After Israel's response to Iran, what's next? | Ian Bremmer's Quick Take

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 окт 2024

Комментарии • 32

  • @AuralioCabal
    @AuralioCabal 36 минут назад

    Oil production and energy grid next after the US elections.

  • @StevenBrener
    @StevenBrener День назад +4

    Good take. More importantly, how's Moose?

  • @WalterBurton
    @WalterBurton День назад +1

    "With Russian support" would be illicit.

  • @kamranaldavood9249
    @kamranaldavood9249 День назад +2

    Wait for episode 3
    True Promise.

  • @Eiretraveller
    @Eiretraveller День назад

    Thank you.

  • @33stryker
    @33stryker День назад +1

    These tit-for-tat attacks and reprisals of dubious symbolic or PR value are childish and a huge waste of money.

  • @user55book
    @user55book 19 часов назад +2

    Iran shouldn't even be a rival to israel, who has access to full military and technological support as well as huge grants. from the USA.
    The fact that Iran is even a rival shows how weak this temporary gang of crimnals named (israel).

    • @AuralioCabal
      @AuralioCabal 32 минуты назад

      Israel ( Isaac) has always been the Blessed one over Ishmael..

  • @MarceloCarmello-y8s
    @MarceloCarmello-y8s День назад +1

    I appreciated the analysis; it was concise and thorough. Many thanks.

  • @JumpingJack79
    @JumpingJack79 День назад

    I think this is a case of "Everybody has a plan until they get punched in the face". Iran has been asking to get punched and now they lost bigly.
    Ironically, Israel also lost bigly.
    It seems like there are no winners in this stupid fight, only losers who occasionally beat other losers 🙄

  • @LumenMichaelOne
    @LumenMichaelOne День назад +1

    No U.S. Election-Chatter this week??? Oooh-COM'OOOON!... 🤷 ...WyyNooot???

  • @Erik-rp1hi
    @Erik-rp1hi День назад

    Is China going to have Iran's back in this?

  • @BrianFullerPDX1
    @BrianFullerPDX1 День назад +4

    It might take ten or fifteen years but I think this is the beginning of the end of apartheid Israel. People see it now. Obviously the two state solution is permanently dead now (to try to implement it now would certainly trigger an Israeli civil war and Israel has nowhere inside the Green Line to house all of the West Bank squatters that would have to be removed) a one state solution is the only option left. It must become one state with a western democracy wherein ALL are citizens and all stand equal before the law regardless of race, religion or creed. The days of pretending this incredibly brutal form of apartheid is democracy are over now. The truth has been revealed, and even after the war more stories of barbarity will continue to emerge. In order to maintain control of ME oil the empire will need to craft a new narrative.

    • @jasonsheath3294
      @jasonsheath3294 День назад +7

      With all due respect this is an arguably naive statement about an area of the world you dont seem to understand or know much about. For much of the Islamic world (as explicitly stated by the Hamas (Sunni), Hezbollah (Shia) and Iranian (Shia) leadership) peace with Israel is "muhrram" or "forbidden" under Islam. Not only that but Arabic and Persian cultures have a terrible history with Western notions of 'democracy'. This is why autocrats and tyrants have such a long history in the region. And add in Islamic ideas around democracy which further distort the notion of one person one vote (as exemplified in Turkiye where the once proud secular republic of Ataturk has been ground down more and more towards autocracy and Islamic government AND military by Islamist parties and leadership) - and what you are claiming is "inevitable" is the destruction of Israel first at the ballot then through repression and violence. This will never happen. Israel has fought war after war of self defense and admittedly committed some terrible acts (Sabra in Lebanon for one) - but this idea that the Palestinians (like the ones for voted for Hamas and still support them in their bloodlust for the slaughter of Israelis) can suddenly be transformed into your ideal Western democratic state is just not supportable in the context of the conflict. You sound like the neo cons who thought they would wipe out Saddam and suddenly Iraq would turn into a stable and prosperous democratic state to anchor a new middle east and act as a buffer against Iran. Like the neo cons you fundamentally misunderstand the religious, political and culture of the region - this is not an area that can be 'resolved' with a one state solution when one side is sworn to slaughter the other side - the fact you claim it will take 10-15 years to settle down is also ahistorical. For the Palestinians that were displaced in 1948 many of them STILL hold the keys to their families former homes and with legacies of intergenerational resentment towards Israel - engendered by unique and toxic UN institutional support. Meanwhile many of the Israelis are descendants from the 700K to 1 million Mizrahi Jews were were forcibly dispossessed and displaced from their homes across North Africa and elsewhere in the Middle East beginning in 1948 and who had to flee to Israel, many of whom with nothing as their land and assets were seized by Islamic governments who exiled them. These Mizrahi Jews then helped to build a prosperous state where there had been little economic development before - not looking back and not living in resentment. This is the heart of the issue which you are missing. Finally, the Koran speaks directly against the Jew and for many Muslims the existence of a Jewish state in the Levant is a religious abomination that must fail and be destroyed as per the will of Allah - ignoring the existence of a Jewish state BEFORE Mohammed existed. The fact that Israel keep surviving and thriving only deepens the resentment of the Jewish state as it flies in the face of Islamic scripture.

    • @terrymckenzie8786
      @terrymckenzie8786 День назад

      @@jasonsheath3294You cannot run a million Muslims out of their homes and burn down 200 villages. It dose t matter how you spin the BS. They have a right to return to their homes, and learn to live with them in a democracy. It’s not tough. You’re not a chosen people and you have to get this BS out of your head.

    • @RyanSemmel77
      @RyanSemmel77 День назад +2

      @@jasonsheath3294quit saying stuff that is so nuanced and complex and start saying more stuff like “genocide” and “apartheid”!

    • @jasonsheath3294
      @jasonsheath3294 День назад +1

      @@RyanSemmel77 lol

    • @KarimElfouly
      @KarimElfouly 3 часа назад

      The beauty of the new emerging global order and the demise of the settlement in the ME is that liars like this will not have an audience anymore

  • @michaelwellen2866
    @michaelwellen2866 День назад

    Called it. I knew they weren't actually going to have a war.

  • @joeyjoejoe314
    @joeyjoejoe314 День назад +5

    Ian, you are a smart guy, but this is a huge Israeli failure.

  • @AbaddonianG
    @AbaddonianG День назад +1

    Iran fired ballistic missiles .
    Israel too did the same.
    But Israel firef them from the air , something which even the USAF can't do .
    Simply because it has no Air launched ballistic missiles .
    About the interception efforts.
    Only the US, Russia, China, India and Israel have the capability to intercept ballistic missiles . All ballistic missiles travel at Hypersonic speeds almost impossible to shoot down.
    Iran can't shoot down shit.
    It's S 300 were destroyed from outside 8ts air space through long ranfe fires.
    Anyways, Israel has said that it yet hasn't avenged the attack on Netanyahu so it'd attack Iran at keast once more .

    • @user55book
      @user55book 19 часов назад

      Iran shouldn't even be a rival to isreel, who has access to full military and technological support as well as huge grants. from the USA.
      The fact that Iran is even a rival shows how weak this temporary gang of crimnals named (isreel).

  • @carolbennett1427
    @carolbennett1427 День назад

    Thank you