The 2 critics are so unprofessional. How could they criticize if they don’t know Reggae music. Most disappointingly, both of them didn’t even heard about the song “Lemon Tree”? OMG They are much less good than the audiences.
[Friendly reminder before you continue watching] This reaction video are done by musicians who never heard of classic songs like "Lemon Tree" and "Don't worry be happy" before
Lemon tree is a famous song, that’s why the Chinese audience started dancing because they all know the Chinese cover of it. It was sung by a female Taiwanese singer and yellow combine the Chinese cover with the original English version and added don’t worry be happy with it too.
I don't know why people use condoms instead of animal intestines during sex, I'm not a professional sex professor but I think people is going against to tradition.
The thing is, it doesn't really have to be authentic reggae, especially when most of your audiences might not have any clue about reggae, let alone if they will accept an authentic reggae adaptation of a song that is very popular in the Mandarin market, considering this is still a competition that you will want to gain as many votes as possible. Also, I'd like to point out that the intro of this song here is actually paying homage to a very classic song from Bob Marley, which is "I shot the sheriff". Idk how you didn't point that out since you seemed to know reggae quite well lol.
![[NoNo's Reaction] Professional vocal teacher evaluates all Huang Xuan's performance in Singer 2024!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/B2_sJv5h88I/mqdefault.jpg)
![Quando Rondo - Life Goes On [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eIf3fhMXAow/mqdefault.jpg)
這個影片就是快轉跳過不用看了！他們在B站也有，我也是不看的。連原版Lemon Tree都沒聽過的人，有什麼資格來做這首歌的reaction，比一般的觀眾還不夠格。而且這是改編，加了很多原素和細節在裡面的，黃宣改得我很喜歡😘
我也是看了三分鐘就發現他們不太夠資格評論這一個作品
The 2 critics are so unprofessional. How could they criticize if they don’t know Reggae music. Most disappointingly, both of them didn’t even heard about the song “Lemon Tree”? OMG They are much less good than the audiences.
No wonder. People like to pretend.
很主觀的去評這首歌，卻不用開放的心去接受其他音樂
沒有人說整首歌要用雷鬼，早已融入不同的風格了，用"正統"雷鬼唱中文歌，你以為中文的咬字適合這樣唱 ?
這首歌的編曲安排服務的對象是舞台，而不是唱片，don't worry be happy 接得超順，用這種方式跟觀眾互動比跳來跳去還厲害，你如果懂這首歌的背景，你就知道"don't worry be happy" 是讓悲傷幽默自嘲的檸檬樹有一個喘氣的空間，某種程度也代表yellow想要傳達的價值觀。不會欣賞歌手的安排就算了，也不用開放的心去享受歌曲，看不懂時尚就說是你媽衣櫃的衣服。咍~我也是學藝術的，太自以為是的去看每件事，真的會有一堆盲點，做的作品淪為自嗨
這麼出名的歌曲，兩位樂評人還未聽過？？？？
好奇怪…
一直說yellow及伴奏不夠雷鬼然後一直說自己不是雷鬼專家…？
要看到這樣一個一面倒負評的reaction也是蠻困難的 只能說真有你的😂😂
也許你們有某領域的專長和喜好
但很抱歉，比起前者，我感受到更多兩位的無知、傲慢與重點錯誤
如果真的是想用負面手法賺流量，那還真是個不聰明的方法
當然，你們自己的頻道自己錄的影片，想評什麼就評什麼，想如何評都可以，是你們的自由
也因此，網路留言的反饋也是你們要概括接受的
很爛的評論
[Friendly reminder before you continue watching] This reaction video are done by musicians who never heard of classic songs like "Lemon Tree" and "Don't worry be happy" before
兩位在螢幕前的律動看起來很好笑。
I feel bad about their reactions.
If arranged this song as reggae completely, it can’t be accepted by audiences easily.
Lemon tree is a famous song, that’s why the Chinese audience started dancing because they all know the Chinese cover of it. It was sung by a female Taiwanese singer and yellow combine the Chinese cover with the original English version and added don’t worry be happy with it too.
這個播主對華語樂壇非常無知，蘇慧倫唱的中文檸檬樹在兩岸都非常出名 ，這個人什麼都不知道，就開始胡說八道。
@@tsaivikki3293 他看起來可能不是華人吧，也不會中文的感覺，所以對華語樂壇不熟是可以理解的。其實現在很多小朋友也不知道這首歌了😭
@@greentofuhouse就算沒聽過，也應該知道什麼是美、什麼是醜吧！除非是......
This reaction really sucks,
The two musicians don't have enough culture background to understand this piece of music. Find it elsewhere.
R U sure they are "musician"?
well, it's reggae influence pop music performance.
黃宣來自我們台灣，咬字唱腔口氣，本來就與大陸不同。
I don't know why people use condoms instead of animal intestines during sex, I'm not a professional sex professor but I think people is going against to tradition.
給一個建議，我是第一次看你們的視頻，穿紅色衣服的主持人，因為身體一直不停止的前後晃動，造成我們視覺上有些不適，頭昏，甚至我需要避開視線，才能繼續觀賞下去。建議您可以注意一下這點，不自覺地不停晃動，對觀賞者視覺上的影響。謝謝您
居然還要求經理人跟觀眾不懂雷鬼的節拍，笑死我！管太多了吧！
他們連原版檸檬樹都不知道了，我想就不用太苛刻他們了😂😂😂😂
他們也不知道這首歌的原意是要對死者的思念有所釋懷，所以才有don't worry be happy
😂😂他们就知道雷鬼，笑死了😅
You are wrong!
The thing is, it doesn't really have to be authentic reggae, especially when most of your audiences might not have any clue about reggae, let alone if they will accept an authentic reggae adaptation of a song that is very popular in the Mandarin market, considering this is still a competition that you will want to gain as many votes as possible. Also, I'd like to point out that the intro of this song here is actually paying homage to a very classic song from Bob Marley, which is "I shot the sheriff". Idk how you didn't point that out since you seemed to know reggae quite well lol.
I'm disgusted by your reaction.
聽假口音英語，好辛苦。假鬼假掰。留長髮，留鬍子就是音樂人？ 四不像聽過嗎？
“雷鬼”說成“雷結”。不知哪門子的「音樂家」?!?
我只想說你們的節目我也看不到什麼亮點，一整個好像只知道找一些問題，連觀眾的問題，你知道你們看的是流行樂種嗎？一直對著不是傳統雷鬼鼓點重音不確實，瘋了！你改成全都雷鬼風，你看看有黃好聽嗎？中間他也不忘本融合自己原民風格你有聽到嗎？你有聽懂嗎？一首歌在現場找問題，你告訴我誰找不到，你們就不要叫評論音樂，叫做專找音樂問題的節目就好，給我看就是侮辱音樂！
好无语😅出这个reaction有什么意义，简直就是来侮辱人的
@@zhangChristopher但最終只讓人看到他們的無知。
懷疑這個影片故意尬黑蹭歌手熱度….
Lemon Tree 算很有名的吧? 我一開始還想說 痾沒聽過??
😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅雷鬼很重要吗？😢
還有一個重點，星期天及一遍一遍。
星期天、一遍一遍，那是他的原住民台式幽默，從小在台灣這個土地長大的人一聽到就會爆笑！
怎麼有那麼多玻璃心的留言，嚇死
連穿衣服也要酸，就酸民啊！
確實，他們不容外國置喙
Awful! 為賦新詞強說愁。
The japanese Musicians said it correctly.
裝懂