The Trinity Explained and Defended

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 216

  • @dwong9289
    @dwong9289 24 дня назад +101

    There is no “logical problem” with the Most Holy Trinity. Great collabing with you!

    • @Scholasticae
      @Scholasticae 24 дня назад +3

      Great job!

    • @dwong9289
      @dwong9289 24 дня назад +1

      @@Scholasticae

    • @Thomas.apologia
      @Thomas.apologia 24 дня назад +11

      Common trinitarian W

    • @MatthewMcRowan
      @MatthewMcRowan 24 дня назад +2

      hi, one tiny suggestion - if you might cite the sources a little bit slower it could help non-native speakers to grasp the thought. God bless

    • @_archangel333
      @_archangel333 24 дня назад +2

      I converted to the Roman catholicism from orthodoxy because of you and your videos! thank you for your help finding the true church.

  • @Scholasticae
    @Scholasticae 24 дня назад +38

    This was one of the greatest Explanations & defenses I’ve seen! Great collab

  • @MatthewMcRowan
    @MatthewMcRowan 24 дня назад +17

    complex ontological concepts are easy to attack from the angle of ignorance

  • @Wuschi2001
    @Wuschi2001 24 дня назад +11

    Hey Brother. I just started my Theology Study in the university. Thank you for you influence.

  • @giovanibenjamin9655
    @giovanibenjamin9655 24 дня назад +10

    This was awesome, the collabs are just beyond exceptional. God bless you brother 🙏🏾

  • @SPIRIT2019
    @SPIRIT2019 24 дня назад +11

    This is a good explanation of the Holy Trinity! However, I wish you defined the term "Person" (even though I already know myself) so that other people can understand the proper meaning.

    • @SanctusApologetics
      @SanctusApologetics  24 дня назад +8

      @@SPIRIT2019 That will be explained more so in a Christology video to come.

  • @beetlejuicewastaken
    @beetlejuicewastaken 23 дня назад +14

    Gloria Patri, et Filio, et Spiritui Sancto, sicut erat in principio, et nunc, et semper, et in saecula saeculorum. Amen.

  • @mokoloko-b1p
    @mokoloko-b1p 24 дня назад +9

    Sanctus you are a W bro.

  • @MrDaftFunk
    @MrDaftFunk 23 дня назад +3

    Trinity is our shield against the evil one.

  • @Thomas.apologia
    @Thomas.apologia 24 дня назад +4

    Great video bro! God bless🙏🏻

  • @rachelbenoit1350
    @rachelbenoit1350 23 дня назад +1

    Your channel is a true blessing! May the Lord Jesus Christ bless and keep you and continue to strengthen these brilliant defences of our faith ✝️🙏

  • @rileypare7946
    @rileypare7946 23 дня назад +2

    Glad I could offer the (little) help I could! (It's bernardo)

  • @cesarerinaldi6750
    @cesarerinaldi6750 6 дней назад +1

    🟠
    Dante's Divine Comedy.
    The Nine Heavens, the Three Archangels and the Two Saints of Paradise:
    I Temperance, II Prudence and III Peace Saint Raphael, IV Wisdom, V Fortitude and VI Justice Saint Gabriel, VII Faith Saint Michael, VIII Hope Saint Joseph, IX Charity Saint Mary.

  • @TheSanctification73
    @TheSanctification73 24 дня назад +3

    Can't wait to watch this🙏

  • @henriquelopes2343
    @henriquelopes2343 24 дня назад +1

    Great video! Greetings from Portugal

  • @dynamic9016
    @dynamic9016 24 дня назад +1

    Really appreciate this video.

  • @JustaRandomCatholic
    @JustaRandomCatholic 24 дня назад +1

    WE DOING THE SIGH OF THE CROSS WITH THIS ONE 🗣🗣🗣🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @AirBunny-
    @AirBunny- 22 дня назад +1

    5:30 really helped me understand great video God bless ✝️☦️

    • @thetrinitybusters
      @thetrinitybusters 21 день назад

      But which Bible verses did the explanation agree with?

    • @AirBunny-
      @AirBunny- 21 день назад

      @ the entire Bible

    • @AirBunny-
      @AirBunny- 20 дней назад

      @ like verses about the trinity ?

    • @thetrinitybusters
      @thetrinitybusters 20 дней назад

      @@AirBunny- Can you give me some examples?

    • @AirBunny-
      @AirBunny- 20 дней назад

      @@thetrinitybusters ok gotchu, the ones that come to mind are in Genesis when God says let us make man in our image and then also Genesis 19:24 where God is on earth but then also God is in the heavens. Also just Jesus’ divinity but also the fact that he talks of God the Father, like he who has seen Me has seen the Father or if they reject me they reject the one who sent me.

  • @wilsontheconqueror8101
    @wilsontheconqueror8101 10 дней назад

    It very clearly states in Genesis "Let US make man in OUR image". It was there from the beginning. ✝️ Praise be to the one true God,Christ is Lord!

  • @DrWolves
    @DrWolves 24 дня назад +1

    Well made video. Great content and thoroughly explained. Although I do not agree 😅 still well made.

  • @aaronhesse-u9s
    @aaronhesse-u9s 24 дня назад +2

    LETS GOOOOO A NEW VIDEO

  • @richardwatterstan
    @richardwatterstan 23 дня назад +2

    D W O N G

  • @guilherme-paini
    @guilherme-paini 23 дня назад +2

    Excellent.

  • @mikeharris2650
    @mikeharris2650 22 дня назад

    The more words I hear spoken about the trinity, the more convinced I am of my "heresy".
    I shall continue to pray to be led to the truth.

    • @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22
      @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 8 дней назад

      Peace be with you Friend ❤️
      What do you mean "I am of my "Heresy""?

    • @mikeharris2650
      @mikeharris2650 8 дней назад

      @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 meaning I dont find the concept of trinity particularly helpful.
      It devides my attention, causes me confusion, it's a stumbling block, I always walked around it.
      Perhaps I am missing something?

    • @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22
      @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 8 дней назад

      It's Ok if you don't get it immediately.
      Since we are talking about God, it is difficult to Comprehend Him(Romans 11:33-36), it's why we have Faith in Him, because we know he is True & is Love(1 John 4:7-10).
      We don't rely on our own Understanding, rather, we Acknowledge & Trust him for who he is, & Follow Him, & He Leads us
      (Proverbs 3:5-7).
      When the time is Right, You may get it, & even now, I can't fully Comprehend Him, but we will in the Future, in the New Heaven & Earth, when we dwell with Him
      (John 16:25/ 1 Corinthians 13:8-13/Revelation 21-22) ❤️✝️🕊️.

    • @mikeharris2650
      @mikeharris2650 7 дней назад

      I left the church in my first decade due to lack of answers. I'm 46 now.
      I do rely on my understanding rather than belief. What I dont understand is uncertain to me, what I do understand is where I put my trust.
      My current understanding of the trinity is that it's some sort of work around to compensate for a limited human understanding.
      I try to always be open to having my own understanding improved. ❤🙏

  • @bikesrcool_1958
    @bikesrcool_1958 24 дня назад +5

    The Trinity is the fullness of our God. Rejoice our God is one! Father, son, and Holy Spirit.
    Muslims don’t have the fullness of God so they reject it. Christian’s may have a spectrum of understanding but we know it’s revealed in scripture and tradition both of which reveal God.
    ✝️✝️✝️✝️✝️✝️✝️💪🏻💪🏻✝️💪🏻✝️✝️✝️

  • @nervouskrystof
    @nervouskrystof 13 дней назад

    Hey sanctus, I just wanted to ask what is your view/position on evolution

  • @thisis_chavez
    @thisis_chavez 23 дня назад +1

    Most Holy Trinity-Father, Son and Holy Spirit-I adore Thee profoundly. I offer Thee the most precious Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus Christ, present in all the tabernacles of the world, in reparation for the outrages, sacrileges, and indifferences whereby He is offended. And through the infinite merits of His Most Sacred Heart and the Immaculate Heart of Mary, I beg of Thee the conversion of poor sinners. Amen

  • @CriticalThomist
    @CriticalThomist 24 дня назад +12

    Let him cook

  • @RawSan98
    @RawSan98 24 дня назад +3

    Common Sanctus W

  • @exoticbutters1025
    @exoticbutters1025 24 дня назад +2

    Waiting for Alonzo Harris

  • @ParadoxOfDivinity
    @ParadoxOfDivinity 20 дней назад

    What software do you use to make your videos

  • @janrudnicki6111
    @janrudnicki6111 24 дня назад +1

    Very good

  • @Triniforchrist
    @Triniforchrist 24 дня назад +3

    Catholic W ❤

  • @JScholastic
    @JScholastic 24 дня назад +1

    Nice ❤

  • @Meatyyyy
    @Meatyyyy 24 дня назад +1

    Random question, does the catholic church consider oriental orthodox church sacraments valid? So would i have to be rebaptized if i wanna convert to catholic?

    • @dwong9289
      @dwong9289 23 дня назад

      @@Meatyyyy you do not need to be rebaptized. You would just have to go through OCIA

    • @Meatyyyy
      @Meatyyyy 23 дня назад

      @@dwong9289 thank you

    • @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22
      @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 8 дней назад

      Peace be with you Friend ❤️
      Just be careful in the Catholic church, & have Faith in Christ, & learn through The Father's Word
      (John 17:17).

  • @AquinoTheCatholic
    @AquinoTheCatholic 24 дня назад +6

    W video!!!

  • @legendsplayground7017
    @legendsplayground7017 12 дней назад

    brother can you explain Aristotle's view on relation... honestly i'm new to this, i couldn't understand most of the stuff cover here, but good news i can understand de ente better :))))

  • @douganceK
    @douganceK 9 дней назад

    This is the 2nd video I’ve seen from you, the first being st John of Damascus, on Islam. He didn’t share this Filioque view of the Holy Trinity, but instead the Capadocian Fathers which is the theology of the 2nd ecumenical council.

  • @JimSneeder
    @JimSneeder 24 дня назад +2

    Real.

  • @TheLastOutlaw-KTS
    @TheLastOutlaw-KTS 23 дня назад

    Prepare for trouble….and make it

  • @captainmorgan757
    @captainmorgan757 24 дня назад +2

    "The Father is not the Son. The Son is not the Holy Ghost. The Holy Ghost is not the Father. "
    Pair that with what Jesus said to Philip, "He who sees Me sees the Father. The Father and I are one."
    Talk about confusing!

    • @matts-7566
      @matts-7566 24 дня назад

      former are explaining Person's distinctions (John 6:38), the latter (John 10:30) are explaining about Essence.
      clearly you were not opening your ears since the early mins, this level of ignorance will not debunk Trinity, only to makes you looks comical. been happened for centuries!

    • @PUNISHERMHS_2021
      @PUNISHERMHS_2021 23 дня назад +1

      ​@@matts-7566 I don't think they were trying to debunk The Trinity

    • @mamamia601
      @mamamia601 22 дня назад

      They are one in essence and nature, not in personhood.

  • @uros2623
    @uros2623 21 день назад

    The Holy Trinity isn't illogical, the burden of proof is on unitarians and muslims who claim so. If God is unitarian what was there for him to love before he made everything, love is necessarily expresed between 2 or more people?

  • @Isac708
    @Isac708 18 дней назад

    Yo i got a question,
    What does it mean that the Father and the Son are the Divine Essence, and what does it mean they are materially identical to the Divine Essence?

    • @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22
      @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 8 дней назад +1

      Peace be with you Friend ❤️
      The phrase “Essence of God” is a theological term used to refer to God's personal characteristics, or to the facets of His personality.

    • @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22
      @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 8 дней назад

      In other words, they are One God, because they are of the Same Divine Essence. God is One Essence that Exists in 3 Persons.

    • @Isac708
      @Isac708 8 дней назад

      @@Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 Oh ok, thanks a lot brother ❤️

  • @glass-floor
    @glass-floor 22 дня назад

    There is no logical problem of the Trinity because the doctrine is based in faith, not reason. If the Trinity is the true nature of God, then the strange reasoning of a medieval philosopher does not change that truth. Nobody can prove the Trinity any more than they cán prove the existence of God. It is a question of faith.

  • @PedroCosta-di8tz
    @PedroCosta-di8tz 23 дня назад

    Can I substitute the conception of son to the conception of mother, explaining the same concept given, but foccusing on the passive nature of filiation to the feminine nature and the active nature of action and intelligence in the figure of father? In that scenario, the son can´t be the Holy Spirit? If no, why not?

  • @sulongenjop7436
    @sulongenjop7436 21 день назад

    Trinity is similar to the unity of a human in the Body, Soul and Spirit. God is in the unity of the Father, Son and Hy Spirit!

  • @alexpontecorvi3092
    @alexpontecorvi3092 16 дней назад

    Damn bro. I have to buy my self the summa teologia to understand what this stuff actually meana

  • @infiniti28160
    @infiniti28160 22 дня назад

    i just use this verse against those that deny it. Isaiah 63:10

    • @thetrinitybusters
      @thetrinitybusters 21 день назад

      Which holy spirit? The one that could not come while Jesus was on earth? Or another one?

    • @infiniti28160
      @infiniti28160 21 день назад

      @@thetrinitybusters With wisdom, the light was sent to spread the word, John 8:12 of that which was the first and last for all those wanting redemption from the killing of the lamb at the creation of the world. The serpent indebted both Adam and Eve, not for mankinds benefit, but for the exaltation of the serpent itself. It has now become a dragon, that gives power to that which is dust, as in the flesh of man, usurping the spiritual light. That is the power of the holy spirit which hovered above the waters of the unformed earth. Genesis 1:2-3
      Genesis 3:15
      You are but a hired man, sent by the usurper, the angel, king of the abyss, to dust you will return
      Gabrielle Aplin - The Power of Love

    • @infiniti28160
      @infiniti28160 21 день назад

      @@thetrinitybusters Genesis 18-19 will show YHWH and two angels becoming flesh and having a meal, it will also show, YHWH while on earth communicting with YHWH in heaven.
      Genesis 18:10 will show that YHWH seeded Sarah with child that became Isaac, which is known as the promise.
      Zechariah 9:9-11 will show the coming of the Lord himself to free the bondage they have been placed under during the first covenant.
      Luke 1: 33- 34 Mary was seeded by YHWH through the holy spirit.
      If you can explain this complexity i would be happy to read about it. otherwise Matthew 4:10
      Isaiah 44:6
      Tony Martin Trio : Who Knows (Jimi Hendrix) cover

    • @thetrinitybusters
      @thetrinitybusters 20 дней назад

      @@infiniti28160 You still dodged explaining why the Comforter could not come until Jesus had left.

    • @thetrinitybusters
      @thetrinitybusters 20 дней назад

      @@infiniti28160 Read Genesis 19:13 and weep.

  • @legendsplayground7017
    @legendsplayground7017 12 дней назад

    as far as i understand, the de ente argument shows that the nature of God is just to be, God's essence cannot include anything stand in potency to act, that's absurd, but then how is begetting a son is part of God's nature? am i understand it wrongly? or how could we go from a being whose essence is to exist to begetting a son and it really is a person? i don't get it :(((

    • @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22
      @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 8 дней назад +1

      Peace be with you Friend ❤️
      Because the Son was Begotten, Not made, Everlastingly & by Necessity. In such a way that the Essence is Not divided.

  • @aceofconquest5745
    @aceofconquest5745 24 дня назад

    The Persons of The Trinity are one physically but different mentally?
    God's thoughts generate things into being, so God thinking of Himself generates The Son and The Will of doing so is The Spirit? And since all Three are God, all have always been since God cannot have been created. And since God cannot be made up of parts but is wholly one all three have always been?

    • @JScholastic
      @JScholastic 24 дня назад +1

      No, the persons are one in an absolute sense via their divine nature but distinct relatively via their relations that subsist in the essence via relative opposition opposition.

    • @johanr4076
      @johanr4076 18 дней назад +1

      The Holy Trinity has only one Divine Mind, not three.

  • @thetrinitybusters
    @thetrinitybusters 21 день назад +1

    I would love someone to explain why Jesus is half naked in these pictures. A high priest is supposed to wear decent clothes. Also sometimes the Father is bald, which makes no sense according to Leviticus.

  • @tonywang7601
    @tonywang7601 21 день назад

    Didn't you just show how the Trinity can be found by natural theology though? Starting from a generic 'supreme being' or Actus Purus who has an intellect and will, you showed through reason alone that there must be 2 persons which differ esse ad, generated through self-intellection and loving will, and a 3rd person who is the principle which is ungenerated but generates the other persons.

    • @johanr4076
      @johanr4076 18 дней назад

      @tonywang7601 No. If reason or philosophy alone were to be used to describe the Pure Act, then it would be discovered that His knowledge of Himself is not self-reflexive.
      For reference, read Summa Theologiae prima pars, question 14, most especially its Article 2’s first objection, then read “I answer that…”, and the Reply to the first objection.

  • @issaavedra
    @issaavedra 24 дня назад +1

    Ok, but how do you go from "the Three Persons have the same Essence" to "the Three Persons are identical to the Essence"

    • @dwong9289
      @dwong9289 23 дня назад +1

      Divine simplicity says whatever is in God is God, as He is not composed of substance and accident, form and matter, universal and particular, essence and existence, etc.

    • @rileyGTG
      @rileyGTG 23 дня назад

      @@dwong9289so the Holy Spirit can be considered an attribute based on this neo platonic logic. But confusing the persons for attributes isn’t anything new since st Augustine states that for god to be an attribute is the same for god to be a person
      And if everything in god Is materially (really) identical to the essence, and the essence is unknown; then now we can’t know god

    • @dwong9289
      @dwong9289 23 дня назад

      @@rileyGTG no, that doesn’t follow at all

    • @rileyGTG
      @rileyGTG 23 дня назад

      @@dwong9289 why not?

    • @rileyGTG
      @rileyGTG 23 дня назад

      @@dwong9289 if the active spiration of the spirit is the love that comes from the will of the father and son, then the Holy Spirit is confused with an attribute

  • @frederickanderson1860
    @frederickanderson1860 24 дня назад

    Isaiah chapter 55:8-9. Enough of trying to explain in theological assumptions and terms. In Isaiah his WAY S are not understood. Focusing on like the people of Moses time made no difference to their lack of understanding of God ways. Jesus miracles and parables did not change their lack of God ways or actions. This verse that l have given in Isaiah just makes posts like these as the wisdom of mortals that he finds foolishness. I totally agree.

  • @m3rcked903
    @m3rcked903 20 дней назад

    Erm did u read deuteronomy 6:4 bduy

    • @Isac708
      @Isac708 18 дней назад +1

      “Hear O Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord is ONE (Echad)
      Erm, do you know what the word “Echad” can refer to? It can refer to multiple entities who form a unity like in Genesis 2, here we see the word “Echad” is being used to refer to the unity of the male and the female”
      “And they shall be one (Echad) flesh.”
      So the word “One” or Echad can refer to multiple entities who form a unity.

    • @apsinthos5439
      @apsinthos5439 11 дней назад

      “Hear O Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord is ONE"
      This "one" is english translation from the word hebrew,"echad", which in Bahasa Indonesia is "esa", which derived from ancient language Sansekerta / Pali word "etad" meaning "wholly one".
      Our Indonesian bible use the word "esa" instead of "one"

  • @pmac_
    @pmac_ 22 дня назад +1

    This whole content is *not even a discussion about scripture* . It is all about man trying to explain to himself who he thinks God is.

  • @gravitas3900
    @gravitas3900 23 дня назад

    Trinity seems to be added to religion years later after him. i do not think Jesus explained and generated this concept etc. search for originals not artificials

    • @dwong9289
      @dwong9289 23 дня назад +3

      @@gravitas3900 He clearly teaches it in the New Testament.

    • @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22
      @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 8 дней назад

      Peace be with you Friend ❤️
      In Matthew 3:16-17; all 3 Members of the Trinity are Seen & all 3 Members of the Trinity are referred to as God in their Verses:
      The Father,(Galatians 1:1)
      The Son,(Hebrews 1:8)
      and the Holy Spirit(Acts 5:3-4)

    • @gravitas3900
      @gravitas3900 8 дней назад

      @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 the books all are mouth wording not originals, there is not any book or relic just written by a prophet, all are transferred and modified by the time.

  • @fcastellanos57
    @fcastellanos57 21 день назад

    The Trinity model of who God is falls down of its own weight. All we have to do is know the definition of one of God’s attributes given by the apostles specifically the apostle Paul. This is what Paul writes in 1 Timothy 6:16 “ who alone has immortality, who dwells in unapproachable light, whom no one has ever seen or can see.”, This statement in reference to the Father, who is the only True God according to Jesus in John 17:3, tell us that God alone is immortal which should suffice to conclude that Jesus is not God because he died. If the rebuttal is that the body of Jesus died, then the question is, What was conceived in Mary and what was born of Mary the body of Jesus or Jesus? The answer is Jesus of course. Also, we can’t ignore the scriptures specially Genesis 2, where Adam was made from the ground and compare him with Jesus who was made in the womb of a woman. Adam was then given a spirit (breath of life), it is to note that Adam is NOT the spirit given from God, and also Jesus received a spirit from God just like Adam did, that spirit is not a person, Jesus received the Spirit of God later at his baptism. Jesus is purely human, therefore the Trinity is false. Jesus is the son of the Most High, and the Spirit is the Spirit of the Most High, his manifested power, not another person, the Trinity is completely a human made up construct.

    • @ALavin-en1kr
      @ALavin-en1kr 21 день назад

      Wrong! A human can be a businessman, a golfer, a father, but God can be only one thing? The Trinity: The Father: Supreme Consciousness: The Transcendent God; beyond creation. The Son: Christ Consciousness; God Consciousness in Creation; in humanity. The Holy Spirt or Holy Ghost: The Word; The Vibration or Motion that structures and maintains creation, or what is manifest.
      Chinese philosophy has it that nothing happens without Three and it is the case. No, the elements or matter did not create the universe(s). Consciousness; Mind: Elements. The first is fundamental to reality, the latter two are elemental emerging with quantum events. The Mind a subtler elemental than the macro elements of space and the micro elements of quantum space.
      The definition of religion is that to which we are bound which is reality; one and the same. And no, life did not start in a muddy pond somewhere. Darwinism is a worm’s eye view of reality. Religion is a bird’s eye view of reality. At the cusp of a quantum age only the bird’s eye view makes sense.
      In addition with communism defeated the next atheistic ideology is trans humanism. Religion will be a bulwark against it as it was against the Dark Occult on the rise from the Dark Age to The Age of Reason.
      No, our minds are not for sale to the latest atheistic ideology we will stay with what is fundamental to life and reality and has been in all cultures over time; even the most primitive. NO to trans humanism.
      Consciousness is ‘the hard problem’ for atheistic philosophy. They will have to make a major paradigm shift in consciousness and mental perspective before they can figure it out. My bet is it will remain ‘the hard problem’ for them. They can analyze the elemental what is fundamental cannot be analyzed as it predates the mind.

    • @ALavin-en1kr
      @ALavin-en1kr 21 день назад

      If Christians cannot, or do not understand, the Trinity, then their clergy is not doing their job. It is necessary to see and understand God in all manifestations. Transcendent; Immanent in Creation; and the Force that began, sustains, and eventually will withdraw creation. Father; Son, Holy Ghost.

    • @fcastellanos57
      @fcastellanos57 21 день назад

      @ So your understanding of who God is comes from Chinese philosophers? I use the Bible and the words of Jesus to get this information. Human philosophy is from our imagination which does not reflect reality. God from the Torah is ONE being not three in one. Words nowadays have lost their meaning. Check out Deuteronomy 6:4-15, the LORD our God is ONE, not three. Jesus made this clear talking to an scribe. Isaiah 44:24 says “ I am Yahweh, who makes all things, who alone stretched out the heavens, who spread out the earth by myself”. Isaiah 45:12 “ I have made the earth, and created man on it, I, even my hands, have stretched the heavens”, first person singular pronoun, very simple. God also calls himself “ I am the existing one”, So stop with these human philosophy which distorts who God is, use the Bible and not empty philosophies.

    • @fcastellanos57
      @fcastellanos57 21 день назад

      @ Why we do not understand the Trinity? Because is incoherent, absurd, and does not conform with the teachings of the Bible. God can manifest his presence in fire, lightning, thunder but it does not mean that He changes his nature and becomes whatever He wants. Jesus said God is Spirit, John 4:24, and James says that God never changes James 1:17, also in 1 Timothy 6:16, God, who is the Father of Jesus, alone has immortality and shares this with those who come to Him in faith by means of His Spirit in us. God is ONE, YHWH, OR YAWEH, not a substance made of three persons, including one who died when we know that God cannot die, read your Bible and stay away from human philosophy.

    • @ALavin-en1kr
      @ALavin-en1kr 21 день назад

      @
      Yes God is One, and all things in Creation are in His Mind. The Old Testament is about God in the sky, who punished humans just because he could, that was how it was, except to the prophets who were all killed as they saw it otherwise. The New Testament is about God as Omnipresent, being everywhere. As how could He be Omnipresent and not be everywhere?” That is why it is ‘not an Eye for an Eye or a Tooth for a Tooth anymore but LOVE your neighbor as yourself.
      The Dark Age is over, time to move on. Otherwise, as we sow we reap and if we live by the sword we perish by the sword, and what happens bears this out. Extend an olive branch at least, that would help. We are still in the age of Pisces, whose symbols are the Fish and the Virgin. Pisces and Virgo. The fish became a symbol and Christ was seen as a fisher of men.
      The Age of Aries the Ram (Aggression)and the Scales of Justice (the law) has pasted. Now it is about the spirit of the law, not just the outer rituals of the law. Hands were ritually washed and that is a good thing today as well. Wine was drunk as the water was polluted.
      Every age has its own religion according to what sign it is under The Egyptians had theirs and so had the Sumerians and all others before. There are those who fall behind and do not enter the new age and there will likely be Christians who fall behind even though Christianity is not just about what is out there; but also a transcendent God who is also within; consciousness; Christ consciousness. Its real meaning is apparent to some while others worship symbolically.
      There are many who observe the rituals but do not get it and Consciousness is ‘the hard problem’ for atheistic philosophy today. No harm in mentioning that, as it is relevant. There are Christians who live more by the Old Testament than the New Testament because they prefer to and Christ’s message goes totally over their heads.
      They do not understand that ‘A New Jerusalem” refers to a broader state of consciousness, symbolically, not to a physical New Jerusalem where Christ will appear again. His message and its application to their own consciousness and in their lives are missing.
      The Second Coming is not about their conversion to better behavior but to a Second Coming in ‘a new Jerusalem where the physical Jerusalem is’ and that through faith alone they will be saved. The Church has said ‘Faith without works is dead.’ And it is the case, be a Sunday preacher and an adulterer on other days, that is not how it works. Again, ‘faith without works is dead.’
      Christ said ye are gods with the potential to relate to the Supreme God; the Father. The prophets saw that, and they were all put to death, to the ignorant it is heresy and much has not changed today, unfortunately.

  • @NailTouze-l2k
    @NailTouze-l2k 24 дня назад

    Can you make a Video about the Omnipresent God.
    I know God can do all things

  • @proseyootoob
    @proseyootoob 5 дней назад

    Rom 10 9 a Christian believes that Jesus is the risen son of God and this our salvation through faith. nowhere in that formulation are we required to believe that - in any sense - Jesus is the same person as God.
    I can find a verse that "proves" that Peter was satan, and i would "defend" that "doctrine" successfully using that one verse!!! (you know which one(s)). but we don't make prudent doctrine on 1 or 12 verses, we make it using the whole bible.
    God always called Jesus his son, and Jesus always called God "Father." God and Jesus are not trinitarians. God does not believe that he was incarnated as Jesus.
    dual nature, incarnation, God the Son: none of these phrases are in the Bible
    For Jesus' death to have been possible (gods don't die) and meaningful, Jesus had to be a man.
    When Jesus ascended, God made Jesus a god and now Jesus sits at the right hand of God. Jesus does not sit at his own right hand. Also note that there is not a third throne to God's left because the Holy Spirit is not personally separable from God any more than you are from your soul. We may have no other gods before God (which trinitarians violate, using their three headed triangle god that became its own son), but there can be other gods (psalm 81), we can have other gods (Jesus), but none before God.
    there may be some verses which, if read a certain way, can be read to support trinity theory. there are thousands of verses which permit no other reasonable interpretation other than to prohibit trinity theory.
    God is one. One means one. Son means son. Father means father. words have meanings, and trinitarians simply do not care.

    • @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22
      @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 4 дня назад

      Peace be with you Friend ❤️
      Because Jesus is The Son of God, he is God. Not God the Father, but the Son. The Word was with God & was God & the Word came in the Flesh(John 1:1,14).

    • @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22
      @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 4 дня назад

      In John 1:18, the Greek Word "Μονογενής/Monogene"(for Only Begotten) is used to claim that Jesus is Unique from all the others sons of God, because he has the Same Essence as God the Father.

    • @proseyootoob
      @proseyootoob 4 дня назад

      @ there is no such thing as “God the son” or “God the Holy Sprit”
      You three headed triangle god worshippers made that up

    • @proseyootoob
      @proseyootoob 4 дня назад

      @ “Essence” doesn’t have a definition
      Use words that are in the Bible and have definitions

    • @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22
      @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 4 дня назад

      @proseyootoob
      We didn't, the Doctrine of it Exists in the Bible. The Words were made out of that Doctrine.
      For Example; God the Son means "Christ regarded as the second person of the Trinity; God as incarnate and resurrected saviour."
      Jesus is definitely God as Incarnated
      (John 1:1,14). & He definitely is the Resurrected Saviour(Matthew 28:6).
      So, God the Son is Biblical ❤️✝️.
      Something's essence tells us what it is at the most fundamental level.
      The phrase “Essence of God” is a theological term used to refer to God's personal characteristics, or to the facets of His personality.

  • @josephgelwix6788
    @josephgelwix6788 24 дня назад

    I am a Christian who does not believe in the trinity. Before anyone attacks me I’d ask you consider a few things, and I am happy to hear more people’s explanation of the trinity if perhaps I have misunderstood!
    1. I find the argument of essence to be non-specific and therefore not substantive for defending the doctrine of the trinity. ie, seems to me like the concept of the trinity was created and then various arguments formed after the fact in an attempt to explain a confusing doctrine. Arguments such as one being and three persons or sharing divine essence.
    2. This is admittedly a tired argument against the trinity, but I find it more compelling nonetheless. There are a myriad of interactions between the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit recorded in the scriptures which suggest to me that each exercises His own agency as an independent being, although all unified with each other.
    3. The vision of Stephen during his martyrdom at the end of Acts 7 I just can’t reconcile with the trinity. He saw specifically God, and Jesus standing at the right hand of God. Anthropomorphized, separate beings.
    4. In my opinion, this course of my study is the principle point which made me question the trinity. The trinity rests upon the idea that God is “one.” But what if “one” was misinterpreted by the early councils? True, in scripture God is described as one, but never specifically as one being. To understand “one,” I look to Genesis 2:24. A man and his wife become “one” flesh. Does this mean that husband and wife become one being? I personally don’t think so. But a person could argue that here, “one” is being used in a different context than it is as describes God. Fair enough. When offering His intercessory prayer (John 17), Jesus used it in a very illuminating way. Specifically, verses 11 and 20-23. Here, He prays not only for His apostles but all who believe in Him. And, He prays that they may be one with Him and He specifies that He is using the word “one” in precisely the same way that He and the Father are one. So if to be one means to be the same being, then there is no trinity at all but a billionity. It seems apparent to me that to be one means to be one in unity and purpose. With this in mind, reading the New Testament it starts to be clear. Jesus constantly emphasized that He was submitting to the will of the Father. It is His obedience to the Father that makes Him one with the Father (who, by the way, Jesus Himself refuted being coequal with in John 14:28).
    I genuinely do not intend to attack the faith of any who adhere to the trinity, simply presenting my belief on it. I recognize there is so much resistance to arguments against the trinity, because so much of Christianity has been built off this and it raises other theological questions. I invite any additional considerations you may think are important! In the end, Christ is our Lord and Savior and I love Him with all my heart. Great video, I really appreciate learning more about the trinity so I thank you.

    • @halfwaydead3087
      @halfwaydead3087 24 дня назад +1

      @Sanctus

    • @Akhgy
      @Akhgy 22 дня назад +1

      I would place my arguments to show your misunderstanding but I am actually n tired of explaining.
      So this is Short.
      - what Stephen Say is The Glorified Christ at the Right Hand of the Father.
      Remember it says the Word because flesh, the Person of the Son became incarnate.
      The Divine Word and Divine Spirit are Of the One God the Father.
      - the Word of God as Scripture says is Begotten of The Father as it Is the One that is the expression of the Father ( the one that reveals him to creation and the One by Whom all things are created)
      Some Called the Holy Spirit the Energy preceding from a the Father or according to the Faith the Life Giver
      So It’s Like This Formulation.
      The Father Creates by His Word through his Spirit… I am in no way Talking about the Active spoken word but the Divine Word which is said To be The Power, The Wisdom, and Expression of the Father.

    • @mamamia601
      @mamamia601 22 дня назад

      There is no such thing as a Christian who doesn't believe in the Trinity. It's like a married bachelor or a square circle. If you actively object to the Trinity as a fact of faith, then you're not a Christian.

    • @thetrinitybusters
      @thetrinitybusters 21 день назад

      @@mamamia601 Says who?

    • @josephgelwix6788
      @josephgelwix6788 21 день назад

      @ thanks for the response! So my question would be what does it mean to be one? What do you make of John 17 and in what way are believers in Christ one with Him and the Father?

  • @marcokite
    @marcokite 24 дня назад +5

    The filioque is heresy.

  • @NadjibSamsung
    @NadjibSamsung 11 дней назад

    Okey So it's our problem that your doctrine is illogical and it doesn't make a freaking sense 😂 what's even funny is jesus never preached this doctrine, the prophets of the old testament never preached it as well. If the trinity was the truth we would have to see it everywhere in the old testament but it's just something the early fathers pulled from their asses in the council of nicaea. Nice try but you will never convince people that this doctrine makes any freaking sense

    • @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22
      @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 8 дней назад +1

      Peace be with you Friend ❤️
      Both Old & New Testament shows the Doctrine of the Trinity.
      It is More apperant in the New Testament, but there is Hint of it in OT.

    • @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22
      @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 8 дней назад

      One God that exists in three Persons:
      Father
      (Genesis 1:1/Galatians 1:1)
      Son,
      (Genesis 31:11‭-‬13‬/Hebrews 1:8)
      and the Holy Spirit
      (Genesis 1:2/Acts 5:3-4)
      ❤️✝️🕊️

    • @NadjibSamsung
      @NadjibSamsung 8 дней назад

      @@Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 no verse from these that you have quoted prove anything. If the trinity was true it have to be mentioned CLEARLY. not with stupid hints that can be interpreted in million way

    • @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22
      @Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 8 дней назад

      @@NadjibSamsung But they do, Friend. Please be Not ignorant.

    • @NadjibSamsung
      @NadjibSamsung 8 дней назад

      @@Daniel_Godismyjudge--Isah33.22 jesus is not a god but he's a great prophet and his mother is a virgin. But God is only one

  • @DrWolves
    @DrWolves 24 дня назад

    Are you so certain that your nature is not the same as the nature of a dog?

  • @gvastida
    @gvastida 24 дня назад +1

    Man. It's so hard to watch a channel that's well produced but acts so intellectually dishonest and works as a constant apologist for its faith. A shame- truly.

    • @SanctusApologetics
      @SanctusApologetics  24 дня назад +9

      @@gvastida We who have faith don’t believe blindly, therefore the faith needs to be defended, so of course apologetics is necessary as with any other worldview.

    • @cster
      @cster 24 дня назад +3

      The first part can be debated but the second part is very confusing. Apologetics provides an explanation for the hope we have as Christian’s and when done correctly tries to bring others closer to that same hope. This video and others like it might very well be what someone needed to make it all click so really the complaint shouldn’t be too much it should be not enough.

    • @yes-cu4uf
      @yes-cu4uf 24 дня назад +3

      wats bro yappin abt 😴

  • @indi_prime
    @indi_prime 24 дня назад

    I think the trinity can be reasoned from nature, but maybe only after the consequences of the revelation allowed it to be observed through a change in nature and our nature. The Father gave the Holy Spirit to the Son through life and its returned to the Father through service in order that there may be peace between them extending that peace to the Mother, sisters and society. The root of discord is estrangement of earthly fathers and sons who are seperate beings and must gap the void between them with the grace of the heavenly Father, Son and Holy Spirit. God only formed Himself into the Trinity and sent His Son because humanity became separated from Him, thereby at the same time revealing an insight into the boundlessness of His love for us that he would extend the bounds of His nature in order that we may enter into communion with Him by replicating His love. Because energy that turns into agapic love will never change and becomes a source of endless energy it must be also as stable form in unity with God