is inconsistent in its quality whereas bloodborne never really falls off the same way ds1 does. I also think the bosses are generally better in the base game especially. DLCs are very close but I think old hunters edges out mainly cuz of all 3 levels (hunters nightmare, research hall, and fishing hamlet) all being amazing.
@@Sephirothkingdom782I only said that cuz I’m ranking it overall as game and I only like ds1 more cuz it’s my first souls and I love it
I mean if you discount chalice dungeons because they are options that's like saying Ash Lake, painted world of Ariamis, Archdragon Peak and most of the other optional content in the games do not matter because they are optional.
The content is in the game, it should be criticised.
1. Bloodborne
2. Dark souls
3. Dark souls 3
4. Sekiro
5. Elden ring
6. Dark souls 2
I haven't played demon souls
I can’t believe u out ds1 above ds3, in my opinion ds3 rivals Bloodborne
Bloodborne nice and all, but ds2 was the peak of gaming
@@thatheway peak of gaming is crazyyy
fact that you are calling demon's souls bosses gimmicky because of ankle breaking whilst fire giant in elden ring 14 years later uses the same mechanism- goes to show how dumb and subjective your rankings are. Limited healing? dude its the upside of having unlimited healing with all the grass you can farm similar to how you farm souls in between bosses. Your list is a derivative lip service to all videos in your echo chamber. demons souls is the og and deserves to be goated for all the inspiration. And for the love of god you dont even have bloodborne in top 3 😂
Well obviously my ranking is subjective that’s the whole point and each souls has a gimmick boss but most des bosses are gimmicky. I didn’t say it’s bad I said it’s the worst compared to others and how is it fun to farm for healing
Ds1 is not better than ds3 and bloodborne
Interms of gameplay they are better but I genuinely just really enjoy ds1 and it’s my first so it holds a special place in my heart
Ds3 was a great game but a product of corporate milking of the cash cow. Ds1 has the kind or magic to it ds3 couldn't replicate. As a whole, that is.
@@MimicMora what gameplay the combat is slow and janky and most of the areas are terrible like catacombs and blight town, same bosses again and again and no fast travel . only lore is amazing thats it
@@mikhailkalinin6536 ds1 is overrated and nostalgic thats it
@@aganbraganca4156 unbelievable shit take
Elden Ring number one? Another cringe normie tier list. Elden Ring can't be in the frist place by any means cuz souls formula don't work in openworld. I don't say elden ring is bad but it can't be on first place that's it. It's litterally dark souls 3 without any fresh experiance for players who played thousands of hours in ds3.
Elden ring has better legacy dungeons than any souls game can even dream of.
@@mikhailkalinin6536 yeah sure good point, shame what half of the game we have to ride horse at empty map. If game would be only legacy dugeones with few more insted of empty map it would be much better.
@@user-tj6je3of4f if ds3 was all like lothric and irythil it would be much better than it was too.
@@mikhailkalinin6536 still much better than riding a horse.
@user-tj6je3of4f how is running on foot through an empty swamp better than riding a horse through an empty field lol. Both are a filler content
Guy puts elden ring on 1st place HAHAHAHAH, dark souls 3/bb/sekiro are all superior game to elden ring, prolly he liked it cause he can use summons
Elden ring >>>> midborne
Cry baby
Bro doesn’t know what an opinion is
Mabye your just butt hurt over an opinion dude. Mabye he's like me, like many others who love open world games, esspessally a souls open world. His tier list isn't the word of god so don't get upset over it
More replay value for ER. Making my summons fight enemies/bosses i already have beaten gives me happy brain chemicals.