Mr. HFY, that was completely unexpected and so very true. I had a professor, much like the one in your story, who did something similar. The lesson we were taught was that there are things not written in books, things we need to understand, but can't be "looked up" in any reference material. As our professor taught us, the best doctors, lawyers, or teachers aren't those who rely on solely on what they were taught in class but on what their patients, clients, or students tell them. Good on you! Thank you for reminding me of this.
Reminds me of those puzzles that you had to find the true puzzle INSIDE the puzzle.. critical thinking puzzle books. It like finding the HIDDEN PICTURE inside a larger picture. 🤔🤔
Logic and Reasoning aren't universal constants. I present to you a celestial phenomenon; The Black hole. Everything we know, everything there is, stops existing once you pass the event horizon. Never forget that everything around you, all the logic, all the reasoning, all the knowledge, Everything there is; was born from Chaos.
I have a problem with stuff like this. The students DID find the solution. But the corrector was dishonest and ignored their answer. (there is no solution IS a solution.) Also, the conclusion used by the professor is a total nonsense. It's a tangle of personal beliefs, racism, ignorance and worse, a failure to teach. All she did was show her students she can't be trusted.
Thanks for the comment! Like I replied to another comment.. this is exactly the purpose of this story! You want a logical answer to a complex problem, that sometimes just pure demonstration of knowledge and logical thinking is not enough. Humans reach their peak when logical and analytical thinking start walking together
@@HFYVengeance It would have worked if they had said the solution, and not just shown propaganda agitating the uniqueness of a human. It's more stupid than it shows anything other than xenophobia.
@@o0shad0oo yeah i was expecting it being something like a sequence puzzle example: www.a2zinterviews.com/Puzzles/puzzles-quiz/puzzles-quiz-19.jpg but instead of the answer being the "obvious" pattern its actually based on what is missing from all the other steps... or for example if we take the answer to that puzzle there which is this: www.a2zinterviews.com/Puzzles/puzzles-quiz/puzzles-quiz-19a.jpg we could also make a version with both black dots and small circles missing from this since in both of the upper rows we have 2 images with a small black dot and 1 without and 2 images with 2 small white balls and 1 without it and with the last row already having 2 images with small black dot and 2 images with 1 small white ball logically there should be that 1 image on that line where there is no black dot and 1 image with no small white ball thus by logic the last image should not have a small white ball or a small black dot in it for it to be consistent with the missing part pattern obviously that is not intended way to solve that particular puzzle but essentially you would have a sequence that breaks if you try to think it normally like instead of 1+2=3 you get something like 1+2=9 because every other part of the sequence is missing a unique number from 1-9 range and the only ones left for those 3 slots were 3,4 and 5... so the actual problem with the missing parts filled in is 41+52=93 which now actually makes sense....
![Stromae, Pomme - “Ma Meilleure Ennemie” (from Arcane Season 2) [Official Visualizer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1F3OGIFnW1k/mqdefault.jpg)
Mr. HFY, that was completely unexpected and so very true. I had a professor, much like the one in your story, who did something similar. The lesson we were taught was that there are things not written in books, things we need to understand, but can't be "looked up" in any reference material. As our professor taught us, the best doctors, lawyers, or teachers aren't those who rely on solely on what they were taught in class but on what their patients, clients, or students tell them. Good on you! Thank you for reminding me of this.
Yeah sometimes people are just messing with you because you pissed them off, it always pays to be nice 😂 respect is a two-way street
After all that build up, then no 1+1 answer? That SUCKED.
short class. 3 class sessions that lasted less than 5 minutes each.
Reminds me of those puzzles that you had to find the true puzzle INSIDE the puzzle.. critical thinking puzzle books. It like finding the HIDDEN PICTURE inside a larger picture. 🤔🤔
I hope that at a certain angle, it just looked like a dog
There is no 1 dimensional puzzle ... minimum is 2 dimensions.
1 = length
2 = length and width
3 = length, width and depth
A very useful perspective. Thank you. UKUK
Logic and Reasoning aren't universal constants.
I present to you a celestial phenomenon; The Black hole.
Everything we know, everything there is, stops existing once you pass the event horizon.
Never forget that everything around you, all the logic, all the reasoning, all the knowledge, Everything there is; was born from Chaos.
........ 😵💫
42*(0/42)
A students...taken down.
I have a problem with stuff like this. The students DID find the solution. But the corrector was dishonest and ignored their answer. (there is no solution IS a solution.) Also, the conclusion used by the professor is a total nonsense. It's a tangle of personal beliefs, racism, ignorance and worse, a failure to teach. All she did was show her students she can't be trusted.
I'm not sure that 'no solution' is true... She just didn't tell them in the end.
We do however, know the solution wasn't strictly logical.
Okay this entire story is horshit. If there's no solution to the problem then it's not a problem it's a bunch of random crap thrown into one location
Crap
So no solution...... waste of 27:05 minutes
Thanks for the comment! Like I replied to another comment.. this is exactly the purpose of this story! You want a logical answer to a complex problem, that sometimes just pure demonstration of knowledge and logical thinking is not enough. Humans reach their peak when logical and analytical thinking start walking together
@@HFYVengeance It would have worked if they had said the solution, and not just shown propaganda agitating the uniqueness of a human. It's more stupid than it shows anything other than xenophobia.
@@HFYVengeance Please give an example of a problem you could ask a class that wouldn't be solvable via logic. This story sucks.
@@o0shad0oo yeah i was expecting it being something like a sequence puzzle
example: www.a2zinterviews.com/Puzzles/puzzles-quiz/puzzles-quiz-19.jpg
but instead of the answer being the "obvious" pattern its actually based on what is missing from all the other steps...
or for example if we take the answer to that puzzle there which is this:
www.a2zinterviews.com/Puzzles/puzzles-quiz/puzzles-quiz-19a.jpg
we could also make a version with both black dots and small circles missing from this since in both of the upper rows we have 2 images with a small black dot and 1 without and 2 images with 2 small white balls and 1 without it and with the last row already having 2 images with small black dot and 2 images with 1 small white ball logically there should be that 1 image on that line where there is no black dot and 1 image with no small white ball thus by logic the last image should not have a small white ball or a small black dot in it for it to be consistent with the missing part pattern
obviously that is not intended way to solve that particular puzzle but essentially you would have a sequence that breaks if you try to think it normally like instead of 1+2=3 you get something like 1+2=9 because every other part of the sequence is missing a unique number from 1-9 range and the only ones left for those 3 slots were 3,4 and 5... so the actual problem with the missing parts filled in is 41+52=93 which now actually makes sense....