so we should lock up everyone with schizophrenia instead of getting this guy some treatment and medication? Oh wait, it's the US so it's impossible to coordinate that because you don't have public healthcare...
Even then, people lie saying they have voices in their head but it's only to get a lighter sentence or to plead insanity. From what I scene alot of school shooters use that excuse once they get caught.
You would think after just 1 year that people would have a change of heart and mind in prison. 24 years later and this guy still has voices ACTIVELY speaking to him. Do not release him, he's still a danger to society.
unless he changed and I hope he did cause 25 years of being in cage is no joke it's always life in prison now these days, back then everything was different he's lucky he gonna step out to freedom soon
@@OatSealCertifiedBeast I mean it’s grateful that she survived, but still sad that she has to be in a wheelchair for something that never should’ve happened to her. overall sad situation. robbed of walking for the rest of her life cause some psycho shot her.
They should've kept him behind bars. The fact that he even mentioned that he had voices in his head proves that he is just making excuses for his unjustifiable actions. Let him stay his ass in prison where he belongs!
@@EDPRETURNS445 😂😂😂😂😂 so it's immature to want someone who killed people to never be released? No it's not immature in the least bit. Projection much. You seem like a very immature child that has a LONG way to go before maturing.
He's a grown man. I'd be more concerned about the threat of school shooters nowadays with all the Chads (jocks) and Staceys (b word) living on social media apps, "window shopping" for partners, and abusing the noble and good-hearted people of their communities.
@@Tweakito maybe but honestly after writing this I started to think maybe they would have done a polygraph on them anyway so maybe they wanted to see if he would be truthful before finding him out?
14 year olds don't have the mentality to fully understand the consequences of their actions at that age.. it's a tough one but he was a kid.. boils down to is prison punishment or reform? No amount of punishment is going to bring those kids back but could there be some redemption in reform. This guy is not the same person anymore..
The constitution states he did his time and has the right to have his gun rights restored. God bless America. I didn't read anything about demons or voices in someone's head in the Bill of Rights therefore it isn't real.
@@youtubestudiosucks978 Legally, they have to because he was a minor. It was what he was sentenced to 25 years ago when he was 14. Sometimes, minors who commit crimes like this for the better do change. Not all of them, but some do. That’s why we have parole.
@@youtubestudiosucks978 you need to relax just because he's eligible for parole does not mean he's going to get it. If you're entitled to a parole hearing you should have parole hearing so that the board can decide based on the facts. He likely won't get out..ever.
And the myth of prisoners becoming smart because they have nothing more than their books all day seems untrue too considering he tried to get parole while telling he killed because he heard voices and that he heard them just 2 days ago lol
I feel sorry for the victims and to the convict as well. My brother has schizophrenia and he hears voices. His condition is manageable. Schizophrenia is horrible disease.
@donniedoesdishes What makes you think he hasn’t been given mental health treatment while in prison? Some people (even those who take their medication every single day) still hear voices telling them to do things. Use your head for other things than sticking it up your Ass.
The constitution states he did his time and has the right to have his gun rights restored. God bless America. I didn't read anything about demons or voices in someone's head in the Bill of Rights therefore it isn't real.
His victims deserve justice...they died and don't get a 2nd chance. 25 years is too light a punishment for killing 3 people and putting a person in a wheelchair
@@bigdaddydal7763 exactly locking an obviously mental ill person for the rest of their lives is not going to fix anything this is what's so wrong about prisons because it does nothing and as soon as they get out they will do it again
As a psychology student, the first thing I thought of was "he could be having a disorder". Then, I felt bad for him. Then, I also see your comments about how it's an excuse and he should be in jail. Thoughts anyone? To me, I'd say he needs to go through stringent psychological testing and get the proper treatment he needs. I do agree that he'd be a danger to society but he does seem to need help.
@@stephanieames66 lmao no, the prison system doesn’t bother with actually fixing people. So when anyone’s term in prison end, they end up worse. The whole “reintegrate into society” is never really done.
Honestly he should be put into a mental hospital or somewhere to help with the voices. Like he shouldn't be released, but he should get help so he can someday be a normal person.
@@stephanieames66 There isnt exactly useful mental help in the prison system. Personally, I think with some level of treatment and psychiatric help, he could become a functioning member of society. Everyone who says otherwise doesnt know how bad mental illness can get when left untreated. While yes, in some cases they feel no remorse, but this is why we should make mental health a top priority in the world.
25 years ago, voices in his head told him to kill people and he did it, today he says he still hears those voices, only difference is that he is in prison and is very limited in what he can do... please, for the love of god, do not let that dude out.
@@lulub1433 Exactly, in the weeks before the shooting he stole several firearms from both his own home and a neighbor's home, he planned it ahead of time which means he didn't just black out one day and start shooting.
Safe to say he's not getting paroled if he admits to still hearing the same voices that made him commit the crime... another word for voices in your head is inner monologue... we all hear a voice in our head, just that most of ours don't tell us to kill. He's not insane he's just evil.
Everybody doesnt have an inner monologue.. a lot of people have no voice in their heads at all... when you read something you can almost hear youself saying it in your mind? Thats not as common as you think.
He’s crazy, unstable, and a murderer. He should never be given parole. He was denied and is now serving life in prison without the possibility of parole.
The three people he murdered (and the others he injured) got the opposite of life. This man should not get the chance to walk free again, regardless of his age at the time of the crime.
He killed THREE people and he wants out in the world? He does NOT need to be in society especially after he said the voices in his head told him to jump off the stairs wtf leave him in jail for 125 years please
When it comes to mass shooters they should NEVER be even given the slightest opportunity for parole it’s sickening that they even hold a trial and entertain the idea for it.
He wouldn’t know what to do outside those walls 25 years later. Much different world. His day was beastie boys , PlayStation 1 and driving a Chevy Cavalier. Today is ps5, tik tok, lil Nas x and driving a Tesla. Two totally different worlds.
@@trump2.o152 nah your insane if you think he should be let go to live his life. Victims weren’t allowed to live theirs so it’s only fair he stay behind bars for life.
@@frankoh3451 he is harmless and what is the point of putting him in prison and there alot of school shooting happening around the United States and get used to
@@frankoh3451 the whole point of prison is paying for your crime by not enjoying the benefits of life while reflecting and reforming. Its only a permanent settlement for those who dont reflect and have no remorse for their actions.
@@EmanPKR sorry man but anyone who takes the life of another person shouldn’t be out on the streets. The victim is gone while the suspect gets to enjoy part of his life? That doesn’t seem like justice for me.
Let's not emphasize his defense over some imaginary 'voices'. That guy took away innocent lives, and damaged so many others. NOW, even after 25yrs he's alive and privileged to talk in front of his cell 'magic mirror' all day long! 🙏
First fool you don't know what he hears 2nd people hear voices all the time because it's real to them 3rd you have no idea what prison does to a person with that being said he should NOT be released
he still has voices in his head. even if he gets intensive treatment after his release, he’s still a danger to everyone. there’s no telling that he wont do it again. do NOT release him, prevent a tragedy from potentially occurring again.
He haven't done treatment yet but you're already judging him. Dude is trying so hard to prove himself he's a changed man now, his better self. He even said he was responsible and feel sorry for what he did and the shootings after his. Instead of keeping him locked up, we should send him to a mental institution to be treated so the bad voices in his head will be gone. More prison time isn't helping him, clearly. Judging him, keeping him up in prison for me is us being cruel to our own. 25 years I think is already enough, let's give him a chance.
@@IgorFranknstn27 he literally killed 3 people and permanently paralyzed a woman. Like she said he sentenced her to life in a wheel chair never to be able to walk again. And he dished out 3 death sentences no mass shooter deserves any kindness or mercy doesn’t matter if he’s “sorry” for what he did (which i would take that sorry as a grain of salt when it comes to people like this)
The constitution states he did his time and has the right to have his gun rights restored. God bless America. I didn't read anything about demons or voices in someone's head in the Bill of Rights therefore it isn't real.
I think he needs more medical and psychological care in a secure facility than to spend another 25 years in prison. He's definitely not ready to be with the public, or be a benefit to society, but that doesn't mean he doesn't deserve to get better.
I agree completely. He should be released from prison into a psychiatric hospital where he can receive treatment for his ongoing mental health issues. I guarantee he hasn’t received adequate, if any, psychiatric treatment since he went to prison. If he is still hearing command voices regularly, he is likely suffering from some sort of psychotic disorder and needs to be in a hospital setting where he can receive proper care. I’m not at all saying he should be released into the public-he shouldn’t. But, he should be sent to a long term, institution.
I totally agree. Denying somone the opportunity to change seems wrong, so put percautions into place where he can try but not do much damage if he does anything more, and maybe someday he can live somewhat of his life in society.
Why should he get out of prison, if this poor lady can’t get out of the wheelchair he put her in? The people he murdered can’t get out of their graves. 25 years, I just don’t know.
even though the purpose of prison is retribution, incapacitation, deterrence and rehabilitation, most people don't care about the rehabilitation part at all. From providing efficient mental health services to prisons, or civilians being hesitant (understandable) to welcome them back into society. its pretty sad all around. especially since many times, we can't tell if these prisoners who served a long time have genuinely changed for the better and won't pose a threat to themselves or others.
I don't believe in rehabilitation for people that commit murder. When you murder it becomes easier and easier to kill again. To trust that a murderer won't kill again is selfish because what if he does kill again now you have another death that could have been avoided because rehabilitation failed.
@@1988vikable i would say the viable but seeing how theres many cases where murderers get out and actually stop killing and living a healthy life in regret says otherwise
Only situation he should even be considered for parole is if he opened fire hitting people but didn’t end up killing them or leaving them disabled for life. Ontop of that he’s still hearing voices and clearly still struggling mentally? How is this even a question keep him in prison
it’s easy to just keep them in prison instead of them getting help huh. you think prison has therapy sessions and medication testing? how can we rehabilitate him if the prison is so broken? people forget that jail/prison is meant to rehabilitate and help them back into society
@@idijwiheufbfwkajlldkwnkjdn3108 Y’all only want therapy and counseling for certain people. What about the drug dealers they put away for life and never get granted parole.
The fact he admitted it makes me feel sorry for him. If he truly meant to do any harm at this point in his life, I don’t think he would have said he hears voices. Clearly makes it tougher to be let out and sounds more like a cry for help.
I understand your empathy. But, lots of people have really severe schizophrenia, and they _decide_ not to hurt others. Most self harm, or self treat with illicit drugs (unfortunately). I hope he gets treatment, but he owns his actions.
@@td.adigee not an excuse. What he describing was not an episode, at best he could have been suffering from perpetrator PTSD, because he remembers what he did, he knew it was wrong, and it's his brain attempting to cope with his trauma. Hence his convenient "blackouts" during the shooting. Point is, he's a liability. There is no way to be certain or not he'll have another episode, his next victim potentially could be you, your family, or anyone's family. Which is why he needs to remain where he is.
I don't really believe him, he "cant remember" firing the shots and "the voices" told him to do it, all while hunched over like a spineless coward... hes just trying to make himself not accountable and if he's released (he wont be) he will probably kill more girls with a head as clear as day.
I was a sophomore when this happened and was going through my school libraries collection of Stephen King books when it happened, so I remember it happening a little more clearly than other events at the time because it all seemed to focus on Kings book "Rage". That dude was huge news....it was a couple years before Columbine and this was still the sort of thing that was severely abnormal at the time. I remember my church acting like Christians were starting to be targeted for their beliefs in schools after this too.
I have a dear dear friend who’s 35 and I’m 54, and he’s schizophrenic and bipolar and I’ve seen him get violent and turn into something that I never ever want to see again. He became like the Incredible Hulk and was hearing voices and I was petrified. I’m a big woman at 5’10 250 and he is 6’4 320 and he could have snapped my neck so easily. But as long as he takes his meds he’s the best person and I call him my adopted son. Being around someone who hears voices and gets violent really made me change my mind about schizophrenia but I don’t think he should ever see the light of day either.
@@goodnightmunchie 🤡you must be friends with this dude then , thinking 20 years is enough for killing people in a school , don’t care how old he was , parole shouldn’t been a option, I feel bad for you thinking 20 years or even parole was enough 🤡🤡
When you realize that your wrong deeds cost you back more than you can imagine 🤔🙄😑 This is why we all should keep a humble character because any kind of evil is punishable. You might having a good time now but later you'll suffer the consequences at your most vulnerable hours...
**UPDATE** On September 26, 2022, the parole board unanimously denied Carneal's bid for parole and ordered him to serve out the remainder of his life sentence. The "serve out" ruling, under Kentucky law, means the inmate in question cannot be considered for any future parole hearings. This means Carneal's life with parole sentence is now effectively a life without parole (or "whole life") sentence.
Not sure he actually wants out; He admitted he still hears the voices. I suspect he is afraid of living outside now, knowing he may not be able to support himself and would end up out on the streets.
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
At the end of the day if someone says they have voices in their heads. Probably the wise thing to do is not grant them parole.
Especially when they said that's what got them there in the first place.
so we should lock up everyone with schizophrenia instead of getting this guy some treatment and medication? Oh wait, it's the US so it's impossible to coordinate that because you don't have public healthcare...
If that’s the case then he shouldn’t have been in prison in the first place due to insanity.
Even then, people lie saying they have voices in their head but it's only to get a lighter sentence or to plead insanity. From what I scene alot of school shooters use that excuse once they get caught.
I thought it was to get help for them
He has voices in his head. DO NOT RELEASE HIM!!!!
@ScariestEdgiestHumor ofc you want him released 😭
@ScariestEdgiestHumor illogical. You must live in Florida or Kentucky lmao
@ScariestEdgiestHumor he killed 2 people for no reason
@ScariestEdgiestHumor Who cares if it was 25 years ago he killed 2 innocent people and still hears voices don't let this psycho out
@ScariestEdgiestHumor shooting up a school is not a little goof
You would think after just 1 year that people would have a change of heart and mind in prison. 24 years later and this guy still has voices ACTIVELY speaking to him. Do not release him, he's still a danger to society.
Yes because it could be a disease
@@goodnightmunchie If he was a black dude, he'd be released 2 weeks after he committed it
@@abel3557 maybe in New york or L.A yes
@@abel3557 statistically, black ppl receive longer sentences for the same crimes. So that doesn’t make sense except if your dumb brain .
@@GMuhammad009 most definitely not
If he still hear voices in hi head ,he MUST NOT be released!!!! He is a DANGER for the society!!!!
so all schizophrenic people should be thrown in prison?
@@heroineheiIf they unalived 3 kids. Yes.
@ not all schizophrenics kill kids. your reading comprehension is horrific
RIP to the victims. Keep him where he is, give him medical intervention. He's still a danger to the public.
unless he changed and I hope he did cause 25 years of being in cage is no joke it's always life in prison now these days, back then everything was different he's lucky he gonna step out to freedom soon
No he’s not he’s a good guy give him a chance.
RIP to them ✝️✝️🌹
@@OatSealCertifiedBeast not funny
@@OatSealCertifiedBeast well he did 1 thing wrong.. not shooting himself first 😂
I feel so sorry for the woman in the wheelchair. She was robbed of her life
We should be grateful for that, not sad!
Precisely 😕
@Blessings From TIKTOK that’s kinda mess up lol
the people that were actually killed were robbed of their lives even more ...let that sink in
@@OatSealCertifiedBeast I mean it’s grateful that she survived, but still sad that she has to be in a wheelchair for something that never should’ve happened to her. overall sad situation. robbed of walking for the rest of her life cause some psycho shot her.
They should've kept him behind bars. The fact that he even mentioned that he had voices in his head proves that he is just making excuses for his unjustifiable actions.
Let him stay his ass in prison where he belongs!
They still have that chance.
Yes.
If he has voices and is confirmed, he should be in a mental asylum.
This is how unfair the justice system is
@@Djevan41598 most of it, yeah.
Fot anyone wondering he was DENIED parole. And I hope they KEEP denying this guy parole. He doesnt deserve to be a free man after what he did.
That’s very immature of you
He was denied parole and now is serving life without parole. Under the law he will never get out of prison now
@@EDPRETURNS445 😂😂😂😂😂 so it's immature to want someone who killed people to never be released? No it's not immature in the least bit. Projection much. You seem like a very immature child that has a LONG way to go before maturing.
@@EDPRETURNS445 He still has voices in his head?? That's clearly not something someone sane would say
@@LucasMoore88 he made a mistake! He needs a chance of freedom to tell his story
If he is STILL hearing voices, than how can you even THINK of letting him out!?!
He's a grown man. I'd be more concerned about the threat of school shooters nowadays with all the Chads (jocks) and Staceys (b word) living on social media apps, "window shopping" for partners, and abusing the noble and good-hearted people of their communities.
That's what I'm saying!!! He's schizophrenic!!! That is a mental illness and yes, he would probably be a danger to society if granted parole!!!
@@goodnightmunchie you may not know
That's not how it works. Your brain is a fast-firing machine.
Tf is wrong with you? The guy spent almost 200% of his life in jail.
There's a voice in my head...it want's to know why parole is even an option?
Mental health issues don't mean u need locked up for what he done he deserves longer than 25yrs
Lmao.
Exactly🙄
Same voice in my head😁😁😁
White. And was a kid when crime committed.
If you’re seeking parole why on Earth would you admit that you have voices in your head telling you to harm yourself and others 😭
Cuz he's a nut
only logical explanation for that is he genuinely wants help to prevent himself from doing anything harmful
@@Tweakito maybe but honestly after writing this I started to think maybe they would have done a polygraph on them anyway so maybe they wanted to see if he would be truthful before finding him out?
Because he’s genuinely mentally ill
because he’s mentally ill
He killed a 14yr old, a 17yr old and a 15yr old. There's absolutely no way he should ever see the outside of a prison.
Don’t forget he was just a kid
@@Emolga6274and?
14 year olds don't have the mentality to fully understand the consequences of their actions at that age.. it's a tough one but he was a kid.. boils down to is prison punishment or reform? No amount of punishment is going to bring those kids back but could there be some redemption in reform. This guy is not the same person anymore..
Troll@@forchrist013
@@forchrist013 stop defending a shooter
At least he's being honest that he still hears voices! I hope they won't let him out!
ya that was shocking really. He definitely doesn't know how the parole game works.
He's lying about the voices
Maybe he doesn't wanna get out? 😂
Imagine letting a mass shooter out of prison
The constitution states he did his time and has the right to have his gun rights restored. God bless America. I didn't read anything about demons or voices in someone's head in the Bill of Rights therefore it isn't real.
The fact that they even consider him for parole it's frightening 😬
Legally, they have to.
@@youtubestudiosucks978 It's literally a google search away.
@@youtubestudiosucks978 Legally, they have to because he was a minor. It was what he was sentenced to 25 years ago when he was 14. Sometimes, minors who commit crimes like this for the better do change. Not all of them, but some do. That’s why we have parole.
@@youtubestudiosucks978 you need to relax just because he's eligible for parole does not mean he's going to get it. If you're entitled to a parole hearing you should have parole hearing so that the board can decide based on the facts. He likely won't get out..ever.
@@Christiangjf they already denied his parole
No murderer should ever walk free.
I agree, the American justice system only protects the criminals. Keep giving them chances, who cares how many victims it takes
Well, when you’re a certain nationality, the judicial system shows you leniency🤣
Self defense?
@@KnockoutNarrativesmurder is unlawful by definition so self defense does not count
the american way of thinking. barbaric beings
He’s only 39???? He looks like he’s 60!!! Prison hasn’t been kind to him.
Prison isn’t kind to anyone. It ages you so bad
@@jasminemitchell8170like being a president. I’m serious. Look at a before and after presidency of Obama
@@The_Gamer1567 you ain’t never lied
And the myth of prisoners becoming smart because they have nothing more than their books all day seems untrue too considering he tried to get parole while telling he killed because he heard voices and that he heard them just 2 days ago lol
Yes it has , he’s still breathing.
Wow! He looks closer to 59 than 39. Prison life has definitely aged him.
White people age like milk though to begin with
As it should! It's not Club Med.
You should see his azz
It all that processes food he eats
Right, preservative @@elephant1992
I feel sorry for the victims and to the convict as well. My brother has schizophrenia and he hears voices. His condition is manageable. Schizophrenia is horrible disease.
Both sides of the situation matter. Thank you for conveying this
I hope your brother has the ability to tell the voices "No".
After he responded that he heard voices a couple of days ago, her response should have been: ‘We’ll see you again in 50 years.’
no it should of been we need to get you help and why for 25 years wasnt he given proper treatment
@donniedoesdishes
What makes you think he hasn’t been given mental health treatment while in prison?
Some people (even those who take their medication every single day) still hear voices telling them to do things.
Use your head for other things than sticking it up your Ass.
@@donniedoesdishes Exactly. As the lady said, the world has changed so much in 25 years, and we may have a means to help him now.
The constitution states he did his time and has the right to have his gun rights restored. God bless America. I didn't read anything about demons or voices in someone's head in the Bill of Rights therefore it isn't real.
@@YourMomsAltAccount Nope..he's still a threat!
What's to keep those voices in his head from killing someone else when he gets out. Keep him locked up for life.
If he is still hearing voices, it's all the more reason to not let him out. Or he will do it again.
His victims deserve justice...they died and don't get a 2nd chance. 25 years is too light a punishment for killing 3 people and putting a person in a wheelchair
Get the man help bruh
@@bigdaddydal7763 exactly locking an obviously mental ill person for the rest of their lives is not going to fix anything this is what's so wrong about prisons because it does nothing and as soon as they get out they will do it again
@@goodnightmunchie if he isn’t acting bad back then
@@goodnightmunchie you may never know 🤷♂️
As a psychology student, the first thing I thought of was "he could be having a disorder". Then, I felt bad for him. Then, I also see your comments about how it's an excuse and he should be in jail. Thoughts anyone? To me, I'd say he needs to go through stringent psychological testing and get the proper treatment he needs. I do agree that he'd be a danger to society but he does seem to need help.
If that's the case then this man should be given proper psychiatric treatment....in JAIL!
Was he not getting treatment all this time?
@@stephanieames66 lmao no, the prison system doesn’t bother with actually fixing people. So when anyone’s term in prison end, they end up worse. The whole “reintegrate into society” is never really done.
Honestly he should be put into a mental hospital or somewhere to help with the voices. Like he shouldn't be released, but he should get help so he can someday be a normal person.
@@stephanieames66 There isnt exactly useful mental help in the prison system. Personally, I think with some level of treatment and psychiatric help, he could become a functioning member of society. Everyone who says otherwise doesnt know how bad mental illness can get when left untreated. While yes, in some cases they feel no remorse, but this is why we should make mental health a top priority in the world.
25 years ago, voices in his head told him to kill people and he did it, today he says he still hears those voices, only difference is that he is in prison and is very limited in what he can do... please, for the love of god, do not let that dude out.
He will never get out now
25 years in a long time of medical advancements, we could potentially have the means to help him now.
@@YourMomsAltAccountyou want to gamble people's lives with "potentially " ? Sorry he killed people. He deserves to be in jail forever
@@YourMomsAltAccountProtecting the innocent should always be the priority over helping the guilty.
He can remember the voices in his head but not firing the loaded gun he took to school.
At least he's honest. I'll give him that. Doesn't help his parole case though
I think because he said he didn't act on it he thought they would think that's a good thing.
@@kenlompart9905 yeah that's why this admission will definitely not help him to get the parole..
He says he doesn't remember. Not buying it for a second!
@@lulub1433 Exactly, in the weeks before the shooting he stole several firearms from both his own home and a neighbor's home, he planned it ahead of time which means he didn't just black out one day and start shooting.
Safe to say he's not getting paroled if he admits to still hearing the same voices that made him commit the crime... another word for voices in your head is inner monologue... we all hear a voice in our head, just that most of ours don't tell us to kill. He's not insane he's just evil.
This isn't inner monologue, he's hallucinating
All the online doctors
Everybody doesnt have an inner monologue.. a lot of people have no voice in their heads at all... when you read something you can almost hear youself saying it in your mind? Thats not as common as you think.
@@APimpNamedSlickBak so Who’s the voice in your head ? Kermit the frog?
@@Njbear7453 It used to be Tony the Tiger..now its just your mom and SHHHHEEEEEEEEES GREAT
That man doesn’t deserve to walk free ever again…
He’s crazy, unstable, and a murderer. He should never be given parole. He was denied and is now serving life in prison without the possibility of parole.
This man needed treatment and support before all this.
People, always be there for your loved ones and allies.
Yeah so he is still hearing voices after 25 years and no one thought a physicatric might be a good idea?
I’m sure he see a psychiatrist once a month in prison. He’s on meds
The three people he murdered (and the others he injured) got the opposite of life. This man should not get the chance to walk free again, regardless of his age at the time of the crime.
He just proved to me that he can't be set loose in society. Too dangerous
He killed THREE people and he wants out in the world? He does NOT need to be in society especially after he said the voices in his head told him to jump off the stairs wtf leave him in jail for 125 years please
When it comes to mass shooters they should NEVER be even given the slightest opportunity for parole it’s sickening that they even hold a trial and entertain the idea for it.
DO NOT RELEASE HIM!! THOSE THREE GIRLS WILL NEVER COME HOME!!
How is killing 3 people equivalent to 20 years in prison..
Ps. 3 people killed and ONLY 20 years!?!!!! That's a ridiculous sentence!
Oh my God!?! 🤬 😮😮
He should never be let out. The trauma alone even if everyone survived.
At least he’s honest about the voices. Makes the parole board’s job easier to deny him.
😄Right...wonder if he knew that🤔
I almost wanna tell em "Dude, you're supposed to lie and tell us you're a changed man!!!!"
He got out.
@@tripledvideos6815 he did not get out. Where do you get your false information from? He was denied parole.
He wouldn’t know what to do outside those walls 25 years later. Much different world. His day was beastie boys , PlayStation 1 and driving a Chevy Cavalier. Today is ps5, tik tok, lil Nas x and driving a Tesla. Two totally different worlds.
They cannot let this man ever be free!
Forget about it besides he is 49 and would he do it again probably not
@@trump2.o152 nah your insane if you think he should be let go to live his life. Victims weren’t allowed to live theirs so it’s only fair he stay behind bars for life.
@@frankoh3451 he is harmless and what is the point of putting him in prison and there alot of school shooting happening around the United States and get used to
@@frankoh3451 the whole point of prison is paying for your crime by not enjoying the benefits of life while reflecting and reforming. Its only a permanent settlement for those who dont reflect and have no remorse for their actions.
@@EmanPKR sorry man but anyone who takes the life of another person shouldn’t be out on the streets. The victim is gone while the suspect gets to enjoy part of his life? That doesn’t seem like justice for me.
He still sounds insane 😮
It's insane to even think that 25 years ago this was happening.
Exactly
M'urica! 🇺🇲
Columbine was even older. Look it up!
The first school shooting was in 1840 in america
Let's not emphasize his defense over some imaginary 'voices'. That guy took away innocent lives, and damaged so many others.
NOW, even after 25yrs he's alive and privileged to talk in front of his cell 'magic mirror' all day long! 🙏
First fool you don't know what he hears 2nd people hear voices all the time because it's real to them 3rd you have no idea what prison does to a person with that being said he should NOT be released
@@goodnightmunchie why would being black change anything?
I think he should be free because he already served his time and what the point of putting him back in prison
He needs to never be let out....ever
He's only 39?! Jesus Christ! Stay out of prison folks.
He cannot be given parole. He took all they had and all they ever had. He needs ro find peace in prison.
he still has voices in his head. even if he gets intensive treatment after his release, he’s still a danger to everyone. there’s no telling that he wont do it again. do NOT release him, prevent a tragedy from potentially occurring again.
He haven't done treatment yet but you're already judging him. Dude is trying so hard to prove himself he's a changed man now, his better self. He even said he was responsible and feel sorry for what he did and the shootings after his. Instead of keeping him locked up, we should send him to a mental institution to be treated so the bad voices in his head will be gone. More prison time isn't helping him, clearly. Judging him, keeping him up in prison for me is us being cruel to our own. 25 years I think is already enough, let's give him a chance.
@@IgorFranknstn27 he literally killed 3 people and permanently paralyzed a woman. Like she said he sentenced her to life in a wheel chair never to be able to walk again. And he dished out 3 death sentences no mass shooter deserves any kindness or mercy doesn’t matter if he’s “sorry” for what he did (which i would take that sorry as a grain of salt when it comes to people like this)
The constitution states he did his time and has the right to have his gun rights restored. God bless America. I didn't read anything about demons or voices in someone's head in the Bill of Rights therefore it isn't real.
@@IgorFranknstn27The girls didn't get a chance, neither does he.
I think he needs more medical and psychological care in a secure facility than to spend another 25 years in prison. He's definitely not ready to be with the public, or be a benefit to society, but that doesn't mean he doesn't deserve to get better.
I agree completely. He should be released from prison into a psychiatric hospital where he can receive treatment for his ongoing mental health issues. I guarantee he hasn’t received adequate, if any, psychiatric treatment since he went to prison. If he is still hearing command voices regularly, he is likely suffering from some sort of psychotic disorder and needs to be in a hospital setting where he can receive proper care. I’m not at all saying he should be released into the public-he shouldn’t. But, he should be sent to a long term, institution.
"facility"
Schizophrenia is not curable snowflake
I totally agree. Denying somone the opportunity to change seems wrong, so put percautions into place where he can try but not do much damage if he does anything more, and maybe someday he can live somewhat of his life in society.
@@xx_3happypig3_xx26 except child predators. if you think they can change then get help
Why should he get out of prison, if this poor lady can’t get out of the wheelchair he put her in? The people he murdered can’t get out of their graves. 25 years, I just don’t know.
There's no way in hell he's getting parole. You can't unbreak what is broken.
This is heartbreaking! He ruined his classmate's life. He is a troubled man. I appreciate his honesty though, he need help.
Should never be let out.
agree
@@KennyMcCormick5467 lmfaoooo
Agreed
@@KennyMcCormick5467 okay so I know it's a joke but if somebody actually said this legitimately what would the reason be of why he should be let out
@@Untaken4 not funny but okay
Oh Hell No. This man is a danger to himself And everybody else.
He may have been sick in the head, but i appreciate his honesty. He could've just lied but he didn't. I hope he gets the treatment he needs.
The fact he stated he still hears voices is a clear indication hes not getting out.
those voices should tell him "stay locked up, you're a danger"
It's so outrageous the way these killers get portrayed as the victims.
even though the purpose of prison is retribution, incapacitation, deterrence and rehabilitation, most people don't care about the rehabilitation part at all. From providing efficient mental health services to prisons, or civilians being hesitant (understandable) to welcome them back into society. its pretty sad all around. especially since many times, we can't tell if these prisoners who served a long time have genuinely changed for the better and won't pose a threat to themselves or others.
If you commit murder, there is no rehabilitation. Just Death.
I don't believe in rehabilitation for people that commit murder. When you murder it becomes easier and easier to kill again. To trust that a murderer won't kill again is selfish because what if he does kill again now you have another death that could have been avoided because rehabilitation failed.
@@1988vikable well that’s his point. There is no rehabilitation in prison. It’s just a lockup
@@1988vikable i would say the viable but seeing how theres many cases where murderers get out and actually stop killing and living a healthy life in regret says otherwise
@@1988vikable well then why do other countries who prioritize rehabilitation have way less returning crime rates?
Only situation he should even be considered for parole is if he opened fire hitting people but didn’t end up killing them or leaving them disabled for life. Ontop of that he’s still hearing voices and clearly still struggling mentally? How is this even a question keep him in prison
it’s easy to just keep them in prison instead of them getting help huh. you think prison has therapy sessions and medication testing? how can we rehabilitate him if the prison is so broken? people forget that jail/prison is meant to rehabilitate and help them back into society
@@idijwiheufbfwkajlldkwnkjdn3108 the people he killed can’t be rehabilitated
Nah - anyone that even *attempts* to kill kids in a manor like that should be locked up for life.
@@idijwiheufbfwkajlldkwnkjdn3108 Y’all only want therapy and counseling for certain people. What about the drug dealers they put away for life and never get granted parole.
@@idijwiheufbfwkajlldkwnkjdn3108 They don’t kill innocent people, but yet they get 25 to more years in prison.
25 years on and still hearing voices. Yeah...that's a definite no
He still hasn’t take accountability ! And he’s still hearing voices he’ll no !
The fact he admitted it makes me feel sorry for him. If he truly meant to do any harm at this point in his life, I don’t think he would have said he hears voices. Clearly makes it tougher to be let out and sounds more like a cry for help.
Let him and his voices rot in a cell.
This is what came to mind as well. He deserves some psychiatric help at least. He sounded honest.
Child bye
I understand your empathy. But, lots of people have really severe schizophrenia, and they _decide_ not to hurt others. Most self harm, or self treat with illicit drugs (unfortunately). I hope he gets treatment, but he owns his actions.
@@yumiko0017 good argument, very thoughtful.
This might be a case of demons.
😅he is the demon himself
He’s only 39??? He looks 59!
Absolutely Rediculously INSANE. People pay taxes to feel safe and secure... now this?
At least he's honest about it. He definitely needs help with those voices. 👀
Do you remember picking UP the gun?? He's sick. Do not release!!
Dude is lying his teeth out, coming up with excuses and denying responsibility
He does not deserve to be released
Just NO!!!
For the record, parole was refused.
The voices in his head is a red flag. My condolences go out to these victims & their families.
Anyone granting parole to those that commit crimes later should be given sentences. Watch parole officers actually look at cases and be more reserved.
I don't wonder "if" they will let him out, I wonder "when" will they let him out
To be fair we all have voices and evil thoughts in our head but the vast majority of us don't act on them.
Correct 👆
@@td.adigee not an excuse. What he describing was not an episode, at best he could have been suffering from perpetrator PTSD, because he remembers what he did, he knew it was wrong, and it's his brain attempting to cope with his trauma. Hence his convenient "blackouts" during the shooting.
Point is, he's a liability.
There is no way to be certain or not he'll have another episode, his next victim potentially could be you, your family, or anyone's family. Which is why he needs to remain where he is.
The most sane take out there. It's ok to live in a crazy world as long as you keep it to your own self.
That is not true.
I don't really believe him, he "cant remember" firing the shots and "the voices" told him to do it, all while hunched over like a spineless coward... hes just trying to make himself not accountable and if he's released (he wont be) he will probably kill more girls with a head as clear as day.
The voices in my head says to keep him where he's at.
Never. Never. It is already a great shame that he is allowed to remain in this world.
Absolutely not!
I was a sophomore when this happened and was going through my school libraries collection of Stephen King books when it happened, so I remember it happening a little more clearly than other events at the time because it all seemed to focus on Kings book "Rage". That dude was huge news....it was a couple years before Columbine and this was still the sort of thing that was severely abnormal at the time. I remember my church acting like Christians were starting to be targeted for their beliefs in schools after this too.
you should have checked out the book and kept it, it's worth money now
I don't want to hear it!!! Life in prison!!!!! Nuff said!!!!!!!
Ad Claustrum
Invincible Ignorance
Ableism
Hope you weren't born with a brain you didn't ask for.
I have a dear dear friend who’s 35 and I’m 54, and he’s schizophrenic and bipolar and I’ve seen him get violent and turn into something that I never ever want to see again. He became like the Incredible Hulk and was hearing voices and I was petrified. I’m a big woman at 5’10 250 and he is 6’4 320 and he could have snapped my neck so easily. But as long as he takes his meds he’s the best person and I call him my adopted son. Being around someone who hears voices and gets violent really made me change my mind about schizophrenia but I don’t think he should ever see the light of day either.
How about NEVER parole him!!
Gotta admire his honesty at least
Idc about his honesty, he comes out thinking he one of us again , her justice is not served
Agreed but i think he should serve 25yrs for each life he sent early to the grave, so that means 75yrs 🐱👍🏿
@@goodnightmunchie 🤡you must be friends with this dude then , thinking 20 years is enough for killing people in a school , don’t care how old he was , parole shouldn’t been a option, I feel bad for you thinking 20 years or even parole was enough 🤡🤡
True
@@absiyehassan36??????
When you realize that your wrong deeds cost you back more than you can imagine 🤔🙄😑 This is why we all should keep a humble character because any kind of evil is punishable. You might having a good time now but later you'll suffer the consequences at your most vulnerable hours...
He was not granted parole. He was ordered to ‘serve out’ his sentence. Which was life in prison. So he will never be released.
After 25 years, and still hearing voices, it’s safe to say he’s too far gone. Can’t feel bad for everybody.
Darn! Prison aged him 40 years in 25!
Only 25 years is crazy !!
Everyone is talking about his killing, but no one is asking him why he did it
I dont believe public shooters should even have the possibility of parole
What about private school shooters?
**UPDATE**
On September 26, 2022, the parole board unanimously denied Carneal's bid for parole and ordered him to serve out the remainder of his life sentence. The "serve out" ruling, under Kentucky law, means the inmate in question cannot be considered for any future parole hearings. This means Carneal's life with parole sentence is now effectively a life without parole (or "whole life") sentence.
3 deaths and irreparable injuries and he wants out after 25 years... he's really not remorseful
Not sure he actually wants out; He admitted he still hears the voices. I suspect he is afraid of living outside now, knowing he may not be able to support himself and would end up out on the streets.
To be clear, though, either way I don’t think he should be released.
He wants parole so how does he not want out...
Maybe one of the voices told him to seek parole, but another doesn’t want it.
Why don’t the voices in the head ever say something like “go feed the homeless “
He shouldn’t be allowed in public
Never. Release. Him. From. Prison.
We all have voices in our head, they're called thoughts
And some people think that's an excuse to not to take responsibility!
it’s called intuition
Or autohallucinations
Search up schizophrenia dude.
no not always
So when the voices in his head tell him non-harmful things he's OK? Should never be released.
This was such a terrible tragedy and I feel like he needs some serious mental health care
He can't even take responsibility after 25 years.
Nope. Blaming nonexistent "voices," thinking that'll somehow help his case. That lie actually brought up a reverse Uno card.
He was denied parole and now will have to serve out his life sentence. He will never be considered for parole again.
That’s not true u get to see parole every 5 years
Dude is 39?? The years have not been kind to him. Guilt is really eating him up. He looks close to 60.