This whole episode should been managed by Dr. Charles. The whole hospital should be run by Dr. Charles. What do I said? the whole series should be run by Dr. Charles.
I'm amazed with all the Ethan vs April comments here. I'm not a healthcare professional, but it seems Ethan was in the right here and I agree, although I can't help but admire April's fortitude to risk her own safety to save somebody else. As a hero, that's incredibly admirable, but as a healthcare worker that's just reckless. I like how this show challenges your beliefs and perceptions of morale like that.
I think if it had come from anyone else she'd have listen. Choi has a way of dismissing her concerns and values with cold rationnality which puts her off every single time.
I think House once said something along the lines of "if you don't think your life is worth anything, just be an organ donor and jump off a cliff". You should never sacrifice yourself for a job and that includes healthcare
Backing Dr Choi's decision 100%. April is too emotional for her own good. Empathy is required in the healthcare field, but not at the expense of putting yourself in danger, which could potentially increase your workmate's workload, use up finite resources, and place the patient - which you were trying so hard to protect, in even more danger due to distracted healthcare professionals and sharing of resources. In such a situation, it is also not a nurse's call to make and it makes no sense to argue with the Dr when they are acting professionally as per training and their direct actions are not considered malpractice or oversight leading to patient harm.
I agree for some reason it's a thing in this show that people overstep certain boundaries, especially manning yelling at everyone left and right superior or not 😭
It also is not a doctor's call. It is a scene of the fire department, which just happens to be in a hospital. It is absolutely their call to make if it is safe enough to lift the car or not. Especially since doctors have no training in evaluating safety for these operations.
@@Silent.Program that's why Ethan asked if the fire dept thought it was safe enough anf essentially told them to take the risk of letting the patient die. In these kinds of situations it's less about whose call it is and more about different teams working together to ensure as few fatalities as possible. That means the fire dept keeping the structure stable and the medical professionals figuring out who they can save
choi's one mistake was not swapping out the fact is he did let his personal feelings cloud his judgment it was too cautious to the point that he put the paitients life at risk just to be 110% sure it was safe when any other doctor would likely have taken the risk sooner the fire guys even said the paitients leg was free they could have pulled him out but choi's feelings for april meant he decied to wait until it was safe beyond any doubt which put the paitient at risk.
I get where April is coming from but i support Ethans decision the most bc if the car collapsed that mean an extra patient plus extra supplies also an extra room
I agree with Ethan. The car could have collapsed if they hadn't waited for the Fire Department to do as much as they could to stabilise the car and the equipment.
Not necessarily. She’s a good person with a massive heart, but as a nurse she is reckless, unprofessional, and borderline incompetent. She absolutely should not have put herself in danger-the second something happens to her, now there are two patients. Personal safety is always step #1 for anyone in healthcare, and first response. Then she is trying to argue with the doctor. The doctor is not committing malpractice or anything of the sort, he was making the right call where she was thinking with her emotions rather than her brain. That is a danger to the healthcare industry-she is a good person, but dangerous to have in a team. She argues with the authorities who are making appropriate calls, and then tries to argue that she wasn’t the patient, “he was”, so they should have all risked her ending up patient #3. Unless she forged her way through nursing school or was off in lala land, she’s an idiot. An emotional, reckless, dangerous idiot who doesn’t like the way the world works and wants to play superhero. It makes her a good person, but it does not make her a good nurse.
@@emikookime1849 No, the doctor is the emotional, reckless, dangerous idiot that cares more about ONE nurse more than a single patient. She knew the risks of getting under the car, having a nurse that is willing the go the extra mile to save a patient is better than a doctor that does a full stop the moment something gets 'too risky'
Yes, both people live. The driver had a tumor near his heart, so instead of replacing the heart as originally planned, they took it out to take out the tumor and put it back in.
A real nurse would not do that put yourself at risk and break health and safety rules Besides never talk about bowel movement pressure sore or anything like that
A nurse like April is a gift to humanity. But the thing is..if they say they can't shift...then they can't. This is the unfortunate truth. The hospital and fire dept could have been sued by April's family if something happened to her though she was the one who forced their hand. Sometimes...there is nothing that can be done.
Thats the fucked up thing to ever do to a person stuck under a car and dying while being asked to be a potential donor for heart. Morover if he is not in an emotional state to consent due to extreme pain and losing consciousness here and there, how his consent would be valid?
I was saying the same thing. How can you ask something like that to a person who's dying? He was already scared to die, they didn't have to make it worse. Also, shouldn't there be a consent form for organ donors? They could've just checked that instead of asking him directly.
From what I’ve seen online and have read online that the owner donor people will find out who’s near to death and start hounding the parents or the spouse or the partner of the one who’s dying for their organs and if the nagging works and they get the organs from the patient once they die, the family never hear from them again no thank you no nothing. Like everything else it’s a business.
I personally love that chicago fire, chicago med and Chicago pd are all linked- Like watching some dramatic scene in CM then seeing kelly from CF is BLOODY AWESOMEEE
If anything happened, April would be his patient too. That wasn't a roses and sunflower situation, it was a trauma case, an extremely sensitive situation. Props to Dr.Choi for acting professional and following the protocol and stay level-headed. April, despite having good intentions acted stupid, she has become a danger to the healthcare system and his team by her reckless and unprofessional decision making and decision making is the prime job of healthcare workers.
Patients who have hypotension’s to that degree are not candidates for organ donation. Asking Don to be an organ donor and standing over him for an answer is ridiculous. He should have been intubated while he was under the car and maximized to the most support as possible ready for straight to the trama OR once he was out.
Honestly I see both sides to what people are saying, but fundamentally April was in the wrong. As a health care worker she needs to stay safe and while Dr. Choi should have left as a doctor he tried to make the best possible decisions he could. Had April not put herself at risk things could have gone extremely differently, with her under the car too she put a second life at risk which added to the reasons of why they had to be even more careful with the car. All in all I think they did the best they could, its easy to judge but people are emotional beings and stuff like this just happens :/
Choi would have done the same thing the only reason he didnt want april there is because they are in a relationship and he cares about her more than a nurse breaking the rules.
This Hospital and its ER seems to be the most dangerous places to work on the planet, the number of staff shot, stabbed, set on fire, hit by cars and mauled to death by Lions is incredible.
@@zucchinikindaslayed Don’t tell me you missed the episode where the circus truck crashed into the ambulance bay, setting a Lion loose in the ER. In the end Dr Charles hypnotised the Lion ‘Crocodile Dundee’ style.
@@makeil2465 there's that one episode where he disagrees with her and wants her to agree with him because he thinks his decision is the best for the patient and she tells him "it's not because we're sleeping together that I have to agree with you!" and I was like woah calm down lady. There's no link between this and that.
@@myheartwillstopinjoy8142 Yeah Ethan was just thinking about the patient and needed others to agree to help him, April is cool i don't hate her but sometimes she does and says some stupid things. She really is driven by emotions.
@@romanov3937 yeah, I agree. I don't know why they always make women doctors and nurses so unnecessarily emotional. It's like the writers think women can't be objective...
There was a whole ER full of people, it only takes about half a dozen people to lift a car off of someone, but still they just stood around helplessly. Useless.
April works off of almost pure emotion sometimes, and while empathy can be an amazing thing, it doesn't always correspond well in the medical field if it controls your decisions. Which is why I never even considered being in the medical field lol.
Where I live a guy went into the hospital and stabbed two nurses (one happened to be his ex wife) and a patient it was all over the news because after he had done that he went a ended it all in the local river!
Watching Chicago med all this time made me wander if I'm making the right decision to enter medical school... You definitely would be face with Unwanted Circumstances you have no control of.
April vs Ethan argument aside, all I can think of is how ironic it was that the driver responsible for Don dying is going to get Don's organs so the driver (again the cause of Don's death) can live. It's like a very bad, very grim joke by the universe. I know the driver didn't intentionally kill Don, but still.
Guy crashed on victim. Victim starts to lose consciousness. Doctor: can we give your heart to the guy? It is a fucked up situation. Victim had all rights to freak out or pissed off and anything.
if I could think straight during such a situation, I'd answer I'm an organ donor but how can they give my organs if I bleed out? If they are to give your organs, they need you in good shape, no? If you bleed out for instance, I'm pretty sure your organs are not good anymore. I'm no medical professional so maybe I'm wrong though XD
it's a fucked up situation, but doctors don't see them as a guy who crashed on victim and the victim, they see them as patients. Patient who is in need of something that could save his life which another patient can provide who's on the verge of dying. It's protocol to ask before the patient died to be an organ donor if they come to a dead-end and nothing can be done to save him anymore. The heart has to be fresh, if he dies the organ is of no use.
The doctors only created more victims in this scenario. They KILLED a doctor (because they were lazy and scared) and saved a criminal who will only kill more people. They failed no matter how you look at it. They didn't save anyone worth saving.
You're not a medical professional so you don't know the absolute terror of possibly losing two people you could potentially save ..but one has lesser chances so you work with that hoping their loss could mean that someone else might get to live on.
But April didnt let it go out on the patient, Choi cared so much abt April he didnt take a risk he easily would have taken if anyone else was under that car.
This is fiction. So maybe the character in the serie is, but they aren’t real healthcare workers. They are comedian, and more seriously its a stuntman.
@@celinewirard7583 So... healthcare workers aren't amazing? The show may be an over-exaggeration, as shows are usually, but it doesn't really diminish how amazing healthcare workers are in the real field. That's just what I meant.
Chicago fire has broken some rules depending on the situation to save people’s lives. The only reason he asked about the donor is so he could at least saved one life for not risking April
in a rescue scenario rescuer should avoid being injured, because an injured rescuer will only add another problem. rescuers also priority safety for themselves first before helping others.
There are so many comments saying April was being emotional and stuff, but no one's talking about Dr Choi. _He was too emotionally involved and everyone could see it._ They even asked to change the doctor because of how terrified he looked but he insisted he was fine. He waited until the last possible moment to get them out, he wanted it to be 100% sure that nothing would fall. But the guy was dying and when the firefighter said "I can't promise it won't collapse" there was a risk he could take. It doesn't matter if you agree with his call or not, what matters is that he was not in his right mind to decide, because since April was involved he couldn't think rationally about the options. You can see he's all over the place, emotional and nervous, while he's usually very calm and collected. I think he was way more emotional than her, she was trying to communicate and defend what she thought was right. He didn't even know what he was defending because he was a mess.
I totally agree. Dr. Choi should of stepped down and let the other doctor resume the situation. Fair play to that nurse stepping into danger and keeping the person calm and stopping the blood in his leg.
So happy she is gone. No idea why they made her South African. Her accent was so terrible, it was unwatchable, I had to skip over all her scenes. And why on earth would her South African mentor go to Chicago for a heart transplant when South Africa is known for heart surgery. Unrealistic storyline.
Sometimes April forgets that she's JUST the Nurse and NOT A DOCTOR!! Let Ethan make his own decisions as a Doctor!! Moreover, it was SO FOOLISH of them to show that so many people took so long to remove car from there. That guy would have been saved. Asking that guy for organ donation was also wrong by Rhodes and Choi. April was right there.
April’s intensional were noble but stupid. Recall the plane crash analogy: Don’t try & help other’s put their masks on before you’ve got yours. Dr. Choi was 100% right here. Yes, they could’ve pulled him out then & there & the car might’ve collapsed on top of both of them. Now, instead of one person being stuck & dying, you’ve got 2. This would also set the responders back, thus keeping the victims trapped longer. Absolutely no good would come from rushing this. As for the organs, was it insensitive to ask about it at the time? Yes. Was it necessary to potentially save someone else? Also, yes. You have to work w/ what you’ve got, & it’s better to know if you’re getting more.
Ethan was 100% right. If the car would´ve collapsed while they tried to pull him out then both of them would have died. I am not healthcare worker but I dont think sacrificing urself is good and creating more work than there already is, isn´t such a great idea when the patient also dies.
The fact she knows she only one to fit then choi wanting switch in. Shows he knows medical if something went wrong from fire side he had more chance under there.
He could have gotten them both killed if he did something sooner. It’s not that black and white. April shouldn’t have put her own life at risk like that. She’s a nurse not a superhero
@@catherinecreativevideos Actually she wasn’t. Step #1 is ALWAYS protect yourself first. You learn that everywhere in healthcare. That’s why PPE is such a big thing-don’t treat your Ebola patient before protecting yourself from getting Ebola. Same thing-don’t crawl under a collapsing car to help a guy who is dying from said-collapsing car. She was not doing her job, she was playing superhero.
Just FYI what they did was provide a backup if the airbags would fail and the car would crash back down. They stacked up blocks of wood, so the car could not get lower as it was when they started. As everything went fine, the "additional safety" did not impact the rescue at all. It is still important but took ages. Stacking up the safety blocks should have been done in very few minutes.
I agree. I'm not an expert but even as a layman I've seen it done faster.... I've even seen thieves lifting up a car with the jack in less than 15 sec (+another 20 to steal catalyctic converter but that's another story)....
It a show and that mean that they have a time to work with. Although it had other cases in this episode, this case or scene was the highlight of the episode, so they could not make it end in 15 minutes
April's emotions can really make her act unprofessional sometimes. Ma'am he wasn't trying to make more victims, what's wrong with you😭 Not these doctors asking bro to donate his heart💀
i agree with ethan because if the car collapsed that would've made two victims and firefighters want to move the car as slowly as possible so it's not unstable to cause further damage plus sometimes you can't guarantee a patient to survive
First rule of first aid: don't create more victims. Help if/where you can but keep yourself safe first. That's what I've been taught at least
True but in this case she practically saved him up to that point
ahh yes but you forget Vince, first rule of making a tv show , More drama means more viewer's,
@@cleo8332 fair enough haha
Ok good to know
If you do everything by the book you'll never get anything done.
This whole episode should been managed by Dr. Charles. The whole hospital should be run by Dr. Charles. What do I said? the whole series should be run by Dr. Charles.
Fr, he is like a superhero! His instincts are rarely ever wrong. We stan Dr Charles ❤
New series to the franchise - Chicago: Charles
🤣🤣🤣
@@dragon_toad please 🤣
@@dragon_toad best thing ever 🤣🤣🤣
I'm amazed with all the Ethan vs April comments here. I'm not a healthcare professional, but it seems Ethan was in the right here and I agree, although I can't help but admire April's fortitude to risk her own safety to save somebody else. As a hero, that's incredibly admirable, but as a healthcare worker that's just reckless. I like how this show challenges your beliefs and perceptions of morale like that.
I think if it had come from anyone else she'd have listen. Choi has a way of dismissing her concerns and values with cold rationnality which puts her off every single time.
I think House once said something along the lines of "if you don't think your life is worth anything, just be an organ donor and jump off a cliff".
You should never sacrifice yourself for a job and that includes healthcare
Backing Dr Choi's decision 100%. April is too emotional for her own good. Empathy is required in the healthcare field, but not at the expense of putting yourself in danger, which could potentially increase your workmate's workload, use up finite resources, and place the patient - which you were trying so hard to protect, in even more danger due to distracted healthcare professionals and sharing of resources. In such a situation, it is also not a nurse's call to make and it makes no sense to argue with the Dr when they are acting professionally as per training and their direct actions are not considered malpractice or oversight leading to patient harm.
I agree for some reason it's a thing in this show that people overstep certain boundaries, especially manning yelling at everyone left and right superior or not 😭
yea it's the only thing that irks me. The blind stupidity characters start having for couch potatoes that need obvious drama every dialogue.
It also is not a doctor's call. It is a scene of the fire department, which just happens to be in a hospital. It is absolutely their call to make if it is safe enough to lift the car or not. Especially since doctors have no training in evaluating safety for these operations.
@@Silent.Program that's why Ethan asked if the fire dept thought it was safe enough anf essentially told them to take the risk of letting the patient die. In these kinds of situations it's less about whose call it is and more about different teams working together to ensure as few fatalities as possible. That means the fire dept keeping the structure stable and the medical professionals figuring out who they can save
choi's one mistake was not swapping out the fact is he did let his personal feelings cloud his judgment it was too cautious to the point that he put the paitients life at risk just to be 110% sure it was safe when any other doctor would likely have taken the risk sooner the fire guys even said the paitients leg was free they could have pulled him out but choi's feelings for april meant he decied to wait until it was safe beyond any doubt which put the paitient at risk.
I get where April is coming from but i support Ethans decision the most bc if the car collapsed that mean an extra patient plus extra supplies also an extra room
I agree with Ethan. The car could have collapsed if they hadn't waited for the Fire Department to do as much as they could to stabilise the car and the equipment.
Ethan loves April so much. April is very emotional about the patients and willingly goes the extra mile. She is an excellent nurse.
Not necessarily. She’s a good person with a massive heart, but as a nurse she is reckless, unprofessional, and borderline incompetent. She absolutely should not have put herself in danger-the second something happens to her, now there are two patients. Personal safety is always step #1 for anyone in healthcare, and first response.
Then she is trying to argue with the doctor. The doctor is not committing malpractice or anything of the sort, he was making the right call where she was thinking with her emotions rather than her brain. That is a danger to the healthcare industry-she is a good person, but dangerous to have in a team. She argues with the authorities who are making appropriate calls, and then tries to argue that she wasn’t the patient, “he was”, so they should have all risked her ending up patient #3.
Unless she forged her way through nursing school or was off in lala land, she’s an idiot. An emotional, reckless, dangerous idiot who doesn’t like the way the world works and wants to play superhero. It makes her a good person, but it does not make her a good nurse.
@@emikookime1849 No, the doctor is the emotional, reckless, dangerous idiot that cares more about ONE nurse more than a single patient. She knew the risks of getting under the car, having a nurse that is willing the go the extra mile to save a patient is better than a doctor that does a full stop the moment something gets 'too risky'
@@DarkFlameVee it's not only the nurse who would have gotten hurt if the car crashed. That patient would also be in more danger
@@DarkFlameVee you're talking so much nonsense, I won't waste my time picking your comment apart.
@@DarkFlameVee Do you require an ice cold bath after getting so viciously burned?
Yes, both people live.
The driver had a tumor near his heart, so instead of replacing the heart as originally planned, they took it out to take out the tumor and put it back in.
First rule of emergency medical services: Don't make yourself another casualty.
April is so caring but sometimes she does get a bit too emotional, still love her though, so sad she's gone 💖😭 and also l love One Chicago 💖
A real nurse would not do that put yourself at risk and break health and safety rules
Besides never talk about bowel movement pressure sore or anything like that
Does she die? I’m
Not up to daye
@@killingkisses5376 me either, oh no
@@killingkisses5376 I think she left the show
I dont remember her daying. When?
A nurse like April is a gift to humanity. But the thing is..if they say they can't shift...then they can't. This is the unfortunate truth. The hospital and fire dept could have been sued by April's family if something happened to her though she was the one who forced their hand. Sometimes...there is nothing that can be done.
Thats the fucked up thing to ever do to a person stuck under a car and dying while being asked to be a potential donor for heart.
Morover if he is not in an emotional state to consent due to extreme pain and losing consciousness here and there, how his consent would be valid?
I was saying the same thing. How can you ask something like that to a person who's dying? He was already scared to die, they didn't have to make it worse. Also, shouldn't there be a consent form for organ donors? They could've just checked that instead of asking him directly.
From what I’ve seen online and have read online that the owner donor people will find out who’s near to death and start hounding the parents or the spouse or the partner of the one who’s dying for their organs and if the nagging works and they get the organs from the patient once they die, the family never hear from them again no thank you no nothing. Like everything else it’s a business.
I personally love that chicago fire, chicago med and Chicago pd are all linked- Like watching some dramatic scene in CM then seeing kelly from CF is BLOODY AWESOMEEE
If anything happened, April would be his patient too. That wasn't a roses and sunflower situation, it was a trauma case, an extremely sensitive situation. Props to Dr.Choi for acting professional and following the protocol and stay level-headed. April, despite having good intentions acted stupid, she has become a danger to the healthcare system and his team by her reckless and unprofessional decision making and decision making is the prime job of healthcare workers.
I don't know what clip you watched, but she was the only reason the patient didn't bleed out.
@@Rosawynbut still WRONG. first rules is SAVE YOURSELF THEN SAVE PATIENT. You can't save patient when you can't save yourself first.
@@sugaryee If the most wrong thing any of us ever does is save someone's life, I think we'd be doing ok.
@@Rosawyn if the vehicle collapsed there would be another patient, her emotions always cloud her judgement which isn’t ideal for this type of career
Chicago med, Chicago pd, and Chicago fire omgg the best things in the world!!!!!💕
Definitely
Yeah
@@k.oseiagyarko4608 it’s the best!
@@ieuanmitchell6798 yes !
@@rachelcomer817 I know that.
After watching so many chicago meds vids/clips that girl is so emotional----
Right? Like I only watched few videos on RUclips and I can tell how her emotions make her unprofessional at some situations.
shut up
Avas face when Rhodes was talking to Robin
Patients who have hypotension’s to that degree are not candidates for organ donation. Asking Don to be an organ donor and standing over him for an answer is ridiculous. He should have been intubated while he was under the car and maximized to the most support as possible ready for straight to the trama OR once he was out.
Honestly I see both sides to what people are saying, but fundamentally April was in the wrong.
As a health care worker she needs to stay safe and while Dr. Choi should have left as a doctor he tried to make the best possible decisions he could.
Had April not put herself at risk things could have gone extremely differently, with her under the car too she put a second life at risk which added to the reasons of why they had to be even more careful with the car.
All in all I think they did the best they could, its easy to judge but people are emotional beings and stuff like this just happens :/
Choi would have done the same thing the only reason he didnt want april there is because they are in a relationship and he cares about her more than a nurse breaking the rules.
This Hospital and its ER seems to be the most dangerous places to work on the planet, the number of staff shot, stabbed, set on fire, hit by cars and mauled to death by Lions is incredible.
lmaoo true tho
wait... LIONS??
@@zucchinikindaslayed Don’t tell me you missed the episode where the circus truck crashed into the ambulance bay, setting a Lion loose in the ER. In the end Dr Charles hypnotised the Lion ‘Crocodile Dundee’ style.
I love the way they are so busy then they jump like 100mph to the scene xd
So hard working people
Correct me if I'm wrong but I have the feeling that April tends to be too emotional and sometimes even a little unprofessional
I do as well she is out of line sometimes and she always thinks that Dr Cho is thinking about her
Absolutely
@@makeil2465 there's that one episode where he disagrees with her and wants her to agree with him because he thinks his decision is the best for the patient and she tells him "it's not because we're sleeping together that I have to agree with you!" and I was like woah calm down lady. There's no link between this and that.
@@myheartwillstopinjoy8142 Yeah Ethan was just thinking about the patient and needed others to agree to help him, April is cool i don't hate her but sometimes she does and says some stupid things. She really is driven by emotions.
@@romanov3937 yeah, I agree. I don't know why they always make women doctors and nurses so unnecessarily emotional. It's like the writers think women can't be objective...
I have to agree with Dr Choi on this one.
April aside, if the car had dropped down even further, the dude would have been crushed as well!
My favourite Chicago med is choi he is so active
There was a whole ER full of people, it only takes about half a dozen people to lift a car off of someone, but still they just stood around helplessly. Useless.
It's a show, they need the watch time and to show the connection with chicago fire
Also, they said his leg was trapped in the wheel well, which would require a fair bit of care in removing safely
April works off of almost pure emotion sometimes, and while empathy can be an amazing thing, it doesn't always correspond well in the medical field if it controls your decisions.
Which is why I never even considered being in the medical field lol.
What a lovely place get hurt. In an Emergency Room (ER)
Severide got hurt here too
@@9-1-1fannn8 every one got hurt here hahah. remember the suicide bomb
@@omaverick2870 yea but they weren't as bad as Severide
Where I live a guy went into the hospital and stabbed two nurses (one happened to be his ex wife) and a patient it was all over the news because after he had done that he went a ended it all in the local river!
@@hstaylor_ oh
Ethan loves April so much, it's crazy. Like it shows through every pores of his skin
YES YOU UPLOADED I WAS SO BORED
Its good to see chicago fire department and chicago medical department working together
April needs to chill like bro he was trying to help you, be grateful
This is the most crazy scene that I've ever seen before. Can't imagine that is very crazy.
Watching Chicago med all this time made me wander if I'm making the right decision to enter medical school...
You definitely would be face with Unwanted Circumstances you have no control of.
April does all it takes to save her patients she could go the extra mile to bring them back to life...she is thoughtful and caring
]
thoughtful and caring? sure, a good nurse? not at all
one of my favourite episodes ❤
What happened next?
Just lift up the freaking car!!
April vs Ethan argument aside, all I can think of is how ironic it was that the driver responsible for Don dying is going to get Don's organs so the driver (again the cause of Don's death) can live. It's like a very bad, very grim joke by the universe. I know the driver didn't intentionally kill Don, but still.
That run and slide from Ethan is definitely a warrior of a samurai at 4:13 😮
Guy crashed on victim. Victim starts to lose consciousness. Doctor: can we give your heart to the guy?
It is a fucked up situation. Victim had all rights to freak out or pissed off and anything.
if I could think straight during such a situation, I'd answer I'm an organ donor but how can they give my organs if I bleed out? If they are to give your organs, they need you in good shape, no? If you bleed out for instance, I'm pretty sure your organs are not good anymore. I'm no medical professional so maybe I'm wrong though XD
@@annabees You just need the organs to be "fresh", not with blood.
it's a fucked up situation, but doctors don't see them as a guy who crashed on victim and the victim, they see them as patients. Patient who is in need of something that could save his life which another patient can provide who's on the verge of dying. It's protocol to ask before the patient died to be an organ donor if they come to a dead-end and nothing can be done to save him anymore. The heart has to be fresh, if he dies the organ is of no use.
The doctors only created more victims in this scenario. They KILLED a doctor (because they were lazy and scared) and saved a criminal who will only kill more people. They failed no matter how you look at it. They didn't save anyone worth saving.
You're not a medical professional so you don't know the absolute terror of possibly losing two people you could potentially save ..but one has lesser chances so you work with that hoping their loss could mean that someone else might get to live on.
When you pass out while driving and crash into the emergency room, god must have been steering that wheel, but he's not a very good driver XD
She out herself in harms way. She basically broke rule number 1 of first aid.
Am I the only one that was like... just put a few car jacks under the car? Did I miss something lol
his leg was stuck in the wheel they couldn't do that.
a car in the hospital?!? I mean that’s just crazy as a concept for this show
okay both of them were emotional during that situation.
But April didnt let it go out on the patient, Choi cared so much abt April he didnt take a risk he easily would have taken if anyone else was under that car.
So April wanted a double kill rather than one casualty? Right.. And now Choi is villain again? Xd man I love this show
God. Healthcare workers are amazing.
This is fiction. So maybe the character in the serie is, but they aren’t real healthcare workers. They are comedian, and more seriously its a stuntman.
@@celinewirard7583 So... healthcare workers aren't amazing? The show may be an over-exaggeration, as shows are usually, but it doesn't really diminish how amazing healthcare workers are in the real field. That's just what I meant.
Ayo that hospital needs an express lane at the entrance
I love how as soon as Kelly saw April on the floor he rushed to her and asked “ April, are you hurt!” ❤😊
Chicago med is the best
Nurse is mad because Dr followed correct emergencgy procedure and didn't risk creating other patients. Media gets it wrong again.
It’s just a show…
She so annoyed in this ep
Chicago fire has broken some rules depending on the situation to save people’s lives. The only reason he asked about the donor is so he could at least saved one life for not risking April
That was a very nice car they wrecked. It was one of the best cars ever made by any company . I know I owned one
I’m surprised April didn’t get cramp in her hands and accidentally let go
atleast they had all equipment on scene
Man I forgot what a badass April is. 👏
in a rescue scenario
rescuer should avoid being injured, because an injured rescuer will only add another problem.
rescuers also priority safety for themselves first before helping others.
There are so many comments saying April was being emotional and stuff, but no one's talking about Dr Choi. _He was too emotionally involved and everyone could see it._
They even asked to change the doctor because of how terrified he looked but he insisted he was fine. He waited until the last possible moment to get them out, he wanted it to be 100% sure that nothing would fall. But the guy was dying and when the firefighter said "I can't promise it won't collapse" there was a risk he could take. It doesn't matter if you agree with his call or not, what matters is that he was not in his right mind to decide, because since April was involved he couldn't think rationally about the options. You can see he's all over the place, emotional and nervous, while he's usually very calm and collected.
I think he was way more emotional than her, she was trying to communicate and defend what she thought was right. He didn't even know what he was defending because he was a mess.
Exactly, Goodwin should have replaced dr choi not offered but told him.
He is in love
I totally agree. Dr. Choi should of stepped down and let the other doctor resume the situation. Fair play to that nurse stepping into danger and keeping the person calm and stopping the blood in his leg.
@@catherinecreativevideos Yh luv her
Or… he didn’t want to risk losing both the patient AND a nurse by the car collapsing. Correct decision, he did right.
Completely agree with you. April was too emotional…especially when she thinks she is in the right.
That's one way to get a quick treatment
Really hate what they did to Ava. She had so much potential.
She was kind of like Dr.Wheeler, added just for a storyline without actually killing an original character
So happy she is gone. No idea why they made her South African. Her accent was so terrible, it was unwatchable, I had to skip over all her scenes. And why on earth would her South African mentor go to Chicago for a heart transplant when South Africa is known for heart surgery. Unrealistic storyline.
@@hermiengreeff6482 she’s South African?!😳 this whole time I thought it was a shitty Australian accent😭 that explains so much 😂😂
bro its like a collab with med and fire 😂
Well yea
Just love the crossover episodes, it gives something extra.
and police!!!!!!!
Sometimes April forgets that she's JUST the Nurse and NOT A DOCTOR!! Let Ethan make his own decisions as a Doctor!! Moreover, it was SO FOOLISH of them to show that so many people took so long to remove car from there. That guy would have been saved. Asking that guy for organ donation was also wrong by Rhodes and Choi. April was right there.
They talk to lots of people that though. It’s important to know if someone could be a match and save someone else’s life.
He was far too emotional to make any kind of rational decision
5:30 the look April cave Sev was priceless
That guy reacted the same way I would I am so scared of death
April’s intensional were noble but stupid. Recall the plane crash analogy: Don’t try & help other’s put their masks on before you’ve got yours. Dr. Choi was 100% right here.
Yes, they could’ve pulled him out then & there & the car might’ve collapsed on top of both of them. Now, instead of one person being stuck & dying, you’ve got 2. This would also set the responders back, thus keeping the victims trapped longer. Absolutely no good would come from rushing this.
As for the organs, was it insensitive to ask about it at the time? Yes. Was it necessary to potentially save someone else? Also, yes. You have to work w/ what you’ve got, & it’s better to know if you’re getting more.
Yet another episode of Dr.Choi is right but people dont listen anyway
OMG THIS IS A MIRACLE
Im so proud of Yaya DaCosta 😊
Ethan was 100% right. If the car would´ve collapsed while they tried to pull him out then both of them would have died. I am not healthcare worker but I dont think sacrificing urself is good and creating more work than there already is, isn´t such a great idea when the patient also dies.
Chicago med the only movie from American ihave ever loved
I hope the e
ER are ok now and nor hurt
Lmfao it was only Yester day I was talking to my friend about how fucking dramatic this show was hahah
You always know a medical soap has jumped the shark when the doctors become the patients.
The fact she knows she only one to fit then choi wanting switch in. Shows he knows medical if something went wrong from fire side he had more chance under there.
More episodes like this pls
It’s on Netflix!!
This is what I would call on the scene
I love this show
This is where the ethics vs protocol comes in.
Not even a minute later and someone is dying already
Didn't the actress who played Nyla Harper in the rookie was there
At least they didn't have far to go.
Blood - 0:25 - 0:39 - 0:55 - 7:26 - 7:34
It's a show about doctors and an ER room. If people can't handle blood then don't watch
0:59 MY LEG!
Dr Choi lost his cool, and because he was more worried about April, he wasn't focusing on his patients needs. He nearly got the guy killed.
He could have gotten them both killed if he did something sooner. It’s not that black and white. April shouldn’t have put her own life at risk like that. She’s a nurse not a superhero
@@katrinerisbjerg she was just doing her job stopping the bleeding in his leg.
@@catherinecreativevideos Actually she wasn’t. Step #1 is ALWAYS protect yourself first. You learn that everywhere in healthcare. That’s why PPE is such a big thing-don’t treat your Ebola patient before protecting yourself from getting Ebola. Same thing-don’t crawl under a collapsing car to help a guy who is dying from said-collapsing car. She was not doing her job, she was playing superhero.
April act very bravely
April is a Karen
Did he survived?
imagine thinking your finally safe in the hospital and then a fuckng car destroys your room
How do you make this?it Looks so real
This is why you don't drive if you're unwell
Presenting to the emergency room
Ur not gonana fit under here april is so funny
8:36 This girl April is a good person with a heart of gold. She is also beautiful.
Is April stupid??? If Dr choi made them move that car before it was safe to do so, they would've had 3 patients instead of 2
But who’s the 3
@@hawraalrahma8493 the guy in the car, the guy under the car and april
@@Horizon1722 oh ok
Just FYI what they did was provide a backup if the airbags would fail and the car would crash back down. They stacked up blocks of wood, so the car could not get lower as it was when they started. As everything went fine, the "additional safety" did not impact the rescue at all. It is still important but took ages. Stacking up the safety blocks should have been done in very few minutes.
@@Silent.Program I was actually thinking about this, but what do I know? 🤣
I was so scared 😨 for him
The most unexpected things happen to the doctor's (cast) in this hospital
Am not giving my heart to something who ran over me
Sorry my only thing is that is the easiest car stabilisation out and yet they are taking for ever.
I agree. I'm not an expert but even as a layman I've seen it done faster.... I've even seen thieves lifting up a car with the jack in less than 15 sec (+another 20 to steal catalyctic converter but that's another story)....
It a show and that mean that they have a time to work with. Although it had other cases in this episode, this case or scene was the highlight of the episode, so they could not make it end in 15 minutes
April's emotions can really make her act unprofessional sometimes. Ma'am he wasn't trying to make more victims, what's wrong with you😭
Not these doctors asking bro to donate his heart💀
i agree with ethan because if the car collapsed that would've made two victims and firefighters want to move the car as slowly as possible so it's not unstable to cause further damage plus sometimes you can't guarantee a patient to survive
Chicago med ,Chicago pd,Chicago fire fight ting💪💪👍👍