Mariah Carey VS Opera Singers (C6-C#7)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 июн 2022
- Like and subscribe for more videos!
Inspired by this video: • Mariah Carey Vs. Opera...
Thanks to THI HILLS Music for the opera clips: / thihills
Chapters:
00:00 Intro
00:09 C6
00:33 C#6
00:52 D6
01:12 Eb6
01:28 E6
01:45 F6
02:02 F#6
02:19 G6
02:25 G#6
02:39 A6
02:51 Bb6
03:12 B6
03:30 C7
03:49 C#7
04:15 Outro 
Видеоклипы
![Head Voice in Opera [C6 - C7]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5l9Y6AlDDa4/mqdefault.jpg)
C6/c#6 is an interesting place in Mariah’s voice because it literally sounds like a mix of head voice and whistle.
Upper head voice - flute register.
@@KajiVocals flageolet?
@@KajiVocals child it’s falsetto
@@daydreamriah8476 Flageolet is an adducted whistle (M3). This was M2.
@@sir3958 Don’t ‘child’ me.
3:21 this is actually her most insane whistle ever, you have to slow it down to hear each note separately, it's so fast you can't even tell.
She's so amazing. There will never be a vocalist with Mariah's, tone, timber and versatility.
I agree. Mariah is an extraordinary singer.
the fact that the opera singers sound like the notes there hitting are so high while mariah's whistles sounds like she be singing in her mid range
That's because they're using different techniques
Mariah will poop her pants if she sings this with head voice.
Mariah's D6 notes was so smooth, like a dream ❣️
I like the fact that Mariah can hit all the notes without sounding like an opera singer. That's what makes her unique.
4:02 that smirk of superiority was so satisfying
4:12 was a straight up eargasm omg
As a fan of both opera and Mariah, I see no reason to pit them against one another as several in the comments have. Opera singers are going to convey musicality far differently than a pop/R&B singer. Especially since they are mostly unmiked. (Apparently some opera houses do have mikes on the stage but most don't.) I love when you do these videos, because it does show how easily Mariah could have been an opera singer in another life. (And indeed, I'm sure if she was ever asked, she could do an opera song.) Videos like these also make me wish opera singers would cover more popular current music. I would love to hear one of them cover "Love Takes Time" or "Can't Let Go." (It seems most opera singers stick to the standard American songbook or more opera.) (Well, Mariah will be in the American songbook soon enough, so we'll get an opera star cover a song of hers one of these decades.)
FOREVER, I STILL BELIEVE, LEAD THE WAY are sounding like Opera songs with many long notes and breath support.
While sure Mariah could sing opera if trained, I don’t see any proof in this video for her as you say being able to sing an aria when asked.
@@KajiVocals her singing sugar plum fairy is the closest thing we got to an « aria » . I do wonder what her voice would’ve sound if properly trained
I do think her mother being an opera singer influenced her singing very much. This video opened my eyes on how much. Mariah would emulate her mother as a kid. I'm sure she picked up alot of what her mother did back in the day.
I'd love to hear opera singers try to cover her song H.A.T.E.U.
I’ve always loved Mariah’s whistle register, and I’ve been enabled with those who have that ability. But this is so interesting to me: all of the opera notes are so loud and heavy. They do nothing for me. It’s really all about the tone and built in melodics of Mariah’s voice that just have me in a chokehold! Love her!
You do realise that opera is sung with no amplification right... Of course it is gonna be loud or at very least projected. A squeak won't project across an opera house. Or a small room full of people for one. Mariah's most technically proficient whistle register was in her earlier years (1990-1992). After that, her closure started lessening which in effect added to the damage on her voice.
@@KajiVocals yes mariahs whistle became more airy especially in the rainbow era where its not even audible some times
@@KajiVocals Mariah's whistles/ falsettos even get easily drowned by WHITNEY'S regular BELTING/operatic HEADVOICE
She got range but SADLY 😭no POWER
@@Swahili14 Whistles as done by Mariah are the volume of a whisper, at most speaking tone. Of course they’ll be overpowered by actual projected vocals. Whistle can be truly projected but not the way Mariah does it.
@@KajiVocalsThis doesn't sound like the volume of a whisper or speaking tone
ruclips.net/video/he7S77QUDH0/видео.htmlm50s
She utilized different volumes.
Don't forget "all in your mind rehearsal." that was mind blowing.🤯
They all SLAYEDDDD. Different techniques but all of em sound great🔥🔥
3:14 these staccato runs!!
Mindblowing
Mariah Is a Goddess of Whistle notes Omg 😳❤️
The fact that mariah could do opera of she wanted to because her mother was a opera singer
But her dream become a pop singer
Some of these sound so similar yet so different.
Because half of them are a strong whistle (flageolet). Same mechanism but more developed.
@@KajiVocals which is bad technique. Most of these high notes on the video done by opera singer are done with bad technique.
@@Ignasimp Flageolet is not a bad technique when done properly. Erna Sack and Ingeborg Hallstein did it wonderfully. No register is ‘bad technique’ when done properly. Dessay is the only one from the higher end in this video who used head register up there. But she probably shouldn’t have. Too high. Too pulled.
@@KajiVocals Flageolet is just a thin and squeezed headvoice. It is bad technique. Those who use it end up developing muscles in their neck that constrict the larynx, instead of using the proper muscles designed to phonate.
@@Ignasimp You are incorrect. Flageolet is the M3 laryngeal vibratory mechanism (whistle) with a high degree of adduction. It was extremely common in opera in the nineteenth century. Tetrazzini spoke of it in some of her papers. She herself has used it on some occasions. True high head register is uncommon past the high F. And even that’s a scream for most people. And your second statement makes no sense. Just sounds like you’re repeating the TiO dogma.
Mariah’s whistles have a sweet and angelic tone, lots of resonance and vibrato, she can go up and down that register with smooth agility. The opera singers use a FULL ON head voice which sometimes can come on too strong and sound strained. Technically they’re not bad but I much prefer Mariah’s tone and control.
Mariah Carey ✨
Yess
@@imNotZack_ hi
Opera and a whistle note are completely different! I will forever love Mariah...BUT, a Soprano is another level of singing.
Her whistles are so beautiful
THANK YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!! I was waiting for this
I love classic music but i'm not a fan of opera. It's a little bit to much for me. I love more voices like Mariah, they are powerful too but more sweet.
Opera has a lot of gentle, sweet moments. There’s many styles and genres of opera. You can’t really put it in one box.
@@KajiVocals i still don't like opera no matter what. It's not my type of music.
@@dinasilva9263 Opera is literally a form of musical theatre… How much opera have you heard to make such statement?
@@KajiVocals sorry, I don't like it. Just because you like opera that doesn't mean i have to like it too.
@@dinasilva9263 Answer the question, "How much opera have you heard to make such statement?"
Mariah´s falsetto voice to whistle but opera singers do it with their head voice
Love your creativity making content about Mariah!! Love your videos🥺🥺🥺💕💕💕💕
just subscribed. cause your content never misses and is actually interesting and is really educational. it’s good for ppl that wanna look into mariah’s vocals etc…
Absolutely amazing dahling GivethanXxo 🙏💪🥰😍
Thank you so much for this video 🥹
Mariah’s first C6 reminds me of Cissy Houston’s high note in Ain’t No Way
The song (It’s a Wrap) is sampling “Aint No Way”
Yay, an updated one love it
it's kinda weird to compare them because opera singers use a heavily coordinated head voice while Mariah is just using the extensions of a falsetto (disconnected head voice, whistle)
but at some point, the weakness of the whistle register somewhat sounds better at some point because it doesn't feel overwhelming cause head voice can sound overwhelming sometimes yeah
Because the opera singers in this video have very bad technique. They have no depth.
Opera is so strident yet somehow Mariah can make it soft, and velvety. But she can also match the percing, metallic ping if she desired but still maintain her agility and vibrato. And then do it all while phrasing actual lyrics. Perfecto.
Lol Mariah Carey will POOP HER PANTS if she sings this with her head voice. Too much forte and the orchestra is too loud.
Ok but 3:34 😍😍😍😍 that staccato
One of her simpler too. True coloratura sopranos (and ones with well-developed registers at that like Erna Sack there) are a rarity.
0:41 That note was operatic.That it feels like a head voice
that is head voice.
Head voice. But not operatic lol. Having vibrato =/= operatic.
@@KajiVocals loved the =/= lmao hahaha
@@KajiVocals that's.definitely falsetto
It's shame if that is also a HEADVOICE
@@Swahili14 😂
Show.. lindo ❤️💕 parabéns Maríah Carey
Top coloraturas
Mado Robin
Katarzyna Dondalska
Erna Sack
Natalie Dessay
Joan Sutherland
Others Diana Damrau, Edita Gruberova, Gianna Rolandi, Roberta Peters, Ruth Ann Swenson
Other Amazing high Coloraturas
BEVERLY HOCH, MARIA REMOLA, INGEBORG HALLSTEIN
ELIZABETH VIDAL
MADY MESPLE
LILY PONS
BOGNA SOKORSKA
ALLA SOLENKOVA
of all whistle singers Minnie Riperton sounds most operatic
Bela Rudenko and Elizabeth Parcells also are awesome high sopranos.
All slayed
These two sing beautifully and did the original justice. Think of the many hours of rehearsals necessary to perfect their performance.
I just needed Callas’ D6 from Armida to demolish the world.
Hmm i dont think its fair to compare profesionally trained opera singers to Mariah since its not even the same genre at All and of course the opera singers Sound Better im Also an opera fan but Mariah is still one of the best ever singers to have lived there Will never be a comparison to her voice nor talent she is a true prodigy 🥰
oh i can't choose
Mariah Carey i love your voice singing
Once queen always queen #ubeatablemariah
Mariah Carey you are having such a beautiful angelic tone of voice 👄 singing you are the best thing ever happen
📌I know Mariah can go higher If she wanted to💙
2:00, it actually looks like she forgot to active her magical whistle button.
Incredible that these Singers can hit that we oth Falsetto.
머라이어 캐리 어머니 직업이 성악가이시고 머라이어는 그 재능을 물려받았고 머라이어는 팝으로 성악을 했구나.그녀가 다른 가수와는 다른특별한 가수라고 생각했는데 머라이어가 천재성도 있었겠지만 그냥 성악가가 팝을 해서 획기적이고 혁신적으로 혁명적으로 보인거였어.성악이 대단하네.
Here she is again reminding your fave will never!!!!!!!!
Operiah
0:40 - ah yes, just her beautifying those horrendous singers 😰😰
I think everything there, including the Mariah note was a bit much.
I'm curious though how do I make a whistle? I can hit the note g#6 but idk how do you make whistles up there that's my thing I'm new never had vocal lessons so yeah..... but I'm just curious
Work on your head voice before you attempt whistles. Whistles are known to ‘cannibalise’ your range when practiced early.
❤️🎤 Sing Mariah 🎤❤️
The Registers that they are using might be different however only one question pops in my mind, "HOW ARE THEY DOING THAT!!!!"
0:53 thought this was the Eurovision intro
4:11 omggg 😍
The greatest vocalist of all time ate the opera singers up. 0:41 is well supported operatic head voice she’s the queen of every register
bold ass statement
huge ass lies
ill leave it at that
@@imNotZack_ This person would go as far as hating on every existing singer on this Earth (other than Mariah, of course) just to put his fave on a pedestal. As if Mariah's upper register could ever top that of an opera singer. Her upper register is amazing but she isn't even close to these singers.
@@varunravi27 ate them up 💅🏼
@@varunravi27 why you hating under a mariah video 💀
@@mariahcautionera the choices TQOL used for opera were poor. but I think he's speaking in general terms that mariah < opera
It's impressive that Mariah can sing so high with so much control, but I just don't hear the same expertise. These opera singers aren't even using a mic and still have a large, explosive whistle register that they can PROJECT way over an orchestra. Mariah's seems more.. stylistic? I feel that people will automatically say Mariah's are better due to her singing pop and having amazing tone, but when you compare opera to pop, the opera singer's inevitably going to blow them out of the water with technique and power.
This is by far the most logical comment I’ve seen under a Mariah Carey video!
Thank you!
Most of the opera singers in the video were using very bad technique though.
@@Ignasimp Not most. But a few.
@@Ignasimp Some women were better than others, sure. But I think you need to study classical music before saying they used bad technique. They're singing without mics and have to project over a busy stage. They have to balance projection and volume against the high note, where as Mariah just had to hit the notes.
Airy and breathy tones like the technique Mariah uses is actually considered a highly damaging, fatal flaw in Opera. And this isn't even something debated among professionals, you can google and immediately see the proof.
Mariah sounds great but healthy technique is a different story. Most of these women were technically correct imo.
@@KajiVocals I agree. I think contemporary music has invaded the singing topic so much that people don't recognize proper, tried and true operatic technique.
Mariah 👑
Alla Solenkova, Bogna Sokorska, Erna Sack, Ingeborg Hallstein, Katarzyna Dondalska, Mado Robin, Maria Remola are the Queen of high × high x high notes.
Opera yes,mariah is the queen of whistle register,queen of melismas,queen of vocal agility,queen of R&b,queen of remix,queen of christmas,queen of billboard
@@ThekingOfMonsters1954 ,Dear, Mariah's treble is phenomenal, unforgettable. However, in terms of timbre, interpretation and sustain in notes, within the categories of gospel, jazz, pop, or R&B: Marion Williams, Delores Washington, Minnie Riperton, Cissy Houston, Melba Moore, Susaye Greene, Dorothy Mcmillian, Deniece Williams, Linda Lewis, Cheryl Lynn, Lecresia Campbell, Rachelle Ferrell, Lisa Fischer and Desirre Coleman Jackson are my favorites.
Betty Wright, I can't forget you, sorry.
Mariah 💯
I love those amazing Coloratura sopranos and their healthy full voices
C#6 sounds polyphonic... Damn Mariah!
夢は叶う
Can you send a link to the hills channel?
Are the opera singers singing in the whistle register too? their notes sound more full while Mariah's sound more airy.
Yes, some do. Past a certain pitch head voice becomes near impossible to control.
O da mariah é mais doce e leve, icônica como sempre.😽 Acredito que ela tenha mais notas, mas claramente ela não tem precisão de pôr nas músicas dela rs..
0:45 I so thought Infinity's hv was ab to show up instead--
1:06 this note (i mean her approach) has always sounded odd to me, shrill and nasal.
Mariah is great. I am her greatest fan
But I don't see why there's a competition between her and the Operatic Sopranos. It's a completely different technique and register.
In opera whistle tone is usually not counted a soprano has to project Thier voice well in to the register using Thier head voice.
So most of what you saw like Mado robin B6 and Eena Sack were not actually whistles but Thier head voice.
Whistle is not as powerful and as loud as the head voice and that is one of the criterion for a soprano in opera (power). There's no mic so you have to sing loud enough for the whole audience to hear
The comparison is over, Mariah can go even higher
Why would you set your favorite up in a video? 💀
3:58 my voice is hurting for her that's crazy that she's doing that In SHV😳
what song the last clip??
Would be wonderful compare Mariah's Eb6 with Callas Eb6
Which one? Aida 1951? Sempre Libera 1951 or 1952? They are a lot more powerful than Mariah tho.
First to comment "first" 😝
😞😤 i was late
Pls give me the link at 0:48
What song is the whistle from 4:10 from?
It’s for a rehearsal at SNL 1990, it’s called “Who’s loving you”
I love Mariah but when it comes to my favorite things about her ASTOUNDING talent and vocal abilities, the whistles are at the bottom of the list for me.
really? why? its a genuine q though
@@sabinecallas8904 It's just simply my least favorite quality in regards to her vocals.
My whistles carried and ate all the others up
Intro song please :(
Underneath The Stars from the Daydream album
Opera is just a little too much for me.
i love opera, not just females, Baritones 😭
0:41 What is that show? Doesn't look like Mariah
ruclips.net/video/RqUVPwb8050/видео.html
Mariah’s whistle is more pleasent to hear. Opera singer hurts the ear a little
The clip choice by Thi Hills Music was not that good. There's better and more beautiful examples of notes in this range out there.
the opera singers use a different technique . I can't explain it but I believe Mariah has a vocal chord anomalie whereas the opera singers trained their chords and use them as they would with "normal" notes. thus they don't whistle.
@@jollyjokress3852 Yes, and no. It is a different technique but same mechanism. It IS a whistle register. Just with more vocal fold adduction and a different acoustic strategy. As for Mariah having an 'anomaly', that's not true. She has nodules, yes. But the form of whistle she uses is just one of the few registrations in the whistle mechanism (M3 laryngeal vibratory mechanism). It's not something exclusive to people with nodules.
@@KajiVocals Oh okay, good to know. -- It is only what I have heard, that something is up with her chord that is either extremely rare or an anomaly.
Sure whistle sounded a lot more easier than actual head voice. Mariah has undeveloped head voice. She will poop her pants if she sings opera.
Embrace yourselves for the salty opera fans
Next... Mariah vs all singers in the world
😐
🫥
Mariah incrível, mais não dá pra ela não! Fazer um agudo não é o mesmo que cantar agudo kkkk
Professional opera singers will ALWAYS be better than pop singers, classical operatic training is hard and consistent plus they can only rely on chest and head voice which is harder (getting up to a C6 in pure head voice than whistle, for example) so, Mariah has NO comparation to an opera singer
I'm not defending Mariah, it's the opposite 🤣
wrdgaf mariah ended them with ease
@@KanChiateyallsfavsup nope 🌚
@@KanChiateyallsfavsupended with ease? How? In fact Mariah was inaudible next to Aretha and Patti lol.
I know it’s the same notes, but is it me or only Mariah’s high notes sound nicer and bearable? I dunno how to describe.
I was kinda having the cringe when I heard all the opera singers but not hers.
Bad clip selection.
Actually in 1:05, that note is a D7 😇
It’s not.
@@KajiVocals the brief note before the sustained D6 is, but definitely an unintentional thing. it's clearer as a polyphonic D6/D7 in other videos of this performance
@@MIXANDMTCH hi
i love you
397 viewer :>
0:41 Those people can't sing.
I wonder what Patricia would say….❤️
Wait... Where are the rest? Keep going... Mariah can go higher than these. 😐
Hay muchas cantantes de ópera increíble, no importa las octavas la gente no disfruta de eso, disfruta del tono del color de voz y Mariah tiene el tono más hermoso que se allá escuchado en cualquier tono eh ella toque, silbido, grave o agudo ella suena tan bonito es su tono es tan precioso tan dulce y eso no se aprende entrenando uno ya nace con ese color de voz.
Ya pero la de la opera es mejor y punto.
@@briancardenas671 nose si mejor pero Mariah se escuchó mil veces más hermoso. :)
Whats that last C#7?????
who's loving you, circa 1990, released recently
Of course Mariah wins
The Opera Singers have more control and Power !!!
No one cares, they sound horrible compared to Mariah’s sublime musical instrument sweetness
Mariah's whistle is more pleasant to hear than the Opera Singers
@@jiecas Not more pleasant than Ingeborg Hallstein’s whistle.
@@CesarJoel94 that's because this video has terrible picks for those opera singers to try to make Mariah look balanced as them/better
@@ce3540 it’s because Mariah sounds better and you need to fix your ears
It is worth mentioning that Opera singers have much more vocal projection, as they do not need a microphone and an entire sound structure like Mariah Carey.
It is worth mentioning we don't give a F about them opera singers who always sing pieces written by dead people from the stone age
This wasn’t even a fair fight, Mariah sounds like a kid playing against professionals.
Mariah is a professional
@@CesarJoel94 not to the level of these singers in the video
@@thabigcohuna of course Mariah is above all of them and is worth over half a billion dollars of net worth and has over 500 million records sold
@@CesarJoel94 what does that have to do with anything?
@@thabigcohuna Mariah sounds better and is more successful than all of them combined , now go fix your ears
great for them but not for my ears