Why TubNet Didn't Succeed

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 6 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 350

  • @CalebIsSalty
    @CalebIsSalty  Год назад +109

    If you liked the video, consider becoming a channel member!
    ruclips.net/channel/UCo73DWkWyTWwzb5ziM774eQjoin

    • @Shift14
      @Shift14 Год назад

      pog

    • @SolarFabric
      @SolarFabric Год назад +1

      WHY JUST WHY you said TECHNO .-. edit .... still sad

    • @Red-lu1rx
      @Red-lu1rx Год назад

      I didnt actually know what TubNet was, only knew when the it died

  • @ArcticaTheFox
    @ArcticaTheFox Год назад +2679

    I was actually curious as to why it’s not advertised more. He was genuinely so excited about it becoming a reality and talked about how revolutionary it was going to be, but when the actual server launched, he seemed a lot more silent about it than I thought he would be.

    • @CalebIsSalty
      @CalebIsSalty  Год назад +384

      EXACTLY!! the whole situation is very confusing, i really thought this server was gonna be big 🤷🏼‍♂️

    • @the_demon_dog
      @the_demon_dog Год назад +177

      @@CalebIsSalty I feel like the biggest thing is that everybody was so excited but he just kept saying “we will open next week” again and again until everybody just forgot (also I think they should do a big event thing bc the only reason I don’t play is that nobody’s on to play WITH and it’s probably the same for other people and if there was a big event going on there would be at least 500 players on )

    • @misspelledbannana6067
      @misspelledbannana6067 Год назад +41

      I thought the server was ONLY for like you-tubers and stuff and not a public server

    • @sold8215
      @sold8215 Год назад +31

      its not very confusing. simply put tubbo is being paid to advertise and they ran out of funds to pay him with. The server itself lost so much money, and its surprising its even still up and running.

    • @misspelledbannana6067
      @misspelledbannana6067 Год назад +71

      @@sold8215 but… its tubbos server he isnt being payed to advertise he is the one RUNNING the server

  • @Willerhide
    @Willerhide Год назад +1493

    The reason Tubbo doesn't advertise the server is because he is aware that the current server is unfun and lacks replayability. The developers have states that over the next couple months we will start to see patches that will add a new gamemode have new events to participate in and more improvements to the general server. I think if you do look at the times Tubbo has played his server on stream, he has noticed these issues and is waiting for them to be fixed before he hardcore advertises it.
    Tubnet Tuesdays was meant to be a weekly event similar to minecraft mondays that they would host for Tubnet. However they stopped doing them because the players that the events were pulling didn't enjoy playing on the server. Advertising a bad product has a negative effect on the brand so it is actually best they don't do anything until the updates come out fixing things.

    • @ell.....
      @ell..... Год назад +47

      TubNet 100% needs more gamemodes. atm there's only 3 (Crystal Rush, Light Strike, and Battle Royale) and most of the time there's only enough players online to queue one of the 3

    • @mira-ez2nx
      @mira-ez2nx Год назад +11

      @ellhasayoutube its confirmed that there is at least 1 new game mode coming "soon"

    • @ell.....
      @ell..... Год назад +4

      @@mira-ez2nx hope it's spacebound

    • @10ones
      @10ones Год назад +7

      I think they stopped doing tubnet Tuesdays is because they broke the game more than not enjoying the game

    • @spidscorp4523
      @spidscorp4523 Год назад +3

      Hi Willerhide

  • @CraftyMasterman
    @CraftyMasterman Год назад +242

    something i dont see a lot of people mention about tubnet is its lack of brain stimulus in general. There's a reason hypixel and mcci lobbies are reletively small, theres always players moving around and especially on hypixel theres a ton of sounds. Tubnet lobbies feel like a barren wasteland not just in player count but because of how unnecessarily large they are. The games themselves also suffer from this with little to no sound design keeping the player engaged.

  • @DarkCrystal_951
    @DarkCrystal_951 Год назад +270

    I was planning to make a video on TubNet but I was pretty surprised to find that there was literally no one there. Everything caleb said is actually explains what I was confused about and literally expresses my frustration that I can't even get on the games that are filled with just the same amount of players - not allowing new people to join without waiting for the other game to finish first. Ty for making this video and it's amazing as usual

    • @CalebIsSalty
      @CalebIsSalty  Год назад +18

      glad to see someone shared the same experience as me! hopefully tubnet makes some changes soon 😂

    • @DarkCrystal_951
      @DarkCrystal_951 Год назад +1

      @@CalebIsSalty Lmao at this rate, I doubt it

  • @JohnnyHT
    @JohnnyHT Год назад +82

    I would debate that battle royal is the smartest thing Tubnet could have done. There are barely any hunger games servers that gives tub net the only upper hand. The problem with that is that MCC has mentioned they are planning to (Eventually ) add survival games, with some developers looking forward to it.

  • @waboo
    @waboo Год назад +5

    DNA test results just came back from you.
    99% Human
    1% Chipmunk

    • @znotchill
      @znotchill Год назад

      fr, randomly just outbursts with some high pitched sentence

  • @josiahsimmons9866
    @josiahsimmons9866 Год назад +76

    It's unfortunate that the server hasn't been very successful. I know Tubbo and his team worked insanely hard to get it out and working. Maybe it's gotten better in the past month, but I do hope it eventually recovers.

  • @EditorAutumn
    @EditorAutumn Год назад +81

    This is actually such a well made video Caleb. I feel like all the excitement built up to the release date but then there was like still a game which hadn't even released yet. After the first week it just stopped being active

  • @MaffWorld
    @MaffWorld Год назад +185

    You've got such great talent caleb. never quit, you're insanely good at what you do.

  • @Deliever
    @Deliever Год назад +34

    As a fellow TubNeter and LS tryhard I agree with most of the points.
    Like Willerhide said they are waiting to advertise more until they improve the server and I think once they do it'll succeed. Also, the fact most of Tubbo's audience is bedrock and that isn't a thing is a major reason why it's not as popular. If he advertises it know some of his fans will be let down, they can't join so I think he's waiting for that feature as well.
    I hope they bring back TubNet Tuesday or any more organized community event (I'm hosting my own atm), as it'll help at least remind people of the server. Overall it still has potential despite the current state, and I hope it starts to grow soon.
    Really hoping it can at least make it to an averaged player count soon and loved the video!!

  • @The_Horizon
    @The_Horizon Год назад +6

    lol I didnt even know it even came out till now as a creator... I thought it was one of those concept things that definetly will come out in the future

  • @ItsSplonk
    @ItsSplonk Год назад +10

    I mean this in the nicest way possible as someone who used to enjoy Tubbo's content a lot, but I remember how much Tubbo babbled on about how revolutionary and insane the server was gonna be, and then it just ended up being a collection of games that you could find on other servers except debatably done worse in terms of long-time playability.
    No ill will to Tubbo or anything, ofc, I just think it's funny how ambitious he was talking this server up to be and then it just...wasn't.

  • @SquareBlock5
    @SquareBlock5 Год назад +4

    Bros voice cracks on every interjection

  • @leazy911
    @leazy911 Год назад +5

    why does bro go up like 4 octaves every couple sentences

  • @phe.mp3
    @phe.mp3 Год назад +5

    It makes me sad that it hasn’t been as popular or stimulating as they thought it would be. I was on one of the original test servers a couple years ago so I know it’s been a LONG time coming! Wishing them more success in the future.

  • @Offbeet2886
    @Offbeet2886 Год назад +6

    i definitely think that the MMO that they've teased will do a lot to boost the server.
    Another factor is the cross-version compatability that they promised but haven't yet accomplished to it's full potential. Once they're able to figure that out, I can almost guarantee that a large amount of players will try out TubNet, especially if it's in Bedrock's "Featured Servers" Section, allowing both console players and players that don't know about the server to try it out.
    I have my faith that TubNet will be great, it has had a rocky start but I'm sure will find the community it needs to thrive in the future :)

  • @butler7135
    @butler7135 Год назад +8

    I feel like for TubNet to succeed, a good 5 streams and videos must be dedicated to advertising the game mode, and a new game mode that should be ORIGINAL so people log on to play it

  • @Nubbyhere
    @Nubbyhere Год назад +35

    although this isnt exactly your normal type of content, i love this documentary styled video with fun bits and infomation, excited to see the next upload caleb :)

    • @CalebIsSalty
      @CalebIsSalty  Год назад +2

      thanks! i might experiment with more of this style in the future so stay tuned :))

  • @escherseo2134
    @escherseo2134 Год назад +6

    ok but why does he voice crack every 10 seconds

  • @gamingcat9867
    @gamingcat9867 Год назад +5

    Tubbo should do some Tubnet tournaments of some kind that would definitely bring up the people active. The advertising was so bad I didn't even know it launched.

  • @ToShortToTell
    @ToShortToTell Год назад +2

    i'm so glad you stumbled upon one of my youtube videos so many months ago. not because i got a view, but because i found you. hats off to you, caleb!!

  • @annonzone
    @annonzone Год назад +1

    1st point is fair enough I didn't even know tubnet was open until this video due to the lack of advertising, but the
    The 2nd point does not work since nothing can be based off of nothing, skyblock, skywars, bedawrs, were not invented by hypixel, (i have not played on the server so my judgment might be incorrect or I might miss some things) as long as the game modes are made unique enough to be different from the ones everywhere it is (usually) fun, from my perspective all three have taken previous modes on existing mc servers and modified them to make it more unique, however as I did say I do have lacking evidence for this. Still a great video with good points to bring up, hope you do more!

  • @gavinhogberg
    @gavinhogberg Год назад +3

    Why does his voice keep going high on completely random syllables?

  • @KDRB.
    @KDRB. 11 месяцев назад +3

    Voice cracks are crazyy

  • @Gluglos
    @Gluglos Год назад +2

    I think the main reason was the release. They hyped up the release so much, then closed it hours later due to bugs. Later began hyping it back up, released it again, but it was buggy again. The texture pack didnt work for me, along with the custum GUI's. Parties didnt exist, so I couldnt enjoy it with my friends. At that point I had given up and haven't played it since, with the only times I have played being the open betas.

  • @Nizaritoo
    @Nizaritoo Год назад

    now that you mention it this way, it kind of makes sense

  • @liamkkhh
    @liamkkhh Год назад +7

    The editing on these videos just keep getting better.

  • @ItzSugarYT
    @ItzSugarYT Год назад +9

    Sometimes in life there will not be success and downfall but this will definitely succeed in the future 😅❤

  • @Qubick
    @Qubick Год назад +26

    Actually a nutty video, love the sunnyv2 style, along with having your own editing niche added to it. ❤

  • @WolfiiDog13
    @WolfiiDog13 Год назад +1

    I'm still waiting for a Hive replacement on Java, I'm not a PVP player, the minigames I enjoy are things like Hide and Seek, Death Run, Plock Party, etc. Granted that some games that existed in the Hive are now on hypixel, but the best ones like Hide and Seek and Death Run are not. There's still not a single Java server that actually fullfills that niche

  • @foxyplays5229
    @foxyplays5229 Год назад +3

    Literally never joined tubnet once after seeing the player count
    also the voice crack at 0:59....

  • @2invisible
    @2invisible Год назад +2

    Another big issue was the timing. Due to technical difficulties TubNet had to release after MCC Island. This means that more people experienced and stuck with MCC Island for 1.19 servers. Also, whenever something is delayed it either gains or loses traction. In this case it lost all the hype that was gained.

  • @RaiderIsDumb
    @RaiderIsDumb Год назад +3

    I'd say its to early to say tubnet failed we should come back later on this year and see how it does since crossplay is around the corner they might actually have a chance

    • @CalebIsSalty
      @CalebIsSalty  Год назад +1

      yeah for sure! we’ll definitely have to see how that plays out B)

  • @The_Trident_Master
    @The_Trident_Master Год назад +2

    I didn’t even know that Tubnet was out, tbh

  • @drspruce6402
    @drspruce6402 Год назад +11

    Probably one of the best Minecraft explanation video i've ever seen. Fantastic job, Caleb.

  • @tyniemeier2039
    @tyniemeier2039 Год назад +3

    bro hit those high notes

  • @CatPCgaming
    @CatPCgaming Год назад +1

    I remember I was super hyped for Tubnet and now I don't really play it, I know they're still working on Spacebound, which seems to be an original game, but given the scope of the game I don't think it'll be coming out soon. Hopefully they'll be able to make it be as popular of a server as they want it to be.

  • @itsaneel
    @itsaneel Год назад +2

    I didn't even know Tubnet had opened up💀

  • @mabroski611
    @mabroski611 Год назад +3

    Honesty the way Caleb said “the star”. Cracked me up

  • @Melonapplesauce
    @Melonapplesauce Год назад

    I grinded so hard and got Crystal Rush leaderboards, I had so many plans that I would stay on the leaderboards and finally have something else to grind other than Hypixel Bedwars, but literally after 3 days the whole server basically died, such a big letdown.
    Anyway, great video.

  • @Palabow
    @Palabow Год назад +5

    bro why does ur voice pitch randomly

  • @RodPrimata
    @RodPrimata Год назад

    they should add ranks to the hunger games

  • @NealjanYT
    @NealjanYT Год назад +1

    I really hope they somehow get Tubnet to work!
    I love TubNet in its concept but it really needs more players

  • @_Tp__
    @_Tp__ Год назад +1

    It was also meant to be bedrock/java crossplay but that never happened and that was one of the main things that was advertised at the start

  • @eclipse9727
    @eclipse9727 Год назад +1

    Only saw this now, but looking at this in hindsight... I feel Tubbo should've followed MCCI in what it was doing. MCCI was following a heavy beta period to iron it out for everyone before the general public had the chance to fully take it in.
    Meanwhile Tubnet was in a much short beta period, and then it was jusy... released fully in such a short amount of time.
    It felt it was all going by too fast, and with a bit more spaced out content, I imagined it wouldn't be hitting this intial flop.
    Hopefully it gets better...

  • @TheExplorer2K
    @TheExplorer2K Год назад +1

    I have been working on a Tubnet video for a while too and I agree with your statement. They should really figure out a way to bump up their statistics.

  • @Uni_op
    @Uni_op Год назад

    Honestly I just never really played it much because all the games are PVP based and I suck at PVP
    (I liked the idea of it, I just wish it had games I could actually be good at)
    I hung out on it when it first opened but I stopped after a while

  • @SnowyRedstone
    @SnowyRedstone Год назад +2

    The suddenly pitch up voice and sometimes even cracks is the best part of the video
    ok despite the joke this a great video

  • @WESSLAYS
    @WESSLAYS Год назад +3

    212 views and 78 likes. That has to be one of the biggest views to like ratios I've seen in a while. Props to you, Caleb.

    • @CalebIsSalty
      @CalebIsSalty  Год назад +1

      haha thanks, the community is strong 😂

  • @dinow269
    @dinow269 Год назад +1

    Tubnet is also just really buggy. In half the Lightstrike games I played, the players got stuck in queuing lobby after the game started, and could only leave by hubbing or disconnecting.

  • @VerySkilledGamer
    @VerySkilledGamer Год назад +2

    The thumbnail suggests a decline. It just wasn’t popular at all from the get-go

  • @celestebeepy
    @celestebeepy Год назад

    I played on it like twice. It was okay. I love tubbo, and I feel bad that it didn't go too well. But, I think after updates and such it will get better.

  • @samstudio1122
    @samstudio1122 Год назад

    wow im so impressed you had commented on my video about 2 years ago and this was when you were making fortnite content im so amazed on how much you have improved ur editing and just videos overall are amazing i found ur channel when you had 800 subs and now you have 12.5k wow thats incredible good job bro keep going!

  • @thedarkreunion.9696
    @thedarkreunion.9696 Год назад +1

    i mean the only “BIG” advertisement was the twitch rivals event for twitchcon, but that’s about it.

  • @PagueroMC
    @PagueroMC Год назад +1

    Another factor why tubnet didn’t succeed is because it released in November.People rarely play games in November compared to April,June etc.The Noxcrew are very smart they know that in the summer people will play games more so they are releasing Mcci open beta in the next few months

  • @HappyPlaysWasTaken
    @HappyPlaysWasTaken Год назад +2

    i didnt even know it was released

  • @Red-lu1rx
    @Red-lu1rx Год назад +1

    TubNet did a Mineplex (Java edition) player base speedrun

  • @NGZ-MC
    @NGZ-MC Год назад +1

    Bro why is your editing so good + I was thinking the same thing about TubNet

  • @ttalgi9712
    @ttalgi9712 Год назад

    I'm a casually MCYT follower and had heard a lot of hype for the upcoming server but it's funny how i had no idea it was even released until i saw this video. I remember tubbo being very excited but the promotion was not there if it couldn't even reach casually veiwers

  • @ItzOwo
    @ItzOwo Год назад +3

    Your editing is insane.

  • @cibianthellama
    @cibianthellama Год назад +1

    i used to have a server... it died when my mod griefed it...

  • @Nitr0Vintage5541
    @Nitr0Vintage5541 Год назад +2

    Tubnet had so much potential. Now its just an annoyance at the top of lunar client servers :(

  • @krlswrld
    @krlswrld Год назад +1

    Didn’t they say that they server is still in beta..? Plus the developers are working on it more to make it better and to fix bugs and they’ll probably hype it up more when it’s ready to be played on again. :)

  • @VamirB
    @VamirB Год назад +6

    I really do like tubnet and the twists that come with it. But the lack of care that went into it with barely any updates make the server boring and helped the server die down. It seems he has completely given up on the server after seeing it die down so fast.

  • @BeepOW
    @BeepOW Год назад

    I really hope MCC Island succeeds and doesn't go the way of TubNet. But so far the player count on the server is decent. I've been playing in the closed beta for some time now and it's such a good server, I am addicted to it.

  • @DundeeYT
    @DundeeYT Год назад +5

    I wonder who would predict such a downfall like this...

  • @NotRisely
    @NotRisely Год назад +8

    This is a really well made and edited video! Hats off to you Caleb!

  • @bobuxlorx
    @bobuxlorx Год назад +4

    bros goofy voice

  • @AmethystBad
    @AmethystBad Год назад +1

    i played tubnet once and it took 5 minutes to fill up one lobby

  • @Simph0ny
    @Simph0ny Год назад

    I literally thought Tubnet was still in Beta because of how little people played on it.
    Thanks for making great content too!

  • @fatmoron7644
    @fatmoron7644 Год назад +1

    I feel all the you tubers were lying, telling every1 it would become the new ‘big thing’ so they could get partnered just Incase
    In the actual player base, everyone I talked to were all predicting the same thing. That it would fail.

  • @DoubleBreakMC
    @DoubleBreakMC Год назад +1

    Its rough when you have the hype like hypixel

  • @dotdankory
    @dotdankory Год назад

    Not only that, tubnet is out on full release, meanwhile MCC island is still in closed beta, seeing it reach 100+ on peak hours, it surely is gonna get 500+ after its full release, they're planning to add new games during open beta, and even more during launch

    • @RandomHandle837
      @RandomHandle837 Год назад

      MCCI on weekend peak hours already hits around 600 players

  • @astraealy
    @astraealy Год назад

    I just hop in it, it only have 5 players inside :(( hoping for more success for TubNet!

  • @Ace_of_Spades0
    @Ace_of_Spades0 Год назад +1

    does the server have an anticheat?

  • @KryaTheEgghead
    @KryaTheEgghead Год назад

    When Tubnet comes out for Bedrock, I think I'll be playing it lots

  • @NewKiddo3
    @NewKiddo3 Год назад +1

    Great video!

  • @OldBlitzz
    @OldBlitzz Год назад +15

    Caleb, your videos are super fun and enjoyable to watch! I really like your unique twists on them! Can't wait for more!

  • @umicarus
    @umicarus Год назад

    i feel like Tubnet wouldve done better if they waited until Starbound (is that the name?) was ready for launch. Instead of launching it at the same time as MCCi which i believe hurt the servers attempt at success.

  • @taylorwolfram3871
    @taylorwolfram3871 Год назад

    i cant even play on it bc i have bedrock :(
    and i feel rly bad for tubbo bc ik how hard he worked on it and how excited he was :(

  • @xSparkYT
    @xSparkYT Год назад +2

    if there was one thing i learned from this video, it was "tHe StARrrRrR"

  • @Mchxdlo
    @Mchxdlo Год назад

    The high pitched sounds are something else man

  • @Wildteen354
    @Wildteen354 Год назад

    The server is in open beta right now too everyone needs to remember

  • @Armegon
    @Armegon Год назад

    The production quality goddamn

  • @TheVoxTech
    @TheVoxTech Год назад

    Also tubnets punishment process is a bit weird, a friend of mine got permanently banned for swearing in chat, but he never got warned about it before, and he didn't get muted just after a week immediate permanent bann

  • @eyesyt7571
    @eyesyt7571 Год назад +1

    1.9+ pvp, yet not crystal pvp. The tryhards won't play it much. Also, I think he's not marketing on purpose because too many players would make it laggy again. I don't think the server can support it.

  • @yoavmamane9084
    @yoavmamane9084 Год назад +3

    wEEEEEEEl tone you voice man

  • @Tomas_2555
    @Tomas_2555 Год назад +1

    I love the video man but please please stop randomly emphasising words and making them super high pitched it’s very very annoying and made it a bit difficult to watch. No hate at all just mentioning it.

  • @gnomish
    @gnomish Год назад +3

    Not to mention the immense cheater problem...

    • @CalebIsSalty
      @CalebIsSalty  Год назад +2

      tubnet anticheat gotta be doing less than watchdog at this point 💀

    • @gnomish
      @gnomish Год назад +1

      @@CalebIsSalty the literal first game I ever played on TubNet, everyone got sweeped by a blatent fly hacker and that was the last time I logged in.

    • @omegamad
      @omegamad Год назад

      anticheat has skill issue

  • @Mrkvaman
    @Mrkvaman Год назад

    3:04 Bro what- idk what servers you are playing on but survival games format in 1.9 is like nowhere to be seen. Which other servers have it??? I would love to know

  • @haseebbbb
    @haseebbbb Год назад +2

    short story: tubnet didnt succeed because another server came

  • @serpent_
    @serpent_ Год назад

    As a valorant player I honestly have no idea what the star is I’m not to sure what it was influenced or inspired by at all

  • @AsaBossaTech1280
    @AsaBossaTech1280 Год назад

    In my opinion. Its because the version, The gamemode. No one want to play bedwars but just can click 2 cps. Its like CSGO but you just can click to shoot

  • @ace2b
    @ace2b Год назад +1

    hey caleb, you remember me? you commented on my video and I wanted to know if you still remembered me.

  • @ProdByB1tter
    @ProdByB1tter Год назад +1

    I actually forgot TubNet exists lol

  • @oijje
    @oijje Год назад +1

    i love it when u say well

  • @Cyorg13
    @Cyorg13 Год назад

    Also, most of his audience probably can only play on Bedrock, and with it being a Java only server requiring a PC good enough to run it well, that doesn't help.

  • @Baeget
    @Baeget Год назад

    Tubbo has said in the past that he doesn't want to be associated with it, he wants it to be its own thing, live on beyond Tubbo himself.

  • @kiramizu
    @kiramizu Год назад +1

    i actually just acknowledged that tubnet even got up, i thought it was still in progress, haha😅