I come from a gorkha community. A few of my senior relatives, one of them being my own fatherwho was in the British army as a cook, used to tell stories of gorkha armymen who switched to INA from British army in the battle field itself in the border areas of Arunachal, Nagaland just because that at the other end fighting with them were the Gorkhas themselves. May be to avoid fratricide and also by conscience that they should be fighting the foreigners not their own brethren. The contribution of Gorkhas in the INA is just overlooked when it comes toremembering INA and Subhas.
@@connectwithin7610 One cannot understand why Subhash named his army: Azad Hind Fauz, all the Arabic words. Hind is also an Arabic word. In Hindi/Urdu it was Hindustan. Or, Bharat.
@@ajeebadmi8052 They didn't migrated to Punjab, they were form that region and were Muslims also so naturally they joined the Pakistani army after Partition
"1947- The Transfer of Power from One Set of Crooks to Another Set of Crooks." - Abhijit Chavda I hope, in future this will become a chapter of History text books in Indian Schools.
True. As I have read in our ICSE history text books of the late 20th, early 21st century, which quoted such hilarious one liners from British bureaucrats of the 19th century, we will (hopefully) see the same repeat in our history textbooks of the late 21st century.
हिन्दी में टिप्पणी करने का प्रयास होना चाहिए।यह कार्यक्रम बहुत ही बढ़िया रहा। आनन्द आ गया।समस्त महाशय जनो को मेरा कोटि कोटि प्रणाम।जय जय सियाराम हर हर महादेव जय बजरंगबली।
प्रोफ़ेसर कपिल कुमार को सुन कर हमेशा ही रोंगटे खड़े हो जाते हैं। अश्रु धारा बहने लगी आज तो उन्हें सुन कर। अभिजीत चावड़ा जी,प्रखर श्रीवास्तव, विक्रम संपत,अनुज धर, आप सभी को साधुवाद, आभार, उद्वेलित,भावुक कर देने वाला सत्र।
Ajit Bharatiji is very critical of judges. I applaud his bravery. I hope many will take example from him and set a movement to change the judiciary. Jai Hind.
Yes, but that is not the only perspective. We have to analyse everything in totality. Prof. Kapil Kumar has put the other perspective by asking the question "if the geo-political perspective of USSR & Britain tussling over warmer ports in central/south Asia was the issue, what business had Gandhi/Congress to play/toe that tussle?"
@@pb8857 Gandhi and Nehru were Britain's obedient servant...They did what Britain wanted them to do... Partition of India is good for British interest... That's why Gandhi & Nehru didn't oppose it....
Power packed stage, I've spent hours listening to them/reading their works. The Chavda magic was the icing on the cake, what an absolutely fantastic moderator Chavda sir is🤩
अलग अलग विशेषज्ञों को सुनकर आत्मा तृप्त हो गई 🙏🏻 😊😊😊😊😊 कार्यक्रम के अंत मे चैतन्य की दशा मे पहुंच गया गीता मे लिखा है तुम क्या लाये थे तुम क्या साथ ले जाओगे मेरे मन मे लिख गया है हम कौन....?
I am Malaysian Indian.had been always proud of my dna originated from Baratham.At least now in my life I have the opportunity to know the truth and greatness of my ancestors who went tru such cruelty.God save India.
I have list of martyrs of Freedom movement from 1857 to 1947 and those who left the British Army and joined INA and laid down their lives fighting the British. It's published by the Ministry of Culture, but not many are aware of it.
जय हिन्द 💖🚩🕉️🚩🙏🏻 जय हिन्द 💖🚩🙏🏻🕉️ जय हिन्द जय भारत वंदेमातरम् सदा वत्सले मातृभूमि जय हिन्द जय भारत वंदेमातरम् सदा वत्सले मातृभूमि जय हिन्द जय भारत वंदेमातरम् सदा वत्सले मातृभूमि जय हिन्द जय भारत वंदेमातरम् सदा वत्सले मातृभूमि जय हिन्द जय भारत वंदेमातरम् सदा वत्सले मातृभूमि 🙏🏻🙏🏻💖🙏🏻🚩💖🙏🏻🚩💖🙏🏻🚩💖🙏🏻🚩💖🙏🏻🚩💖❤️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Brilliant panel with a vast scope of knowledge. I admire how varying their approach and suggestions are but the goal remains the same. Special mention to Sardarji "Shaastra k saath Shastra zaruri hai". Indian culture has always believed in this statement.
Every time movement is pulled back.. thats the main contribution of our so self called father n chacha...😡 Thanks a lot to entire yeam of JD for revealing truth....🙏🙏🙏
I would like to thank Mr. Sanjay Dikshit and the whole team of Jaipur Dialogues for creating this platform. Bringing together the voices that need to be heard and introduced to mainstream.
Prof. Kapil kumar ji ko sunkar Or baki sabko bhi, mujhe bhi hamare desh ka history janne ka bhut mn hai. Sir aap log jo kadam uthaye ho thank you soo much .. Ham aap logo ko full support krte h... Hum aapke sath hai
@@JAIBhAWAANI i hadn't made the connection but you are absolutely right brother. What a great way to arm and train our brothers against the next Direct Action
मंच पर विराजमान सभी महानुभाव को सुन कर सुखद अनुभूति होती है कि स्वतंत्रता आंदोलन का सच एक न एक दिन तथ्यों सहित हमारे समक्ष होंगे और आजादी के वो दीवाने जो देश के लिये खप गये अपना बनता स्थान शान से पायेंगे। प्रो• कपिल कुमार जी सुनना 👍 मुझे हमेशा रुचिकर लगता है 🙏, 🙏🙏 जयहिन्द जय भारत । 🥀🥀 जयपुर डायलाग ☺
Kapil sir was emotional & n anger hs words cme frm heart -& thts why there was stillness n audience. Hats off to Kapil sir, Anuj sir, Vikram sir ( a soft person) & Chavada sir.
British Empire Power has shifted from England to the US . But the action on the ground didn't change... British ran away from India and US abandoned Afghanistan.
Loaded information and power pack speakers.....kudos to all the great knowledgeable personalities to bring the real history of freedom..thanks to SD sir and KD for amazing work👏👏👏🙏
I come from a gorkha community. A few of my senior relatives, one of them being my own fatherwho was in the British army as a cook, used to tell stories of gorkha armymen who switched to INA from British army in the battle field itself in the border areas of Arunachal, Nagaland just because that at the other end fighting with them were the Gorkhas themselves. May be to avoid fratricide and also by conscience that they should be fighting the foreigners not their own brethren. The contribution of Gorkhas in the INA is just overlooked when it comes toremembering INA and Subhas.
Subhash Chandra Bose never Catagerized his soldiers as Gorkhas etc for him all very INA Soldiers
Most of INA migrated to Pakistan, and soon invaded Kashmir.
@@connectwithin7610 One cannot understand why Subhash named his army: Azad Hind Fauz, all the Arabic words. Hind is also an Arabic word. In Hindi/Urdu it was Hindustan. Or, Bharat.
@@ajeebadmi8052 They didn't migrated to Punjab, they were form that region and were Muslims also so naturally they joined the Pakistani army after Partition
Salute to them brother
"1947- The Transfer of Power from One Set of Crooks to Another Set of Crooks." - Abhijit Chavda
I hope, in future this will become a chapter of History text books in Indian Schools.
True. As I have read in our ICSE history text books of the late 20th, early 21st century, which quoted such hilarious one liners from British bureaucrats of the 19th century, we will (hopefully) see the same repeat in our history textbooks of the late 21st century.
Yes
@@abhijeetm29 by
True
Aaa
हिन्दी में टिप्पणी करने का प्रयास होना चाहिए।यह कार्यक्रम बहुत ही बढ़िया रहा। आनन्द आ गया।समस्त महाशय जनो को मेरा कोटि कोटि प्रणाम।जय जय सियाराम हर हर महादेव जय बजरंगबली।
Abhijit sir is the reason I came for, stayed for all of them
same
Vikram is awesome..... do listen
अभिजीत मित्रा??
@@rushikeshhindusthani4086 Chavda
Same
ऐसे ही सेमिनार देश के अलग अलग स्थानों में होने चाहिए। संजय सर को दिल से अभिनंदन
Book by Anuj Dhar CONUNDRUM is amazing and gives goosebumps at certain points .
प्रोफ़ेसर कपिल कुमार को सुन कर हमेशा ही रोंगटे खड़े हो जाते हैं।
अश्रु धारा बहने लगी आज तो उन्हें सुन कर।
अभिजीत चावड़ा जी,प्रखर श्रीवास्तव, विक्रम संपत,अनुज धर, आप सभी को साधुवाद, आभार,
उद्वेलित,भावुक कर देने वाला सत्र।
किंतु इन लोगों का बाप, दादा ने उस समय पर अपने गांव में बैठ कर बच्चें पैदे कर रहे थे।😁।
आज आधुनिक मनीषीयों को देखकर मन प्रसन्न है।इतिहास की रचना कर रहे हैं।प्रणाम 🙏🙏🙏
Abhijit Chavada Sir is a gem
He has prejudiced mind.
Ajit Bharatiji is very critical of judges. I applaud his bravery. I hope many will take example from him and set a movement to change the judiciary. Jai Hind.
Kon
@@Shandilya-q3i do politics
Ajeet bharti
ajeet bharti
Kon
Prof Kapil Kumar -- excellent👍👏🌹
Anuj dhar -- outstanding research 🇮🇳
Abhijit Chavda-- knowledgeable 🌹
Prakhar srivadtav --intelligent research🌹
Sanjay dixit ji-- bring more such sessions
ऐसा कार्यक्रम हर ब्लॉक लेवल पर होना चाहिए,
बहुत बड़ा काम किया है आपने संजय जी
Abhijit Chavda is brilliant ...Only he understands the geo-political perspetive......
true he is civilsed
@@yasho9851 Lolz!! What's civilized?? Even the British & Europeans had called themselves civilized!!
We were expecting Vikram sampatji to give some speech 🙏
Yes, but that is not the only perspective. We have to analyse everything in totality. Prof. Kapil Kumar has put the other perspective by asking the question "if the geo-political perspective of USSR & Britain tussling over warmer ports in central/south Asia was the issue, what business had Gandhi/Congress to play/toe that tussle?"
@@pb8857 Gandhi and Nehru were Britain's obedient servant...They did what Britain wanted them to do... Partition of India is good for British interest... That's why Gandhi & Nehru didn't oppose it....
Vikram sir is gem of contemporary 🇮🇳
All legends on same stage. This is epic.
Such a profound information from Kapil Kumar. The present govt should award Bharat Ratna to netaji and make special memorial for Azad hind martyrs.
Power packed stage, I've spent hours listening to them/reading their works. The Chavda magic was the icing on the cake, what an absolutely fantastic moderator Chavda sir is🤩
Absolutely right 👍💯‼️
Abhijeet sir is a pro.. and a magnet ... which are really good qualities....
अलग अलग विशेषज्ञों को सुनकर आत्मा तृप्त हो गई 🙏🏻
😊😊😊😊😊
कार्यक्रम के अंत मे चैतन्य की दशा मे पहुंच गया
गीता मे लिखा है
तुम क्या लाये थे
तुम क्या साथ ले जाओगे
मेरे मन मे लिख गया है
हम कौन....?
संजय दिक्षित जी आपको बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद जो आपने अच्छे मुद्दे उठाये हैं।
प्राध्यापक इतिहासकार कपिल कुमार गुरुजी ज्ञान का अथांग सागर है।
नमन है। 🙏
आज बहुत कुछ नया सुनने को मिला। 🕉️🚩
Anuj Dhar Pushpendra Kulshreshta sir are really true game 💯❤️
You can listen these two for hours
Many indian People won't like anuj dhar because he also speak against Indian who supported british army
All questions were asked to anuj dhar😊
That is the power of Netaji subhash chandra bose❤
One set of crooks to another set of crooks well said
I am Malaysian Indian.had been always proud of my dna originated from Baratham.At least now in my life I have the opportunity to know the truth and greatness of my ancestors who went tru such cruelty.God save India.
Is Hindu in Kerala is about to decline? Want to understand as outsiders?
Every speaker on The Jaipur Dialogues is a library.
विचारोत्तेजक सत्र.. हमें विश्लेषण से समाधान.. समाधान से क्रियान्वयन और क्रियान्वयन से गौरवशाली सनातन राष्ट्र की स्थापना तक बढ़ना होगा..।
I have list of martyrs of Freedom movement from 1857 to 1947 and those who left the British Army and joined INA and laid down their lives fighting the British.
It's published by the Ministry of Culture, but not many are aware of it.
Can you please provide a link? Or mention how we can access it?
Provide the link please!
It will be very helpful....!
@@ayandey137
Just search ..... ministry of culture.. dictionary of martyrs ...
जाओ
PRAKHAD SRIVASTAVA deserves appreciation for unmasking "quit-INDIA"
Prof Kapil Kumar is on fire. So much to know from him. I can spend hours listening to him. Thank you Sir ❤️
One of the best sessions😊 We really cannot thank JD enough for bringing these speakers and topics to us
जय हिन्द 💖🚩🕉️🚩🙏🏻 जय हिन्द 💖🚩🙏🏻🕉️ जय हिन्द जय भारत वंदेमातरम् सदा वत्सले मातृभूमि जय हिन्द जय भारत वंदेमातरम् सदा वत्सले मातृभूमि जय हिन्द जय भारत वंदेमातरम् सदा वत्सले मातृभूमि जय हिन्द जय भारत वंदेमातरम् सदा वत्सले मातृभूमि जय हिन्द जय भारत वंदेमातरम् सदा वत्सले मातृभूमि 🙏🏻🙏🏻💖🙏🏻🚩💖🙏🏻🚩💖🙏🏻🚩💖🙏🏻🚩💖🙏🏻🚩💖❤️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Sandeep Dixit g ko Dil se bahut bahut dhanyawad karte hai hum....jo ye information hame pata lag pa rahi hai....
Sanjay dixit
Sanjay hai bhai 🤣😂🤣
संजय
बहुत सुन्दर विश्लेषण | सभी वक्ताओं का आभार | वामपंथी विचारकों को तार-तार कर दिया |
हमारे योद्धाओ को प्रणाम
विजयी भवः
जय हिंद वंदे मातरम प्रणाम संजय दीक्षित सर जी 🙏🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🙏
Brilliant panel with a vast scope of knowledge. I admire how varying their approach and suggestions are but the goal remains the same.
Special mention to Sardarji "Shaastra k saath Shastra zaruri hai". Indian culture has always believed in this statement.
Every time movement is pulled back.. thats the main contribution of our so self called father n chacha...😡
Thanks a lot to entire yeam of JD for revealing truth....🙏🙏🙏
Its a pleasure to hear Vikram sir.... A big fan...
Prof sahib. Your suggestions are exactly what is required in India today.
आपने सही कहा कोर्ट में सब के सब जज भ्रष्ट है। कानून बनना चाहिए ऐसे जजों को जेल भेजना चाहिए। दुश्मनों को मुआफ करने की बजाए उनकी गर्दन काटनी चाहिए।
Big admire of Abhijit sir and Anuj dhar sir
I would like to thank Mr. Sanjay Dikshit and the whole team of Jaipur Dialogues for creating this platform. Bringing together the voices that need to be heard and introduced to mainstream.
Prof. Kapil kumar ji ko sunkar Or baki sabko bhi, mujhe bhi hamare desh ka history janne ka bhut mn hai. Sir aap log jo kadam uthaye ho thank you soo much .. Ham aap logo ko full support krte h... Hum aapke sath hai
Excellent panel...Prakhar ji and Abhijit ji and Sampat ji
Seeing Sardar sir gave a ray of hope. A minimum of 10 cr Hindus need to be armed and ready when the inevitable Direct Action day happens again
Agniveer is the same process
Agreed
अग्निवीर
@@JAIBhAWAANI i hadn't made the connection but you are absolutely right brother. What a great way to arm and train our brothers against the next Direct Action
Sardar
You both are the stars of the show Mr prakhar shrivastav and Mr Abhijit Chavda
Their is absolutely no doubt that the history of 🇮🇳 should be rewritten and free of biases, the truth and only the truth should rule.
इस एपिसोड मे अनुज जी ने सबसे ज्यादा तथ्यों पर बात किया है
What a bliss to hear all the GOATs at the same time on the same stage
शत् शत् नमन् प्रोफेसर कपील कुमार जी आपकी दिलेरी को.
मंच पर विराजमान सभी महानुभाव को सुन कर सुखद अनुभूति होती है कि स्वतंत्रता आंदोलन का सच एक न एक दिन तथ्यों सहित हमारे समक्ष होंगे और आजादी के वो दीवाने जो देश के लिये खप गये अपना बनता स्थान शान से पायेंगे। प्रो• कपिल कुमार जी सुनना 👍 मुझे हमेशा रुचिकर लगता है 🙏, 🙏🙏 जयहिन्द जय भारत ।
🥀🥀 जयपुर डायलाग ☺
Jai hindurashtra Good discussion and analysis bharat mata ki jai vande matram har har mahadev
Abhijeet Chawda sir, Anuj Dhar sir, Vikram Sampat ji aap to amazing ho hi lekin ye baki log bhi OMG
I will be wonder,if government doesn't open it's eyes after seeing this conversation with facts.🙏 kudos to The jaipur dialogue.
Wowwwww
I did NOT knew that.
I bow down to each of them, each of these Historians, just WOW!
Rajat, Entrepreneur, Uttarakhand
I am Willing to Contribute 🤝 to Such Awakening ACTIVITY 🙏🏻 for It's Continued EFFORTS
Thanks a lot for telling us the right history! Respect for all of you, especially for gems like Vikram Sampath and Abhijit Chavda 💯
Abhijit Chavda ❤️
Iss baar kaafi topics kay liye jo panel chunay gaye hain woh bahut zabardast hain❤
'Independence was transfer of power by one set of crooks to another set of crooks'- Sir Abhijeet
This cannot be said any better than this.
Thanks!
Vikram Ji and Abijit Ji. Thank u for explaining in English, sadly alot of us don't understand hindi..
Kapil sir was emotional & n anger
hs words cme frm heart -& thts why
there was stillness n audience.
Hats off to Kapil sir, Anuj sir, Vikram sir ( a soft person) & Chavada sir.
British Empire Power has shifted from England to the US . But the action on the ground didn't change... British ran away from India and US abandoned Afghanistan.
Thanks
Absolutely fantastic session, and Kapil ji is right that there shud be more of these kind of dilouges...
Prakhar JI’s style of quoting is amazing!!
Abhijeet is great
Sampath ji as always super specific
Ajit ji I
Simply a blessing for us
वाह सही इतीहास उजागर हो रहा है
प्रखर श्रीवास्तव हमेशा लॉजिकल बात करते हैं। वो भी फेक्ट के साथ। love @prakhar ❤️
This crusade of real-time nationalism should continue.
आप सभी का दिल से आभार
thank you...
Congratulations to Sanjay sir and his team to organize such mega multidimensional event 👌 selection of speakers are awesome throughout the event.
Superb programme conducted by Jaipur Dialogue.
Thank you for this awakening knowledge about our real heroes and their history of India .
Jai Hind
अगली विजयादशमी रंगपुर में..! जय अखंड हिंदु राष्ट्र..! 🚩🦁⚔️🔫🔥🙏
Loaded information and power pack speakers.....kudos to all the great knowledgeable personalities to bring the real history of freedom..thanks to SD sir and KD for amazing work👏👏👏🙏
legends together like avengers!!!!
I'm 24 year science student.I have lot of interest in history. Sanjay sir helping a lot of youngster to think intuitively.
Excellent session...prof Kapil Kumar is a great inspirational figure
Thanks. I will personally take our real history forward for the rest of my lifetime.
Elder brother of my Great Grandfather was a Sikh, but my great grandfather was a Hindu. So my dad's cousins are sikhs but my dad is a Hindu.
Sanjay Dixit ji is the most eligible person to answer the last question on partition of India, that Mr. Abhijit answered.
AWESOME...... ENLIGHTENING...... REVEALING...... Ashamed to know how doggish and puny our national leaders had been!!😡😡
Anuj is superb...talks with evidence.
संजय सर देश सदैव याद रखेगा आपको
Quite enlightening....Thanks to RUclips we are learning true history
abhijit chavda was on fire 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Great Program as usual. Humare Prof Sahab ne to poora program ka time khud hee le liya 😃🙏🏽🇮🇳🚩
New History books for the youth of this country is the need of hour..🙏
What a great session a real template to the original history of indian independence
A very awaited and absolutely right step taken by youu people!
VANDE MATARAM 🇮🇳✨💥🙏❤️
Professor साहब के पास शानदार इतिहास का ज्ञान ह
Finally get to see Abhijit Chavda in public discussions. Was long due.
To be an audience of such august, knowledgeable and profound speakers is a great privilege This has only been made possible by JD
❤love you all.hope next generation will read right history of india
Aj to Proffessor Kapil Kumar yuddh chhed diye Jaipur se.
Jay ho.
Very inspiring
Jai Hind
Mentali
I listened Profesor Kapil the very first time and i am sure that till today my ears were not heard of a legend like him ❤️🙏
Hats off Jaipur Dialogues
Hats off to all panelists...
Great going
The most proud part of the video which fills my heart with immense joy is the 'young boys and girls listening to the speakers with full attention' !
Distinguished guests of the Panel KO Shat Shat Naman 🙏 🙏🙏 .Marvellous Session
Deep Knowledge of Guests. Interesting and Informative.