Your opinions are surprisingly similar to mine. I dont get why people see ftb as some god tier song that descented from heavens or some shit. To me it ranks propably around top 40-50. Sandman and NEM are overplayed but their not bad songs or anything Master of puppets to me is unnecesserily long, without the interlude it wouldn't even make the top 50 fuel is kinda overrated i quess. To me the song has always been kinda meh Seek and destroy is overplayed but the song kinda became the "Iron maiden song" of metallica (The song that's played at every show) so i think that's understandable. I do actually like the song quite a bit but there are better ones on KEA Whiskey in the jar sounds like dogshit imo If darkness had a son is 3-4 minutes too long but it has a couple of cool riffs here and there Harvester of sorrow and For whom the bell tolls have the same problem tbh Both start great but then the song doesn't really go anywhere and gets repetive
Holy crap!!! Finally someone who comprehends my opinion!! MOP is actually one of my favorites and my placement in the catalog for it is #21/119. Whiskey is a song i never got into, it's not terrible, has a few cool riffs and sections but i just cannot stand those over the top vocals and specially the main riff, it sounds so silly, clumsy and ugly... i trult don't know what ppl see in this song.... Ftb is a great song but it's NOT GOD tier like you say. A god tier song for me is Disposable Heroes and a few pop songs like Meet Me Halfway or It's been so long (Fnaf2 song). Yeah, i just needed to get that off my head. FTB could have been shorter imo Harvester sounds really good live imo
@@vinceyrankings thanks for the reply. Mop used to be my favourite back when i was 15 (im 20 now) but i overlistened to it and with time i got bored with it. The only thing that still feels fresh to me is the interlude. Lots of live versions sound more energetic which makes them often sound better. Whiskey is a song i would never put to my playlist but i do often need to listen to it on sauna because my little brother decides the music there mostly, but i quess that means i dont hate it exactly. I also agree that disposable heroes is a god tier song tho there are couple song by metallica i like more which might surprise you. The frayed ends of sanity, Where the wild things are and Through the never are propably my favourites
@@stangerdeath9555 Even if you liked songs like Some Kind of Monster, Cure or If Darkness. I'm completely fine with that.. I really like those you've mentioned. Wild Things is the perfect example of a basic but amazing song and it's truly perplexing they've never played it live (..And Justice for Jason XD) After losing Dave, Cliff and specially Jason, they've kind of lost their touch or inspiration from St Anger onwards. Really? Your younger brother likes Whiskey in the Jar?! HAHA, not surprised. Yeah the message of this video is just that this songs are mostly good but not god tier aside from maybe MOP
@@vinceyrankings My little brother is more of a casual listener who listens to metallica, rammstein and "radio rock" i quess. It's actually kinda funny how he sometimes tries to be super musical about stuff but his fav songs are stuff like Enter sandman because he doesn't really dig further down a bands catalog than spotify top 10 or something
@@stangerdeath9555 XDDD i think we all used to be like that, introduce him some of the other songs like Escape or Thing that Should not be. Subbed to u btw
@@vinceyrankingswell whiskey is historic, it started as an Irish drinking song but then thin Lizzy made it into a rock song and then Metallica covered it, I love it but you don't have too
To me overplayed but not overrated are: Enter Sandman The Unforgiven Nothing Else Matters Master Of Puppets All are top songs with whom I have experienced the "can't get enough". But now sometimes they feel overplayed.
master of puppets being on this list hurt me. its probably my favorite song of all time (for about 3 years now) and that second opening riff in the song probably being one of my favorite riffs ever because not only is it fun to play its also just so good. its such a great song and i dont think its over rated at all.
I enjoy every song from Justice but i do think Harvester is overrated since it has some (very) mediocre parts like the chorus or the solo. No single band has a perfect discography and we need to understand that. :)
Overrated means songs that are considered to be better than they actually are, name one song off of St. Anger that's considered semi-highly and doesn't deserve it.
@@Slender1870 sweet amber. people are like "yo its the only good st anger song" except it sounds like shit. and they dont even give attention to frantic that is actually good
I just needed a few extra songs top have a top 10🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️ Otherwise, you have a point that MOP and FTB. At least they have a reason to get a lot of attention. But when it comes to Whiskey in the jar.. i really don't get it....🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️
When you play a guitar like me your interest for songs differs from others. And song are more enjoyable to play along with. Fuel is one of those, along with darkness had a son, harvester of sorrow
Harvester of Sorrow was exceptionally well performed in Seattle 1989, but it always sounds good to me. I agree with Sandman, Fuel being overrated but not bad, I’d include Sad but True and King Nothing on this list, totally agree that Whiskey in the Jar is one of the worst songs on Garage Inc.
Seeing Fade to Black at three hurt a tad as it’s my all time favorite Metallica song, but I completely agree with your number 1 selection. Seek & Destroy is easily the most overrated Metallica track.
I agree it should have been 7 min or smth but IDHAS gets a lot of popularity it's not worth of. That song is boring, wacky main riff, too repetitive, lazy lyrics, HORRIBLE SOLO and never liked the raspy vocals. Inamorata doesn't have those problems imo (maybe it's repetitive) Same for You Must Burn, never been a fan of that one either.
I agree with everything you said about Harvester. It's just the same riff over and over throughout the song, the solo is boring and plain and the chorus is basically James just yelling "Harvester of Sorrow". It's a good song with amazing lyrics, but very overrated
not to say that it’s really good and defending it for being overrated, but back when my dad was stationed in okinawa back in the late 90s he carved H. O. S. on the back of his helmet for Harvester of Sorrow because it is was favorite song
I am sort of modern metallica guy (rare breed) because I was born around Death Magnetic, and I can say I do agree with most of this list. But I do have to say I see WAY more people hating on If Darkness Had A Son then defending it, and I personally like the song but I can see why you and others don't. The only songs I would've changed are Screaming Suicide for If Darkness Had A Son, and The Memory Remains for Fade To Black.
I agree with every single one besides ftb because that songs message is beautiful and sad at the same time and seek and destroy might be overplayed but it is such an amazing song.
I like the list and agree with your points for the most part. I don't agree with Harvester, it's good example of mid paced heaviness but I do think Leper Messiah, The Thing That Should Not Be and Eye of the Beholder are underrated in this regard. Whiskey in the Jar is a good cover overall, but Thin Lizzy version is so much better that I have to agree.
My top 10 Most Overrated songs: 10) Inamorata (fight me) 9) One 8) Blackened 7) Battery 6) Fuel 5) Nothing Else Matters 4) Master Of Puppets 3) Seek & Destrrroy 2) Sad But True 1) Enter Sandman Bonus: Whiskey in The Jar
I think One deserves to be overhyped so I'd say it's overplayed and Blackened is my favorite from AJFA but I perfectly understand all of your choices. Whiskey In The Jar should take 4th place at least LOL Fuel is extremely overrated. Only the intro is good.. the main riff is clumsy and the song is just confusing. I'd say it's not necessarily a bad song but very comparable to a mid-budget hollywood movie if you get what I mean.
I think there is a lot of misconception of an overplayed song being an overrated song. If you have anything too much too often, it spoils how special it is, and an overindulgence of being force-fed even your favorite food makes you want to throw up. Oversaturation of a song dilutes its genius to the point of "cookie-cutter pop song" perception. The song loses its edge, cult status, and commercializes the song with no true appreciation of insight, composition, or lyrics. There are many great songs that music stores employees once loved but now hate are the very songs that almost every potential customer trying out a guitar plays in the store. The overplaying of _Smoke on the Water, Nothing Else Matters, Stairway To Heaven_ make music store employees perceive these as "overrated" and make them want to throw up.
Very good comment dude. You defined very well what the misconception was and gave a good example. Yeah, If Darkness Had A Son is an example bcs it just became popular and somehow commercialized without even being good enough to be considered an "average song" thus it shouldn't have been a single. That song is so weird, repetitive and makes up for an annoying listen. (*it's just my opinion*) The solo is easily worse or as bad as the one in ManUNKind
Overrated, to me means everybody likes, but I don't see whats so great about them. I only have three songs on this list. 1. Sad But True 2. One 3. King Nothing
100% agree for Whiskey, I don’t like that song (well it’s a cover). Not a huge fan of Fuel as well. I thing it’s too soon for If Darkness had a son. I disagree for all the others… but yes Sandman has been overplayed.
I mean, they're all amazing imo aside from If Darkness and Whiskey in The Jar. Whiskey is soooo clumsy and weird, i hate the main riff so much, the rest goes from alright to bad
I think that overrated is the wrong word to describe these song, because some like fade to black and master of puppets are actually works of art. Of course they are the most streamed song so people don’t know that Metallica have made a lot of other beautiful songs. Personally I really like harvester of sorrow, I think it gives a lot of power and badness but I agree it is a bit ripetitive.
Only ones i agreed with were Darkness (didn't like that one. Deffo the worst on 72 Seasons) Sandman and Nothing Else (again, because they steal attention away from other bangers like The God That Failed) and partially with Seek but i love that song, but i can agree it takes attention from other awesome songs like Whiplash and No Remorse (my favorite on KEA)
No Remorse is a killer song and I don't see why Metallica plays If Darkness at every show.. Imagine how happy ppl would be with them playing Struggle Within, Escape, All Nightmare Long, Trapped Under Ice, Wild Things instead of that thing. It's called M72 for a reason... they should play the album in its entirity plus playing more rare songs would make up for a more popular and appealing tour than it already is
most of these were understandable, but I gotta say putting fade to black in number 3 for most overplayed, even above enter sandman, is the... craziest? (tryna be nice) opinion ever
I'm not the person who just tells his age but i confirm you i'm in my late teens so i'm young. As someone young i appreciate Load and Reload and some stuff from the new albums. Kind of like Murder One hehe I already knew Metallica before, had heard to Nothing Else matters, My Friend of Misery, Enter sandman before Stranger Things 4, from my parents and older ppl i know. That scene with Eddie in the upside down is what truly got me into the band, him shredding the master of puppets solo
@@vinceyrankings Alright! 👍 I was 14 when I discovered Metallica and I m 45 so there were only 5 albums at the time...when I look back, I ve changed my mind on some songs...and it will probably happen to you as well ! At first, I used to like The day that never comes, great intro, great verses...and since a few years, I find it's just a bad rendition of Fade to black ! I find that Screaming Suicide is a bad song, the main riff is weak but maybe one day I will find it good...no, not this one, bad example ! 😂 You know what I mean? I'm glad the young generation is into Metallica! 🤘🤘🤘 Greetings from France! My English is not perfect...but no so bad! 😁
@@sebastienfayemendie2514 J'aime le français! Oui je comprends qu'on peut changer d'avis de temps en temps. D'abord je considerais Escape une chanson peu ennuyeuse mais avec temps elle a grandi sur moi, c'est maintenant dans mon top 3. Salutations de Flandre!
@@vinceyrankings Ah! Je pensais que tu étais Américain ! Je ne sais pas pourquoi d ailleurs...🙄 Certains Fans sont impitoyables, avec un esprit fermé, j ai du mal à comprendre ça...j aime Load et Reload aussi, pas vraiment St Anger même avec 20 ans de recul...ce que j aime avant tout, c'est la prise de risques et chez Metallica, on est servis ! Dés fois c est génial, d autres fois c est raté, c est comme ça...longue vie à Metallica ! 🤘
It became popular because it's a masterpiece. Imagine being in 1986 you buy the disc and come back at your place and listen to this song for the first time what would be yout thought about it? People need to stop being influenced by the fact that if something is "popular" it is overrated. Analyze the music. the riffs, the melody, the lyrics, the solo, how does it make you feel@@midnighttube1941
So do you think that Metallica's take on Whiskey is bad, or song is bad in general? Seeing that it's based mostly on Thin Lizzy's version, Hetfield himself would probably hunt you down for disliking the song in general. XD
También. Luego las 10 peores y mejores canciones. Si ya viste mi ranking de todas las canciones, sabrás perfectamente cuales son, pero lo haré de todas formas para tener mas contenido
@@vinceyrankings si, efectivamente el business primero jaja. Fuera coñas es mejor dividir tu contenido en mucho ya que hay que gente que no vera 17 min de ranking. Yo si pero no todos. No pusiste minus human en el ranking o si?
@@Mundo-Metal No incluí canciones bonus pero la pondría momentaneamente entre top 90-80. No leaf clover iría al top 50 o quizas 40. Si, tienes razón pero hay gente que raramente ha conseguido muchas vistas haciendo los mismos videos y con la misma duración.
If darkens had a son: Cannot listen to The original, so Boring. The one on my play list Is a fan edited. You find it as "shorter and faster" on YT. Way better.
I think fade to black is so popular because its not that heavy. Most people dont like metal, so the slow, melodic songs like ftb, the unforgiven and nem are the most popular.
I feel like master of puppets is a little overrated. dont get me wrong, i love this album, it has my favorite metallica song, (disposable heroes) but its not there best album. (In my opinion, its fine to disagree.)
I appreciate the video but to make an opinion on this viable you actually have to explain why something is overrated. MOP might be one of the most overplayed songs ever, but if it's SO GOOD that it excuses it then it's not. You have to actually explain what about the song you don't like. As an example, a valid criticism about MOP is the fact that it drags on and on and on, it's reasonable. Then, if you want to talk about how overplayed songs overshadow other and better ones, the right video would be: "10 Metallica songs that deserve more justice" Hope I explained myself
No puedo ir diciendo que es así? Es solo mi opinión y si tengo derecho de hacerla saber. Esta lista es subjetiva y siempre habrá gente que este en (des)/acuerdo conmigo. Además admite que 3 o 4 de estas canciones estan recontra idolatradas😂😏
Overrated is a song that is considered better than it is. FTB is a good one but a bit slow and repetitive. It was actually funny to place it on 52/119. I'd put it higher now but still not even top 30
Master, Harvester, For Whom the Bell Tolls, Fade to Black, Seek and Destroy... you could have put more effort into it instead of putting masterpieces on this list... And Whiskey in the jar is only a cover
Harvester and Seek are so insanely overrated, they're fine but not god tier masterpieces. Whiskey is just a cover, yes, but i don't like it and unlike the songs you've mentioned, it does not deserve the hype, love and popularity it has
I dont think that whiskey in the jar is overrated. I dont think that many people even know about this song. I understand that you dont like this, I am not saying that you cant dislike this song, in my opinion it isnt bad i quite enjoy it, but not every needs to like it and i respect that. And overrated means that it is rated highly or valued more than it should Meaning that it isnt as good as people say it is and whiskey in the jar doesnt isnt a song that people would say that it is extremely good. There are alot of people (including you) that dont like this song and more that dont know this song as i said before. And whiskey in the jar is a cover song it wasnt wrote by metallica that is why it doesnt sound like other traditional metallica song.
Im considering your are a young person but I do not agree with most of this list. MOP, FWTBT, FTB, SnD, ESM, we’re absolute game changers in their time. And the fact they are still relevant today shows how important they are. Harvester is a great song but more of a filler. NEM always had a hard time liking that song since it came out 30years ago. My wife loves it, figures. Overplayed yes, but it does not mean overrated.
what? the most overrated song is: 1. Whiskey in the jar. every, EVERY and i mean absolut E V E R Y other Cover song is 956959595 times better. I hate it when they play whiskey on a METAL concert. ➡(best cover songs: breadfan, mercyful fate, the wait, its electric, turn the page, astronomy... etc) 1.2 enter sandman! there is no other song that is so "bad" but popular. The song is basicly just one lame riff... and it is stolen by "Stone" from the song "get stoned".... the song "get stoned" is better lol.
never been to a show of them, but I'll probably go in 2025 since I do not want to hear If Darkness Had a Son, that song is so overrated and I don't like it. But I bet that song will be one of the "good and classic songs" from the new albums. I haven't even listened to the entire cover of Whiskey bcs my brain just asked me to pause it, it was awful.
Some songs steal the attention from other great underrated songs but that doesn't mean they're bad. If Darkness and Whiskey are songs that don't deserve to be hyped imo and I dislike them
Well, it's your choice to agree or not. Maybe i'm wrong with some stuff, then correct me. But let's be honest, some songs like Whiskey are not that good and Seek is not as strong as some of the other songs on KEA
@@vinceyrankings Seek & Destroy is my favorite from the KEA man. It's on 15 in my list. That song feels like it's not from KEA. Also I really like Whiskey in the Jar, on my 21. I remember first I heard that was on a radio or something and then I was just looking for it for over 2 weeks. When I finally found it, I've listened it all day.
![Every METALLICA Song LEAST TO MOST PLAYED [2024]](/img/1.gif)
Your opinions are surprisingly similar to mine.
I dont get why people see ftb as some god tier song that descented from heavens or some shit.
To me it ranks propably around top 40-50.
Sandman and NEM are overplayed but their not bad songs or anything
Master of puppets to me is unnecesserily long, without the interlude it wouldn't even make the top 50
fuel is kinda overrated i quess. To me the song has always been kinda meh
Seek and destroy is overplayed but the song kinda became the "Iron maiden song" of metallica (The song that's played at every show) so i think that's understandable. I do actually like the song quite a bit but there are better ones on KEA
Whiskey in the jar sounds like dogshit imo
If darkness had a son is 3-4 minutes too long but it has a couple of cool riffs here and there
Harvester of sorrow and For whom the bell tolls have the same problem tbh
Both start great but then the song doesn't really go anywhere and gets repetive
Holy crap!!! Finally someone who comprehends my opinion!! MOP is actually one of my favorites and my placement in the catalog for it is #21/119. Whiskey is a song i never got into, it's not terrible, has a few cool riffs and sections but i just cannot stand those over the top vocals and specially the main riff, it sounds so silly, clumsy and ugly... i trult don't know what ppl see in this song....
Ftb is a great song but it's NOT GOD tier like you say. A god tier song for me is Disposable Heroes and a few pop songs like Meet Me Halfway or It's been so long (Fnaf2 song). Yeah, i just needed to get that off my head.
FTB could have been shorter imo
Harvester sounds really good live imo
@@vinceyrankings thanks for the reply.
Mop used to be my favourite back when i was 15 (im 20 now) but i overlistened to it and with time i got bored with it. The only thing that still feels fresh to me is the interlude. Lots of live versions sound more energetic which makes them often sound better. Whiskey is a song i would never put to my playlist but i do often need to listen to it on sauna because my little brother decides the music there mostly, but i quess that means i dont hate it exactly. I also agree that disposable heroes is a god tier song tho there are couple song by metallica i like more which might surprise you. The frayed ends of sanity, Where the wild things are and Through the never are propably my favourites
@@stangerdeath9555 Even if you liked songs like Some Kind of Monster, Cure or If Darkness. I'm completely fine with that..
I really like those you've mentioned. Wild Things is the perfect example of a basic but amazing song and it's truly perplexing they've never played it live (..And Justice for Jason XD) After losing Dave, Cliff and specially Jason, they've kind of lost their touch or inspiration from St Anger onwards.
Really? Your younger brother likes Whiskey in the Jar?! HAHA, not surprised.
Yeah the message of this video is just that this songs are mostly good but not god tier aside from maybe MOP
@@vinceyrankings My little brother is more of a casual listener who listens to metallica, rammstein and "radio rock" i quess. It's actually kinda funny how he sometimes tries to be super musical about stuff but his fav songs are stuff like Enter sandman because he doesn't really dig further down a bands catalog than spotify top 10 or something
@@stangerdeath9555 XDDD i think we all used to be like that, introduce him some of the other songs like Escape or Thing that Should not be. Subbed to u btw
Fade to Black being on this list is wild
Fade to black is one of the best songs of the band
Right? Worst part is that it’s not number 10, and it’s above enter sandman.
it honestly should be number 1 on this list
i know wtf
@@_amp1262 i think number 4 or 3 is the best placement
Ok, that's enough social media for today
Fr
These songs may be over rated but everyone of them is a master piece
true, aside from Whiskey and Harvester. Harvester is alright, just disappointing and Whiskey is not terrible, just very weird
@@vinceyrankingswell whiskey is historic, it started as an Irish drinking song but then thin Lizzy made it into a rock song and then Metallica covered it, I love it but you don't have too
@@Clobwobda_man Im glad u respect my taste🤘🏼
Except for Darkness
Fuel is nice but not a masterpiece at all
Overplayed ≠ overrated
Yeah, u got a right point there, didn't think about that
To me overplayed but not overrated are:
Enter Sandman
The Unforgiven
Nothing Else Matters
Master Of Puppets
All are top songs with whom I have experienced the "can't get enough". But now sometimes they feel overplayed.
master of puppets being on this list hurt me. its probably my favorite song of all time (for about 3 years now) and that second opening riff in the song probably being one of my favorite riffs ever because not only is it fun to play its also just so good. its such a great song and i dont think its over rated at all.
I replace it with the Memory remains
OVERRATED?
They're our Lord's of THRASH METAL.
Listen & enjoy or off with your head any day!!!
I enjoy every song from Justice but i do think Harvester is overrated since it has some (very) mediocre parts like the chorus or the solo. No single band has a perfect discography and we need to understand that. :)
Plus i'm not a fan of Whiskey in The Jar
Bro Whiskey in the Jar is my favourite
I'm sorrreyy! 😅
You either die a hero or live long enough to become overrated
wise words
I actually replace MOP with The Memory Remains bcs that song is good but not great and has some weird vocals. I'd give that a 5,6/10.
I totally agree with nothing else matters and enter sandman, and sliiiightly agree with fuel and fade to black
I get it but imo FTB, WITJ and S&D are their most overrated songs. Yes, more than Sandman or NEM
@@vinceyrankingsI dont listen to WITJ, dont get it why people like it so much
@@MisshKrodets It's not awful, but still bad somehow. I've never liked it, I ask myself the same question
The fact that no Sgt anger songs are there and fade to black is, is outrageous
Read the title of the video?
Overrated means songs that are considered to be better than they actually are, name one song off of St. Anger that's considered semi-highly and doesn't deserve it.
@@Slender1870 Sgt anger is one of top 3 all time metallica songs
@@Slender1870 sweet amber. people are like "yo its the only good st anger song" except it sounds like shit. and they dont even give attention to frantic that is actually good
@@camiam9576🤨
I absolutely agree with you about Fuel,Enter sandman and Whiskey.but
rest of it are truly amazing songs!
Fuel is not a bad song but just very confusing and nothing stands out aside from the intro. Whiskey In The Jar covered by them is so boring and weird
I expected a really bad list but i was suprised i agree with most of em except mop , fade to black and whiskey in a jar
I just needed a few extra songs top have a top 10🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️
Otherwise, you have a point that MOP and FTB. At least they have a reason to get a lot of attention. But when it comes to Whiskey in the jar.. i really don't get it....🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️
i love fade to black, but harvester of sorrow i really agree with, its bland af and so repetitive
When you play a guitar like me your interest for songs differs from others. And song are more enjoyable to play along with. Fuel is one of those, along with darkness had a son, harvester of sorrow
I dont see whats wrong with If Darkness had a Son
I literally explained why. + Raspy vocals sound really off. But if you do like this song, it's completly fine.
everything is wrong with that song. thst song and screaming suicide are the worst on the album
@@4md17 Finally someone who agrees but i think Screaming is not that bad
It's boring asf
mop is just so overplayed after stranger things released, its the thing that happened to bohemian rhapsody
Harvester of Sorrow was exceptionally well performed in Seattle 1989, but it always sounds good to me. I agree with Sandman, Fuel being overrated but not bad, I’d include Sad but True and King Nothing on this list, totally agree that Whiskey in the Jar is one of the worst songs on Garage Inc.
I mean, Whiskey is not garbage but just feels out of place
Seeing Fade to Black at three hurt a tad as it’s my all time favorite Metallica song, but I completely agree with your number 1 selection. Seek & Destroy is easily the most overrated Metallica track.
Bro... Fade to Black is NOT overrated bro 💀
you should put innamorata, it's slow, boring, I literally slept when I heard it, but people love because I dont know
I agree it should have been 7 min or smth but IDHAS gets a lot of popularity it's not worth of. That song is boring, wacky main riff, too repetitive, lazy lyrics, HORRIBLE SOLO and never liked the raspy vocals. Inamorata doesn't have those problems imo (maybe it's repetitive)
Same for You Must Burn, never been a fan of that one either.
I agree
I agree with everything you said about Harvester. It's just the same riff over and over throughout the song, the solo is boring and plain and the chorus is basically James just yelling "Harvester of Sorrow". It's a good song with amazing lyrics, but very overrated
You should watch Become The Knight's video on this song, it's pretty interesting.
not to say that it’s really good and defending it for being overrated, but back when my dad was stationed in okinawa back in the late 90s he carved H. O. S. on the back of his helmet for Harvester of Sorrow because it is was favorite song
@@tog9341 Wow that's actually really cool. Props to him!
No
I think that no song is really overrated, it just depends on the person's point of view.
I am sort of modern metallica guy (rare breed) because I was born around Death Magnetic, and I can say I do agree with most of this list. But I do have to say I see WAY more people hating on If Darkness Had A Son then defending it, and I personally like the song but I can see why you and others don't. The only songs I would've changed are Screaming Suicide for If Darkness Had A Son, and The Memory Remains for Fade To Black.
I agree with every single one besides ftb because that songs message is beautiful and sad at the same time and seek and destroy might be overplayed but it is such an amazing song.
I agree with u on every songs except Harvester and Seek. But the rest are correct. Great video!
Master of Puppets is overrated? Ahahahahahahhah
Fade To Blak and Whiskey are huge misses Whiskey is amazing on probably the best cover song.
I like the list and agree with your points for the most part. I don't agree with Harvester, it's good example of mid paced heaviness but I do think Leper Messiah, The Thing That Should Not Be and Eye of the Beholder are underrated in this regard. Whiskey in the Jar is a good cover overall, but Thin Lizzy version is so much better that I have to agree.
I agree with Master of Puppets Im a huge Metallica fan but that álbum has some really awesome songs! That's not the only one...
oh nice! But only disagree whit ALL THE SONG and replace them whit the album St.Anger
The drums on Fuel totally predicts the terrible drums on the St Anger album 😵
Totally agree about If Darkness Had a Son. Decent song until you get to the chorus, which sucks
Fuel is a masterpiece
I love seek and destroy
Nothing else matters is genius.
One of the greatest bonding songs in rock history. It will be played at my funeral, without doubt.
You had me until Fade to Black
Just pretend it was never on the list🤘🏼
My top 10 Most Overrated songs:
10) Inamorata (fight me)
9) One
8) Blackened
7) Battery
6) Fuel
5) Nothing Else Matters
4) Master Of Puppets
3) Seek & Destrrroy
2) Sad But True
1) Enter Sandman
Bonus: Whiskey in The Jar
I think One deserves to be overhyped so I'd say it's overplayed and Blackened is my favorite from AJFA but I perfectly understand all of your choices. Whiskey In The Jar should take 4th place at least LOL
Fuel is extremely overrated. Only the intro is good.. the main riff is clumsy and the song is just confusing. I'd say it's not necessarily a bad song but very comparable to a mid-budget hollywood movie if you get what I mean.
I think there is a lot of misconception of an overplayed song being an overrated song. If you have anything too much too often, it spoils how special it is, and an overindulgence of being force-fed even your favorite food makes you want to throw up. Oversaturation of a song dilutes its genius to the point of "cookie-cutter pop song" perception. The song loses its edge, cult status, and commercializes the song with no true appreciation of insight, composition, or lyrics. There are many great songs that music stores employees once loved but now hate are the very songs that almost every potential customer trying out a guitar plays in the store. The overplaying of _Smoke on the Water, Nothing Else Matters, Stairway To Heaven_ make music store employees perceive these as "overrated" and make them want to throw up.
Very good comment dude. You defined very well what the misconception was and gave a good example. Yeah, If Darkness Had A Son is an example bcs it just became popular and somehow commercialized without even being good enough to be considered an "average song" thus it shouldn't have been a single. That song is so weird, repetitive and makes up for an annoying listen. (*it's just my opinion*) The solo is easily worse or as bad as the one in ManUNKind
I think the main metal part of master of puppets, while cool, is a bit overrated. I personally think the interlude leading to the solo is way better.
tbh without the interlude it would not even make it to my top 50
Something I feel is a crime is that Stone Cold Crazy is the least listened to song on Garage Inc
Overrated, to me means everybody likes, but I don't see whats so great about them.
I only have three songs on this list.
1. Sad But True
2. One
3. King Nothing
100% agree for Whiskey, I don’t like that song (well it’s a cover). Not a huge fan of Fuel as well. I thing it’s too soon for If Darkness had a son. I disagree for all the others… but yes Sandman has been overplayed.
I mean, they're all amazing imo aside from If Darkness and Whiskey in The Jar.
Whiskey is soooo clumsy and weird, i hate the main riff so much, the rest goes from alright to bad
I think that overrated is the wrong word to describe these song, because some like fade to black and master of puppets are actually works of art. Of course they are the most streamed song so people don’t know that Metallica have made a lot of other beautiful songs. Personally I really like harvester of sorrow, I think it gives a lot of power and badness but I agree it is a bit ripetitive.
Whiskey in the jar I can understand since it is a cover, the original Thin Lizzy version is much better
No Metallica song is overrated to me honestly just I wish they play more rare songs more often or songs never been played live yet
nothing else matters
sad but true
seek and destroy
fuel
whiskey
Master of Puppets may be the best metal tune ever written. I tuned out after that call.
They play Whiskey in the jar in order to give tribute to cliff and he likes thin lizzy band
Really? I'd find to live is to die a way better way to tribute Cliff 🤔
Only ones i agreed with were Darkness (didn't like that one. Deffo the worst on 72 Seasons) Sandman and Nothing Else (again, because they steal attention away from other bangers like The God That Failed) and partially with Seek but i love that song, but i can agree it takes attention from other awesome songs like Whiplash and No Remorse (my favorite on KEA)
No Remorse is a killer song and I don't see why Metallica plays If Darkness at every show.. Imagine how happy ppl would be with them playing Struggle Within, Escape, All Nightmare Long, Trapped Under Ice, Wild Things instead of that thing.
It's called M72 for a reason... they should play the album in its entirity plus playing more rare songs would make up for a more popular and appealing tour than it already is
u did not say whiskey OMFG that makes me actually wanna throw whiskey at you (for legal reasons that a joke XDXDXD)
A joke's a joke
most of these were understandable, but I gotta say putting fade to black in number 3 for most overplayed, even above enter sandman, is the... craziest? (tryna be nice) opinion ever
Ik i can be crazy at times..
@@vinceyrankingscrazy? I was crazy once. They locked me in this cage. Can't you see that's why my brain says RAAAAAAAAAAGE
How old are you and when did you discovered Metallica? I think it matters, at least to me, to understand your choices more...🤘
I'm not the person who just tells his age but i confirm you i'm in my late teens so i'm young. As someone young i appreciate Load and Reload and some stuff from the new albums. Kind of like Murder One hehe
I already knew Metallica before, had heard to Nothing Else matters, My Friend of Misery, Enter sandman before Stranger Things 4, from my parents and older ppl i know. That scene with Eddie in the upside down is what truly got me into the band, him shredding the master of puppets solo
@@vinceyrankings Alright! 👍 I was 14 when I discovered Metallica and I m 45 so there were only 5 albums at the time...when I look back, I ve changed my mind on some songs...and it will probably happen to you as well ! At first, I used to like The day that never comes, great intro, great verses...and since a few years, I find it's just a bad rendition of Fade to black ! I find that Screaming Suicide is a bad song, the main riff is weak but maybe one day I will find it good...no, not this one, bad example ! 😂 You know what I mean? I'm glad the young generation is into Metallica! 🤘🤘🤘 Greetings from France! My English is not perfect...but no so bad! 😁
@@sebastienfayemendie2514 J'aime le français! Oui je comprends qu'on peut changer d'avis de temps en temps. D'abord je considerais Escape une chanson peu ennuyeuse mais avec temps elle a grandi sur moi, c'est maintenant dans mon top 3. Salutations de Flandre!
@@vinceyrankings Ah! Je pensais que tu étais Américain ! Je ne sais pas pourquoi d ailleurs...🙄 Certains Fans sont impitoyables, avec un esprit fermé, j ai du mal à comprendre ça...j aime Load et Reload aussi, pas vraiment St Anger même avec 20 ans de recul...ce que j aime avant tout, c'est la prise de risques et chez Metallica, on est servis ! Dés fois c est génial, d autres fois c est raté, c est comme ça...longue vie à Metallica ! 🤘
master of puppets is underrated
master of puppets is one of there most popular songs and it's extremely overrated
It became popular because it's a masterpiece. Imagine being in 1986 you buy the disc and come back at your place and listen to this song for the first time what would be yout thought about it? People need to stop being influenced by the fact that if something is "popular" it is overrated. Analyze the music. the riffs, the melody, the lyrics, the solo, how does it make you feel@@midnighttube1941
It's just overplayed but still an iconic song, yet I still think there are better songs and it could've been way more than it currently is
@@vinceyrankings I meant overplayed
My top 5:
5)Moth into flame
4)Whiskey in the jar
3)Battery
2)For whom the bell tolls
1)Why even the fuck is "Too far gone?" on top 6# of spotify?
Buen video, que programa usas para editar?
Solo uso CapCut, es bastante sencilla de usar y puedes hacer muy buenos videos
3:03 i love fade to black beacuse i can relate to it
are you ok?
@@she.luv.hexiii no
So do you think that Metallica's take on Whiskey is bad, or song is bad in general? Seeing that it's based mostly on Thin Lizzy's version, Hetfield himself would probably hunt you down for disliking the song in general. XD
Haven't listened to the original yet. It's just not for me, i don't like the main riff but some parts are cool
Ok that's enough RUclips
Overplayed doesnt mean overrated
I do agree with a Whiskey in the Jar. Horrible song and I dont like any part of it
Good point and Whiskey is such a bad song
Tienes planeado hacer un video de canciones infravaloradas?
También. Luego las 10 peores y mejores canciones. Si ya viste mi ranking de todas las canciones, sabrás perfectamente cuales son, pero lo haré de todas formas para tener mas contenido
@@vinceyrankings si, efectivamente el business primero jaja.
Fuera coñas es mejor dividir tu contenido en mucho ya que hay que gente que no vera 17 min de ranking. Yo si pero no todos. No pusiste minus human en el ranking o si?
@@Mundo-Metal No incluí canciones bonus pero la pondría momentaneamente entre top 90-80. No leaf clover iría al top 50 o quizas 40. Si, tienes razón pero hay gente que raramente ha conseguido muchas vistas haciendo los mismos videos y con la misma duración.
@@vinceyrankingscómo no pongas Fixxxer te denuncio el canal jajajaj
Finally someone else agrees that whiskey in a jar isn’t great
yesss!!
It's just ok imo
Ok come on from whom the bells tolls is amazing
this is an absolutely preposterous video, i understand opinions but all of these songs are amazing
Bro, fade to black is a freaking masterpiece
If darkens had a son: Cannot listen to The original, so Boring. The one on my play list Is a fan edited. You find it as "shorter and faster" on YT. Way better.
I think fade to black is so popular because its not that heavy. Most people dont like metal, so the slow, melodic songs like ftb, the unforgiven and nem are the most popular.
And also in my opinion the best song in master of puppets is battery
I thought memory remains turn the page and one would have been on here
I feel like master of puppets is a little overrated. dont get me wrong, i love this album, it has my favorite metallica song, (disposable heroes) but its not there best album. (In my opinion, its fine to disagree.)
I appreciate the video but to make an opinion on this viable you actually have to explain why something is overrated.
MOP might be one of the most overplayed songs ever, but if it's SO GOOD that it excuses it then it's not.
You have to actually explain what about the song you don't like. As an example, a valid criticism about MOP is the fact that it drags on and on and on, it's reasonable.
Then, if you want to talk about how overplayed songs overshadow other and better ones, the right video would be: "10 Metallica songs that deserve more justice"
Hope I explained myself
Esa será tu opinión, pero no puedes ir puntuando por ahí tu opinión y diciendo que es así. Sera así para ti, pero no en general.
No puedo ir diciendo que es así? Es solo mi opinión y si tengo derecho de hacerla saber. Esta lista es subjetiva y siempre habrá gente que este en (des)/acuerdo conmigo.
Además admite que 3 o 4 de estas canciones estan recontra idolatradas😂😏
@@Miguel54675 ahi vamos!
pero por qué fade to black está sobrevalorada? si es buenísima y no es muy conocida
I think Anesthesia should've on here tbh.
I can see why you don’t like Harvester nor Darkness, but you gotta admit, they’re songs that sound way better live (honestly all songs on the list).
i always try to tell my friend overrated =\= bad and he still doesnt listen to me lmao
Overrated is a song that is considered better than it is. FTB is a good one but a bit slow and repetitive. It was actually funny to place it on 52/119. I'd put it higher now but still not even top 30
I agreed with everything until i saw the whiskey in the jar slander
1. THE MEMORY REMAINS (definitely one of my top 3 worst ever Metallica songs)
2. Jump in the Fire
I LOVE jump in the fire but I agree on The Memory Remains
Master, Harvester, For Whom the Bell Tolls, Fade to Black, Seek and Destroy... you could have put more effort into it instead of putting masterpieces on this list... And Whiskey in the jar is only a cover
Harvester and Seek are so insanely overrated, they're fine but not god tier masterpieces. Whiskey is just a cover, yes, but i don't like it and unlike the songs you've mentioned, it does not deserve the hype, love and popularity it has
@@vinceyrankings opinions
@@mr.busticador2691 There you got it!
I dont think that whiskey in the jar is overrated. I dont think that many people even know about this song. I understand that you dont like this, I am not saying that you cant dislike this song, in my opinion it isnt bad i quite enjoy it, but not every needs to like it and i respect that. And overrated means that it is rated highly or valued more than it should Meaning that it isnt as good as people say it is and whiskey in the jar doesnt isnt a song that people would say that it is extremely good. There are alot of people (including you) that dont like this song and more that dont know this song as i said before. And whiskey in the jar is a cover song it wasnt wrote by metallica that is why it doesnt sound like other traditional metallica song.
The song was overplayed at some period of the time. Non Metallica fans who know Metallica it is one of the songs they know and like.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion, wrong though it may be.
Great video! ♥Only one I disagree with Harvester Of Sorrow. Pretty fairly rated in my opinion!♥
No master of puppeta?
Orion
Surely the "most overrated" instrumental but still really good and not that overrated like S&D or Harvester
Whiskey is a cover so you can't complain about the verses and chorus lol...
nothing on this list is overrated nothing is overrated
no
Im considering your are a young person but I do not agree with most of this list. MOP, FWTBT, FTB, SnD, ESM, we’re absolute game changers in their time. And the fact they are still relevant today shows how important they are. Harvester is a great song but more of a filler. NEM always had a hard time liking that song since it came out 30years ago. My wife loves it, figures. Overplayed yes, but it does not mean overrated.
You don’t now what your talking about. These songs are great!! Seek and destroy is in my top 10!!!
what? the most overrated song is:
1. Whiskey in the jar. every, EVERY and i mean absolut E V E R Y other Cover song is 956959595 times better. I hate it when they play whiskey on a METAL concert.
➡(best cover songs: breadfan, mercyful fate, the wait, its electric, turn the page, astronomy... etc)
1.2 enter sandman! there is no other song that is so "bad" but popular. The song is basicly just one lame riff... and it is stolen by "Stone" from the song "get stoned"....
the song "get stoned" is better lol.
never been to a show of them, but I'll probably go in 2025 since I do not want to hear If Darkness Had a Son, that song is so overrated and I don't like it. But I bet that song will be one of the "good and classic songs" from the new albums.
I haven't even listened to the entire cover of Whiskey bcs my brain just asked me to pause it, it was awful.
Whiskey in the jar is a cover
Master of Puppets is underrated
Enter sandman… I’ll never understand. 🤷🏼♂️
fade to black is so overrated
Gosh finally someone who agrees with me. It's really good but not as good as the others imo
the only overrated metallica songs are every song made after the black album, it is all crap, and i have heard it all.
So many mixed opinions..
It was a great day when I got over it and discovered how great the Load and Garage albums were. I listen to them much more than the old sh&t.
whiskey in the jar isn't even their song 😭😭
It's a cover but i think it's the perfect example of an overrated song. It's just my opinion, i don't like the main riff but still has some cool parts
Bro why you got to put alot of their good stuff on the list
Some songs steal the attention from other great underrated songs but that doesn't mean they're bad. If Darkness and Whiskey are songs that don't deserve to be hyped imo and I dislike them
worst song on this list is whiskey in a jar. Like how do people even like it it does not sound good at all
One is extremely overrated
I DO NOT agree with anything you say
Well, it's your choice to agree or not. Maybe i'm wrong with some stuff, then correct me. But let's be honest, some songs like Whiskey are not that good and Seek is not as strong as some of the other songs on KEA
@@vinceyrankings Seek & Destroy is my favorite from the KEA man. It's on 15 in my list. That song feels like it's not from KEA. Also I really like Whiskey in the Jar, on my 21. I remember first I heard that was on a radio or something and then I was just looking for it for over 2 weeks. When I finally found it, I've listened it all day.
@@Dunkingdom I'm glad you have pleasure listening to the song, everyone has its own taste 😀
Damn, I hate seek and destroy