Hey buddy! Awesome, awesome tutorial on the modularity and accuracy gains through the multiple Ways of tunning this Awesome moderator/air stripper system! As we enter into the high power world of slugs and long distance shooting, harmonics and post muzzle air management becomes exponentially more important and is the final equation to accuracy... extremely well done PJ! 😎
I would say the first priority of using a moderator is to reduce sound. With these new moderators you may be able to get away with leaving out a section to get better harmonics but to me that is not ideal. Where for me the harmonics come into play for accuracy is with shooting slugs at higher power. For pellets different moderator weights and types has not made as much difference unless you have a long untensioned shroud with a heavy moderator on. I tend to use the FX tuner shrouds and tuners on my airguns to get the best accuracy for slugs and they always shoot pellets well too. I do not have any tensioned barrel systems and have found in general shorter barrels can handle heavier moderators and long barrels tend to need lighter moderators when using the FX tuners to avoid excessive barrel whipping. What I would like to see come to market is a moderator with a built in tuner. Then you can have the full benefit of the moderator sound suppression. I do appreciate your videos.
I agree. I’ve used prototype tuning moderators and with the right airgun, they are the premier barrel tuning tool. I’m not sure you’ll see one hit the market anytime soon. Barrel system design definitely matters when it comes to how much a length or weight change of the system impacts precision, and there are definitely barrels that get too whippy when anything more than a Tatsu gets attached.
@@WiscAirGunners Thanks for the reply. The FX tuners like I said really did have an dramatic effect on shrinking slug group sizes. What I did not like about them was they did not have a quality durable finish. Also the threading on them was not consistent on the ones I owned and at times making them hard to adjust.
I agree. You have approached this in a very scientific manner providing objective data. There is always going to be a degree of subjectivity in this area of sound perception. I would personally like to see some big bore testing with the Yokozuna comparable to this testing with the Ryu. I have seen that the DonnyFL site has no moderators currently listed. What is your take of the federal government stepping in to accessory ban screw on barrel moderators? Thank you.
@@SilverShadow2LWB my preference would be that air and CO2 powered BB and pellet/slug firing rifles and pistols be left out of the scope of what is regulated as they are not firearms.
@@WiscAirGunners I wholeheartedly agree with you. All it's going to take is for someone to screw on a moderator with metal internal cones, partitions, or mechanisms onto a real firearm. Many can just screw onto a real firearm. It is not a ban against pellet guns, but if that part could be illegally used on a firearm without a license. It's the few knuckleheads that will ruin it for the majority of responsible PCP owners.
As I've send before, I really enjoy your work. You are easy to understand (audio-wise) and don't "rush things. So I have a RAW Micro in .22 and I love it with 15.89 JSB at 790 fps and 22 ft pounds. I( am a real "fan" DonnyFL and have a Ronin (for my Panthera 600mm in .22), a Yokozuna in .22 on my FX Hunter Compact in .22 and Ryu on my RAW Micro in .22. So, if I am not mistaken, you ented up with Ryu and 2 baffles in RAW Micro in .177 (.22 cal Ryu). So does that imply that the most accurate configuration on my Micro is 2 baffles inasmuch as my RAW Micro is .22 ? I have FX Panthera Hunter in .22, Brocock/Brk Atomic XR in .22 and RAW Micro in .22. Each is very accurate but my overall favorite is the RAW Micro in .22 for accuracy and build quality. I made no changes out of the box with my Micro and it was perfection in all respects as it came out of the box, no changes to anything, using the 15.89 JSB pellet. I have never had that out of the box experience with anything other than the RAW Micro. I usually have to spend 1 day and hundreds of pellets to tune my other PCPs. I am looking into putting a 24" RAW .22 cal barrel on my Micro for versatility. I am waiting for a response from RAW. Your thoughts on this? Again, thanks for your great videos.
First, thank you. Second, I'm not convinced that my results with this airgun/moderator combo will extend to other calibers of the same airgun. I'd like to think it's a good starting point. If you have a .22 I'd use a .25 Ryu. Third, a new barrel, especially switching from a shrouded barrel with it's own stripper to a "plain" barrel is a different animal entirely and I have no data on how that would work out. Fourth, RAW puts a lot of work into each airgun before they go out. I think you are seeign the results of that care.
I know it would be really hard to edit but would you be able to do the noise comparisons without the sound of the impact, cut the play back a frame or 2 before the pellet hitting where it's going Alternatively you could do the sound test in a field with no impact noise just the sound of the gun sending the lead ?
Great no!w you have given me something ELSE to tune on my gun! You should try with a tensioned barrel. Would think on something like a TJ tensioned system you really wouldn't see much of a change due to the stiffness of the barrel. But it would still be cool to see what would happen.
Thank you for the video and, as usual a rich trove of information. I have a coupe of questions but not about the ryu: at what velocity do you shoot the .177 10.34gr in this particular rifle and what the barrel’s length is?
great looking product. How much does the adapter add to the barrel length? my maverick is already tight in it's case :). Do I need to go up to a .25 for a .22 Maverick or is this considered on the barrel?
It’s not more than a few mm longer than the shroud threads on an FX rifle. The Maverick shroud has a internal hard connection to the barrel so I’d feel confident in running a .22 on a .22.
@@WiscAirGunnershello good day dear. Sorry you busy. Help me? I used fx maverick sniper .22 cal 700 mm barrel. Donnfyl ryu you think very good accuracy? Or sumo the best?
@@kricketkricket6737 you’d have to try them head to head. Every air rifle is different. Be sure to shoot multiple groups in each condition. You want what is consistently the best, not just the one time winner. You may have two that are equal but one is quieter…pick the winner.
I have a M3 .25 cal 700mm barrel with the tensioned barrel and a BC carbon fiber shroud. Would you still recommend upgrading to a bigger caliber size on the Ryu? Shooting mk2 34gr
I’d recommend the Yokozuna. You should be good with the .25 size. When you go to the CF shroud you loose the shroud, which acts like an expansion chamber in concert with your moderator. The Ryu might not be able to keep up.
Fantastic Video! I have an Evanix .25 Max Air II Bullpup that is pretty loud. The current DonnyFL FX .30 tamed it a bit but I want it to be quieter. The Donny I have is 1.36" X 5". Is there a big difference in sound reduction from Yokozuna vs Ryu? I'm undecided on which one to buy.
What is the speed difference between with and without ? something you have to consider I think ? the moderator reduce a little the speed of the bullet so if you set up your gun without moderator and the same speed wit moderator, you should probably have the same groups ?
I would because I like the compact gun, how it balances, and the trigger is awesome. There are lots of airguns that are purpose built for the sport, so someone with more experience might give you a different answer. The new AirArms field trget rifle is supposed to be pretty awesome, and Thomas certainly is the one I've heard people talk the most about, but it's more than twice the price and you wait to have one made.
HI SIR I Really hope you don't mind me asking this question. Please settle my mind I've got a FX Dreamline with 600mm and 380mm stx super light barrels. So I'll need a 25cal moderator? Thanks 🎯🇺🇲👍🏼
Be cautious with extra weight on the super light design. It tends to get whippy, especially the 600mm. I used a Tatsu on my 600 and a Sumo on my 380 when I had my Crown Continuum with those barrels.
@@WiscAirGunners THANKYOU Sir I was a little worried about the weight. Honestly I've been using Hugget BECAUSE of the wide choice of the DONNY and not quite knowing what would best. NOW with your help I've got a lot better idea for which I'm very thankful 🎯🇺🇲👍🏼
@@WiscAirGunners HI Sir after your advice and then watching videos on RUclips of them both. I have pulled the trigger (as they say) lol. ORDERED myself 1 of each. Thanks for the advice and I hope you and yours have a great Easter 🇬🇧🇺🇲🎯👍🏼
With a direct threading to the barrel or an internal bushing that ensures that the barrel is and stays concentric to the shroud (using DonnyFL sizing-other companies size differently-I'll go .22 on a .22. For an air rifle like the AvengeX, where the barrel is floating within the shroud, I'd go a size up. In the Ryu-Yoko world, that would be a .25. For the Tatsu or Sumo, a.22/25 will work.
DonnyFL is not selling moderators direct to customers, but the dealer network has units in stock. A new international facility has been set up to serve the global community.
@@franciscodacuna5096 RUclips dice que toma un tiempo generar los subtítulos en español, así que modifiqué la configuración en algunos videos y veré qué sucede y luego haré más. Este video es uno de los que cambié, así que avíseme si ver los resultados y si son positivos.
You will see some of the anodizing flake off. It is a byproduct of the friction fit design, and it will not effect the performance of the unit. When the DonnyFL team experimented with different coatings (and uncoated) we found that there needed to be a snug fit or the unit would work loose when shooting. Every Ryu and Yokozuna is test fit before it leaves during final assembly, and the jig we use gets hundreds of installs before it is replaced. I've used those on my personal rifle and they still function properly, though they aren't as pretty as a new one. The corners wear down a bit, but the actual bearing surface (the part that matters) stays flat and true.
This is what I would say. With a bigger caliber, or an airgun that doesn’t already have an airstriper in the shroud, more baffles will make more of a difference. I have tested this on numerous airguns, and there are definitely some where having all three baffles Installed is definitely quieter than just two. I was just shooting an AirForce Escape in .25…the difference between 2 and 3 baffles is noticeable. That’s with the Yokozuna. On the Micro Hunter, in .177, it’s not uncomfortable to shoot without a moderator. As I have it set up with two baffles, it’s so quiet it sounds broken from just a couple yards away.
@@WiscAirGunners yes I understand your point, had a fat boy and now this one because it’s new and I need to remove the mod in order to fit in the case panthera 700. However I tried sumo and it was inaccurate and it’s alot quieter and accurate with a Weihrauch XL so it’s a little disappointing on the performance side on sound reduction useing yokuzuna
Hey buddy! Awesome, awesome tutorial on the modularity and accuracy gains through the multiple Ways of tunning this Awesome moderator/air stripper system! As we enter into the high power world of slugs and long distance shooting, harmonics and post muzzle air management becomes exponentially more important and is the final equation to accuracy... extremely well done PJ! 😎
Thanks Steve!
Thanks so much for the thorough review!
Glad you found it useful.
Thank you for your time and experience Sir,, I love your videos,,,
Thank you very much!
I would say the first priority of using a moderator is to reduce sound. With these new moderators you may be able to get away with leaving out a section to get better harmonics but to me that is not ideal. Where for me the harmonics come into play for accuracy is with shooting slugs at higher power. For pellets different moderator weights and types has not made as much difference unless you have a long untensioned shroud with a heavy moderator on. I tend to use the FX tuner shrouds and tuners on my airguns to get the best accuracy for slugs and they always shoot pellets well too. I do not have any tensioned barrel systems and have found in general shorter barrels can handle heavier moderators and long barrels tend to need lighter moderators when using the FX tuners to avoid excessive barrel whipping. What I would like to see come to market is a moderator with a built in tuner. Then you can have the full benefit of the moderator sound suppression. I do appreciate your videos.
I agree.
I’ve used prototype tuning moderators and with the right airgun, they are the premier barrel tuning tool. I’m not sure you’ll see one hit the market anytime soon.
Barrel system design definitely matters when it comes to how much a length or weight change of the system impacts precision, and there are definitely barrels that get too whippy when anything more than a Tatsu gets attached.
@@WiscAirGunners Thanks for the reply. The FX tuners like I said really did have an dramatic effect on shrinking slug group sizes. What I did not like about them was they did not have a quality durable finish. Also the threading on them was not consistent on the ones I owned and at times making them hard to adjust.
I love the sound pitch the ryu and Yokozuna makes ❤ great review
Thanks!
Best video so far on the RAW micro hunter. Also best video on the new Donny FL. 👍🇺🇲
Cool!
I agree. You have approached this in a very scientific manner providing objective data. There is always going to be a degree of subjectivity in this area of sound perception. I would personally like to see some big bore testing with the Yokozuna comparable to this testing with the Ryu. I have seen that the DonnyFL site has no moderators currently listed. What is your take of the federal government stepping in to accessory ban screw on barrel moderators? Thank you.
@@SilverShadow2LWB Airgun moderators are not regulated.
@@SilverShadow2LWB my preference would be that air and CO2 powered BB and pellet/slug firing rifles and pistols be left out of the scope of what is regulated as they are not firearms.
@@WiscAirGunners I wholeheartedly agree with you. All it's going to take is for someone to screw on a moderator with metal internal cones, partitions, or mechanisms onto a real firearm. Many can just screw onto a real firearm. It is not a ban against pellet guns, but if that part could be illegally used on a firearm without a license. It's the few knuckleheads that will ruin it for the majority of responsible PCP owners.
Very nice and detailed review. Congratulations!!!
Thanks.
Top quality video told me everything I needed to know thanks from 12ft lbs land 🇬🇧
Glad to help out. Have a great day.
Im receiving mine tomorrow 😊 cant wait to try it on my dream tac
Enjoy!
Can't wait to get mine, ordered DonnyFL Harakiri for my M3
Awesome pice of art!! definitely love it !! Wow
Thanks!
Great video on how to test and tune them thanks
Glad to help out.
Great Video. Thanks
Glad you liked it.
Nice info
Thanks for sharing 👍
You are welcome!
Nice video
Thanks!
I'm sold ,time to replace the Ronin
I still love my Ronon, but it isn't the right choice for every airgun.
As I've send before, I really enjoy your work. You are easy to understand (audio-wise) and don't "rush things. So I have a RAW Micro in .22 and I love it with 15.89 JSB at 790 fps and 22 ft pounds. I( am a real "fan" DonnyFL and have a Ronin (for my Panthera 600mm in .22), a Yokozuna in .22 on my FX Hunter Compact in .22 and Ryu on my RAW Micro in .22. So, if I am not mistaken, you ented up with Ryu and 2 baffles in RAW Micro in .177 (.22 cal Ryu). So does that imply that the most accurate configuration on my Micro is 2 baffles inasmuch as my RAW Micro is .22 ? I have FX Panthera Hunter in .22, Brocock/Brk Atomic XR in .22 and RAW Micro in .22. Each is very accurate but my overall favorite is the RAW Micro in .22 for accuracy and build quality. I made no changes out of the box with my Micro and it was perfection in all respects as it came out of the box, no changes to anything, using the 15.89 JSB pellet. I have never had that out of the box experience with anything other than the RAW Micro. I usually have to spend 1 day and hundreds of pellets to tune my other PCPs. I am looking into putting a 24" RAW .22 cal barrel on my Micro for versatility. I am waiting for a response from RAW. Your thoughts on this? Again, thanks for your great videos.
First, thank you.
Second, I'm not convinced that my results with this airgun/moderator combo will extend to other calibers of the same airgun. I'd like to think it's a good starting point. If you have a .22 I'd use a .25 Ryu.
Third, a new barrel, especially switching from a shrouded barrel with it's own stripper to a "plain" barrel is a different animal entirely and I have no data on how that would work out.
Fourth, RAW puts a lot of work into each airgun before they go out. I think you are seeign the results of that care.
I know it would be really hard to edit but would you be able to do the noise comparisons without the sound of the impact, cut the play back a frame or 2 before the pellet hitting where it's going
Alternatively you could do the sound test in a field with no impact noise just the sound of the gun sending the lead ?
Finding a space where I can shoot out into the great nothing will be the hard part. Next time I go to Utah I will see what I can do.
Great no!w you have given me something ELSE to tune on my gun! You should try with a tensioned barrel. Would think on something like a TJ tensioned system you really wouldn't see much of a change due to the stiffness of the barrel. But it would still be cool to see what would happen.
Wish I had access to one.
@@WiscAirGunners I have one up here, but being there in FL makes shipping a pain. Though would be willing to help you guys out if needed
Great video! Just wanted to check that the .22 version is correct when shooting .177? As I didn't see a .177 version on the website. Thanks!
That is correct.
@@WiscAirGunners thanks!
Can you do a test in the FX Impact M3 in 30 caliber with JSB 44.75? I'd be interested to see your results .
I will see what I can do.
Very heavy. Over 11oz - for comparison the Ronin is 10oz and the Impulse air is 4ish oz - I think these are amazing if kept on 600mm barrels
Thank you for the video and, as usual a rich trove of information. I have a coupe of questions but not about the ryu: at what velocity do you shoot the .177 10.34gr in this particular rifle and what the barrel’s length is?
I think it’s a 9” barrel and about 812 fps. I’ll have a full review out in the coming weeks.
Idk if the ryu is gonna quiet my gk1 down enough. I think I’m gonna have to go with the Yokozuna.
We are using one on our .25 in the shop and it’s pretty quiet. I suppose how you have it tuned will make a difference.
will the ryu make my 22 cal jts airacuda silent or just reduce it so much game wont notice?
Huben GK1, would you go one size higher or stick with the same caliber?
As it connects through an adapter I'd go a size up.
great looking product. How much does the adapter add to the barrel length? my maverick is already tight in it's case :). Do I need to go up to a .25 for a .22 Maverick or is this considered on the barrel?
It’s not more than a few mm longer than the shroud threads on an FX rifle.
The Maverick shroud has a internal hard connection to the barrel so I’d feel confident in running a .22 on a .22.
Thanks for the advice@@WiscAirGunners
@@WiscAirGunnershello good day dear. Sorry you busy. Help me? I used fx maverick sniper .22 cal 700 mm barrel. Donnfyl ryu you think very good accuracy? Or sumo the best?
@@kricketkricket6737 you’d have to try them head to head. Every air rifle is different. Be sure to shoot multiple groups in each condition. You want what is consistently the best, not just the one time winner. You may have two that are equal but one is quieter…pick the winner.
I have a M3 .25 cal 700mm barrel with the tensioned barrel and a BC carbon fiber shroud. Would you still recommend upgrading to a bigger caliber size on the Ryu? Shooting mk2 34gr
I’d recommend the Yokozuna. You should be good with the .25 size. When you go to the CF shroud you loose the shroud, which acts like an expansion chamber in concert with your moderator. The Ryu might not be able to keep up.
Fantastic Video! I have an Evanix .25 Max Air II Bullpup that is pretty loud. The current DonnyFL FX .30 tamed it a bit but I want it to be quieter. The Donny I have is 1.36" X 5". Is there a big difference in sound reduction from Yokozuna vs Ryu? I'm undecided on which one to buy.
The Yokozuna has more internal volume and is more likely to bring the noise down on your Max Air.
@@WiscAirGunners Greatly appreciated on the fast response. Yokozuna it is then!
If it can quit down a AEA .357 and improve accuracy then I'll buy.
You'll want the Yokozuna for that.
The Yokozuna is perfect for the Panthea IMHO, great review.@@WiscAirGunners
Thank you @@mackellyman5642
What is the speed difference between with and without ? something you have to consider I think ? the moderator reduce a little the speed of the bullet so if you set up your gun without moderator and the same speed wit moderator, you should probably have the same groups ?
Something I will have to test and report back.
Would you use a micro hunter .177 for HFT or are there better choices. Despite your problem with yours at PAC?
I would because I like the compact gun, how it balances, and the trigger is awesome. There are lots of airguns that are purpose built for the sport, so someone with more experience might give you a different answer. The new AirArms field trget rifle is supposed to be pretty awesome, and Thomas certainly is the one I've heard people talk the most about, but it's more than twice the price and you wait to have one made.
HI SIR I Really hope you don't mind me asking this question. Please settle my mind I've got a FX Dreamline with 600mm and 380mm stx super light barrels. So I'll need a 25cal moderator? Thanks 🎯🇺🇲👍🏼
Be cautious with extra weight on the super light design. It tends to get whippy, especially the 600mm. I used a Tatsu on my 600 and a Sumo on my 380 when I had my Crown Continuum with those barrels.
@@WiscAirGunners THANKYOU Sir I was a little worried about the weight. Honestly I've been using Hugget BECAUSE of the wide choice of the DONNY and not quite knowing what would best. NOW with your help I've got a lot better idea for which I'm very thankful 🎯🇺🇲👍🏼
@@mikebird8290 glad to help.
@@WiscAirGunners HI Sir after your advice and then watching videos on RUclips of them both. I have pulled the trigger (as they say) lol. ORDERED myself 1 of each. Thanks for the advice and I hope you and yours have a great Easter 🇬🇧🇺🇲🎯👍🏼
@@mikebird8290 Easter greetings to you and your family as well.
PJ will that moderator fit on a 25 caliber R3M EDGUN.
I don’t know much about the shroud on the R3M. I’ve seen some with 1/2x20 UNF thread at the muzzle, and some without, and don’t know what is stock.
Just received the Avenge X in 22. Just to confirm I'm safe to go with 22 on the moderator or do you still recommend going a size larger?
With a direct threading to the barrel or an internal bushing that ensures that the barrel is and stays concentric to the shroud (using DonnyFL sizing-other companies size differently-I'll go .22 on a .22. For an air rifle like the AvengeX, where the barrel is floating within the shroud, I'd go a size up. In the Ryu-Yoko world, that would be a .25. For the Tatsu or Sumo, a.22/25 will work.
@@WiscAirGunners Thank you!
Hey if you don't mind me asking but what type of side wheel are you using on your element optic scope?
BlackArts Design. Absolutely love it. The asymmetrical design really lets me know where I am without looking at the wheel.
@@WiscAirGunners thanks budd
I got the impression DonnyFL stopped selling moderators?
DonnyFL is not selling moderators direct to customers, but the dealer network has units in stock. A new international facility has been set up to serve the global community.
what are thew OD on both moderator?
The Ryu is 1.2 inches and the Yokozuna is 1.6 inches.
Thank you!
@@WiscAirGunners
Hola muy buenos los videos
Los subtítulos puedes ser en ESPAÑOL
Gracias 👍👍👍👌👌👌
Gracias. Si he hecho las paradas correctamente deberías verlas pronto. He configurado el canal para que se puedan generar.
Muchísimas gracias
Yo lo sigo en el canal ace tiempo los de seteo de Fx M3 si pudieras ponerlos te lo agradecería y te dejo mis likes 👍
@@franciscodacuna5096 RUclips dice que toma un tiempo generar los subtítulos en español, así que modifiqué la configuración en algunos videos y veré qué sucede y luego haré más. Este video es uno de los que cambié, así que avíseme si ver los resultados y si son positivos.
Ok perfecto le dejaremos un tiempo para que se configure
Si se cambia te dire Gracias
Hola se an cambiado genial 👌👌👌
👍😉🇳🇱👍😉🇳🇱
Where can I order it ?
The Ryu is at dealers worldwide.
Pellet shop
@@mikejoseph8392 a good choice!
Hello there, i got my yokozuna yesterday and fit so tight that it is making some metal shaving. Is that normal?
You will see some of the anodizing flake off. It is a byproduct of the friction fit design, and it will not effect the performance of the unit. When the DonnyFL team experimented with different coatings (and uncoated) we found that there needed to be a snug fit or the unit would work loose when shooting. Every Ryu and Yokozuna is test fit before it leaves during final assembly, and the jig we use gets hundreds of installs before it is replaced. I've used those on my personal rifle and they still function properly, though they aren't as pretty as a new one. The corners wear down a bit, but the actual bearing surface (the part that matters) stays flat and true.
@WiscAirGunners great thanks for your fast response and your time great content as always ✌️✌️
It’s a shame it makes no difference in noise reduction
This is what I would say. With a bigger caliber, or an airgun that doesn’t already have an airstriper in the shroud, more baffles will make more of a difference.
I have tested this on numerous airguns, and there are definitely some where having all three baffles Installed is definitely quieter than just two.
I was just shooting an AirForce Escape in .25…the difference between 2 and 3 baffles is noticeable. That’s with the Yokozuna.
On the Micro Hunter, in .177, it’s not uncomfortable to shoot without a moderator. As I have it set up with two baffles, it’s so quiet it sounds broken from just a couple yards away.
@@WiscAirGunners yes I understand your point, had a fat boy and now this one because it’s new and I need to remove the mod in order to fit in the case panthera 700. However I tried sumo and it was inaccurate and it’s alot quieter and accurate with a Weihrauch XL so it’s a little disappointing on the performance side on sound reduction useing yokuzuna
@@neilyoung7373 sorry it didn’t work out for you.
You have to pay the Fed’s for that?
All DonnyFl products are for Airgun Use Only.