£1000 vs £10,000 Road Bike

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 мар 2023
  • Three bikes that do the same job, but how much more do you get for your money and are there diminishing returns?
    The bikes in this video are:
    £1000 Scott Speedster 50 (with some small upgrades)
    £5000 Scott Addict RC
    £10,000 Scott Foil Ultimate
    All bikes have the same 28mm hutchinson fusion5 tyres set up with butyl inner tubes.
    Support the channel, check out my streetwear brand here - wearethewildones.co.uk/collec...
    PATREON if you'd like to help support the channel for less than the price of a greggs espresso & vegan sausage roll: / franciscade
    the main GoPro GRILL mount i use: www.prostandard.com/?ref=0Wo1...
    the Low Down Axle mount i use: www.nut-r.co.uk/fc
    the GoPro I use: prf.hn/l/ryjmwQn
    Really small action camera: www.insta360.com/sal/go_2?ins...
    360 action camera: www.insta360.com/sal/one_x2?i...
    25% off your first purchase of STYRKR Carbs and Gels: bit.ly/36WrFyn use code: FCADE25
    / francis_cade
    / francisccade
    LUTs - You can buy my LUT for $4 (or above) by becoming a supporter on Patreon here: / franciscade
    MUSIC - I used Musicbed, use the same music for your videoswith my affiliate link here: fm.pxf.io/c/3541078/1347628/1...
    GT85 (The stuff I use to clean & maintain my bikes): bit.ly/2RZCAji
    The following companies (that you'll see in my content) support me either financially or with free stuff, so huge thanks to these guys for helping the channel thrive:
    Attacus Cycling,
    SCOTT,
    MET Helmets,
    Shimano,
    fidlock,
    Hutchinson Tyres
    Sungod
    Tailfin
    GT85
    Garmin
    Parcours Wheels
    #cycling #bikes #bicycle
  • СпортСпорт

Комментарии • 507

  • @kalebzehr6850
    @kalebzehr6850 Год назад +260

    I remember the first time I rode a Specialized Allez after only ever riding $150 walmart bikes and it absolutely blew my mind. Then a couple years later I tried a $3000 bike and that blew my mind. That same day I tried a $11,000 bike and was like "That's it?" lol My personal sweet spot is around The 105 mechanical with a carbon frame. The difference between the entry bike and the next level is massive, but between that and the super high end one is barely there in my opinion.

    • @owensnicholas
      @owensnicholas Год назад +23

      As soon as you hit 105, the returns diminish sharply.
      I agree. 105 is the sweet spot for me. It always works, it’s nice to use, and it’s not too pricey.

    • @YuichiTamaki
      @YuichiTamaki Год назад +11

      Great comment! I just got a bike equipped with 105. Good to know that after that you don't get much more.

    • @arbuncklecycling
      @arbuncklecycling Год назад +9

      #groupsetofthepeople

    • @chickenpoodle
      @chickenpoodle Год назад +2

      which allez were you riding? there were quite a few iterations of them, and they weren't all built the same.
      if it were one of the better allez models, and if you were able to toss some top spec components on that allez, that would have blew your mind too. hahah

    • @kalebzehr6850
      @kalebzehr6850 Год назад +2

      @@chickenpoodle Base model with claris! 2018

  • @Johnox_
    @Johnox_ Год назад +233

    £1000 bike with tourney groupset 🤯

    • @dan_lazaro
      @dan_lazaro Год назад +42

      Ikr that's a Tiagra minimum for 1k maybe 105 and maybe even carbon on some brands

    • @badspyro
      @badspyro Год назад +38

      Carrera Vanquish, half the price with carbon fork and Claris. For just over £1k Boardman do a full carbon with 105 on special at the moment. £1k for tourney is quite frankly more money than sense.

    • @diningtable2
      @diningtable2 Год назад +6

      @@dan_lazaro allow me to introduce the big Chinese bike brands of Asia: Java, Pardus, Elves, etc.

    • @vaska00762
      @vaska00762 Год назад +11

      I have a £1.5k custom build with SRAM Force 22. I've seen £200 bikes in Halfords and Decathlon with Tourney 7 speed.

    • @GCPerformance18
      @GCPerformance18 Год назад +8

      I have $600 dollar cruiser bikes on my sales floor with that same tourney group on there lol

  • @Ak-vc4oc
    @Ak-vc4oc Год назад +168

    I think the reason that there's such a stark difference between the 1000-pound bike and the more expensive ones is because Scott does not necessarily specialise in entry-level bikes and other bike brands such as B-Twin or Vitus tend to offer much better value bikes at the low-end price range. While I do understand you're sponsored by Scott, maybe comparing the absolute best bikes in each price range regardless of a brand would give a much better comparison, love the videos tho so keep doing what you're doing!
    Edit: spelling, also thank you sm Cade Media for responding!

    • @evertonyoung4031
      @evertonyoung4031 Год назад +19

      Totally agree that Scott £1,000 bike is nowhere the same build as a Cannondale CAD 12 or 10.

    • @NikeonaBike
      @NikeonaBike Год назад +13

      Another thing to consider is that in normal economies at the 1000 price point, a used bike stands a good chance of being a far, far, far better value proposition provided you know enough about bikes to not get ripped off.

    • @fotografamos4083
      @fotografamos4083 Год назад +13

      Totally agree. Decathlon and their RC520 range is unbelievably good value. 850 pounds for a 105 equipped disc brake bike is unbeatable, even if at 10kg.

    • @gavinward3176
      @gavinward3176 Год назад

      I would be very interested in their thoughts on Colnagos, not many reviews of those, especially compared to other brands

    • @cccpkingu
      @cccpkingu Год назад +1

      The difference is the wheels. Put the better wheels on and it is up there too.

  • @JayLato
    @JayLato Год назад +46

    That Blue Scott is one of the best looking bikes I’ve seen.

    • @sail5820
      @sail5820 Год назад

      yeah looks really cool

    • @silvagc
      @silvagc Год назад

      Love it! Not sure about 1x setup, but for me, this looks like a great road bike!

  • @chrisobyrne5675
    @chrisobyrne5675 Год назад +34

    My £1k bike from 2018, an Allez Elite, has 105 and a carbon fork so it shows how at that price point today the spec has to be diluted to hit the same value. Recognised the testing hill!

    • @a1white
      @a1white Год назад +5

      The Tourney bike here is so poor value. Really shocking. If you shop around you can get Sora or even Tiagra for not much more than that.

    • @PhilOsGarage
      @PhilOsGarage Год назад +3

      I was actually thinking the opposite, the £1000 bike is a terrible spec for the money. For significantly less you can get a Triban or Vitus that is not only lighter, but will have a carbon fork and a better group set. I don’t think it’s a fair representation of a £1000 bike, tbh the spec wouldn’t be competitive at half that price now.

    • @tomweis1194
      @tomweis1194 Год назад +1

      2017 BMC Team Machine AL01 - aluminum + carbon fork + 105 5800: $1100 (on discount). On my budget and at my age, I don't see ever needing to spend more or to upgrade.

    • @nen_star
      @nen_star Год назад

      scott got terrible value for money

  • @michaellangfitt2077
    @michaellangfitt2077 Год назад +2

    Perhaps the most realistic and honest review I have heard. Other than EGO [which is a definite factor for some] you only need what YOUR level of riding demands. Fantastic reviews.

  • @cb6866
    @cb6866 Год назад +5

    Thanks Francis and Jimmi...the 1K , with a few upgrades . I have 3 bikes , MTB , gravel and road, cuz I'm a dope . Newly retired , knew nothing , and wasn't sure where I'd be riding ....yeah .The gravel is my favorite for many reasons , the other 2 barely get ridden . Horses for courses . Thanks to Nic and Catherine as well , for her stearn rebuttal , and sense of humor

  • @PP-cm4re
    @PP-cm4re Год назад +7

    £1000 bike with tourney groupset and no carbon forks is a rip off.

  • @brabrabarabra5027
    @brabrabarabra5027 Год назад +3

    €10.000+ bikes exist so €5.000 bikes seem a reasonable priced bike to the buyer. It's a selling strategy.

    • @Mas421
      @Mas421 Год назад

      Yes, called the „anchoring effect“

  • @WILDFOXRUNNING
    @WILDFOXRUNNING Год назад +7

    This video was awesome Francis. Great insight and funny as always. I got a 600€ road bike, upgraded to carbon wheels and a bigger Sora 9 speed cassette and it does everything amazingly well like you said. Also got a giant Trinity TT bike for Triathlon racing and some training but the road bike is where I do most of the mileage and I don’t need more, would be nice but don’t need it. Cheers

  • @qibble455
    @qibble455 Год назад +6

    The 5k bike is the sweet spot, The 10k bike is aspirational and mainly for marketing imho. I really enjoy your videos CM.

  • @garethjackson3545
    @garethjackson3545 Год назад +8

    Thanks Francis & Jimmy this comparison is great appreciated! I'm not fat free or whippet like so there's no point in me having a super-bike; however, the £5k would be just as far as I could justify for my weight and ability 😉. Thanks again, great work & keep it up.

  • @Aragorn.Strider
    @Aragorn.Strider Год назад +2

    Last year I kinda bought the middle one (although half of that price even) and still feels amazing to me. Carbon frame and fork. Hydraulic disc brakes.

  • @matt_m126
    @matt_m126 Год назад

    I've been riding an alloy Devinci Hatchet Claris and upgraded to a Trek Domane SL5 Gen 4. No electronic gears yet, but mechanical 105. I have not ridden it yet, because Canada + snow, but this video got me even more excited.

  • @vidyapremkumar3851
    @vidyapremkumar3851 Год назад +10

    Catherine has the best response to the 10000 pound bike i have ever seen !

    • @DC-lu5qs
      @DC-lu5qs Год назад +2

      No matter how great your bike, if you don't fuel properly you're gonna have a bad day. She has good instincts

  • @theonemanopinion2764
    @theonemanopinion2764 Год назад +1

    I’m riding a bike a built from bits! frame is a 2019 vitus zenium I paid £200 for, aluminium but full carbon forks. £400 for full 105 disc group set. Wheels need upgrading but we’re only £90 used shimano RS. Carbon seatpost, stem and bars. Weighs 8.7kg. Cost me £750 to build.

  • @brizzie2009
    @brizzie2009 Год назад +2

    I’d buy the £5K bike.
    At the moment I ride a Bianchi Oltre on the road, Diamondback Haanjo on mixed surfaces and a Trek 1120 on adventures.
    You have set a very high bar with this new format - keep it going! 👍

  • @tdavis85
    @tdavis85 Год назад

    i love you guys vids. they're totally no bull and relate to us normal people who don't or can't afford mental bikes. and your sense of humour adds to it

  • @MikeNorthrup
    @MikeNorthrup Год назад

    Have to agree about the new format-you’re setting a high bar. A great vertical comparison at 3 price points.

  • @mikelivingston2845
    @mikelivingston2845 Год назад

    I continue to ride my 2009 Cervelo S2 aero road bike. Over the years I’ve replaced the drivetrain and wheels several times but always stayed close to the original build. I currently have mechanical 11-speed Ultegra components and Vision Team 35 alloy wheels. I’d love to see a comparison of a 2009 S2 and a 2023 Cervelo S2 - or similar comparison of the same make and model bike 10-15 apart. Loved this video. Looking forward to more like it.

  • @ElGranCoati
    @ElGranCoati Год назад

    Oh man, I have a 6-year with me, already used when I bought it, aluminium frame with carbon *steel* forks, old 9s-sora with replaced Sensah Ignite shifters (my poor STIs just DIED at the beginning of the year), and I absolutely LOVE that bike, it was cheap, everything is cheap to replace when needed, and I don't race, just ride for fun!

  • @edwardsnowdenofficial
    @edwardsnowdenofficial Год назад +1

    Love my Aero Bike! Felt AR4, its a beast and soo fast it scares me sometimes!! However got a Giant Defy I bought off eBay during lockdown for £115 and that is a superb bike as well!

  • @rangersmith4652
    @rangersmith4652 Год назад

    I really enjoy comparisons like this. The Speedster's spec is very similar to a bike in the same price range that I bought -- the Tommaso Imola. It's got an alloy frame and a steel fork, but it's also wearing Claris 3x8. With that small chain ring, the Imola, even at at 10.9 kilos, can nicely serve 80-85% of riders (a guess, but you get the idea), especially riders with no racing aspirations and who don't plan on winning any KOMs. And it can be had at times for

  • @thewayisbetter4695
    @thewayisbetter4695 Год назад

    Thank you for this video. I am a newbie and have been struggling with what to buy but this confirmed my thinking. I got the middle range Giant Propel and I love it.

  • @getfuzed1887
    @getfuzed1887 11 месяцев назад

    Very well done, that was one of the best feedback videos ive seen in a while

  • @spaghettibadger647
    @spaghettibadger647 Год назад

    I'm still riding my Merida Ride 400 from 2015
    But i've upgraded the wheels/ tyres and just changed handle bars after seeing your videos about bar width. Went from a 44cm bar to 40

  • @enuazeal
    @enuazeal Год назад

    i'm ridding 2016. Toemus Sliker, bought it 3 years ago from bike shop owner, was his personal bike. it has ultegra di2 11speed, and its full carbon for 1600eur. im happy with it, road thousands and thousands miles on it, enjoying it

  • @TenSapphires
    @TenSapphires Год назад +2

    I bought Gianr Contend AR2 2020 in 2021 with Tiagra 4700 and Tectro c550 mechanical disc brakes for 900$, 10.50kg

  • @billferguson2609
    @billferguson2609 Год назад

    I have several classic steel bikes but my favorite to ride is my 2007 Scott Speedster 40s. It is a bike that seems at home doing it all. It has Tiagra derailleurs and though a aluminum frame with carbon fork and seatpost it rides smooth. Riding below 20mph it seems docile but above that the bike surprises you with a quicker attitude more like a race bike
    The newer models have changed a bit but I will keep my older model for great riding fun.

  • @GallardoFreak888
    @GallardoFreak888 Год назад

    Riding on a multitude of bikes but… road bike is a 2013 Specialized Allez. It’s been upgraded over the years with carbon wheels and 105 components. Road an Aethos a few weeks back and a tarmac SL6 years ago and it made my bike feel like lead. But I love my lead bike 🥳

  • @jonburnell532
    @jonburnell532 Год назад

    For me, the Addict Gravel 30 with a wheel and tyre upgrade is pretty much perfect and more than I could ever fully use. And it'd cost less than £4k. But that still isn't "cheap". As for what I'm riding, a 2003 Trek 5200.

  • @MasteringGrappling
    @MasteringGrappling Год назад

    I am riding a Yoeleo R11 which is a climbing bike. I went from aluminum Cannondale synapse to this bike. Yes, during acceleration you feel the difference in the carbon frame and in the aero tube profiles. It is easier to hold speed with the carbon bike than with my aluminum bike.

  • @malcontent510
    @malcontent510 Год назад +5

    Loving this collaboration.
    Carry on gents.

  • @edwardsnowdenofficial
    @edwardsnowdenofficial Год назад +1

    Also grabbed a Specialized Allez for £215 during lock down! Another bargain and great ride! Have £3k bike but just as happy on the Defy and Allez!

  • @Craig_Beale
    @Craig_Beale Год назад +28

    Summed up perfectly guys! I think for most of us mere mortals the sweet spot is around 3-5k, although thanks to inflation that's getting harder to achieve! Appreciate your affiliation with Scott, but you can definitely get a much better spec'd bike for 1k too! Keep up the good work 👍

    • @gregschramm8180
      @gregschramm8180 Год назад +1

      My. Titanium lynskey is fantastic but the gear set isn’t any good.

    • @bonbonflippers4298
      @bonbonflippers4298 Год назад

      @@gregschramm8180 got a lynskey also. Best value for a ti bike or say for us normal people. Durable, little heavy but can take abuse and scratches no problem.

  • @malcontent510
    @malcontent510 Год назад +9

    My daily driver/commuter is a steel framed single speed-love it

  • @dsarcevic
    @dsarcevic Год назад

    Glad that you had rim brake bikes. I learned the necessities of cycling on my aluminum alloy Trek Emonda ALR5 and I upgraded to a carbon Trek Emonda SL5 with disc brakes. Still not a fan of the disc brakes. But had few options during covid lockdown when I purchased it.

    • @aizins3420
      @aizins3420 Год назад

      @@kimhoffmannandersen5477 rim brakes are becoming "obsolete" because of marketing lol

  • @global_nomad.
    @global_nomad. Год назад

    good to see you presenting in an 'entry level' way - your use of language is accessible to newcomers by not using jargon or knowledge of terms that comes with years of riding, so kudos for that.
    asking a money no object question is rather moot though, anyone who is into their riding is likely to take the most expensive. how many weeks income would you spend on a bike might reveal more...my current bike is around 6/7 weeks net income.

  • @Woopigmavs
    @Woopigmavs Год назад

    When I first got into riding/triathlon about 5 years ago I bought a cannondale caad3 frame from around 2000 and put on a new tiagra 10-speed group set. About a year later I added $400 superteam carbon wheels and GP 5000 tires to it. A year later I found a 2017 giant tcr advanced pro frame and moved all of my components onto it. Absolutely loved that bike and only had about $2000 into it, but unfortunately it was stolen recently. Lucky for me, insurance replaced it with a brand new TCR advanced pro disc. $5000 bike stock with carbon wheels, disc brakes, ultegra, dual sided power meter, etc.
    In all of that, the biggest difference to me was adding the $400 carbon wheels and GP 5000 tires to my 20 year old cannondale lol. The jump to a carbon frame was noticeably more stiff and comfortable, but the jump from my 2017 TCR to a brand new one really wasn’t that significant (but I do love it!)

  • @royevans4581
    @royevans4581 Год назад +27

    I remember when not too long ago, you could get a lightweight alloy framed bike with carbon fork and 105 groupset (FSA crankset) plus Ritchey finishing kit for £650. A la Boardman Comp.

    • @abedfo88
      @abedfo88 Год назад +2

      Yes ! That was my first road bike in 2008. I was at uni and my dad got it for me on cycle2work scheme. I then paid the debt off to him 😅

    • @adredy
      @adredy Год назад +2

      Now 1200 but i dont know nothing about frame quality .

    • @sdolman79
      @sdolman79 Год назад

      Agree my Scott speedster 20 came with 105 and a carbon fork for £600 reduced from £1000.

    • @royevans4581
      @royevans4581 Год назад +1

      @diesel They were bigger too.

  • @Missinglink3003
    @Missinglink3003 Год назад +5

    Just got myself a 750€ Triban Gravel bike. There is plenty room to improve of course but it's absolutely great value and is on par with a lot more expensive bikes. And if you'd put the difference in upgrades it is really superior.

    • @entombed_kills
      @entombed_kills Год назад

      I still love my 250 Euro Triban Roadbike. Some PRs with still hold, because I was fitter back then.

  • @madsheepz
    @madsheepz Год назад

    Excited to see what you think of the reform, I work with the guys that make it it’s so cool

  • @alefone2
    @alefone2 Год назад

    I've have/had many. Budget bike for me CAAD12 with 105 would be #1 choice for anyone starting. After testing many I settled on SWORKS Crux but still have a my CAAD12...If you can afford, it's fine but 1500$ CAD can bring you just as much fun for sure:)

  • @_vinceverano
    @_vinceverano Год назад +8

    I totally agree with you guys. Cheap bikes are "very, very, very capable very good bike". I just had my first race yesterday using my £500 bike. Though I didn't win, I finished the race and the ride felt good and had no issues at all. Really all comes down to if you have the budget for more expensive, high performance bikes.

  • @MegaSixpac
    @MegaSixpac Год назад

    For my road bike I have a 2017 Wilier Centro Air. Really like it other than going down hill in cross winds which makes descending a nightmare.

  • @chrisscott8362
    @chrisscott8362 Год назад

    My main bike is a 2010 Titanium Ritchey Break Away w / Sram etap. Ride mostly group rides in flat midwest usa.
    I have no plans to go aero or downgrade to disc brakes.

  • @sv-cr5yo
    @sv-cr5yo Год назад +1

    Riding Speedster 50; same model and enjoying a lot :)

  • @M3GRSD
    @M3GRSD Год назад

    Great video, top marks. Seeing that I'm already the chap who has a $1,000 bike and upgraded it to the very limit, I would go with the $10,000 if money were no option. Even though the parts can be upgraded, the frame material, power transfer from the bottom bracket, and the weight of the frame... Upgrading parts can't make your $1,000 bike a $10,000. It just wouldn't be the same. Once you've been cycling for several years, the obsession with the very best overcomes you.

  • @danielfoster1322
    @danielfoster1322 Год назад

    I have a Scott Speedster 10 disc 105 11 speed 2022, I love it and so comfy just wish it was a little bit lighter my only complaint 🙈

  • @Xarx42
    @Xarx42 Год назад

    I had the same discussion recently with a colleague. At the end we all have to find our sweet spot how much money we like to throw into our hobbys. Because even if the feeling might be not so different you do get something for the higher price (to a certain point; looking at specialized and colnago eg...). I'll be a happy owner of a Simplon Pride II in 2 months (but with ultegra) and I am already looking forward to have electronic shifting with automatic gear adjustment. Dont need to ask my girlfriend to keep paddeling on the smarttrainer while I am stuck in the corner adjusting the screws... :D

  • @jimpeyton1459
    @jimpeyton1459 Год назад

    THANKS FOR THIS. Good fun.
    I'd go with mid range with 2X just because that's what I'm used to. Biggest technology jump for me was buying a Specialized Allez in 1989 that had indexed rear derailleur (Suntour GPX). Two years later the carbon Allez Epic was my first carbon bike (delaminated in crit race in 1993).
    As others have said my sweet spot is 105 mechanical. I have that on two Specialized Roubaix bikes (one rim brake the other disc). I'm looking out for an 11 speed Ultegra Di2 to try. I like disc brake stopping...weight issues are more easily solved by making the rider weigh less.
    My Felt Broam 30 gravel has GRX 810 (2X). It's versatile in mixed terrain, but a pig to ride on hilly tarmac routes. Interesting groupset, but for something designed for gravel/rail trails, I find it surprisingly fragile. YMMV.
    Would I buy a USD 10K bike? If the geometry suited a 65 year old rider and it didn't look like a 3D printed alien... maybe.

  • @MrSupertramp76
    @MrSupertramp76 Год назад

    How about comparing a high graded carbon frame with budget gearing and vise versa. Great video as always👍🤟

  • @bennyhill4131
    @bennyhill4131 Год назад

    I'm about to get my dream bike this year as it happens. Can't wait for my TIME Scylon, kitted up with SRAM Red and ENVE wheels/aerobars....;)

  • @jrother
    @jrother Год назад +1

    Having begun to do the maintenance on my own bike, I'd take the mid-range Scott you ran with. Changing brakes with all internal routing is just a nightmare for the garage builder, in my mind. I bought my Felt Z100 in 2016 and it's the only roadie I have owned. It's fitted with Shimano Claris, except for the chainset. I'm just a guy who likes riding around in the sun; I never thought I needed something more high-end. Though, I still do want to swap that chainset...

    • @jimpeyton1459
      @jimpeyton1459 Год назад +1

      💯% the semi internal are not so bad, but working on a friend's Aethos (weekend emergency) was a nightmare.

  • @adrianherrell661
    @adrianherrell661 Год назад

    I bought a 2yr old Ford Focus for less than 10k and my Genesis Volare ( 2nd hand £200) fits in the back just fine.
    Previous bike owner bought high end carbon weapon and didn't need the money so I'm happy that people want these upgrades , good for 2nd hand buyers. I have £1k legs.

  • @michaelscholl4541
    @michaelscholl4541 Год назад +8

    I would take the 5000 bike, it is just looks simple and beautiful

  • @geoff5623
    @geoff5623 Год назад

    My 2008 Specialized Secteur (Alu frame, carbon fork, 105 group) that I got second hand (for $900 cad) has served me well for many years now, and I'm glad I got it over a new bike at a comparable price that would have been all alloy and a lower spec groupset.
    I rented a Cannondale Supersix a few years ago on a trip and liked it - a little sharper handling, and the Ultegra groupset was noticeably better shifting - but as much as I keep considering an upgrade since then I just haven't felt that spending $2-3000 is going to be worthwhile for the improvement (especially if I'm not sure it's going to be a bike I'll love the fit and geometry of).
    (I have also been spending money on my track bike instead :)

  • @MxCraven
    @MxCraven Год назад +1

    You'd get bigger aero gains by zipping up your jersey ;)
    I do love the mid range (the true mid range, Tiagra/Sora groupsets) of bikes. 2nd hand you can get them for a steal, put the widest tyres you can on them, and you're good to go for cafe rides and general purpose tourist cycling.

    • @zedddddful
      @zedddddful Год назад

      Tiagra is properly decent Sora is just too big gear jump's tiagra hit's the sweet spot 👌

  • @PeerensClement
    @PeerensClement Год назад

    Thanks, this is a refreshing take. You can do any event an amateur would conceivably do on a 1000$ bike. Most amateurs overspend by a lot.

  • @WredFawks
    @WredFawks 4 месяца назад

    /late coming in with a 54cm 2x7 converted 52/39 11/28 C. Itoh badged Bridgestone Kabuki. Original weight 15.8kg with the pedals on, 12.9 after swapping in single wall aluminum rims, a matching rear center pull dual pivot brake, and a new saddle. 3kg has been quite the difference and I'm hoping the next build is just under 10kg, material and tube shape doesn't matter that much to me.
    That said, glad to hear about the Tourney shifters being workable, if a touch awkward. Given the state of 105 mechanical going for around US $600 currently, I might just save that extra cash and try to budget US $1,500-2,000 for the 'good range' on a light steel frame (if new new).

  • @zimboy777
    @zimboy777 Год назад

    the value sweet spot def around 5k used to be 3k. carbon frame fork and ultegra equivalent groupset (electronic) deep section light wheels bike weight in 7kg range decent tires - enough to really enjoy then just lose body weight and ride hard -good video right conclusion 👍

  • @leonschumann2361
    @leonschumann2361 Год назад

    l have an elves falath pro 2022, ultegra 11s Di2, elite wheels 80/60mm wheels. overall cost probably around 5k. fully integrated, aero, electronic, tubeless everything. especially with the new UCI legal falath evo coming out. would never spend more for a bike. l think everybody can 100% agree with you on this topic

  • @johndef5075
    @johndef5075 Год назад +2

    Its fun passing 10k bikes on my 22 lb. steel Raleigh 😅

    • @zedddddful
      @zedddddful Год назад

      I've blasted past many a weekend warrior on my commuter hybrid bike fully loaded with a week's worth of shopping lol YOU CAN'T BUY LEG'S.

  • @salzhaltigersalzhaufen586
    @salzhaltigersalzhaufen586 Год назад +1

    well I do own a cheap road bike (Trek domane al2 disc) and there are defenitly times when I notice that you just gotta train harder to keep up with other people I mean even I was able to go up a hill with 40km/h with that bike and you can easly drop E-Bikes or even other road cyclist on these bikes just invest your money in some nice clothing get in a really aero position (if you think you are aero try to go even lower xD) and just have fun riding. One good thing about a cheap bike is you dont have to feel bad when people pass you but if you pass someone else man you can be happy and also if something breaks its not as expensive to replace

  • @thegrizzlys
    @thegrizzlys Год назад

    Id take the 5k bike, but i'd prefer disc brakes. currently building a Cinelli Veltrix with Sram force/rival axs and will pretty much come in at the 4k to 5k mark by the time its done, gonna be a massive upgrade on my 1986 steel peugeot tourmalet which I upgraded to tiagra and some dt swiss wheels a while back

  • @richardgeorge4424
    @richardgeorge4424 Год назад

    Great Vid Francis, I'm in the market for a bike computer, maybe a vid comparing different makes, at the monment Hammerhead is the top of my list, but also in the mix is garmin, wahoo etc. I'm mainly a weekend rider but like taking a few longer trips each year and the mapping on the Hammerhead looks good but batery life has been highligted as its downfall. Interested what you guys think

  • @dinosor8819
    @dinosor8819 4 дня назад

    Riding the Trek Emonda SL5 rim brake with upgraded carbon saddle, seat mast & handlebars. With vision wheel set

  • @davidmulligan42
    @davidmulligan42 Год назад

    I ordered a Trek Emonda during Covid, and after a few months the bike shop said none of the bikes were coming to the east coast. I ended up ordering a much more expensive 2020 Trek Emonda SLR7 eTap Project One (just under $10k). I doubt it makes any difference to my performance, but it's a nice bike. If there were no supply chain issues, I'd look to spend less than $6k.

  • @simonpolakoff9047
    @simonpolakoff9047 Год назад +1

    I’d love to see you compare the s-works aethos or a really high end light bike to an aero bike.

  • @thatwebbloke
    @thatwebbloke Год назад +1

    My £5,000 bike (picked up for £3,500 in on sale) that I brought for weekend rides, ruined my commuter, which was on a £1,000.
    Every time I rode to work, which has a couple of massive hills, I wished I was on my other bike. The lightness, better brakes, range of gears and electronic groupset just make the ride more enjoyable, so I recently ordered a £2,500 gravel bike for my commute, same groupset, but 1x, lighter titanium frame, rather than alloy.
    So in summary, unless you have the money to spend, don't try a more expensive bike, as you will just yearn for the better one.

  • @paullefko
    @paullefko Год назад +1

    Would love to see the real world differences between say a Cervello Caledonia and the soloist, they seem so close on paper, does the endurance bike beat the race /hill climbing bike or vise versa

  • @tobycolin6271
    @tobycolin6271 Год назад +1

    Trouble with bikes like the foil (and bikes like it) is if you haven’t got the engine to beat Average Jo on a group ride you just look a fool. On a bad day no one notices you on an average bike. But good luck to the people that have them. There is nothing better than hanging on or over taking an aero bike on something with down tube shifters.

  • @greggjames448
    @greggjames448 Год назад

    Having ridden a £400 bike for several years and then upgrading to a £3000 bike in 2020, one of the biggest differences is fatigue on longer rides. As the cheaper bike was heavier, lost power through everything and didn’t have as wide a cassette range I would feel tired quicker on it compared to my more expensive bike

  • @mlee6050
    @mlee6050 Год назад

    That is my issue, I want aero bike but with standard round seatpost so can use axs dropper in it if want

  • @adriancozma6161
    @adriancozma6161 Год назад

    I've had a 3k€ bike for several years and recently a friend gave me his 8k€ or so bike and I was impressed how much a difference it made. Even though mine was an aero bike and his was a more normal one, I still managed to beat some of my shorter KOM which was interesting 🤔🎉

  • @samtravis4822
    @samtravis4822 Год назад

    For me the best upgrade is electronic gears, they just work, stay perfect, are super smooth when changing, when you're changing gears thousands of times on a long ride the difference really adds up

  • @andrewtabberer5610
    @andrewtabberer5610 Год назад

    Hey Francis … what camera strap would you recommend for cycling and a Sony a500 ? Going on a cycling trip and would love to take some pics on the way …. I have my iPhone but for different effects would hope the camera would be a better option…. Thanks for the great vlogs

  • @PunjabiCyclist
    @PunjabiCyclist Год назад

    I think £5k to £6K is more than enough for a solid bike that lasts you a long time; and beyond this is diminishing returns as you guys rightly put it!

  • @lukesanders768
    @lukesanders768 Год назад

    I've always ridden alloy or cromoly bikes. I once rode a carbon roubaix with all the bells and whistles and I felt it too stiff for me. haven't tried other carbon frames but it all depends on the type of riding and the rider you are. I don't take part in races and I don't intend to do so. Alloy is good for me.

  • @forzasquality210
    @forzasquality210 Год назад

    Giant Defy VS Giant propel would be great. Love the videos .

  • @daronaldridge684
    @daronaldridge684 Год назад

    I have a 2013 Scott foil 10 with full sram red, how would it compare to the £10000 bike?

  • @craigleslie7
    @craigleslie7 Год назад

    Love the videos but as others have said, you can get more value entry level bikes for the £1000 mark, example of this is Canyon Endurace AL Rim Brake with Shimano Tiagra 4700 GS with 10-speed and 11-34 tooth cassette. If you can afford £300 more you can get it with 105 and £500 more with disk brakes. but is 1500 entry level?. Looking forward to the next video.

  • @markusseppala6547
    @markusseppala6547 Год назад +1

    Upgrade the £1000 with something like 105 5800 11s groupset, I just found one used for 140€. Then it would be a great value for money.

  • @mwbpo1
    @mwbpo1 Год назад

    Really enjoying this new format.

  • @coreyallert1482
    @coreyallert1482 Год назад

    5k bike
    I have a cannondale Topstone (Sora) and a Canyon Endurace with DI2 I enjoy electronic shifting a lot

  • @sabaffira
    @sabaffira Год назад

    Still regret selling my $400 Merida Ride91 alloy bike with Sora groupset. It was so smooth with hardly any noise.

  • @bernardwind1633
    @bernardwind1633 Год назад

    I wonder what an aero h/bar, 50mm deep carbon rimmed wheelset + TT tyres and ultegra 11speed mechanical g/set, or equivalent would do to the aluminum frame to compare against the £5000 bike ??

  • @rancescott
    @rancescott Год назад +2

    I’ve had a cannondale synapse 105 carbon since 2014 cost £1400. Great bike.
    Recently bought an evo supersix £4000 honestly I think I prefer my synapse, expensive bike definitely isn’t worth it.

    • @entombed_kills
      @entombed_kills Год назад

      My Specialized isn't 10 times better than my Triban to be honest.

  • @draugmithrin
    @draugmithrin Год назад

    Gone retro on my Surly LHT, fitted 7 speed Vintage NOS Shimano Exage Sport LX Downtube Shifters and a shiny Wipperman 708 chain. Also ordered microSHIFT R473 3x7 Speed Dual Control Lever Set for just £28 from Wiggle. Who needs Shimano Cues?

  • @heinzholger8321
    @heinzholger8321 Год назад +3

    It's not the 10k bike that bothers me. Top high-end tech, materials and manufacturing will always demand a high premium. It's the pricing of the entry and mid tier bikes that really annoys me. Mass produced bikes should never even cost nearly as much as some brands want us to pay.

    • @ariffau
      @ariffau Год назад

      Branded goods are also priced at a premium price point. Use something from Android if you can’t afford the Apple ecosystem.
      Same thing applies for cycling and bikes. If we can’t afford a particular brand, look elsewhere.

    • @entombed_kills
      @entombed_kills Год назад

      @@ariffau The 1000 pound bike is just a bad deal compared to other 1000 Pound offers. The name Scott is not a big nane brand. They simply don't care to offer a good deal here.

    • @ariffau
      @ariffau Год назад

      @@entombed_kills then go buy something else.
      Where I’m from, Scott offers excellent post sales customer service. So do brands like Pinarello, Spesh, Orbea. None of these are cheap. But if and when something goes wrong, it’s a breeze to deal with them.

  • @nigelhanson2353
    @nigelhanson2353 Год назад

    i have the Scott addict 10 carbon, endurance version with ultegra groupset but would love the £5000 rc version shown in the video..... can you have a word Francis! Also in the collection is an alloy planet x rt58 and a Focus Cayo Disc, both with Tiagra which is a brilliant groupset btw, also a kinesis which is sat on the trainer oh and a voodoo bizango mtb, oh and a Claud butler cape wrath mtb. my missis reckons ive got too many bikes!😂

  • @JakeMay
    @JakeMay Год назад +13

    I think complete beginners would find it useful to do a functional comparison between a road bike, a hybrid bike and a gravel / adventure bike - what and who is each type of bike for

  • @FutureMark809
    @FutureMark809 Год назад

    Makes me feel better about my Scott Speedster 20 👌🏼 I always thought I was the limiting factor 🤣

  • @gavinward3176
    @gavinward3176 Год назад

    I currently have a PlanetX RTD80, SRAM Rival x11 mechanical and mechanical disc brakes. Cost just under £1k in 2018 with discount from £1,200. It's been a difficult bike with maintenance, main problem with front derailleur alignment. Cannot say I have had the best of experiences with this bike one way or another.
    Currently I have on order a Colnago V3 Ultegra di2 x12, should arrive in a month or so, cost is £5,399. Thinking of a Colnago C68 but an Ultegra di2 x12 build is coming in at £8,599. Question I have is whether I should just get some summer wheels for the V3? This is likely to push up the price to £6.5k. The alternative being I would go for the C68 but accept that it will only have entry level alloy wheels?
    Personally, I think bike prices have gone crazy. If the C68 was £6-7k including carbon wheels I would go for it but I hesitate when the price goes so high.
    Let me know what you think.

  • @randomUnhold
    @randomUnhold Год назад

    How about some highend-Ti Bike versus other materials? Great content! Fun to watch :)

  • @takumi4321
    @takumi4321 11 месяцев назад

    A £1000 bike with Shimano Tourney Groupset is crazy though... Where I am at - Malaysia - that sort of prices should be getting you a Tiagra level groupset at least...

  • @amytysoe2292
    @amytysoe2292 Год назад

    other short, sharp, horrible hills in tyneside - low heworth lane in (unsurprisingly enough) Heworth and Redwell bank onto lizard lane in south shields. Kill me every time, give 'em a go sometime :D (and I'm on 2x8 mechanical disc brake £950-ish trek domane that mostly just needs its bar tape redoing)

  • @TheImprobableIronman
    @TheImprobableIronman Год назад

    Great video and very pragmatic analysis.

  • @Hintonbro.
    @Hintonbro. Год назад

    We need more of this kind of discussion! Folks looking to buy have to remember that the upfront outlay of cash is not the end of the story.
    There are constant expenses with cycling - almost everything on the bike is ’consumable’.
    So a $10,000 bike means much higher ongoing costs.
    It’s not one expense and done.
    Also I’d argue it is a great idea to set aside cycling budget for **travel**- rides or events in epic locations are cycling moments that you will never forget and I’d say is worth much much more than showing off your $10,000 super bike at a café.

  • @joecadec4101
    @joecadec4101 Год назад

    I ride a focus cayo concept full carbon fibre, shimano tiagra groupset with mavic kyrsium ust tyres