Different endings of Butterfly effect 1 compilation
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 дек 2009
- My photography page: www.bit.ly/aceshooting
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Different endings of Butterfly effect 1 compilation:
4 endings:
1- Theatrical cut ending
2- Happy ending
3- Open ending
4- Directors cut ending
Related videos:
Editing in the butterfly effect: • Editing effects in the... 
Кино
Imagine knowing that the person you love could have had a better life had you not been in it?
That's what breaks my heart about the theatrical version.
Lauren Kelly Vinette it kills me inside
@@billy5939 actually they both become better if not spent childhood together. either evan dead or alive
I know for a fact she would have
11 years ago i let my girl go for this reason i came to terms over the year i was hurting her a lot... maybe when we're old and gray we try it again
@@topwargear I understand your pain. Sometimes doing what's right can feel painfully wrong.
the ending where they both kept walking is so powerful
I felt kinda sad after the ending of the first they never knew they existed until a lot of years later
+Marco Mark I feel like it was the best ending. Although I'm a huge sucker for the ending where they wanna go out for coffee (as cliché as it was) because after all the shit they went through I feel like they both just deserved it. The stalker ending I also liked because it wasn't a straight up happy ending, it just showed that Evan still loved her and wanted her in his life, even after it seemed like it was never meant to happen he still went chasing after her. The stillborn ending was unbelievably depressing as fuck but in all honesty the directors cut did tell the best and most powerful story, and ended with evan making the hugest sacrifice imaginable so his friends and family could live happy lives. Overall if you gave me a choice for what was considered the true ending, I'd probably say either directors cut or theatre ending, but I do love the theatre ending and felt it was the most satisfying. It shows that Life has consequences and some things aren't meant to be, but it also shows that things aren't totally bleak either. It had the best balance out of the endings because while it's still sad, Evan and everyone else in this timeline clearly are living much better lives than if Kaylee and Evan met as kids.
+allwalledup Evan wan't the only one who made such a sacrifice. His father and grandfather tried the same thing, and his stillborn siblings succeeded. I agree that it's sad that way but it's also best. The other versions don't quite work because Evan keeps all his actions secret from the people he loves, and that unfairly distances him from them. That's why he doesn't deserve Kayleigh and the other guy does.
+thefulfox time is a flat circle
lupash
As opposed to square circles?
It's crazy to think that when he kills himself as a baby, there were two other people that went through the same things as him and ultimately kill themselves as babies.
Daaaaaaaamn. That's right... she did have 2 other still births... so they could have had the same butterfly effects , and killed themselves....🤯🤯🤯🤯(mindblown)
What is really crazy is that during that ending when she's telling the story, she said she was pregnant 3 other times instead of 2, so she's talking to a whole other person who may in fact end up going through it as well.
@@shawnd507 as i understood it and based on what imdb says, she's referring to her forth baby she had with her new husband (chuck?). the new babygirl broke the family curse (you can see Andrea, her new husband and baby outside the house in the directors cut after evan killed himself; 7:39)
@@ingridrnilsen Oh, right on. I didn't catch that part.
@@shawnd507 Whatever the ability is carries on through the male descendants in the family so his grandad,father and two miscarriages. It is probable that the two miscarriages could either have been different guys entirely rather than Evan as if it were Evan being reborn after the last two times, then the new child Andrea has wouldn't have been a girl but Evan again
Crazy to think that movie critics didnt like this movie. One of the best movies def in my top 20 all time. Still have it on VHS.
Agreed!
I never have listened to the opinions of movie critics
Mostly because of the bad press garnered by the leading actor
movie critics are idiots. movie critics gave black panther a 10/10. note i dont think BP is bad but 10/10? give me a break
@@randomguy4781 facts the movie critics just loved it because it was basically an all black cast. They just are virtue signaling trying to make it out to look like they the most politically correct perfect people to ever exist.
The first version i've seen was the director's cut ... so now i see the other versions, i feel less depressed
Yeah, me too. I'll show this to my friend since we both watched the director's cut. Eases up a little bit.
Someone else here said they didn't like that ending because it implied he wasn't meant to exist at all, because "everyone has a place in the world." I like that quote. I'm glad the director's cut isn't the canon ending.
You have no place in the world.
So do I.
I know that feel bro.
holy fuck I just watched the director's cut full movie and I was like "holy shit this isn't how I remember the movie"
i thought i was caught up in some parallel dimension dimension shit
Me too I was contemplating life I thought I WAS crazy.
Well, i just watched the director's cut, and said "What the ???" The movie is all freak!
Just like the Berenstein and Berenstain Bears.
Dude that’s like -2 dimensions. (So high right now)
Hahahha saaame
As a massive film enthusiast, I honestly believe this film and “Dark City” are the two most underrated films in all of cinematic history. This film is incredibly engaging and way ahead of its time.
Momento is right up there and even Angel Heart
@@DMalltheway Except that Momento gets massive love now. People have come to appreciate it. This movie is not really appreciated for how good it really is. I liked it when it first came out and watched it multiple times even with all the hate surrounding it.
I love dark city
there have been sequels or spin-offs or something so it wasnt that underrated actually.
that being said, this movie is underrated af.
I wouldn’t go that far there are questionable moments in this movie tho I think it was very entertaining and had a lot of thought put into it
The theatrical ending has Oasis. It's automatically the best ending.
Yeah. The song, the editing, the emotion, everything makes this the best ending by far for me. It's just so powerful and memorable.
I am surprised that this movie didn't get higher ratings. After watching all the alternate endings, I also agree that the theatrical one where Evan and Kayleigh make eye contact, both stop, think, turn around, then keep walking is the best ending. AND the Oasis song from 2002 "Stop Crying Your Heart Out" makes adds a great touch. But maybe with the song by Oasis being played over top of the other endings, they also would seem to work well. Credit to Oasis, they are an awesome band. IF the damn brothers Liam and Noel Gallagher would have gotten along better, they could have surpassed the Beatles in their fame! That is what many critics have said about the powerful songs by Oasis.
True
but just ... ahem...
*MAYBEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE*
Nah. Wrong. Baby finally realising he wasn't supposed to be in this world is the most impactful one.
i remember seeing this movie when i was younger and i remember the first ending and i just rewatched and and saw a different ending where he kills himself as a baby before birth and i was like WTF
haha same here!
lupinmodz dude same I only REMBER the first one until I rewatched the movie and saw where he killed himself in the womb
i just know there are 4 different endings ......
i love ending 1 the most!
Literally just happened to me to and I looked it up and here I am!
haha just happened to me
The 1st one, theatrical cut, is the best. Evan chose to make sacrifice and continued living with the consequence. It fits the film and makes sense the most.
Nah ending 4 makes the most sense. It ties in with the fact his brothers also went back to kill themselves. Ending 1 is just for people who don't want tragedy 😛
oh wow the brothers going back to kill themselves never really crossed my mind!
Shanes Channel That would have left room for a second and third movie showing what the previous brother and sisters life was like. The ending for those potential movies would have been repetitive though.
those scenes, where the viewer learns about the 2 fail births and other scenes related to the directors cut are left out on the other ending versions. I never watched the directors cut of the movie. I watched the theatrical one (first ending), so it seems the best ending to me.
@UC9_b80gXbR-8ZOBvzrNu4Ag they could've still done that without Evan doing it too it still makes sense without that horribly depressing piece of shit
3:09 this single shot of Keileigh walking down the road is so powerful. It really shows how much she thrived without Evan.. although we know she can be happy with Evan too with the sorority path, if only Evan had told the dad to be good to both of the kids instead of just Keileigh
she wouldn't be happy with evan in the sorority path because tommy was still abused.
@@avril7527 Hence why Somili said "if only Evan had told the dad to be good to both kids"
@@Mithcoriel yes ! that would of saved everything.. or maybe not..
I think the way that the story went with his connection to keileigh, tommy and lenny sets up for the fact that he was always fated to fall short in his “corrections.” Tommy was fated to either hate Evan or never know he existed, their father is bound to abuse someone no matter what, and Evan is forced to learn his lesson with his power and correct it all. I agree the scene of keileigh walking alone is so powerful, I think the director meant for the theatrical cut to seem like the most satisfying one for Evan specifically, even if he doesn’t get the girl. He uses the power to right all his wrongs and make the girl he loves truly happy, which is a depressingly beautiful and selfless concept.
The whole movie is about showing how everytime he changed something it made something else worse lol
Bro that "not again" was heartbreaking.
this movie fucked me up, one of the best ones Ive seen, what if the people who we consider crazy arent crazy at all?
You're absolutely right. I've recently had to come to the realization that calling someone crazy just because we don't understand something is never a good idea. When you go through something first hand that makes others view you as crazy, it changes your entire perspective; especially if you can actually see how crazy you seem, but know full well that you aren't.
Since you watch this masterpiece of a movie.
Play the game Life is Strange.
The power to control TIME is an amazing power.
yep I'm trusting to get it
its just a movie.
In real life crazy people are crazy.
dont compare dramatic movie to reality
I think the theatrical cut is the best. becuase the story at its core is about two soul mates who are cursed to doom them or those around them. Never meeting breaks the curse. and when he sees her again. he just walks away... because he knows that he still can never be with her. even if fate trys its best.
and evan had learnt a lesson
he burnt all the stuff that get him to the past
metallavery But then it leaves a plothole. What about him never having a lifeline? No soul? He was never meant to be? No, the idea of him realizing he needs to never have existed is sad, but imo the best. But to each his own.
earp1673 I agree with you man. Plus, we have to look at the other two miscarriages. Is it possible that those two babies had the same powers, and that they grew up and wrecked their timelines and took the same route Evan did? Or, maybe Evan's dad caused the deaths of those other two babies to try and stop the curse, but couldn't bring himself to do it to his wife a third time, hence Evan was born. Just watched the movie again with the stillborn ending. I think that one is the best. In the ending where Evan sees her in NY and just keeps walking, that doesn't take into account all the brain damage he sustained. However, in that ending it's safe to say that the ONLY jump he actually made was to threaten Kalie, and after that never did it again, undoing the brain damage. I still say the stillborn ending leaves the least plotholes.
Tony Mirabella He couldnt get the photo albums after he got stuck in a timeline where his wife didnt mess with him. So the third baby probably just went on living.
baby is septate living after birth. Still in a parall universe he could have been still born or smothered, but yet exsisted in another. here but not here,
I had no idea he is supposed to be alive. I have only ever seen the directors cut ending. Seeing how he is supposed to be alive just breaks my teenage heart, back when I watched it.
Same i literally just found out from watching it again on Netflix
I was so confused and had to look it up
I saw it as a teenager in ‘04, and the ending was that he lived and ignored Kaylee. First time seeing that he died in the director’s cut. I saw it in theaters.
@@jonnyOATHI watched it today on tv with that dieing ending so i was confused about other endings ,i guess on Netflix which i dont use and other sites are different endings
I saw it as a teenager back then (2004), then I watch this movie again today, got super confused because I don't remember that ending at all, it goes back to the womb holysht. Back then I only remember he saw her as an adult and let her go.
Ending One: "If you love someone you let them go because it was never meant to be." 0:00
Ending Two: "Everything happens for a reason and always at the right place at the right time." 3:21
Ending Three: "We make our fate in this world." 4:27
Ending Four: "By sacrificing your happiness for others, is the true meaning of life.' 5:19
I liked the theatrical ending the most, the one with oasis song, i think it fits perfectly with scene and its so overwhelming but maybe it's bcuz I saw that one when I first watched this movie on tv. I honestly hate Director's Cut ending bcuz it's so tragic and morbid.
@@petraleopold2713 Me too
@@brierichardson8462 :)
This should be the top comment
@@petraleopold2713 the director’s cut ending was meant to be the original ending but test audiences weren’t happy so they filmed a different ending where Evan upsets Kayleigh where she would end up living with her mother along with Tommy which meant she didn’t have to suffer abuse at the hands of her father and Evan and Lenny burns the journals never to alter time again,then fast forward to the future Evan is a therapist and he pass by Kayleigh and they stare at each other but he keeps walking. I honestly prefer the happy ending where Evan meets Kayleigh and they introduce themselves and go out for coffee
lol this movie is like a video game with Best, Good, Normal, Bad endings etc..
great movie
16dylan2 Life Is Strange?
ThePraetor that's what i came for :p
ThePraetor AHah, after playing Life Is Stange, wanted to watch this movie again !
+OminousStrike me too just finished episode 4 and i cant wait for episode 5 but at the same time i dont want it to end.
+16dylan2 also Silent Hill : Book of memories (although not so good game)
first ending is the one I saw when I first watched the movie. I didn't even know there was multiple endings and I watched the movie again and got the director's cut this time. DC is depressing as hell
i agree, but over all the DC gives you more to think about than just an "Happy ending" or atleast semi-happy
Alex R. True, but I did prefer to have an ending that somewhat happily resolved the plot after so many fuck ups by the main character.
I thought the director's cut was a cheesy happy ending to start with with Evan and Kayleigh getting married, then I realised it was a different guy marrying Kayleigh and Evan had snuffed himself out in his mother's womb.
same here. i saw first ending when i first saw movie, then this time the directors cut. the director's cut as sad as it is the best for the movie.
*****
that doesnt even make sense.
The ending where he kills him self as a baby straightup makes me cry
Its brutal
I'm happy they chose the first ending. It's just dramatic, open and left a lot of questions in my head. The last ending is way too sad
He clearly did not care about his mom's feelings at all.
I don't like the womb one because it sends the message that the world was better off without him
and it was... the DC ending is the only that make sense, sadly for Evan
The one where they go on their separate ways is the real one some things are better left dead.
Bro, the theater's original version was exactly that: the original ending. It doesn't matter what the director wanted; the original writer of the story is the one who decides what is canon, and that would be the first ending.
wow. i understand why jeremymd said break and i understand why goblinhk is going on with his comments.
+goblinhk wow, "triggered" there buddy?
I liked the director's cut ending because it's consistent with Jason (Evan's father) trying to kill him when he was 7, saying "It's the only way," and explains why his mother had two previous stillbirths...meaning his could've-been older siblings also had the time-travel gift and must have "lived" interesting time-travel-filled lives as well, until they decided to kill themselves in the womb. He just followed the suicide cycle until Jason (the dad) was out of the picture for good so his mom could move on with another man who didn't carry the gene with the "curse."
U sure it was Jason that said that. I thought it was the guards
@@thechillmaster5836it was Jason bro
Please repent and find YHWH Elohim and keep the commandments in Exodus 20 and Leviticus 11
Please read Exodus 20 and pray for forgiveness
2nd Corinthians 5:17
“Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, the new creation has come: The old has gone, the new is here!”
[37] Jesus said unto him, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind. [38] This is the first and great commandment. [39] And the second is like unto it, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself. [40] On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets. Matthew 22:37-40
Please read the book of Jonah, Matthew, Exodus you'll have the information you need. 😅😂😊
@@Lolirock971 seeing how you’re religious fanatic, your username checks out.
@@Lolirock971literally no one asked
I prefer the theatrical ending. It's a sacrifice but not too dark. They both get to have their lives. Plus the music is awesome.
Also, anyone else thinking that for the "happy ending" he totally stood up his mom?
Not exactly 😂, I mean they could’ve just scheduled the coffee date
Imagine how many times you've walked past the love of your (alternative) life.
A Thousand times
0
😭 or just friends
And this is why to think I "had to" be monogam is hurting my brain. Just to finally dont let me have even one relationship because... You know...
Guys. Just to add here. It kinda shrills me out even thinking about it. Hope, everyone get what they deserve.
I like the second ending the best. The point of the whole movie was that their lives are ruined because never grew up in a stable home. Now that they're healthy adults and Evan can no longer time travel, they can finally be together
SirVolcy yeah i agree but isn't Evan with someone? As he's walking out the building he tells the person on the phone that they can get soup then he call her hon, so I'm guessing he is in a relationship, if not already married....
Edit: (9/3/18) (yeah guys you right he did say mom) I'ma posted the endings in a list from best to worsted.
1st: Second Ending - love at first sight, God giving them another chance.
2nd: Theater Version - More realistic
3rd: Third Ending - It could happen too
4th: Forth Ending - tf they just killed off the main character.. as a baby.. in his mother's womb 😱
JR137 I thought he was talking to his mom on the phone and said “mom” not “hon.” Maybe I misheard, though.
JR137 he said mom
SirVolcy true but at the same time the whole flow of the movie proves that you can't force something no matter how much u try to change it. A happg ending would've been cool though, just doesn't seem to fit for this film
Yeah, third one doesnt seem fit for this film,Because the message from this movie is “something gotta be sacrificed to change fate" . What would that be?his legs?his life? or this love?
#3 is the Stalker Ending
So true 😂 lol
I thought that was the worst ending. It makes you think what's going to happen
He ruined her life again I guess. Destiny won.
No, we don't know her life will be ruined. It leaves the door open.
It is entirely possible for someone like Evan to learn from his mistakes, and not do it again.
Negan's Evil Twin That’s why it’s up to the viewers to decide what happens next.
There is a scene where the alternate reality is created where Evan finds himself at college as a fraternity brother. When his memory is being 'rebuilt', Kayleigh hitches a ride to visit Evan at age 13 after he moved away. People don't realize (and it's not even mentioned in the DVD commentary) that the driver is Karl, the bald prisoner who would exist in that reality before going to the same prison as Evan
Source IMDb , most important thing you missed I’m here to share it with you
Actually, that is after he changes things in the prison and gives Lenny the piece of metal and Tommy is killed. It's to insinuate that she went down a much darker path after Tommy was killed and she met Karl while hitchhiking, which is why we see her as a strung out junkie prostitute.
No, that's the wrong one. It's when she runs away and becomes a prostitute.
She takes a grey hound type bus to meet Evan in the sorority/frat future.
Ending 3 is the definition of stalking.
2 person are going for a walk but only one of them is aware of that.
here goes the butterfly effects of the "Butterfly Effect"
+Rocco Hunter The title fits the story perfectly. Somewhen in the movie I thought „Hey, that's the butterfly effect... oh, right, that's in the title.”
+Rocco Hunter HAHAHAHA! TRUE STORY =D!!
Manuel Medina =D
I only ever saw the last ending (the director's cut version)...
It hit me so hard... I just sat there watching the credits, listening to the music until it ended... I don't know what to believe anymore
I've already seen the first version so many times... But I just got done watching the directors cut and I did exactly what you described.... Just sat there looking at the credits
I downloaded the movie where he kills himself. When the credits started rolling i was like "Well this is retarted.
i did the same too,. i was just staring at the screen and trying to absorb all that happened in the movie,. i didnt know there's a happy ending till now..
Did the exact same thing. Kept staring at the credits...
And i just did the same today
After everything happened Evan wanted to hurt others as little as possible. This ending makes sense because him saying a few mean things to Kaylee was far less hurtful than him killing himself as a fetus and putting his mother through the hell of a stillbirth so the ending shows how he managed to create a reality that benefits everybody. But of course he being the only one truly affected by it by grieving the relationship he wished he could have had with Kaylee. A relationship that just wasn't meant to be.
Such a brilliant film. Ashton is truly remarkable. He doesn't get enough credit. 💯
This is why *The Butterfly Effect* is my favorite movie of all time, so many different endings and an amazing heart-pacing story to back up the movie.
Smitty WerbenJagerManJensen
Not my exact fav but definetly top 20.
Top 5 of all time
You will probably love the mind-bender movie "Identity (2003)" and "What Dreams May Come"
I don't like the suicide ending, as it puts the blame on Evan, while George Miller the paedophile is really the one who ruins everyone's lives. It is really his actions that are having the butterfly effect.
but no matter what he did somebodies life was messed up afterwords.
devmyster925
to be fair the stuff he did he messed up if he made correct choices he could easily fix stuff but remember every time he went back he had moments to try and correct it and almost every time he made a fatal error.
by that if he planned out what to do and think of possible outcomes before he went back he could fix some things
OMBseabass
I agree but what Evan should have done was go back to the time where the mail box exploded. Do not give his friend the piece of metal shard but still give his motivational speech...This in turn will probably avoid one killing the other, and the dog being saved. But again the baby and the mother would still have died. Too bad he did not go back to that memory again and tried to change it again to avoid his hands being blown off. It seemed in that instance though the mail box exploded a lot faster then before since the mother was still halfway in the lawn. But since there is no real measure of time here since its a quick flashback, I guess it was overlooked.
2Pac Remix he couldn't go back because he never wrote it :/
The point isnt who's a bad guy, but there are choices & sacrifices.
I think ending one hurts the most because he knows he’s fixed her life and everyone else’s but doesn’t know what would happen if he goes into her life so he leaves. He’s left to wonder what could have been and wondering if he made the right choice by walking away and possibly never seeing her again
LITERALLY THIS IS BY FAR THE MOST DEPRESSING ENDING
Theatrical version is the best one imo.
While the happy ending seems good, it's just seems too perfect. In the movie, every time he thinks that he fixed things, not everything is perfect. (e.g. when his friends are alright, but his mom is dying from lung cancer.)
So in this version, having them walk away from each other shows that not everything is exactly perfect, but our main character is willing to sacrifice his relationship with Kayleigh because everything else is way better than it could have been. He has learned his lesson.
Also having them going for coffee makes the previous scene where he scares her away and the sacrifice means lesser. It's too perfect and makes the viewer lose suspension of disbelief.
This movie should definetively end with Evan asking for his diary-books and the doc just answering:" nope, they did never exist!!".
This would be a very terrifc ending, because we wouldn't know if he just was crazy the whole time or is now captured in the most shittiest parallel-universe ever.
would be like shutter island ;)
Sensei .Takagaki omg i though the same as you when the doctor said that, i was like ''omg, if this ends here, im gonna love that movie so much'' 'because left all open... and would be nice imagine if he really had a mental problem and everything was just part of his brain or if everything was true... that would blow minds and i'm pretty sure it would make the movie more interesting. Well, I really like it anyways
Sensei .Takagaki That would be interesting, but I wouldn't like that. I hate those ending of whether it's real or not, whether it was just a dream. It's quite cliched.
Rosandi Minyety They made 2 movies after this soo they knew it was all real :)
megagrifonumon well that's truth:p
this movie fucked me up real bad.... it was very intense
That happy ending was what I always wanted it to be.
Why not let them link back up later on in life and give people a happy ending? They deserve it,we deserve it. Ughhhh ♡ im just glad it exists
I first watched the directors cut one, but I preferred the first where he sees her again but has enough confidence and maturity in himself to not go for it again and let her go her separate ways, they’re better off without each other. bittersweet and melancholic
this movie hit me damn hard.
I mean, the protagonist is in a situation where he genuinely believes that the world and his friends would be better off if he wrote himself out of history.
I don't think I'd say this for any other film, but I prefer the 'happy' ending most: I think Evan and Kayleigh damn well deserve to rewrite their relationship.
torn- B-I-a-S
You and I think alike. I usually prefer the movies to end with the bittersweat endings or the downer endings. But in this case, no. I preferred the first ending.
Altruism is a bitch
@@michellesmith9256 I think the first ending is by far the most depressing. He fixed everything but is still afraid that he’s a poison to her. He should get the girl and ride off into the sunset..
Theatrical ending is the best ending, in my opinion. Evan actually gets to learn his lesson and moves on knowing that the girl he loves is probably happy. Not only is it needlessly cruel to imply she'd be better off if he didn't exist, that doesn't even make sense. He wasn't the reason why she was stuck with her abusive father and crazy brother. I don't think it's worth the "ohhhhhh" moment when you realize his mom had previous miscarriages.
Well she said the only reason that she didn't move in with her mom was because she knew Evan was in the neighborhood and she wanted to stay because she knew if she left she would never see Evan again. Also it makes more sense for when the father tried to kill his own son, if there was a way out where his son could live a happy life I doubt he would have tried to kill him. It only makes sense if Evan was just never meant to exist in the first place and it would be best for everyone in his life
I think the DC was the best. Sometimes life is cruel.
the fact that this movie have many alternative ending goes along with the premise of this movie
This movie was remarkable and it stayed with me my whole life. It’s a film I randomly think about often Ashton Kutcher did an amazing job.
The Director's Cut is by far the most powerful version. However, it makes no sense that he was not born because if he wasn't born then he would not be able to go back in time to make sure he was born. Additionally, his mother would have probably resorted to chain smoking or worse, I mean this was her third still birth. Therefore the theatrical cut is the better option because it follows the timeline but instead he gives up on the love of his life to let her live a good life. The happy ending could also have been done although it would not have left the same mark in my mind. Very underrated film, one of my favorite films now because it really makes you question the choices you make and how we are not meant to play God.
The baby is about to be born, it is alive, the older version is in control of the whole situation, this would be her third stillbirth because her previous pregnancies did exactly the same, killed themselves.
K Smith All the endings were good, but to me at least, the theatrical/final cut on the dvd fit the best. He really learned something from all of this and we get the clear ending that him and Kaley are happy.
The Director's cut definitely had kind of a shock factor to it but Evan never came across as the type that would kind of give up like that. That ending turned it into a noble sacrifice kind of story, and it just didn't feel too fit..The audience really likes Evan from start to finish.
The others all had great appeal and mystery to them, but I argue that it would show that didn't learn anything from his experience. Even though we kind of want him to pursue Kaley again, we respect more of the fact that he refrains, for the first true time in the narrative.
Shaquille does not get it at all lmao.
Also, the father is still in the picture. He would probably use his ability to stop it. Additionally, the two still born kids probably were born and had the ability, but most likely killed themselves like he does in the director's cut.
Riley Courter Indeed, it put a conclusion on the father aspect but audiences wanted Evan to learn. It makes me think of the original ending to Fatal Attraction, where Michael Douglas's character is wrongly arrested for Glenn Close's murder.. As Close described it, it was a homage to film noire, but audiences wanted Douglas to actually defeat her.
I like the first one best. In the end, everyone gets a happy ending, just not the happy ending he wanted. Obviously, him being with her leads to some sort of tragic end for someone in their social so, him talking to her could risk the inevitable happening. And the suicide one would just ruin his mom after having failed so many times before.
That's exactly what I was thinking. She would chain smoke even more having three stillbirths. If I were him, I'd go for the ending where they walk past each other. He'll find someone else.
The suicide ending shows that his mom meets another man (who does not carry Evan's father "curse") and they have a baby girl, who is perfectly normal as her father is normal too.
Facundo Bazzi Yeah but, she still would of had to deal with another child lost during delivery.
The original ending (i.e. the first one) still gives me chills. Always loved this movie SO much, and the part where their adolescents definitely reminds me of my youth.
The year is 2022, and I just learned about these alternate endings.
This movie fucked me up for a while. The theatrical ending is the most tragic, in my opinion. It seemed like Fate was the reason they met on the street, and as if it was meant to be. No matter how hard the universe tried to keep them together, Evan-despite literally loving her with every ounce of his being-ignored her, and ignored his feelings. How is that not the best ending?
i agree w you, i like the theatrical ending the most too
@@petraleopold2713 bro can you explain me why in the first ending lenny dont remember keitligh. Like they just stop talking to each other as a kids. Thats it isnt it?
@@Magrodik every ending is different bcuz its in different universe, reality
@Happy Little Accidents with Jason Avery exactlyyy
The way he turns back to look just as she turns back away. So brilliant. Like Orpheus and Eurydice
I like the 3rd one the best because it's a lot more open to interpretation. Also it isn't a sad ending and it isn't a cheesy ending.
it was you all along....
the stalker ending, lol.
@@BearWindAppleyardthat’s your interpretation I guess. Mine is that he didn’t follow her, just tapped on her shoulder to talk
0:00 Theatrical Cut ending
3:27 Happy ending
4:25 Open ending
5:22 Director's Cut ending (sad, headcanon)
The director's cut us so dark. It's like the answer to the question "Would everything be better of if I never existed?".
I never knew this movie had so many alternative endings. I was talking about this movie just yesterday with a co-worker and he mentioned this ending and it blew my mind. Still shocking to see it exists.
the only part i found really stupid about this movie is how he stands right next to the mailbox when he knows its about to blow up, like what did he think would happen? Either way it is still one of my favorite movies.
Ill save you lady!
Name Required baby: WAAAHHHAAA
Im saying though!! That made me mad! Like save her but maybe step away from the mailbox?? 🙄
he acted like a moron with 0 IQ
What annoyed me was that everytime he made these mistakes he could go back to those moments and do it a little bit different.
Like why couldn't he go into an entry before they blew up the mailbox and just not do it.
And then after he kisses Kayleigh later on.
Instead of using any kind of blade he can just promise to Tommy that he won't see Kayleigh and then he can report Tommy to some form of police or see Kayleigh in secret.
And then for the whole "My dad never hit me, he saved it all for Tommy."
He could have just threatened the dad again except this time threatened the dad into not touching either of the kids.
I remember watching this as a kid and seeing the ending where he goes back and kills himself as a baby, but i tripped out cause rewatching it now that I’m 22 i got the ending where he lives i was LIKE WAIT WHAT?!
I've watched the Director's cut not knowing it was that when I was like 15 years old. And all this time it was a woah story and a depressing one but a movie that I will never forget. Then I rewatched it now, Im 25 and was shocked that there are a lot of endings and what I watched was the theatrical one. I was mind boggled but damn both are good endings and all are actually good
what can I say? Life is strange.
Ayyyy I got that.
never go back in time and fuck up things :V !!! LiS brought me here :3
I got the joke, i'm happy. x)
WeepingOdin
That was cringey as fuck. But I'll let it slide.
Bae over Bay right?
The best ending to this story is when Donnie decides to save everyone by going to his bedroom and allowing the turbine engine to kill him.
Fuck u😂
LMAO
“All around me are familiar faces...”
i just watch that before the butterfly effect AHHAAH
😂
Ending 3 is great. Way to make the main actor look like a stalker
he gave up on the soup or something.
I just re watched and i thought the mandela effect got me. I didn't know there was different endings 😂
The directors cut ending was the worst and most unrealistic. How would an unborn baby inside a mother be able to do that.
I felt the urge to respond to that for some reason. I like the directors cut ending the most although it's a bit strange how he would have killed himself. I tried to explain this to myself like this: every time his life changes, he still has all the memories, scars and skills from all the other lives. Like the new sex moves, the marks on his palms when looking like jesus. So it is possible that somehow he would be able to strangle himself to death because he already knows how to move his limbs. But one thing I can't explain is how he can actually die by being choked as a fetus. But otherwise, my favourite movie!!
oh okay so it actually is possible, i understand now. good everything worked out with you!
I
***** I did, slimey
***** I did, slimey
Theatrical ending is the jam. I LOVE this movie. No ending better than the way they released it. Perfect. And great song, too.
When the movie took a super dark turn when the dad started "making a movie".... this movie brought up the real life situations that are to real to accept they exist
first one is the best ending. powerful and heartbreaking at the same time.
The original ending has the most power imo, as it meant that for him to have a "normal" life without all the mayhem, he had to remove the one girl from his life he loved most. The directors cut wasn't bad, but just didn't match the film as naturally imo, as in all previous clips it had always been about being with Kaley.
The original (theatrical version) was the best. 2nd one would’ve been the best if they had just ended with them talking instead of a date
the real ending fits bc it means the other 3 brothers had the same thing happen to them. the theatrical ending isn't bad but deff doesn't fit with the palm reading and stillborn points.
@@Brain-washed2 the palm reading and stillborn stuff isn’t in the original version at all. So it fits in that version
@@dalkay yeah… bc they cut those parts out of the original story so it would be more palatable for theaters…
I think the one where he burns his journals is the better option mainly just because it shows that instead of just ending his life to "save" everyone else he manged to keep everyone sane and not hurt them. I think it is also just better because it is saying that he is giving up on going back in time to keep things from happening and it just going to start over.
The first ending...when he mumbled "goodbye", my tears burst out right away.
One of the best movies ever made.
According to me, the director's cut alternative ending (the one in hospital) is so much better. Let me explain why.
First, it gave us clear explanations about the stillbirths Evan's mother experienced : we can easily assume that all the children she had made the same choice than Evan. They went back in time too and made the ultimate sacrifice as well.
Second, the psychic Evan went to see with his mother told him that he had no lifeline, he was never meant to be : this scene makes more sense with the director's cut ending.
Eventually, Evan's brothers or sisters died before they born.
We can hope a movie about them, it would be a good idea and a good movie. At least, better than the movie 2 and 3 which were terrible to watch.
Except the psychic part was a deleted scene and so was her telling him about the stillbirths
The directors cut is the true end, like it or not. Plus it implies that the stillborns before him also did the same and the child born after will also do the same. It matches the overall darker tone of the film too so having a happy ending makes no sense and feels like a cop out
Connor Spencer Its going to make a loop his mom is going to be known as the women with 1000 stillborns
Connor Spencer It looks like it was a girl that was born after him. Maybe the gene for time traveling was in the boys, so the girl would live a normal life.
+Connor Spencer Exactly
+Connor Spencer correct but wrong at the end, after evan kills himself he is the last and only still born, notice that his mom has a new husband with a daughter, evans dad possessed the ability to rewrite his history but he`s gone now and his trait is only passed down to males in the family notice that evans mom has a healthy baby girl so this ends the never ending stillborns
+Connor Spencer the true ending most likely giving a neverending stillborn childs. So this is a logical explanation. It could be that the director made another ending is to stop the loop.
I never saw the Directors Cut Ending before, but as I saw it, my eyes were filled up with tears. The first ending was the one I've known and I thought, that one was dramatic but also impressing, because it showed that he learned from his mistakes and that he has another life now. But the Directors Cut Ending is much more dramatic and tragic. Especially the fact that his mother already lost 3 Babys before made me cry, because every unborn baby could have hsd the same problems as Evan had and decided to kill himself. I'm very confused right now and I don't know what to say.
This movie was the first real movie i loved. I was young and considered "weird" for watching it multiple times. I only had seen the first ending at that time. Few years later i saw the directors cut and was like damn wtf that's too sad. And just now (again, years later lol) i saw the coffee and stalker endings and as much as i lovee happy endings, i guess the BEST ending is still the theatrical. It shows that it just isn't meant to be sometimes no matter how hard you try to fix it (just like the theme of the movie). Well balanced. I'll always have a soft spot for this movie
one of the most criminally underrated movies ever made. it’s damn close to a masterpiece.
I don't get the movie, he could of made a better life for everyone but he just fucks up everytime. Like with the dynamite, just try not to make the dynamite roll up to the girl ! Or when they try to save the women and her child. Just don't go near the mailbox and yell to the lady to stay back ! I mean things like that. He just keep trying once on every scenario. That's what bugs me
The moral of the story is no human being can play god. You can't change one thing for the better without sacrificing another.
orichic51 That may be the best conclusion. There're many times I've asked myself "If I could go back to the past and change it, would it really better than now?". I think now I understand the title of the movie "The butterfly effect".
***** You know the butterfly effect is based of the principal that if you went back and for example killed a butterfly the present would be verry different then it should be. Thats why its called the BUTTERFLY effect. :P
Rionsic That's what the movie wants us to think about. It's hard to predict a small thing like a butterfly or even we killed a butterfly, there would be appearance of new effects: "the bird or rat effect" for example :D.
Rionsic Wrong.'' It has been said that something as small as the flutter of a butterfly's wing can ultimately cause a typhoon halfway around the world'' - Chaos Theory. That's why movie is called like that. He went back to change one little thing, but in the end there is no little things. Every action leads somewhere. I mean - title is from Chaos Theory, nothing to do with butterfly killing.
I watched this movie so many years ago and even today it still makes me cry and smile alot. I could say it's one of those few movies that makes stop for a moment and think about every decision you take. It has a very powerful message and either theatrical and director's cut ending leave you with many emotions at the heart.
I like the first one cause it show that he cares and doesn’t want to take the chance to screw up her life again as well as keep her safe.
The first one, theatrical cut has still always been my favorite, but at the same time the look on his face when he sees her always kills me. How much he wants to turn and go after her, but doesn't out of fear for it ruining their lives again.
The director's cut is by far the best one, it all makes sense that the other babies before him suicided too and shows how can someone sacrifice himself for a chance to make other's lives better.
So sad, but that is True Ending: 『Life is not always rosy』
Yea and she will never know he sacrifised himself for her.
It's a good ending but I think the theatrical ending suits the rest of the movie a little better
That Oasis song makes me ball my eyes out every time, part of me doesn't even want to listen to that song anymore because of this film haha. But this is my all time favourite film!
My favorite is the first. The fact they both looked back at different times kills me but it was for the best.
I saw the directors cut version but it ended differently than that, like just up until he strangled himself into more timeline explanation. It fit more than the version that was on this take.
Everytime I watch this movie it takes me back to a time when I had to tell a very special girl who really loved me that I did not love her, when I in fact did so very much, I was bad news back in those crazy days of my youth. I heard that now she is a Civil Engineer with an awesome family. Not a day goes by that I don't think of her. I am so glad I did not drag her down with me, I had to let her go....
yolo214 damn you just destroyed him like that? Merciless
I’m proud of u. Don’t know if an opinion of a random person means anything to u. I do hope so.
Life is all about those decisions that brings in good overall to others in this world. U brought something positive somewhere and created more positive ripples. In a larger scale u did really well.
I hope u appreciate that
Spiderman lol
The first ending was the best
Just saw the movie for the first time and I have to say I am impressed. Almost no movie ever had me thinking this much about everything. Incredible!
Crying your heart out made the 1st ending more powerful
Cmon, the first ending is boss no doubt. Evan should not have to fucking die
A baby killing itself in the womb is the most boss thing ever dude, come on. Erasing its own existence to give others a chance at a happier life is the most selfless act of love. Plus I figure Evan was pretty sick of life by that point, keep in mind he was around 20 years old but lived though several different timelines, retaining memories of all lives lived. I'm sure the ones where he had no arms or was butt-raped in prison didn't exactly leave a pleasant taste in his mouth, or anus. lol
I never knew about the first "theatrical ending"... I never saw it in theaters. Funny how this is all so possible. Who knows who we are in alternate universes. One split second, one visual, sound, taste could/has altered everything.
Not only possible but from what I understand about 'Parallel Realities/Timelines' that ALL of these outcomes can and will happen.
Since there are unlimited 'Realities' then there is an unlimited amount of outcomes....
If you can 'Think It' then it happens. We create our own realities.
Time is NOT linear. Time is the Eternal Now.
Linear Time is a 3rd Dimensional Construct.
Everything happens at the 'Same Time'.
Because we are all Quantum Beings and we are so much MORE than the 3D Vehicles (Bodies) that we reside within....
Our Spirit/Soul is vast. Much more than we realize...
Makes my brain hurt....LOL
OldDood
My brain just jizzed.
Still, Time should only flow in 1 way :D
The first ending is by far the best. It hits the nail right on the head. Having to make a sacrifice to allow her happiness and success
I agree. I think the suicide ending is a little too grim dark. Watching it made me laugh while the first ending felt balanced and tragic but not overly so.
the first ending is the one i saw
still my favorite )))
I'm another who saw the theatrical ending when it came out and have just seen the director's cut. It took me a bit by surprise as I didn't know there were alternate endings. I thought the theatrical ending was stronger. A concious move to save Kaley knowing he would never get to know the love of his life. A baby strangling itself in the womb is a bit far-fetched (even for a sci-fi movie).
Well it wasn't the baby's mind controlling that action though of course, it was adult Evan's mind behind the wheel just the same as it was when he took over other younger version's of himself. From that perspective it isn't far-fetched as it is in line with his ability.
I agree. The suicide ending is corny imo
The director's cut ending is the only one that makes sense in the story line. In the end, Evan realized a few things:
1. His time travelling to change the past can and will have unexpected consequences.
2. The root of the series of events ruining everyone's life is with Kayleigh's desire to stay with Evan and therefore not moving in with her mother.
4. Every time he tries to perfect everyone's life, he messes up. This accumulates in the penultimate timeline where he accidentally kills Kayleigh with the dynamite as he tries to prevent all the events from occurring.
3. He remembered the psychic and his talk with his father.
All the other endings neglect everything but point #2. For example: What if Kayleigh eventually got over the insult and ended up being Evan's friend anyways? What if the insult emotionally damaged Kayleigh in some way? What if, instead of Kayleigh/Tommy, some other kid ended up befriending Evan and suffering from his curse? What if Evan has kids eventually, giving them the curse? Evan, just like his father in the mental hospital, realized that the only way to prevent anything from going wrong was to completely remove himself from the situation and end his life.
Sure, many people don't like tragedy and prefer a story line dominated by sorrow to end happily. But to do so would completely contradict the philosophy of this movie, and it simply would not make sense with the character and story of Evan. After everything he went through, to try to meddle with other people's lives again would not have even crossed his mind. Just like he wanted to remove himself from everyone's life in the bathtub suicide scene when they were all happy in life, the only fix he would have been able to see would be to have never lived at all.
Agreed. Just because he forced her to go live with her mom doesnt change the fact that he still has that ability and can still pass it down. Thats why the directors cut is the best one and explains that his brothers probably went back to kill themselves as well.
tragedy happens regardless of what evan does. maybe if he is never born kayleigh gets hit by a car, etc. etc. anything could happen
See again when his killing himself and listen to his mother ''i was pregnant *3* times'' that say if Evan don't born,there's gonna be another one who can have the ''curse''
Fernando Rigoberto de las rosas de liniers not with the mom no. It was passed down from his dad and his dad going into the psych ward was supposed to end that effect leaving him as the last one, but it didnt.
That's right.But i heard the mother telling ''i was pregnant 3 times'' so the trouble there is: The third son was Jason's son too?
I’ve never seen this movie but that first ending is so damn powerful.
Jashawn Slater must watch movie
Kayleigh's father was the main reason they became who they were, for all those horrible things that happened to them. But being brought up by her mother with support and real love, they all grew up with good heads on their shoulders and made better choices. While I do think the theatrical ending made the most sense out of all of them, I do think they could have made it if they just met as well-adjusted, successful adults.
Amy Smart is so beautiful in some of these scenes.
The last ending aka the director's cut is the true ending, it explains why the physic said he is not meant to be he has no lifeline, explains the 3 stillborns that were with jasons and they did the same thing as he did, and thats why his father said when they visited him in the hospital "I was praying this curse would have ended with me, you can't play god son it must end with me", so the director's cut ending fits the movie perfectly.
+Filsoh The first time I've seen the DC was lastnight. And in any other version of the movie, the physic scene never happened. I agree that it did make everthing alot more interesting though. Still think the theatrical version is better nonetheless.
Absolutely. The happy theatrical ending is for the mindless movie-going droves who the studios thought needed a happy ending to like the movie. The director's true intent is what is seen in the director's cut.
@@neogeo8705 No it's not. Here's the director stating the Happy Sappy ending is the real one: ruclips.net/video/ygSY-PXFaSs/видео.html
Also, the "Happy Sappy" ending isn't that happy either, but also bittersweet, as Evan had to erase all of Kayleigh's memories of him upto that point.
What a lot of people are forgetting about the Director’s cut is that he was on the brink of time and it was his last change to save Kayleigh. If the birthing video was the first one to come up, he would have had to choose that one since he had no time to choose another. So maybe he didn’t kill himself thinking everybody would be better off, maybe he did it as it was the only thing he could do to save Kayleigh.
Part of me was expecting there to be a version where they meet each other in the crowd, she looks at him, and she tells him . . .
That she doesn't like him and if he ever comes near her again, she'll target him and everyone he loves . . . :3
Crazy story here, but I watched this movie for the first time when I was 10. I remembered little parts about it like when Evan made himself look like Jesus by stabbing his hands, and the mailbox blowing up. But I only just now found out what the movie was called. I watched it last night, and I have to say it was the most nostalgic experience of my life, lol. Great movie
The Directors Cut makes NO SENSE! First off it sends a message that killing yourself will make the lives of people around you much better. There are people who truly feel that way. It also says suicide is okay. Evan wasn't a quitter. Second the big thing Evan was trying to accomplish this whole movie was making EVERYONE he loved happy. That was his issue because he would go back in time and make one person happy, but another person would be left with a shitty ending causing him to continuously try to fix things. If he was a stillborn that would've destroyed his mom and she would've been a mess, maybe she would've started smoking and possibly get lung cancer like she did in one of his time travel episodes? With the Theatrical version. he makes everyones lives happier in a realistic way, but still has to deal with not being with Kayleigh which is difficult. Its the most realistic ending to the story in my opinion
noob
Vanessa Cunha I totally agree with you!
I know your post is 9 years old, but I just want to say that the most "Realistic" ending really is the Directors cut. As long as he exists, he and Kayleigh can get back together. Remember that child version of Evan has no idea the intentions of Adult Evan. In "Reality" what he did at the birthday can be explained away by the blackouts and he can make up with Kayleigh.
However.... if he dies... he can't ever see her again.
Just saying.
I remember my dad buying this when it first came out on dvd and we watched the directors cut I think I was around 9-10 and I remember thinking the ending was really sad but my dad explained it was the only way everyone turned out ok and it made me feel a bit better I still like the directors cut ending but the other endings would’ve probably been easier to watch as a kid lol
Never knew this movie had multiple endings. I saw the director's cut one (when he chokes himself in the womb). The most tragic yet the one who makes most sense to me.